AudioStreamPlayer emits finished signal inconsistently.

[abdlquadri]

Godot version

Godot_v4.0-dev.20211004_linux.64

System information

5.4.0-91-generic #102-Ubuntu SMP x86_64 x86_64 x86_64 GNU/Linux

Issue description

Godot master branch emits finished signal inconsistently for different audio files.

Audios 001001.mp3, 001001.ogg does not emit finished while 002030.mp3 does emit.

Godot 3.4 behaves correctly. Meaning all files emit finished signal.

Steps to reproduce

Load project https://github.com/abdlquadri/GodotAudioPlayerSignalDemo/tree/main/TestingAudioPlayerSignals in Godot_v4.

Expect to see fini printed in console after audio stops.

This expected behavior is true for some files ( 002030.mp3) but not others (001001.mp3, 001001.ogg)

You can load https://github.com/abdlquadri/GodotAudioPlayerSignalDemo/tree/main/TestingAudioPlayerSignals_v3 in Godot_v3 to see that it works for Godot 3

Minimal reproduction project

https://github.com/abdlquadri/GodotAudioPlayerSignalDemo/tree/main/TestingAudioPlayerSignals

[abdlquadri]

Hi @Calinou , if I could be directed to where to look, I might be able to fix this issue myself. Thank you.

[Calinou]

This is likely a regression from #51296.

The fix may be similar to #55808. See also #55570 which might have affected this.

[abdlquadri]

Ok. Thanks. @Calinou

[lufog]

I understand absolutely nothing about audio stream processing. But after playing around with the debugger, and comparing the behavior when playing mp3 and ogg files.

I noticed the following:

When playing mp3 file, the is_playback_active(playback) returns false at the end. Which results in the line 49 being executed:

godot/scene/audio/audio_stream_player.cpp

Lines 48 to 50 in e9e2aaf

	if (playback.is_valid() && !AudioServer::get_singleton()->is_playback_active(playback) && !AudioServer::get_singleton()->is_playback_paused(playback)) {
	playbacks_to_remove.push_back(playback);
	}

But when playing ogg file, is_playback_active(playback) always returns true, line 49 is not executed. So playbacks_to_remove is always empty, and this code is never executed:

godot/scene/audio/audio_stream_player.cpp

Lines 61 to 63 in e9e2aaf

	if (!playbacks_to_remove.is_empty()) {
	emit_signal(SNAME("finished"));
	}

[lufog]

The emission of the finished signal depends on the length or bit depth of the audio file. For example, in this test project, when playing 6 mp3 files of different bit depth, the finished signal is emitted for only one.

AudioPlayerSignalTest.zip

[pierpo]

Anyone looking at this issue? 😊

@ellenhp Since it could be related to your past work on the audio, would you have an idea of a possible cause?
I hope it's okay to ping you, I have no idea if it's acceptable behavior to do such a thing. Of course I'm not asking for you to look into it directly, I'm just asking for some guesses if you can think of any 😊

We'd love to know if there's at least a workaround 😉
And maybe dive into it, with some indications!

[croked91]

Hi, if somebody else has this problem, try my trick. Yes, it's not ideal solution, but it's works:

class_name AudioPlayer
extends AudioStreamPlayer

signal audio_finished


@onready var check_track_finished_timer := Timer.new()


func _ready() -> void:
	add_child(check_track_finished_timer)
	audio_finished.connect(_some_func)

func play_track() -> void:
	...
	_check_is_finished()
	await audio_finished
	...

func  _some_func() -> void:
	....

func _check_is_finished() -> void:
	if not playing:
		audio_finished.emit()
		check_track_finished_timer.stop()
		return
	check_track_finished_timer.timeout.connect(_check_is_finished)
	check_track_finished_timer.start(0.5)

Just example. If you have any questions or comments, I will be happy to answer.