For knitr, the chunk option message = FALSE will suppress messages now

[yihui]

This package is failing on CRAN right now: https://cran.r-project.org/web/checks/check_results_whereami.html The failed test is

whereami/tests/testthat/test-thisfile.R

Line 31 in 64ee46b

testthat::expect_message(

This is because a change in the evaluate package: https://github.com/r-lib/evaluate/blob/main/NEWS.md#version-019 That means message = FALSE will completely suppress the messages.

Sorry for not discovering this earlier (because whereami is not a reverse dependency of evaluate)!

[yonicd]

No worries I saw a message from CRAN the other day. I will update and resubmit. thanks for reaching out to show what the fix is!

[yonicd]

@yihui I am not sure if I follow where {evaluate} fits in, I don't see a formal for message or keep_message in the {knitr} call

Am I not running the test correctly under the changes to {knitr}?

testthat::test_that("thisfile works with knitr", {
  testthat::skip_if_not_installed("knitr")
  out <- tempfile(pattern = "whereami", fileext = ".md")
  testthat::expect_message(
    knitr::knit("scripts/thisfile.Rmd", output = out, quiet = TRUE),
    normalizePath("scripts/thisfile.Rmd"),
    fixed = TRUE
  )
})

thanks

> packageVersion('knitr')
[1] ‘1.41’
> formals(knitr::knit)
$input


$output
NULL

$tangle
[1] FALSE

$text
NULL

$quiet
[1] FALSE

$envir
parent.frame()

$encoding
[1] "UTF-8"

[yihui]

I was unclear and just modified the issue title here. I meant the chunk option message:

whereami/tests/testthat/scripts/thisfile.Rmd

Line 1 in 64ee46b

```{r echo=FALSE, results='markup', comment="", message=FALSE}

[yonicd]

Ah. That makes sense. Thanks for the clarification!

[yihui]

Just FYI, I added support for the old behavior in evaluate and knitr---you can set message = NA after their next versions are released to CRAN.

[yonicd]

thanks for the update. I rewrote the test to work around the new functionality and pushed to cran.