Problem: How does the sentence end?

Patricia had an emotional reaction to the movie while Maria did not because 
Answer: Patricia was emotionally invested in the characters.

Problem: How does the sentence end?

The taste of tomatoes really appeals to Joel but not to Adam. 
Answer: Joel ordered the fried green tomatoes for their appetizer.

Problem: How does the sentence end?

The girl wanted to store her makeup inside her case but the 
Answer: makeup was too large.

Problem: How does the sentence end?

Nick skipped out on the school pep rallies while Matthew was always cheering, since 
Answer:
Matthew possessed school spirit.