Persistency FT Meeting Minutes 2026

[vbogdanb]

Persistency FT Meeting Minutes 2026

[vbogdanb]

Meeting minutes 2026-01-08->2026-01-22:
https://github.com/orgs/eclipse-score/discussions/1680#discussioncomment-15445877
https://github.com/orgs/eclipse-score/discussions/1680#discussioncomment-15507542
https://github.com/orgs/eclipse-score/discussions/1680#discussioncomment-15570887

[vbogdanb]

Weekly 2026-01-29

Participants

@vbogdanb - Bogdan B.
@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC - Ahmed E.
@PandaeDo - Volker H.
@tizava - Tibor Z.
@arkjedrz Arek
@vinodreddy-g Vinod

Meeting Minutes

eclipse-score/persistency#182 -> to fix after common interface definition
eclipse-score/persistency#227 comp req should be rework and reviewed
The component shall encode each key as valid UTF-8? -> @tizava
https://github.com/eclipse-score/persistency/actions/runs/21214394044/job/61151306834?pr=172 -> @arkjedrz

eclipse-score/persistency#230 -> review and check findings from @arkjedrz
@vbogdanb Ask about safe writing in the Architecture Meeting, ask about snapshot,hash validation, test tool usage from OEMs

[vbogdanb]

Weekly 2026-02-12

Participants

@vbogdanb - Bogdan B.
@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC - Ahmed E.
@PandaeDo - Volker H.
@tizava - Tibor Z.
@arkjedrz Arek
@umaucher

Meeting Minutes

Snapshots decision:

• Will keep snapshots
• Will remove snapshot rotation
• Will modify the api to explicitly create snapshots and load them in memory

SnapshotCreate(SnapshotID)
SnapshotDelete(SnapshotID)
SnapshotRestore(SnapshotID)
SnapshotCount()
SnapshotMaxCount()

New snapshot functions will not be added to the current kvs api inside eclipse-score/persistency#172 !

Doc-as-code will be fixed, expected next week
Do not resolve reviewer comments in the PR !!! ( Reviewers will re-review the fix and resolve the comments)
If PR come too late for offline review , they will not be discussed in the Pers meeting. They will be mentioned so people can have a offline review of them.

New folder structure definition -> eclipse-score/module_template#40 (comment)

eclipse-score/persistency#182 -> to fix after common interface definition
eclipse-score/persistency#227 comp req should be rework and reviewed - @vbogdanb @tizava to be done by 2026-03-12
The component shall encode each key as valid UTF-8? -> @tizava

@vbogdanb Ask about safe writing in the Architecture Meeting, ask about snapshot,hash validation, test tool usage from OEMs

[arkjedrz]

Weekly 2026-03-12

Participants

@PandaeDo - Volker H.
@tizava - Tibor Z.
@arkjedrz - Arek J.
@umaucher - Uwe M.

Meeting Minutes

• [C++] flush is asynchronously writing into std streams.
  • Fix: Fix for data are not flushed to disk in context of Kvs::flush() persistency#254
  • Review: @arkjedrz
• [C++] Update update kvs build to avoid reopen opened instance. persistency#102
  • To be rechecked and updated: @umaucher
• Update set permission for kvs file persistency#107
  • To be updated: @umaucher
  • This should be discussed if required or to be dropped.
  • Rust impl once agreed: @arkjedrz
• add compile-time configuration for kvs maximum storage size persistency#165
  • Configuration of this parameter is okay, but the parameter should be init-time configurable.
• Cpp KVS does not reflect if the default value is set. persistency#182
  • To be fixed: @arkjedrz
• Improvement: remake component requirements persistency#227
  • @tizava @vbogdanb please recheck.
• Required some dashboard to be able to track fulfilled requirements.
  • @arkjedrz: ask internally.
• Rework snapshot approach to make them explicit and disable implicit snapshot rotation in flush.
  • Changes to design and provide changes to code: @tizava

[arkjedrz]

Weekly 2026-03-19

Participants

@PandaeDo - Volker H.
@arkjedrz - Arek J.
@umaucher - Uwe M.
- Vansi K.

Meeting Minutes

• [C++] flush is asynchronously writing into std streams.
  • Fix: Fix for data are not flushed to disk in context of Kvs::flush() persistency#254
  • Review: @arkjedrz
• [C++] Update update kvs build to avoid reopen opened instance. persistency#102
  • To be rechecked and updated: @umaucher
• Update set permission for kvs file persistency#107
  • To be updated: @umaucher
  • In progress, discussions during meeting. Permissions handling moved to a concrete backend implementation.
  • Rust impl once agreed: @arkjedrz
• add compile-time configuration for kvs maximum storage size persistency#165
  • Configuration of this parameter is okay, but the parameter should be init-time configurable.
• Cpp KVS does not reflect if the default value is set. persistency#182
  • To be fixed: @arkjedrz
  • Only started yet.
• Improvement: remake component requirements persistency#227
  • @tizava @vbogdanb please recheck.
• Rework snapshot approach to make them explicit and disable implicit snapshot rotation in flush.
  • Changes to design and provide changes to code: @tizava

[arkjedrz]

Weekly 2026-03-26

Participants

@arkjedrz - Arek J.
@tizava Tibor Z.

Meeting Minutes

• @vbogdanb - are You still in the project?
  • Should someone else from the team join architecture meetings?
• [C++] flush is asynchronously writing into std streams.
  • Fix: Fix for data are not flushed to disk in context of Kvs::flush() persistency#254
  • Review: @arkjedrz - to be rechecked this week, Maurizio committed some changes.
• [C++] Update update kvs build to avoid reopen opened instance. persistency#102
  • To be rechecked and updated: @umaucher
  • No updates.
• Update set permission for kvs file persistency#107
  • To be updated: @umaucher
  • No updates.
  • In progress, discussions during meeting. Permissions handling moved to a concrete backend implementation.
  • Rust impl once agreed: @arkjedrz
• add compile-time configuration for kvs maximum storage size persistency#165
  • Configuration of this parameter is okay, but the parameter should be init-time configurable.
  • No updates.
• Improvement: remake component requirements persistency#227
  • @tizava @vbogdanb please recheck.
  • Reqs containing hard-coded limits should be dropped.
• Rework snapshot approach to make them explicit and disable implicit snapshot rotation in flush.
  • Changes to design and provide changes to code: @tizava
  • No updates.

[antonkri]

Weekly 2026-04-23

Participants

@tizava Tibor Z.
@umaucher
@antonkri
@PandaeDo

Meeting Minutes

1. FT Lead election
   • Uwe is elected as Feature Team lead, Anton will help to with administrative tasks.
   • We need know-how for RUST part of persistency. @antonkri to address on Monday, who can help us here and maintain the code.
2. Release v0.7
   • Release ticket for persistency: Persistency - v0.3.2 #2795
     • Update dependencies according to the checklist in the ticket -> @antonkri
     • Define new Release workflow based on what baselibs/communication have -> @antonkri
3. Codeowner
   • agreed to nominate Uwe as Codeowner
   • following checklist needs to be checked: https://github.com/eclipse-score/persistency/blob/main/docs/persistency/docs/safety_mgt/module_codeowners.rst and documented internally at BMW
   • later following page should be extended with confirmation for Uwe: https://github.com/eclipse-score/persistency/blob/main/docs/persistency/docs/safety_mgt/module_codeowners.rst
   • @umaucher will approach @aschemmel-tech

[umaucher]

Weekly 2026-04-30

Participants

@umaucher
@PandaeDo

Meeting Minutes

1. FT handling
2. Release v0.7

• Release ticket for persistency: Persistency - v0.3.2 #2795
  • ✅ Update dependencies according to the checklist in the ticket -> @antonkri -> update deps for v07 persistency#284
  • Define new Release workflow based on what baselibs/communication have -> @antonkri

3. Codeowner

• agreed to nominate @umaucher and @antonkri as Codeowner
• @umaucher will approach @PandaeDo after sync with @antonkri

[umaucher]

Weekly 2026-05-07

Participants

@umaucher
@PandaeDo
@odra
@tizava

Meeting Minutes

1. FT handling

• Reviews:
  • Update Persistency safety analysis fdr #2873
• Implementation:
  • Adaption of current snapshot handling to requirements

3. Release v0.7

• ✅ Release ticket for persistency: Persistency - v0.3.2 #2795
  • https://github.com/eclipse-score/persistency/releases/tag/v0.3.2

4. Codeowner

• ✅ nominate @umaucher and @antonkri as co -> Update codeowner & Skillcheck persistency#287 (@PandaeDo will find a solution for the merge deadlock)

5. Misc

• 2026-05-05 - Technical Lead Workshop Ulm update from TLC

[umaucher]

Weekly 2026-05-21

Participants

@umaucher
@PandaeDo

Meeting Minutes

1. FT handling

• Reviews:
• Implementation:
  • after cleanup of doc structure plan cleanup of code structure as well
  • cleanup of json docs after clarification of baselib json plans (see Add vajson to score baselibs baselibs#139 and discussion on Rust)
• Misc:
  • Shift of FT meeting to Thu 13:00 (Europe/Berlin). Announced ✅ --> https://sdvworkinggroup.slack.com/archives/C08B339ETQU/p1779868476730059

[umaucher]

Weekly 2026-06-11

Participants

@umaucher
@PandaeDo
@aschemmel-tech
@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC
@tizava

Meeting Minutes

1. FT handling

• Reviews:
  • Discussion on Inspection Component Req KVS persistency#288 with @aschemmel-tech: Review will be concluded from @umaucher and @PandaeDo collection task for findings will be created --> KVS Requirement Inspection Findings (PR #288) persistency#297
  • Fix typos, add missing docs persistency#295: typos, missing documentation ✅
  • Move documents from score to module persistency#296 Feature documentation will be shifted to module as defined in folder structure: Requires clean-up and partly revert of Move persistency documentation to module #2964 @PandaeDo
  • @PandaeDo investigates in the usage of docs-as-code dashboards_and_quality_gates and gives and update next week
  • Snapshots feature refactor persistency#292 Refactoring snapshot feature: Review pending cross-check updated requirements
• Implementation:
  • none
• Misc / all:
  • Updates from https://github.com/orgs/eclipse-score/discussions/434?sort=new#discussioncomment-17135459
  • Refinement of Persistency for S-CORE Release v0.8 #2898: Create subticket if a topic is worked on
  • Cleanup of https://github.com/eclipse-score/persistency/issues: Close old / deprecated stuff until next week, review and update together

[PandaeDo]

Weekly 2026-06-18

Participants

@PandaeDo
@aschemmel-tech?
@tizava
@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC

Agenda

Input from @RolandJentschETAS for Persistency Feature Architecture: Is there any reason to use puml instead of the integrated draw function of sphinx ? Outside the appearance (all other features look different) it does not allow the automated drawing, but needs manual created drawings and needs manual checks. See as well discussion in slack: https://sdvworkinggroup.slack.com/archives/C08B339ETQU/p1781510683571199 --> skipped to next week because relevant stakeholders were not participating in the meeting

Meeting Minutes

1. FT handling

• Reviews:
  • Inspection Component Req KVS persistency#288: Could be merged follow-up: KVS Requirement Inspection Findings (PR #288) persistency#297
  • Move documents from score to module persistency#296: update / status
  • Snapshots feature refactor persistency#292 Refactoring snapshot feature: new commends from @arkjedrz
  • chore: update Bazel to 8.6.0 persistency#299: Merged during the week just for information to everyone we updated to use bazel 8.6.0
• Implementation:
  • none
• Misc / all:
  • @PandaeDo investigates in the usage of docs-as-code dashboards_and_quality_gates and gives and update next week --> not finalized because of depencencies
  • Updates from https://github.com/orgs/eclipse-score/discussions/434?sort=new#discussioncomment-17304915:
    • explizit request for a "basic" planning for v0.8 so we need to refine subtickets in Persistency for S-CORE Release v0.8 #2898 --> adressed in table at the end of the MoM
  • Cleanup of https://github.com/eclipse-score/persistency/issues: review

eclipse-score/persistency#296 open due to a needed docs-as-code update. After that we will finally have moved the documentation into the module.

We're going to update to versions like in eclipse-score/process_description#708. @PandaeDo will do it.

All FDR's are completed. Need to update on findings we have. Will invite for meetings

"basic" planning for v0.8
Detailed Design: Update @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC
Implementation Inspection: @PandaeDo  
C0/C1 Coverage: @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC
Component Integration Tests:
Static Code Analysis findings: Postponed. Unclear if we have archieved "0" by having no Static Code Analysis or if we have no findings
Feature Integration Tests: @tizava  
Dynamic Code Analysis findings: Unclear which tool can be used. Question to be raised next Monday.
Module Verification Report: @PandaeDo  

[umaucher]

Weekly 2026-06-25

Participants

@PandaeDo
@arkjedrz
@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC

Agenda

Input from @RolandJentschETAS for Persistency Feature Architecture: Is there any reason to use puml instead of the integrated draw function of sphinx ? Outside the appearance (all other features look different) it does not allow the automated drawing, but needs manual created drawings and needs manual checks. See as well discussion in slack: https://sdvworkinggroup.slack.com/archives/C08B339ETQU/p1781510683571199
-->

Meeting Minutes

1. FT handling

• Reviews:
  • KVS Requirement Inspection Findings (PR #288) persistency#297: @umaucher assigned
  • Move documents from score to module persistency#296: Minor remaining work: Update documentation persistency#307 @PandaeDo will rebase and ask for review
  • Snapshots feature refactor persistency#292: Clarification of real use cases and needs ... then finalize documentation / requirements and adapt implementation @umaucher will sync with @tizava (working assumption split of "usual" flush and snapshot handling, no rotation only explicit store(override) and explizit load of snapshot)
  • feat(kvs): enforce maximum key length of 32 bytes (C++) persistency#308: Clarify for a rational and if it is really needed ... otherwise just reject and remove the according comp_req comp_req__persistency__key_length and the need of feat_req__persistency__cfg. Discussion in slack: https://sdvworkinggroup.slack.com/archives/C08B339ETQU/p1782132299960689
• Implementation:
  • none
• Misc / all:
  • @PandaeDo investigates in the usage of docs-as-code dashboards_and_quality_gates and gives and update next week
  • Updates from https://github.com/orgs/eclipse-score/discussions/434?sort=new#discussioncomment-17304915:
    • explizit request for a "basic" planning for v0.8 so we need to refine subtickets in Persistency for S-CORE Release v0.8 #2898 --> adressed in table at the end of the MoM
  • Cleanup of https://github.com/eclipse-score/persistency/issues: review
  • Move documents from score to module persistency#296 open due to a needed docs-as-code update. After that we will finally have moved the documentation into the module.
  • We're going to update to versions like in add versioning of requirements process_description#708. @PandaeDo will do it.
  • Discussion in https://sdvworkinggroup.slack.com/archives/C0894QGRZDM/p1782378775004079
  • Location of test code?? Sync with @PiotrKorkus next week

All FDR's are completed. Need to update on findings we have. Will invite for meetings
"basic" planning for v0.8
Detailed Design: Update @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC
Implementation Inspection: @PandaeDo  
C0/C1 Coverage: @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC
Component Integration Tests:
Static Code Analysis findings: Postponed. Unclear if we have archieved "0" by having no Static Code Analysis or if we have no findings
Feature Integration Tests: @tizava / @PiotrKorkus
Dynamic Code Analysis findings: Unclear which tool can be used. Question to be raised next Monday.
Module Verification Report: @PandaeDo

[umaucher]

Weekly 2026-07-02

Participants

• @PandaeDo
• @umaucher
• @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC
• @tizava
• @arkjedrz

Updates (Tasks, Bugs, PRs)

Issues - New

• Quality: Finalise documentation of Persistency persistency#321 opened 2026-07-01, assignees: @PandaeDo, @umaucher, topic: finalize persistency documentation

Issues - Closed

• Switch from score_toolchains_qnx to score_bazel_cpp_toolchains persistency#317 closed 2026-06-30, completed by PR Switch from score_toolchains_qnx to score_bazel_cpp_toolchains persistency#318 (toolchain migration)
• Dependency Dashboard persistency#313 closed 2026-06-29
• Use docs-as-code 4.6.0 and remove docs-as-code git override persistency#309 closed 2026-06-29, implemented via PR Use docs-as-code 4.6.0 and remove docs-as-code git override persistency#310

PRs - Final State This Week

• chore: add REPO.bazel and simplify sphinx configuration persistency#322 merged 2026-07-02, opened 2026-07-01
• Update dependency score_process to v2 persistency#320 merged 2026-07-01, opened 2026-06-30
• deps: use baselibs instead of baselibs_rust persistency#319 merged 2026-06-30, opened 2026-06-30
• Switch from score_toolchains_qnx to score_bazel_cpp_toolchains persistency#318 merged 2026-06-30, opened 2026-06-30
• Update dependency score_crates to v0.0.10 persistency#312 merged 2026-06-29, opened 2026-06-29
• Update dependency score_baselibs to v0.2.8 persistency#311 merged 2026-06-29, opened 2026-06-29
• Use docs-as-code 4.6.0 and remove docs-as-code git override persistency#310 merged 2026-06-29, opened 2026-06-26
• Update dependency score_bazel_cpp_toolchains to v0.5.4 - autoclosed persistency#316 closed (not merged/autoclosed) 2026-06-30, opened 2026-06-29
• Update dependency score_toolchains_qnx to v0.0.7 - autoclosed persistency#315 closed (not merged/autoclosed) 2026-06-30, opened 2026-06-29
• Update dependency score_logging to v0.2.1 - autoclosed persistency#314 closed (not merged/autoclosed) 2026-06-30, opened 2026-06-29
• tests: Don't try to build QNX tests if the target platform doesn't match persistency#176 closed (not merged) 2026-07-01

Misc

• Add additional discussion topics here.
• Add decisions and action items.

[umaucher]

Weekly 2026-07-09

Participants

• @PandaeDo
• @umaucher
• @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC
• @tizava
• @arkjedrz

Updates (Issues, PRs)

Issues - New

• Exclude host-only tooling from QNX wildcard builds persistency#323 "Exclude host-only tooling from QNX wildcard builds" opened 2026-07-03, closed same day by Exclude host-only tooling from QNX wildcard builds persistency#324
• chore: update score_baselibs to 0.2.9 persistency#327 "chore: update score_baselibs to 0.2.9" opened 2026-07-07, closed same day by chore: update score_baselibs to 0.2.9 persistency#328

Issues - Closed

• Exclude host-only tooling from QNX wildcard builds persistency#323 "Exclude host-only tooling from QNX wildcard builds" closed 2026-07-03, completed by Exclude host-only tooling from QNX wildcard builds persistency#324
• chore: update score_baselibs to 0.2.9 persistency#327 "chore: update score_baselibs to 0.2.9" closed 2026-07-07, completed by chore: update score_baselibs to 0.2.9 persistency#328
• bazel build //... fails persistency#84 "bazel build //... fails" closed 2026-07-09, completed by Register Ferrocene Rust toolchain for default build config persistency#329

PRs - Final State This Week

• Exclude host-only tooling from QNX wildcard builds persistency#324 "Exclude host-only tooling from QNX wildcard builds" merged 2026-07-03, opened 2026-07-03
• Update dependency score_process to v2.0.1 persistency#325 "Update dependency score_process to v2.0.1" merged 2026-07-03, opened 2026-07-03
• chore: update dependent Bazel modules to avoid warnings persistency#326 "chore: update dependent Bazel modules to avoid warnings" merged 2026-07-06, opened 2026-07-06
• chore: update score_baselibs to 0.2.9 persistency#328 "chore: update score_baselibs to 0.2.9" merged 2026-07-07, opened 2026-07-07
• Register Ferrocene Rust toolchain for default build config persistency#329 "Register Ferrocene Rust toolchain for default build config" merged 2026-07-09, opened 2026-07-07
• added test cases for requirements to add coverage persistency#251 "added test cases for requirements to add coverage" closed (not merged) 2026-07-06
• adopt verification report persistency#330 "adopt verification report" open (Draft) 2026-07-08
• ci: add workflow_dispatch + dry_run support to release workflow persistency#331 "ci: add workflow_dispatch + dry_run support to release workflow" open (Draft) 2026-07-09

Misc

• Add additional discussion topics here.
• Add decisions and action items.

[umaucher]

Persistency FT Meeting Minutes - 2026-07-23

Participants

• @PandaeDo
• @umaucher
• @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC
• @tizava
• @anmittag
• @arkjedrz

Updates (Issues, PRs)

Issues

• new:
  • CI: make CIT tests-report mandatory for docs build & finalize secure fork-PR checkout (follow-up to #346) persistency#349 (@umaucher)
  • Project content being sent to the Eclipse Dash License Tool persistency#347
• updated:
  • Quality: Finalise documentation of Persistency persistency#321 (@PandaeDo, @umaucher)
  • KVS Requirement Inspection Findings (PR #288) persistency#297 (@umaucher)
  • cpp code coverage: Update after toolchain switch persistency#160 (@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC)
• closed:
  • none

PRs

• new:
  • cicd: pin actions/checkout to v4.2.2 to restore fork-PR CIT persistency#350
  • fix ut coverage report persistency#346
• updated:
  • Update req inspect persistency#345
  • Rework of component requirements related to snapshots persistency#337
  • ci: release workflow improvements persistency#335
  • adopt verification report persistency#330
  • feat(kvs): enforce maximum key length of 32 bytes (C++) persistency#308
  • Add public rust_binary targets for rust_kvs examples persistency#301
  • Snapshots feature refactor persistency#292
• merged/closed:
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_process to v2.0.2 persistency#348 merged 2026-07-23

Misc

• Detailed design needed for "small" components or not? Might use persistency or baselib as a showcase.
• CI is currently broken — see cicd: pin actions/checkout to v4.2.2 to restore fork-PR CIT persistency#350 for details.
• Reminder: check and review open issues again (https://github.com/eclipse-score/persistency/issues), and assign them where possible.
• Open action: finalize planning for v0.9 — Persistency for S-CORE Release v0.9 #3052, Roadmap v0.9
• Links:
  • Component Requirements Statistics (can we get an overview at feature level?)
  • "Safety sentinel": https://eclipse-score.github.io/tooling/latest/overview.html

[umaucher]

Persistency FT Meeting Minutes - 2026-07-30

Participants

• @PandaeDo
• @umaucher
• @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC
• @tizava
• @arkjedrz

Updates (Issues, PRs)

Issues

• new:
  • none
• updated:
  • none
• closed:
  • none

PRs

• new:
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_baselibs to v0.2.10 persistency#354
  • chore: move docs persistency#353
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_docs_as_code to v5 - autoclosed persistency#352
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_toolchains_rust to v0.10.0 persistency#351
• updated:
  • cicd: pin actions/checkout to v4.2.2 to restore fork-PR CIT persistency#350 (@umaucher)
  • Rework of component requirements related to snapshots persistency#337 (@tizava)
  • feat(kvs): enforce maximum key length of 32 bytes (C++) persistency#308 (@atarekra)
• merged/closed:
  • none

Misc

• Add additional discussion topics here.
• Add decisions and action items.

[umaucher]

Persistency FT Meeting Minutes - 2026-08-06

Participants

• @PandaeDo
• @umaucher
• @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC
• @AnnaPaolaMusio
• @tizava
• @arkjedrz

Updates (Issues, PRs)

Issues

• new:
  • none
• updated:
  • none
• closed:
  • none

PRs

• new:
  • none
• updated:
  • chore: move docs persistency#353 (@AlexanderLanin) --> @umaucher get updates
  • Rework of component requirements related to snapshots persistency#337 (@tizava) --> additional changes requested
  • adopt verification report persistency#330 (@FScholPer) --> @umaucher get updates + review of report
• merged/closed:
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_toolchains_rust to v0.10.0 persistency#351 merged 2026-07-31
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_platform to v0.6.3 persistency#357 merged 2026-08-03
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_docs_as_code to v6 persistency#356 merged 2026-08-03
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_baselibs to v0.2.10 persistency#354 merged 2026-08-04
  • docs: rename belong_to to satisfied_by persistency#358 merged 2026-08-04
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_process to v2.0.3 persistency#359 merged 2026-08-05

Misc

• Discussion on sync/async behaviour needs for "flush" -> @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC prepares a ticket and some first suggestions --> Flush function enhancement persistency#362

[umaucher]

Persistency FT Meeting Minutes - 2026-08-13

Participants

• @PandaeDo
• @umaucher
• @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC
• @tizava
• @arkjedrz

Updates (Issues, PRs)

Issues

• new:
  • persistency enhancement points to dicuss persistency#366 (@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC)
• updated:
  • Big integer numbers are stored incorrectly in json persistency#204 (@arkjedrz)
• closed:
  • Tailoring out Detail Design in Module Safety Plan persistency#355 closed 2026-08-10 (completed by Module Safety Plan: Update tailoring, fix tables persistency#363)
  • docs() target in root BUILD references dev_dependency bazel_dep, breaks when persistency is consumed as a transitive module persistency#365 closed 2026-08-11 (completed by chore: move docs persistency#353)

PRs

• new:
  • chore(deps): update Bazel dependencies for score_crates v0.0.11 persistency#372
• updated:
  • none
• merged/closed:
  • Module Safety Plan: Update tailoring, fix tables persistency#363 merged 2026-08-10
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_platform to v0.6.4 persistency#364 merged 2026-08-07
  • chore: simplify workflows persistency#367 merged 2026-08-11
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_rules_imagefs to v0.0.4 persistency#368 merged 2026-08-12
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_bazel_platforms to v1 persistency#369 merged 2026-08-12
  • fix: add c.this_doc() to needextend persistency#370 merged 2026-08-12
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_docs_as_code to v7.1.0 persistency#371 merged 2026-08-13
  • chore: move docs persistency#353 merged 2026-08-11

Misc

• Meeting skipped (vacation season)

[umaucher]

Persistency FT Meeting Minutes - 2026-08-20

Participants

• @PandaeDo
• @umaucher
• @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC
• @tizava
• @arkjedrz

Updates (Issues, PRs)

Issues

• new:
  • ScoreDebug not implemented for Path/&Path, breaking rust_kvs build persistency#375 (@Saumya-R)
• updated:
  • persistency enhancement points to dicuss persistency#366 (@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC)
• closed:
  • none

PRs

• new:
  • fix: support ScoreDebug formatting for paths persistency#376
  • coverage: adopt the unified LLVM coverage pipeline from score_tooling 2.1.1 persistency#380
• updated:
  • none
• merged/closed:
  • chore(deps): update Bazel dependencies for score_crates v0.0.11 persistency#372 merged 2026-08-14
  • fix: update qnx-build workflow pin persistency#373 merged 2026-08-17
  • fix: remove stale ANDROID_HOME Bazel override persistency#374 merged 2026-08-17
  • fix: restore Rust formatter policies persistency#377 merged 2026-08-17
  • fix: migrate format targets to score format checker persistency#378 merged 2026-08-18
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_baselibs to v0.2.11 persistency#379 closed 2026-08-19 (not merged)

Misc

• folder structure clarification Add DR about module folder structure #3194 @umaucher will prepare a PR for the "non src" solution

[PandaeDo]

Persistency FT Meeting Minutes - 2026-08-20

Participants

• @PandaeDo
• @umaucher
• @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC
• @tizava
• @arkjedrz

Updates (Issues, PRs)

Issues

• new:

• updated:
  • persistency enhancement points to dicuss persistency#366 (@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC)
  • ScoreDebug not implemented for Path/&Path, breaking rust_kvs build persistency#375 (@Saumya-R) -> @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC will discuss with ark if he can handle it .
• closed:
  • none
  • [note] some changes merged without linking to issues.

PRs

• new:

  • feat: make KVS max snapshot count configurable persistency#383

• updated:

  • fix: support ScoreDebug formatting for paths persistency#376

• merged/closed:

  • coverage: adopt the unified LLVM coverage pipeline from score_tooling 2.1.1 persistency#380
  • restructure: align module folder layout with score module folder structure persistency#386
  • fix: align docs-as-code integration with current setup guide persistency#385
  • Remove doubled entries persistency#382

Misc

• Rework of component requirements related to snapshots persistency#337 -> @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC will review it and approve it if not issues . To be discussed coming meeting.

[Ahmed-Elsaka-JC]

Persistency FT Meeting Minutes - 2026-09-03

Participants

• @PandaeDo
• @umaucher
• @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC
• @tizava
• @arkjedrz
• @AnnaPaolaMusio

Updates (Issues, PRs)

Issues

• new:
  • Log messages in kvs.cpp have doubled spaces persistency#402
• updated:
  • persistency enhancement points to dicuss persistency#366 (@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC) will create subtasks
  • ScoreDebug not implemented for Path/&Path, breaking rust_kvs build persistency#375 (@Saumya-R) -> @arkjedrz will provide the correct command for execution
• closed:
  • none
  • [note] some changes merged without linking to issues.

PRs

• new:

  • feat: make KVS max snapshot count configurable persistency#383 -> approved , need to be merged.

• updated:

  • fix: support ScoreDebug formatting for paths persistency#376

• merged/closed:

Misc

• Rework of component requirements related to snapshots persistency#337 -> @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC feedback provided , waiting to fix review points.

[umaucher]

Persistency FT Meeting Minutes - 2026-09-10

Participants

• @PandaeDo
• @umaucher
• @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC
• @tizava
• @arkjedrz

Updates (Issues, PRs)

Issues

• new:
  • update public APIS persistency#409 (@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC)
  • implementation of backup mechanism persistency#410 (@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC)
  • implementing configuration by file persistency#411 (@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC)
  • Storage Access control persistency#412
  • update Corruption detection algorithm from adler32 to CRC64 persistency#413
• updated:
  • none
• closed:
  • ScoreDebug not implemented for Path/&Path, breaking rust_kvs build persistency#375 (closed 2026-09-09)

PRs

• new:
  • rollback googletest persistency#415
• updated:
  • feat: make KVS max snapshot count configurable persistency#383
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_crates to v0.0.12 persistency#401
• merged/closed:
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_docs_as_code to v8.1.1 persistency#398 (merged 2026-09-08)
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_bazel_platforms to v1.1.0 persistency#399 (merged 2026-09-08)
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_bazel_cpp_toolchains to v1.0.3 persistency#404 (merged 2026-09-08)
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_logging to v0.2.4 persistency#405 (merged 2026-09-08)
  • doc: README.md updates persistency#406 (merged 2026-09-09)
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_platform to v0.7.2 persistency#407 (merged 2026-09-08)
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_rules_imagefs to v0.1.0 persistency#408 (merged 2026-09-08)
  • rollback google test version. persistency#414 (closed 2026-09-10)

Misc

• Follow-up: Rework of component requirements related to snapshots persistency#337 is awaiting review fixes. -> fixes done "final" review from @umaucher
• cleanup of Persistency for S-CORE Release v0.9 #3052 and move / update in Persistency for S-CORE Release v0.10 #3111 -> @umaucher

[umaucher]

Persistency FT Meeting Minutes - 2026-09-17

Participants

• @PandaeDo
• @umaucher
• @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC
• @tizava
• @arkjedrz

Updates (Issues, PRs)

Issues

• new:
  • Maximum number of snapshots persistency#416 (@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC)
• updated:
  • update public APIS persistency#409 (@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC)
  • implementation of backup mechanism persistency#410 (@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC)
  • implementing configuration by file persistency#411 (@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC)
• closed:
  • Log messages in kvs.cpp have doubled spaces persistency#402 (closed 2026-09-14)

PRs

• new:
  • none
• updated:
  • feat: make KVS max snapshot count configurable persistency#383
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_crates to v0.0.12 persistency#401
  • rollback googletest persistency#415 (merged 2026-09-10)
  • update get_value function persistency#417
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_docs_as_code to v8.1.2 persistency#418 (merged 2026-09-11)
  • docs: fix README title and trailing whitespace persistency#419 (merged 2026-09-11)
  • docs: add CI concept and trust-boundary manuals persistency#420
  • adding remove all keys persistency#421 (merged 2026-09-14)
  • ci: trusted chain for DASH license check with fork gate persistency#422
  • ci: trusted chain for DASH license check with fork gate persistency#423
  • fix: classify KVS unit and integration tests as small persistency#424 (merged 2026-09-15)
• merged/closed:
  • none

Follow-up

• Rework of component requirements related to snapshots persistency#337
• Persistency for S-CORE Release v0.9 #3052
• Persistency for S-CORE Release v0.10 #3111

Misc

• none

[umaucher]

Persistency FT Meeting Minutes - 2026-09-24

Participants

• @PandaeDo
• @umaucher
• @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC
• @tizava
• @arkjedrz
• @janis-qorix

Updates (Issues, PRs)

Issues

• new:
  • [enhancement] update current requirements to match code persistency#429 (@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC)
  • New behavior for Snapshot handling persistency#436
  • Provide Async APis for time consuming functions. persistency#438
  • Snapshot remove API persistency#439
  • supporting versioning persistency#440
  • persistency tool persistency#441
• updated:
  • Improvement: Make it possible to initialize KVS when snapshot with ID=0 is not available persistency#237
  • implementing configuration by file persistency#411 (@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC)
• closed:
  • update public APIS persistency#409 closed 2026-09-21

PRs

• new:
  • feat: use score_sbom for license handling persistency#430
  • fix: mark pip, score_rules_imagefs and googletest as non-dev dependencies persistency#434
  • update array and object types persistency#437
  • docs(safety): resolve inconsistent persistency AoUs (Action_64) persistency#442
• updated:
  • feat(kvs): enforce maximum key length of 32 bytes (C++) persistency#308 (@atarekra)
  • adopt verification report persistency#330 (@FScholPer)
  • Rework of component requirements related to snapshots persistency#337 (@tizava)
  • Update req inspect persistency#345 (@PandaeDo)
  • feat: make KVS max snapshot count configurable persistency#383
  • feat: allow KVS initialization from an explicit snapshot persistency#400
  • docs: add CI concept and trust-boundary manuals persistency#420
• merged/closed:
  • update get_value function persistency#417 merged 2026-09-18
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_baselibs to v0.2.13 persistency#425 merged 2026-09-18
  • Module index table fix persistency#426 merged 2026-09-18
  • Improvements in documentation persistency#427 merged 2026-09-18
  • using vajson lib persistency#428 merged 2026-09-18
  • build: migrate Baselibs Rust targets persistency#431 merged 2026-09-22
  • feat: declare package license via rules_license persistency#432 closed 2026-09-23
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_docs_as_code to v8.2.0 persistency#433 merged 2026-09-23
  • docs(verification_report): switch to post_template persistency#435 merged 2026-09-23

Misc

• Follow-up: Rework of component requirements related to snapshots persistency#337
• Follow-up: Persistency for S-CORE Release v0.9 #3052
• Follow-up: Persistency for S-CORE Release v0.10 #3111
• Follow-up: update persistency feature requirements #3284

[umaucher]

Persistency FT Meeting Minutes - 2026-10-01

Participants

• @PandaeDo
• @umaucher
• @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC
• @tizava
• @arkjedrz
• @janis-qorix

Updates (Issues, PRs)

Issues

• new:
  • Improvement: Update module documentation persistency#445 (@chetanb-qorix, @janis-qorix)
  • Align KVS C++ headers with project-prefixed include paths persistency#446
  • Decide on configurable storage filenames and storage specifiers persistency#452
• updated:
  • supporting versioning persistency#440
  • persistency tool persistency#441 (@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC)
• closed:
  • none

PRs

• new:
  • update component requirements. persistency#443
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_bazel_cpp_toolchains to v1.0.5 persistency#447
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_baselibs to v0.2.14 - abandoned persistency#448
• updated:
  • Update req inspect persistency#345 (@PandaeDo)
  • feat: use score_sbom for license handling persistency#430
  • docs(safety): resolve inconsistent persistency AoUs (Action_64) persistency#442
• merged/closed:
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_docs_as_code to v8.3.0 persistency#444 merged 2026-09-28
  • update array and object types persistency#437 merged 2026-10-01
  • docs: set KVS bundle primary need persistency#449 merged 2026-09-30
  • Migrate coverage pipeline to score_coverage 0.3.1 persistency#450 merged 2026-09-30
  • Fix component definition location persistency#451 merged 2026-09-30

Misc

• Follow-up: update array and object types persistency#437

[umaucher]

Persistency FT Meeting Minutes - 2026-10-08

Participants

• @PandaeDo
• @umaucher
• @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC
• @tizava
• @arkjedrz
• @janis-qorix
• @karolnowak

Updates (Issues, PRs)

Issues

• new:
  • none
• updated:
  • implementing configuration by file persistency#411 (@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC)
  • New behavior for Snapshot handling persistency#436 (@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC)
  • Snapshot remove API persistency#439 (@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC)
• closed:
  • Test plan in Persistency persistency#267 closed 2026-10-05
  • Improvement: Update module documentation persistency#445 closed 2026-10-08

PRs

• new:
  • Move kvs_tool persistency#456 (@arkjedrz)
  • Move kvs_rust persistency#457 (@arkjedrz)
  • Move integration_test_scenarios persistency#459 (@arkjedrz)
  • Reorganise C++ library persistency#461 (@arkjedrz)
  • impl: make it possible to load a selected snapshot persistency#464
  • Reorganise CIT persistency#475 (@arkjedrz)
  • fix: Use copyright_checker from tools persistency#476
  • Update dependency score_platform to v0.7.3 persistency#477
• updated:
  • add compile-time configuration for kvs maximum storage size persistency#165 (@atarekra)
  • feat(kvs): enforce maximum key length of 32 bytes (C++) persistency#308 (@atarekra)
  • feat: make KVS max snapshot count configurable persistency#383
  • feat: allow KVS initialization from an explicit snapshot persistency#400
  • update component requirements. persistency#443
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_bazel_cpp_toolchains to v1.0.5 persistency#447
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_baselibs to v0.2.14 - abandoned persistency#448
• merged/closed:
  • Update req inspect persistency#345 closed 2026-10-02
  • Editorial update documents persistency#453 merged 2026-10-02
  • chore: update Bazel to 8.7.0 persistency#454 merged 2026-10-02
  • Migrating from deprecated score::ResultBlank to score::Result<void>. persistency#455 merged 2026-10-05
  • update feature architecture and component achitecture persistency#458 merged 2026-10-02
  • Move C++ unit tests persistency#460 merged 2026-10-08
  • chore(docs): update score_docs_as_code gitignore configuration persistency#462 merged 2026-10-05
  • fix: Use score_pytest from score_tools instead of score_tooling persistency#463 merged 2026-10-05
  • feat: use score_sbom for license handling persistency#430 merged 2026-10-06
  • Update score_crates to 0.0.12 persistency#465 closed 2026-10-06
  • fix: Use unique pip hub name and drop unused test venv persistency#466 merged 2026-10-06
  • Update score_crates to 0.0.13 persistency#467 merged 2026-10-06
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_crates to v0.0.12 persistency#401 closed 2026-10-06
  • Update index File persistency#468 merged 2026-10-08
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_platform to v0.7.3 persistency#469 closed 2026-10-07
  • build: misc dependency and toolchain cleanup persistency#470 merged 2026-10-07
  • Drop src in rust_kvs persistency#471 merged 2026-10-08
  • Drop src in rust_kvs_tool persistency#472 merged 2026-10-08
  • Avoid documentation deployment from deleted merge-queue refs persistency#473 merged 2026-10-07
  • Drop src in CIT test scenarios persistency#474 merged 2026-10-08

Misc

[umaucher]

Persistency FT Meeting Minutes - 2026-10-15

Participants

• @PandaeDo
• @umaucher
• @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC
• @tizava
• @arkjedrz
• @janis-qorix
• @karolnowak

Updates (Issues, PRs)

Issues

• new:
  • Remove deprecated aliases left by CIT reorganisation and verify consumers persistency#487
  • rust_kvs: flush() does not sync KVS and hash files to storage persistency#493
  • feat: prevent access to a single KVS instance from multiple OS processes [cpp] persistency#494 (@karolnowak)
  • Boolean are incorrectly stored as 0/1 persistency#495 (@arkjedrz)
  • Proper tooling integration persistency#498 (@arkjedrz)
  • Only accept keys that consist of printable ASCII characters persistency#504 (@arkjedrz)
  • Ask defaults file handling by the KVS tool persistency#505
  • Code quality improvements persistency#507
  • Update architecture documents persistency#510
  • Validate kvs_tool against cpp implementation persistency#511
• updated:
  • Flush function enhancement persistency#362
  • Storage Access control persistency#412 (@arkjedrz)
  • New behavior for Snapshot handling persistency#436 (@Ahmed-Elsaka-JC)
• closed:
  • Improvement: set KVS_MAX_SNAPSHOTS as configuration parameter persistency#108 closed 2026-10-12
  • Add compile-time configuration for maximum Key-Value Storage (KVS) size persistency#161 closed 2026-10-12
  • Add _ suffix to non-public fields persistency#480 closed 2026-10-13

PRs

• new:
  • kvs: align the internal repr between C++ and Rust persistency#490 (@arkjedrz)
  • kvs_tool: basic ITF tests persistency#497 (@arkjedrz)
  • tooling: improve IDE support persistency#500 (@arkjedrz)
  • kvs: atomic file operations, file permissions persistency#503 (@arkjedrz)
  • kvs: C++ key handling changes persistency#508 (@arkjedrz)
  • kvs: Rust key handling changes persistency#509 (@arkjedrz)
  • chore: update score_test_scenarios deps to score/ paths persistency#512
• updated:
  • adopt verification report persistency#330 (@FScholPer)
  • update component requirements. persistency#443
  • Update Safety Analysis persistency#481
• merged/closed:
  • add compile-time configuration for kvs maximum storage size persistency#165 merged 2026-10-12 (@atarekra)
  • feat(kvs): enforce maximum key length of 32 bytes (C++) persistency#308 merged 2026-10-12 (@atarekra)
  • feat: make KVS max snapshot count configurable persistency#383 merged 2026-10-12
  • feat: allow KVS initialization from an explicit snapshot persistency#400 closed 2026-10-12
  • Reorganise CIT persistency#475 merged 2026-10-09
  • Update dependency score_platform to v0.7.3 persistency#477 closed 2026-10-15
  • ci: bump cicd-workflows to v0.0.3-26-gd31fdc0 persistency#482 merged 2026-10-09
  • Update safety plan persistency#483 merged 2026-10-13
  • impl: make it possible to load a selected snapshot [rust] persistency#484 merged 2026-10-14
  • Initial version of user manual persistency#485 merged 2026-10-14
  • Fix test scenario kvs target oversight persistency#486 merged 2026-10-09
  • test: dummy PR to verify QNX approval concurrency (do not merge) persistency#488 closed 2026-10-09
  • fix(rust_kvs): sync KVS and hash files to storage on flush persistency#489 merged 2026-10-15
  • Update safety manual & codeowner, prepare safety analysis fdr persistency#491 merged 2026-10-14
  • Update security documents persistency#492 merged 2026-10-14
  • Update dependency score_coverage to v0.4.0 persistency#496 merged 2026-10-13
  • ci: split docs workflow into build and publish persistency#499 merged 2026-10-13
  • style: add _ suffix to non-public fields persistency#501 merged 2026-10-13
  • Update dependency score_coverage to v0.4.1 persistency#502 merged 2026-10-13
  • Update dependency score_docs_as_code to v8.4.0 persistency#506 merged 2026-10-13

Misc / Discussions

• IDE support: We can have a config suggestions but could not enforce it see Proper tooling integration persistency#498 (comment)
• kvs key handling: see Only accept keys that consist of printable ASCII characters persistency#504 (comment)
• component requirements: in general keep PR's simple and only fix / implement one thing ... for the dedicated PR check to split for the integration of score_platform v0.7.3 and introduction of new component requirements. New component requirements leading to discussions might even go in a third PR

[umaucher]

Persistency FT Meeting Minutes - 2026-10-22

Participants

• @PandaeDo
• @umaucher
• @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC
• @tizava
• @arkjedrz
• @janis-qorix
• @karolnowak
• @apichlkostner-b

Updates (Issues, PRs)

Issues

• new:
  • Update Persistency tooling persistency#513 (@arkjedrz)
  • Separate JSON and hash file operations are inevitably not atomic persistency#515 (@arkjedrz)
  • Update code docs to match behavior and requirements persistency#517
  • Add const in C++ impl persistency#520 (@arkjedrz)
  • Resetting key without default value is an error persistency#527
  • Replace std::filesystem with score::filesystem persistency#532
  • Prevent bad_variant_access in noexcept functions persistency#542
  • Adapt C++ impl to baselibs style guide persistency#556 (@arkjedrz)
• updated:
  • Flush function enhancement persistency#362
  • update Corruption detection algorithm from adler32 to CRC64 persistency#413
  • Boolean are incorrectly stored as 0/1 persistency#495 (@arkjedrz)
  • Proper tooling integration persistency#498 (@arkjedrz)
  • Code quality improvements persistency#507
• closed:
  • integrity check CRC32 instead of adler persistency#111 closed 2026-10-20
  • Storage Access control persistency#412 closed 2026-10-21
  • Provide Async APis for time consuming functions. persistency#438 closed 2026-10-20
  • rust_kvs: flush() does not sync KVS and hash files to storage persistency#493 closed 2026-10-16
  • Only accept keys that consist of printable ASCII characters persistency#504 closed 2026-10-19
  • Remove TODOs from code persistency#516 closed 2026-10-21
  • Add score::cpp::ignore to explicit return value ignores persistency#518 closed 2026-10-21
  • Use noexcept in C++ impl persistency#519 closed 2026-10-20
  • Mark final for final classes persistency#521 closed 2026-10-21
  • Drop single point of return rule persistency#522 closed 2026-10-20
  • Align docs and comments style with other components persistency#530 closed 2026-10-21

PRs

• new:
  • build: move format, copyright and license checks to //tools persistency#534 (@arkjedrz)
  • build: add clang-tidy, Clippy and Ruff lint with --config=lint persistency#536 (@arkjedrz)
  • impl: KVS Instance state registry [cpp] persistency#538
  • Add initial version of security plan and manual persistency#539
  • Initial version release notes persistency#540
  • Update safety manual - correct tag persistency#541
  • chore(deps): bump eclipse-score/cicd-workflows/.github/workflows/docs.yml from 8ab73967470fa41977dd1c1102d03719b2e2c7e2 to b775b8e8e53aa6fcc9f47afc6d62cc8b66bbe18f persistency#544
  • chore(deps): bump eclipse-score/cicd-workflows/.github/workflows/on-pr.yml from 8ab73967470fa41977dd1c1102d03719b2e2c7e2 to b775b8e8e53aa6fcc9f47afc6d62cc8b66bbe18f persistency#545
  • chore(deps): bump eclipse-score/cicd-actions/unblock-user-namespace-for-linux-sandbox from 63c3e9c93df76d76a1baca18e407745ddaeb2fca to 30740c18c728bc58f9b17c914c5592a5008f6b98 persistency#546
  • chore(deps): bump actions/setup-python from 5.6.0 to 7.0.0 persistency#547
  • Safety: prefill safety plan FDR (reviewer aschemmel-tech) persistency#550
  • Safety: prefill safety analysis FDR, drop obsolete feature FDR  persistency#551
  • inspection: prepare KVS requirements inspection persistency#552
  • inspection: prepare KVS architecture inspection persistency#553
  • inspection: prepare feature architecture inspection persistency#554
  • kvs: improve constness persistency#555 (@arkjedrz)
  • Add code ql workflow persistency#557
  • docs: add the C++ style guide persistency#561 (@arkjedrz)
  • kvs: rename C++ headers to snake_case .h persistency#562 (@arkjedrz)
  • Remove redundant type member of KvsValue persistency#563
• updated:
  • docs: add CI concept and trust-boundary manuals persistency#420
  • ci: trusted chain for DASH license check with fork gate persistency#423
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_baselibs to v0.2.14 - abandoned persistency#448
  • Update Safety Analysis persistency#481
  • kvs: align the internal repr between C++ and Rust persistency#490 (@arkjedrz)
  • tooling: improve IDE support persistency#500 (@arkjedrz)
• merged/closed:
  • update component requirements. persistency#443 merged 2026-10-16
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_bazel_cpp_toolchains to v1.0.5 persistency#447 merged 2026-10-22
  • kvs: atomic file operations, file permissions persistency#503 merged 2026-10-21
  • kvs: C++ key handling changes persistency#508 merged 2026-10-16
  • kvs: Rust key handling changes persistency#509 merged 2026-10-19
  • chore: update score_test_scenarios deps to score/ paths persistency#512 merged 2026-10-16
  • Update dependency score_process_description to v2.2.1 - autoclosed persistency#514 closed 2026-10-20
  • ci: bump cicd-workflows, pin actions and adopt cicd common steps persistency#523 closed 2026-10-19
  • ci: bump cicd-workflows, pin actions and adopt cicd common steps persistency#524 merged 2026-10-20
  • build(bazel): split .bazelrc and rename platform configs to score-* persistency#525 merged 2026-10-21
  • Update dependency score_coverage to v0.4.2 persistency#528 merged 2026-10-19
  • kvs: small code quality improvements persistency#529 merged 2026-10-21
  • build(bazel): adopt score_cpp_policies and treat C++ warnings as errors persistency#531 merged 2026-10-21
  • kvs: make C++ impl noexcept persistency#533 merged 2026-10-20
  • kvs: drop single point of return rule persistency#535 merged 2026-10-20
  • docs: use mod_ver_report need type for module verification report persistency#537 merged 2026-10-20
  • chore(deps): bump astral-sh/setup-uv from 10.0.1 to 10.3.0 in the github-actions group across 1 directory persistency#543 merged 2026-10-22
  • Update realize wp__module_user_manual, add it to the safety plan persistency#548 merged 2026-10-21
  • Fix wrong safety plan entry persistency#549 merged 2026-10-21
  • kvs: unify comment style persistency#558 merged 2026-10-21
  • ci: skip QNX build for Dependabot PRs, add manual dispatch persistency#559 merged 2026-10-22
  • chore(deps): update dependency score_cpp_policies to v0.1.2 persistency#560 merged 2026-10-21

Misc / Discussions

• meeting shift 13:30 --> slack poll https://sdvworkinggroup.slack.com/archives/C08B339ETQU/p1792677071393689
• push for https://eclipse-score.github.io/score/main/contribute/development/cpp/coding_guidelines.html#code-style in the Monday TL sync meeting
  • name space match folder structure (tbc / raised) in TL sync on monday or a topic for the next point
  • all PR's like kvs: apply C++ idiom and class layout rules persistency#566
• depandabot / renovate updates and config: Also trigger discussion in TL sync
  • do we need both?
  • generic setup / config for all repos?
  • tagging of cicd-workflows/actions
• PR handling:
  • avoid rebasing if not needed (requires new approval for the QNX builds) use the "Update branch" -> "Update with merge commit" if needed
• Remove redundant type member of KvsValue persistency#563 review + suggestion / help for testing / mocking is needed
• outcome reset_key discussion --> Resetting key without default value is an error persistency#527 (comment)

[Ahmed-Elsaka-JC]

Persistency FT Meeting Minutes - 2026-10-29

Participants

• @PandaeDo
• @umaucher
• @Ahmed-Elsaka-JC
• @tizava
• @arkjedrz
• @janis-qorix
• @karolnowak
• @apichlkostner-b

Updates (Issues, PRs)

Window: 2026-10-23..2026-10-29

Issues

new (6)

• Avoid using private APIs and fields for testing persistency#574 (@arkjedrz)
• is_value_default doesn't lock persistency#584
• Global logger object persistency#601 (@arkjedrz)
• Approach to mutex locking is not clear persistency#607
• Introduce Kvs interface persistency#620
• Add support for 8-bit and 16-bit integers persistency#624

updated (4)

• Same instance id called multiple times  persistency#63 (@karolnowak)
• Validate and adopt the S-CORE global toolchain configuration persistency#478
• Prevent bad_variant_access in noexcept functions persistency#542 (@divran24)
• Adapt C++ impl to baselibs style guide persistency#556 (@arkjedrz)

closed (9)

• Improvement: Revisit thread safe implementation and have locking and time out persistency#75 closed 2026-10-28 (not planned)
• Improvement: set storage file permission persistency#99 closed 2026-10-28 (not planned)
• KVS_CPP: hide implementation of public functions persistency#119 closed 2026-10-28 (not planned)
• Requirements improvements persistency#148 closed 2026-10-28 (not planned)
• Improvement: remake component requirements persistency#227 closed 2026-10-28 (not planned)
• Rename namespace in C++ persistency#479 closed 2026-10-28 (completed by kvs: rename namespace persistency#614)
• Boolean are incorrectly stored as 0/1 persistency#495 closed 2026-10-28
• Add const in C++ impl persistency#520 closed 2026-10-26 (completed by kvs: improve constness persistency#555)
• Resetting key without default value is an error persistency#527 closed 2026-10-29 (completed by kvs: Rename reset_key to set_value_to_default persistency#585)

PRs

new (19)

• feat: add KVS showcase example binaries persistency#573
• build(coverage): move coverage to tools/coverage, add scope check persistency#577 (@arkjedrz)
• build: add sanitizer configs and Linux sanitizer workflow persistency#578 (@arkjedrz)
• ci: add Linux aarch64 and QNX on-target tests, split build CI persistency#587 (@arkjedrz)
• implement configuration by file. persistency#595
• build: drop root check aliases and call //tools targets persistency#596 (@arkjedrz)
• Prevent bad_variant_access in noexcept conversion persistency#597
• kvs: global logger and enhanced logs persistency#608 (@arkjedrz)
• ci: create release as verified draft with docs and SBOM assets persistency#609
• ci: add Bazel cache maintenance workflow persistency#612 (@arkjedrz)
• ci: rebuild release on the reusable checks, modernize docs CI persistency#613 (@arkjedrz)
• chore(deps): bump eclipse-score/cicd-workflows/.github/workflows/license-check.yml from 58cb0ec5a80441d593464d3af09d634ab91247e0 to 3f61217cfa69b1d40b366049ace7fc63932e63c2 persistency#615
• chore(deps): bump eclipse-score/cicd-workflows/.github/workflows/docs-publish.yml from 58cb0ec5a80441d593464d3af09d634ab91247e0 to 3f61217cfa69b1d40b366049ace7fc63932e63c2 persistency#616
• chore(deps): bump eclipse-score/cicd-workflows/.github/workflows/daily.yml from 58cb0ec5a80441d593464d3af09d634ab91247e0 to 3f61217cfa69b1d40b366049ace7fc63932e63c2 persistency#617
• chore(deps): bump eclipse-score/cicd-workflows/.github/workflows/static-analysis.yml from 58cb0ec5a80441d593464d3af09d634ab91247e0 to 3f61217cfa69b1d40b366049ace7fc63932e63c2 persistency#618
• chore(deps): bump eclipse-score/cicd-workflows/.github/workflows/docs.yml from 58cb0ec5a80441d593464d3af09d634ab91247e0 to 3f61217cfa69b1d40b366049ace7fc63932e63c2 persistency#619
• test: inject filesystem, parser and writer into Kvs::Open persistency#621 (@arkjedrz)
• kvs: spell out abbreviated C++ names persistency#622 (@arkjedrz)
• kvs: drop kvs_mutex_ lock-failure tests persistency#623 (@arkjedrz)

updated (5)

• fix: mark pip, score_rules_imagefs and googletest as non-dev dependencies persistency#434
• kvs: align the internal repr between C++ and Rust persistency#490 (@arkjedrz)
• tooling: improve IDE support persistency#500 (@arkjedrz)
• impl: KVS Instance state registry [cpp] persistency#538
• kvs: fix small C++ issues persistency#571 (@arkjedrz)

merged/closed (43)

• ci: trusted chain for DASH license check with fork gate persistency#423 closed 2026-10-26 (not merged)
• chore(deps): update dependency score_baselibs to v0.2.14 - abandoned persistency#448 closed 2026-10-26 (not merged)
• Move integration_test_scenarios persistency#459 closed 2026-10-28 (not merged)
• Update Safety Analysis persistency#481 merged 2026-10-29
• build: move format, copyright and license checks to //tools persistency#534 merged 2026-10-26
• build: add clang-tidy, Clippy and Ruff lint with --config=lint persistency#536 merged 2026-10-26
• Add initial version of security plan and manual persistency#539 merged 2026-10-28
• Update safety manual - correct tag persistency#541 merged 2026-10-23
• chore(deps): bump actions/setup-python from 5.6.0 to 7.0.0 persistency#547 merged 2026-10-26
• Safety: prefill safety plan FDR (reviewer aschemmel-tech) persistency#550 merged 2026-10-27
• kvs: improve constness persistency#555 merged 2026-10-26
• docs: add the C++ style guide persistency#561 closed 2026-10-28 (not merged)
• kvs: rename C++ headers to snake_case .h persistency#562 merged 2026-10-27
• Remove redundant type member of KvsValue persistency#563 merged 2026-10-23
• kvs: apply C++ naming rules and align C++ names with the Rust API persistency#564 merged 2026-10-28
• kvs: apply C++ idiom and class layout rules persistency#566 merged 2026-10-28
• style: apply clang-format and fix end-of-file issues persistency#575 merged 2026-10-23
• fix(lint): resolve clang-tidy and Ruff findings persistency#576 merged 2026-10-23
• chore(deps): bump eclipse-score/cicd-workflows/.github/workflows/license-check.yml from 8ab73967470fa41977dd1c1102d03719b2e2c7e2 to f77ed751fa587e3a1142b2d85320917e00c888ae persistency#579 merged 2026-10-23
• chore(deps): bump eclipse-score/cicd-workflows/.github/workflows/daily.yml from 8ab73967470fa41977dd1c1102d03719b2e2c7e2 to f77ed751fa587e3a1142b2d85320917e00c888ae persistency#580 merged 2026-10-23
• chore(deps): bump softprops/action-gh-release from 2.5.0 to 3.0.3 persistency#581 merged 2026-10-23
• chore(deps): bump eclipse-score/cicd-workflows/.github/workflows/qnx-build.yml from 8ab73967470fa41977dd1c1102d03719b2e2c7e2 to f77ed751fa587e3a1142b2d85320917e00c888ae persistency#582 merged 2026-10-23
• Bump module dependencies and add Renovate config persistency#583 merged 2026-10-26
• kvs: Rename reset_key to set_value_to_default persistency#585 merged 2026-10-29
• fix(kvs): make unit tests pass on QNX targets persistency#586 merged 2026-10-26
• chore(deps): bump the github-actions group with 2 updates persistency#588 merged 2026-10-27
• chore(deps): bump eclipse-score/cicd-workflows/.github/workflows/daily.yml from f77ed751fa587e3a1142b2d85320917e00c888ae to 58cb0ec5a80441d593464d3af09d634ab91247e0 persistency#589 merged 2026-10-26
• chore(deps): bump eclipse-score/cicd-workflows/.github/workflows/docs.yml from f77ed751fa587e3a1142b2d85320917e00c888ae to 58cb0ec5a80441d593464d3af09d634ab91247e0 persistency#590 merged 2026-10-26
• chore(deps): bump eclipse-score/cicd-workflows/.github/workflows/static-analysis.yml from f77ed751fa587e3a1142b2d85320917e00c888ae to 58cb0ec5a80441d593464d3af09d634ab91247e0 persistency#591 merged 2026-10-27
• chore(deps): bump eclipse-score/cicd-workflows/.github/workflows/qnx-build.yml from f77ed751fa587e3a1142b2d85320917e00c888ae to 58cb0ec5a80441d593464d3af09d634ab91247e0 persistency#592 merged 2026-10-26
• test: use the public API in C++ unit tests persistency#593 merged 2026-10-28
• tests: use the public API in json_backend and kvs_builder tests persistency#594 merged 2026-10-28
• chore(deps): update dependency score_process_description to v2.2.2 persistency#598 merged 2026-10-28
• Bump score_tools to 0.0.4 persistency#599 merged 2026-10-28
• chore(deps): update dependency score_baselibs to v0.2.16 persistency#600 merged 2026-10-27
• chore(deps): bump eclipse-score/cicd-workflows/.github/workflows/on-pr.yml from f77ed751fa587e3a1142b2d85320917e00c888ae to 58cb0ec5a80441d593464d3af09d634ab91247e0 persistency#602 merged 2026-10-27
• chore(deps): bump eclipse-score/cicd-workflows/.github/workflows/docs-publish.yml from 8ab73967470fa41977dd1c1102d03719b2e2c7e2 to 58cb0ec5a80441d593464d3af09d634ab91247e0 persistency#603 merged 2026-10-27
• chore(deps): bump eclipse-score/cicd-workflows/.github/workflows/license-check.yml from f77ed751fa587e3a1142b2d85320917e00c888ae to 58cb0ec5a80441d593464d3af09d634ab91247e0 persistency#604 merged 2026-10-27
• chore(deps): bump eclipse-score/cicd-actions/unblock-user-namespace-for-linux-sandbox from 30740c18c728bc58f9b17c914c5592a5008f6b98 to 168b6f51b21b5f0ebe49808939db53557dca410c persistency#605 merged 2026-10-27
• chore: bump score test scenarios persistency#606 merged 2026-10-27
• chore(deps): update dependency score_docs_as_code to v8.6.0 persistency#610 merged 2026-10-28
• chore(deps): update dependency score_platform to v0.7.4 persistency#611 merged 2026-10-27
• kvs: rename namespace persistency#614 merged 2026-10-28

Misc

• Follow-ups from 2026-10-22:
  • Meeting time shift to 13:30 (Slack poll).
  • C++ coding guidelines / namespace-matches-folder-structure: raise in Monday TL sync.
  • Dependabot / Renovate setup and cicd-workflows/actions tagging: raise in TL sync.
  • PR handling: prefer "Update branch" (merge commit) over rebase, to keep QNX approvals.
  • Already resolved this week: Remove redundant type member of KvsValue persistency#563 and kvs: apply C++ idiom and class layout rules persistency#566 merged, Resetting key without default value is an error persistency#527 closed via kvs: Rename reset_key to set_value_to_default persistency#585.
• Safety analysis: Update Safety Analysis persistency#481 merged 2026-10-29, next audit 2026-11-05.
• Add additional discussion topics here.
• Add decisions and action items.