[Mempool] Fix mempool limiting and replace-by-fee for PrioritiseTrans…

…action

1) Fix mempool limiting for PrioritiseTransaction

Redo the feerate index to be based on mining score, rather than fee.

Update mempool_packages.py to test prioritisetransaction's effect on
package scores.

2) Update replace-by-fee logic to use fee deltas

3) Use fee deltas for determining mempool acceptance

4) Remove GetMinRelayFee

One test in AcceptToMemoryPool was to compare a transaction's fee
agains the value returned by GetMinRelayFee. This value was zero for
all small transactions.  For larger transactions (between
DEFAULT_BLOCK_PRIORITY_SIZE and MAX_STANDARD_TX_SIZE), this function
was preventing low fee transactions from ever being accepted.

With this function removed, we will now allow transactions in that range
with fees (including modifications via PrioritiseTransaction) below
the minRelayTxFee, provided that they have sufficient priority.

Github-Pull: #7062
Rebased-From: eb30666 9ef2a25 27fae34 901b01d

qa/rpc-tests/mempool_packages.py

@@ -64,17 +64,41 @@ def run_test(self):
         for x in reversed(chain):
             assert_equal(mempool[x]['descendantcount'], descendant_count)
             descendant_fees += mempool[x]['fee']
+            assert_equal(mempool[x]['modifiedfee'], mempool[x]['fee'])
             assert_equal(mempool[x]['descendantfees'], SATOSHIS*descendant_fees)
             descendant_size += mempool[x]['size']
             assert_equal(mempool[x]['descendantsize'], descendant_size)
             descendant_count += 1
 
+        # Check that descendant modified fees includes fee deltas from
+        # prioritisetransaction
+        self.nodes[0].prioritisetransaction(chain[-1], 0, 1000)
+        mempool = self.nodes[0].getrawmempool(True)
+
+        descendant_fees = 0
+        for x in reversed(chain):
+            descendant_fees += mempool[x]['fee']
+            assert_equal(mempool[x]['descendantfees'], SATOSHIS*descendant_fees+1000)
+
         # Adding one more transaction on to the chain should fail.
         try:
             self.chain_transaction(self.nodes[0], txid, vout, value, fee, 1)
         except JSONRPCException as e:
             print "too-long-ancestor-chain successfully rejected"
 
+        # Check that prioritising a tx before it's added to the mempool works
+        self.nodes[0].generate(1)
+        self.nodes[0].prioritisetransaction(chain[-1], 0, 2000)
+        self.nodes[0].invalidateblock(self.nodes[0].getbestblockhash())
+        mempool = self.nodes[0].getrawmempool(True)
+
+        descendant_fees = 0
+        for x in reversed(chain):
+            descendant_fees += mempool[x]['fee']
+            if (x == chain[-1]):
+                assert_equal(mempool[x]['modifiedfee'], mempool[x]['fee']+satoshi_round(0.00002))
+            assert_equal(mempool[x]['descendantfees'], SATOSHIS*descendant_fees+2000)
+
         # TODO: check that node1's mempool is as expected
 
         # TODO: test ancestor size limits

qa/rpc-tests/prioritise_transaction.py

@@ -143,5 +143,45 @@ def run_test(self):
             if (x != high_fee_tx):
                 assert(x not in mempool)
 
+        # Create a free, low priority transaction.  Should be rejected.
+        utxo_list = self.nodes[0].listunspent()
+        assert(len(utxo_list) > 0)
+        utxo = utxo_list[0]
+
+        inputs = []
+        outputs = {}
+        inputs.append({"txid" : utxo["txid"], "vout" : utxo["vout"]})
+        outputs[self.nodes[0].getnewaddress()] = utxo["amount"] - self.relayfee
+        raw_tx = self.nodes[0].createrawtransaction(inputs, outputs)
+        tx_hex = self.nodes[0].signrawtransaction(raw_tx)["hex"]
+        txid = self.nodes[0].sendrawtransaction(tx_hex)
+
+        # A tx that spends an in-mempool tx has 0 priority, so we can use it to
+        # test the effect of using prioritise transaction for mempool acceptance
+        inputs = []
+        inputs.append({"txid": txid, "vout": 0})
+        outputs = {}
+        outputs[self.nodes[0].getnewaddress()] = utxo["amount"] - self.relayfee
+        raw_tx2 = self.nodes[0].createrawtransaction(inputs, outputs)
+        tx2_hex = self.nodes[0].signrawtransaction(raw_tx2)["hex"]
+        tx2_id = self.nodes[0].decoderawtransaction(tx2_hex)["txid"]
+
+        try:
+            self.nodes[0].sendrawtransaction(tx2_hex)
+        except JSONRPCException as exp:
+            assert_equal(exp.error['code'], -26) # insufficient fee
+            assert(tx2_id not in self.nodes[0].getrawmempool())
+        else:
+            assert(False)
+
+        # This is a less than 1000-byte transaction, so just set the fee
+        # to be the minimum for a 1000 byte transaction and check that it is
+        # accepted.
+        self.nodes[0].prioritisetransaction(tx2_id, 0, int(self.relayfee*COIN))
+
+        print "Assert that prioritised free transaction is accepted to mempool"
+        assert_equal(self.nodes[0].sendrawtransaction(tx2_hex), tx2_id)
+        assert(tx2_id in self.nodes[0].getrawmempool())
+
 if __name__ == '__main__':
     PrioritiseTransactionTest().main()

qa/rpc-tests/replace-by-fee.py

@@ -63,16 +63,22 @@ def make_utxo(node, amount, confirmed=True, scriptPubKey=CScript([1])):
 
     # If requested, ensure txouts are confirmed.
     if confirmed:
-        while len(node.getrawmempool()):
+        mempool_size = len(node.getrawmempool())
+        while mempool_size > 0:
             node.generate(1)
+            new_size = len(node.getrawmempool())
+            # Error out if we have something stuck in the mempool, as this
+            # would likely be a bug.
+            assert(new_size < mempool_size)
+            mempool_size = new_size
 
     return COutPoint(int(txid, 16), 0)
 
 class ReplaceByFeeTest(BitcoinTestFramework):
 
     def setup_network(self):
         self.nodes = []
-        self.nodes.append(start_node(0, self.options.tmpdir, ["-maxorphantx=1000",
+        self.nodes.append(start_node(0, self.options.tmpdir, ["-maxorphantx=1000", "-debug",
                                                               "-relaypriority=0", "-whitelist=127.0.0.1",
                                                               "-limitancestorcount=50",
                                                               "-limitancestorsize=101",
@@ -108,6 +114,9 @@ def run_test(self):
         print "Running test opt-in..."
         self.test_opt_in()
 
+        print "Running test prioritised transactions..."
+        self.test_prioritised_transactions()
+
         print "Passed\n"
 
     def test_simple_doublespend(self):
@@ -513,5 +522,72 @@ def test_opt_in(self):
         # but make sure it is accepted anyway
         self.nodes[0].sendrawtransaction(tx3c_hex, True)
 
+    def test_prioritised_transactions(self):
+        # Ensure that fee deltas used via prioritisetransaction are
+        # correctly used by replacement logic
+
+        # 1. Check that feeperkb uses modified fees
+        tx0_outpoint = make_utxo(self.nodes[0], 1.1*COIN)
+
+        tx1a = CTransaction()
+        tx1a.vin = [CTxIn(tx0_outpoint, nSequence=0)]
+        tx1a.vout = [CTxOut(1*COIN, CScript([b'a']))]
+        tx1a_hex = txToHex(tx1a)
+        tx1a_txid = self.nodes[0].sendrawtransaction(tx1a_hex, True)
+
+        # Higher fee, but the actual fee per KB is much lower.
+        tx1b = CTransaction()
+        tx1b.vin = [CTxIn(tx0_outpoint, nSequence=0)]
+        tx1b.vout = [CTxOut(0.001*COIN, CScript([b'a'*740000]))]
+        tx1b_hex = txToHex(tx1b)
+
+        # Verify tx1b cannot replace tx1a.
+        try:
+            tx1b_txid = self.nodes[0].sendrawtransaction(tx1b_hex, True)
+        except JSONRPCException as exp:
+            assert_equal(exp.error['code'], -26)
+        else:
+            assert(False)
+
+        # Use prioritisetransaction to set tx1a's fee to 0.
+        self.nodes[0].prioritisetransaction(tx1a_txid, 0, int(-0.1*COIN))
+
+        # Now tx1b should be able to replace tx1a
+        tx1b_txid = self.nodes[0].sendrawtransaction(tx1b_hex, True)
+
+        assert(tx1b_txid in self.nodes[0].getrawmempool())
+
+        # 2. Check that absolute fee checks use modified fee.
+        tx1_outpoint = make_utxo(self.nodes[0], 1.1*COIN)
+
+        tx2a = CTransaction()
+        tx2a.vin = [CTxIn(tx1_outpoint, nSequence=0)]
+        tx2a.vout = [CTxOut(1*COIN, CScript([b'a']))]
+        tx2a_hex = txToHex(tx2a)
+        tx2a_txid = self.nodes[0].sendrawtransaction(tx2a_hex, True)
+
+        # Lower fee, but we'll prioritise it
+        tx2b = CTransaction()
+        tx2b.vin = [CTxIn(tx1_outpoint, nSequence=0)]
+        tx2b.vout = [CTxOut(1.01*COIN, CScript([b'a']))]
+        tx2b.rehash()
+        tx2b_hex = txToHex(tx2b)
+
+        # Verify tx2b cannot replace tx2a.
+        try:
+            tx2b_txid = self.nodes[0].sendrawtransaction(tx2b_hex, True)
+        except JSONRPCException as exp:
+            assert_equal(exp.error['code'], -26)
+        else:
+            assert(False)
+
+        # Now prioritise tx2b to have a higher modified fee
+        self.nodes[0].prioritisetransaction(tx2b.hash, 0, int(0.1*COIN))
+
+        # tx2b should now be accepted
+        tx2b_txid = self.nodes[0].sendrawtransaction(tx2b_hex, True)
+
+        assert(tx2b_txid in self.nodes[0].getrawmempool())
+
 if __name__ == '__main__':
     ReplaceByFeeTest().main()

src/main.cpp

@@ -800,32 +800,6 @@ void LimitMempoolSize(CTxMemPool& pool, size_t limit, unsigned long age) {
         pcoinsTip->Uncache(removed);
 }
 
-CAmount GetMinRelayFee(const CTransaction& tx, const CTxMemPool& pool, unsigned int nBytes, bool fAllowFree)
-{
-    uint256 hash = tx.GetHash();
-    double dPriorityDelta = 0;
-    CAmount nFeeDelta = 0;
-    pool.ApplyDeltas(hash, dPriorityDelta, nFeeDelta);
-    if (dPriorityDelta > 0 || nFeeDelta > 0)
-        return 0;
-
-    CAmount nMinFee = ::minRelayTxFee.GetFee(nBytes);
-
-    if (fAllowFree)
-    {
-        // There is a free transaction area in blocks created by most miners,
-        // * If we are relaying we allow transactions up to DEFAULT_BLOCK_PRIORITY_SIZE - 1000
-        //   to be considered to fall into this category. We don't want to encourage sending
-        //   multiple transactions instead of one big transaction to avoid fees.
-        if (nBytes < (DEFAULT_BLOCK_PRIORITY_SIZE - 1000))
-            nMinFee = 0;
-    }
-
-    if (!MoneyRange(nMinFee))
-        nMinFee = MAX_MONEY;
-    return nMinFee;
-}
-
 /** Convert CValidationState to a human-readable message for logging */
 std::string FormatStateMessage(const CValidationState &state)
 {
@@ -968,6 +942,11 @@ bool AcceptToMemoryPoolWorker(CTxMemPool& pool, CValidationState &state, const C
 
         CAmount nValueOut = tx.GetValueOut();
         CAmount nFees = nValueIn-nValueOut;
+        // nModifiedFees includes any fee deltas from PrioritiseTransaction
+        CAmount nModifiedFees = nFees;
+        double nPriorityDummy = 0;
+        pool.ApplyDeltas(hash, nPriorityDummy, nModifiedFees);
+
         CAmount inChainInputValue;
         double dPriority = view.GetPriority(tx, chainActive.Height(), inChainInputValue);
 
@@ -985,24 +964,18 @@ bool AcceptToMemoryPoolWorker(CTxMemPool& pool, CValidationState &state, const C
         CTxMemPoolEntry entry(tx, nFees, GetTime(), dPriority, chainActive.Height(), pool.HasNoInputsOf(tx), inChainInputValue, fSpendsCoinbase, nSigOps);
         unsigned int nSize = entry.GetTxSize();
 
-        // Don't accept it if it can't get into a block
-        CAmount txMinFee = GetMinRelayFee(tx, pool, nSize, true);
-        if (fLimitFree && nFees < txMinFee)
-            return state.DoS(0, false, REJECT_INSUFFICIENTFEE, "insufficient fee", false,
-                strprintf("%d < %d", nFees, txMinFee));
-
         CAmount mempoolRejectFee = pool.GetMinFee(GetArg("-maxmempool", DEFAULT_MAX_MEMPOOL_SIZE) * 1000000).GetFee(nSize);
-        if (mempoolRejectFee > 0 && nFees < mempoolRejectFee) {
+        if (mempoolRejectFee > 0 && nModifiedFees < mempoolRejectFee) {
             return state.DoS(0, false, REJECT_INSUFFICIENTFEE, "mempool min fee not met", false, strprintf("%d < %d", nFees, mempoolRejectFee));
-        } else if (GetBoolArg("-relaypriority", DEFAULT_RELAYPRIORITY) && nFees < ::minRelayTxFee.GetFee(nSize) && !AllowFree(entry.GetPriority(chainActive.Height() + 1))) {
+        } else if (GetBoolArg("-relaypriority", DEFAULT_RELAYPRIORITY) && nModifiedFees < ::minRelayTxFee.GetFee(nSize) && !AllowFree(entry.GetPriority(chainActive.Height() + 1))) {
             // Require that free transactions have sufficient priority to be mined in the next block.
             return state.DoS(0, false, REJECT_INSUFFICIENTFEE, "insufficient priority");
         }
 
         // Continuously rate-limit free (really, very-low-fee) transactions
         // This mitigates 'penny-flooding' -- sending thousands of free transactions just to
         // be annoying or make others' transactions take longer to confirm.
-        if (fLimitFree && nFees < ::minRelayTxFee.GetFee(nSize))
+        if (fLimitFree && nModifiedFees < ::minRelayTxFee.GetFee(nSize))
         {
             static CCriticalSection csFreeLimiter;
             static double dFreeCount;
@@ -1067,7 +1040,7 @@ bool AcceptToMemoryPoolWorker(CTxMemPool& pool, CValidationState &state, const C
         LOCK(pool.cs);
         if (setConflicts.size())
         {
-            CFeeRate newFeeRate(nFees, nSize);
+            CFeeRate newFeeRate(nModifiedFees, nSize);
             set<uint256> setConflictsParents;
             const int maxDescendantsToVisit = 100;
             CTxMemPool::setEntries setIterConflicting;
@@ -1110,7 +1083,7 @@ bool AcceptToMemoryPoolWorker(CTxMemPool& pool, CValidationState &state, const C
                 // ignored when deciding whether or not to replace, we do
                 // require the replacement to pay more overall fees too,
                 // mitigating most cases.
-                CFeeRate oldFeeRate(mi->GetFee(), mi->GetTxSize());
+                CFeeRate oldFeeRate(mi->GetModifiedFee(), mi->GetTxSize());
                 if (newFeeRate <= oldFeeRate)
                 {
                     return state.DoS(0,
@@ -1138,7 +1111,7 @@ bool AcceptToMemoryPoolWorker(CTxMemPool& pool, CValidationState &state, const C
                     pool.CalculateDescendants(it, allConflicting);
                 }
                 BOOST_FOREACH(CTxMemPool::txiter it, allConflicting) {
-                    nConflictingFees += it->GetFee();
+                    nConflictingFees += it->GetModifiedFee();
                     nConflictingSize += it->GetTxSize();
                 }
             } else {
@@ -1171,16 +1144,16 @@ bool AcceptToMemoryPoolWorker(CTxMemPool& pool, CValidationState &state, const C
             // The replacement must pay greater fees than the transactions it
             // replaces - if we did the bandwidth used by those conflicting
             // transactions would not be paid for.
-            if (nFees < nConflictingFees)
+            if (nModifiedFees < nConflictingFees)
             {
                 return state.DoS(0, error("AcceptToMemoryPool: rejecting replacement %s, less fees than conflicting txs; %s < %s",
-                                          hash.ToString(), FormatMoney(nFees), FormatMoney(nConflictingFees)),
+                                          hash.ToString(), FormatMoney(nModifiedFees), FormatMoney(nConflictingFees)),
                                  REJECT_INSUFFICIENTFEE, "insufficient fee");
             }
 
             // Finally in addition to paying more fees than the conflicts the
             // new transaction must pay for its own bandwidth.
-            CAmount nDeltaFees = nFees - nConflictingFees;
+            CAmount nDeltaFees = nModifiedFees - nConflictingFees;
             if (nDeltaFees < ::minRelayTxFee.GetFee(nSize))
             {
                 return state.DoS(0,
@@ -1218,7 +1191,7 @@ bool AcceptToMemoryPoolWorker(CTxMemPool& pool, CValidationState &state, const C
             LogPrint("mempool", "replacing tx %s with %s for %s BTC additional fees, %d delta bytes\n",
                     it->GetTx().GetHash().ToString(),
                     hash.ToString(),
-                    FormatMoney(nFees - nConflictingFees),
+                    FormatMoney(nModifiedFees - nConflictingFees),
                     (int)nSize - (int)nConflictingSize);
         }
         pool.RemoveStaged(allConflicting);

src/main.h

@@ -300,8 +300,6 @@ struct CDiskTxPos : public CDiskBlockPos
 };
 
 
-CAmount GetMinRelayFee(const CTransaction& tx, unsigned int nBytes, bool fAllowFree);
-
 /** 
  * Count ECDSA signature operations the old-fashioned (pre-0.6) way
  * @return number of sigops this transaction's outputs will produce when spent

src/rpcblockchain.cpp

@@ -197,7 +197,7 @@ UniValue mempoolToJSON(bool fVerbose = false)
             info.push_back(Pair("currentpriority", e.GetPriority(chainActive.Height())));
             info.push_back(Pair("descendantcount", e.GetCountWithDescendants()));
             info.push_back(Pair("descendantsize", e.GetSizeWithDescendants()));
-            info.push_back(Pair("descendantfees", e.GetFeesWithDescendants()));
+            info.push_back(Pair("descendantfees", e.GetModFeesWithDescendants()));
             const CTransaction& tx = e.GetTx();
             set<string> setDepends;
             BOOST_FOREACH(const CTxIn& txin, tx.vin)
@@ -255,7 +255,7 @@ UniValue getrawmempool(const UniValue& params, bool fHelp)
             "    \"currentpriority\" : n,  (numeric) transaction priority now\n"
             "    \"descendantcount\" : n,  (numeric) number of in-mempool descendant transactions (including this one)\n"
             "    \"descendantsize\" : n,   (numeric) size of in-mempool descendants (including this one)\n"
-            "    \"descendantfees\" : n,   (numeric) fees of in-mempool descendants (including this one)\n"
+            "    \"descendantfees\" : n,   (numeric) modified fees (see above) of in-mempool descendants (including this one)\n"
             "    \"depends\" : [           (array) unconfirmed transactions used as inputs for this transaction\n"
             "        \"transactionid\",    (string) parent transaction id\n"
             "       ... ]\n"