Message signing

[devastgh]

• I have checked this feature was not yet requested.

Please implement message signing with a bitcoin address in the new app. This feature was available in the old chrome app.

Thanks!

[tookdrums]

I support this although I feel like with segwit transaction becoming more and more current, there need to be a standardized discussion on how to handle P2SH outputs.

[EvilJordan]

@tookdrums Separate issue.

[pointbiz]

I support this feature request.

[BlinkVoid]

This feature is quite useful, if possible, please add it to the ledger live software.

[gotah]

I support this request

[stevesbrain]

Would also love to see this! Currently having to use other apps to achieve this (and is a regression from old Chrome App functionality)

[freeAgent85]

Here's another vote for getting this feature added to Ledger Live. I used the signature feature in the Chrome apps to prove ownership of an address for audit purposes. That would be much, much more difficult to do now that the feature is removed from Ledger Live.

[bfriel]

Please consider this as auditors prefer wallet signing to prove ownership of addresses. We like our current Ledger set up but will migrate to another solution if this feature is discontinued

[cgilliard]

If this is implemented please comply with BIP 137: https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0137.mediawiki

[sanchopansa]

Is there any update on this?

I actually just received a Ledge Nano X at home and wasn't aware that this is not possible. It's a big issue for proving ownership of assets.

[rjhbraun]

Wholeheartedly agree that this is a must-have for Ledger Live.

[mctrivia]

need this feature for all coins not just bitcoin address. should be simple feature to add since code is already in place to sign transactions just need to add gui and encode to base64 for human readable signature.

[kmphua]

This is a must-have feature, please implement this ASAP! I'm tempted to move away from Ledger soon if it is not implemented by the end of this year.

[jugi1]

Add this LEDGER.
After latest Nano S updates you shrinked space and made installing PGP app very hard.

[MarcelBurger]

Can you please implement message signing asap?

[gre]

We're definitely considering the feature. no ETA yet however.

[cgilliard]

Lead developer of the MWC airdrop here. Just to give you some input from the field, a number of ledger users want this feature and the number one support request we got is: how do I sign to prove funds with a ledger? We actually had to make a video showing how to sign on a ledger using electrum. I hope this is something that can be prioritized. For reference, the BIP that would be ideal for ledger to support is BIP 137: https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0137.mediawiki

…

On Sun, Sep 8, 2019 at 12:00 PM Gaëtan Renaudeau ***@***.***> wrote: We're definitely considering the feature. no ETA yet however. — You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#1136?email_source=notifications&email_token=ABXFVN2QHKEJ7LSYWGN5UY3QIUOSVA5CNFSM4FKASSS2YY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOD6FTGDI#issuecomment-529216269>, or mute the thread <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ABXFVN2EJS4AO6IIWGVJKQDQIUOSVANCNFSM4FKASSSQ> .

[gre]

cc @IAmMorrow

[gabbello835]

2020 and still not having this option?

[ZwaZo22]

This request is now open for 2 1/2 years... Any updates from the developers ?

[devastgh]

This request is now open for 2 1/2 years... Any updates from the developers ?

I guess, or more like hope, that they're just waiting for bip322 to somewhat finalize. At this point in time implementing p2pkh signing is just... meh. This old signing method will probably become obsolate soon as well, and most people are using bech32 or p2sh by now anyway.

[ElvisPresly]

This request is now open for 2 1/2 years... Any updates from the developers ?

I guess, or more like hope, that they're just waiting for bip322 to somewhat finalize. At this point in time implementing p2pkh signing is just... meh. This old signing method will probably become obsolate soon as well, and most people are using bech32 or p2sh by now anyway.

I think that they are very lazy and will not do anything without money. Judging by the fact that they have almost stopped adding new coins to the wallet, the price for listing is very high.

[dskloet]

How is this still not implemented??

[francis2]

I need to sign a msg to verify this stupid wallet with an exchange. Ledger makse this very difficult so I have to throw this thing away and buy a better hardware wallet. Not going to buy from them ever again..

[girifox]

This would be a helpful quality-of-life feature.

[reijndert]

Please implement message signing. I love my Ledger (Nano S) and the Ledger Live application should be able support Message Signing.
Thank you.

[mandrean]

3 years later, and Ledger still didn't bother implementing message signing. Smh.

[ChenLi0830]

Please implement this. This should be one of the most basic features for a wallet that hold your private key.

[MarianBojescu]

4 years and nothing.

[qleguennec]

We need this feature as well.