App with UI schema in aragonpm is showing with "No UI available" when installed

[chrishobcroft]

🐛 Bug Report

When installing an Aragon App with a UI schema available on aragonpm, the tool fails to deploy a UI, claiming "No UI available".

Can be reproduced for livepeer.open.aragonpm.eth and ens.open.aragonpm.eth

Have you read the Contributing Guidelines on issues?

Yes.

Context

Mainnet or testnet?

Rinkeby testnet

Organization

0x5E1BE46d9B590E080D443Df0bd14fd6a77112376

Environment

• OS and OS version: Ubuntu 19.04
• Add any other context about the problem here.

To Reproduce

Case in point is livepeer.open.aragonpm.eth

0. Start with a DAO, with an Agent installed, where you have permissions to install apps
1. Run aragon apm info livepeer.open.aragonpm.eth --environment aragon:rinkeby
2. See that there exists a full schema for the app in the aragonpm
3. Install the livepeer.open.aragonpm.eth app in the DAO by running this command:

dao install <DAO-address> livepeer.open.aragonpm.eth --app-init-args <Agent-App-Address> 0x37dC71366Ec655093b9930bc816E16e6b587F968 --environment aragon:rinkeby

4. Add 1 permission by running this command:

dao acl create <DAO-address> <Livepeer-App-Proxy-Address>  REWARD_ROLE 0xffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff 0xffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff --environment aragon:rinkeby

5. Get a list of all the apps installed in the DAO, by running this command:

dao apps <DAO-address> --environment aragon:rinkeby --all

6. See that the installed Livepeer app is listed as (No UI available).
7. Furthermore, when going to view the DAO on the web app, the livepeer app isn't shown.

https://rinkeby.aragon.org/#/

Expected behavior

I expect that the UI defined in the schema shown via aragon apm info... should be used to provide the UI for the app, and for the app to appear in the DAO on the web app.

For example - this DAO / app: https://rinkeby.aragon.org/#/livepeerdelegator/0x698af62d8cd4edb8ee6c7def4e70b6885e34f2b6/

Actual Behavior

The app seems to be installed, but the UI is marked as (No UI available).

Furthermore, the permissions that are set via the cli are not visible in the Web UI

(Write what happened. Add screenshots, if applicable.)

Reproducible Demo

An example DAO which has had multiple instances of the livepeer app installed is 0x5E1BE46d9B590E080D443Df0bd14fd6a77112376.

You can query the apps installed via this command:

dao apps 0x5E1BE46d9B590E080D443Df0bd14fd6a77112376 --environment aragon:rinkeby --all

You can query which permissions are assigned using this command:

dao acl view 0x5E1BE46d9B590E080D443Df0bd14fd6a77112376 --environment aragon:rinkeby

[chrishobcroft]

To reproduce fully, follow this script:

Variables:

<Your-AragonCLI-Address>
<DAO-Address>
<DAO-Token-Address>
<Token-Manager-Proxy-Address>
<Voting-App-Proxy-Address>
<Agent-App-Proxy-Address>
<Livepeer-App-Proxy-Address>

Commands start here:

dao new --environment aragon:rinkeby

dao token new "HelloToken" "HELLO" 0 --environment aragon:rinkeby

dao install <DAO-Address> token-manager --app-init none --environment aragon:rinkeby

dao token change-controller <DAO-Token-Address> <Token-Manager-Proxy-Address> --environment aragon:rinkeby
dao acl create <DAO-Address> <Token-Manager-Proxy-Address> MINT_ROLE <Your-AragonCLI-Address> <Your-AragonCLI-Address> --environment aragon:rinkeby
dao exec <DAO-Address> <Token-Manager-Proxy-Address> initialize <DAO-Token-Address> true 0 --environment aragon:rinkeby
dao exec <DAO-Address> <Token-Manager-Proxy-Address> mint <Your-AragonCLI-Address> 1 --environment aragon:rinkeby
dao install <DAO-Address> voting --app-init-args <DAO-Token-Address> 500000000000000000 500000000000000000 86400 --environment aragon:rinkeby

dao acl create <DAO-Address> <Voting-App-Proxy-Address> CREATE_VOTES_ROLE <Token-Manager-Proxy-Address> <Voting-App-Proxy-Address> --environment aragon:rinkeby

dao install <DAO-Address> agent --environment aragon:rinkeby

STOP at this point, and in the next command, verify the livepeer.open.aragonpm.eth information in aragonpm:

aragon apm info livepeer.open.aragonpm.eth --environment aragon:rinkeby

It's definitely there, right?

So, on with the installation...

dao install <DAO-Address> livepeer.open.aragonpm.eth --app-init-args <Agent-App-Proxy-Address> 0x37dC71366Ec655093b9930bc816E16e6b587F968 --environment aragon:rinkeby

dao acl create <DAO-Address> <Agent-App-Proxy-Address> EXECUTE_ROLE <Livepeer-App-Proxy-Address> <Voting-App-Proxy-Address> --environment aragon:rinkeby
dao acl create <DAO-Address> <Agent-App-Proxy-Address> RUN_SCRIPT_ROLE <Livepeer-App-Proxy-Address> <Voting-App-Proxy-Address> --environment aragon:rinkeby

dao acl create <DAO-Address> <Livepeer-App-Proxy-Address> APPROVE_AND_BOND_ROLE 0xffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff 0xffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff --environment aragon:rinkeby

So... to see what apps we have installed in the DAO:

dao apps <DAO-Address> --environment aragon:rinkeby --all

The Livepeer app is there in the list, right, but "(No UI available)... what gives?

Go to https://rinkeby.aragon.org/#/<DAO-Address> and the Livepeer app isn't showing up... right?

And... to see what permissions each app has:

dao acl view <DAO-Address> --environment aragon:rinkeby

Go to https://rinkeby.aragon.org/#/<DAO-Address>/permissions and the Livepeer app is shown as "Unknown" right?

Here is an example of this script being run, using this DAO: 0x5E1BE46d9B590E080D443Df0bd14fd6a77112376

https://rinkeby.aragon.org/#/0x5E1BE46d9B590E080D443Df0bd14fd6a77112376

[macor161]

Hey @chrishobcroft , seems like the latest version of livepeer doesn't have the correct appName in its artifact.json: https://ipfs.eth.aragon.network/ipfs/QmRzdnYhpwDGh4DWpnEDQdVbDVApJyZDNx2Wo6xnPqdTco/artifact.json
It should be "livepeer.open.aragonpm.eth" instead of "livepeer.aragonpm.eth".
I believe this should fix your problem :)
If you want you can install version 8.3.0 which has the correct appName.

[macor161]

Tested with https://rinkeby.aragon.org/#/test0011/0x95ef4916eca9617c5ccbdeef2c4a68a60e59dc96
Let me know if you're still experiencing trouble with the app, I'll reopen the issue.

[chrishobcroft]

Thanks @macor161 can you confirm how to deploy a previous version of the app?

Right now I'm running:

dao install <DAO-Address> livepeer.open.aragonpm.eth --app-init-args <Agent-App-Proxy-Address> 0x37dC71366Ec655093b9930bc816E16e6b587F968 --environment aragon:rinkeby

What command do I run instead?

[chrishobcroft]

Message from @willjgriff who deployed the app:

The Default option is only used for local deployment. Is like that in the template. So the correct name for Rinkeby and Mainnet is livepeer.open.aragonpm.eth.

<appname>.aragonpm.eth is reserved for main Aragon deployed apps, Voting, Finance etc.

I don't believe the issue your experiencing is because of that naming your referring too. I think it might be an IPFS issue.

So, how come it isn't working?

(@macor161 please reopen)

[macor161]

@chrishobcroft hmm maybe it's a deployment problem then. What I can say is that every working version have livepeer.open.aragonpm.eth in their artifact.json except for the latest broken version: https://ipfs.eth.aragon.network/ipfs/QmRzdnYhpwDGh4DWpnEDQdVbDVApJyZDNx2Wo6xnPqdTco/artifact.json Do you know when was this version released?

To install 8.3.0:
dao install <DAO> livepeer.open.aragonpm.eth "8.3.0" --app-init-args <agent address> 0x37dC71366Ec655093b9930bc816E16e6b587F968 --environment aragon:rinkeby

[chrishobcroft]

OK, thanks @macor161, perhaps that is the culprit after all.

I will try the deployment with the downgraded version.

[macor161]

@chrishobcroft Were you able to install it with version 8.3.0?

[chrishobcroft]

I did, yes, thank you @macor161.

It would appear that the issue here is indeed with the appName - you were right :)

Closing