Checklist for the 0.0.1 MVP prototype: rules for JSON-LD, generated page and year page (basis for #13)

[WolfgangFahl]

✍️🤖 Agent/Evi: proposed checklist for the 0.0.1 MVP prototype (#13) as a basis for discussion. Each rule has a criterion that passes or fails. The objects checked are a volume's JSON-LD, the page generated from it and the year page.

#	Rule	Check	Source
1	The JSON-LD uses the normative context	namespace is https://ceur-ws.org/rdf/schema# and all terms resolve in ontology/ceur-ws-context.jsonld	repo ontology
2	The volume number is a positive integer	value parses as integer and equals N of Vol-N	#14
3	The proceedings title names the edition	title contains a year or an ordinal	#22
4	The volume has a year	the event start date is an ISO date; its year is the year of the volume, also when that breaks the order of volume numbers	Wolfgang Fahl, #24
5	The URN is correct	matches urn:nbn:de:0074-N-C with C the computed check digit	#2
6	Event dates are valid	ISO dates, start not after end, duration at most 11 days	#12
7	Every editor has a full name	given and family name non-empty	Vol-3889
8	Every paper has title, URL and at least one author	fields present and non-empty	#1
9	Person names are clean	no family name consisting of digits	Vol-3889
10	Titles are single-line	no line break, no run of spaces	Vol-3889
11	Paper URLs are flat	Vol-N/name.pdf, no subdirectory	WolfgangFahl/pyCEURmake#2
12	The volume is linked to Wikidata	Wikidata id present and its volume number equals N	#13
13	The generated page is valid HTML5	W3C validator reports no errors	WolfgangFahl/pyCEURmake#2
14	The generated page is UTF-8	file decodes as UTF-8	#7
15	No broken paper links	every paper link on the page resolves	WolfgangFahl/pyCEURmake#2
16	The page embeds its JSON-LD	exactly one JSON-LD fence, extractable	#21
17	The round trip holds	JSON-LD extracted from the page equals the input	#16, #21
18a	Prototype: the page links back twice	two links present, see agent reading below	Wolfgang Fahl
18b	Production: differs from the prototype	to be specified	Wolfgang Fahl
19	The year page is complete	lists exactly the volumes whose event starts in that year	#13, #24
20	The project is compliant	checkos reports no failed check	pyOpenSourceProjects
21	Generated resources are content negotiated	a request without extension returns the HTML for Accept: text/html and the JSON-LD for Accept: application/ld+json	#5
22	The year page links to its neighbours	links to the previous and the next year, where those years exist	Wolfgang Fahl

Prototype, generated by the generator of #24 from the ceur-spt JSON-LD, year by event date: 2023 with Vol-3887, 2024 with Vol-4175 and Vol-3889, 2025 with Vol-4184, 2026 with Vol-4183. These are the latest volumes per event year that ceur-spt serves, plus Vol-3889; ceur-spt answers with a server error for volumes above about Vol-4184.

State on the generated pages:

• pass on all four year pages and five volume pages: 13 (W3C check without messages), 14, 15, 16, 17 with semantify3 0.1.0, 21, 22
• pass: 20, checkos 47 of 47
• pass for the five volumes: 4
• open: 19, each year page lists only the volumes generated so far; 18, the pages carry links to the original and the mirror, see agent reading
• fail on the ceur-spt JSON-LD of Vol-3889: 1, 2, 7, 9, 10
• not yet checked: 3, 5, 6, 8, 11, 12
• a volume without event start date has no year by rule 4; the generator skips and reports it

Agent reading, not from a source:

• rule 1 assumes the normative context is the target; ceur-spt serves https://ceur-ws.org/schema# with ceur:Proceedings and ceur:volume_nr, the context in this repo uses https://ceur-ws.org/rdf/schema# with ProceedingsVolume and volumeNumber
• rule 18a: the two links are read as the original page https://ceur-ws.org/Vol-N/ and its copy on the mirror
• rules 7, 9 and 10 are derived from the defects seen in the Vol-3889 JSON-LD, not from an issue