Migrate legacy EDModules to thread-efficient alternatives #36404

makortel · 2021-12-07T21:17:13Z

Legacy EDModules have been effectively deprecated since the start of Run 2, and we are now phasing out their support.

Current ways to locate legacy EDModules:

Static analyzer lists those not in test/ directories
CMSDEPRECATED IB lists all of them as compilation warnings (accompanied with code that needs to be migrated to esConsumes, Migrate ED modules to use esConsumes #31061)
cmsRun jobs print out a warning message listing legacy EDModules run in that job

The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:

cmsbuild · 2021-12-07T21:17:32Z

A new Issue was created by @makortel Matti Kortelainen.

@Dr15Jones, @perrotta, @dpiparo, @makortel, @smuzaffar, @qliphy can you please review it and eventually sign/assign? Thanks.

cms-bot commands are listed here

makortel · 2021-12-07T21:18:42Z

assign analysis,code,db,dqm,generators,l1,upgrade

(starting with categories whose legacy EDModules are being run in IBs)

cmsbuild · 2021-12-07T21:19:02Z

New categories assigned: upgrade,db,analysis,generators,l1,dqm

@jfernan2,@ahmad3213,@AdrianoDee,@mkirsano,@rvenditti,@emanueleusai,@ggovi,@srimanob,@alberto-sanchez,@SiewYan,@santocch,@rekovic,@GurpreetSinghChahal,@francescobrivio,@pbo0,@malbouis,@tvami,@Saptaparna,@cecilecaillol,@agrohsje,@pmandrik you have been requested to review this Pull request/Issue and eventually sign? Thanks

makortel · 2021-12-07T21:21:49Z

As a step towards being able to change the warning message to an exception (goal is by 13_0_0) I gathered EDModules listed by the warning messages in full runTheMatrix and unit test logs, and classified the EDModules by their packages and L2 areas. Below is a list from CMSSW_12_3_X_2021-12-06-2300 (the name(s) after the C++ type name are the module labels in the jobs they were run).

@cms-sw/analysis-l2

PhysicsTools/HepMCCandAlgos:
- ParticleListDrawer printDecaySubset
PhysicsTools/UtilAlgos:
- WrappedEDMuonAnalyzer muonAnalyzer
TopQuarkAnalysis/TopEventProducers:
- TopDecaySubset decaySubset
- TopInitSubset initSubset
- TtFullHadEvtBuilder ttFullHadEvent
- TtFullLepEvtBuilder ttFullLepEvent
- TtGenEventReco genEvt
- TtSemiLepEvtBuilder ttSemiLepEvent
TopQuarkAnalysis/TopHitFit:
- TtSemiLepHitFitProducerMuon hitFitTtSemiLepEvent,hitFitTtSemiLepEventHypothesis
TopQuarkAnalysis/TopKinFitter:
- TtFullHadKinFitProducer kinFitTtFullHadEvent,kinFitTtFullHadEventHypothesis
- TtFullLepKinSolutionProducer kinSolutionTtFullLepEvent,kinSolutionTtFullLepEventHypothesis
- TtSemiLepKinFitProducerMuon kinFitTtSemiLepEvent,kinFitTtSemiLepEventHypothesis,kinFitTtSemiLepEventSelection
TopQuarkAnalysis/TopJetCombination:
- TtFullHadHypGenMatch ttFullHadHypGenMatch
- TtFullHadHypKinFit ttFullHadHypKinFit
- TtFullLepHypGenMatch ttFullLepHypGenMatch
- TtFullLepHypKinSolution ttFullLepHypKinSolution
- TtSemiLepHypGenMatch ttSemiLepHypGenMatch
- TtSemiLepHypGeom ttSemiLepHypGeom
- TtSemiLepHypHitFit ttSemiLepHypHitFit
- TtSemiLepHypKinFit ttSemiLepHypKinFit
- TtSemiLepHypMaxSumPtWMass ttSemiLepHypMaxSumPtWMass
- TtSemiLepHypMVADisc ttSemiLepHypMVADisc
- TtSemiLepHypWMassDeltaTopMass ttSemiLepHypWMassDeltaTopMass
- TtSemiLepHypWMassMaxSumPt ttSemiLepHypWMassMaxSumPt
- TtSemiLepJetCombGeom findTtSemiLepJetCombGeom
- TtSemiLepJetCombMaxSumPtWMass findTtSemiLepJetCombMaxSumPtWMass
- TtSemiLepJetCombWMassDeltaTopMass findTtSemiLepJetCombWMassDeltaTopMass
- TtSemiLepJetCombWMassMaxSumPt findTtSemiLepJetCombWMassMaxSumPt
TopQuarkAnalysis/TopSkimming:
- TtDecayChannelFilter ttFullHadronicFilter,ttFullLeptonicFilter,ttSemiLeptonicFilter
TopQuarkAnalysis/TopTools:
- TtFullHadJetPartonMatch ttFullHadJetPartonMatch
- TtFullLepJetPartonMatch ttFullLepJetPartonMatch
- TtSemiLepJetPartonMatch ttSemiLepJetPartonMatch

@cms-sw/core-l2

FWCore/Framework:
- IntLegacyProducer one,two
- TestBeginEndJobAnalyzer m1
- TestFailuresAnalyzer m1
FWCore/Integration:
- HierarchicalEDProducer h
- ProdigalAnalyzer analyzer

@cms-sw/db-l2

OnlineDB/SiStripO2O:
- SiStripO2OBadStrip siStripO2O

@cms-sw/dqm-l2

DQM/BeamMonitor:
- AlcaBeamMonitorClient AlcaBeamMonitorClient
DQM/EcalCommon:
- EcalMonitorPrescaler ecalPhysicsFilter
DQM/EcalPreshowerMonitorModule:
- ESDaqInfoTask ecalPreshowerDaqInfoTask
- ESDataCertificationTask ecalPreshowerDataCertificationTask
- ESDcsInfoTask ecalPreshowerDcsInfoTask
DQM/SiStripMonitorClient:
- SiStripAnalyser SiStripAnalyser
- SiStripCertificationInfo siStripCertificationInfo
- SiStripDaqInfo siStripDaqInfo
- SiStripDcsInfo siStripDcsInfo
DQMOffline/Trigger:
- DQMOfflineHLTEventInfoClient HLTOverallSummary
- EgHLTOfflineSummaryClient egHLTOffDQMSummaryClient
- HLTInclusiveVBFClient hltInclusiveVBFClient
DQMServices/Components:
- DQMFEDIntegrityClient dqmFEDIntegrity
- DQMMessageLoggerClient DQMMessageLoggerClient
DQMServices/Demo:
- TestLegacyEDAnalyzer testlegacy
- TestLegacyFillRunEDAnalyzer testlegacyfillrun
- TestLegacyFillLumiEDAnalyzer testlegacyfilllumi
- TestLegacyHarvester testlegacyharvester
DQMServices/FwkIO:
- DummyReadDQMStore reader
Validation/RecoEgamma:
- ConversionPostprocessing conversionPostprocessing
- PhotonPostprocessing pfPhotonPostprocessing,photonPostprocessing
Validation/RecoTau:
- DQMHistNormalizer normalizePlotsZTT

@cms-sw/generators-l2

GeneratorInterface/LHEInterface:
- DummyLHEAnalyzer lhedump

@cms-sw/l1-l2

DataFormats/L1TrackTrigger:
- TTTrackTrackWordDummyOneAnalyzer dummyAna
EventFilter/CSCTFRawToDigi:
- CSCTFSingleGen csctfsinglegen
- CSCTFAnalyzer csctfanalyzer

@cms-sw/upgrade-l2

DataFormats/L1TrackTrigger:
- TTTrackTrackWordDummyOneAnalyzer dummyAna

makortel · 2021-12-07T21:22:04Z

assign core

cmsbuild · 2021-12-07T21:22:06Z

New categories assigned: core

@Dr15Jones,@smuzaffar,@makortel you have been requested to review this Pull request/Issue and eventually sign? Thanks

agrohsje · 2021-12-08T07:34:16Z

Hi @SiewYan . Do you mind updating
GeneratorInterface/LHEInterface:

DummyLHEAnalyzer lhedump ?
Thanks!

SiewYan · 2021-12-08T08:24:09Z

@agrohsje , i will see to it!

jfernan2 · 2021-12-09T11:38:35Z

Thanks @makortel
Regarding the DQM modules, some of them (see below) are running on Online DQM (single thread) or in dedicated test configs or Unit Tests. Anyway, could you please remind in this thread some information about which are the alternatives and some instructions?

I found these two twikis but I am not sure if they are up to date:
https://twiki.cern.ch/twiki/bin/view/CMSPublic/FWMultithreadedThreadSafeDataStructures
https://twiki.cern.ch/twiki/bin/view/CMSPublic/FWMultithreadedAnalysisEDAnalyzer
Thank you

ecalPhysicsFilter
SiStripAnalyser
egHLTOffDQMSummaryClient
testlegacy*
DummyReadDQMStore reader

makortel · 2021-12-09T16:54:02Z

@jfernan2 Those two links are largely up to date. In addition, the different module types (globla/stream/one) are documented in https://twiki.cern.ch/twiki/bin/view/CMSPublic/FWMultithreadedFrameworkModuleTypes and links in there.

Some general rules of thumb

EDAnalyzers that expect to see every event to e.g. fill a histogram are easiest to migrate to edm::one.
- Especially if they use TFileService they need to be edm::one and use edm::one::SharedResources extension as shown in https://twiki.cern.ch/twiki/bin/view/CMSPublic/FWMultithreadedAnalysisEDAnalyzer#Using_TFileService or https://twiki.cern.ch/twiki/bin/view/CMSPublic/FWMultithreadedFrameworkOneModuleInterface#edm_one_SharedResources
EDProducers/EDFilters that do not need to see every event, and use EDModule member data to communicate per-Event information between member functions are easiest to migrate to edm::stream
EDProducers/EDFilters that use member data only for (constant) configuration parameters, and all helper functions they call are thread safe, can be migrated to edm::global (which is the most resource-efficient type)

(there are many cases that do not fit in these categories, but I'd expect those to be easiest to discuss case-by-case)

makortel · 2021-12-09T17:26:45Z

@jfernan2 Looking at the specific cases you listed

EcalMonitorPrescaler ecalPhysicsFilter could be migrated to edm::global::EDFilter<edm::RunCache<...>> when using atomics for the counters (or without atomics to edm::one with RunCache, but it would be less efficient)
SiStripAnalyser SiStripAnalyser looks complicated, it also accesses DQMStore directly
EgHLTOfflineSummaryClient egHLTOffDQMSummaryClient I'd try to migrate to DQMEDHarvester
TestLegacy* testlegacy* eventually remove?
DummyReadDQMStore reader I'd try edm::one, similarly to DQMEDHarvester (but likely fewer extensions are needed)

makortel · 2022-05-18T22:32:29Z

Around 2022-05-02 the deprecation annotations in CMSDEPRECATED_X were updated such that they should now flag reliably all classes that derive from legacy EDModule (or at least more reliably than earlier).

I also went through the logs of CMSSW_12_5_X_2022-05-17-2300 matrix tests and unit tests, and the following legacy EDModules are being run there for sure (there can be more that my log parsing approach fails to find)

@cms-sw/analysis-l2

PhysicsTools/UtilAlgos:
- WrappedEDMuonAnalyzer muonAnalyzer
TopQuarkAnalysis/TopKinFitter:
- TtFullLepKinSolutionProducer kinSolutionTtFullLepEvent,kinSolutionTtFullLepEventHypothesis

@cms-sw/core-l2

FWCore/Framework:
- IntLegacyProducer one,two

@cms-sw/dqm-l2

DQM/BeamMonitor:
- AlcaBeamMonitorClient AlcaBeamMonitorClient
DQM/EcalCommon:
- EcalMonitorPrescaler ecalPhysicsFilter
DQM/EcalPreshowerMonitorModule:
- ESDaqInfoTask ecalPreshowerDaqInfoTask
- ESDataCertificationTask ecalPreshowerDataCertificationTask
- ESDcsInfoTask ecalPreshowerDcsInfoTask
DQM/SiStripMonitorClient:
- SiStripAnalyser SiStripAnalyser
- SiStripCertificationInfo siStripCertificationInfo
- SiStripDaqInfo siStripDaqInfo
- SiStripDcsInfo siStripDcsInfo
DQMOffline/Trigger:
- DQMOfflineHLTEventInfoClient HLTOverallSummary
- EgHLTOfflineSummaryClient egHLTOffDQMSummaryClient
- HLTInclusiveVBFClient hltInclusiveVBFClient
DQMServices/Demo:
- TestLegacyEDAnalyzer testlegacy
- TestLegacyFillRunEDAnalyzer testlegacyfillrun
- TestLegacyFillLumiEDAnalyzer testlegacyfilllumi
- TestLegacyHarvester testlegacyharvester
DQMServices/FwkIO:
- DummyReadDQMStore reader
Validation/RecoTau:
- DQMHistNormalizer normalizePlotsZTT

Thanks for the help! The list continues to shrink.

makortel · 2022-09-28T15:42:11Z

I updated the list of legacy EDModules still being run as part of runTheMatrix or unit tests for sure (there can be more that my log parsing approach fails to find) in CMSSW_12_6_X_2022-09-27-2300

Former @cms-sw/analysis-l2

PhysicsTools/UtilAlgos:
- WrappedEDMuonAnalyzer muonAnalyzer

@cms-sw/core-l2

FWCore/Framework:
- IntLegacyProducer one,two

@cms-sw/dqm-l2

DQM/BeamMonitor:
- AlcaBeamMonitorClient AlcaBeamMonitorClient
DQM/EcalPreshowerMonitorModule:
- ESDaqInfoTask ecalPreshowerDaqInfoTask
- ESDataCertificationTask ecalPreshowerDataCertificationTask
- ESDcsInfoTask ecalPreshowerDcsInfoTask
DQM/SiStripMonitorClient:
- SiStripAnalyser SiStripAnalyser
- SiStripCertificationInfo siStripCertificationInfo
- SiStripDaqInfo siStripDaqInfo
- SiStripDcsInfo siStripDcsInfo
DQMServices/Demo:
- TestLegacyEDAnalyzer testlegacy
- TestLegacyFillRunEDAnalyzer testlegacyfillrun
- TestLegacyFillLumiEDAnalyzer testlegacyfilllumi
- TestLegacyHarvester testlegacyharvester
DQMServices/FwkIO:
- DummyReadDQMStore reader
Validation/RecoTau:
- DQMHistNormalizer normalizePlotsZTT

tvami · 2022-09-28T15:50:45Z

I happen to do a tk offline shift this week and started to deal with

DQM/SiStripMonitorClient:

SiStripAnalyser SiStripAnalyser

SiStripCertificationInfo siStripCertificationInfo

SiStripDaqInfo siStripDaqInfo

SiStripDcsInfo siStripDcsInfo

in #39518

tvami · 2022-09-28T15:51:58Z

For

DQM/BeamMonitor:

AlcaBeamMonitorClient AlcaBeamMonitorClient

@dzuolo can you fix this please?

wddgit · 2022-09-28T16:12:40Z

I'm working on these now:

DQM/EcalPreshowerMonitorModule:
DQMServices/FwkIO

Dr15Jones · 2022-10-03T17:29:47Z

I did
CommonTools/RecoUtils #39584
DataFormat/Math #39585
DQM/DataScouting #39586
EventFilter/EcalRawToDigi #39587
EventFilter/GctRawToDigi #39588
EventFilter/L1GlobalTriggerRawToDigi #39589

EventFilter/LTCRawToDigi #39603
EventFilter/RawDataCollector #39604
HLTrigger/btau #39610
IORawData/DTCommissioning #39613
JetMETCorrections/JetVertexAssociation #39614

JetMETCorrections/Type1MET #39628
L1Trigger/GlobalCaloTrigger #39629
L1Trigger/L1ExtraFromDigis #39632
L1Trigger/TextToDigi #39637
PhysicsTools/CandAlgos #39639
RecoBTag/SoftLepton #39640
RecoHI/HiJetAlgos #39643

RecoHI/HiTracking #39654
RecoJets/JetAssociationProducers #39657
RecoJets/JetProducers #39658
RecoLocalCalo/HcalLaserReco #39660
RecoMuon/CosmicMuonProducer #39661
RecoMuon/GlobalMuonProducer #39662
RecoMuon/GlobalTrackingTools #39663

RecoMuon/MuonIdentification
RecoMuon/MuonIsolation
RecoMuon/MuonIsolationProducers #39674

RecoTBCalo/EcalTBHodoscopeReconstructor
RecoTBCalo/EcalTBTDCReconstructor
RecoTBCalo/HcalTBObjectUnpacker #39696

RecoTracker/DebugTools
RecoTracker/SpecialSeedGenerators
RecoVertex/AdaptiveVertexFinder #39698

SimPPS/RPDigiProducer #39699
TopQuarkAnalysis/TopEventProducers #39701

wddgit · 2022-10-04T22:12:18Z

These are done and the PRs are submitted now:

DQM/EcalPreshowerMonitorModule (PR #39616):

ESDaqInfoTask ecalPreshowerDaqInfoTask
ESDataCertificationTask ecalPreshowerDataCertificationTask
ESDcsInfoTask ecalPreshowerDcsInfoTask

DQMServices/FwkIO (PR #39541):

DummyReadDQMStore reader

makortel · 2022-10-16T11:22:52Z

For

DQM/BeamMonitor:

AlcaBeamMonitorClient AlcaBeamMonitorClient

@dzuolo can you fix this please?

@tvami @dzuolo Any news on this? Thanks!

makortel · 2022-10-16T11:26:17Z

DQMServices/Demo:
- TestLegacyEDAnalyzer testlegacy
- TestLegacyFillRunEDAnalyzer testlegacyfillrun
- TestLegacyFillLumiEDAnalyzer testlegacyfilllumi
- TestLegacyHarvester testlegacyharvester

@cms-sw/dqm-l2 I suppose these modules could just be removed. When do you think that could be done? Could you take care of that? Thanks!

emanueleusai · 2022-10-17T04:39:39Z

ok I will take care of it this week

tvami · 2022-10-17T12:47:46Z

DQM/BeamMonitor:
AlcaBeamMonitorClient AlcaBeamMonitorClient
@dzuolo can you fix this please?
@tvami @dzuolo Any news on this? Thanks!

Nothing yet, @francescobrivio do we have anybody else in the beamspot team who could do this? Simone maybe?

I should also note @makortel that technically this is a dqm signature module, not alca

dzuolo · 2022-10-17T16:10:36Z

DQM/BeamMonitor:

AlcaBeamMonitorClient AlcaBeamMonitorClient

@dzuolo can you fix this please?

@tvami @dzuolo Any news on this? Thanks!

Nothing yet, @francescobrivio do we have anybody else in the beamspot team who could do this? Simone maybe?

I should also note @makortel that technically this is a dqm signature module, not alca

Dear colleagues,
Unfortunately at the moment nobody from the beamspot team is available to work on this topic due to a lack of time and/or knowledge of the core software. @gennai is for sure the most qualified person but he is busy with other activities. Would like to add something simone?

Dr15Jones · 2022-10-17T18:14:51Z

Just did

#39746
L1TriggerConfig/CSCTFConfigProducers
L1TriggerConfig/DTTPGConfigProducers
L1TriggerConfig/L1GeometryProducers
L1TriggerConfig/RCTConfigProducers

wddgit · 2022-10-17T21:42:55Z

I just did L1Trigger/L1TMuonOverlap. I was just starting L1TriggerConfig, your comment was just in time. I'll do RecoJets/JetAnalyzers next.

Dr15Jones · 2022-10-20T16:01:11Z

Just did

#39798
L1Trigger/DTTrackFinder
L1Trigger/DTTrigger
L1Trigger/GlobalTrigger
L1Trigger/L1GctAnalyzer
L1Trigger/L1TCalorimeter
L1Trigger/L1TGEM
L1Trigger/L1TMuonEndCap

#39801
RecoEgamma/EgammaElectronProducers RecoEgamma/EgammaIsolationAlgos RecoEgamma/EgammaTools

Dr15Jones · 2022-10-21T15:57:54Z

Did

#39819

JetMETCorrections/
       IsolatedParticles  MCJet  TauJet

HLTrigger/HLTanalyzers #39821

makortel · 2022-10-27T22:30:51Z

DQM/BeamMonitor:
AlcaBeamMonitorClient AlcaBeamMonitorClient

@dzuolo can you fix this please?

@tvami @dzuolo Any news on this? Thanks!

Nothing yet, @francescobrivio do we have anybody else in the beamspot team who could do this? Simone maybe?

AlcaBeamMonitorClient is now migrated in #39888 (in a suboptimal way though, that does not use DQM base classes and prevents concurrent lumis).

I should also note @makortel that technically this is a dqm signature module, not alca

I know, but I replied to your (@tvami) comment in #36404 (comment).

makortel · 2022-11-03T13:46:23Z

DQMServices/Demo:
- TestLegacyEDAnalyzer testlegacy
- TestLegacyFillRunEDAnalyzer testlegacyfillrun
- TestLegacyFillLumiEDAnalyzer testlegacyfilllumi
- TestLegacyHarvester testlegacyharvester
@cms-sw/dqm-l2 I suppose these modules could just be removed. When do you think that could be done? Could you take care of that? Thanks!
ok I will take care of it this week

@emanueleusai These are now one of the few last legacy modules. Would you be able to take care of them soon? Or should we (core) make an attempt to remove them?

makortel · 2022-11-22T23:35:56Z

DQMServices/Demo:
- TestLegacyEDAnalyzer testlegacy
- TestLegacyFillRunEDAnalyzer testlegacyfillrun
- TestLegacyFillLumiEDAnalyzer testlegacyfilllumi
- TestLegacyHarvester testlegacyharvester
@cms-sw/dqm-l2 I suppose these modules could just be removed. When do you think that could be done? Could you take care of that? Thanks!
ok I will take care of it this week
@emanueleusai These are now one of the few last legacy modules. Would you be able to take care of them soon? Or should we (core) make an attempt to remove them?

@emanueleusai Would you have any update when these modules could be removed (or otherwise be taken care of)? Or should we make an attempt?

makortel · 2022-12-27T20:47:51Z

DQMServices/Demo:
- TestLegacyEDAnalyzer testlegacy
- TestLegacyFillRunEDAnalyzer testlegacyfillrun
- TestLegacyFillLumiEDAnalyzer testlegacyfilllumi
- TestLegacyHarvester testlegacyharvester

These are now migrated in #40409.

makortel · 2023-01-12T14:19:27Z

+core

All legacy EDModules in CMSSW have been migrated, and the support for legacy EDModules has been removed in #39710 and #40466

cmsbuild added the pending-assignment label Dec 7, 2021

cmsbuild added analysis-pending db-pending dqm-pending generators-pending l1-pending pending-signatures upgrade-pending and removed pending-assignment labels Dec 7, 2021

cmsbuild added the core-pending label Dec 7, 2021

This was referenced Dec 8, 2021

remove CMSDEPRECATED_X warnings from DPGAnalysis/Skims #36410

Merged

Modernize OnlineDB/SiStrip* #36413

Merged

modernize EventFilter/Phase2TrackerRawToDigi #36414

Merged

mmusich mentioned this issue Dec 10, 2021

Modernize use of EDModules for CalibMuon/DTCalibration #36434

Merged

SiewYan mentioned this issue Dec 10, 2021

update legacy module: DummyLHEAnalyzer #36454

Merged

makortel mentioned this issue Dec 13, 2021

Migrate remaining framework EDModules away from legacy types cms-sw/framework-team#197

Closed

This was referenced Dec 14, 2021

modernize MuonAnalysis/MomentumScaleCalibration #36485

Merged

get rid of CMS deprecation warnings in Validation/*Track #36495

Merged

get rid of CMSDEPRECATED_X warnings in SLHCUpgradeSimulations/Geometry #36516

Merged

mmusich mentioned this issue May 13, 2022

migrate PixelVTXMonitor to DQMEDAnalyzer #37942

Merged

alejands mentioned this issue Jun 22, 2022

Migrate EcalMonitorPrescaler deprecated legacy EDFilter #38460

Merged

emanueleusai mentioned this issue Oct 29, 2022

JetCorrector migration in DQM/Physics #39847

Merged

mmusich mentioned this issue Nov 3, 2022

Migrate DQM/BeamMonitor plugins to avoid blocking concurrent lumisections #39973

Open

makortel mentioned this issue Dec 27, 2022

Migrate TestLegacy* DQM modules to edm::one::EDAnalyzer #40409

Merged

makortel closed this as completed Jan 12, 2023

cmsbuild added core-approved and removed core-pending labels Jan 12, 2023

mmusich mentioned this issue Oct 11, 2023

HLT IBs tests: edmPluginHelp crashing for CkfTrackCandidateMaker plugin #42988

Closed

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Migrate legacy EDModules to thread-efficient alternatives #36404

Migrate legacy EDModules to thread-efficient alternatives #36404

makortel commented Dec 7, 2021

cmsbuild commented Dec 7, 2021

makortel commented Dec 7, 2021

cmsbuild commented Dec 7, 2021

makortel commented Dec 7, 2021

makortel commented Dec 7, 2021

cmsbuild commented Dec 7, 2021

agrohsje commented Dec 8, 2021

SiewYan commented Dec 8, 2021

jfernan2 commented Dec 9, 2021 •

edited

Loading

makortel commented Dec 9, 2021

makortel commented Dec 9, 2021 •

edited

Loading

makortel commented May 18, 2022

makortel commented Sep 28, 2022

tvami commented Sep 28, 2022

tvami commented Sep 28, 2022

wddgit commented Sep 28, 2022

Dr15Jones commented Oct 3, 2022 •

edited

Loading

wddgit commented Oct 4, 2022

makortel commented Oct 16, 2022

makortel commented Oct 16, 2022

emanueleusai commented Oct 17, 2022

tvami commented Oct 17, 2022 •

edited

Loading

dzuolo commented Oct 17, 2022

Dr15Jones commented Oct 17, 2022

wddgit commented Oct 17, 2022

Dr15Jones commented Oct 20, 2022 •

edited

Loading

Dr15Jones commented Oct 21, 2022 •

edited

Loading

makortel commented Oct 27, 2022

makortel commented Nov 3, 2022

makortel commented Nov 22, 2022

makortel commented Dec 27, 2022

makortel commented Jan 12, 2023

Migrate legacy EDModules to thread-efficient alternatives #36404

Migrate legacy EDModules to thread-efficient alternatives #36404

Comments

makortel commented Dec 7, 2021

cmsbuild commented Dec 7, 2021

makortel commented Dec 7, 2021

cmsbuild commented Dec 7, 2021

makortel commented Dec 7, 2021

makortel commented Dec 7, 2021

cmsbuild commented Dec 7, 2021

agrohsje commented Dec 8, 2021

SiewYan commented Dec 8, 2021

jfernan2 commented Dec 9, 2021 • edited Loading

makortel commented Dec 9, 2021

makortel commented Dec 9, 2021 • edited Loading

makortel commented May 18, 2022

makortel commented Sep 28, 2022

tvami commented Sep 28, 2022

tvami commented Sep 28, 2022

wddgit commented Sep 28, 2022

Dr15Jones commented Oct 3, 2022 • edited Loading

wddgit commented Oct 4, 2022

makortel commented Oct 16, 2022

makortel commented Oct 16, 2022

emanueleusai commented Oct 17, 2022

tvami commented Oct 17, 2022 • edited Loading

dzuolo commented Oct 17, 2022

Dr15Jones commented Oct 17, 2022

wddgit commented Oct 17, 2022

Dr15Jones commented Oct 20, 2022 • edited Loading

Dr15Jones commented Oct 21, 2022 • edited Loading

makortel commented Oct 27, 2022

makortel commented Nov 3, 2022

makortel commented Nov 22, 2022

makortel commented Dec 27, 2022

makortel commented Jan 12, 2023

jfernan2 commented Dec 9, 2021 •

edited

Loading

makortel commented Dec 9, 2021 •

edited

Loading

Dr15Jones commented Oct 3, 2022 •

edited

Loading

tvami commented Oct 17, 2022 •

edited

Loading

Dr15Jones commented Oct 20, 2022 •

edited

Loading

Dr15Jones commented Oct 21, 2022 •

edited

Loading