Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Make the user aware of volume settings #44

Closed
algazarra opened this issue Oct 19, 2014 · 7 comments
Closed

Make the user aware of volume settings #44

algazarra opened this issue Oct 19, 2014 · 7 comments

Comments

@algazarra
Copy link
Member

correct me if i'm wrong. boilr is set to be silent if we silence the cellphone right? While you sleep you may want silent cellphone for all sms and phonecalls but still want your boilr alarms to wake you up.

there could be an option on the general settings and an individual option on the advanced options of each alarm, when on, boilr would sound even when in silence. maybe a special icon should be in the status bar while this is activated.

@dllud
Copy link
Member

dllud commented Oct 19, 2014

Please read again #27. It is all explained there.

Summing it up, if you choose an Alarm sound and put your phone in the normal silent it still plays. It doesn't play if you choose a Ringtone or Notification sound. This is Android behaviour not ours.

On 19 October 2014 20:21:51 WEST, cicardia notifications@github.com wrote:

correct me if i'm wrong. boilr is set to be silent if we silence the
cellphone right? While you sleep you may want silent cellphone for all
sms and phonecalls but still want your boilr alarms to wake you up.

there could be an option on the general settings and an individual
option on the advanced options of each alarm, when on, boilr would
sound even when in silence. maybe a special icon should be in the
status bar while this is activated.


Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub:
#44

@algazarra
Copy link
Member Author

"The most common case is putting the phone in silent mode. What Android does is setting the Notifications and Ringtones volumes to zero, but keeps Alarm at a loud value. Thus, if you have low significance alarms in Boilr, set to a Notification or Ringtone sound, they will be muted. On the other hand, the important ones to which you have assigned an Alarm sound will play as usual. Android also has a "hard" silent mode, which sets all volumes to zero, including Alarms."

yes! my bad, it's perfect the way it is!

@dllud
Copy link
Member

dllud commented Oct 20, 2014

I will add a small text to the top of the Alert Type list preference remembering people about this. Most users know that Android has 3 independent sound channels because they have seen them in the volume settings. Yet they won't figure out that they are used by Boilr according to the Alert Type they choose.

Please help me summarize the following sentence.

"Check your Android volume settings. Boilr uses the system volume for the selected Alert type. On most phones the Alarm type is at full volume even when the phone is set to silent."

@algazarra
Copy link
Member Author

it's not clear enough. that wouldn't help me understand what's involved in this. let me see if i understand:

alarm - always plays, even when in silence mode
alert & notification - only play when the device has sound enabled

right?

@dllud
Copy link
Member

dllud commented Oct 20, 2014

Right but only if you kept the default Android settings. That is why we need to point the user to her Android settings. She might have changed them and it won't work that way.

dllud pushed a commit that referenced this issue Oct 20, 2014
After choosing an exchange and pair they become the default for next
alarm creation. Closes #42.
Added dialog message to alert type selection explaining volume settings
as discussed on #44.
Last price on alarm list is now coloured according to price direction
(up, down or same). Implements 1. of #41.
@algazarra
Copy link
Member Author

what about creating a shortcut to system sound options?

@dllud
Copy link
Member

dllud commented Oct 21, 2014

That plus a sentence explaining that Boilr uses the system settings should work. Will try it.

@dllud dllud reopened this Oct 21, 2014
@dllud dllud changed the title Option - have alarm sound even when cellphone is silent Make the user aware of volume settings Oct 21, 2014
@dllud dllud closed this as completed in e41ef6f Oct 23, 2014
@dllud dllud removed the question label Apr 1, 2015
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants