Black Desert (582660) #3620
Comments
kisak-valve
added
the
Game compatibility - Unofficial
|
Not 100% sure, but it looks like the problem may be with which seems to involve Qt code (QNetworkReplyHttpImpl). Since Qt is garbage with Wine https://appdb.winehq.org/objectManager.php?sClass=version&iId=37891 I wonder if the problem is that Wine needs fixes for Qt applications since it throws a fixme just before this error? Looks like in the best case it may return ERROR_SUCCESS whatever a successful error means. That error was a success lol. Funny people. Might not be playing this game anytime soon. |
|
On another note, that problem appears to affect wifi so I wonder if Newbytee is using wifi? The gist doesn't have that info. That might fix that issue (using wired lan port) or that the code gets called anyway wifi or not. |
I'm using Ethernet. |
|
This game apparently uses a kernel driver for anticheat (xigncode), so even if the current issue isn't related (and were to be fixed), I doubt it would run until kernel drivers are properly supported in wine (as far as I understand, they aren't). |
|
Black Desert Online - game launcher crashes Issue transferred from #3913. Compatibility Report
System Information
I confirm:
https://gist.github.com/Gman1988/966d43fac5e79323652626a29ec9d617 SymptomsGame installs fine. Launcher open up, when I press "start game", account creation shows up for 1 sec and that is it, nothing else is happening. Reproduction
|
|
any news ? |
|
Same problem here with latest version of Black Desert Online as of today; System Information
|
|
Problem persists here my log and system info: |
Black Desert changed to Easy AntiCheat about 6 months ago, better hopes for it now. |
|
After the release of the new version of Easy Anti-Cheat, tried to run the game. As a result, the Launcher did not even start. The logo appears and then closes. |
|
This title switched to Epic's Anti Cheat service, which to my knowledge looks to be the same as used in the AVA CBT which ran like a charm for that game. Could this game please be reinvestigated for issues? EDIT: All I can detect from the logs is that there's a null pointer exception somewhere, if I need to run this with any special features please let me know. The proton versions tried were experimental and tkg. |
|
If I remember correctly, the launcher does a bunch of web request before even starting. It feels/looks like that is failing. Here are some more log files: |
This is the case, and if you use a custom launcher you are able to play the game using DX9 mode apparently (You can't use the Steam version of the game). If it could be implemented where the check succeeds then this game should start working in some capacity. This project here is the workaround that I've seen talked about. https://github.com/jsoctocat/BDO-Launcher |
I use this launcher on Windows for OTP reasons, and it cannot download or update the game. How do you update the game every Wednesday with this workaround method? I've to try it and give more feedback. |
It requires you to move the files from Windows every week in order to make use of it. Less than ideal, if work could be done to get the official launcher working that would be great. Here's a link to someone talking about the process. https://www.reddit.com/r/blackdesertonline/comments/yg1isl/comment/iu6msod/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3 |
Dx9 is being removed on February 1st: https://www.naeu.playblackdesert.com/en-US/News/Detail?groupContentNo=4595 |
Even if that's the case, at least we have 2 solid issues now telling us what we need to get the game running.
We know it's not the anti-cheat that's at fault, so it's actually a possibility to get running. (Unless the reddit users used a workaround for the anti-cheat) |
|
You can get past the client now. "Failed to init Auth." |
|
@Hourija which version of Proton did you use? Did you use special command line parameters? All Versions (Experimental, Hotfix, 8.0-2) I tried to start Black Desert show me the Launcher Icon and after that I get a black window which the cursor changes if I hover over it. If I click in certain spots my browser opens the links in the launcher. Sadly I cannot start the game by clicking in the lower right corner (where the play button is supposed to be). The launcher itself looks like this:
I use Manjaro with an Ryzen R5 5600 + RX 5700XT |
|
@dominik-code |
Same here (in my case on Fedora 38 and AMD), but nothing occurs once I have clicked the play button. I see the logs below where it seems to repeat an
Repeated section:
Long Log Excerpt |
|
Black Desert moving back to Xigncode, has already changed on the public test server.
|
I've heard mixed reports about xigncode. How well does it work on proton? |
As far as I know, it doesn't. I became very interested in trying out Scarlet Blade, which implements XIGNCODE as well, and even though the game does install successfully and the game launcher works like a charm, the game itself does not even start with WINE, and we all know that Proton is a slight modification of WINE's codebase but for Steam. |
|
At least according to long time BDO players, XIGNCODE also tends to lead to false-positive bans that Kakao was reluctant to overturn. If PA implements it in a similar way to the prior use, it will have a higher chance for account bans than I would be comfortable with (at least hopefully PA would be more responsive...) |
|
Today BDO switched from EAC to XIGNCODE. The Game is working now on Linux. The only Problem left is that the Launcher is completely black and you've to type in your Account-Data blind. |
|
If you use the Steam version of the game (authenticates using your Steam ID), does that skip the launcher entirely or do you still have to click on the "play" button? |
|
Which launch option again? |
SteamGameId=582660 %command% |
|
Oh thank you, I will try it. Work on non-steam version of the game also right? |
|
Ouch, still crashing |
|
After 2 afternoons of troubleshooting I come to you with a comprehensive list of what doesn't affect BSA esque windows not loading in. SteamGameId=582660 NOSTEAM=1 %command% however to no avail. BSA just randomly decided to die, don't recall anything changing, maybe some arch kernel update scadoodle. Windows such as the settings archive also don't ever load. Update 1: now every version of GE boots me to the login screen on the launcher, making the game unplayable, proton experimental and 9.0+ load the launcher properly but not the windows. Older proton versions have black screens for launchers but you can still start the game normally. No luck with BSA and such though. At this point the only variable I haven't inspected is my kernel. It may have something to do with arch 6.8 Update 2: downgrading to 6.7.8, which I for a fact knew was fine doesn't fix the issue, along with not doing anything to GE problems. I hereby conclude that PA just broke something in the latest patch. Update 3: clearing all the cache files as per GM instructions doesn't affect BSA either. Though now I can run the game through GE again. Weirdly enough I noticed another bug, I seem to not be able to click on certain UI elements (regardless of proton version): |
|
@mirai-ux , maybe I miss something, but .. what do you mean by BSA ? |
|
@wildtruc |
|
Ahhh. |
|
Sadly I tried it both ways but to no avail. Didn't mention it during my previous comment, probably should have. I am running the steam version and am on an amd gpu. Here are my launch options: From reading this issue, it seems as if I'm experiencing very similar issues to what was described in the early days of xigncode. However none of the fixes mentioned do anything. At this point I'm starting to consider whether a proton is just screwed up on my system, or is it really PA. It worked flawlessly earlier. Now I'm just noticing more and more windows that are blank. So far its up to: BSA, SA, Beauty Page, Guild Sayings. |
For what it's worth, I'm running a very similiar setup, however I've never tested spam clicking the tray to see what happens. From what I managed to read up on, it's probably an xorg issue, that isn't very easily solvable. Wayland may be the easiest way out |
|
It’s not an xorg issue. It’s an issue with his system tray not properly supporting legacy tray applications. Some system trays allow you to disable support entirely, which makes the BDO tray icon float in its own window and it works perfectly. As an aside, I understand the urge but this GitHub issue is not meant for general tech support getting the game working on your system, but for reporting bugs in the game caused by incompatibilities with Proton. If you can trace your issues getting the game working back to Proton itself, then feel free to post here. Otherwise, please post on another platform. As it stands, those of us watching the issue for important updates are being flooded with emails irrelevant to the issue itself. Sorry, and thank you. |
|
I probably should have clarified my intentions more clearly. At this point, I realize that the issue may be more complex than a simple version swap. My primary goal was to document the troubleshooting steps I've taken and their effects, in case others encounter a similar problem. I initially assumed the issue on Proton's repository might be broader, but I now understand it's more specifically related to Proton itself. Sorry for any inconveniences this may have caused. If I do manage to identify a solution or encounter any further anomalies related to Proton versions, I'll be sure to report back though. |
|
Ok, so because i have also a Steam version, I tried. By the way, because @Daktyl198 mention it. I created a thread for Linux Help in BDO EN forum Feedback, there : thread in BDO's EN forum. |
|
Anyone with issue when minimized the game, can't find a way to open it back? |
find a bar with a system tray that supports legacy tray apps, or don’t minimize to tray. AFAIK it’s an upstream wine issue where they don’t support modern systray apis. |
I found, that BSA doesn't work without SteamGameId variable set. It's rather strange, I launch non-Steam version of the game and should to set Steam related variable. I also didn't find, what this variable do with the game to make it work properly. |
Part of the way Proton works is by including game-specific workarounds. They are changes to Wine or related code that fixed a bug in one game, but is considered hacky or would break other games so it’s not applied globally. Proton knows to apply these fixes by reading the SteamGameId variable. |
|
Anyone dealing with random closing after 5-10mins on bleeding or ge 9-5 or hotfix lately? Like last 1-2 weeks. Game would be running fine and dandy then randomly close, got a feeling it's Xigncode (Anticheat) complaining about something but the log for it is encrypted. No closing on Proton 9.0-1 but lost access to the marketplace again. Args used Edit: Trying ge 9-6 |
|
For me I installed BDO with the Lutris script and I keep getting random crashes/closing every 20~ or so minutes. The launcher window is also black. I tried Proton Experimental, GE 9-6 and 9-7. I tried variations of all the launch options above. Running on Arch with latest everything. Right now I'm using Though, none of those flags (or subsets of them) fix the black launcher or the crashes. I compiled Proton 9-7 GE with a wine patch and that fixed the black launcher issue, but not the crashes. Is anyone else here crashing every 20~ minutes? Any idea what the fix is? |
|
For me, the launcher opens fine while running BDO through Steam on Proton Experimental and on the latest version of Proton-GE. However, when presented with the 2FA screen where I must type in a code, the launcher doesn't receive any input from my keyboard. I can still click on things, such as links, and it will open those links. I run the latest version of Hyprland on NixOS. Does anyone know what might cause this? |
|
Hi every one. |
|
It doesn't look to a proton bug. I don't thing you need to compil
proton for this (at least it is really required).
You probably may ask Arch community, they will have probably better
answers around the distro specificity.
Note that I experienced Black spirit adventure troubles with NOSTEAM=1.
Le lundi 17 juin 2024 à 08:53 -0700, lambdadelt4 a écrit :
… For me I installed BDO with the Lutris script and I keep getting
random crashes/closing every 20~ or so minutes. The launcher window
is also black. I tried Proton Experimental, GE 9-6 and 9-7. I tried
variations of all the launch options above. Running on Arch with
latest everything.
Right now I'm using DXVK_CONFIG="dxgi.syncInterval=0"
PROTON_ENABLE_NGX_UPDATER=1 PROTON_ENABLE_NVAPI=1 SteamGameId=582660
NOSTEAM=1 %command%
Though, none of those flags (or subsets of them) fix the black
launcher or the crashes.
I compiled Proton 9-7 GE with a wine patch and that fixed the black
launcher issue, but not the crashes. Is anyone else here crashing
every 20~ minutes? Any idea what the fix is?
—
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe.
You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID:
***@***.***>
|
|
@lambdadelt4 Have you tried running the game on Steam (as a 3rd party application) instead of through Lutris? I'm not sure if Proton needs some Steam special sauce. @vickydotbat did you try using another WM? I've not had this issue on Plasma, but it could be a recent breakage. |
Actually I did not, I will give that a try. Having some issues with Hyprland mouse input anyway. |
Yup. Plasma works fine. Thank you! |
|
idk how you guys can pass the launcher. |
Have the same issue on Hyprland after the xwayland rewrite, opened an issue hyprwm/Hyprland#7507 |
|
Updating to Proton Ge 9.18 and the latest bleeding: shows the following error on client launch: Proton Ge 9.15 has no issues. |
I did a little bit of experimentation yesterday and determined that it was caused by dxvk, could you make an issue there |
and others
Compatibility Report
System Information
I confirm:
steam-582660.log
Symptoms
Registration window appears, which works, however after restarting the game once (it crashed the first time during registration) and registering again plus verifying, this happens:
Reproduction
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: