Skip to content
This repository has been archived by the owner on Feb 4, 2021. It is now read-only.

Drukhari Issues #3908

Closed
6 of 25 tasks
Mad-Spy opened this issue Jun 15, 2017 · 9 comments
Closed
6 of 25 tasks

Drukhari Issues #3908

Mad-Spy opened this issue Jun 15, 2017 · 9 comments

Comments

@Mad-Spy
Copy link

Mad-Spy commented Jun 15, 2017

@Toreador13

File/Catalogue: Drukhari v10

BattleScribe version: 2.01.02.89

Platform: Windows

Dropbox: No

Description:

  • Phantasm Grenade Launcher: should be "subtract 1 from its Leadership" in the description.

  • Haemonculus: Haemonculus tools and Splinter Pistol should not be optional.

  • Crucible of Malediction is misspelled.

  • Crucible of Malediction: should be "unleash its contents" in the description.

  • Liquifier gun: should be "hits its target" in the description.

  • Flesh Gauntlet: should be "suffers a mortal wound" in the description

  • Lelith Hesperax: The implementation of Lelith's weapons is odd. It would seem better to give her a fixed Penetrating Blade, then an option for the second blade/Impaler (which should be costed as it's optional). I assume that only default wargear is included in her points cost, not optional.
    image

  • Archon: Members is misspelled as Memebers in Court of the Archon.

  • Succubus: Needs Splinter pistol set as default ranged weapon.

  • Succubus: Missing "Lightning Dodge" and "No Escape" abilities.

  • Kabalite Warriors: PL increments are incorrect. As I understand it, PL should increase once minimum is exceeded, not when maximum is reached. i.e. 1 Sybarite + 4 Warriors is 3 PL, 1 Sybarite + 5 Warriors should be 5 PL.

  • Wracks: Should Acothyst's Haemonculus tools be 0-1 as he has to swap them for his Weapons of Torture option as per RAW? As the Acothyst has no ranged weapon, how can he swap it for Tools of Torment which is required RAW? I suggest RAI is that he swaps Haemonculus tools for one of the other options. Would need adding to 8th Edition - Assumed Amendments #3748.

  • Wyches: Unit size should be 5-20, not 5-15.

  • Beastmaster: Adding Khymerae pairs does not increment PL.

  • Beastmaster: The Khymerae have a 5+ inv save, but the Beastmaster does not gain it, The way this is currently implemented makes it look as if he does when you add them as his free unit. Not sure how/whether this can be fixed.

  • Grotesques: Grotesque with Weapons of Torture needn't have weapon options other than Weapons of Torture. He can't replace his Monstrous Cleaver with both a Liquifier Gun and a Weapon of Torture at the same time.

  • Hekatrix Bloodbrides: Same PL increment issue as with Kabalite Warriors.

  • Incubi: Klaivex should have Klaive as default weapon.

  • Incubi: Incubi Model entry should be Max 9 Selections in Parent (currently 10 which causes a validation error).

  • Mandrakes: Should be 9 PL at 6+ models, not 10.

  • Mandrakes: Should be "any of your Movement Phases" in From Out of the Shadows description. Also a missing whitespace in "at least 9"away from".

  • Sslyth: Shardcarbine should be one word.

  • Sslyth: Sslyth who are included in the Court of the Archon have the same problem as with Khymerae for the Beastmaster, in that the way rules are grouped implies that the Archon (and any other models in the "unit") get a 5+ save.

  • Reaver: Individual Reaver upgrades should be max 1 per parent. Also, conceivably any Reaver can take them, so they should be included on the Special Weapons Reavers as well. This is likely to need major rework.

  • Dark Lance: It would seem neater to use a modifier to change the weapon type if it's equipped on a relevant vehicle rather than relying on the ability text.
    image

@Toreador13
Copy link
Contributor

Toreador13 commented Jun 15, 2017

I am very unsure that the Impaler would cost more than the penetrating blade, or that a model that includes points costs for all wargear would then have a further points cost.

It is somewhat clunky, but all the different ways I tried were not either intuitive or worse in layout to me.

@amis92
Copy link
Member

amis92 commented Jun 15, 2017

@Toreador13 maybe add it to #3748 ?

@Toreador13
Copy link
Contributor

image Haemonculus tools and Splinter Pistol are only optional because Tools of Torture and Weapons of Torture require you to give them up.

@Toreador13
Copy link
Contributor

All corrections are in V12 which will release tonight.

@Mad-Spy
Copy link
Author

Mad-Spy commented Jun 15, 2017

Sorry, missed that rule.

I have a suggestion on how to make the Haemonculus weapon options look tidier by putting the default weapon options into a selection group with the other options of the same type.

image
image

It makes it a bit more obvious that it's a choice to switch from the default weapons to one of the options.

Alternatively, you can add the default options into the actual selection groups and hide them when they're not applicable, which looks even neater, but means that you can't pre-select the defaults because each model which uses the list has a different default.

@Mad-Spy Mad-Spy closed this as completed Jun 15, 2017
@Mad-Spy
Copy link
Author

Mad-Spy commented Jun 15, 2017

In terms of Lelith, I guess we'll have to wait for GW to FAQ whether or not the Impaler is extra. I haven't been able to find any other "points including wargear" model which has weapon options, so you may well be right.

@Mad-Spy Mad-Spy reopened this Jun 15, 2017
@Toreador13
Copy link
Contributor

I did change the weapon options to have you have it for the haemonculus. I like the look, but it works clunky since you have to go back and deselect.

I also missed that rule the first several times. SO much to go over in so many places. Information overload!

@Mad-Spy
Copy link
Author

Mad-Spy commented Jun 15, 2017

@Toreador13, I was in the process of adding more issues to the bottom of the list in the opening comment. Do you want to reopen this issue (as I now can't do so), or for me to start a new one?

@Toreador13
Copy link
Contributor

Toreador13 commented Jun 15, 2017

Add more here. I am going through right now and removing all it's. Late night typing really hurts the brain.

@Toreador13 Toreador13 reopened this Jun 16, 2017
Toreador13 added a commit that referenced this issue Jun 16, 2017
fixes items in #3908
@amis92 amis92 added this to the 8th Edition milestone Jun 16, 2017
@amis92 amis92 closed this as completed Jun 16, 2017
Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

3 participants