[TRACKER] Scene Inheritance related issues

[kubecz3k]

This is a tracker for issues related to Scene Inheritance.

Tasks

Beta Give feedback

1. IMPORT:: New meshes introduced into scene lose their name #2223
   bug confirmed topic:editor usability +4
2. "Parse Error: Unexpected end of file" in inherited .tscn files #3897
   bug topic:core +2
3. Inherited scenes: float variables always seen as custom, can't be reset #4759
   bug good first issue topic:editor +3
4. Editing exported boolean of base scene child is not working in inherited scene #3904
   bug topic:core +2
5. Inherited scene saving parent nodes in incorrect order #3945
   bug topic:core +2
6. Scenes are unable to remember it's nodes fold state #3395
   bug confirmed topic:editor usability +4
7. tscn/tres: Inconsistencies in the extension filters of the save/open file dialogs #2946
   enhancement topic:editor usability +3
8. "signal already connected" error in inherited scenes #6106
   bug confirmed topic:core topic:editor +4
9. CollisionShapes added to inherited scenes are ignored #5798
   bug confirmed topic:core +3
10. Collision shapes overridden in inherited scenes are not used by physics, but display fine. #8103
    bug enhancement topic:core +3
11. Exported vars not immediatelly updating for inherited scenes. #5997
    archived bug topic:editor +3
12. Inherited Models don't hold information about textures/mappings #10147
    bug topic:core topic:editor +3
13. Multi-line String creates duplicate string #6212
    bug confirmed topic:core +3
14. Sub-inherited scene is not updated properly in the editor #7984
    bug confirmed topic:editor +3
15. Scripts not added retroactively to instanced inherited scenes open in editor #10156
    bug confirmed topic:core +3
16. it's impossible to disconnect signals in inherited scene. #12373
    bug confirmed topic:editor +3
17. Object's set_meta() doesn't work on inherited scenes #12990
    bug confirmed topic:core topic:plugin +4
18. Ability to modify Animation player in inherited scenes. #6169
    enhancement topic:core usability +3
19. Typo in Wiki #621
    +0
20. Ability to extend base scene script easily for inherited scenes #4585
    archived enhancement topic:editor usability +4
21. Easier ways to create a new inherited scene #13013
    enhancement topic:editor usability +3
22. Crash On Trying to Add Scene as Child #481
    +0

[kubecz3k]

2.1 milestone since at least bug fixes should be considered for 2.1

[reduz]

done with the bugs

[kubecz3k]

Updated the list, hopefully I didn't miss anything.

[reduz]

would be nice to see how much of this changed

[kubecz3k]

Actually have this on my todo list :) I will update it at the beginning of the week!

[kubecz3k]

I was searching today for new scene inheritance related issues in order to update tracker. But I haven't found anything new... (only one issue that I submitted earlier today)

[LikeLakers2]

#3354 is fixed.

[pwab]

#10147 is fixed and documentation for making resources unique is tracked by godot-docs/issues/581

[rcorre]

Ability to modify Animation player in inherited scenes #6169 (enhancement)

Is this fixed? Even importing animations as separate files only persists changes until the next time you export your scene, at which point all your added tracks are wiped out.

@akien-mga's last comment was

AnimationTreePlayer is deprecated in Godot 3.1 and will be removed in Godot 3.2. It is replaced by AnimationTree, which was written from scratch and likely fixes/deprecates this issue.

However, I'm unclear on how AnimationTree can replace the need for adding audio/call tracks to animations. I mentioned some use cases on #28275, maybe that issue should be part of this list?