[Q]: How does the sentence end?

Have you ever been on  a nature walk Samantha asked Tanya , 
OPTIONS:
- Samantha is giving a reply to a question.
- Tanya is giving a reply to a question.

[A]: Tanya is giving a reply to a question.
QUES: Continue writing.

The lady told me that Megan was always a critic about everything unlike Amy, due to 

OPTIONS:
- Megan being optimistic.
- Amy being optimistic.
+++++++++
ANS: Amy being optimistic.
Problem: How does the sentence end?

The windows were very dirty, but Joseph saw no reason to clean them while William immediately cleaned them.  
OPTIONS:
- Joseph was a naturally dirty person.
- William was a naturally dirty person.
Answer: Joseph was a naturally dirty person.
sentence: Bob saw on a sign that BMW was 5 miles away and Whataburger was 2 miles away. Bob traveled to the  OPTIONS:
- Whataburger first because it was closer.
- BMW first because it was closer.
complete: Whataburger first because it was closer.
Josh and his friends went to the diner after the dance instead of the restaurant because the 
OPTIONS:
- restaurant closed later.
- diner closed later.
diner closed later.
Problem: Continue the following story.

Hunter put on a thick blue sweater but Joel did not as 
OPTIONS:
- Hunter was feeling warm.
- Joel was feeling warm.
Here's how I want to continue it:
Joel was feeling warm.