Turnstile - One Way Encryption

Turnstile encrypts data so that it can only be decrypted on another computer (and can't be decrypted on the encrypting computer).

Cryptographically, Turnstile is just a wrapper around libsodium's box. Similar functionality could be acheived with an ECIES variant.

Encrypting

• The source computer makes an ephemeral keypair.
• The source's private key is used with the target's public key to make the precomputed key.
• The precomputed key is used to encrypt the message.
• The source's ephemeral public key is part of the encrypted message, but otherwise not kept.
• The source's ephemeral private key is discarded.

Decrypting

• The target computer has a long-lived keypair.
• The target's private key is used with the source's public key (contained in the encrypted message) to make the precomputed key.
• The precomputed key is used to decrypt the message.

Uses Cases

Logging

Piping logs through Turnstile causes logs to be readable only after moving them off-box, to the computer with the target private key. This means that historical logs are protected if a webserver, for example, is compromised.

Encrypting Files

If you are given a recipient's public key, you can encrypt data and put it in a public place, knowing that only they can decrypt it. (You can't even decrypt it yourself, so you'd better keep the original, if it's needed.)

You can already do similar things with openssl or PGP, so this isn't very exciting.

Usage

Creating a base62 ed25519 key on the target machine:

target:/some/dir $ turnstile keygen
new secret key written into /home/fadedbee/.turnstile/i8q8p2L8gZpZsPD8NRcTiFfQHLfrhoq3IvsaEwWzPJH.secret

Encrypt a stream on the source machine:

source:/other/dir $ echo "hello world" | turnstile encrypt i8q8p2L8gZpZsPD8NRcTiFfQHLfrhoq3IvsaEwWzPJH > filename.txt.t7e

Encrypt a file on the source machine:

source:/other/dir $ turnstile -i filename.txt -o filename.txt.t7e encrypt i8q8p2L8gZpZsPD8NRcTiFfQHLfrhoq3IvsaEwWzPJH

Decrypt a stream on the target machine:

target:/some/dir $ cat filename.txt.t7e | turnstile decrypt
hello world

(filename.txt.t7e contains the target's public key. Decryption reads the associated secret key from /home/fadedbee/.turnstile/i8q8p2L8gZpZsPD8NRcTiFfQHLfrhoq3IvsaEwWzPJH.secret.)

Decrypt a file on the target machine:

target:/some/dir $ turnstile -i filename.txt -o filename.txt.t7e -o decrypted.txt decrypt
target:/some/dir $ cat decrypted.txt
hello world

Stream/File Format for Version 1.0.X.

Header:

+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+
|FA|DE|DB|EE|t |u |r |n |s |t |i |l |e |Version |
+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+
|                                               |
+            Encryptor's Public Key             +
|                                               |
+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+
|                                               |
+        Intended Decryptor's Public Key        |
|             (informational only)              |
+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+
|                 Initial Nonce                 |
+                       +--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+
|                       |
+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+

Chunks:

+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+--+
| Len |                                         |
+--+--+                                         +
|                                               |
+                  Ciphertext                   +
|                                               |
v                                               v

Final Chunk:

+--+--+
|00 00|
+--+--+

Design Choices

Documentation of trade-offs and compromises.

Requiring private keys to be contained in files (in ~/.turnstile)

It would have been possible to specify target secret keys on the command line, rather than using ~/.turnstile.

This would be insecure for multi-user machines, as ps and top show the command line arguments of other users.

Using Base62

• Base64 is more common, but needs to be quoted in shell commands and does not cut and paste easily.
• Base58 has guards which might be useful for hand-typing keys, but is longer and variably sized.
• In a nice coincidence, 43 base 62 digits provide 256.03 bits. log2(62)*43 == 256.03

Including the Target Public Key in the Encryption Output

There is no cryptographic need for the target public key to exist in the encryption output, but we do include it.

Pros:

• Allows decryption to only try one secret key, rather than all that it knows.
• Users can inspect a .t7e file to find which public key they need to use to decrypt it.

Cons:

• Adds identifiable information to the encryption output.

Using ~/.turnstile rather than Ed25519 SSH keys from ~/.ssh

The encryption used by turnstile is compatible with SSH's .ssh/id_ed25519.pub files.

It would have been nice to use pre-existing keys, but:

• We'd need to explain the differences between SSH key types to users.
• Base64 and quoting would have to be used.

Using a 16-bit Ciphertext Length in Chunks

In order to deal with streaming, we must break the input up into chunks, each of which can be decrypted in turn. (Decryption includes an integrity check.)

Smaller chunks have more overhead. but allowing larger chunks means more length overhead for each small chunk.

We could have used a variably-sized integer for the length, which would have saved some space, at the expense of some CPU cycles and complexity.

For the time-being, we've settled on a maximum chunk size of 65,535 bytes.

For large files, every 65,519 bytes of plaintext results in a chunk containing 2 bytes of length and 65,535 bytes of cipher text.

This is less than a 0.03% overhead. This is acceptable, for v1.0.0, given the simplicity of using a u16 for the chunk length.

Nonce generation

Nonces must not be reused for any given pair of public and secret keys.

Every chunk is encrypted with a different nonce, which is simple an XOR of the initial nonce and the chunk number.

As each message is encrypted using a different secret key, there is no need for initial nonces to differ. But we randomly generate initial nonces and write them into the header, just in case...