Problem: How does the sentence end?

Carol handed the date to Robert, who refused it. He wanted a prune instead. The 
Answer: prune was perfect for his taste buds.

Problem: How does the sentence end?

The lecture failed to convert him, but the essay convinced him to change, as the 
Answer: essay was compelling.

Problem: How does the sentence end?

Nothing made Erin relax like a nice massage, but they wigged out Tanya, as 
Answer: Erin felt comfortable being touched.

Problem: How does the sentence end?

The old jeans no longer fit Craig but did fit Lawrence because 
Answer:
Lawrence hadn't gained weight over the years.