Skip to content
This repository has been archived by the owner on Sep 26, 2021. It is now read-only.

Remove synthcpu flag for Virtualbox 5 support #1496

Merged
merged 1 commit into from
Jul 12, 2015

Conversation

nathanleclaire
Copy link
Contributor

Closes #1387

cc @ehazlett

This option is no longer supported in Virtualbox 5 and creates will fail as long as it is specified.

@SvenDowideit @tianon Do you know if this will affect the experience for users of older versions of VirtualBox (<5)? Given the nature of the flag (it is meant to help preserve transfer of saved-state VMs across platforms), I'm somewhat surprised that we have to turn it off by default anyway.

Signed-off-by: Nathan LeClaire nathan.leclaire@gmail.com

Signed-off-by: Nathan LeClaire <nathan.leclaire@gmail.com>
@tianon
Copy link
Contributor

tianon commented Jul 9, 2015

I'm not sure what it'll affect, but I'm 100% +1 to removing as many flags as possible and just accepting VirtualBox's defaults, especially when upstream has removed the flag. 😄

@FrenchBen
Copy link
Contributor

@nathanleclaire Can you provide the list of flags available via VBoxManage.
The docs still point to synthcpu being a correct flag:
https://www.virtualbox.org/manual/ch08.html

@nathanleclaire
Copy link
Contributor Author

@FrenchBen Here's what I see on my system with VBox 5, maybe the docs haven't been updated yet:

$ VBoxManage | grep -A 139 modifyvm
  modifyvm                  <uuid|vmname>
                            [--name <name>]
                            [--groups <group>, ...]
                            [--description <desc>]
                            [--ostype <ostype>]
                            [--iconfile <filename>]
                            [--memory <memorysize in MB>]
                            [--pagefusion on|off]
                            [--vram <vramsize in MB>]
                            [--acpi on|off]
                            [--pciattach 03:04.0]
                            [--pciattach 03:04.0@02:01.0]
                            [--pcidetach 03:04.0]
                            [--ioapic on|off]
                            [--hpet on|off]
                            [--triplefaultreset on|off]
                            [--paravirtprovider none|default|legacy|minimal|
                                                hyperv|kvm]
                            [--hwvirtex on|off]
                            [--nestedpaging on|off]
                            [--largepages on|off]
                            [--vtxvpid on|off]
                            [--vtxux on|off]
                            [--pae on|off]
                            [--longmode on|off]
                            [--cpuid-portability-level <0..3>
                            [--cpuidset <leaf> <eax> <ebx> <ecx> <edx>]
                            [--cpuidremove <leaf>]
                            [--cpuidremoveall]
                            [--hardwareuuid <uuid>]
                            [--cpus <number>]
                            [--cpuhotplug on|off]
                            [--plugcpu <id>]
                            [--unplugcpu <id>]
                            [--cpuexecutioncap <1-100>]
                            [--rtcuseutc on|off]
                            [--graphicscontroller none|vboxvga|vmsvga]
                            [--monitorcount <number>]
                            [--accelerate3d on|off]
                            [--accelerate2dvideo on|off]
                            [--firmware bios|efi|efi32|efi64]
                            [--chipset ich9|piix3]
                            [--bioslogofadein on|off]
                            [--bioslogofadeout on|off]
                            [--bioslogodisplaytime <msec>]
                            [--bioslogoimagepath <imagepath>]
                            [--biosbootmenu disabled|menuonly|messageandmenu]
                            [--biossystemtimeoffset <msec>]
                            [--biospxedebug on|off]
                            [--boot<1-4> none|floppy|dvd|disk|net>]
                            [--nic<1-N> none|null|nat|bridged|intnet|hostonly|
                                        generic|natnetwork]
                            [--nictype<1-N> Am79C970A|Am79C973|
                                            82540EM|82543GC|82545EM|
                                            virtio]
                            [--cableconnected<1-N> on|off]
                            [--nictrace<1-N> on|off]
                            [--nictracefile<1-N> <filename>]
                            [--nicproperty<1-N> name=[value]]
                            [--nicspeed<1-N> <kbps>]
                            [--nicbootprio<1-N> <priority>]
                            [--nicpromisc<1-N> deny|allow-vms|allow-all]
                            [--nicbandwidthgroup<1-N> none|<name>]
                            [--bridgeadapter<1-N> none|<devicename>]
                            [--hostonlyadapter<1-N> none|<devicename>]
                            [--intnet<1-N> <network name>]
                            [--nat-network<1-N> <network name>]
                            [--nicgenericdrv<1-N> <driver>
                            [--natnet<1-N> <network>|default]
                            [--natsettings<1-N> [<mtu>],[<socksnd>],
                                                [<sockrcv>],[<tcpsnd>],
                                                [<tcprcv>]]
                            [--natpf<1-N> [<rulename>],tcp|udp,[<hostip>],
                                          <hostport>,[<guestip>],<guestport>]
                            [--natpf<1-N> delete <rulename>]
                            [--nattftpprefix<1-N> <prefix>]
                            [--nattftpfile<1-N> <file>]
                            [--nattftpserver<1-N> <ip>]
                            [--natbindip<1-N> <ip>
                            [--natdnspassdomain<1-N> on|off]
                            [--natdnsproxy<1-N> on|off]
                            [--natdnshostresolver<1-N> on|off]
                            [--nataliasmode<1-N> default|[log],[proxyonly],
                                                         [sameports]]
                            [--macaddress<1-N> auto|<mac>]
                            [--mouse ps2|usb|usbtablet|usbmultitouch]
                            [--keyboard ps2|usb
                            [--uart<1-N> off|<I/O base> <IRQ>]
                            [--uartmode<1-N> disconnected|
                                             server <pipe>|
                                             client <pipe>|
                                             tcpserver <port>|
                                             tcpclient <hostname:port>|
                                             file <file>|
                                             <devicename>]
                            [--guestmemoryballoon <balloonsize in MB>]
                            [--audio none|null|coreaudio]
                            [--audiocontroller ac97|hda|sb16]
                            [--audiocodec stac9700|ad1980|stac9221|sb16]
                            [--clipboard disabled|hosttoguest|guesttohost|
                                         bidirectional]
                            [--draganddrop disabled|hosttoguest]
                            [--vrde on|off]
                            [--vrdeextpack default|<name>
                            [--vrdeproperty <name=[value]>]
                            [--vrdeport <hostport>]
                            [--vrdeaddress <hostip>]
                            [--vrdeauthtype null|external|guest]
                            [--vrdeauthlibrary default|<name>
                            [--vrdemulticon on|off]
                            [--vrdereusecon on|off]
                            [--vrdevideochannel on|off]
                            [--vrdevideochannelquality <percent>]
                            [--usb on|off]
                            [--usbehci on|off]
                            [--usbxhci on|off]
                            [--usbrename <oldname> <newname>]
                            [--snapshotfolder default|<path>]
                            [--teleporter on|off]
                            [--teleporterport <port>]
                            [--teleporteraddress <address|empty>
                            [--teleporterpassword <password>]
                            [--teleporterpasswordfile <file>|stdin]
                            [--tracing-enabled on|off]
                            [--tracing-config <config-string>]
                            [--tracing-allow-vm-access on|off]
                            [--usbcardreader on|off]
                            [--autostart-enabled on|off]
                            [--autostart-delay <seconds>]
                            [--videocap on|off]
                            [--videocapscreens all|<screen ID> [<screen ID> ...]]
                            [--videocapfile <filename>]
                            [--videocapres <width> <height>]
                            [--videocaprate <rate>]
                            [--videocapfps <fps>]
                            [--videocapmaxtime <ms>]
                            [--videocapmaxsize <MB>]
                            [--videocapopts <key=value> [<key=value> ...]]
                            [--defaultfrontend default|<name>]

$ VBoxManage | grep synth
$

Note that synthcpu isn't listed in the help output.

@FrenchBen
Copy link
Contributor

👍 thanks - LGTM

ps: to your question, since the flag was set to 'off' by default, I don't think it would affect users moving forward.

@nathanleclaire
Copy link
Contributor Author

I've created a Virtualbox VM on 4.3.18 with this patch no problems, I am pretty sure it can be merged.

@guilhermecvm
Copy link

+1

@CpuID
Copy link

CpuID commented Jul 11, 2015

+1 to merging this, same result after installing Virtualbox 5.0 on OSX. docker-machine 0.3.0

Tested HEAD with this patch, no longer getting the error.

@ehazlett
Copy link
Contributor

Tested with vbox 5.0 on linux. Works for me as well.

LGTM

@Spechal
Copy link

Spechal commented Sep 14, 2015

Kitematic v1.8.2 and docker machine 0.2.0 produce a fatal error and boxes cannot be created.

VBoxManage: error: Unknown option: --synthcpu

VirtualBox 5.0.4 provided by Kitematic

@nathanleclaire
Copy link
Contributor Author

@Spechal docker-machine 0.2.0 is way old. Please try the latest release (0.4.1) and see if it works.

Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

8 participants