



Produced by Al Haines









[Frontispiece: GENERAL SIR H. SMITH-DORRIEN.  _From the Painting by
Arnold Mountford._]



  The
  Retreat from Mons

  BY ONE WHO SHARED IN IT



  BY
  A. CORBETT-SMITH
  (_Major, R.F.A._)



  _With Three Plates and Map_



  For who is he, whose chin is but enrich'd
  With one appearing hair, that will not follow
  These cull'd and choice-drawn cavaliers to France?



  CASSELL AND COMPANY, LTD
  London, New York, Toronto and Melbourne
  1916




  To

  GENERAL SIR H. L. SMITH-DORRIEN,
  G.C.M.G., G.C.B., D.S.O., ETC.

DEAR GENERAL SMITH-DORRIEN,

When, some few months ago, you honoured me by your acceptance of this
dedication I had in mind to make a single volume which should trace the
course of the War during the period of your command of the Second Army,
the unforgettable days from Mons to Ypres.

Since then I have found that there is one phase of the operations which
has gripped the imagination of the public more than any other event of
the past two years: the "Retreat from Mons."  It is, indeed, almost
incredible how little the people know of this, and how splendidly they
respond to the telling of the story.

But it seems to me that the story can never be told as it should be.
Only those who actually experienced the horror and the splendour of
those ten days could hope to tell it, and for them the facts are
blurred and distorted by the nightmare through which they passed.

Still, I am rashly making the attempt, and in doing so I try to write
of the big, human side of things.  For it is the trivial, homely
incidents in the daily life of the British soldier, and the stories of
noble devotion and chivalry of gallant gentlemen like Francis Grenfell
and Bradbury, which fire the imagination.  I know that you will
understand and appreciate my motives.

For the rest, should the public be kind to this trivial volume I shall
hope later to continue the narrative as I had originally intended.

Will you, then, accept my book, not in tribute of a Command which must
remain indelibly scored in letters of gold on the page of our country's
history so long as Britain endures, but as a memory of the two or three
years of peace when I was privileged to work with you and of the year
of war when I had the honour of serving, one of that "band of
brothers," in your Command?

I am,
    Very faithfully yours,
        A. CORBETT-SMITH.

THE MIDDLE TEMPLE,
  LONDON.




AUTHOR'S ACKNOWLEDGMENT

I tender my very grateful thanks to GENERAL SIR HORACE SMITH-DORRIEN
for his kindness in reading the proof-sheets of the book and for
several most valuable items of information.

My thanks are also due to CAPTAIN C. T. ATKINSON, of the Historical
Section, Committee of Imperial Defence, for his courteous help in the
task of compiling the Roll of Honour.  Also to the SECRETARY, K.A.
Institution, for the loan of material for the same purpose.

I have availed myself to some extent of the researches of MR. HILAIRE
BELLOC in my estimates in Chapter V.; while my details of the German
Army are taken from German sources, "Deutsche Land- und Seemacht," by
Rabenau, and other volumes.

To my comrades-in-arms (few, alas! remain), whose deeds and experiences
have contributed to the writing of the story, I hold out a hand of
greeting.  I salute in reverence the immortal souls of the gallant dead.

A. C.-S.




CONTENTS

Roll of Honour

CHAPTER

   1.  Mobilisation
   2.  The Sailing of the Force
   3.  The Landing of the Force
   4.  Up Country
   5.  The Marshalling of the Armies
   6.  Mons
   7.  Mons (_continued_)
   8.  The Retreat Begins
   9.  The Second Day
  10.  An Interlude
  11.  Wednesday, the 26th of August
  12.  Wednesday, the 26th of August (_continued_)
  13.  The Retreat Continues
  14.  Past Compiègne
  15.  The Final Stages

Appendix I.

Appendix II.




LIST OF PLATES

General Sir H. Smith-Dorrien . . . _Frontispiece_

Field-Marshal Viscount French

General Sir Douglas Haig

Map of Country from Mons to Paris




  The Roll of Honour

  OF THE

  FIRST EXPEDITIONARY FORGE

  _General Officer Commanding-in-Chief the British Forces:_
  FIELD-MARSHAL SIR J. D. P. FRENCH.

  _Chief of the General Staff:_
  LIEUTENANT-GENERAL SIR A. J. MURRAY.

  _Adjutant-General:_
  MAJOR-GENERAL SIR C. F. N. MACREADY.

  _Quartermaster-General:_
  MAJOR-GENERAL SIR W. R. ROBERTSON.



  _FIRST ARMY CORPS_

  _General Officer Commanding-in-Chief_--
  LIEUTENANT-GENERAL SIR DOUGLAS HAIG.


  1st DIVISION

  _General Officer Commanding_--MAJOR-GENERAL S. H. LOMAX.


  1st Infantry Brigade

  _Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL F. I. MAXSE.
  1st Batt. Coldstream Guards.
  1st Batt. R. Highlanders.
  1st Batt. Scots Guards.
  2nd Batt. R. Munster Fusiliers.


  2nd Infantry Brigade

  _Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL E. S. BULFIN.
  2nd Batt. R. Sussex Regt.
  1st Batt. Northampton Regt.
  1st Batt. N. Lancs. Regt.
  2nd Batt. K. R. Rifle Corps


  3rd Infantry Brigade

  _Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL H. J. S. LANDON.
  1st Batt. R. W. Surrey Regt.
  1st Batt. Gloucester Regt.
  1st Batt. S. Wales Borderers.
  2nd Batt. Welsh Regt.

  CAVALRY (attached)
  C Squadron 15th Hussars.

  ROYAL ENGINEERS
  23rd and 26th Field Companies.

  ROYAL ARTILLERY
  R.F.A. Batteries--113, 114, 115, 116, 117, 118, 46, 51, 54;
  (Howitzer) 30, 40, 57.
  _Heavy Battery R.G.A._--26.
  An Ammunition Column and an Ammunition Park.



  2nd DIVISION

  _General Officer Commanding_--MAJOR-GENERAL C. C. MONRO.


  4th Infantry Brigade

  _Brigade-Commander_--GENERAL R. SCOTT-KERR.
  2nd Batt. Grenadier Guards
  3rd Batt. Coldstream Guards
  2nd Batt. Coldstream Guards
  lst Batt. Irish Guards.


  5th Infantry Brigade

  _Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL R. C. B. HAKING.

  2nd Batt. Worcester Regt.
  2nd Batt. Highland L.I.
  2nd Batt. Oxford and Bucks L.I.
  2nd Batt. Connaught Rangers


  6th Infantry Brigade

  _Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL R. H. DAVIES.
  1st Batt. Liverpool Regt.
  1st Batt. R. Berks Regt.
  2nd Batt. S. Staffs. Regt.
  lst Batt. K. R. Rifle

  CAVALRY (attached)
  B Squadron 15th Hussars.

  ROYAL ENGINEERS
  5th and 11th Field Companies.

  ROYAL ARTILLERY

  _R.F.A. Batteries_--22, 50, 70, 15, 48, 71, 9, 16, 17;
  (Howitzer) 47, 56, 60.
  _Heavy Battery R.G.A._--35.
  An Ammunition Column and an Ammunition Park.



  CAVALRY

  _A Division_ (_Four Brigades_)

  General Officer Commanding--MAJOR-GENERAL E. H. H. ALLENBY.


  1st Brigade

  _Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL C. J. BRIGGS.

  2nd Dragoon Guards.
  5th Dragoon Guards.
  11th Hussars.


  2nd Brigade

  _Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL H. DE B. DE LISLE.

  4th Dragoon Guards.
  9th Lancers.
  18th Hussars.


  3rd Brigade

  _Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL H. DE LA POER GOUGH.

  4th Hussars.
  5th Lancers.
  16th Lancers.


  4th Brigade

  _Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL HON. C. E. BINGHAM.

  Household Cavalry (composite Regiment).
  6th Dragoon Guards.
  3rd Hussars.

  And--

  the 5th Brigade

  _Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL SIR P. W. CHETWODE.
  12th Lancers.
  20th Hussars.
  2nd Dragoons.


  ROYAL HORSE ARTILLERY
  _Batteries_ "D," "E," "I," "J," "L."



  SECOND ARMY CORPS

  _General Officer Commanding-in-Chief_--
  GENERAL SIR H. L. SMITH-DORRIEN.


  3rd DIVISION

  _General Officer Commanding_--MAJOR-GENERAL H. I. W. HAMILTON.


  7th Infantry Brigade

  _Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL F. W. N. McCRACHEN.

  3rd Batt. Worcester Regt.
  1st Batt. Wilts Regt.
  2nd Batt. S. Lancs. Regt.
  2nd Batt. R. Irish Rifles.


  8th Infantry Brigade

  _Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL B. J. C. DORAN.

  2nd Batt. R. Scots.
  4th Batt. Middlesex Regt.
  2nd Batt. R. Irish Regt.
  1st Batt. Gordon Highlanders.


  9th Infantry Brigade

  _Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL F. C. SHAW.
  1st Batt. Northumberland Fusiliers.
  1st Batt. Lincolnshire Regt.
  1st Batt. R. Scots Fusiliers.
  4th Batt. R. Fusiliers.


  CAVALRY (attached)
  A Squadron 15th Hussars.

  ROYAL ENGINEERS
  56th and 57th Field Companies.

  ROYAL ARTILLERY

  _R.F.A. Batteries_--107, 108, 109, 6, 23, 49, 29, 41, 45;
  (Howitzer) 128, 129, 130.
  _Heavy Battery R. G. A._--48.
  An Ammunition Column and an Ammunition Park.



  5th DIVISION

  _General Officer Commanding_--MAJOR-GENERAL SIR C. FERGUSSON.


  13th Infantry Brigade

  _Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL G. J. CUTHBERT.
  2nd Batt. K. O. Scottish Borderers.
  1st Batt. R.W. Kent Regt.
  2nd Batt. Yorks L.I.
  2nd Batt. W. Riding Regt.


  14th Infantry Brigade

  _Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL S. P. ROLT.
  2nd Batt. Suffolk Regt.
  1st Batt. Duke of Cornwall's L.I.
  1st Batt. East Surrey Regt.
  2nd Batt. Manchester Regt.


  15th Infantry Brigade

  _Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL COUNT A. E. W. GLEICHEN.

  1st Batt. Norfolk Regt.
  1st Batt. Cheshire Regt.
  1st Batt. Bedford Regt.
  1st Batt. Dorset Regt.

  CAVALRY (attached)
  A Squadron 19th Hussars.

  ROYAL ENGINEERS
  17th and 59th Field Companies.

  ROYAL ARTILLERY
  _R.F.A. Batteries_--11, 52, 80, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124;
  (Howitzer) 37, 61, 65.
  _Heavy Battery R.G.A._--108.
  An Ammunition Column and an Ammunition Park.


  19th Infantry Brigade

  _Brigade Commander_--MAJOR-GENERAL L. G. DRUMMOND.
  2nd Batt. R. Welsh Fusiliers.
  1st Batt. Middlesex Regt.
  1st Batt. Scottish Rifles.
  2nd Batt. Argyll and Sutherland Highlanders.


  ROYAL FLYING CORPS

  Aeroplane Squadrons Nos. 2, 3, 4 and 5.



  ARMY SERVICE CORPS

  Horsed and Mechanical Transport.


  ROYAL ARMY MEDICAL CORPS


  There came into line at Le Cateau on August 25th the--

  4th DIVISION

  _General Officer Commanding_--MAJOR-GENERAL T. D. O. SNOW.


  10th Infantry Brigade

  Brigade Commander--BRIGADIER-GENERAL J. A. L. HALDANE.
  1st Batt. R. Warwickshire Regt.
  1st Batt. R. Irish Fusiliers.
  2nd Batt. Seaforth Highlanders.
  2nd Batt. R. Dublin Fusiliers.


  11th Infantry Brigade

  _Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL A. G. HUNTER-WESTON.
  1st Batt. Somersetshire L.I.
  1st Batt. Hampshire Regt.
  1st Batt. E. Lancs. Regt.
  1st Batt. Rifle Brigade.


  12th Infantry Brigade

  _Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL H. F. M. WILSON.
  1st Batt. R. Lancs. Regt.
  2nd Batt. R. Inniskilling Fusiliers.
  2nd Batt. Lancashire Fusiliers.
  2nd Batt. Essex Regt.

  CAVALRY (attached)
  B Squadron 19th Hussars.

  ROYAL ENGINEERS
  7th and 9th Field Companies.

  ROYAL ARTILLERY

  _R.F.A. Batteries_--39, 68, 88 (xiv. Brigade); 125, 126, 127 (xxix
  Brigade); 27, 134, 135 (xxxii. Brigade); 31, 35, 55 (xxxvii. Brigade).

  _Heavy Battery R.G.A._--31.

  LINES OF COMMUNICATION AND ARMY TROOPS

  1st Batt. Devonshire Regt.
  1st Batt. Cameron Highlanders




The Retreat from Mons



CHAPTER I

MOBILISATION

  _Now all the youth of England are on fire,
  And silken dalliance in the wardrobe lies;
  Now thrive the armourers, and honour's thought
  Reigns solely in the breast of every man._


August 5th, 1914!  "Who would have dreamed of such a thing!" exclaimed
the big majority.  "So it has come at last," said the small minority.

Broadly speaking, there you have the country's opinion during those now
dimly remembered days which followed immediately upon Germany's
throwing down of the gauntlet.

Officers and men of our once-upon-a-time professional Army did not
bother very much about it either way.  War was their job.  Active
service was to be welcomed as a picnic change from the monotony of
soldiering in England.  Also, to the man keen on his profession (and
since the Boer War such men have been steadily increasing in numbers)
it meant the chance of promotion and of showing what he was made of.

A war, even long foreseen, must inevitably come as a surprise when it
does actually break out, and this one was no exception.  During the
last week of that July there were very, very few in Aldershot who felt
certain that the hour was at last striking.

But Aldershot was ready for it.  For many a long year past Aldershot
had existed for the Army.  Latterly it had been the forge where
Britain's little striking force, the spear-head of her armies, had been
welded, sharpened and tested, made ready for instant launching.  So,
with the Fleet, were we prepared to fulfil our pact with France; or, if
the summons came, to stand by Belgium.

Aldershot existed for war, and the comings and goings of troops passed
almost unnoticed.  True, it now became increasingly difficult to find
rooms in the town, and the local outfitters promptly set to work to
reap a golden harvest from the fantastic prices which they put upon war
gear of all kinds, but that was all--at least to the eye of a casual
observer.

There was Fritz, the doyen of Aldershot hairdressers.  I wonder how
much he learned in those days of the movements of units.  Fritz had
been an institution in the camps when present-day G.O.C.'s, grizzled
and weather-beaten, had, as junior subalterns, sought his advice upon
the training of incipient moustaches.  Fritz remembered them all, could
instantly reel off details of their careers, their regiments or
stations, from the time they had left Aldershot until they had returned
in senior commands.  All duly pigeonholed in Berlin together with
seemingly trivial incidents in their private lives.

Later on, sometime at the Aisne, rumour came round that Herr Fritz had
been up to mischief of a more serious nature and that he had been duly
lodged in prison, or shot, or something equally suitable.

Those were happy if very strenuous days at Aldershot that week or so
before the embarkation.  Men talked very little about the future,
everyone was really too busy.  Thoughts naturally flew back to the
South African War when they did talk.

"Nobody was particularly keen on that," was the generally expressed
opinion; "nobody wanted to kill the Boers; too one-sided.  This--oh!
this is the real thing.  We've got our work cut out."

The very day after the mobilisation the Officers' Mess showed signs of
packing up.  It reminded one so much of the third act in _The Second in
Command_.  Two notices in the hall brought things home:--

"Officers may wear Service dress or blue undress jackets in Mess."

"Officers are particularly requested to pay their mess bills before
leaving."

Packing-cases and parcels began to drift in and lie about: dozens of
telegrams passed in and out: a smaller variety of dishes appeared at
luncheon and dinner: the regimental band came and played to us every
night (the cheerier spirits all took a hand at conducting, especially
rag-time).

Everybody had his job, and nobody knew what anyone else was doing.
Right at the beginning we experienced a curious feeling of secrecy.
You would see an officer at lunch and miss him at dinner.

"Oh yes!  I believe he has gone this afternoon," someone remarks.

"When are you off?" Colonel X. would say to an officer in a moment of
forgetfulness, hastily adding, "No, I don't want to know--but, mind you
pay your mess bill before you go."

This secrecy of movement was certainly the most striking feature of
those early days: that, and the splendid organisation.  We have got
accustomed to it since, but at the time, and to men used to the
happy-go-lucky methods of this dear, lovable, muddle-headed old country
of ours, that organisation struck one as amazing.

On August 5th every C.O. was handed a file of documents.  In these were
given the most precise directions as to times, places and dates when
his unit was to leave Aldershot.  For instance:

"Train No. 463Y will arrive at siding B at 12.35 A.M., August 10th.

"You will complete loading by 3.40 A.M.

"This train will leave siding C at 9.45 A.M., August 10th.

"You will march on to the platform at 9.30 A.M. and complete your
entraining by 9.40."

And I believe it is a fact that every train left five minutes ahead of
its scheduled time.  The London and South Western Railway was given
sixty hours in which to send to Southampton 350 troop-trains.  They did
it in forty-five hours.  "Some" hustle!  The astonishing efficiency of
it all, and the admirable co-operation between military and civil
authorities.  I very much doubt if there were more than two officers of
the Staff at Aldershot H.Q. who knew details of the intended movements.
Fritz must have been annoyed.  C.O.'s, and other individual officers,
who knew when their own unit was timed for departure, entered
splendidly into the spirit of the game and loyally kept the information
to themselves; would not even tell their people, nor their best girls.

One day the King came down.  The visit was as secret as everything
else.  Each unit received about a quarter of an hour's warning of His
Majesty's approach, and the men turned out of their tents or broke off
their work to line up by the road.  A few words of "good-bye, and good
luck" to the men, a warm hand-clasp to the officers, three cheers, and
the Royal car slipped forward to the next unit.  One could hear the
ripple of cheering flow round the camps as His Majesty passed.

By the way, it is a little curious how, from the very beginning, there
have been just three words used by everyone in bidding "good-bye."
"Good-bye, and good luck."  A kind of spontaneous, universal formula.
Officers used it, the men, mothers, wives and sweethearts.

  "Good-bye, and good luck" to our sailors
    (It's a big debt we owe you to-day),
  "Good-bye, and good luck" to our soldiers
    (Some day we shall hope to repay).
  Though anxious the hearts left behind you,
    And a tear from the eye seems to fall,
  Yet--"good-bye"--God be with you, "good luck attend you,
    "Good-bye, and good luck to you all"--

as the refrain of a popular song had it later.

Impressions of those few hurried days are blurred.  In a sense one had
been through it all many times before.  It differed but little from
moving station or preparing for manoeuvres.  And yet there was
something of the glamour of an unknown future before one: an
instinctive feeling that this was the end of soldiering as we had known
it.  Not that anyone dreamed of the war lasting beyond Christmas; there
are no pessimists in the Army.  We were all at school breaking up for
the holidays, and I think that just about sums up the situation as we
saw it at Aldershot.  The unknown future was more on the lines of
"Shall we get any skating?"  "Will there be some good shows at the
theatres?"  "What sort of fun will the Pytchley give us?"  "Shall I be
able to get in the Hunt Ball?"

And so one has little enough to say about the days of mobilisation and
packing up.  Besides, quite enough has already been written to satisfy
an interested public.  One little adventure, however, seems worth
recording.  It befell a certain Gunner captain who was detailed to
conduct a draft of men from one unit to another.  The yarn has the
merit of being true in every particular.  It may form a small chapter
to itself.


A TOURING COMPANY

"Putting two and two together," said the A.S.C. major, "I imagine that
you're to take this draft on to Portsmouth and hand over to the O.C. of
the company down there."

Why a Gunner captain should have to conduct a draft of Field Gunners to
a place like Portsmouth and hand them over to the tender mercies of an
A.S.C. Company Commander, I couldn't imagine.  Nor indeed why a Gunner
should take his instructions from an A.S.C. major at all.  But the
Divisional C.R.A. had sent me up to him with the remark, "It looks as
though you ought to report there," and that was all about it.

Mobilisation is responsible for a good many queer happenings, and here
at Aldershot on the third day of it most men were rather at sea.

Even in those few hours one had learned not to ask questions.  There
was no objection to the asking, but the answer was usually a vacant,
far-away look over the shoulder and "Eenteenth Brigade Office?  Oh,
it's over there"; and a wave of the arm would comprehensively include
Farnborough, Deepcut and the Town Station.

And that was how the trouble began.  If only the A.S.C. major had
exercised a little imagination and made five out of his addition sum:
if only he had read his own instructions a little more carefully
(although we didn't know that till afterwards), a draft of tired
Gunners would not have spent the next week trailing about the South of
England looking for an A.S.C. company which didn't want them, and their
officer would not have received a black mark which nearly damned his
future chances at the very outset.  But that by the way.

"The men had their breakfast at three this morning," and the cheery
little subaltern, who had brought the draft down from Newcastle,
saluted and discreetly made himself still smaller by vanishing hastily
round the nearest corner.

I took my railway warrant and went out to have a look at the draft.

A fresh-looking lot they were; young, most of them, averaging about
twenty-three years old; special reservists the senior sergeant told me.
The few old hands, who sadly needed a shave and a wash, showed how
young the rest of them were.  I didn't take much stock of them, then.
One doesn't when it's just a conducting job of a few hours, handing
over, and back to Headquarters right away.

The men stood to attention, picked up their kits, and, with a "Fours
left," we were off to the station down the shimmering, dancing, sandy
roads of the Aldershot camps.  The A.S.C. major returned to his ledgers
and more arithmetic, and the cheery subaltern reclined at lordly ease
in a Gunner Mess arm-chair, with a tinkling glass of gin and ginger
beer at his elbow, and discussed the striking results of the previous
day's battle in the North Sea--which had not taken place.

The station-master, who didn't look as worried as he felt, touched his
cap.

"A local to ----, then change and go on to Reigate" (was it Reigate?  I
forget now, one visited so many out-of-the-way places), "and from there
you'll probably get a through train to Portsmouth.  If there isn't room
in the train you can always turn people out."

Visions of burly, homespun-clad farmers and comfortable market-women
being turned out, protesting, by a mere Gunner captain danced through
my brain.  Actions for assault and battery, damages, bail, prison.

"How an if they will not turn out?" said I.

And then I realised.  This was War, red War; and Great Britain was
mobilising.  The needs of the State were paramount.

"You shall bid them turn out in the Prince's name," and, unlike
Dogberry, shall see that you are obeyed.

And I made myself two inches taller because after all a Gunner captain
was somebody in the world now.  And people looked with a new interest
at the lads in khaki and began to realise, perhaps for the first time,
that they would have to count on the British Army even though it were
"such a little one."

To do the good folk justice there was never a word of protest at the
idea of having to turn out.  And we had to invite them to do so a good
many times before the company finished its tour of the Southern ports.
Really it might have been a railway in Germany from the way the
civilians gave road to the uniform.  This change of attitude was
certainly a vivid contrast to the days--last week was it?--when a man
in His Majesty's uniform was looked at askance in crowded street and
bar.

At Reigate, where we had to wait an hour, a bombardier, one of the old
hands, begged leave to visit a certain hotel outside the station to buy
some bread and cheese.

He was a man who hardly gave the appearance of being bread-and-cheese
hungry, if you quite take my meaning, and the glassy stare with which
this ancient tried to fix me augured ill for discipline if there were
many others in the draft like him.  Permission was refused.  It was a
trivial point gained but it had its consequences.

Portsmouth was reached in some five hours; and twenty minutes' march
brought us to the A.S.C. barracks where a hot dinner would cheer us
all; for I had remembered to send a telegram _en route_ to tell them to
expect us.

We were received with cordiality by a decrepit old store-keeper, and
the stables' cat.  Otherwise the barracks looked as though an army had
lately sacked the place from floor to basement.

The men looked glum, and there was more than a hint of a move to a
near-by hotel for "bread and cheese."  Well, they were only young
reservists and discipline was an almost unknown quantity.

But dinner had to materialise somehow.  So, demanding the keys of the
castle from the unwilling seneschal, the senior sergeant, the
bombardier, the stables' cat and myself started on a tour of inspection.

Good!  The kitchen contained a sack of flour and most of a sheep.
Apparently the sheep was intended to last the decrepit servitor and his
struggling family for the rest of the week.  But we paid no heed to
tearful entreaties and ruthlessly tore the meat away from their very
mouths.

"This is War," said I.

Soon dinner was well on the way, blankets were found for the men, and
off I went to report to Headquarters.

H.Q. "received me most politely," as Harry Fragson used to sing, and
didn't think they wanted me nor my company for any performance in
Portsmouth.

"Come back to-morrow morning," said H.Q., "and we'll tell you."

The next day.  "Oh, yes!" said H.Q., "you're Field Gunners, you're
evidently sent here for Hilsea (two miles out): you'd better move on at
once."

"Parade with kits in half an hour," I ordered.

Merrily we marched forth from the castle gates.  Were we not wanted at
Hilsea?

A cyclist orderly threw himself, panting, from his machine.

"H.Q.'s compliments and will you please report there at once."

"Halt!  Fours about!  Quick march!"

H.Q. again received me most politely.

"No, you're not to go to Hilsea.  You've evidently got to join the
Eenty-eenth A.S.C. Company which has gone on to Bristol.  You'll just
catch the 5.0 train if you're sharp."

"We're to go to Bristol," said I to the senior sergeant, "and you've
got to get a move on or we'll miss the train."

"I've heard tell of Bristol," he ruminated; "nice place, so my wife's
cousin's husband used to say.  He did tell as how----"

But I cut the soliloquy short and got the draft out of the castle again.

A few minutes later peaceable citizens fled into doorways and up
courts, electric cars pulled up short with a grinding of brakes,
policemen held up traffic.  The R.F.A. draft approached at a steady
double.

"Where's the fire?" yelled some.

"The Germans have captured the 'Hampshire Arms,'" said others.

"It's for a cinema show," screamed a ragged urchin.  Everyone gave us
kindly encouragement, and girls waved merrily as we flew past.  The
bombardier, who was on the pavement side, threw an arm gallantly round
the waist of a stout matron of some forty summers and dragged her, not
unwillingly, half a dozen yards before he could get home with a kiss on
the cheek.

But we caught that train with five minutes to spare.  The men were now
beginning to see the joke.  As yet it had escaped me.  Of course it was
not the first time I had seen "Tommy" at his cheeriest under
misadventures; but this cheeriness now struck me vividly for the first
time.  To-day it is world-famous.

They certainly made that journey a lively one.  Six hours in a slow
train across country--it is apt to become somewhat tedious.  I tried to
look like the man who owns a dog which persists in nibbling the
trousers of total strangers--to pretend they (the men, not the
trousers) didn't belong to me.  It was no good.  They might have been
Lancashire lads off to Blackpool for the "wakes."

So with imitations of Harry Tate, George Robey and other well-known
favourites of the music-halls, the railway officials at the various
stations being made the butt of the jokes; with a weird medley of
harmony and melody, from "Hallo, hallo, who's your lady friend?" to
"Sun of my Soul," the journey passed happily enough until the first of
the Bristol stations was reached about 11.45 P.M.

As no one knew where the A.S.C. barracks were I got through on the
telephone to H.Q.

"This is Captain Estcourt, R.F.A., speaking.  I've got----"

The orderly evidently went to fetch someone else.  It turned out to be
an adjutant, who listened to me most politely.

"No, we've got no A.S.C. here.  I don't think there are any in Bristol.
But you might ring up ---- Barracks and see."  Prrr.

"Hallo!  Is that ---- Barracks?  I'm Captain----"

The orderly went to fetch someone.  This time, after a long wait, it
was evidently an irascible senior officer.

"No.  No A.S.C. here.  Try Avonmouth."  Prrr.

This looked like bedding down in the station waiting-rooms.  Still we
would try Avonmouth.

Avonmouth Headquarters received me over the telephone most politely,
considering the time of night.

"No, we've got no A.S.C. here; but you might ring up the Embarkation
Office."  Prrr.

"Hallo!  Embarkation Office?  I'm ----, etc."

The Embarkation Office was not quite so polite in its reception.  It
sounded very worried.

"No.  We've got no A.S.C. here.  You can come along down if you like in
case the company should turn up."

Luckily the last train had not gone.  When it drew up in the station
the men greeted it as a long-lost friend.  To the strains of "All
aboard for Dixie" they clambered in, more cheery than ever.

At Avonmouth we came out into a wilderness of mighty sheds.  The night
breeze from the Bristol Channel carried with it the pungent, cleanly
smell of tarred rope.

"This is Avonmouth," said I to the senior sergeant, "and we can't go
any farther unless a ship is waiting for us.  I'm going to see where we
can bed down."

The Embarkation Office had had time to recover from its worries and
received me very politely.

Eventually we got the men into one of the sheds where hundreds of sacks
of oats lay about.  In ten minutes they had made themselves amazingly
comfortable and peace reigned.

But I'm glad we went to Avonmouth.  It gave me my first real glimpse of
the astonishing organisation under which the Expeditionary Force was to
take the field; and also of the methods of supply.

Outside the dock gates, by all the approach roads into the little town,
there were streaming in hundreds upon hundreds of great motor lorries,
the majority of them built to carry three tons.

From all parts of England and Scotland dozens were arriving every hour.
The organisation of it!  Here was the third or fourth day from
mobilisation and there were a couple of thousand ready for
transportation.

You picture a vividly green lorry of a big whisky distillery up North
axle to axle with the scarlet of a Brixton firm with its blatant
advertisement of somebody's corsets.  The cockney driver from a London
furnishing house exchanged honeyed words with a colleague from "'twixt
Trent and Tweed" in a polite inquiry as to why the hell he couldn't let
his tail-board down without using his (the Londoner's) radiator to
scrape his boots on.

"Can't you imagine Tommy's comments when he finds a 'Johnny Walker' van
bringing up his ammunition in the wilds of Belgium," was the general
remark, "but I suppose they'll give them a coat of paint first."

They didn't, as a matter of fact; at least not for several months, so
that Tommy was able to indulge his gift of language to the full.

And so nearly two days passed.  The men amused themselves by wandering
about the docks, wondering at the shipping, and making sarcastic
remarks about the lorry drivers who were being taught how to handle a
rifle.

Then came a telegram from H.Q., Aldershot.

"Return and report here immediately."

"Good," said the senior sergeant to me, "I always did like Aldershot.
But we've had quite a pleasant holiday seeing the country."

The draft duly paraded again, and when they learned their next
destination their remarks were a joy to listen to.

We caught a 9.0 train in the evening into Bristol.  Then we marched
across the city, a matter of, say, three miles.  It was a Sunday night,
the good citizens were abed.  But my lads were determined to show that
they were by no means downhearted.

The march across was one long pageant of melody.  "I'm going home to
Dixie" was prime favourite, and splendidly they sang it in harmony.
Then some evening hymns, then more rag-time--they were really excellent
exponents of that difficult art--then "Onward, Christian Soldiers"; but
never a note of "Tipperary."  That immortal chorus had not yet
"arrived."

The midnight train from Bristol to Reading.  A wait of three hours.
Finally, Aldershot (the wrong station) at 6.30 A.M.  A march of four
miles into camp somewhat took the spirit out of the men, breakfastless
and carrying heavy kits.  But we rallied them at the last post and came
in singing "Somewhere the sun is shining," like a choir of Welsh
colliers.  We certainly looked the part.

"We've been looking for you for a week; where on earth have you been?"
was hurled at us as we marched in.

The bombardier started upon a story which would have made that intrepid
explorer Captain de Rougemont green with envy.  I left him to his
astonished audience and went off for a bath and shave before attending
my own funeral at H.Q.

It will have been observed that there were varying degrees in the
politeness with which successive H.Q.s greeted my touring company.  The
politeness with which Aldershot Headquarters now greeted me was well
below freezing-point.

"I received your telegrams from Portsmouth and various other places,"
was the Chief's opening.  "You appear to have been taking your men upon
an extended holiday round the southern coast health resorts.  May I
inquire, without appearing too inquisitive, your authority for this
expenditure of public money?"

"Will you allow me to explain, sir?"

"I am waiting for your explanation."

I began.  When I had recounted the story of the A.S.C. major's
arithmetical problem I saw that I had the Great Man's attention.  As
soon as I had caught the 5 P.M. train from Portsmouth----

"Sit down, won't you," said the Great Man; "cigarette?"

I took one from his proffered case and lit it carefully.

"If only I can hold him," thought I, "I shall pull through."

I did hold him, and I did pull through.

"I don't know that I can compliment you on your perspicacity," said the
Great Man, "but I can see now where the blame lies.  I had intended to
withdraw your name from the Expeditionary Force, but----"

I got up, mouth open.

"Expeditionary Force?"  It can only have been a feeble gasp which the
Great Man heard.  "Am I going out with the Force?"

The Great Man smiled and put his hand on my shoulder.

"We'll overlook it this time.  Let's see how well you can do your job.
And if you send in your claim for travelling expenses, send it to me
and I'll countersign it."

I suppose I must have said something by way of thanks.  I suppose I
must have saluted, and closed the door behind me.  I know that I
cleared half a dozen or so of the stairs down at a bound and fell over
an astonished sentry at the bottom.  It must have looked most
undignified in a Gunner captain, but--I had actually been selected to
join the British Expeditionary Force with a command of my own and----

I leaped into the waiting taxicab in a state of delirium.

The driver touched his cap.

"Where to, sir?" said he.

"Where to?  Where to?  Oh!  Brussels; anywhere."

The driver grinned in sympathetic understanding and got on to third
speed in as many seconds.


And that is how I very nearly missed the most gorgeous adventure of my
life.




CHAPTER II

THE SAILING OF THE FORCE

        _Follow, follow!
  Grapple your minds to sternage of this navy;
  And leave your England as dead midnight still.
      *      *      *      *      *
  For who is he, whose chin is but enrich'd
  With one appearing hair, that will not follow
  These cull'd and choice-drawn cavaliers to France?_

"_I consider that I have command of the sea when I am able to tell my
Government that they can move an expedition to any point without fear
of interference from an enemy's fleet._"--SIR GEOFFREY HORNBY.


Train No. B46 had slipped unostentatiously into its appointed siding
precisely on its scheduled time.  For a couple of hours the men had
been working like galley-slaves to get the ammunition on board in time.
The C.O. and two other officers with their coats off were working as
hard as the rest.  And it is no joke heaving up and packing neatly
cases of 18-pr. and howitzer shell, especially when you are not used to
it.

Finished at last, and with half an hour to the good.  Another four
hours and they will be on the road themselves, the first step into the
unknown.

A couple of hours' sleep, a shave and a bath, a final look round the
battery office, a last hurried breakfast in the Mess, and a last
handshake with the colonel.

"You off?  Well, good-bye, and good luck to you.  We shall meet over
the other side, I expect."

The battery parades.  "Battery all present, sir," reports the
sergeant-major.  The report runs through until it reaches the C.O.  A
few minutes to ride round the teams and then:

"Column o' route from the right.  Walk--march!" and the battery is off
through the early morning quiet of the Aldershot streets, bound for the
port of embarkation.

Thus the mounted units, or most of them.  Others by train.  A few lines
will serve as description for all these.

A Railway Transport Officer meets the C.O. on the platform as the men
march in.

"Get your men in as quickly as you can, please; we always get off five
minutes ahead of time."

"What's our port?" asks the C.O.

"No idea.  Push on, please."

The C.O. "pushes on."

"All in," he reports to the R.T.O., and turns for a final shake of the
hand.

"Well, good-bye, and good luck" (always that phrase); "wish I was
coming with you."

The R.T.O. gives the signal and looks wistfully for a moment after the
train before he clambers across the metals to dispatch another dozen or
so units from other sidings.

"Where are we embarking?" asks everyone.  Not a soul knows.  I don't
believe the engine-driver himself knew.  He just went gaily forward
following the points or stopping for signals.

"Through Winchester!  Why, it must be Southampton.  Wonder what our
port will be the other side?"


Detraining and embarkation at Southampton were carried out under the
same admirable conditions of efficiency and speed, and with never a
single hitch.  It seems little enough to read the sentence in cold
print, but the more one thinks about it the more wonderful appears the
organisation.  Had it been the German War Staff directing movements the
affair would have seemed no more than an ordinary episode.  But with
memories of the South African War, and a hundred everyday incidents
constantly revealing muddling, red-tape methods, one can find no words
in which to express adequately one's admiration for this astonishing
volte-face.  One single incident, one of fifty like it, will show to
what excellent purpose the Authorities had profited by experience, even
in those early days.

An A.S.C. motor transport unit was detailed to embark upon a certain
ship.  Nearly a day's warning had been given to the O.C.  The lorries
were driven to the dock-side and were just being got on board.  The
Embarkation Officer, who was standing quietly by, suddenly informed the
C.O. that his ship was not that one but another due to sail from
another dock some distance away.

The C.O. had barely time in which to get his lorries across, and the
ship sailed the moment all was reported clear.

An incident trivial enough, and how un-English it seemed at the time.
But after the secret landing of the 9th Army Corps at Suvla, and the
subsequent evacuation of Gallipoli, it would appear that we have
nothing to learn in the art of ruse.

The weather in those early days of August was perfect: the sea so calm
that there was no discomfort even, with the men and horses packed on
board like sardines in a tin.  If it was a night crossing, the men
bedded down in rows out on the decks just as they had filed on board.
The transports were of all kinds, from an Atlantic liner to a coasting
tramp.

The ship's officers did more than their best for everybody's comfort,
giving up their cabins to the officers, sharing their meals and
refusing to accept any payment for food and drinks.  If the skipper of
a certain ship of the Royal Mail Company, which sailed on the early
morning of August 16th from Southampton, chances to see these lines I
would tell him how gratefully his kindness is remembered, and how the
little mascot, in the shape of a tiny teapot from the steward's pantry,
brought the best of luck through ten months' hard service, always made
excellent tea whenever called upon, and now occupies a place of honour
in my china cabinet.  Here's wishing everything of the best to those
who carry on the fine traditions of the blue or red ensign!

"Well, where are we bound for?"  This to the First Officer.

"Don't know a bit," he replies.  "The skipper may know, but I'm not
sure.  Anyway he's as close as a barnacle about it."

We steamed across Channel with all lights on.  It was another of those
astonishing facts which didn't strike one until later.  We were off the
mouth of the Seine exactly twelve hours after sailing.  And all that
time we only once sighted anything in the shape of a convoy, and that
was a T.B.D. for about twenty minutes a couple of miles to starboard.

At this stage it seems almost invidious to say anything more about the
work of the Grand Fleet during that first fortnight.  And yet, even
now, the public is amazingly ignorant of what the Navy has
accomplished, or, indeed is still accomplishing.  Ignorant, not through
indifference, but because the Authorities still steadily refuse to take
seriously in hand the work of education in war facts and ideas.

How the Navy succeeded in sweeping the enemy flag from the North Sea
and the Channel in a couple of days, apparently without firing a shot,
we cannot pretend to guess.  Some day the story will be told.  But the
result was the most astonishing manifestation of the real meaning of
naval supremacy that the world has ever seen, or is ever likely to see.
And Germany, by her naval inaction, lost for ever her great chance of
the War, and so, in failing to intercept or damage the British
Expeditionary Force, failed also to enter Paris and to end the war upon
her own terms within the period she had intended.  The British Army may
have saved Paris, but the British Navy enabled it to do so.

Entering the Seine the skipper revealed the name of our destination,
Rouen.  Another instance of organisation and forethought on the part of
the Authorities in using small ships so as to get right up the river
and disembark troops and stores well inland.

Again, this has become a matter of everyday routine, but in those days
each such new manoeuvre was sufficiently remarkable for admiring
comment.

Here the pilot came on board.  A typical old son of Normandy he was,
grizzled and weatherbeaten, clambering aboard with stiff heavy gait.

On to the bridge he climbed: saw our lads clustered thick as bees in
the fo'c'sle and lower deck.  Up went his cap into the air, tears
sprang to his eyes.

"Vivent les Anglais!" he shouted, "vive l'Angleterre!  A--ah" (with an
instinct of triumph), "ça va bien.  Ils arrivent."

How the lads yelled in answer.

"Cheer-o, moossoo.  Veeve France!  'Who's your lady friend?'  'For he's
a jolly good fellow,'"--and other pertinent observations.

Then, to my astonishment, they burst into the "Marseillaise."  How and
where they had learned it I have no idea.  But sing it they did, and
very well too.  They took that little curly bit in the middle, where a
B flat comes when you least expect it, just like an old hunter clearing
a stiff post-and-rails.  And that old chap stood on the bridge and
mopped his eyes, and didn't care who saw him do it.  The English had
really come to stand by his beloved France.  _Comme ça va bien!_

That was the first hint we had of the reception which awaited us.

You picture the transport steaming slowly up river between the high,
wooded banks.  Little houses, such as Peter Pan might have built for
Wendy, seem to sway dizzily in the tree-tops.  Out on to the verandas,
down to the river path run the women and children, and the few old men
who remain.  Everyone carries a little flag; not the French tricolour,
but the British Jack--or rather an excellent substitute.

Dimly one can see the waving hands, faintly across the water echo the
treble voices.  But know now what it means, and gallantly our lads
respond to this welcome of our future hosts, who, with true French
courtesy, have met their guests at the very entrance gates.

Far up the hill-side, close under the ridge, there nestles a tiny
cottage.  A blot of deep crimson staining the deeper green of the trees
makes me take out my binoculars.  The good house-wife, with no British
flag available, yet determined to do honour to her country's allies,
has taken the red tablecloth, has stitched long bands of white across
it to form a St. Andrew's Cross, and flung it proudly across the
balustrade.  What monarch ever had truer-hearted welcome from his own
people?  Well, the sight brought a lump to the throat of at least one
Englishman.

And so slowly we steamed up the historic river.  France had indeed
flung wide her gates in welcome.  Here we found ourselves moving in a
small procession of transports.  Greetings swung across from one ship
to the next, to combine and roar out a British answer to our French
friends on shore.

Ah! but it was good to feel that Britain had not failed France, though
the obligation were no more than a moral one.  It was good to be an
Englishman that day; good to feel that Englishmen then in France could
now look Frenchmen squarely in the face and say:

"You thought we were going to stand aside, didn't you?  Well, you see
we are coming in with you and you can bet that means that we intend to
see it through."

Yes, one felt proud as never before.




CHAPTER III

THE LANDING OF THE FORCE

"_Shall not thou and I, between Saint Dennis and Saint George, compound
a boy, half French, half English, that shall go to Constantinople, and
take the Turk by the beard?_"


The dominant note in the reception which the French gave to the Force
on landing was undoubtedly that of _relief_.  Happy in showering little
courtesies, surprised and delighted with everything British--all these,
but it was relief which came uppermost in their minds.  The feeling
which the old pilot had expressed in his "comme ça va bien, maintenant."

And as transport after transport slid quietly to her berth alongside
the broad Rouen quays, discharged her freight of men, horses, guns,
stores, lorries, and the countless trappings of a modern army, and then
as quickly and noiselessly vacated the berth for her successor, so
increased the wonder and delight of the good Normandy folk.

That _les anglais_ should really have arrived was splendid enough, but
that they should also bring with them their own food and cooking
arrangements--"mais c'est tonnant! et quelle organisation!"

Everyone spoke in admiring comment about it.  And how Rouen crowded
down to the quays or out to the rest camps to watch _les anglais_
cooking their dinners!  Army stores those few days were sadly depleted
of tins of jam, biscuits and "grocery ration."  How could one refuse
the hungry look in the eye of a motherly matron as she espied a packet
of the famous English tea?

And the children!  We learned for the first time how hungry children
could be when they saw biscuits and jam.

Make a fuss of the kiddies and you have won the mothers!  And if you
have won the mothers and women of France you have conquered "la belle
France" herself.  And _les anglais_ conquered France in those few days
at the French ports.  The happiest of victories, and one which augured
well for the future.

Nothing pleased the French more than British courtesy and gentleness to
women and children; and their kindness to and care of their horses.
British love of personal cleanliness, and the unfailing cheeriness of
the men, these have, of course, long since become proverbial.  But then
it was all new to France, almost to the world, and so one records these
things as first impressions.

And the Scotties.  Everyone knows how the lads from north of the Tweed
made sad havoc among French hearts.  Have they not always done so since
Frenchmen and Scotsmen first clasped hands in alliance?

If a Scotsman was asked once a day whether he wore anything under his
kilt he was asked a hundred times.  And truth compels me to add that it
was generally the ladies who put the question.  What the answer was I
never found out.  I imagine that our lads were not sorry to hide their
blushes in the troop trains which carried them forward to the frontier.

But all these little details have been so admirably recorded by Philip
Gibbs in his masterly book, "The Soul of the War," that there is really
not much more to tell.  I shall have still a little to add in the next
chapter, when it comes to trekking up country.

I had some little cause on the first day of landing to regret the
exuberance of French hospitality.  Half my men, they were mostly
Special Reservists, suddenly disappeared into the unknown directly they
set foot on shore.  And they hadn't a week's pay in their pockets
either.

Eventually I got them rounded up and next morning there were
twenty-five prisoners, "caps off," for "office."  To say they were
surprised is to give a very poor indication of their feelings when they
found varying degrees of punishment awarded to them.

But this was nothing to the ludicrous expressions of the men when all
the remainder were paraded and informed what they had to expect on
active service.  It ran somewhat as follows:

  "When a sentry, sleeping upon his post."
    Punishment--DEATH.
  "Leaving his C.O. to go in search of
    plunder."  Punishment--DEATH.
  "Forcing a safeguard."--DEATH.
  "Quitting his guard without leave."--DEATH.
  "Disobeying the lawful command of his
    superior officer."--DEATH.

And so on, the lightest punishment being about fourteen years' Rigorous
Imprisonment.

Their faces got longer and longer as the list proceeded, and it was a
very meek detachment who turned to their dinners on the quay-side.  And
that was the beginning and end of any trouble with those good lads
until the day when they, or the poor remnant who pulled through,
crowded round to sing "Auld lang syne" and give me a farewell cheer.
Fine work they did, and always as cheery and lovable as any unit in the
Force.

Disembarkation was carried on with the same admirable efficiency which
had characterised embarkation.  A large number of British Staff
officers had, I believe, crossed to France immediately upon
mobilisation.  There, in collaboration with French colleagues, every
possible arrangement was made for the reception of the Force.

Rest camps were pitched or billets were allotted, branches of the Army
Post Office were established, a field cashier was installed at the
Banque de France and imprests in French notes for the men's pay could
be obtained on demand.

Of course everybody had seized the few hours' holiday on board ship to
write more or less lengthy letters home, hoping, in their innocence,
that the ship's officers would post them on returning to England.

Alas! before ever the ship was berthed, an all-powerful bogy swarmed up
the companion way and greedily snatched away the ship's correspondence.
Calling for a brush and a barrel of black fluid, he gleefully set to
work upon the letters and postcards.  When he had finished with them
(and it took him a good couple of hours on our ship) they looked like
the slips of paper you use in the parlour round-game where the first
player writes a line and leaves the next to continue the sentence.

We had all given the most vivid description of our adventures, filling
page after page.  When the precious documents ultimately reached their
destination, our fond parents, or best girls, must have been gratified
to find that their four-page letter had dwindled down to:


"MY DEAR FATHER,--

(Four pages of brush and fluid work.)

"Well, I think I have told you all the news now.  My love to the Mater
and, cheer-oh, we shall soon be home again.

"Your affect. son,
    "----"


It was very interesting to compare the way in which French and British
temperaments expressed themselves; intensely interesting to note how
each so quickly became the complement of the other.

One knew so well the attitude of disdain of anything foreign which
invariably characterises the Briton abroad; an unfortunate attitude
which has been encouraged, or so it would almost seem, by the
invariable courtesy, under the most irritating conditions, of men and
women of the Latin races.

Here were some seventy or eighty thousand men thrust headlong into a
strange country.  Probably at least two-thirds of that number had never
been out of England before.  Everyone knows the impression which your
average Englishman of the middle and lower classes has of French men
and French women.  Certainly it has not been very complimentary.  How
would our men now bear themselves?

And if our attitude to the French has for the most part been one of
cold disdain and amusement, the French would seem to have regarded us,
as a race, with incredulity, tempered by such a degree of irritation as
their native courtesy would permit.  This, together with an under
current of admiration.

"_Que j'aime la hardiesse anglaise!_" says Voltaire, "_que j'aime les
gens qui disent ce qu'ils pensent._"

During those early August days before the Retreat there was little real
opportunity to modify racial opinions.  But if British disdain was not
yet effaced, the overwhelming reception by the French went far to break
it down.  Soon it was to be washed clean away in the blood sacrament
which united French and English in a closer tie than that of
brothers-in-arms.

French methods and customs still amused our men, but the amusement
became that light-hearted gaiety, in tackling and surmounting trifling
difficulties in a foreign country, which is quite irresistible.  Here
the British soldier or sailor is always at his very best, and the
anecdotes of his adventures in French villages and towns would fill a
volume.

Wiseacres who try to invent some universal language should certainly
base it upon that of Thomas A. in a strange country.  He is equally at
home in China, Peru, the wilds of Africa or Spain.

The fact which astonished him more than anything else about the French
language was that all the children spoke it.  He could understand
grown-ups learning it in time; but how the kiddies were able to talk it
with such amazing fluency, that was quite beyond him.

As for the French attitude of mind, I am inclined to think that their
incredulity, admiration and irritation were all intensified; the last
named, however, being even less in evidence than before.

The attitude of the French women is easier to define.  It is literally
true to remark that, from highest to lowest in the land, there were no
half measures in their welcome.  One can say this now because the fact
has long since been recognised and openly discussed in France.  This,
however, is not the place in which to make more than passing reference
to a subject which, apart from the purely human aspect, is more a
matter for the student of physiology or psychology.

"Combien de coeurs vous avez ravagé dans un si petit délai que vous
avez stationné ici," a French girl once remarked, "et cependant on ne
devrait pas refuser aux anglais les baisers qu'ils nous demandent
puisqu'ils se donnent pour nous."

And the last half of the sentence admirably sums up the French woman's
point of view.

This landing of the portion of the Force at Rouen was typical of what
happened at Boulogne or Havre.  John Buchan, in his first volume of the
"History of the War," has given a most interesting glimpse of incidents
at the former port.

In no case did the troops remain at these bases for more than a couple
of days.  Nobody appeared to have the least idea of what was going on
up at the frontiers, but time was obviously of importance.

No one knew where they were bound for; no one appeared to have the
slightest presentiment of the tragedy, and the magnificence of the days
which were so soon to crowd upon them.  Still the cheery,
light-hearted, end-of-term spirit.  A summer holiday on the Continong!
Cheer-oh!

And so they were merry parties of men which boarded the funny French
trains; where you had to clamber up the sides of the carriages from
platforms which didn't really exist, and where you were packed in like
a Cup Tie crowd returning from the Crystal Palace.

How the horses hated those French trucks.  Never before had they
suffered such indignity.  I would not have been a stableman on duty in
one of those trucks for many a month's pay.

"Mais, quelles bêtes!" said the railway officials.  And the porters
would run and fetch the stationmaster and gesticulate at the
Compagnie's trucks, which had begun to look like bundles of firewood
long before the frontier was reached.

"Third return Clapham Junction, please," said the company wag.

"Wotto!  Berlin!  Not 'arf," shouted the rest....

And off the trains would steam, every compartment labelled "Berlin."
It's rather pathetic how history repeats itself.  This time the French
were silent.  They _knew_.

So, forward into the unknown!




CHAPTER IV

UP COUNTRY

  _So be there 'twixt your kingdoms such a spousal,
  That never may ill office, or fell jealousy,
      *      *      *      *      *
  Thrust in between the paction of these kingdoms,
  To make divorce of their incorporate league:
  That English may as French, French Englishmen,
  Receive each other!_


Patience, still a little patience!  The stage is not yet set.  The
actors have not yet reached the theatre.  Very soon now shall you see
unfolded the opening scenes of the Great Drama, and hear the first
clash of the armies.  Soon shall you have your fill of the horror and
splendour of modern warfare.

We have seen the Force into the French troop trains, horse, guns and
foot.  But not all journeyed thus to the frontier.  Some of the units,
the most mobile, went by road.  Units which were intended to take their
places in the reserve lines, and especially the A.S.C. motor transport,
ammunition or supplies.  Let us move forward with one of these and see
a little of the France through which so soon the armies will come
rolling back.

Out from Rouen and across the lovely Normandy country.  You picture the
excitement and amusement of the country folk as a great procession of
those motor lorries, which we have seen coming into Avonmouth, pants
heavily through the towns and villages.

Here is a part of a letter, from an officer in one of those units,
which appeared in the _Times_ towards the end of August.  It seems to
give a very happy picture of the French reception of our men.


ROSES, ROSES, ALL THE WAY

I can, of course, tell you nothing of our movements, nor where we are.
I can, however, say something of the reception we have met with moving
across country.  It has been simply wonderful and most affecting.  We
travel entirely by motor transport (if the censor will allow that), and
it has been flowers all the way.  One long procession of acclamation.
By the wayside and through the villages men, women, and children cheer
us on with the greatest enthusiasm, and everyone wants to give us
something.  Even the babies in arms have been taught to wave their
little hands.

They strip their flower gardens, and the cars look like carnival
carriages.  They pelt us with fruit, cigarettes, chocolate, bread,
anything, and everything.  It is simply impossible to convey an
impression of it all.  One village had stretched across the road a big
banner, "Honour to the British Army."  Always cries of "Vivent les
anglais, vive l'Angleterre," etc., and often they would make the sign
of hanging, and cutting the throat (the Kaiser), pointing forward along
the road.  This always struck me as so curious.

Yesterday, my own car had to stop in a town for petrol.  In a moment
there must have been a couple of hundred people round, clamouring.
Autograph albums were thrust in front of me; a perfect delirium.  A
tray of wine and biscuits appeared, and before we started again the car
had come to look like a grocery delivery van with a florist's window
display in front.

In another town I had to stop for an hour and took the opportunity to
do some shopping.  I wanted some motor goggles, an eye bath, some
boracic, provisions, etc.  They would not let me pay for a single
thing, and there was lunch and drinks as well.

The farther we go the more enthusiastic is the greeting.  What it will
be like at the end of the war one cannot attempt to guess.

This all sounds like a picnic, but the work is hard and continuous.
One eats and sleeps just when one can.  There is no division between
night and day.  But we are all very fit and well, and the men, who have
an easy time compared to the officers, look upon it as a huge joke--at
present.

My French is, of course, simply invaluable, and each day I can
understand and talk better and better.  It is extraordinary that I am
absolutely the only officer I have come across (except one or two Staff
men) who can speak it with any fluency.  Well, this will surely be the
last of war amongst civilised peoples, and the dreams of the idealists
will be fulfilled.  The French seem to think that it will all be over
certainly by Christmas.  I wonder?


Thus the men came to see something of French life away from the beaten
track of the tourist, and, needless to say, they made friends at every
stopping-place.

"Mais, si polis, ces messieurs anglais," everyone remarks.  And how
could "ces messieurs" refuse some little trifles in return for such
hospitality?  The word "souvenir" soon became a nightmare in their
dreams.  There was a peculiar bleat in the intonation of the word which
was, after a time, positively hateful.  But during the first few days
the men gave readily enough all sorts of little articles for which they
had no immediate use, and others for which they had.

Before a week had elapsed very few had any buttons left.  It was a
mystery how they kept their trousers up.  Regimental badges on caps and
shoulder-straps were much appreciated, especially the Gunners' letters.
It did not take long for the quick-witted French girl to discover that
R.F.A. was obviously intended to represent the Triple Entente--Russie,
France, Angleterre.

When these units eventually rolled up at their destination it was found
that about half the men had lost not only all their buttons and badges
but their caps as well, getting in exchange some horrible provincial
product in the shape of a rakish tweed cap.  Bits of tape and string
held coats and trousers together.

But long ere this Thomas Atkins was fed up with souvenir-hunters, and
one recalls a _Punch_ picture which showed a weary and wounded soldier
sitting by the roadside with what remained of his kit and arms.

"'Souvenir' is it you want?" he remarks in reply to a little urchin who
is bleating the hateful word at him.  "Here, you can take the ----
lot."  And he pitches his rifle and kit at the youngster's head.

The officers and men who came up by road must have had a very cheery
time in the various towns where they were billeted.  The route lay, I
believe, by way of Amiens, and so up through St. Quentin and Bohain to
Le Cateau.

Hardly was there a hint of war in all that lovely country-side.  What
war could ever touch those glowing cornfields, those orchards heavy
with plum and apple, the stately châteaux or dim cloisters of mediæval
church or convent?  As little can we conceive our fragrant villages of
Kent or Surrey blasted and devastated by poisonous shells.

Very, very few men were to be seen anywhere; only Government officials
and others over military age.  Such guards or sentries as were posted
were somewhat decrepit-looking Territorials, with arms and
accoutrements which looked as if they had done good service in 1870.
But they made up for their deficiencies in other respects by an excess
of zeal in carrying out imaginary orders.

Their method of challenging, in particular, had the merit of simplicity
and, at the same time, involved no undue straining of the vocal powers.
It was merely the thrusting of a rifle-barrel into the face or chest of
the passer-by.  And when there is a very shaky hand on the trigger you
don't lose much time in getting out your credentials.

One of these men caused much excitement one evening by holding up and
clapping into the guardroom every single individual who attempted to
pass him.  He was performing sentry duty across a certain main road.

This went on for a couple of hours, and the guardroom was becoming
uncomfortably crowded with a very miscellaneous assortment of
travellers.  In fact, when a particularly plump matron, carrying a
basket of particularly evil-smelling cheeses, was incontinently thrust
in, to fall heavily across the toes of an already irate railway porter,
there was very nearly a riot.

At length a gilded Staff officer came along.  He too was held up.  But
this time the sentry met his match.  The officer demanded to see the
N.C.O. of the guard.  Whereupon the sentry, who was really somewhat the
worse for drink, fell down upon his knees in the road, and with salty
tears coursing down his cheeks piteously besought the officer to allow
him to go home and get his supper.

But French Territorials did their "bit" gallantly enough a few days
later, away on the British left.  Old reservists as they were, they
hung on splendidly at Tournai, and, led by de Villaret, fought
gallantly against overwhelming numbers until they were surrounded,
killed, or captured.

So, on through the golden August sunshine or beneath the heavy harvest
moon.  Interminable processions of columns, horsed and petrol-driven,
threading their way along the endless, poplar-lined roads of France;
the white dust churned up and drifting over men and vehicles until they
look like Arctic adventurers.

No one knows what is happening in the great "beyond."  No one very much
cares.  "Let's get on and have it over," is the philosophy of the hour.
"Expect those Germans are being held up a bit in Belgium; wonder where
we shall come in?"

The enemy had marched in triumph through Brussels on August 20th.  The
British Force was not actually in position until two days later: and
Brussels is only 30 odd miles from Mons.

After it was all over; after the tide of war had crashed forward almost
to the gates of Paris and then rolled sullenly back, one saw a little
of the devastation it had left behind.  Here are two pictures.

      *      *      *      *      *

_August_ 20_th_.  Can you, too, see that little vicarage hard by the
tiny church?  (Think, it might have been plucked from a Surrey hamlet.)
The cool, veranda-shaded rooms filled with a hundred homely treasures;
the tiled kitchen with its winking copper pots and pans.  Out through
the flagged yard, where pigeons coo in gentle defiance of predatory
sparrows, and down to a miniature farmstead.  The pretty alleyed garden
of roses, hollyhocks and the flowers and sweet herbs of English
garden-lovers.

Can you see the old curé as he browses over a volume of Renan?  He has
tended his flock in that village for a quarter of a century.  A pretty
niece keeps house for him; and her dainty herb-potions and unwearied
nursing have saved many a life in the little community.  They think of
her as of an angel from heaven.


_September_ 7_th_.  A fortnight later!  The village street has
disappeared beneath the debris of what was once the village.  One
cow-shed is still miraculously intact, and from it creeps a gaunt,
haggard old crone.  They have not touched her.  She was too old and
infirm to make good fun, even for the rank and file.

She points with shaking finger to the wayside crucifix from which the
Christ looks down with infinite patience.  He also has been
miraculously preserved.  He gazes still over His tiny sanctuary, now
but two blackened, battered walls.  The vicarage has disappeared as
though in an earthquake.  The incendiary tablets have done their work
well.  The little garden with its pretty rose trees has been ploughed
up, it would seem, by giant shares.

Stay, in one corner, down by the brook, there is planted a rough wooden
cross.

The old curé had refused to leave his post when the stream of refugees
had passed through.  They told him of the horror behind them.  He stood
firm.  Jeannette, too, would stay with her uncle.

_They_ came.  The curé, they said, must be a spy left behind by the
French troops.  Besides, he had carrier-pigeons.  "What need have we of
further witnesses?"

And so they tied him against the stem of his pigeon-cote.  He met his
death as a gallant gentleman of France.

The girl.  Ah, young and tender!  Good sport for the plucking!  First
let her bury the old man.  "Rather hard work using a spade when you're
not used to it, isn't it?--Done?  Good, now get us dinner."

After dinner, a dance--Eastern slave fashion.  First, good sport for
the officers.  "When we have finished throw her to the men."

What need to tell the horrors of it?  The village marked the ebb of the
tide.  The French and British had turned at last.  Hurried orders came
to retire at dawn.  The girl had not been such good sport after
all--fainted too easily.

A leering, drunken satyr slashes at her naked breasts with his bayonet
and Jeannette falls dead over the threshold.  The house is fired, the
body is pitched on to the pyre.

One village in France?  No, one of a hundred where such things were
done.  And this is almost as nothing beside such as this England of
ours has, by God's gracious mercy, been spared.  What does England know
of this war?

      *      *      *      *      *

Now the various units begin to converge and concentrate on the French
frontier.  "Each unit," says the G.O.C.-in-Chief in his first dispatch,
"arrived at its destination in this country well within the scheduled
time."

For some days past the French troop trains have been disgorging their
living freight at a number of stations and sidings, most of them
hastily improvised, within a few miles' radius on a line
Valenciennes-Maubeuge.

The columns which came by road halted in various little villages about
the town of Le Cateau.  You will get the general lie of the land and
the principal points of interest from the picture-map.

Now to set the stage.




CHAPTER V

THE MARSHALLING OF THE ARMIES

  _Now entertain conjecture of a time,
  When creeping murmur, and the poring dark,
  Fills the wide vessel of the universe.
  From camp to camp, through the foul womb of night,
  The hum of either army stilly sounds,_
      *      *      *      *      *
          _..... and from the tents,
  The armourers, accomplishing the knights,
  With busy hammers closing rivets up,
  Give dreadful note of preparation._


A well-known American, it was probably Roosevelt, remarked à propos of
the outbreak of the War that Germany's readiness would redound to her
eternal dishonour, while Britain's unreadiness would be to her eternal
honour.

The term "unready" applies to the nation as a whole.  Fortunately for
civilisation the British Navy and the little striking Force were, as we
have seen, kept trained to an hour.  And so it was that, upon a single
word, the whole machine moved precisely as the admirable organisation
had planned for it.

It must also be remembered that for some years past everybody who had
studied international affairs with any intelligence knew precisely how
and where Germany would attack; that even in 1908 it was possible to
give the approximate date of such attack; and that when the attack came
the position of the British Expeditionary Force would be in the post of
honour upon the left of the French line in, approximately, the district
in which it actually deployed.

Thus, up to a certain point, events fell out as anticipated.  But one
or two big factors were not foreseen, or, at least, not sufficiently
appreciated.  These were the amazing speed and mobility with which the
German initial attack was destined to develop; the overwhelming numbers
of the enemy; and, lastly, the astonishing effect of big gun fire, as
instanced at Liége and other fortresses.  This lack of foresight came
within an ace of losing the war for the Entente Powers.

It was not until Saturday, August 15th, that the gates into Belgium by
way of Liége were fully opened for the German armies, although Liége
itself had been entered on the 7th.

The immediate effect, apart from the great moral value, of Belgium's
heroic and successful resistance of those two or three days was to give
to the British Force at least a sporting chance.  The Force was late;
those three days allowed it to get into position.  It needs no great
effort to imagine what would otherwise inevitably have happened.

Now let me at this point disclaim any intention of giving details of
strategy and tactics, even were I sufficiently competent to do so.  So
far as I can I shall try to tell the story as simply as possible,
omitting everything which may tend to confusion or which may render
necessary continuous reference to maps.  In a word, I am making this
record of facts and impressions for the public, not for the experts.
It is the human side and not the military which I would emphasise.

It is, however, necessary at the outset to get a good general idea of
numbers, and the disposition of the armies on August 22nd in the
particular area, if we wish fully to appreciate the events, and their
significance, of the succeeding ten days.  For the sake of convenience
I will make sub-headings:


_The German Forces_

The total strength, all ranks, of a German _Army Corps_ is, roughly,
45,000; of a _Division_, roughly, 17,500.  We may take this as a
minimum.

Each Corps and each Division has, respectively, about 160 and 72
field-guns, and 48 and 24 machine-guns.  The numbers of the latter arm
were materially increased during 1913-14.

The German forces which concentrated on this far Western front, from
Namur to about Tournai, consisted of no fewer than 13 Army Corps, _each
Corps being augmented by an extra Division_.  These Reserve Divisions
were, I believe, combined into separate "Reserve Corps."

The Corps were divided up:--

  5 under von Kluck (First German Army),
    attacking British.
  4 under von Buelow (Second German
    Army), attacking 5th French Army.
  4 under von Hausen (Third German
    Army), attacking 4th French Army.


The general lines of advance will be seen in plan A (page 71) and plan
B (page 98).

Thus, the total German force concentrated on or about this immediate
front must have numbered at least 812,500, with, say, 3,010 field-guns
and 936 machine-guns.

It is not unreasonable to add to this total the not inconsiderable
number of cavalry which operated, more or less independently, on the
extreme flanks, and particularly from Tournai down through Amiens
towards Le Havre.


_The French Forces_

The total strength, all ranks, of a French Army Corps is, roughly,
40,000, with, say, 160 field- and 48 machine-guns.

In this area there were present 3 corps under Lanrezac (5th French
Army) holding the line Charleroi-Namur, and 3 corps under de Langle de
Gary (4th French Army) holding a line west of the River Meuse
south-west from Namur.

Away on the left flank of the British was another Corps, of
Territorials, under d'Amade; and near Maubeuge, in reserve, were two or
three Cavalry Divisions.  These last did not, I believe, operate; and
the Territorials were also fully occupied in their own area.

Reckoning up, then, we get an approximate total of, say, 240,000 men,
960 field- and 288 machine-guns.


_The British Forces_

A British Army Corps, of two Divisions, contains about 36,145, all
ranks, with 152 field- and 48 machine-guns.

A Cavalry Division contains about 9,270, all ranks, with 24 field- and
24 machine-guns; a Cavalry Brigade about 2,285, all ranks, 6 field- and
6 machine-guns.

This is not revealing State secrets, because the numbers may be
obtained from any military reference books.

Now it was, I believe, originally intended that the Expeditionary Force
should be about 120,000 strong, or half the strength of the army with
the colours.

The force actually present at Mons on August 22nd consisted, nominally,
of two Army Corps, a Cavalry Division and a Cavalry Brigade.  But
several authorities, including Mr. Hilaire Belloc, assert that one of
these corps was considerably below strength, and that, in round
numbers, the strength of the Force was no more than 75,000, with 250
guns.

If we calculate up the _official_ strength the numbers should work out
at 83,845 all ranks, 334 field- and 126 machine-guns.

Another Infantry Brigade came up on the 23rd and joined the Second
Corps, and another Division (the 4th) also arrived.[1]

Taking everything into account it is, I think, reasonable to put the
British strength at about 80,000 men, 300 field- and 100 machine-guns
when battle was first joined.

Let me put these figures in tabular form so that we can get a
comparison at a glance.

                                                _Machine-_
                  _All ranks.    Field-guns.      guns._

  _Actual Approximate Numbers on August_ 22_nd_

  _British_ . . .    80,000          300           100
  _French_  . . .   240,000          960           288
  _German_  . . .   812,500        3,016           936

  _Excess German
  strength over
  Franco-British_  492,500        1,756            548


It is always rather difficult to grasp the _meaning_ of big numbers
like these, so let me put it another way.

Place one German against each man in the Franco-British Force, and one
German field-gun against each field-gun on our side.  Now take all the
German soldiers and guns still remaining over and imagine that you are
watching them march past you down Whitehall, the men in fours all doing
their "goose" parade step and the guns going by at a trot.

The army, marching night and day, without a moment's halt, would take
just about three days to pass you.

Such then was the enemy superiority; about four or five times as great
as the most pessimistic prophets had anticipated.  We shall see shortly
what this superiority developed into against the British Force.


_The Position of the Forces_

British.--The general position of the opposing forces before battle was
joined, at least for the British, will be realised from plan A (page
71), and there is little need to add anything by way of explanation.

It will be noted that the British line extended along a front of about
25 miles, with Mons near the centre of the line.  On Saturday, August
22nd, Sir John French disposed the Force into its positions.  The
Second Corps, under Sir Horace Smith-Dorrien, held the canal line from
Condé, on the west, to Mons, on the east.  The First Corps, under Sir
Douglas Haig, extended from Mons, on the west, to Binche, on the east.

As there were no British reserves, the Cavalry Division, under General
Allenby, was detailed to act as such and to be ready to move forward
where and as required.

The 5th Cavalry Brigade, under Sir Philip Chetwode, was posted in and
around Binche.

French.--I have indicated the composition of the French force, and plan
A (page 71) will show how it was disposed on the morning of the 22nd;
i.e. 5th French Army from Charleroi to just south of Namur, and 4th
Army down the River Meuse to south of Dinant.

Similarly, there is nothing further to add about the German
dispositions if the general lines of the enemy advance be noted: an
attempted out-flanking movement on the extreme west, and the driving in
of a wedge in the neighbourhood of Namur.  These, together with heavy
frontal attacks.


In all that follows it is necessary to add in, by way of reinforcements
on the German side, the very great moral encouragement which the enemy
had received by their triumphal passage through Belgium.  They were in
overwhelming strength; their heavy guns had crushed the fortresses in a
few hours like so many egg-shells; they had, for many a long year,
believed themselves invincible as against the world; and now they were
marching directly upon Paris with the confident hope that within three
months France would have ceased to exist as a nation, and that by the
end of the year the war would be finished, with terms of peace dictated
by their all-highest and supremely-powerful deity, the Kaiser.

It was, too, not merely an army disciplined and trained in the minutest
details of war which was thus bludgeoning forward into France; it was,
in effect, a nation in arms.  A nation which, for many a long year
past, had been educated to regard war as the greatest of all earthly
things---a supreme issue to which all the sciences and arts of the
preliminary years of peace were to be directed.

It was a nation which regarded as fully legitimate any means whatever
to the supreme end desired.

I recall a remark made to me during the South African War by a Prussian
naval officer.

"You English," he said, "do not know the rudiments of war.  When the
day comes for us to go to war you shall see how we deal with the men,
women and children.  With us terror is our greatest weapon."

To-day the world knows how that weapon has been mercilessly wielded;
and how impotent it has been.

On her side Britain was equally united, but in a different sense.  She
had taken up the gauntlet because her people were assured that the
cause was a just one.  In those early days the Expeditionary Force was
not concerned one way or the other with the reasons for its presence in
France.  The men were, for the most part, quite ignorant of the facts;
they were there as a professional army to do their "bit," as they had
often had to do it before, and I cannot recall a single instance during
the first month where the men spoke of the meaning of the war.

In numbers they were hopelessly insignificant beside the enormous
masses ranged against them, but, for its size, the army with the
colours has always been recognised the world over as without a peer.

There was, however, one factor which in no small degree tended to level
the balance.  Discipline in the Germany Army meant discipline in the
mass, by regiments or companies, under constant supervision of officers
and N.C.O.'s.  In the British Army it meant discipline of the
individual.  In a word, if a British soldier finds himself alone in a
tight corner he generally knows how to get out, if it is humanly
possible.  The German, accustomed from his childhood to be dry-nursed
in every trivial detail of his every-day life, would be hopelessly at
sea when forced to act on his own initiative.  When properly led the
German is splendidly courageous, and in this respect, quite apart from
numbers and moral, it was an exceedingly tough proposition which French
and British were up against at Mons.

As regards the French it is rather more difficult to estimate their
outlook in the early days.  From their experience in 1870 they knew
what war with Germany meant, both in the actual fighting and in the
nameless atrocities which the enemy committed on the civil population.
Thus they wanted their revenge.

But France had not yet suffered in this war.  She had not yet seen her
borough officials taken as hostages and murdered in cold blood; her
older men sold into slavery; her women raped and mutilated; her infant
children impaled upon the bayonet and thrown into the fire; her
Cathedral of Rheims tortured and desecrated.  All this was yet to come.

At the beginning they fought valiantly but blindly.  The shock was too
sudden and overwhelming.  Mistakes were made in the higher commands.

But within the month France awoke.  The Soul of her still lived; and it
was the Soul of a nation which was mighty many a generation before ever
Germanic tribes had banded together in primitive community.

The Soul of France awoke in every one of her children.  Not one, man,
woman or child, but saw the way clear before him, but felt the grip of
steel-cold determination to follow that path straight to the end.

Such was the France which turned at bay before the very gates of her
capital, to show the world that the doom of civilisation's enemy was
irrevocably sealed.



[1] Until Wednesday the 26th, the 19th Brigade was acting directly
under orders from G.H.Q.  On that date, being isolated it was
appropriated by the Second Corps.  The 4th Division detrained at Le
Cateau and took up position in and about Solesmes to cover the
retirement.




CHAPTER VI

MONS

"_If the English had any apprehension they would run away._"

      *      *      *      *      *

"_That island of England breeds very valiant creatures: their mastiffs
are of unmatchable courage._"


The dawn of Sunday, the 23rd, broke dim and misty, giving promise of
heat.  From the late afternoon of the previous day squadrons and
reconnaissance patrols from Chetwode's Cavalry Brigade had been pushing
well forward on the flanks and front of the British line.  They were
regiments with names "familiar in our mouths as household words": 12th
Lancers, 20th Hussars and Scots Greys.

It was pretty though delicate work this feeling forward to get into
touch with enemy outposts and patrols.  Nor was there a troop which did
not have some story to tell that evening of a tussle with enemy
cavalry, with its ending, happy or otherwise, determined by the more
wide-awake patrol.

In one place an officer's patrol, moving quietly out from a grassy
forest track, stumbled straight upon a dozen Uhlans having a meal.  The
British had no time to draw swords, and certainly the Uhlans hadn't, it
was just a question of riding them down, and swords and pistols out
when you could.

In another place a German and a British patrol entered a village
simultaneously from either end, unbeknown to each other.  The turn of a
corner and they were face to face.  Our men were the more wide-awake,
and they got spurs to their horses and swords out before the enemy
grasped the situation.  The little affair was over in five minutes.

But as our cavalry pushed farther and farther northwards they found
themselves confronting ever-increasing numbers, and retirement became
necessary.

Thus were the first shots fired.

At six in the morning of this Sunday, Sir John French held a "pow-wow"
with the three G.O.C.'s, Generals Haig, Smith-Dorrien and Allenby, and
discussed the situation, somewhat in these terms:[1]

"So far as I can see from the messages I've had from French H.Q. I
don't think we've got more than a couple of Corps in front of us,
perhaps a Cavalry Division as well.[2]  And it doesn't look as though
they are trying to outflank, because the cavalry have been right out
there and didn't meet with much opposition; nor do the aircraft appear
to have noticed anything unusual going on.  It'll be a big enemy
superiority, but I don't think too big if we've got dug in properly and
the lines are all right.  We ought to hold them when they come on.  The
French, as you know, are holding our right, Namur, and down the Meuse."

Here is a plan to show the situation as it was known at G.H.Q.:

[Illustration: PLAN A]

The morning wears on.  You picture the country-side as not unlike one
of our own mining districts, the little villages and low-roofed houses
giving that curious smoky, grimy effect of mean suburbs bordering on a
large industrial town.  Here and there great heaps of slag or disused
pits and quarries; gaunt iron stems carrying great wheels and heavy
machinery.

The soldiers are billeted all through the houses or make a shake-down
in odd barns and yards.  Look over the garden gate of one little house
and you will see the company cooks of one regiment getting the Sunday
dinner ready, peeling the potatoes, swinging the pots on to the camp
fires.

From a barn hard by you'll hear the sound of singing.  A padre has
looked in as the rollicking chorus of "Who's your lady friend?" swung
out into the roadway, and with gentle interruption has improvised a
short service, suggesting "Rock of Ages" as a substitute for the
music-hall ditty.

Down the road a couple of sergeants of the West Ridings lean idly over
a gate smoking and watching the folk going off to Mass.

Out over the canal line the men are hard at work trench-digging,
pausing now and again to look skywards as the drowsy hum of an
aeroplane propeller sounds over them.  Whether the machine is friend or
foe they have no idea.

Three girls saunter down the road, arms round waists, and stop to look
with interest and amusement at some of the West Kents washing out their
shirts.  One of the men is stripped for a wash and Marie exchanges a
little repartee with him, to run off laughing as a burly lance-corporal
plants a sounding kiss on her cheek, by way of finishing the argument.

So peaceful it all is, with just that under-current of excitement which
the presence of strange troops would give.  Imagine a Lancashire or
Yorkshire village on a summer Sunday morning and you have the picture.

It is now eleven o'clock and the people are streaming home from church.
The service seems to have been cut rather shorter than usual and there
is just a hint of anxiety to be seen on their faces.  What was it the
curé had said, something about keeping quietly in their homes and
trusting _le bon Dieu_?  But there is no danger, the English are here
to protect us.  Still, those aeroplanes have an ugly sound, something
of _un air menaçant_.

Another aeroplane--and look, it has a great black cross under the
wings!  Un Boche?  No, it cannot be.  Ah, see, see, a French one, ours!
It goes to meet it.  Mon Dieu! they fight!  And dimly from the sunny
heaven there falls the crackle of revolvers.

A motor dispatch-rider hurls himself from his machine straight upon the
astonished group of West Kents.

"Where's the officer?  Get moving; you're wanted up there!" and he
jerks a thumb over his shoulder.

The men rush for their kit and rifles.  Away to the west there is the
crack of an 18-pounder.

Down the street the cyclist pants.  A subaltern bursts in on the Sunday
dinner of the Bedfords.

"Fall in outside at once!"

Another aeroplane sails over.  It hovers for a moment over the Scottish
Borderers in their trenches.  A trail of black smoke drops down, and
instinctively the men cower below the parapet.  Slowly it falls.
Nothing more.  The men raise their heads.

"Eh, man, but a thocht yon werre one o' thae----"

A sudden, odd hum in the air, and then--crash!

The Scots corporal slowly and painfully drags himself out from the pile
of earth and debris and looks round.  There is a curious numb feeling
in his right arm.  He sits up with a dazed gasp.  There is a hand by
him on the ground.  His?  He looks at his arm, and realises.  Near by
five of his pals are laid out.  He seems to have escaped.

"The Lord ha' maircy--but the regiment's fair blooded this day," and he
falls back in a faint.

More aeroplanes, more trails of smoke; and, wherever they fall, within
twenty odd seconds a German shell bursts fair and true.

All down the line there springs the crack of rifles.  Beyond the canal
the outposts of the Lincolns, Royal Scots and others are coming in at
the double.  A curtain of shell-fire is lowered behind them as the
British batteries come into action.  A curtain of fire rolls down
before them as the German guns take the range.

It is now close upon one o'clock, and enemy shells have begun to creep
nearer and nearer in from the suburbs upon Mons itself.  The good curé
and his words are forgotten, for what living things can remain?  And so
there begins that pitiable exodus of old men, women and children which
streamed steadily southwards, ever increasing as it crowded through the
villages and towns.

But there is no time to-day to think of them.  They must go, or stay
and perish--anything so long as they do not interfere with the great
game of War.

North of the town, where our lines necessarily bulged out, making a
salient, the fighting was becoming desperate.  Here three regiments
especially (the Middlesex, Royal Irish and Royal Fusiliers) lost very
heavily as they sturdily contested every yard of ground.  This
particular point had, from the first, been recognised as the weakest in
the British lines.

Barely an hour since the first shots were fired, and now by one o'clock
practically every gun and every rifle of the British Force is blazing
away as though the powers of hell were set loose.

As yet it would seem that the ammunition is being merely wasted for the
sake of making a noise.  There is no enemy in sight save in the air the
circling aeroplanes, and away on the flanks dimly-seen clouds of
horsemen.  A modern battlefield with its curious emptiness has so often
been described that here one need only record the fact in passing.
There is nothing to be seen.  The men are firing, in the first flush of
excitement, at corners of possible concealment--the line of a hedge,
the edge of a wood, the very occasional flash of a field-gun.  On the
left, in the Second Corps, the British fire slackens somewhat as the
men pull themselves together.  No one has the foggiest notion of what
is really happening.  It is the officers' business of the moment to
steady the ranks and keep them under cover.

But away on the right, out by Binche, where the Guards are, the storm
has burst in fullest fury.  No slackening there.  The extreme right was
held by battalions of historic regiments, names to conjure with:
Munster Fusiliers, Black Watch, Scots and Coldstream Guards.  Ah, those
Guards!  The glorious discipline of them!  But how distinguish between
any of the regiments that day, and after?

Almost from the first the senior officers began to realise that
something was wrong, especially on the right.  The Divisional
Commanders and their immediate staffs, to whom the general idea of
strengths and dispositions was known, began to wonder whether a big
mistake had not been made.  "Well, never mind, we're in for it now, we
must do the best we can.  But, those guns!  There certainly should not
be so many out there."

And it was positively uncanny how the German guns got their range.
That fact struck everybody almost more than anything else.  There
appeared to be no preliminary ranging, as was always usual, but guns
got direct on to the target at once.

It is difficult at times to avoid launching out into details which are
of more interest to soldiers than to the general public, but as
everything at this time was so new an occasional lapse may perhaps be
excused.

Again, one's brain is so confused with such a mass of detail that it
becomes most difficult to disentangle impressions and note them down in
dispassionate language.  If, however, the reader will take the little
pen-pictures of incidents which are given and imagine them, not as
isolated facts but as being reproduced fifty times all through the
fighting lines, he may get a fair idea of the course of events.

      *      *      *      *      *

As the day wore on that uncanny effect of the German fire increased.
There is no doubt that it was mainly due to the amazingly efficient
secret service of the enemy.  The H.Q. of a division or a brigade, for
instance, does not blatantly advertise its position, and yet time and
time again shells were dropped clean on to the particular building
where the Staff happened to be.  And when they got into another
building, plump would come more shells.

Looking back it is a little curious to remember that even in that first
week a very considerable percentage of our total casualties were caused
by high explosive shell, and the shooting of them was astonishingly
accurate.

Yes, the German guns did their work well, but they did not fully
succeed in their object.  Their local successes were great, especially
against British guns and batteries.

Here is a British battery which has made two mistakes--it is not
sufficiently concealed, the battery commander is perched up on an
observation limber, and the guns are not far enough back behind the
crest.  (The Germans always "search" for some 300 yards behind crests
of hills.)  The B.C. is quickly spotted by an aeroplane observer and a
perfect hell of fire is switched on by the enemy.  In a moment
telephone wires are cut, communications are broken, and within five
minutes the gun detachments are wiped out.

The effect of a shell from the enemy heavier guns is overwhelming.  The
flank gun of the battery is hit, practically "direct."  Some R.A.M.C.
men double up a few minutes later to help out the wounded.  There is
nothing, save a great hole, fragments of twisted steel, and--a few
limbs of brave men.  Nothing can be done except, later, dig in the
sides of the pit to cover the remains.

The rest of the guns remain, but there is no one to work them.  The
horses, a little way to the rear, have also suffered badly.  A
subaltern officer staggers painfully through the tornado of fire from
one gun to the next, slowly, deliberately putting them out of action,
rendering them useless should the enemy come up to capture them.

Early in the afternoon Brigade Commanders have got orders round to the
British lines to hold up the infantry fire as far as possible.  It is
now all well under control, for everyone realises that the artillery
bombardment was a preliminary only, that the real attack is yet to
come.  The men have had their baptism of fire and magnificently have
they stood it.  This is discipline, and now they are ready for anything
which may come along.

[Illustration: FIELD-MARSHAL VISCOUNT FRENCH.]

But already the casualties have been very heavy.  Early in the day you
have seen that company of the West Kents double up to the support of
their battalion entrenched about half-way along the Second Corps line.
I find a note in my diary: "W. Kents, Middlesex and Northumberlands"
(they were all in the Second Corps) "decimated by shell fire."  One or
two companies of the W. Kents were, I believe, on outpost duty, which
would mean that they were literally wiped out.

And, remember, the British trenches were not those of later days round
Ypres.  They had all been hastily dug in extremely hard and difficult
ground, so that there were none of the niceties of snug dug-outs and
bomb-proof shelters.  In many places it was just a matter of scratching
up the soil behind a hump of shale and cramming oneself in as far as
one could go.  To imagine, as one is led to do by some writers, that
our men sat snugly in deep trenches through all that shell fire waiting
calmly for the infantry attack is to get a hopelessly wrong idea.  And
if this was so on the first day when the men started in fresh, the
conditions during the days which followed may be vaguely guessed.

Think for a moment of the splendid work the R.A.M.C. were doing all
this time.  I wonder how many V.C.'s were earned by that
self-sacrificing corps during the week.  It is easy enough to do what
people call a gallant deed with arms in your hands when the blood is
up, to pick up a live bomb and hurl it away--little trifles of the
moment which no one thinks twice about,--but the courage demanded in
walking quietly into a hail of lead to bandage and carry out a wounded
man, a feat which the R.A.M.C. men in the firing lines do a dozen times
a day, _that_ is worth talking about.

On our right the fight does not go well for us, and the suspicion that
some mistake has been made becomes a certainty.  If it is only a matter
of two German corps and a Cavalry division in front of our position
where on earth have all those guns come from?

Still the British guns out towards Binche go pounding gallantly on,
hopelessly outmatched though they are.  It's pretty shooting, for our
18-prs. can get in six or seven shots a minute more than the German
field-guns, but we cannot compete against their heavier metal.  And,
just as in a naval fight, it is the heavier metal which tells.

The fighting on the right where General Lomax has the 1st Division has
not slackened for a moment, but steadily becomes more intense.  Now,
for the first time, the enemy is really seen.  And as his infantry
begin an advance the German shell-fire redoubles in intensity.  Every
house where British can be concealed, every possible observation post,
every foot of trench, every hill-crest and 400 yards behind it is swept
and devastated by the tornado.

What communication between units is possible in such a storm?  Now
battalions and batteries find themselves cut off from their neighbours,
each fighting and carrying on by itself.

Chetwode's Cavalry Brigade is caught in the thick of it.  The Guards
are out there and they hold on almost by their teeth.  The 1st Irish
are in action for the first time since their formation.  They'll see
the Germans in hell before they're going to quit.  The Munsters are in
the hottest corner, if indeed you can see any degrees of difference.

The cavalry have to go; and the Munsters and Black Watch lose horribly
as they cover the retirement.  No finer fighting regiments in the world
than these on the right, but nothing human can stay there and live.
The little town of Binche is abandoned; the first enemy success that
day.  The First Corps has had to swing back its outer flank.

But if you think that the Black Watch, or the Guards, or any of them,
have been sitting there quietly to be shot at when there's an enemy in
sight, you know little of those regiments.  And you don't imagine that
the Scots Greys, or Lancers, or Hussars, with such a reputation behind
them, are going to sneak out of Binche by a back way without first
getting a little of their own back.

No, if the Germans have got to have Binche they must bring up a great
many more men than that to take it.  There has been much talk of a
repetition of that famous charge of the Greys, with the Black Watch
hanging on to the stirrup-leathers.  If indeed it was repeated that
August then this must have been the moment.  I am sorry to say that I
have never been able to obtain any real confirmation of the story, so I
shall not set it down.

But it might well have happened, and one likes to think that it did.
Anyway, during that hour or so, there was many a gallant, desperate
charge in that corner.  A charge against overwhelming odds, when the
utmost to be expected was the breaking and rout of the first two or
three lines of the advance.

It needs no vivid flight of imagination to picture it.  On the far
outskirts of the town a railway line runs.  Under the lee of a
sheltering embankment and bridge the officers collect and re-form some
of the squadrons, now grown pitiably less in numbers.  Words of command
are almost inaudible, but the men understand.  Hard by, on their left,
you have the flanking companies of the line regiments.  One or two
brief messages pass to and fro between cavalry and infantry.

"The Greys and Lancers are going to charge the left of infantry
advancing beyond the wood.  Give them all the support you can!"

The British fire slackens from loophole and broken window.  The
Scottish regiment and the Coldstream Guards insist on taking a share.
They cut out through the leaden hail and make some yards' advance,
dropping again under what cover they can.

A last look round, a final pull at girth-straps, and the word is
passed.  The enemy infantry is 300 yards away.

"Tr-rot!"  They are clear of the embankment.  All well in hand.  The
enemy guns have not yet got them.

The Scots and Coldstream Guards make another rush and again drop.

"Can-ter!"  And men and horses settle down into the steady swing.  The
infantry who have got the orders to support start blazing away again as
fast as they can get the magazine clips home.

Now the German gunners see what is happening and one gun after another
drops its range and fuse.  The German infantry is 250 yards away.

"Cha-arge!"  No need to sound it.  The officers are in front, and where
the officers go their men will follow.  Anywhere!

The Scots and Coldstreamers are after them as hard as they can leg it.

The enemy on the flank try to swing round to meet the charge, but there
is no time.  The German guns mercilessly drop the range still
more--what matter if they sweep away their own men as well.

One hundred yards!  Fifty yards!  A long, sickening crash--and the
Greys and Lancers are in them.  Hacking, slashing, hewing!  The Scots
are hard on their heels just to their left.  A mighty heave as the
bayonets get home.  The first rank is through.  There are no more
ranks, only a vast confusion.

Five little minutes (it seems an eternity) and the enemy flank is
crushed in, smashed to pulp as a block of stone smashes in the head of
a man.

"Who goes home?"  Who can?  Ten men, a dozen, perhaps twenty have
struggled through.  A few will cover again the ground over which they
charged.  A few, such a tiny few, will get back under cover again.
"The rest is silence."

But they have done it.  The enemy have learned what a British charge is
like.  They know now what bayonet work is, and the lesson sinks deep.
They will not face the steel again.  Ask the men who fought at the
Aisne, at Ypres.



[1] I have simply turned paragraphs of Sir John French's dispatch into
imaginary spoken words.

[2] A German Cavalry Division numbered, approximately, 5,200, all
ranks, including 2 batteries Horse Artillery and 1 machine-gun battery.




CHAPTER VII

MONS (_continued_)

          _But pardon, gentles all,
  The flat unraised spirits that have dar'd,
  On this unworthy scaffold to bring forth
  So great an object: can this cockpit hold
  The vasty fields of France?_


It may be of interest at this point if the narrative be broken off for
a few minutes to give some details of the methods the Germans employ in
their infantry attack, especially as they differ so greatly from our
own.

The two main features are (_a_) they consider rifle work as of
comparatively little value and rely mainly on machine-gun fire, and
(_b_) they attack in dense masses, shoulder to shoulder.

British methods are, or were, precisely the opposite.  Our men have
brought musketry to such perfection that an infantryman will get off in
one minute almost double the number of rounds that a German will; and,
what is more to the point, they will all hit the mark.  Let it be noted
that the British Army owes this perfection to the wise foresight of
Lord Roberts.  (Ah, if only the nation, too, had listened to him!)

British troops, adopting the lessons of the Boer War, attack with an
interval between the files, i.e. in extended order.

Now at Mons, and after, a German battalion generally attacked in three
double ranks.  The rear double rank had with it four or six
machine-guns.  They count upon the first three or four ranks stopping
the enemy's bullets, but, by the time these are swept away, the last
ranks (with the machine-guns) should be sufficiently near to carry the
position attacked: say about 300 yards.

This reckless sacrifice of life is typical of the German "machine," as
opposed to the British "individual."

As a matter of fact their method never succeeded over open ground
before the British fire, for the front ranks were always swept away at
the very beginning of the attack, and so they did not get near enough
with the rear ranks.

The German officer who gave me these details remarked that the rapidity
and accuracy of the British fire were simply incredible, that they
never had a chance.

"Our men," he said, "have come to believe that every one of you carries
a portable Maxim with him."

      *      *      *      *      *

It must have been about 2.30 in the afternoon that Binche had to be
abandoned.  But it was before this that the German infantry attacks
began all along the line.

For nearly two hours our men had somehow or other been weathering the
storm of shrapnel, and we have seen that they had by now settled down
under it.  Let us get back to the Second Corps and see what is
happening.  You have got some idea of the look of the country in front
of our positions, all broken up, uneven ground, little woods here and
there.  Out on the left flank there are county regiments, men of
Dorset, Norfolk, Suffolk, Cheshire, Surrey.  They know something about
"ground" work, and they have learned a deal more with their regiments.

One end of the Yorks L.I. trench ends in a little stone-walled pigsty.
At least it was a pigsty about church time that morning, but a German
gunner thought it would look better without any roof or walls.

There is still a fragment three feet high on the weather side, and the
Yorks C.O. finds it a convenient shelter for the time being.  He is not
attending church-parade that day, so it doesn't matter about lying full
length in the filth on the ground.  The last remaining company
colour-sergeant is with him--also embedded in the manure.  They are
both nibbling chocolate.  Tobacco would be particularly useful just
now, but they have both run out of it.

For some minutes the C.O. has been intently watching through his
glasses the corner of a wood about 500 yards in front.  He hands the
binoculars to the sergeant.

"What do you make of it?  That corner over the little shed."

The sergeant has a look.  He returns the glasses and slowly nods.

"It might be a brigade, sir, from the number of them."

"Yes," says the C.O., "I thought it was about time.  Get word along
that there is to be no firing till the order's given."

"Very good, sir!" And the sergeant scrambles to his feet, salutes,
ducks hastily as a shell seems to whistle past unnecessarily close, and
dives into the rabbit-burrow in which his men are squatting.  The C.O.
returns to his glasses.

The C.O. of a British battery, in position some distance to the rear,
has evidently also spotted that particular target, for puffs of
bursting shrapnel have begun to appear over the wood and round the
edges.

Now there is a distinct movement of troops emerging from behind the
wood.  It is a movement only which can be seen, for the men themselves
can scarcely be distinguished against the grey-green country-side.

At the very same moment it seems as though all the guns in the world
have been turned on to those few miles of British front, and to the
batteries behind.

The British gun-fire wavers for a minute or so; but soon it picks up
again though, alas! not so strongly as before.

The Yorks C.O. has lost his enemy infantry for a minute; they are
working forward under the edge of a rise in the ground.

Now the front ranks appear, and the C.O. gives a sharp whistle of
astonishment.  Four hundred yards off, and it looks like a great
glacier rolling down a mountain-side.

Nearer still it creeps, and the German guns have raised their range to
give their infantry a chance.  "Besides, there will probably be nothing
but empty trenches to take anyway," they say.

Fifty yards nearer, and the temptation is too great.

"Let it go, Yorkshires!" he yells down the trench.  (The command is not
in the drill-book, but it serves very well.)

And the Yorkshires "let it go" accordingly.

"Eh, lads," sings out a lad from Halifax, "'tis t' crowd coom oop for
t' Coop Day!  And t' lads yonder can't shoot for nuts," he blithely
adds as myriads of rifle bullets whistle high overhead.

And he and the lads from Trent-side proceed very methodically to give
"t' lads" from Spreeside a lesson in how shooting should be done.

Very methodically; but that means something like 16 shots a minute each
man, and you may be sure that very, very few bullets go off the target.
No one dreams of keeping cover.  Indeed, the men prop their rifles on
the parapet and pump out lead as hard as their fingers can work bolt
and trigger.

Miss?  It's impossible to miss.  You can't help hitting the side of a
house--and that's what the target looks like.  It is just slaughter.
The oncoming ranks simply melt away.

And now through the unholy din you can hear a cracking noise which is
quite distinct in the uproar.  Something like the continuous back-fire
of a mammoth motor-cycle.  Machine-guns.

The Dorsets have got a man who is a past-master in the use of these
infernal engines.  How he escaped that day no one can tell.  But for
many an hour he sat at the gun spraying the enemy attack with his steel
hose.  His "bag" must have run into thousands.

The attack still comes on.  Though hundreds, thousands of the grey
coats are mown down, as many more crowd forward to refill the ranks.

Nearer still, and with a hoarse yell the Yorkshires, Dorsets, Cornwalls
and others are out of the trenches, officers ahead of them, with
bayonets fixed and heading straight at the enemy.  A murderous Maxim
fire meets them but it does not stop them, and in a minute they are
thrusting and bashing with rifles, fists, stones, in amongst the enemy
ranks.

Again the German gunners drop their range and pour their shells
indiscriminately into friend and foe.  It is too much for the attacking
regiments and they break up hopelessly, turn and begin to struggle
back.  It is impossible to attempt any rally of our men.  They must go
on until they are overwhelmed by sheer numbers, or they must straggle
to the lines as best they can in knots of twos and threes, or wander
aimlessly off to the flanks and get lost.

Such was one single attack.  But no sooner was it broken than fresh
regiments would march out to begin it all over again.  And here is no
Pass of Thermopylae where a handful of men can withstand for indefinite
time an army.  What can the British hope to do against such
overwhelming numbers?  The end, you will say, must be annihilation.

The cavalry, the only reserves, are working, surely, as no cavalry has
ever worked before.  Squadrons are everywhere at once.  Wherever a gap
is threatened they are there in support.  And wherever they go there
also go the Horse Gunners working hand and glove with them.  Charge and
counter-charge upon the flanks of the attacking infantry, dismounting
to cover with their fire a British infantry rally, fierce hand-to-hand
encounters with enemy squadrons.  Wherever they are wanted, each man
and horse is doing the work of ten.

But this cannot last for long.  Now it is becoming only too evident
that far from there being a reasonable superiority against us the
British are everywhere along the line hopelessly outnumbered in every
arm.  And at 5 P.M. there happened one of the most dramatic incidents
of the war, that day or afterwards.  You will find the bare recital of
the event set forth in cold official language in the G.O.C.-in-Chief's
dispatch, beginning: "In the meantime, about 5 P.M., I received a most
unexpected message from General Joffre."

It will be remembered that from information received from French G.H.Q.
the previous night, and from his own reconnaissance reports, the
Commander-in-Chief had concluded that his right flank was reasonably
secured by the French armies, that the fortress of Namur was still
being held, and that the enemy strength in front of him was about
134,000 men and 490 field-guns, at an outside estimate.

All the afternoon the enemy had been attacking, and the British right
had had to give ground before it, with the consequence that Mons itself
had to be abandoned.

Now, like a bolt from the blue, came the message from the French.
"Unexpected," one would think, is a very mild term:--

"Namur has fallen.  The Germans _yesterday_ won the passages over the
River Sambre between Charleroi and Namur.  The French armies are
retiring.  You have _at least_ 187,500 men and 690 guns attacking you
in front; another 62,500 men and 230 guns trying to turn your left
flank; and probably another 300,000 men" (the victorious army in
pursuit of the French) "driving in a wedge on your right."

This is what the message would look like:--

[Illustration: Attacking and defending forces]


But we have seen that there were really thirteen German corps attacking
the positions Tournai--Namur--Dinant.

Thus the _real_ figures would probably look like this:--

[Illustration: Attacking and defending forces]


We may, of course, take it that by the end of the day the figures were
somewhat reduced all round, British and German; the German losses being
"out of all proportion to those which we have suffered."

[Illustration: PLAN B.  Position as it appeared at 5 pm Aug 23.]

Such then was the situation at 5.0 P.M. on that eventful Sunday.  An
average of nearly four times our number of guns against us all along
the position.  No wonder that senior officers had guessed from the
first that "something was wrong."

And G.H.Q.?  You imagine, perhaps, that the municipal offices where the
General Staff had its abode would now be seething with excitement.  You
will picture Staff officers rushing from room to room; orders and
counter-orders being reeled off; the Intelligence and Army Signals
Departments looking like Peter Robinson's in sales week; an army of
motor-cyclist dispatch riders being hurled from the courtyard towards
every point of the compass.

Wrong!  G.H.Q. that day, and the next, was less concerned than a little
French provincial mairie would be on France's national fête day.  The
casual visitor would have seen less bustle of activity than at the
Liverpool offices of a shipping firm on mail day.

The Postal Department: "Business as usual."  Army Censor: Not much
doing.  Intelligence: Half a dozen red-tabbed officers looking at big
maps with blue and red chalk-marks on them.  Director of Ordnance
Supplies: "Better see about moving rail-head a few miles farther
south."  A.G.'s (Adjutant-General) Office: "We shall want orders out
about stragglers, what they are to do."  And so on, all through the
list.  If this was an instance of that British phlegm which so amuses
the French, then commend me to it!  If anybody wanted a tonic against
pessimism these days of the Retreat he only had to drop in at G.H.Q.
He would certainly come out with the conviction that we should indeed
be home by Christmas, with the German Army wiped off the map.


Yes, that week which followed, indeed, welded into one "band of
brothers" all the officers and men in the little Force.  In those days
everybody seemed to know everybody else.  Regimental jealousy (if it
ever existed) was obliterated completely, and every officer and man,
from the General Officers Commanding Corps down to the bus drivers who
drove the A.S.C. lorries, worked shoulder to shoulder.  And so we
pulled through.


Now there were other units in the Force besides those in the
firing-line.  There were all those columns which trekked up by road.
Normally, most of these should be something like 15 miles to the rear.
They know very little of what is going on ahead of them, though the
ammunition columns can gauge fairly well by the demands made on them.

So it was that about midnight on that Sunday they began to realise back
there that things were moving by a sudden and insistent demand for
every scrap of rifle and 18-pr. ammunition they carried.

No sooner was that sent than there came more demands, and there was
nothing to send.  Wagons and lorries had trundled off at once to
rail-head, but it would be hours before they could get back.  Thus, on
the very first day, the overwhelming nature of the situation pulled at
and snapped the slender threads of communication.  The threads were
soon mended, but, as will be seen later, they never got properly into
working order until the Marne.

Nor did those columns altogether escape disaster even at the very
outset of the fighting.  One, out towards the flank, was attacked and
practically destroyed by raiding cavalry, for they do not work with
escorts.

In one column, about 10.0 P.M., the alarm was given by an imaginative
A.S.C. subaltern.  What the men were to fight with is not clear, for
only about 25 per cent. of the detachment had ever handled a rifle, and
no ammunition was issued.

"It's Germans crawling through that field," said the subaltern.  "I saw
their electric-torch flashes."

The men stood to, peering into the darkness, and feeling certain that
their last hour had come.

A farmer came slowly out of the field-gate and begged two of the men to
come and help him round up his cows.

So the detachment turned in again, cursing heartily.

But soon the A.S.C. bus drivers were "doing their bit" under fire as
gallantly as everybody else.  How and when you shall hear in another
chapter.


6.0 P.M.--The enemy have concentrated their fire upon the town of Mons
and it has become untenable.

Only six hours, six little hours since the Belgian townsfolk had come
peacefully home from Mass to their Sunday _déjeuner_, proud and hopeful
in the presence of their British allies.  And now their houses, their
town, a heap of smoking ruins.

In those short hours how many women have seen their children crushed by
falling walls or blown to atoms by bursting shells?  How many children
are left helpless and alone in the world, with no mother or father to
take them by the hand and guide them from the hell of destruction?

Is there no thought for them, you who have been following the fortunes
of the day for the British?  Many have escaped, with such few household
treasures as they can carry in perambulators and little handcarts.
They, at least, have some hope of life.  These may struggle on for a
little while--to faint or die of hunger and exhaustion by the roadside.
The strongest may get through.

For the rest, their lives are sacrificed to make a German holiday.
They die, but in their death the battalions of these innocents have
joined the mighty, mysterious army of souls who shall haunt the German
people until Germany ceases to be.

  _C'est l'armée de ceux qui sont morts_
    _En maudissant les Allemands,_
  _Et dont les invincibles renforts_
    _Vengeront le sang innocent._[1]


With such an overwhelming attack working forward in front and on both
flanks the only problem left was how to get the British force away with
the smallest loss.  To remain obviously meant certain annihilation
sooner or later.  As a matter of course, possible positions in rear had
long since been reconnoitred.  They were not particularly good ones,
but the best that were available.

From earlier in the afternoon the Sappers had been at work on all the
bridges crossing the canal, laying mines ready to blow them up in front
of a possible successful enemy advance.  By no means a pleasant task
this, for the men were working under heavy fire practically all the
time.  But the Sappers are another of those corps of the Service which
are well used to the kicks without the ha'pence, and nothing comes
amiss to them.  There is no regiment in the Army whose work merits
recognition more than the R.E.; there is no regiment more surprised and
pleased at receiving it.

As the dusk draws on the enemy fire has slackened a little, and the men
in their trenches are here and there able to snatch mouthfuls of any
food they happen to have handy.  Most of them have not tasted anything
since early morning, and they have been fighting hard all day.  But
there is no thought of rest.

The darkening night becomes red day as the glare of burning houses and
buildings everywhere mounts to heaven in great shafts of light.  It is
such a picture as only a Rembrandt could give us on canvas.

The men sit or crouch wearily in their burrows, rifles always ready,
heads sunk forward over the butts.  Now and again there is a momentary
stir as a doctor or stretcher-bearers scramble through the debris to
get at the wounded.  The fantastic, twisted shapes of the dead are
reverently composed and laid down on the ground.  The belongings of
them are carefully collected, with the little metal identity disc.  So
far as possible these will reach the wife, mother, or sweetheart at
home.

Perhaps those evening hours of the first day's fighting were the most
terrible the men were ever to know.  The tension had very slightly
relaxed, and the brain began once again something of its functions.
They began to _feel_ things.  No one ever gets accustomed to being
under the fire of modern warfare, and this was the first day of it.
The horror of everything began to crush the senses.  Soon physical and
mental action became purely mechanical; men ceased to feel, but moved,
fired a rifle, fed themselves, with the grotesque jerks of children's
toys.  But this was not yet.  Now they were conscious, if but a little.

One man, a bugler in a county regiment, little more than a child in
years, went raving mad as he staggered across a trench and fell,
dragging with him a headless Thing which still kept watch with rifle
against shoulder.  His shrieks, as they pulled the two apart, ring even
now in the ears.  He died that night, simply from shock after the awful
tension of the day.

Consciousness came to the men, yet with it came also amazing
cheerfulness even in the midst of the horror.  But it was the
cheerfulness not of high spirits but of determination, and of pity.
They had fought through the day against an enemy which, even to men who
did not understand, was in overwhelming strength; and yet they had been
able to hold their ground.  It was the cheerfulness which, at a word
from their officers, would have taken them straight at the enemy's
throat.

And pity, if it is to be helpful and sincere, must have behind it a
gaiety of heart.  No man in the world is more tender to helpless or
dumb creatures than the British soldier or sailor; no man more
cheerful.  And no man in the Force but felt his heart wrung by the
infinite pathos of the folk of Mons and round it.  History will never
record how many soldiers lost their lives that day in succouring the
people who had put such trust in their presence.

And how many won such a distinction as no king can bestow--the love and
gratitude of little children?  One man, at least, I knew (I never
learned his name) who, at the tears of two tiny mites, clambered into
the ruins of a burning outhouse, then being shelled, to fetch something
they wanted, he could not understand what.  He found a terror-stricken
cat and brought it out safely.  No, not pussy, something else as well.
Back he went again, and after a little search discovered on the floor
in a corner a wicker cage, in it a blackbird.  Yes, that was it.  And,
oh, the joy of the girl mite at finding it still alive!

"Well, you see, sir," he said afterwards, "I've got two kiddies the
image of them.  And it was no trouble, anyway."


About 2 A.M. (the 24th) orders to begin retiring were issued from
G.H.Q.  Some four hours before a few of the units--those north of the
canal--had begun to fall back; and so the beginning of the move was
made.  As the last of these crossed the bridges the detonator fuses
were fired and the bridges blown up.

For the rest, the men crouched ever in their places, bayonets fixed,
rifles always ready--waiting, waiting.



[1] 'Tis the army of those who in dying
      Have cursed the German flood--
    And whose growing invincible forces
      Will avenge all innocent blood.--EMILE CAMMAERTS.




CHAPTER VIII

THE RETREAT BEGINS

        _The poor condemned English,
  Like sacrifices, by their watchful fires
  Sit patiently, and inly ruminate
  The morning's danger._


To follow now the fortunes of the British Force you must imagine it, if
you will, divided, like Caesar's Gaul, into three parts.  There is the
First Corps, which still holds its position, save that extreme right by
Binche; there is the Second Corps, which has begun at 3 A.M. to retire
to a new position; and there is the Cavalry, Allenby's Division and the
remainder of Chetwode's Brigade, which turns up whereever it is most
needed to lend a helping hand.

If you glance through Sir John French's dispatch (at the end of the
book) you will see that he had in mind to retire in what is called
"echelon" formation.  That is, one-half retires and takes up a new
position, while the other half stays behind to act as a rear-guard and
hold up enemy attacks.  Then, in turn, that other half retires behind
the first half, and so on.

That was the idea, and on the first day it worked very well.  But after
that it was found simply impossible to keep to it, partly through the
enemy's thunderbolt movements, and partly because our men became more
and more exhausted.

Now, it is also a cardinal principle in rearguard fights that you must
not only check your enemy, but must also, whenever possible, make a
counter-attack.  In fact, the counter-attacks are part and parcel of
the checking movements.  This is where cavalry comes in very useful.

Let us, then, take the three divisions of the Force separately.


_The First Corps_

Night attacks, especially in the early morning (it sounds rather
Irish), are horribly uncomfortable things.  The nerves are continuously
on edge and you are apt to loose off guns or rifles at the merest
suspicion of a movement.

"If ye should see a wee brrown beastie in frront o' ye," a canny Scot
sergeant told his men, "ye mauna fire, because likely it'll be a bit
rrabbit, and rrabbits are guid for the pot.  But if the beastie should
walk upon twa legs, then ye may ken it's no a rrabbit, but a Gerrman,
an' ye will tak a verry quick but carefu' sicht o' him."

All through that Sunday night the men had snatched odd minutes of sleep
just where they had fought through the day.  And very little rest did
the enemy allow them.  For one can well imagine how exasperated by this
time the enemy were at being held up by a handful of a "contemptible
little army."  It was most difficult, too, to get any food up to the
lines, for the German guns had "registered" all the approaches and
persistently dropped their shells across them.

But the men hung on cheerily enough, and if they couldn't get any sleep
they made up their minds that the Germans should not either, especially
where they were dug in only a few hundred yards in front.

So the short summer night was passed.  And with the first hint of dawn
the news ran quickly round that, far from dreaming of retiring, the
First Corps was going to attack.  The news was as good as a big
breakfast.  Somehow or other the A.S.C. got up rations to most of the
units, and so it was the cheeriest of 2nd Divisions which swung out of
their trenches and loop holed houses and headed for the enemy's left
flank in Binche.  The 1st Division acted as supports.

In the attack there was something more of a hint of that method and
timing which, eight months later, were brought to such perfection in
Flanders.  The British batteries had by now recovered somewhat from
their severe handling during the day, and at the given moment every gun
got well to work in support of the infantry, and very fine practice
they made.

Of course the attack was really no more than a ruse, daringly conceived
and successfully executed.  Binche could not have been held even if it
had been recaptured.  But it is not difficult to imagine the enemy's
astonishment at finding an Army Corps, which they had fondly imagined
as good as wiped out, coming to life again and actually having the
cheek to attack them.  Kipling's remark about the Fuzzy-wuzzy who is
"generally shamming when 'e's dead" was an excellent motto for that
morning's work.

When the attack was well launched General Lomax began to withdraw very
carefully some of his regiments from the supporting 1st Division.  The
task of the British guns of the two divisions (working together) was to
lower such a curtain of fire in front of the 2nd Division as to make it
as difficult as possible for the enemy to counter-attack or, indeed, to
advance at all.  As soon as the 1st Division have retired a little, it
will be the turn of the division which has made that excellent sortie.

It is easy enough to say "the guns will check an enemy advance," but
think for a moment what that means.  There is already a big enemy
superiority in guns, and, what is more, these have already got the
ranges to a nicety.

Our batteries, or most of them, were in quite good positions, but at
this early date we had not yet learned the art of concealing them
sufficiently.  The enemy aircraft were very active, and against them
our own aircraft were hopelessly outnumbered.  And so it was not long
before our guns were "spotted," with the inevitable result.

Imagine, then, how gloriously those gun detachments must have worked to
have accomplished what they did that day, "enabling Sir Douglas Haig,
with the First Corps, to reach the new line without much further loss
about 7 P.M."  For it was undoubtedly the devotion of the guns which
made possible this and succeeding retirements.  Unless facts like this
are realised, the astonishing work of the Force in its retreat can
never be appreciated.


_The Second Corps_

If that Monday was an anxious day for Sir Douglas Haig, what must it
have been for General Smith-Dorrien and his men?  One looks hopelessly
at the blank writing-pad in despair of giving even the most primitive
description of the anxiety, the work, and the accomplishment of it.

Here is a Corps which has gone through, for the first time, the awful
ordeal of a day's modern shell-fire and massed infantry attack.  The
men have supped full of horrors, and, at 3 A.M., hungry, weary and with
nerves stretched to their utmost tension, they have received orders to
move.  There is not a regiment which has not lost heavily, especially
in officers, and there is not a man but receives the command with his
senses tangled in bewilderment.

Now it should be remembered that up to this time all our dispositions
had been made for an advance.  The impedimenta to the rear of the
firing-line were so arranged that they might the more easily follow up
a British attack.  There was no real thought of retiring.  The British
were in the place of honour on the left of the line, and intended, with
our French comrades, to drive the enemy back again through Belgium.  I
will not say that all this was a foregone conclusion, but at least it
was "confidently anticipated."  Remembering this, you will perhaps
realise more vividly how staggering were the contents of that telegram
from French G.H.Q.  The work, therefore, of clearing the roads of the
transport was exceedingly difficult.  This devolves upon the Q.M.G.'s
department, and General Smith-Dorrien has placed on record the wholly
admirable way in which it was accomplished by General Ryecroft and his
Staff.  But proper Staff work for all the retiring troops during the
hours of darkness was even more complicated.

Thus some few of the companies, with no one to guide them, start off in
the wrong direction and march straight into the German lines; they are
shot or captured.  Others wander off to the east, struggle painfully
through the shell-fire on Mons, and drift into their comrade ranks of
the First Corps.  Others, again, march off to the west, and are
hopelessly lost; they are either captured by the flanking German corps
or they get through and meet with friendly peasants, to turn up
eventually at base ports or other towns.

Night marching across unknown country is not always easy in peace time,
with guides at the heads of columns.  Now there was the added confusion
of the crowds of emigrants, a perfect network of roads to choose from,
and, above all, continual alarms of enemy attacks which the British had
to turn to meet.  The whole of the night and all the Monday was one
long period of marching, fighting, marching and fighting.

Early in the morning another infantry brigade, the 19th, arrived by
railway, detraining at Valenciennes, and it is no exaggeration to say
that the men went straight off the trains into the thick of the fight.
It was a very welcome reinforcement of about 4,000 men.

By 8 A.M. the enemy had burst through Mons, across the canal line, and
were in hot pursuit in overwhelming numbers.  Away on the left flank
they had attacked Tournai, which was occupied by French Territorials
and also, I believe, by a British battery, though how it got there, or
why, I do not know.  That bit of fighting was over by midday with the
capture of the town and the destruction or capture of its defenders.
The Germans were then free to resume their victorious advance.

About the middle of the morning, then, the line of the Second Corps
extended from a little Belgian village called Frameries, five miles
S.W. of Mons, through the village of Dour.  The right flank was the
more forward, partly because the regiments there had to encounter the
more furious attacks and could not break away.

It was at this point that there was made one more of those splendid but
hopeless cavalry charges of which we so often read in military history.
It is, curiously enough, almost the only definite incident mentioned by
Sir John French in his dispatch.  But the incident, or rather the
sequel to it, caught the public imagination, mainly because of the fine
work of that most gallant gentleman, Francis Grenfell.

Of all the noble, lion-hearted men who have "gone west" in this bloody
war, no man more worthily deserves the description applied to the
Chevalier Bayard, "_sans peur et sans reproche_," than Francis
Grenfell--he and one other whom I shall name hereafter.  Gallant
soldier, brilliant sportsman, graceful poet, and true lover of Nature,
a genuine statesman in his dealings with men, and the most loyal of
friends, he died later on the field of honour, and Britain--nay, the
world is the poorer for his loss.

The charge was made by the 9th Lancers, which regiment, with others of
the 2nd Brigade, had been moved forward to ease the pressure on the
right flank.

About 400 yards from the German infantry and guns the Lancers galloped
full tilt into barbed wire.  There was nothing for it but to swerve
across the German front.  How a single man or horse escaped the hail of
shell and bullets which was turned on them one can never understand.
But a poor remnant, under Captain Francis Grenfell, did indeed get
across, mercilessly pursued by that storm of lead, and eventually found
some little shelter under a railway embankment.

A R.F.A. battery was in action here.  At least, the guns were still
there, but officers and detachments had been gradually wiped out until
there were just one officer and two detachments left to work the
battery.  It was only a matter of minutes before the remainder must be
killed and the guns fall into the hands of the enemy, for the German
guns had the range and the German infantry were crowding up.

The 9th Lancers and the Gunners are old friends, and the Lancers do not
leave old friends (or new ones) to finish a losing fight alone.

"The Germans don't get those guns while any of us are left," said
Grenfell.  "I'm off to see how we can get them away."

Now Grenfell was already badly wounded, but he stuck on his horse
somehow and _walked_ that gallant beast out into the storm to see where
he was to run the guns to.  (Why does not His Majesty create a
decoration for horses?  But I'll wager Grenfell hung his V.C. round his
charger's neck a month later.)

Well, he walked him out and he walked him back, just to show his men
what poor shots the Germans were.

"Now then," said Grenfell, "who's for the guns?"

And, since (as I have said) the Lancers always stand by old pals, every
man of them was.

They tied their horses up, and Lancers and Gunners set to work.  One by
one of those guns they got at the wheels and trails and worked and
worked.  Down went more gallant Lancers and more gallant Gunners, but
there were still a few left, and, by Heaven, those few stuck to it.

"Come on, lads, just one more!" sang out Grenfell, with his coat off.

And they worked and heaved, and did it.  Every one of those guns they
saved.

But then, be it repeated, the Lancers and Gunners always were good pals.


By midday General Smith-Dorrien's task had become one of the gravest
difficulty.  And this was but the opening phase of a movement which, I
venture to think, will be accounted by the historian as one of the most
astonishing pieces of work in military history.  I refer not to the
Retreat as a whole, but to the work of the Second Corps and its leader
from 3 A.M. of the 24th to about midnight of the 26th--27th.  An
eternity of years was encircled by those few hours.

The difficulties of the movement can probably be appreciated at their
full value only by the military student with a vivid imagination, so I
will just suggest what had to be done.  First of all, General
Smith-Dorrien had to get his men away from the Mons line in the early
dawn in the face of overwhelming numbers, numbers which he could only
guess at, for at any moment a big attack might be made by another army
upon his left flank.  This was very much complicated by his men having
been severely handled all through the Sunday, and getting no food nor
rest.  In fact, it was the human element which really made all the
movement so difficult.  The feeling that at any moment the tremendous
strain upon the men's endurance would stretch to breaking-point and
snap.

Then the G.O.C. had not merely to get his men gradually back, but they
had to show a bold front the whole time.  It was a matter of fighting
backwards without a moment's rest.  A couple of regiments, say, with
some cavalry, would halt for half an hour on a certain line, and hold
up with the heaviest fire they could the attack on their particular
section.  Then, when the enemy got nearer, up they would jump and go
straight at the Germans with the bayonet, the cavalry backing them up
all they knew.  The same with the guns.

A battery would manoeuvre into a position, come into action, and pound
away for a quarter of an hour.  Then, at the right moment (and it
called for the nicest judgment to select that moment) four guns would
be run back, limbered up, and got away, while the remaining couple
would continue an intermittent fire to cover the retirement.  These in
turn would slip away--if they could.

The casualties under conditions like these must, of course, be very
heavy indeed.  That they were not infinitely heavier was due to the
splendid use the men made of the ground, taking cover and so on, and to
the noble spirit of self-sacrifice for comrades which animated every
unit.

Thirdly, the G.O.C. had to remember that he was not playing a lone
hand, but that he had to consider the retirement of the First Corps on
his right.  He had to play the match for his side.  Just at the moment
Jessop, in the person of Sir Douglas Haig, was in with him, and Jessop
had to hit out against time to make the runs while Leveson-Gower
(Smith-Dorrien) kept up his wicket at the other end.

And, fourthly, to carry on the metaphor, when Jessop was forced to
"retire hurt" Leveson-Gower had to begin to hit at just that moment
when he felt that he had "collared the bowling."  In other words, the
G.O.C., having held a certain line of defence for a couple of hours or
so, had to judge to a nicety the exact moment when he had, for the
time, broken the enemy's attack sufficiently to permit of retirement
another two miles to the next position.

Those four points, then, constitute in very broad outline the task
which General Smith-Dorrien had to perform.  Our people have not been
slow to recognise how magnificently he and his men accomplished it.

The enemy were now, by accident or design, beginning to drive in a
wedge at Frameries between the two corps.  Always a serious situation,
especially when, as now, units had become very scattered in the gradual
retirement.  The gap was filled to some extent by the 5th Brigade,
which General Smith-Dorrien borrowed from the First Corps.

      *      *      *      *      *

Impressions gleaned from the other side are always of interest.
Another German officer, whom we got a few days later, gave me his
opinion of the British work somewhat like this.

"All our text-books," he said, "about rear-guard actions will have to
be rewritten, and you have certainly taught us a lesson.  It has been
just like advancing into a wall of fog.  The fog is elastic enough when
one enters it, but soon it clings all round and chokes you.  We pushed
in all right, but never came out at the other side."

Personally, I felt inclined to apply the metaphor the reverse way, and
that is how the men felt it.  The dense, overpowering cloud rolling
down, the battling against it with impotent arms, and the fog
penetrating into every gap in the lines.

The men were dazed, stunned by the continuous onslaughts.  There seemed
no end to them.  As fast as one German company was mown down another
would spring up.  It was as though their aircraft flew over with
watchful eye to sow in every field another bushel of the mythical
dragon's teeth.  And everywhere more and more German guns would come
into action to support their infantry, and everywhere more and more
machine-guns would be rushed up by their very mobile transport to rake
and enfilade the British companies or gun detachments.

At the time all these things were not realised, for there was no
sitting down for five minutes to ruminate.  But now, after eighteen
months, when one pieces together this fact and that, and learns
something of what the actual numbers were, one hesitates to set it down
on paper for fear of being flatly disbelieved.


Any record of feelings during those hours is blurred.  But there was
one thought which, I know, was uppermost in every man's mind: "Where on
earth are the French?"

When a thought like that has been born it is easy to guess how it will
grow and run through the ranks.  If only now and again they had seen a
French squadron swoop down upon the enemy's flank in front of them
everything would have been well.  They would have cheered their French
comrades on, and gone in for all they were worth to avenge their death,
if called upon.  But never a French soldier did one of our lads see.

So far as I know, our Allies have published no official account of
their retreat from Namur, although they have very frankly admitted, in
an official Government report, the mistakes which were then made and
have shown how they were since rectified.  It is by no means clear what
happened to the 5th French Army on our right after Namur had fallen; we
only knew that we never saw them.

But at the time it must be remembered that no one in the British Force,
save G.H.Q., knew what was happening even to themselves, so it was
hardly likely that they could learn anything definite about the French.
So there the subject may rest.


In the early afternoon General Smith-Dorrien learned that the First
Corps had "made good" during the morning, and were fighting their way
back with sufficient success to admit of his own retirement when he was
able to break away.

Although, perhaps, too little space has been given in this chapter to
the work of the First Corps, they had nearly as hard a fight as the
rest of the Force.  The task before Sir Douglas Haig was probably not
quite so delicate as General Smith-Dorrien's, but it was obviously one
of as grave a responsibility.  However, in the late afternoon he got
safely back, as we have seen, to the position determined by the
Commander-in-Chief.

The Second Corps then succeeded in breaking away, and by the evening a
new line of the entire Force was formed, reaching from the fortress of
Maubeuge on the right to two little villages, Bry and Jenlain, on the
left.  The 19th Brigade, which had come into the fight in the morning,
was posted on and across the extreme left.

It should be noted that, with the fall of Tournai and the destruction
of the French troops in that neighbourhood, the whole country on the
west was open to the invaders.  Their victorious army corps operating
there was now able to swing round to attack the British left, and their
cavalry was already sweeping in flying squadrons and patrols over the
country-side.  In fact, the French Channel ports, from Boulogne to
Havre, were there for the taking, and the French coast line, for which
the enemy fought so valiantly a few months later, would have been
theirs without a struggle.

But these facts were only vaguely realised in the Force, and the men,
of course, knew nothing of doings save only upon their immediate front.
At every moment they fully expected to make a definite stand, with an
advance to follow, and thus they remained in good heart, secure in the
conviction that though badly mauled they were not even at the beginning
of a defeat.  But some of us knew and realised, and it was a hard task
to keep the knowledge from the men and from the friendly country-folk.




CHAPTER IX

THE SECOND DAY

  _Gloucester, 'tis true that we are in great danger;
  The greater, therefore, should our courage be.--
                  . . . . God Almighty!
  There is some soul of goodness in things evil,
  Would men observingly distil it out.
  For our bad neighbour makes us early stirrers,
  Which is both healthful and good husbandry._


During the night of Monday the whole Force was on or about the line
already indicated, with the fortress of Maubeuge on their right flank.
But let it not be imagined that the men settled down quietly at 9 P.M.
to a cosy supper with a night's sleep to follow.  There was no such
thing as a halt for any time.  Incidentally, most of the horses went
through the whole business without being off-saddled once.  The first
regiments in were the first to move off again.  The men just dropped
down in the road where they halted and, if lucky, snatched ten minutes'
sleep.  Many of the men seemed to sleep while they marched; although,
as one has often done it on night manoeuvres at home, there was nothing
curious about that.

By midnight I do not think that anybody very much cared what happened.
There was a certain amount of trench digging going on, and there was,
in consequence, some idea that a stand would be made.  But the men were
really too exhausted to care one way or the other.

It is all very well to remark upon their invariable cheeriness, as most
writers seem to delight in doing, but it gives a hopelessly wrong
impression of the hardships.  A certain form of "cheery spirit" is
inseparable from the British soldier when he is up against a tough job,
but you can't very well be lively and make funny remarks (as reported
in the Press) when you have become an automaton in all your movements.

Had the French held firm, in all probability a stand would have been
made on this line.  But there is no object in speculating about it now.
The view adopted by the Commander-in-Chief, which determined a further
retreat, may best be given in his own words:

"The French were still retiring, and I had no support except such as
was afforded by the fortress of Maubeuge; and the determined attempts
of the enemy to get round my left flank assured me that it was his
intention to hem me against that place and surround me.  I felt that
not a moment must be lost in retiring to another position."

"I hoped," he adds, "that the enemy's pursuit would not be too vigorous
to prevent me effecting my object."

This hope was, fortunately, fulfilled, and the second day's retirement
was, on the whole, less eventful.  Later I will hazard a suggestion why
it was so.

The necessary orders had been given overnight to be clear of the
Valenciennes--Bavai--Maubeuge road by 5.30 A.M.  The Second Corps got
clear by the time specified, but the First Corps could only begin their
move at that hour, and so got behind.  This fact tended to make
inevitable the fight which took place that evening at Landrecies.

It was, as I remember, a baking hot day, with a blazing sun in a
cloudless sky.  Along English country roads and through our own little
dappled-grey villages it would have been trying enough; but French
roads, built Roman fashion, do not try to be picturesque and charming,
and they certainly have no sense of humour like ours.  Thus, the day's
march was simply purgatory to a tired force.  The fruit trees with
their harvest really saved the situation.  But, oh, those green apples
and pears!

Once again, do not imagine the regiments trekking along straight for
their next destination.  The day was less eventful only in comparison
with Monday and Wednesday.  It was a rear-guard action most of the way,
and there was quite enough fighting to break the monotony, with some
big cavalry actions and the 5th Brigade heavily engaged.

Take, for instance, a field battery in the 2nd Division.  The
time-table would be something like this: 5.30 A.M., open fire; 6, cease
fire and limber up; 6.10, en route to new position; 6.30, halt, open
fire; 6.40, cease fire, limber up, and start off for new position;
7.15, halt, open fire; and so on all through the day.  In fact, that
was the ordinary day's programme.  The particular battery I have in
mind had a little adventure all to itself on Tuesday.  It is of
interest as revealing another side of German thoroughness.

The battery was in action, but had temporarily ceased firing, and the
detachments were lying by the guns.

A big grey "Sunbeam" drew up on a road to the flank of the battery, and
a couple of red-tabbed Staff officers jumped out, walked up to the
nearest gun, and started to chat with one of the gunners.

After a few remarks about how well the battery had been doing, they
asked some questions about casualties, positions of neighbouring
batteries, the infantry near them, and the usual facts which the Staff
come to inquire about.

The major had been watching from the far flank, and, as the Staff
officers turned to get into their car, he remarked to the
sergeant-major:

"I don't quite like the look of those two officers; there's something
wrong about them."  And he had a look through his glasses.

Some distance along the road there was marching down a company of
R.E.'s.

"Call up those sappers (by flag) and tell them to hold up that car."

The sergeant-major repeated the message to the flag-wagger.

"Stop grey car--suspicious."

The R.E. sergeant ran up to the subaltern in charge:

"Battery signals 'stop grey car.'"

"Well, stop it, then," replied the subaltern irritably.

So the grey car was stopped, very much to the annoyance of two Staff
officers who were in a great hurry to get back to G.H.Q.

"Very sorry, sir," said the subaltern, "but it's a telegraph message
from that battery.  The O.C. has probably got something special to send
to G.H.Q."  And the car was escorted back again.

The O.C. had "something special to send" in the shape of a couple of
German officers, very carefully disguised as British.  A drum-head
court-martial was held at Corps H.Q., and as the Germans in question
were hopelessly compromised by the very full notes which they had
managed to collect from various units about the Force, the case was
clear.

"Guilty.  To be shot at dawn."

They were plucky fellows, but--well, a spy is a spy, and that's all
about it.


Less than a week before the country folk had watched with delight and
relief the passing of mighty transport columns of British, had welcomed
and cheered the men forward, proud and confident in the anticipation of
early victory.

Now imagine their feelings, their alarm, at the sight of British
regiments, war-worn, weary and battered, trailing back as fast as they
could move.

Of what use was it to tell them that this was only a strategical
retirement?  Panic spreads quickly, and once the hint of calamity is
given it is impossible to check the alarm.

But even then it was some little time before the stolid peasants of
Northern France could grasp the meaning of what they saw, and I
remember well how the inhabitants of a certain little village crowded
out to watch the extraordinary (to them) behaviour of a regiment which
was in the extreme rear of the retiring First Corps.

The village overlooked a valley, and there was a splendid view of the
British lines retiring in open order up the hill towards the little
hamlet.  They came up panting heavily and, just under the brow of the
hill, set to work to dig up some rough shelter.  The folk stood
watching, laughing and talking, until an exasperated lance-corporal
threw his tool in front of an oldish man.

"'Ere, it's about b---- well time _you_ did a bit"; and the corporal
sat down to wipe off some of the dirt from his face.

In a few minutes all the men and women had started digging as though
for buried treasure, and the British sat still for a spell and
encouraged them with happy comments.

Very soon down the opposite <DW72> thousands of little grey-blue ants
came swiftly, and from the ridge behind them dim flashes shot out.

"Now, then, you'd better 'op it!" said the lance-corporal.

And even then they didn't understand what those ants really were.

"Allmonds!" was the lance-corporal's laconic remark.

The arrival of a shell settled it, and the villagers ran helter-skelter
for their houses and little treasures.  In a quarter of an hour another
pitiable reinforcement had joined the ranks of the refugee army flying
southwards, and only the old curé remained, ever true to his charge.
They were gallant gentlemen those French curés, and bravely they faced
the death which nearly always overtook them at the hands of those
murderers.

It was not until the British had turned to advance from the Marne that
they began fully to realise the nature of the Germans.  As yet they
encountered no evidence of the atrocious, bestial work of the enemy.
But already rumour was busy, and even on this day I had recorded
authentic details that the Germans were placing women and children
before their advancing infantry, and that they were stabbing the
wounded with the bayonet.


On the Sunday another British Division, the 4th, had arrived at Le
Cateau, the little town to which the Force was now moving.  This meant
a reinforcement of some 14,500 men, together with three field
batteries.  They were there waiting to come into action on the
Wednesday, and in the meantime had begun to entrench.

The general line of retirement on the Tuesday was:

(_a_) First Corps, Bavai--Maubeuge, to Landrecies--Maroilles.

(_b_) Second Corps, Bry--Bavai, to west of Le Cateau.

A glance at the picture-map will show the position of these places.  It
will be noted that the various divisions kept together pretty well.
Also that between Landrecies and Le Cateau there was a gap in the line
which the 6th Brigade could not properly fill.  The Commander-in-Chief
remarks in his dispatch that the men in the First Corps were too
exhausted to march farther so as to cover this gap.


You picture, then, the regiments arriving one by one at the end of that
most exhausting day.  The men dog-tired, hardly able to drag their feet
over the burning ground, no proper meal since a hasty breakfast at
dawn, fighting on and off all day, and now simply done to the world.

Now, it is a golden rule in the Service that, however tired the men may
be, they must set to work at the end of their march to entrench
themselves or otherwise prepare against possible attack.  I leave it to
your imagination to realise the meaning of "discipline" when you learn
that the men did entrench themselves that evening.  And never was that
rule more finely vindicated.

I conceive Marshal von Kluck at German G.H.Q. soliloquising that
Tuesday morning something in this wise:

"My friends von Buelow and Hausen have between them settled with the
French on this side, and _they_ won't give any more trouble.  Von
Buelow and I have pretty well pounded and demoralised the English, and
one more effort should finish _them_.  Now, I will just give them
enough to keep them busy through to-day, keep them on the run and
exhaust them thoroughly, and then to-night we'll have a really hot
attack and crumple up the First Corps.  They'll never stand that; and
we shall then have the rest of their army surrounded."?

And that is the suggestion about the day's work which I venture to
make.  We have seen how the daylight hours went for the British, and
how the Force drifted in to their destinations.  Now we will see how
von Kluck crumpled up the First Corps with his night attack.

The 1st Division was halted in and about Maroilles, and the 2nd
Division at Landrecies.  They were therefore on the extreme right of
the line, with their flank more or less "in the air," for no French
seemed to be near.  Landrecies was held by the 4th Brigade, battalions
of the Foot Guards, Grenadiers, Coldstreams and Irish, under General
Scott-Kerr.

The torrid heat of the day had been the prelude to a cool, rainy
evening.  Room was found for about two-thirds of the Brigade in the
houses and halls of the little town--a typical French country-town,
with its straight streets and market-place.  The remainder of the men
got what little comfort they could on a rainy night outside.

By 9 P.M. they had hardly begun to settle down, after "clearing decks
for action"--in case.  Outposts had been placed, and the men were
congratulating themselves on a comfortable shelter after so many nights
of foot slogging.  At 9.30 lights were out, and town and country-side
were in pitch darkness.

A battalion of the Coldstream Guards had not yet arrived, but was about
a quarter of a mile from the town, marching in.  The colonel was at the
head of the column with the guide.  This man persisted in flashing an
electric torch to and fro towards the left, and the C.O. peremptorily
ordered him to put it out.

The man obeyed for a few yards, and then flashed the light again.

The C.O. at once grasped the situation, drew his revolver, and shot the
spy dead.

It was as though that bullet had been fired straight into a mountain of
gunpowder.

With a terrific crash German guns opened fire.  Simultaneously, on
front and flank, rifles and machine-guns blazed out.

A German night attack is no question of feeling a way in open order
until the enemy's outposts are driven in; it comes down like a smith's
hammer on the anvil.

The Coldstreamers, with miraculous discipline, swung round and got into
a kind of line with the outposts already there, then continued
retirement to the town at the double.

The outpost line was crushed through almost in a moment like tissue
paper, and before anyone could grasp what was happening the Germans
were pouring their massed columns into the town.

Thus began perhaps the most critical and certainly the most remarkable
fight in which British regiments have ever been engaged.

Tired out, the men tumbled out of the houses; three privates and a
corporal here, a dozen men and a sergeant there, a subaltern, a private
and a machine-gun at another corner, half a dozen men at two
first-floor windows somewhere else.  And the only light came from the
flash of the rifles.

There was no idea of forming ranks, even had it been possible.  Slowly,
steadily up the streets the great German mammoth crept, and, like
tigers at their prey, the men of the Guards sprang at head and flanks,
worrying with grim-set teeth to the heart of the beast.

Now the British machine-guns opened fire straight upon the head of the
column, swept it away, swept the succeeding ranks, until the mass was
brought to a standstill.

More Guardsmen threw themselves straight at the ranks, firing as they
could, crashing in with bayonet and clubbed rifle.

Now the column shivers; but the Germans are brave men.  They rally, for
their comrades are pouring into the town to help them.  Up side streets
and lanes, by all the approaches they come, and everywhere the men of
the Guards spring at them.

But surely numbers must tell.  What can four battered regiments,
fighting by handfuls, do in face of such thousands of a fresh army
corps!

From Maroilles right down the line the British are fighting for their
lives, for von Kluck has staked heavily on this throw, and it would
seem that the dice are loaded.  He pushes his guns up still closer
until some are firing into the town almost at point-blank range.
Again, what does it matter if his own men are swept away?  There are
thousands more to fill their places.

The houses have begun to blaze fiercely in the torrents of rain, and
there is plenty of light at last.  And now the Guards rally for a
supreme effort.  The last, the forlorn hope--but it is the Guards, and
at least they will go down fighting to the last man.

One mighty heave--in at them--again--they are breaking--heave!

They have done it.  Broken them.  Driven them out.  And behind them the
enemy leave close upon 1,000 dead.

Away up by Maroilles Sir Douglas Haig has fought his men like one
possessed, and there, too, he has broken the German attack, just as two
French Reserve Divisions came up to his aid.

Slowly, sullenly, von Kluck withdraws his legions.  Slowly and fitfully
the firing dies away, and by 2 A.M. all is still once more.




CHAPTER X

AN INTERLUDE

  _... As many ways meet in one town;
  As many fresh streams meet in one salt sea;
  As many lines close in the dial's centre;
  So may a thousand actions, once afoot,
  End in one purpose, and be all well borne
  Without defeat._


There is something more than magic in the poetry of Shakespeare's
_Henry V._ when it is read to illustrate the stirring events of these
opening phases of the War.  To set it side by side with the recital of
the story is to listen to the voice of a singer supported by the
gravely-sounding, deep-toned brass instruments of an orchestra.

There is more than beauty of accompaniment, there is the magic of
prophecy.  I can hardly find an incident of those August days which was
not mirrored three centuries ago in the verse of this play.  Thus, I
have sought in no other for the musical preludes of my chapters; and I
confess often to have rubbed my eyes in astonishment at the aptness of
the poetry to the incidents of the moment.

Now those few bars of introduction suggest another _motif_; let me try
to expand the theme a little.

In reading the cold, semi-official language which states that the
British Force halted at such and such an hour along a line extending
from So-and-So to Somewhere, one is apt to gain an impression which is
far removed from reality.

You picture, perhaps, the various units retiring along routes carefully
assigned by gilded Staff officers, and duly arriving at the scheduled
times in various villages and hamlets.  That there they are met by
courteous billeting parties, who proceed to allot the men to more or
less unwilling householders.  That at the hour specified in the report
you find the Dorsets in one place, the Irish Guards next to them, the
batteries with their guns neatly parked, and so on all down the line.
The various H.Q.'s of Brigades, Divisions or Corps all in readily
accessible spots, and everybody connected up with everybody else by
telegraph or telephone, so that any unit can be set in motion at any
minute.

That is the ideal.  Well, that delightful ideal first assumed definite
shape after the Battle of the Marne and not before.  Here is a little
sketch of a tiny village on the line of retreat on the evening of
Tuesday, August 25th:


M. le maire, old Pierre Godolphin, sat slowly pulling at a new clay
pipe as he looked with unseeing eyes up the long dusty road which led
out of the village away over the northern uplands.  A trimly kept hedge
of privet bordered his rose-garden and the road, and his favourite seat
was set in a little niche of the greenery whence he could command all
that went on in his tiny kingdom and, without moving, could see exactly
what Madame la Femme du Maire was about in the stone-flagged kitchen.

That afternoon an avalanche of three-ton motor lorries had descended
upon the village, weird vehicles which announced in blatant language
the superiority over all others of Mayflower's margarine or the
outstanding merits of Pulltite's corsets.  The men in authority were
obviously, from their uniforms, English officers, and not travellers
for the firms in question.  But, frankly, old Pierre was puzzled.  They
had come from the south, and why did they not continue their journey?
Two of the officers were actually proposing to stay with him, for an
indefinite period.

M. le boulanger walked slowly across the road to confer with him about
the baking of more bread.  "But these English are like a locust swarm,
and I have no more flour," he explained.

"A glass of cider for monsieur, Henriette."

"I do not understand," Pierre went on, "what it is ces braves garçons
do here.  It is the third week of war, and by now surely ces bêtes de
Boches should have been driven back into their own pigsties----  Mais,
nom de Dieu, qu'est ce que c'est?"

Down the village street a four-seater car came lurching from side to
side like a drunken man.  Crash!  It has caught a stone post and turned
over.  In an instant the road is full of people running.

Two men lay dazed as they had been thrown out.  Both in the
yellow-green uniform of the British, one, certainly, an officer.
Willing hands lift them tenderly, and someone dashes a jug of water
over their heads.  Then one sees what has happened.

Between the shoulders on the officer's tunic there is spreading a great
dark stain.  Very carefully they take off the coat and shirt and try to
stanch the blood.  But it is too late; there is a bullet through the
lungs, and, with a little gasp, the officer lies still.

In a few minutes the other man recovers sufficiently to tell how they
were taking a dispatch through to the rear.  The officer was driving
the car when they ran straight into a patrol of enemy cavalry.  They
had got through, but the enemy opened fire, and now his officer lies
dead.  Things are going badly up there--and the man vaguely indicates
the country up north: our men are retiring as hard as they can; whole
regiments are getting wiped out; and "Gawd knows where the French are."
Can he get a motor-bike to take on the message?

An A.S.C. officer runs for his car, the man is put in, and off they
start again.

Only the A.S.C. lorry drivers understood the story, but the villagers
were quick to realise that something serious was happening.  Old Pierre
remembered 1870, and he knew what war meant; but to the rest it was a
new, hideous thing, dimly realised, but now, at last, with this mute
witness before them, very real.

Then things began to happen.  No one ever knows how a crowd will spring
up in a city street, apparently by magic, and here suddenly the village
began to fill with men.

Four soldiers--two Scots, a Dorset and a Bedford man--black with grime,
three days' growth of beard, hollow-eyed and limping painfully,
appeared in front of Pierre and asked where they were to go.  A captain
of the Guards, riding a tired farm-horse, with a colonel walking by his
side, one hand on the horse's flank, came behind, and, tackling the
A.S.C. captain, asked for something to eat.

"We've been on the trudge for twelve hours," said the colonel, "and
could get nothing.  No one knows where anyone is.  The regiment?  Badly
cut up last night and all scattered, heaven knows where."

"Is the mayor about anywhere?"  And a young Staff officer, with a
French interpreter, pushes his way through the crowd.

"A cavalry brigade (or what's left of it"--he adds in an undertone)
"will be here to-night.  What barns and houses have you available?  How
much hay can you get?"

Old Pierre is beginning to lose his wits in the amazing turn of events.

"If monsieur will come into the house I will try to arrange."

The officer follows, with a shrug of the shoulders which might have
meant many things.

The long summer's day is closing, but there is no hint of the evening's
cool in the heavy air.  All over the little village green, where the
church tower has thrown a grateful shadow, lie groups of men worn with
exhaustion and sleeping with gulping breaths.  In one corner Henriette
is busy with water and clean linen, bathing and bandaging horrible,
staring wounds.  And the men lie patiently, with now and then a moan of
pain, gazing up at her with the great round eyes of a hurt collie dog.

And now the vanguard of the retiring army begins to stream in and
through--all arms, all regiments.  Overhead a flight of aeroplanes
circle, like homing pigeons, seeking where they may alight.  It is
incredible that these are the regiments which a little ten days ago
swung gaily down the Aldershot roads.

At the head of the column there marches a field battery.  Two days ago
the major took it into action six guns and wagons strong, with perhaps
a couple of hundred men; so proud in his command, his men, his horses.

Now, stand by the path and watch the battery pass!  And, as it passes,
uncover your head, for it has returned from the very gates of Death.

Two guns--with three horses each to draw them.  There are still four
drivers left, and there are still half a dozen gunners.  On the first
limber ride a subaltern and the sergeant-major, and by the gun walk
another sergeant and the quartermaster-sergeant.  That is the battery.

On the second limber three men sit, swaying dizzily.  A captain of a
cavalry regiment and two privates of a Scottish regiment.

Here marches a battalion of the Guards.  Two days ago it went into
action perhaps 1,100 strong.  Uncover your head once again as it
passes, for these men too have looked Death in the face.

At the head there paces slowly an ammunition mule.  On it, wearing a
peasant's slouch hat, with breeches cut off above the knees, and with
left arm held close by a rough bandage, there rides the colonel.  Count
the men as they march past in fours: 80, 120, 160, 180, 220.  No, that
is the next regiment you are counting in.  Just 200!  That is the tale
of them.

Blackened by dust and powder, bearded, breeches cut short like those of
their commanding officer, the few puttees that are left to them wrapped
round their feet for boots--otherwise bits of sacking or cloth, bloody
bandages round heads or arms, some with hats like the colonel's, most
with none at all slowly they limp by.  And, as they pass, the A.S.C.
drivers silently offer such biscuits or bread as they have.  God, how
they wolf the food!

The colonel turns round on his "charger," and in a hoarse shout:

"Battalion!  'Tention!  Pull yourselves together, lads; a French
village!"

Ah, the pride of them!  The glory of race and blood!  This is not the
Mons country, with its blood-soaked memories; 'tis the Horse Guards
Parade, and we're Trooping the Colour!

The click of rifles coming to the <DW72> runs down the ranks.  The fours
line by magic as the men straighten themselves; it is a new regiment,
marching into action, which the French villagers see pass before them.

"Defeat?  Why, this is part of the joke!  Just to draw the Germans on
into the trap."  And at a word they would have turned to charge an army
corps.

And so the regiments pass.  And as the last of the Division goes
through, lights twinkle from the tiny windows of the cottages and the
great yellow moon climbs slowly over the poplar trees.  An A.S.C.
sergeant mounts a lorry with a copy of the Paris _Daily Mail_ in his
hand, and entertains an ever-growing audience with the news that the
Russians have invaded Germany and are marching on Berlin.

"It will be all over by Christmas--but I'd 'ave liked just one slap at
them Germans, so as I could tell the missis," says a late bus-driver.

But on the outskirts of the crowd the Staff officer is talking to the
A.S.C. captain:

"I've no orders for you, but you've evidently been forgotten.  You
ought to have had your park fifteen miles farther south by now.  Things
are bad, and there will be the hell of a scrap round here to-morrow
morning.  I should clear out if I were you."

Away up to the north there is a blinding electric glare coming fast
down the road.  Nearer, and it is the headlight on the first of a long
train of R.F.C. light motor-lorries, slipping silently down on rubber
tires.  The dust rises in clouds above and about them.  Half-way
through the village a motor-cyclist rides, meeting them.  The dust
takes his shadow, and as he approaches the headlight the silhouette
rises higher and higher until it mounts to the sky and disappears.
Just as when children play a shadow pantomime and vanish by jumping
over the lamp.

The lorries pass, and the dust slowly settles once more.  The little
lights twinkle clearly again, and the moon now floods the countryside
in a sheen of silver.

But the A.S.C. captain talks earnestly with his sergeant-major and M.
le maire.

"We must move, but how can we possibly carry all those wounded and
stragglers?"

M. le maire is of opinion that as _les Boches_ are being driven back
into Germany, the wounded might well remain until ambulances can be got.

The O.C. looks at his sergeant-major.  They have both guessed the
meaning of that retirement, and they guess also something that they
dare not tell the mayor.

A few minutes suffice to rouse all the men and to get the wounded made
as comfortable as possible in the lorries.  Lights are switched on the
cars, and within half an hour the column is clear of the village on its
way south.

An hour later the advance patrols of a German cavalry division ride in
from the north; and old Pierre finds that the hay he had collected for
_les anglais_ does not go very far with his new visitors.

Poor old Pierre, and Madame the mayoress, and the pretty little
rose-garden!

Such is a little pen-picture, not one whit exaggerated, of an evening
of the Retreat.  And perhaps those few lines will serve to convey some
trifling idea of the wonder of the achievement.

Everywhere regiments and units forgotten, or lost, or acting on their
own initiative.  And yet, somehow or other, making a composite whole to
turn and repel the attacking hordes.  Staff work practically ceased to
exist, and yet the threads of communication held fast, though only by a
little.

Now you have had a glimpse of the men who, the very next day, fought
_and won_ perhaps the most glorious fight a British Army has ever
shared in.

  So may a thousand actions, once afoot,
  End in one purpose, and be all well borne
  Without defeat.




CHAPTER XI

WEDNESDAY, THE 26TH OF AUGUST

  _We few, we happy few, we band of brothers;
  For he to-day that sheds his blood with me
  Shall be my brother; be he ne'er so vile,
  This day shall gentle his condition._

WESTMORELAND.  _Of fighting men they have full three-score thousand._

EXETER.  _There's five to one; besides, they all are fresh._

SALISBURY.  _God's arm strike with us! 'tis a fearful odds._


The night attack which the First Corps had so magnificently repulsed
was but the prelude to the greater attack of August 26th.  So imminent
did the danger appear to the Commander-in-chief, so tense was the
anxiety, that immediately after the firing had died away at midnight
orders were issued to the First Corps to march again at daybreak.  I
cannot attempt to dwell upon the condition of the men after the battle
of Sunday, the fighting and marching of Monday and Tuesday, and,
finally, the great fight of Tuesday night.  One can but quote the words
of Sir John French: "They were too exhausted to be placed in the
fighting line," and "were at the moment incapable of movement," and so
leave the rest to the imagination.

To that extent, then, had von Kluck succeeded in his scheme.  The First
Corps were temporarily out of action; the French, as the
Commander-in-Chief remarks, "were unable to afford any support on the
most critical day of all"; and to the Second Corps was left the task of
withstanding the whole German attack, designed to outflank them on the
left and roll them up.  And the odds against them were, as at
Agincourt, "five to one"; in guns, more than six to one.

Apart from his 3rd and 5th Divisions, General Smith-Dorrien had taken
under his command the detached 19th Infantry Brigade (composed of the
2nd Royal Welsh Fusiliers, 1st Scottish Rifles, 1st Middlesex, 2nd
Argyll and Sutherland Highlanders), the infantry and some of the R.F.A.
of the 4th Division, and two brigades of cavalry, out by Cambrai.

The line of the Second Corps on the Tuesday night extended, roughly,
from Le Cateau on the east to a little south of Cambrai on the west, or
a front of about fifteen miles.  Trenches had been hastily dug since
the previous afternoon.  East of Le Cateau was a big gap between the
two Corps.  This could not be bridged owing to the exhausted condition
of the regiments in the 2nd Division.

Some hours before battle was joined General Smith-Dorrien realised that
it was absolutely impossible for him to carry out the
Commander-in-Chief's instructions and continue his retirement in
conjunction with the First Corps.  A retirement in face of such
overwhelming numbers would have meant annihilation.  At 2 A.M. he
decided to fight, and reported so to his Chief.  Sir John French
replied that the retirement must continue.

"My only chance," rejoined the General, "is to do my utmost in
weakening the enemy's attack, and then seize such a moment as I can to
retire."

General Smith-Dorrien was on the field of action; Sir John French was
at G.H.Q., some twenty miles to the south.  The man on the spot,
realising that the only hope of stopping the enemy lay in a successful
action, proceeded with his plans of battle.  The fight began at
daylight.

About 7 A.M. General Smith-Dorrien informed G.H.Q. by telephone that
the battle was in progress, and that he was confident that he could
deal the enemy a smashing blow sufficiently heavy to gain time to
withdraw his weary troops.

"General," said the senior Staff officer over the telephone, "yours is
the cheeriest voice I've heard for three days.  I'll go and tell the
Chief."

The Commander-in-Chief, who did not approve of the decision to fight,
in reply instructed him "to use his utmost endeavours to break off the
action and retire at the earliest possible moment."


Le Cateau, after which this battle has come to be named, is a pleasant
enough little town set in a country-side not unlike the Sussex uplands
between Tonbridge and Hastings--broad, open pasture- and meadow-land,
cut by tiny valleys, rolling away south to the dip of St. Quentin.
Through the town runs one broad street, and here, in the town hall
offices, G.H.Q. had its habitation for a short spell earlier in the
week.  Opposite there was a little bun-shop and cafè combined, which
proudly announced: "English five o'clock tea."  The two buxom ladies
who dispensed the refreshing beverage must have overheard many a little
confidence exchanged between their unsuspecting officer clients, and we
heard later that one of the two had been shot as a German spy.

With the earliest dawn the firing began along the front with such a
curious spitefulness (if one could so call it) that many of our men
afterwards remarked about it.  There were evidently to be no half
measures about this attack, for the German infantry came on almost with
the first rounds from their guns, advancing in their usual masses and
making big play with their machine-guns.  It was good country for this
kind of work, while the cover our men got was generally only such as
they could make for themselves by digging.

The morning came on radiantly sunny, with the sky a lovely pale limpid
blue, washed clear by the downpour of the previous night.

"'An' 'tis a foine morning they'll be having in Lismore for the fair
this day," remarked a lad from County Cork; "but I would not be missin'
the fair _we'll_ be having for all the porter in Daddy Breean's ould
tent.  Ah, will ye look at that now!  Shure, 'tis the bhoys are coming
early for the knocks they'll be getting.  Will I be seeing how the
little gun is shooting this morning, yer honour?"

The platoon commander nodded, for Jerry was a privileged favourite.  He
was also a remarkably fine shot.

So Jerry nestled his cheek cosily down to his little gun and took a
deep breath, while the two or three near him looked on with interest.
Jerry lifted his head again, for he was an artist and knew the value of
arousing expectation.

"And will it be a golden sovereign if I take the coat-tails of the
little ould gentleman with the spy-glasses?"  This was Jerry's way of
making a bet.

"Yes; I'll bet you a sovereign you won't down that officer on the
right, and he looks like the colonel," said the platoon commander.  It
was a 500 yards' shot, and hazy, too.

Jerry carefully judged the distance by a half-way haystack, adjusted
his sight, and settled down once again.  "For the ould counthry!" he
breathed, and slowly squeezed the trigger.

The "little ould gentleman" was seen to clap his hand smartly to his
leg, while two men ran up to him.

"Will ye double the stakes, yer honour, for me to take the three o'
them?" said Jerry over his shoulder, clicking his bolt back and forward
again.

"A fiver, Jerry, if you do it."

Jerry wedged his rifle between two stones, took a slightly fuller
sight, and almost before you could have counted them three shots
cracked out.

"Have you that fiver on you, yer honour, or will I be taking an IOU?"
And Jerry leaned back with a sigh of satisfaction as a mighty cheer ran
down the trench, and the platoon officer shook him hard by the hand.
What the enemy thought about it one could only surmise, but a few of
the men shook their fists threateningly in the direction of the British
lines.


Now let us follow for a little the fortunes of a Brigade in a
particularly warm corner of the line close to a small town where a very
strong German attack soon developed.  The guns of the Brigade opened
fire at daybreak.  They had managed to dig some serviceable pits, and
were as snugly ensconced as time had allowed.

[Illustration: GENERAL SIR DOUGLAS HAIG.]

For an hour, perhaps, the German guns pounded steadily away without
making very much impression; and our R.F.A. as steadily replied.  Many
of the outlying farms and houses were badly knocked about and began to
burn fiercely.  About 7.30 the enemy made a determined attempt to get
hold of a flank position for their machine-guns to enfilade our
infantry; and it was then that one regiment lost horribly before our
cavalry could get round in a counter-attack.  So heavy were their
casualties that, as a regiment, they were simply out of action, and an
urgent message was dispatched to the next Brigade for anything they
could possibly send in the way of reinforcements.  Badly off though
they were, two battalions were promptly transferred.  Just one more
instance of working shoulder to shoulder.

It was curious how certain regiments suffered very heavily while other
units next to them got off comparatively lightly.  One R.F.A. brigade,
for instance, was right in the thick of the fighting from Mons to the
Aisne, and yet had very few losses until the middle of September, while
the battery next on their left on this Wednesday suffered very badly.
Of two other batteries I came across, one was in action right through
to the Aisne, and did not have a single casualty, while a second (most
curious of all), in the First Corps, never fired a shot until the big
advance of the Corps at the Aisne on September 14th.

About 9 A.M. things began to look serious.  Several enemy infantry
attacks had been met by desperate counter-charges; but numbers were
bound to tell.  A German cavalry regiment had succeeded in working
round to the flank, and now they made a gallant effort to capture the
British guns.

This was, I believe, one of the very few occasions when the enemy
cavalry had a real chance of getting any of our batteries by a charge.
There was a clear field, and they had got to within 500 yards of the
battery, when the guns opened on them.  Our men had heard about the
fatal charge of the 9th Lancers, and now it was their turn.  The
battery commander dropped to "fuse o, open sights," and the detachments
worked as though the devil were behind them.  In the next 250 yards the
cavalry lost a good two-thirds of the regiment, and they got no nearer
than 200 yards from the guns.  A British squadron luckily came out at
the moment, and charged clean through the remnant, wheeled, and cut up
what still remained.  And that was the end of that very game attack.

If only the Germans would always play fair, there would be nothing to
grumble about.  Their infantry cannot, of course, be compared with the
British, and our cavalry have always come out better than theirs in a
clean fight; but the Germans have always fought courageously when it
was a case of genuine fighting.  Indeed, it is a very poor compliment
to our men to suggest otherwise.

But the main attack, instead of being checked, seemed to gather
strength, until it became manifestly impossible to protect and hold the
little town any longer.  The infantry accordingly gradually withdrew
under cover of the guns, and at last the guns were limbered up and
marched back to another position farther south, the Brigade having held
the corner for something like four hours.

Most of the townsfolk had begun their flight late on the previous
evening, but a good many still remained.  Had they only known the fate
in store for them, the invaders would have found an empty town.  But,
at least in this case, vengeance was swift, as you shall hear.

The Brigade, then, took up its new position, and the men were able to
make themselves fairly snug before the enemy had finished with the
town.  Fortunately, too, many of our wounded were got away from the
hospital, for the Germans had begun to shell that some time before.
But it was a very trying business, as there were not enough ambulances
for the very large number of casualties, and many had to be carried on
the already overloaded regimental transport.


Now, it must be remembered that General Smith-Dorrien had absolutely no
reserves on which to draw if any part of his line began to bend back.
The usual plan is, of course, to keep certain fresh regiments
concentrated at given spots to move up in support as and when required.
But now, if the Inniskillings were getting badly cut up and a gap was
being made, the G.O.C. could only call upon the Cheshires, say, a mile
off, who were not being so strongly attacked, to send a company or so
to the help of their comrades.

Another thing.  I have hinted in a previous chapter that the threads of
communication with the ammunition supply were badly stretched to
breaking-point, owing to the astonishing speed at which the British had
to retire.  Normally, the ammunition parks (motor transport) draw the
ammunition supplies from railhead, and carry it up to the divisional
ammunition columns.  These, in turn, distribute to brigade columns, and
the actual units draw upon the last named.  Thus there are several
links between railhead and the firing-line, and the motor-lorries
should not come within about eight miles of the line.

But on this Wednesday and the two or three following days all this
arrangement literally went to pieces.  How could it be otherwise?  And
that is how the A.S.C. drivers came to do their bit with all the rest.
Speed was vital, and the lorries could cover the distance in a third of
the time taken by the horse transport.  In fact, the horse transport
was ignored or forgotten, although there were exceptions.  One saw the
divisional columns aimlessly trekking about the country, at one moment
under orders to go to a certain village, only to find on arrival that
the enemy were just a mile off; back they would come again as hard as
the tired horses could do it.

Time and again an urgent message would go back from a battery for more
18-pr. or howitzer, and the dispatch-rider would have instructions to
get the stuff wherever he could lay hands on it.  He generally managed
to find a few lorries of a "park," and so off the bus drivers would
start with their three-ton vehicles, little dreaming that they were
going under fire.

"Gor blimey, sir," said one of them next day to his officer, "I tell
yer it wos a fair beano!  We'd gone abaht a couple o' miles, when the
sergeant wot wos along o' me on the box 'e sez: 'Stevens,' sez 'e, 'can
yer knock anything more aht of 'er?  'Cos they're firing acrost the
road.'  Lor lumme, I nearly put 'er in the ditch at the turn 'e giv me!
Yer see, sir, I didn't enlist to get knocked aht by no b---- German.
I'm a peaceable man, I am, wot likes my grub and pint o' bitter reg'lar
like, and the missus the same.  But, as I wos a-sayin', I turned to the
sergeant an' I sez: 'Yer don't fink there's no danger, do yer?'  An'
the sergeant, 'e sez, sarkastic-like: 'Ho no, they're only bustin' the
shells on the road, an' we've got a few tons of fireworks be'ind wot's
bahnd to bust too if we gits 'it!'  S'welp me pink, sir, I turned that
cold you could 'ave 'eard my teeth going louder nor the enjin.

"'E 'adn't 'ardly spoke when there was the 'ell of a bang somewheres
just be'ind, and--well, you can bet your life, sir, we did a guy for
all we wos worth.  Lord, 'ow we 'opped it dahn that road!  I tell yer,
sir, we knocked forty-five miles an hour aht o' that ole bus, and she
come up to it like as we wos knockin' spots orf of a pirit bus dahn
Piccadilly.

"The sergeant, 'e jammed 'is 'eel dahn on the accelerator, an' I just
'eld on to the wheel wiv bofe 'ands.  It wos a fair old Brock's benifit
we wos in.  But we got frew orl right, and wen we got to the place
where we wos to drop the stuff, there weren't no guns wot wanted it.
An', as old G. R. Sims sez, 'hit wos the unkindest cut of orl.'  Well,
I wasn't coming back agin frew that pyrriteknikle show not for the ole
bus full o' suvrins, an' so we come 'ome rahnd by a place I forgit the
name of, and that's 'ow we're late; but it was worf the hextra thirty
miles rahnd, an' I 'ope, sir, yer won't mind this time."

There was another occasion on this day when three of these lorries went
forward under the charge of an officer.  He was quite unaware that the
village whence the call for howitzer shell had come had been captured
by the Germans half an hour after the message had been sent.  On the
way he picked up another officer who was lost.

Rounding a corner by a wood, about a mile from the village, they came
straight upon a small German cavalry outpost.  The Germans sprang to
their feet at the rumble of the approaching lorries, and a sergeant
stood in the road to bar the way.

There was not a moment for thought, and the second officer whipped his
pistol out and took a snap shot.  Luckily, he killed the sergeant
outright.  The officer in charge jumped down into the road as the lorry
pulled up, with his own revolver in hand, and levelled it at the group
by the roadside.  One of them got his carbine off from the hip, and the
shot just missed the first lorry driver on his seat.  The officer
promptly sent a bullet through the man's chest.  Over his shoulder he
shouted to the drivers to reverse the lorries, while he and the other
officer held up the Germans.

Now, reversing three big lorries in not too wide a road needs some
doing; but they all backed and advanced and sidled and backed until it
was done.  Then one officer jumped up behind the last one, the second
officer followed, and off the lorries went.

There was nothing remarkable about the little experience, and it is
only recorded to show the difficulties in ammunition supply at this
time and also how the A.S.C. drivers were doing their job.


You must imagine that while we have been at the rear with the A.S.C.,
the fighting all along the British line has been growing in intensity.
A big flank attack, with the idea of rolling up the whole line like a
ball of string, is always a favourite move of the Germans, and this
time they were trying to crush the British left.

But although the left was the main objective, the enemy still had a big
superiority in numbers for frontal attacks, and these they kept up
without ceasing.  It was just like the crashing of many mighty hammers
from one end to the other.

Following up the policy of making counterattacks whenever possible, a
bold offensive was made against the little town from which we had just
been driven.  The enemy had now been in possession for two or three
hours.  So word was passed to the batteries, some of the indefatigable
cavalry was concentrated, and the infantry, with the two reinforcing
battalions, received the cheering news that they were to advance.

How they all went at it!  Under the heaviest fire our guns could pour
in, the infantry rushed the outlying houses, the main street, and the
town itself, the cavalry sweeping up on the flank.  The gunners, after
raising the range to put a curtain before the infantry, limbered up,
and had the satisfaction of marching back through the town which they
had just been forced to evacuate.

Then it was that our men first saw a little of the hideous work of the
invaders upon the civilian population.  And if anything more were
needed to brace them up to fight to the last man, they had it in that
brief hour in the recaptured town.

The hospital was burning fiercely, just as that at Mons had done.  Such
a building, with its Red Cross flag, was always a convenient ranging
point for the enemy.  In it there had been some 400 wounded and other
casualties.  A large number of these had been got away, but a number
had, perforce, to be left.  Their end must have been too cruel to dwell
upon.

Up the main street everywhere was horrible evidence that _they_ had
been at work.  Mingled with dead or wounded combatants were bodies of
women and children, many terribly mutilated, while other women knelt
beside them, with stone-set faces or gasping through hysterical
weeping.  From behind shutters or half-closed doors others looked out,
blinded with terror.

But there was one thing which, for the men who saw it, dwarfed all
else.  Hanging up in the open window of a shop, strung from a hook in
the cross-beam, like a joint in a butcher's shop, was the body of a
little girl, five years old, perhaps.  Its poor little hands had been
hacked off, and through the slender body were vicious bayonet stabs.

Yes, close your eyes in horror, but it is right that our people should
hear and know these things.  There must be no false, vapid sentiment in
refusing to think about them.  There should not be a home in the
British Empire where the facts of German atrocities are not known, and
where, in realising them, hearts are not nerved to yield their last
drop of blood in stamping out from the world of men the hideous Thing
which has done them.

After that the Brigade "saw red."  There was no more talk of taking
prisoners, and if there was another ounce they could put into their
work they did it.  The sight of those poor distracted women kneeling
down in the road before our men, or hanging round their knees praying
to be taken away, would have melted the stoniest hearts.  The situation
was serious enough, for another German attack in force was bound to
follow, and the Brigade had little hope of getting away safely
themselves.  But they could not possibly leave the women behind
again--nor did they.  Somehow or other they escorted, on guns, limbers
and vehicles, all they could find safely on to the southward road,
sullenly retiring once more before the new counter-attack.




CHAPTER XII

  WEDNESDAY, THE 26TH OF AUGUST
  (_continued_)

  _A many of our bodies shall, no doubt
  Find native graves; upon the which, I trust,
  Shall witness live in brass of this day's work;
  And those that leave their valiant bones in France,
  Dying like men, ...
  They shall be fam'd._


By midday the tide of battle had begun to roll southwards, though only
by a very little.  The British lines were forced back, a mile here,
half a mile there, but they still held on with superhuman energy and
determination.  And not only did they hold on, but, wherever there was
the least chance, a regiment or cavalry squadron would launch a
counter-attack.  But it all seemed so hopeless, just as one might throw
pebbles into the waves of the sea as they break upon a beach.

Some day it is to be hoped that an adequate record will be published of
the remarkable work which the cavalry performed during the Retreat.
Sir John French, perhaps because he was himself a cavalry leader,
hardly mentions them in his first dispatch.  Wherever they were most
wanted, there they were in the thick of the fighting.  How the horses
"carried on" and where and how fresh animals were obtained remains a
mystery, in view of the muddle in which everything was.

But where every unit and every man worked as they did, it seems almost
invidious to single out for mention any particular regiment or episode.
Take a single half-hour of the fighting on the left, and you have an
example of what was repeated fifty times that day across the whole
British front.

A blue-grey mass of enemy infantry appears advancing with steady,
swinging pace.  At 500 yards or a trifle more one of our regiments
opens rapid fire upon them.  You can actually see the lanes in the
German ranks ploughed through by the British rifle-fire.  Still they
advance, for the gaps are filled almost immediately.  Nearer and
nearer, until that regiment which began the advance has almost ceased
to exist.  The remnant breaks and scatters in confusion, and as they
break away another new regiment is disclosed behind them.  Such is the
method of the German massed attack, overwhelming by sheer numbers.

But rarely did they get near enough to the British lines for a
hand-to-hand fight.  Regiment after regiment would be held at bay by
the murderous rifle-fire of the little handful of British; regiment
after regiment would appear to fill the gap.  Now and again the weight
of the attack would tell, and the Germans would get close enough for a
final rush on the British trench.  Then, at the critical moment, a
British company, slightly forward on the flank, pours in a withering
enfilade fire, and while the German infantry stagger under this
unexpected attack the British cavalry charge through our own lines
straight on the front and flank of the enemy.  There are a few minutes
of mad cut and thrust, and the Germans, who always dread the cold steel
as a Chinese dreads rain, break and run as though all the fiends of
hell were after them.


Just about this time General Smith-Dorrien and a couple of his Staff
officers were following the fortunes of the battle from some rising
ground not far from the centre of the line.  A sudden outburst of heavy
and incessant firing was heard from the direction of Cambrai, where, it
will be remembered, the enemy were trying to outflank us.

"Good heavens," cried the General, "the Germans have got round our
left!"  And, jumping on to his horse, he galloped off towards the
firing.

To his astonishment and delight he found, as he drew near the flank,
that the firing came not from victorious Germans, but from some of our
French comrades.

Never was help more opportune; seldom can it have come in more dramatic
fashion.  By all accounts General Sordêt with his cavalry should have
been sitting by the roadside, forty miles away on the British right,
tending his worn-out horses.  Yet, at the call for help, by sheer grit
and determination he and his Corps had carried through that long forced
march (Heaven knows how the horses did it!), and swept up on our left
with his squadrons and horse artillery.  Everyone knows what splendid
work the French gunners can do, and--well, this was one of their best
days.

It was a thrilling episode, and why, in common justice to our gallant
Allies, the details have not been published I do not know.  You will
find General Smith-Dorrien's record and appreciation of the invaluable
help thus given by General Sordêt in the second Appendix at the end of
the book.

While such were the conditions about midday up with the front line, the
situation immediately in the rear was fast becoming indescribable in
its confusion and complexity.  Looking back at it now, after the lapse
of so many months, it seemed very much like a theatrical performance
where a "front cloth" has been lowered to conceal from the audience a
strike of stage hands and the despair of the actors at setting the
stage and getting on with the play.  Before the front cloth a special
"turn" is performing to gain time and appease the growing impatience of
the audience.

There was, for instance, a particular centre of cross-roads, nearly a
mile beyond where German shells were bursting.  It was just outside a
large village, and the inhabitants were streaming out with their
belongings, yet uncertain whether there was actual danger or no.

At the cross-roads were gradually arriving ammunition columns, remnants
of battered regiments, motor-lorries, and odd cavalry patrols; and no
one had the vaguest idea as to why they were there nor where they were
to go next.  A Staff officer standing there was as much at sea as the
rest.  Every moment more and more transport would roll up, and more and
more stragglers, while hanging on to the outskirts of the crowd were
increasing numbers of frightened women and children.  An old curé alone
seemed calm and collected.  Over another village a little way back down
the road the German shells come bursting ever nearer.  It must be
remembered that even the Staff had but a hazy idea of the trend of
events, and that outside the Staff not a soul had any notion of what
was really happening to the Force.  It was just a matter of doing your
own special bit.

Right into this confused mass came running some R..A.M.C. orderlies.
"The Germans are just behind!" they shouted.  There might have been a
bad panic with all those civilians about, but there was only rather
more confusion.  The Staff officer gave a general order to retire on
St. Quentin (a large town about seven miles to the south); and then
there was one mad rush.

Motor-lorries blocked the whole road, trying to reverse, while wounded
and stragglers made a dash for the nearest vehicles.  Ammunition
columns struck off the road on to the open down-land.  The refugees
streamed straight across country.  Down the road the heavy lorries went
pounding, and soon outdistanced everyone else.  At one corner there
were two R.F.A. drivers in charge of five heavy draught horses.
"Germans be'ind us," yelled a lorry driver; "better move!"  And they
did move.  The sight of those old "hairies" clopping down the road at a
hand gallop after the disappearing lorries was too ludicrous for words.


By 3 P.M. the weight of the enemy's attack had begun to tell, and, to
quote the Commander-in-Chief's dispatch, "it became apparent that, if
complete annihilation was to be avoided, a retirement must be
attempted; and the order was given to commence it about 3.30 P.M."

Now came the most critical time of all.  At the beginning of the day
the enemy must have imagined that a retirement would be made at the
earliest opportunity.  But as the hours passed, and the British line
still held, the impression may have spread that they intended to fight
the day to a finish where they stood.  Certainly it is impossible to
think that had they realised a definite retirement to be in progress,
they would not have thrown every man they had upon the rear of the
Corps.

Slowly and cautiously, then, regiment after regiment fell back.  I have
tried to show in an earlier chapter what that means and how much
depends upon the guns at such a juncture.  Again I can only quote the
Commander-in-Chief's words: "The movement was covered with the most
devoted intrepidity and determination by the artillery, which had
itself suffered severely."

I will just give one instance of what that devotion meant, a devotion
which, as has everywhere been agreed, saved the situation.

Close under a ridge a battery had been in action without a moment's
rest for the last six hours.  One gun after another had been knocked
out, the battery commander and every officer save one killed, all the
men of the detachments killed or wounded, until there was left just one
gun, one subaltern, and one driver.  And still they kept the battery in
action; still they loaded and fired, as they had been doing all through
that ghastly day.

"Got a drink?" said the subaltern; "a cigarette?  Good!  Thank God for
a white man's cigarette again!"  And he went on with his job.  That was
what "covering the movement" meant.

But the battle had been won.  General Smith-Dorrien, his officers and
men, had accomplished the almost superhuman task thrust upon them.
They had not merely held the German attack through all the long hours
of that blazing August day; they had _broken_ it.  For the remainder of
the Retreat it never recovered its sting and energy, and so the Force
and Paris were saved.

Events have had time to shape themselves during the months that have
lapsed since August, 1914, and it is possible to view them in a certain
perspective.  It has been urged that we British have exaggerated the
importance of the work of the Force in the Retreat; that while we were
holding a line of no more than 20 odd miles, the French were extended
over a front of 400 miles against an equally strong attack; that, by
the prominence given to the work of the Force to the neglect of that of
the French, a distorted picture has been given of the operations during
August from Alsace to the sea.

To these arguments I would reply that Germany was staking everything
upon that rush to Paris.  For years past we had known that her
intentions were to bring France to her knees within the first month or
so, to admit of turning to meet Russia before that country had fully
mobilised.  And so, with this definite task in view, Germany
concentrated her main attack through Belgium and south by Mons.  She
had not only her greatest strength in the armies of von Kluck and von
Buelow, but she included in these masses of troops the flower of the
German Army, picked regiments like the Prussian Guard, the "Iron" 3rd
Corps of Brandenburg,[1] and others.  Add to these facts the sustained
violence of the invasion, and the concentrated hate which was levelled
against Belgians and British by the invaders when the attack was
continually and successfully checked, and I think that there is
sufficient evidence to indicate the vital importance of the work of the
British Force.

Moreover, the French people themselves had, with fine generosity,
recognised that it was the British Force, under God's hand, which had
saved Paris: for on Sunday, August 30th, prayers of thanksgiving were
offered up in the churches on behalf of our troops.


And now, hopelessly inadequate as this record has so far been, words
utterly fail me in attempting to describe the events of the next twelve
hours, and how the Retreat was continued.  It was one long, ghastly
nightmare.

As regiment after regiment received its orders to retire, the survivors
staggered to their feet, blinded by the ordeal of the day, and crept
back until they reached a point where ranks could be formed.  Then they
got moving.  Their destination no one knew, no one cared....  Keep
moving!  Men licked their blackened lips with parched tongues.  "Any
chance of a drink?"  "Not here; perhaps we shall pass a village."  Keep
moving!  "Got a fag on you?"  "Smoked the last this morning; perhaps
get some in the village."  "Where the b---- 'ell is your village?"
"Gawd knows." ... Keep moving!

Ten minutes later.  "Where the 'ell are we going? and why the ---- are
we retreating?  Give 'em socks, didn't we?  And where the ---- are them
---- Frenchies?"   "Oh, shut yer 'ed, carn't yer?" ... Keep moving!

There was a tiny village called Estrées in a hollow of the downs about
three miles out from St. Quentin.  Here at 4 P.M. the confusion was
indescribable.  Lorries, stragglers, refugees, transport columns,
guns--all inextricably mixed up.  It was, I believe, supposed to be a
bivouac point for the night, but no one knew definitely.  In any case,
they were all tightly wedged in that hollow, and the Germans were but a
very few miles behind.  Had an enemy battery come within range, as it
might well have done, it would have meant certain death for every soul
there.  Later in the evening news got to G.H.Q. of the position, and
rations were sent up to the starving troops, with definite orders about
further retirement.

Staff work simply went to pieces.  It was not that men lost their heads
or anything like that, but the various H.Q.'s found it impossible to
keep pace with events.  A regiment would be in a certain position, then
it would be completely forgotten (or so it seemed), and no orders would
arrive to move.  Many C.O.'s retired entirely on their own initiative,
and so got clear.  Others decided to await instructions, and so got
wiped out or captured.

As dusk gathered into darkness the confusion grew worse, while
discomfort increased (if possible) with the steady downpour of ram
which followed.  But there was no moment's rest for the exhausted
troops, save when a regiment came up against an obstacle across the
road--a broken-down motor-van or gun-wagon.  Then, if there were any
sappers handy, the vehicle would be blown up and the road cleared....
Anyhow, keep moving!

And the dreadful agonies of the wounded.  At St. Quentin there was a
big hospital which had been gradually filling during the past
twenty-four hours.  Now, on this afternoon, G.H.Q. found it advisable
to pack up in a hurry and leave for farther south.  And the
hospital--would it share the same fate as those of Mons and Le Cateau?
Once again the movable cases were hastily got into ambulances and other
conveyances, and carried off in the wake of G.H.Q.  But for hundreds of
men there was no chance of getting even so far as St. Quentin for
attention.  Through the day the R.A.M.C. had worked as hard as the
fighters, but it was very little more than first aid which could be
given.  No chance for deft operation, anti-tetanus serum or the like.

So, mingled with the retreating army were the ghosts of men swathed in
bloody bandages, some clinging to vehicles on which they had found a
seat, others marching with vague, uncertain pace by the infantry,
others, again, just dropping out, to huddle exhausted by the roadside
waiting for dawn and a fate which now had no meaning for them.

Keep moving! ... Horse after horse in the slowly trekking columns of
batteries or supply transport dropped down and fouled the wheels.
Unhook or cut the traces; push the poor beast out of the road.  An old
pal, was he?  Aye, he was a fine "wheeler," that dark bay!  Remember
the first time we had him in at practice camp?  Nothing matters now but
keeping on the move.  Yes, better shoot him.  He deserves a clean end.


Dozens, perhaps hundreds of men got cut adrift from their regiments
that day, adrift and hopelessly lost in a strange country.  No house,
no village was safe as sanctuary, for the tide of invasion lapped at
the threshold and would presently overwhelm it.  One trivial incident I
heard of seems worthy of record as an instance of "individuality" in
the training of the British soldier.

A man---we will call him Headlam--got adrift by himself from the 3rd
Division out on the left flank.  After many hours' wandering, he came
to a little farmhouse on the road.  Here the good woman took him in,
fed him, and gave him a shakedown.  There were also there a couple of
French stragglers.

A few hours later the little son of the farm came running in with the
news that a patrol of the dreaded Uhlans was coming down the road.
That meant murder for everyone.  There was no time to hide, and the
French were at their wits' end.

Headlam's first thought was for cover.  Out in the yard there was a big
rain-tub.  Calling the two French soldiers to help, they rolled it out
longways on into the road, and one of them, with Headlam, got behind
with their rifles.  The moment the patrol appeared, Headlam gave the
Uhlans an excellent example of rapid fire, and three saddles were empty
before they realised where the attack came from.  Then they charged.
French and British, side by side, ground away with their rifles, and
when the Uhlans reached the little fortress there were only three left
out of the patrol of nine.  The second Frenchman, by the side of the
road, accounted for another, and, with three to two, the Uhlans
surrendered.

So our three musketeers found themselves with five excellent horses and
a couple of prisoners; and I leave you to picture the triumphal
procession which passed through the villages on the southward journey.
The order of march was: Jacques and a led horse, Pierre and a led
horse, two disconsolate Uhlans on foot (and hating it), and Headlam
(with female escort), as G.O.C., bringing up the rear....


Keep moving! ... But oh, the inexpressible weariness of it!  No torture
is more refined than that of preventing a worn-out human being from
sleeping; and here it was experienced to the full.  The picture of the
Force that night might well have created for Dante the vision of one
more circle of Hell.

Hunger was long since forgotten, but a red-hot thirst remained.  One
could appreciate as never before how Dives thirsted when he asked for
Lazarus to touch his lips with a moistened finger.  On, ever on, for
hour after eternal hour, riding or trudging through the inky darkness,
never a halt....  Keep moving!

How the troops did it I cannot tell.  It was not the triumph of will
over the exhausted body, for the sense of volition had fled, and men
were mere automata in their movements.  The legs jerked forwards as
those of a clockwork toy.  Had the men halted they could never have got
moving again; the clockwork would have run down.

In the saddle it was little better.  Every muscle of the body ached
with an intolerable dull throbbing; a deadly coma crept through the
brain and dragged at the eyelids.  Nerveless fingers clutched at the
pommel of the saddle, and were pulled away by the drag of the heavy
arms.

One knows how a single night of sleeplessness will tell its tale in the
face of a man or woman.  Here was the fourth night of ceaseless
fighting and marching, with only an odd hour of rest now and again.

All through the night and on into the daylight hours sounded the
plod-plod of marching men, the grumble--creak--grumble of transport or
guns.  And in the far rear of the moving columns were more regiments
lined out, showing a bold front to the still advancing enemy, ever
guarding the backs of their comrades so far as was humanly possible.


One particularly sad disaster befell a regiment in the course of the
retirement; it is remarkable that there were not many others of a like
nature.  The 1st Gordons lost their way after dark, and began to march
in a direction across the front of the German advance.  About midnight
the regiment found itself moving into masses of troops.  The first
thought was that they were amongst the French, for it was supposed that
they had been marching towards French support.

Suddenly fire was opened upon the regiment from all sides, and though
the Gordons put up the gallant fight which they have ever done in a
tight corner, the odds were too impossible, and ten minutes saw the end.

I think that disaster affected the Force more than anything else in
that opening month.  Men spoke of it in hushed tones.  A magnificent
regiment with glorious traditions, and to be crushed out as they were
in those few minutes.  And yet not crushed out!  Though the older
generation of the family may die, there is the younger generation which
follows, and their sons after them.  And well do I remember that
younger generation at the Aisne, when the Regiment rose again
reincarnate from the ashes of the dead.  I see now the stern-set faces
of the officers, proud in their determination to avenge their honour;
faces shaded and hallowed by the knowledge of what the Regiment had
done and suffered, what it must now do and suffer that their dead may
rest in peace.  As it was, so shall it be,

  Rising, roaring, rushing like the tide,
    (Gay goes the Gordon to a fight)
  They're up through the fire-zone, not to be denied;
    (Bayonets! and charge! by the right!)
  Thirty bullets straight where the rest went wide,
  And thirty lads are lying on the bare hillside;
  But they passed in the hour of the Gordons' pride,
    To the skirl of the pipers' playing.



[1] This Corps is always regarded in Germany as the finest in the
German Army.




CHAPTER XIII

THE RETREAT CONTINUES

  _We are but warriors for the working-day;
  Our gayness and our gilt are all besmirch'd
  With rainy marching in the painful field;
  There's not a piece of feather in our host,
      *      *      *      *      *
  And time hath worn us into slovenry;
  But, by the mass, our hearts are in the trim._


The following days saw no rest for the exhausted troops, and they were
compelled to plod on ever farther and farther south.  If the rapidity
of the German advance was so astonishing, even more so was the speed at
which the British retired before them.  For it is a hundred times more
easy to do the advancing than the retiring.  In the former case there
is the confidence of success, with the feeling that at any moment the
coveted prize may be snapped up.  In the latter there is the inevitable
feeling that things are going wrong, that the army is suffering defeat,
and the constant dread that the troops may not stand the tremendous
strain upon their powers of endurance.

So it was that every encouragement was given to the rumour which ran
through the Force that this was but a strategical retirement, part of
the plan decided on years before between the French and British
Headquarters Staffs.  And the idea of the Retreat was that the British
were to draw the Germans ever southward, while the Belgian forces were
gradually closing in behind the invaders on the west, and the French
doing the same on the east.  Then at the psychological moment the
signal would be flashed round, the British would suddenly turn and
present a dead wall, the strings of the net would be pulled tight,
and--hey presto! we should all be home by Christmas.

There was only one part of the scheme which everyone regretted, and
that was that we should be out of the entry into Berlin.  It is all
very well to keep up your wicket while the other fellow makes the runs,
but then the other fellow gets all the credit.  You see, everybody knew
for a fact that the Russians were only a couple of days from the German
capital, and that heartened the Force almost more than anything else.
However, one consoled the men by telling them that regiments were sure
to be picked by ballot to represent the British in the march through;
and as for the newspaper prizes to the first man or regiment in--well,
that regiment would surely be sporting and share the prize.

How many times one must have explained this wonderful piece of strategy
to the good French folk I should not like to guess.  On passing through
a little village, generally at dusk, one of the things one always had
to do, after dispelling the fears of the ancient policeman who tried to
hold up the battery with an antiquated fowling-piece, was to draw maps
on the sanded floor of the café for the edification of the local
magnates.

"Why do we thus retire, madame?  But it is so simple.  It is a piece of
strategy of the most clever.  The Allemands"--here the audience spit
profusely--"come thus, the Belgians are here, etc.  etc.  At any moment
we turn to attack, etc.  How many English, madame?  Ah, madame, it is
not permitted to tell; but for your ear, madame (and I would tell no
one else), they say that the second quarter of a million disembarked
yesterday."

Perhaps our kindly hosts will by now have forgiven us, but at least
much of it we believed ourselves at the time.  It all helped to keep
the men going and prevent sudden panic with the countryfolk.  It is
difficult to say whether we did wrong.

By 8 A.M. on the Thursday the retiring columns were well on their way
beyond St. Quentin.  The First Corps, during the eventful Wednesday,
had also been steadily retiring, and had had comparatively little
fighting to do.  The condition of the troops will be remembered.

About half an hour later the rear-guard reached St. Quentin.  The
batteries marched in, watered their horses in the square, and marched
out again immediately, the infantry covering them outside the town.

It was a little curious in St. Quentin--the attitude of the
inhabitants.  No one seemed to take any interest in the British
movements, and certainly no one appeared to bother himself one atom
about the German approach.  St. Quentin is a big garrison town, with
fine open places and streets, excellent shops and stately buildings,
and the wealth of the place must be great.  Yet there was never a hint
of an exodus, and the people accepted the whole situation with
astonishing sang-froid.  I believe that when the Germans did arrive, a
little later in the day, they surrounded the town and marched in from
all sides at once, to find their triumphant entry opposed by--one
British soldier.  This man had got lost or left behind in a house, and
now turned out with his rifle to defend the town.  The German division
had to open fire with a machine-gun upon the gallant lad before he
fell, face to the enemy, riddled with bullets.  The war can have
witnessed few more remarkable episodes.

The fact that the R.F.A. with the rearguard were able to continue their
retirement throughout the day without having to fire a round will show
how well the Second Corps had smashed the German attack.

It should also be recorded that on this Thursday and Friday the Force
had further help from the French.  General Sordêt's cavalry continued
its excellent work in relieving the pressure on the left of the Second
Corps.

G.H.Q. had moved from St. Quentin on the Wednesday afternoon, and taken
up their abode at Noyon, a cathedral town about 30 miles farther south.
Here, again, no one seemed to have the slightest inkling of impending
danger, and the business of the town was being carried on as usual.
The mayor certainly posted a proclamation imploring the "citoyens" to
remain calm and to pay no heed to rumours, and the citoyens obeyed by
wondering why M. le maire should have so put himself about as to issue
such a notice.

That was on the Thursday.  But on the Friday the citoyens received
something of a shock.  A number of British regiments marched through in
broad daylight, and it was now plainly to be seen that something very
serious was happening.  After the first gasp of astonishment and utter
incredulity, the people stood by the road in dead silence with tears of
pity running down their cheeks.  So long as I live I can never forget
that scene, the intense drama of it, the tragedy, and the glory of
achievement which shone radiantly forth.

The remnants of three gallant regiments we watched go by, and we could
look no longer.  There is no need to say which they were, for they were
but typical of all the other regiments in the Force that day.  Again
there were but a poor 200 men left of each 1,000.  Officers and men
alike in their pitiable destitution.  Barefooted, or shifts of bandages
round their swollen feet; torn breeches, cut short like football
knickers.  Great bearded men they were, with the grime and dust of five
terrible days' incessant fighting and marching upon them; but in their
eyes the unquenchable light of their native pluck and steadfastness.
There was no trace of defeat there, only the hungry, dazed look of men
who long for a little sleep before they turn once more to crash their
way into an enemy's ranks.

It is not such things as these that our people at home are told, and so
I set them down.  Tales of gallant deeds in the fighting-line they have
now in plenty, but the great human side of this bloody war is passed
over in discreet silence.  England knows nothing of the meaning of
modern war; she has not suffered invasion, save from the predatory
attacks of aircraft.  Her sons are fighting for her, and the knowledge
thrills our womenfolk; but of the conditions under which they have
fought, and of the appalling sufferings of tortured Belgium and France
and Poland and Serbia, they are hopelessly ignorant.  If but a tenth
part were thoroughly realised there would be one mighty irresistible
cry from the heart of the civilised world:

"Stand at nothing to finish this war at once, and it shall be the last!"

There are no such things as neutral nations.  If a nation refuses to be
enrolled for Civilisation, then it is fighting by the side of the
obscene Horror which has plunged Europe into this carnival of blood and
misery.

On the Friday afternoon some of us learned from a wounded French lancer
that the German centre had been badly smashed and was actually retiring
from St. Quentin, owing to a French counter-offensive; also some of our
cavalry had been doing specially good work south of that town.  The 3rd
Cavalry Brigade broke and beat back the Prussian Guard and another
cavalry regiment, and the 5th Cavalry Brigade had a similar success
with other German cavalry.

In the meantime G.H.Q. had removed still farther south to Compiègne,
and occupied Napoleon's magnificent palace, or a wing of it.


It had been intended to give the Force a really good rest when they
reached the River Oise on the Friday night.  By that time the British
line (both Corps) ran along the river from La Fère to Noyon.  But it
was, after all, little more than five or six hours which could be
spared; many of the regiments and batteries did not even get that brief
respite.  "Keep moving" was still the order of the day.

But for the fortunate it was a glimpse of Paradise.  It meant, above
all else, a proper all-over wash and a clean shirt, even though you had
to wash it yourself.  It meant the luxury of a shave, if you could
manage to get hold of anything in the shape of a razor.  There was a
square meal served out, and there were two or three hours of blessed
sleep, when you lay with next to nothing on (for your shirt was drying)
under a shady tree.  It was all little enough, and, truth to tell, most
of the men could only turn out of the ranks to fall straight into the
sleep of utter exhaustion, a sleep of the clock round had it been
allowed.

Tobacco in those days was a luxury, and it was needed most.  Now there
is a regular weekly ration, and in addition kind friends at home see
that the supply of cigarettes does not fail.  But in the Retreat the
usual substitute was dried tea-leaves rolled in the parchment paper of
the emergency ration.  Tea-leaves are very nasty to smoke, but I am not
sure that they are so nasty as brown paper or the seat of a
cane-bottomed chair; and I have tried them all.

The men's equipment, too, was a constant source of trouble.  They would
throw away their greatcoats and packs, anything to march as lightly as
possible.  The Germans must have had a fine haul, and there were
several occasions when they dressed up their infantry companies in
British greatcoats and caps, and got well up to our lines before their
identity was discovered.

And that reminds me that in Noyon we caught a German spy wearing no
fewer than three different uniforms.  First, a French; over it a
Belgian; and on top of these a khaki greatcoat with cap.  It was a very
hot day, and the man's obvious discomfort was the first thing to give
him away.  It did not take ten minutes to settle that little affair.

By the time the two corps joined up again the refugee problem had
become really serious.  All the way back the army of unfortunates had
been steadily growing larger, and it was but natural that they should
hang on to the skirts of the Force for protection.  How many of the
poor women and little children died of exposure and exhaustion, it is
impossible to tell.  Our men were themselves badly off for food, but,
needless to say, they were always eager to share their emergency
rations with those who had nothing at all save what could be garnered
in wayside village or cottage.

Rules about commandeering are most rigid; nothing must be taken without
payment, or at least a voucher.  I remember one C.O. buying a couple of
fruit trees for his unit.  But it went to the men's hearts to leave
behind them tender chickens and toothsome bunnies, even though there
was no chance of cooking them, to be snapped up by Germans with no such
qualms of conscience.

Yet, to give the Germans credit, they did, in many cases, give written
receipts for provisions when it was a question of an odd duck or bale
of hay; but when a house was properly ransacked the receipt given more
usually bore the signature of that redoubtable warrior, Herr von
Koepenick.  It was one of the very few occasions when they showed a
sense of humour, if one can call it so.

Amongst those fortunate regiments which had been able to snatch the few
hours' rest there was a very general, and a very natural, impression
that a definite stand was now going to be made.  The position was a
good one, and it was also confidently expected that more divisions were
being hurried out from England as fast as ship and train could bring
them.

Perhaps, under other circumstances, the stand might indeed have been
made.  But what we did not know was that the main French Armies away to
the east were being dealt a series of such smashing blows by the
Germans that they were retiring almost more quickly than we were.


Although we are concerned here solely with the fortunes of the British
Force, yet it must be remembered that the fighting on the west was only
a small part of the general engagement, and that the Force had
necessarily to conform with the main strategical idea.  The capture of
Paris would have been of incalculable moral value to the Germans.  They
recognised this, and therefore made that special bid for it.  But the
triumphant entry into Paris would have possessed no _real_ value so
long as the French and British Armies were still "in being."  Just as,
later, the capture of Warsaw was of little real value (save as a
strategic centre), because the Russian Armies had escaped.

The position, then, on Saturday morning, the 29th, was:

(_a_) The Force was retiring, not too severely pressed by the enemy,
but with continuous rear-guard actions.

(_b_) Two new French Armies (the 6th and 7th) were coming into position
on our left, by Amiens and Roye.

(_c_) On our immediate right was the 5th French Army, the one which had
suffered so badly after the fall of Namur.

(_d_) Generally, the French forces on the east were being steadily
pushed back by the very strong enemy advance.

On that morning the Commander-in-Chief received a visit from General
Joffre, and this is what took place.  I quote from Sir John French's
second dispatch:

"I strongly represented my position to the French Commander-in-Chief,
who was most kind, cordial and sympathetic, as he has always been.  He
told me that he had directed the 5th French Army on the Oise to move
forward and attack the Germans on the Somme with a view to checking
pursuit.

"I finally arranged with General Joffre to effect a further short
retirement towards the line Compiègne--Soissons, promising him,
however, to do my utmost to keep always within a day's march of him."

It may be noted here (although, of course, we did not know it till much
later) that, owing to the German advance on the west, Le Havre was
evacuated as the British base, and the organisation, stores, hospitals
and everything, were rushed at half a day's notice right down to St.
Nazaire, at the mouth of the River Loire.  It was an amusing episode in
the war, and quite a happy little yarn it would make; "but that is
another story," as Kipling says.

On the Saturday evening the Force was got on the move again, heartened
and not a little refreshed.  The country-side now was as lovely as any
district in France.  Gentle, undulating downs, crowned by the beautiful
forest of Ligues, and besprinkled with dainty little villages and
stately châteaux.  If these lines should chance to be read by the mayor
and mayoress of a certain little village hard by Compiègne, I would beg
them to believe that the officer whom they so graciously entertained
for those brief hours remembers their kindness with the deepest
gratitude, and records the day as one of the most perfect he has ever
spent.  Officers and men made so many good friends even during those
crowded hours of life, only to realise with heartfelt sorrow that
perhaps half a day later their kindly hosts must have been engulfed by
the tide of invasion.

I vividly recall how curious seemed that order to go on retiring when,
from all accounts, the German centre had the previous day been so badly
beaten.  Madame's instincts, when the order came, were only too
correct.  She guessed the truth; we continued our trek hopelessly blind
to the real facts.




CHAPTER XIV

PAST COMPIÈGNE

KING HENRY.  _The sum of all our answer is but this:
  We would not seek a battle, as we are;
  Nor, as we are, we say we will not shun it.
      *      *      *      *      *
  We are in God's hand, brother, not in theirs.
  March to the bridge;
  Beyond the river we'll encamp ourselves,
  And on to-morrow bid them march away._


The destruction of a bridge, especially if it spans a river, always
seems to me so pathetic.  Bridges are such companionable things; they
fall so readily into one's mood, and there are, I imagine, few persons
who do not possess pleasant memories of one or another.  Whether in
town or country, there is always fascination in staying one's journey
for a few minutes to lean over the parapet and watch the stream--the
basking of a trout amongst the pebbles, the sway of the water-weeds,
the trailing of heavy barges, or the twinkling shore-lights.

In Compiègne there is a particularly handsome structure which spans the
River Oise.  The French people love a noble bridge to ferry their broad
highways over the rivers, and I cannot help thinking that it was not
alone special reliance upon the workmanship of our sappers which
induced the French authorities to resign to them the destruction.  For,
whenever possible, British sappers were called in for the work.  They
made such a clean job of it, the French would say.  No; it was, I feel
sure, their affection and pride for beautiful works of art with tender
associations that made them reluctant to lay sacrilegious hands upon
them.

It must have been on Sunday, the 30th, that the last of the Force
marched through or past Compiègne, and the bridge, besides many
another, was blown up.  The R.F.A. of the rear-guard passed through the
town and halted, guns unlimbered, about 500 yards out the other side,
ready to open fire, if necessary, for they were being hard pressed.
The fuses were laid and lighted literally in face of the advancing
enemy, and two R.E. officers who were doing the work were killed by
enemy bullets.  With a terrific crash the bridge fell, cut in two, and
the retirement was continued while the Germans hurled impotent curses
and (at that time) ineffectual shells after the column.

The Second Corps had now reached country which was very difficult; not
only for manoeuvre, but especially so for transport.  Immediately after
you leave Compiègne its glorious forest is entered, and directly that
is passed it is a country of very steep ravines, thickly wooded, with
little villages clinging limpet-like to the ridges.  The heat of the
day, too, was most trying.

The First Corps, which had joined up at Noyon, crossed the Aisne, and
continued its retirement via Soissons.

The German pursuit, which during the last two or three days had seemed
to slacken off, began to get serious again on the afternoon of Monday,
the 31st.

About 3 P.M. three field batteries and the Brigade of Guards (First
Corps) were out by Villers-Cotterets, and the Germans were pushing on
almost as fast as they did during the first days.  Their guns came into
action at about 1,700 yards, and as our brigade there was far
outnumbered, orders were given to go on retiring.

Well, the major of one of the batteries was "fed up" with retiring
without getting some of his own back, so he put his telescope (a
battery carries a telescope) to his blind eye and said he'd be hanged
before he retired (or words to that effect), and "let's give them a
dressing down first."

So it was "Halt; action right!" and, after a couple of ranging shots,
"Two rounds gun-fire!"  And that was all that battery got in.  The
Germans put a couple of guns out of action, and then turned their
attention to the wagon line, where they made a considerable mess-up
with the teams.

That settled it.  "Signal the teams up and let's get out of it!" said
the major; and it was so.  The quartermaster-sergeant put the fear of
God, not the Germans, into the drivers; up came the teams, "rear limber
up," and away they went, damaged guns and all.  The Guards meanwhile
had gone on.

There was nothing particularly heroic about it all, but it was very
excusable, and it certainly helped to buck the men up a little.

The Guards, however, gave further excellent evidence of their fighting
qualities in a series of stiff hand-to-hand encounters in the forest
glades.  While they suffered badly, they succeeded again and again in
beating back the enemy's attacks, and so further relieving the pressure
on the rear.


Now, despite the continuous fighting and marching, there was no doubt
whatever that the men were daily becoming more war-hardened and fit.
The worst was over, and with that firm conviction their spirits grew
lighter.  During the first few days the troops were marching perhaps 25
to 30 miles a day, apart from the fighting.  Take, for instance,
Wednesday, the 26th.  The men had begun that great fight practically
tired out.  They fought all day, and then at the end of it did a
retirement of some 25 miles.  Staff officers were simply worn out by
the nerve-racking ordeal, and General Smith-Dorrien himself says that
he did not average more than two hours' sleep during the first six days.

But the week's campaigning had done more for the troops than ten years'
peace work.  Their self-reliance, their confidence in and affection for
their officers were evidenced in a hundred ways; while officers, for
their part, had perfect confidence in their men and knew that, however
impossible an order might seem, it would be carried out.  The Force
was, in short, one big happy family.  Everybody seemed to know
everybody else, and that meant that everybody helped everybody else.
After the Marne it was never quite the same, because the Force began to
increase in size.  New-comers were immediately recognised, and the old
hands could never resist a momentary exhibition of very pardonable
pride at having "been out since the beginning."

The heavy losses in officers and N.C.O.'s had an inevitable effect on
discipline, though it might well have been worse had not the sense of
discipline amongst the rank and file been so strong.  It must be
remembered that so soon as the vanguard of the retiring Force passed
through a village, practically the whole of the inhabitants would pack
up such few of their belongings as they could carry on light carts,
perambulators and any available vehicle, and then join the ever-growing
stream of refugees.  So the next units to pass through would find
nothing but empty houses, and the temptation to carry away a few
"souvenirs" was very hard to check, especially in the case of food.

One man of an infantry regiment "found" a horse wandering loose in a
field.  He was very tired, so why, thought he, should he not take what
the gods sent him?  He did, and rode the horse for a couple of days.
Knowing nothing about horses, the poor beast got little enough to eat,
and the man thought that the heaven-sent gift was becoming a nuisance.
So he talked the matter over with a pal, and swopped his charger for--a
packet of Woodbines!  And I don't think the pal was a canny Scot either.

I remember particularly the date September 1st, and going through the
little town of Crépy-en-Valois, because we then realised for the first
time that something was wrong about that "strategical retirement"
business.  Our maps included Belgium and all N.E. France, but Compiègne
was the farthest point south; and when we had retired below that town
we knew that retreat so far south was not a part of the original scheme.

Then most of us saw some French troops for the first time, and, ominous
sign, they were always engaged in barricading and mining the roads,
opening the barricades to let us pass through.

But Tuesday, September 1st, must ever be a red-letter day in the annals
of the Royal Regiment, on account of the famous fight of L Battery,
R.H.A., at Nery, hard by Compiègne.  I always regard that episode as
one of the most wonderful incidents in this war.  Nor do I think so
because it was my own regiment, though naturally one can appreciate it
the more from being a Gunner.  The story is, of course, well known, but
no repetition can mar the effect, however bald the telling of it may be.

L Battery was working with the 1st Cavalry Brigade, which was made up
of the 2nd Dragoons (Queen's Bays), the 11th Hussars, and the 5th
Dragoons.  For the benefit of the uninitiated it may be explained that
a horse artillery battery of six guns forms an integral part of a
cavalry brigade; wherever the cavalry go, there can go the "Horse
Gunners," for the gun is of lighter calibre than that of the field
batteries.

About 2 o'clock in the morning word reached Second Corps H.Q. that a
strong force of Germans, 90 guns and cavalry, was moving towards the
1st Cavalry Brigade in bivouac at Nery.  The Third Army Corps, which
was still included in General Smith-Dorrien's command, was also not far
away.  Our cavalry were actually bivouacked within about 600 yards of
the Germans, and I believe that our outposts were, for some reason or
other, not sufficiently advanced.

In an earlier chapter, writing of Captain Francis Grenfell, I have
remarked that there was one other to whose life might well be applied
the phrase: "_Sans peur et sans reproche_."  That other was Captain E.
K. Bradbury, of L Battery.  All that I have ventured to say of Grenfell
I would say also of Bradbury.  I doubt whether there ever lived a
Gunner officer who was more beloved by his men, or one more worthy to
be so beloved.  And when that is said, what else remains?

Half-past four in the morning, and the mists have scarcely begun to
rise above the beech trees.  You picture the guns of L Battery parked
in line just on the downward <DW72> of a slight hill and in a little
clearing of the woods.  The horses of the gun-teams are tethered to the
gun and limber-wheels; others are down at a little stream hard by,
where some of the men are washing and scrubbing out their shirts.  The
Queen's Bays are in bivouac in a neighbouring field.

"Some of our scouts out there, aren't they?" remarked a shoeing-smith,
pointing to some rising ground about 500 yards to the north; "or is it
French cursers?" (cuirassiers).

"Looks more like Germans to me," said one of the gunners.  "Let's have
a squint through the telescope."

"What's up?" said the sergeant-major, passing at the moment.

"Half a mo!" mumbled the gunner, eye glued to the battery telescope.
"Yes, it is--Germans--I can see the spiky helmets."

"Rot," returned the sergeant-major; "can't be!"

"Anyway, I'm off to report to the captain," said the gunner.

Bradbury was talking to the horses by one of the guns when a breathless
gunner of the battery staff appeared with the telescope.

"Beg pardon, sir, but there are----"

CRASH!  A percussion shell burst clean in the middle of the battery,
followed the next instant by a couple more.  And in the few moments'
breathless pause it was realised that practically every horse and every
driver was either killed outright or wounded.

"Action rear!" yelled Bradbury, who found himself in command.

Their leader's voice above the unholy din pulled them together, and the
gun detachments, such as were left, leaped to the trails to get the
limbers clear.  But no more than three guns could they get into action.

Now a tornado of shell and machine-gun bullets from close range burst
over and through the devoted remnant--Bradbury, three subalterns
(Giffard, Campbell and Mundy), the sergeant-major, a sergeant, a couple
of gunners, and a driver.  And in action against them were ten German
field-guns, and two machine-guns enfilading from the wood.

Of their three guns, they had now to abandon two.

"All hands number 2 gun!" called Bradbury, who, with the sergeant, had
already opened fire.

The others rushed the few yards to Bradbury's gun; but even in that
short space Giffard was hit five times.  Bradbury acted as No. 1
(layer), the sergeant No. 2, while Mundy acted as observing officer.
One of the gunners and the driver carried across all the ammunition by
hand, through the hail of lead, from the firing battery wagons.

The range was, say, 600 yards, but in such a nerve-racking storm it was
difficult for the little detachment to work clearly with no one to
observe the burst of the shells.  There was only a little chance, but
Mundy took it, and stepped calmly out from the shelter of the
gun-shield to observe.

Then No. 2 gun began its work in earnest.

"Five minutes more left," said Mundy; "add twenty-five."

Crack went the report.  "One out!" said Mundy.

"Ten minutes more right; drop twenty-five."

Crack again!  "Short," murmured Mundy; then, "add twenty-five."

"Two out!" he counted.

When three German guns had been counted out, Bradbury called over his
shoulder to the sergeant-major:

"Take my place; I'll load for a bit."

He had barely changed places when a bursting shell carried away a leg
at the thigh.  Yet, by some superhuman will-power, he stuck to his post
and went on loading.

Now Mundy was mortally wounded.  Then Campbell fell.  But still the gun
was served, laid, and fired.  And as surely were the German guns being
counted out, one by one.

Then there burst true another shell.  The gallant Bradbury received his
death-wound, and his other leg was carried away.  The rest of the
detachment were all wounded.  Still that tiny remnant stuck to it
through the storm.

Now only are left the sergeant-major, Sergeant Nelson, the gunner, and
the driver.  Still they work.  Still they watch one enemy gun after
another ceasing to fire, until all are counted out but one.

All the ammunition is finished.  Nothing left now but to crawl back out
of that hell.  I Battery coming up?  Well, they can finish it.  Lend us
some "wheelers" to get our guns back.

So were the six guns of L Battery brought out of action.  Torn and
battered, but safe.  Glorious relics of perhaps the most wonderful
action a battery of the Regiment has ever fought--and won.

I Battery opened on the massed columns of the German cavalry now
appearing, and rent mighty lanes through their ranks, turned and
scattered them.  The Queen's Bays, who had been working as infantry,
for their horses stampeded when the firing began, collected up, and
with I Battery and the Lincolns went over the hill after the retiring
enemy.

There they found the German battery out of action and abandoned.

And Bradbury?  His last conscious words were an appeal for morphia and
to be carried away as quickly as possible that his men might not
witness his agony and be unnerved.

So passed that heroic soul away.  A life nobly spent, a death nobly
encountered.

  Nothing is here for tears,
    ... nothing but well and fair
  And what may quiet us in a death so noble.




CHAPTER XV

THE FINAL STAGES

FRENCH KING.  _'Tis certain he hath passed the river Somme._

CONSTABLE OF FRANCE.  _And if he be not fought withal, my lord,
  Let us not live in France: let us quit all,
  And give our vineyards to a barbarous people._


The fighting in the neighbourhood of Compiègne developed into something
of a general action, an action in which the British more than held
their own.  There was some doubt whether the 4th Division would be able
to shake off the heavy attack which was being made upon them, so
another brigade was ordered to their help.  The retirement was then
easily effected.

The 3rd Brigade was a little north of Crépy-en-Valois, and, without
waiting for the enemy, themselves made a spirited advance for a short
distance, and did excellent work with their R.F.A. against the German
infantry.

Soon after midnight on Wednesday, September 2nd, the Force continued
its retirement.  There may have been some little grumbling, and it
became increasingly difficult to keep up the old fiction--now indeed a
fact--about a "strategical retirement"; but, somehow or other, a
genuine conviction was stealing through the ranks that at any moment
the real end would come.  If our men were very, very weary, so also
were the enemy, and every day brought fresh evidence of the fact.

Then, too, news came to us that the French (the 7th Army) were really
tackling von Buelow's armies, and were doing well against them.  That
had a very inspiriting effect.

Now the Force, or rather our left, was actually in sight of the
outlying forts of Paris, about a dozen miles off.  Great was the
excitement, for, of course, everyone jumped to the conclusion that we
were making for the capital.  G.H.Q. was at Lagny-sur-Marne, just 15
miles due east of Paris.  They actually got as far south as Melun, on
the outskirts of the Forest of Fontainebleau, before the tide turned.

If you look at these places on the picture-map you will see that, after
Senlis was passed, the Force, instead of retiring straight on towards
Paris, as it had been doing, now swung round, with the right flank of
the First Corps as pivot, and marched in a south-easterly direction.
Possibly the enemy imagined from this that their chance had come, and
that they would now be able to slip in between our left and Paris.  But
the new French army was coming up from behind Paris, upon our left, to
fill the gap and cover the approaches to the city.

That swinging round movement to cross the River Marne was rather a
risky business, for it meant marching for a certain distance across the
enemy's front.  However, it was successfully accomplished, and by the
evening of September 3rd the Force was south of the river.  That same
afternoon our aircraft reported that the Germans had also swung
eastwards, and were now apparently making for the large town of
Château-Thierry, the point of division between our extreme right and
the 5th French Army.

The position in which the Force found themselves that evening was
wellnigh hopeless from a defensive point of view.  To make matters
worse, we were very badly off for entrenching tools, the men having
lost the greater part in the hurried retirement after the hard battle
at the Wednesday.  This question of entrenching tools was further
complicated by the removal of our base to St. Nazaire, for that meant a
much more serious difficulty in getting up supplies.

I forgot to mention that when orders reached the Second Corps and 4th
Division on the Thursday night to keep on the move, instructions were
given by G.H.Q. to abandon everything, even the ammunition, which might
<DW44> the transport, and so to leave the vehicles free for wounded or
the more exhausted of the men.  Only one Division carried out the
order, and that only partially, before the G.O.C. Second Corps on the
spot realised it was unnecessary and countermanded it.


During and after the battle of Le Cateau, as I have said the fight of
the Wednesday has come to be spoken of, a rather curious adventure
befell one of the motor transport ammunition parks About ten of the
lorries, under an A.S.C. subaltern, had been doing some detached work
away from the main body.  These had got out of rather a tight corner,
but the rest of the park (some sixty odd lorries) had become involved
in that mix-up at Estrées.

About 3 P M. the A.S.C. captain in charge received an order to go back
in the direction of Le Cateau.  This was, apparently, straight into the
advancing enemy, who were only some three or four miles off.  The C.O.
obeyed his orders and took his lorries back.  From that moment those
sixty great lorries vanished into thin air, and not a soul knew what
had happened to them.  At G.H.Q. the unit was officially reported as
"missing," and it so appeared, I believe, in the London Press.

The subaltern invented and spread abroad a delicious yarn.  I omit his
version of his own adventures, for he got a "mention in dispatches" for
it, though this was subsequently quashed.

When the order to go back was received, he said, and annihilation of
the park seemed certain, the O.C. called his subalterns together and
told them the position.  They unanimously decided to obey and charge
the advancing enemy with the lorries.  The drivers (our old friends the
busmen) were instructed to go full speed ahead into the enemy column.
But the drivers were not having any.  So the officers produced their
revolvers and threatened to shoot any man who refused to obey.  That
decided them.  "We will die by German bullets rather than British."  So
away they went, the lorries bumping along the road straight into the
ranks of the astonished Germans.  Nothing could stop them, and the
column got through (the narrator forgot to mention where to) with the
loss of about half the park.

The subaltern carried his arm in a sling for a fortnight afterwards.  A
shrapnel splinter, he said, when they were rushing the enemy.  It had
really been caused by the back-fire of a motor-bike.  Possibly this is
the origin of that glorified picture which appeared in certain of the
London illustrated papers.

The park was, however, actually lost for nearly a week.  They had
vanished as completely as though the earth had opened and swallowed
them.  They were eventually heard of by the merest accident, when a
sergeant came in to one of the towns on the line of retreat to get
provisions.  But even then they could not be found, for the sergeant
had gone again without leaving his address.  So for days Staff officers
scoured the country in swift cars, and thus the park was eventually run
to earth.  No one was more surprised than the C.O. to hear that he had
been lost.  They had not seen a single German, and they had had such a
jolly time, thank you, seeing the pretty country.

But to tell of half the curious or amusing incidents I should need a
volume many times the size of this one.  Things happened every day any
one of which would provide a newspaper with a column of excellent
"copy."  At the time one thought little about them, for everybody was
too busy looking after his job and himself.  There was, for instance,
the Adventure of the Flat-Nosed Bullet, the Adventure of the Man with
the Crooked Ear, the Adventure of the Field Cashier and the Pay Chest,
the Adventure of the Blood-stained Putty Knife, the Adventure of the
Perishing Cat, and many another.


The great question on the morning of Friday, September 4th, was: "Are
we going right back to the Seine, with our left on Paris?"  You picture
the Force, tired enough but in most excellent fettle, growing hourly
more impatient, longing with all their hearts to turn and have a go at
the enemy who had caused them all that trouble and discomfort.

"Give a guess," I asked two of my sergeants that day, "how long we have
been out here?"

They thought for a few minutes.  "Six weeks," they said; "perhaps
seven."

And, you see, it was only a fortnight after all.  But they would not
believe it until a calendar was produced.  Unconsciously everyone
reckoned each night as another day, for nights and days were alike so
far as work was concerned.  I think that remark was more telling than
pages of descriptive writing.

The days during those final stages were almost tropical in their heat,
which told very severely on men and horses.  The nights were chill and
wet.  So altogether one had one's work cut out in mothering the men.
Cases of bowel complaints were very common, and one has to be so
careful to prevent serious developments.  The lads really need looking
after like children, bless them!  Aromatic chalk-powder with opium
(5-grain tablets) I found an excellent remedy, and cured dozens of
cases.  So there is a little tip for other officers.  Calomel is
useful, too, and I saved much agony from bad wounds by doses of opium
(1-grain tablets), but this must not be given in cases of stomach
wounds--most to be dreaded of any.  Aspirin, also, is, of course,
invaluable.  Certainly no officer should be without a small
medicine-case, and it is the one thing they never seem to think of when
getting kit together.  A trivial lapse, this, into egotism, I am
afraid.  I hope it will be excused for the sake of the hints offered.


In the evening of September 4th orders came to continue the retirement
still farther.  The Second Corps marched through most of the night
towards the River Seine, the First Corps conforming to the movement on
the east.  The 6th French Army was coming up well on our left, and thus
the western end of the Franco-British line was gradually swinging round
and up between Paris and the right flank of the Germans, who were now
definitely moving east-south-east.  You must remember, though, that
these facts were only apparent at the time to a handful of officers of
the Headquarters Staff; everyone else was still in the dark.  But how
thrilling those hours must have been to an airman observing from above,
and who knew the facts.

On the 5th (Saturday), at noon, one battery found itself halted in a
field by the 12-kilometre stone from Paris, and the men were confident
that "la ville lumière" was their next stop.  There was an undercurrent
of excitement, for another couple of thousand men had joined up to the
corps as reinforcements.  It was a definite halt and a rest, the first
they had had since Mons, and they were making the most of it.

Just about 6 P.M. the major came into the lines with a paper in his
hand.  There was something in his walk, something about him--the men
jumped up as he approached.  "Paris?"--the major shook his head.
"Not--not--is it advance, sir?"  The major nodded.  "We are going to
advance," he said.

ADVANCE!

There was a cheer which must have startled the French Government in
Bordeaux, or whereever they had gone to.

The drivers rushed at their horses, the gunners rushed to the limbers
to help hook in.  "Stand to your horses!" sang out the sergeant-major.
Then, in a very few minutes: "Battery all ready, sir!"

The major stood up in his stirrups with a splendid laugh in his eyes.

"Sub-sections right-about-wheel!  Walk, march!"

Another rousing shout, which soon merged into the cheery strains of
"All aboard for Dixie," and the battery began a march, this time in the
right direction, which only stopped at 2 A.M. for the sake of the
horses.  The men were ready to go on for a week.

The great Retreat had ended.  The Advance had begun.

How and why the tide turned against the invaders at that, for them,
most critical moment we cannot exactly tell.  It was, as I see it, a
combination of circumstances.  There was the imminence of the Russian
invasion into Prussia, and it was said that the Germans withdrew two
army corps from the Western front to meet it.  There was the sudden
production by the French Commander-in-Chief of an entirely new French
army from behind Paris to attack the German right.

But one thing, at least, is certain.  Von Kluck made, perhaps, the
biggest mistake in his life in imagining that "the contemptible little
army" which he and his legions had been hunting for a fortnight was now
too dispirited and broken for further fighting; and, with that
conviction in his mind, he started to do the very thing which the most
elementary military textbooks tell you is absolutely wrong.  He moved
his army across the unbroken front of a hostile force.

General Smith-Dorrien had been compelled to do the same thing with the
Second Corps only three days before.  But he did it with the full
knowledge of the dangers, and he took every possible precaution to
obviate them.  He succeeded.

Von Kluck, in his delusion, saw no danger.  He failed.

"I should conceive it," says Sir John French, "to have been about noon
on September 6th ... that the enemy realised the powerful threat that
was being made against the flank of his columns moving south-east, and
began the great retreat which opened the battle of the Marne."

      *      *      *      *      *

And there I draw the tableau curtains on the first act of the drama.

How inadequately the story has been told, or rather outlined, no one is
more conscious than the writer.  For every omission the critics may
find, I will find two.  But if I have so written that the great-hearted
public may realise a little more of what the Retreat from Mons meant to
the lads of ours who worked and fought so marvellously, to themselves
at home, to our brothers and sisters overseas, then indeed I am
satisfied.

Of necessity I have had to omit a great deal which may not be told
until the war has ended.  To an officer on the active list freedom of
speech is rightly denied.  But some day I shall hope to write in fuller
detail and to do more justice to the work of individuals.  It is only
right that the public should learn the actual facts.

The glory of the achievement lay not merely in the hourly repulse, over
a period of fourteen days, of an overwhelming attack, and of a
continued retirement, which somehow never broke, before such an
inveterate pursuit.  But there was also the big question of
temperament.  The Germans knew exactly what they wanted, and they went
straight for it, backed by all the resources of their wonderful
organisation working to that particular end for a decade of years or
longer.  The British, on the other hand, were thrust into the breach
literally at the last moment, a week late, and then had to fight for a
fortnight in total ignorance of the course of events.

I recall a remark once made by General Joffre:

"The better he understands the importance of the movements of the
attack wherein he participates, the braver the French soldier fights,
and the more trust he puts in the measures taken by his leaders."

While the converse may not always be true, it will, I think, suggest
how very difficult is the execution of a delicate piece of strategy
when the officers and men are ignorant of the motives which prompt it.

The Retreat was carried to a successful conclusion because, by the
inherent qualities of race, it was a piece of work of a character in
which the British Army has always excelled; and also, in face of the
terrible engines of modern slaughter, because of the splendid
discipline of the men and their training as individual human beings.

Of the invariable cheerfulness of the men I have given several
examples; but I would again attempt to correct the popular impression
that such cheerfulness is no more than the cracking of jokes on all
occasions.  No, it is something far deeper and finer than that.  The
casual observer will watch a party of sappers mending a road, under
fire, with loads of flint stones.  He will hear them grumbling about
the shocking waste of the ratepayers' money, and will then write home a
letter for publication narrating the incident as a funny remark under
fire.  He omits to point out that it is only the cheery spirits of the
men (and, of course, discipline, etc.) which make possible the clean
finish of the work.

So it was in the Retreat.  The men were far too exhausted to crack
jokes, but the unconquerable soul of them rose high above every
obstacle, and so the work was done.


Looking back over what I have written, I find that, quite
unconsciously, I have said little or nothing of the work of the
officers.  Yet there is nothing else that I can say.  It is not for me
to remark upon the work of our leaders and of my brother-officers.  I
can only repeat the words of the Commander-in-Chief, and I venture to
do so because the general public bothers but little with official
dispatches.

"It is impossible," Sir John French remarked, "for me to speak too
highly of the skill evinced by the two General Officers Commanding Army
Corps; the self-sacrificing and devoted exertions of their Staffs; the
direction of the troops by Divisional, Brigade and Regimental leaders;
the command of the smaller units by their officers; and the magnificent
fighting spirit displayed by non-commissioned officers and men."

But in the Commander-in-Chief's dispatches there is one officer whose
name shines out like a beacon.  You who have followed in spirit the
work of the Second Corps on August 26th will have realised the
imperishable debt which the nation owes to the General Officer
Commanding that corps.  The verdict of posterity will but confirm that
of the present generation.

Again I can but quote the Commander-in-Chief:

"I cannot close the brief account of this glorious stand of the British
troops without putting on record my deep appreciation of the valuable
services rendered by General Sir Horace Smith-Dorrien.

"I say without hesitation that the saving of the left wing of the Army
under my command on the morning of August 26th could never have been
accomplished unless a commander of rare and unusual coolness,
intrepidity and determination had been present to personally conduct
the operation."

At the head of my sketch of that day's work I have set Shakespeare's
immortal lines on St. Crispin's Day.  May one who was privileged to
serve as a member of that "band of brothers" on that day venture to
offer his poor tribute to the leader of that band?

From Mons to the Marne, wherever the fight was hottest, wherever his
men were working against heaviest odds, there was the General at hand
to help and stiffen them.  The outposts before Mons were heavily
engaged; the General was up with them, under shell-fire, to see how
things were going.  Through the days that followed, wherever
opportunity served, their commander stepped from his car to say a few
words of cheery encouragement to the passing troops.  Was there a field
hospital, a passing ambulance?--again, those few words of kindly
inquiry which made the poor sufferers forget everything save only the
desire to be well again to give their-chief, and Britain, all that was
in them.  If the Commander-in-Chief owed so much to General
Smith-Dorrien, I can only say that the Second Corps would have stormed
the gates of Hell for their leader, and would have trusted implicitly
in him to bring them through.


I seem to have said practically nothing about the Flying Corps, and
very little about the Sappers.  I am afraid that I saw very little of
our aeroplane work until the Aisne, and so I cannot speak from personal
observation.  In fact, there are far too many omissions in this brief
chronicle.

      But pardon, gentles all,
      *      *      *      *      *
  Oh, pardon! since a crooked figure may
  Attest in little place a million;
  And let us, ciphers to this great accompt,
  On your imaginary forces work,
      *      *      *      *      *
  Piece out our imperfections with your thoughts.


Indeed, I find it quite impossible to speak of one branch of the Force
more than another.  It was just one perfect whole.  Thus I have, so far
as possible, refrained from designating particular regiments.  If I
have written of the 9th Lancers or L Battery it is because the gallant
work of those units is already a household word throughout the Empire.
But, so far as that first fortnight was concerned, there was not a
single unit, officer or man, who did not achieve something equally as
gallant did the opportunity come his way.  Indeed, had it not been so,
the Retreat could never have been accomplished as it was.  Every man
played the game for his side, and, in consequence, that side won.

And if that were so, then there can be no question of "mentions in
dispatches," D.S.O.'s and D.C.M.'s.  Every regiment in the firing-line
should be "mentioned."  If, by great good fortune, a regiment achieves
some specially noble piece of work which comes to the notice of the
authorities, then, say I, let the Colour of that regiment be decorated.
To single out individuals, to give a Victoria Cross to the colonel, a
D.S.O. to the senior major, a Military Cross to the senior captain, and
so on, is to create jealousy, and is, also, unfair to others.


Humanity, the other noble trait in the character of our men, I have
barely mentioned, for it seems quite unnecessary to do so.  It is a
characteristic of British sailors and soldiers which is always taken
for granted.  One need only recall some of the many occasions in our
naval actions when British sailors have rescued Germans at the peril of
their lives, and have been fired at while doing so.  And set in
contrast the murderous attack by German destroyers upon the crew of a
British submarine stranded on the Swedish coast.

And so it has been with our soldiers.  Our men invariably enter a fight
with the innate feeling that it is a sporting contest, where you shake
hands with your adversary before and after the fight.  If he knocks out
his adversary, then the winner is the man to help him to his feet.

We have seen from the very beginning that "chivalry" and "fair play"
are words unknown to the Germans.  To them nothing matters but to win,
preferably by foul means.  So, on the very first day, British soldiers
were terribly undeceived.  They saw German infantry advancing to the
attack behind a screen of Belgian women and children, driven on at the
bayonet point.  From then onwards we lost hundreds of gallant men
simply through their feelings of humanity towards wounded enemies,
being shot at by other Germans, or being treacherously shot or stabbed
by the very man to whose lips they were holding a flask of water.

And yet, with such examples before them of their comrades' fate, the
sense of humanity and chivalry was never dulled.  Despite the stringent
orders on the subject, the men, even now, hesitate to fire when the
enemy raises a white flag, and will always, whenever possible, succour
a wounded German lying before the trench.  These are the men who have
only, as yet, learned of German treachery by hearsay evidence.  But
there are others.  There are companies and battalions who know from
ghastly experience.  These men adopt other methods.

But nothing I can write will make people at home understand what this
war really is.  Nothing, short of actual experience, can do that.
Stay, perhaps there is one thing: the genius of Louis Raemaekers.  He,
at least, by his cartoons, is bringing home to millions the hideous
meaning of this war.  And not only of this war, but of all modern war.
I would have a volume of his cartoons distributed gratis by the
Government to every household in the kingdom.  I would have half a
dozen of the cartoons thrown upon the screen in every cinema-house at
every entertainment.  The people would shudder with horror, but they
would see them and learn what Germany is and what war means.

Apart from this, I hold it to be the sacred duty of every man and woman
who can use a pen to advantage, or who can command the attention of an
audience, to make known this meaning.  To cry from the housetops what
is this foul thing which Germany has thrust upon the world, and to show
the people why and how Civilisation must crush it out for ever.


There is no greater honour to-day that a man may wear--alas, there are
but few left to wear it!--than the honour of having served his King and
Country in France throughout August and September, 1914.  Just that.
He needs no decoration, no "mention."  He served through the "Retreat
from Mons."  In days to come our children, our children's children,
will point with pride to that one little word on the regimental colour,
"Mons."  For in that single word will be summed up the Liberation of
the World.  It was the victory of the Marne which won for Civilisation
that freedom, but it was, under God's hand, the British Navy, the stand
of Belgium, and the "Retreat from Mons" which made that victory
possible.




APPENDIX I

  MILITARY DESPATCHES FROM THE FIELD-MARSHAL
  COMMANDING-IN-CHIEF, BRITISH FORCES IN THE FIELD,
  DATED SEPTEMBER 7TH AND 17TH

7th September, 1914.

MY LORD,

I have the honour to report the proceedings of the Field Force under my
command up to the time of rendering this despatch.

1. The transport of the troops from England both by sea and by rail was
effected in the best order and without a check.  Each unit arrived at
its destination in this country well within the scheduled time.

The concentration was practically complete on the evening of Friday,
the 21st ultimo, and I was able to make dispositions to move the Force
during Saturday, the 22nd, to positions I considered most favourable
from which to commence operations which the French Commander-in-Chief,
General Joffre, requested me to undertake in pursuance of his plans in
prosecution of the campaign.


Position at Mons

The line taken up extended along the line of the canal from Condé on
the west, through Mons and Binche on the east.  This line was taken up
as follows:--

From Condé to Mons inclusive was assigned to the Second Corps, and to
the right of the Second Corps from Mons the First Corps was posted.
The 5th Cavalry Brigade was placed at Binche.

In the absence of my Third Army Corps I desired to keep the Cavalry
Division as much as possible as a reserve to act on my outer flank, or
move in support of any threatened part of the line.  The forward
reconnaissance was entrusted to Brigadier-General Sir Philip Chetwode
with the 5th Cavalry Brigade, but I directed General Allenby to send
forward a few squadrons to assist in this work.

During the 22nd and 23rd these advanced squadrons did some excellent
work, some of them penetrating as far as Soignies, and several
encounters took place in which our troops showed to great advantage.


Sunday, August 23

2. At 6 a.m., on August 23rd, I assembled the Commanders of the First
and Second Corps and Cavalry Division at a point close to the position,
and explained the general situation of the Allies, and what I
understood to be General Joffre's plan.  I discussed with them, at some
length the immediate situation in front of us.

From information I received from French Headquarters I understood that
little more than one, or at most two, of the enemy's Army Corps, with
perhaps one Cavalry Division, were in front of my position; and I was
aware of no attempted outflanking movement by the enemy.  I was
confirmed in this opinion by the fact that my patrols encountered no
undue opposition in their reconnoitring operations.  The observation of
my aeroplanes seemed also to bear out this estimate.

About 3 p.m. on Sunday, the 23rd, reports began coming in to the effect
that the enemy was commencing an attack on the Mons line, apparently in
some strength, but that the right of the position from Mons and Bray
was being particularly threatened.

The Commander of the First Corps had pushed his flank back to some high
ground south of Bray, and the 5th Cavalry Brigade evacuated Binche,
moving slightly south: the enemy thereupon occupied Binche.

The right of the 3rd Division, under General Hamilton, was at Mons,
which formed a somewhat dangerous salient; and I directed the Commander
of the Second Corps to be careful not to keep the troops on this
salient too long, but, if threatened seriously, to draw back the centre
behind Mons.  This was done before dark.  In the meantime, about 5
p.m., I received a most unexpected message from General Joffre by
telegraph, telling me that at least three German Corps, viz., a reserve
corps, the 4th Corps and the 9th Corps, were moving on my position in
front, and that the Second Corps was engaged in a turning movement from
the direction of Tournay.  He also informed me that the two reserve
French Divisions and the 5th French Army on my right were retiring, the
Germans having on the previous day gained possession of the passages of
the Sambre between Charleroi and Namur.


Monday, August 24

3. In view of the possibility of my being driven from the Mons
position, I had previously ordered a position in rear to be
reconnoitred.  This position rested on the fortress of Maubeuge on the
right and extended west to Jenlain, south-east of Valenciennes, on the
left.  The position was reported difficult to hold, because standing
crops and buildings made the siting of trenches very difficult and
limited the field of fire in many important localities.  It
nevertheless afforded a few good artillery positions.

When the news of the retirement of the French and the heavy German
threatening on my front reached me, I endeavoured to confirm it by
aeroplane reconnaissance; and as a result of this I determined to
effect a retirement to the Maubeuge position at daybreak on the 24th.

A certain amount of fighting continued along the whole line throughout
the night, and at daybreak on the 24th the 2nd Division from the
neighbourhood of Harmignies made a powerful demonstration as if to
retake Binche.  This was supported by the artillery of both the 1st and
2nd Divisions, whilst the 1st Division took up a supporting position in
the neighbourhood of Peissant.  Under cover of this demonstration the
Second Corps retired on the line Dour--Quarouble--Frameries.  The 3rd
Division on the right of the Corps suffered considerable loss in this
operation from the enemy, who had retaken Mons.

The Second Corps halted on this line, where they partially entrenched
themselves, enabling Sir Douglas Haig with the First Corps gradually to
withdraw to the new position; and he effected this without much further
loss, reaching the line Bavai--Maubeuge about 7 p.m.  Towards midday
the enemy appeared to be directing his principal effort against our
left.


Work of the Cavalry

I had previously ordered General Allenby with the Cavalry to act
vigorously in advance of my left front and endeavour to take the
pressure off.

About 7.30 a.m. General Allenby received a message from Sir Charles
Fergusson, commanding 5th Division, saying that he was very hard
pressed and in urgent need of support.  On receipt of this message
General Allenby drew in the Cavalry and endeavoured to bring direct
support to the 5th Division.

During the course of this operation General De Lisle, of the 2nd
Cavalry Brigade, thought he saw a good opportunity to paralyse the
further advance of the enemy's infantry by making a mounted attack on
his flank.  He formed up and advanced for this purpose, but was held up
by wire about 500 yards from his objective, and the 9th Lancers and
18th Hussars suffered severely in the retirement of the Brigade.

The 19th Infantry Brigade, which had been guarding the Line of
Communications, was brought up by rail to Valenciennes on the 22nd and
23rd.  On the morning of the 24th they were moved out to a position
south of Quarouble to support the left flank of the Second Corps.

With the assistance of the Cavalry Sir Horace Smith-Dorrien was enabled
to effect his retreat to a new position; although, having two corps of
the enemy on his front and one threatening his flank, he suffered great
losses in doing so.

At nightfall the position was occupied by the Second Corps to the west
of Bavai, the First Corps to the right.  The right was protected by the
Fortress of Maubeuge, the left by the 19th Brigade in position between
Jenlain and Bry, and the Cavalry on the outer flank.


Tuesday, August 25

4. The French were still retiring, and I had no support except such as
was afforded by the Fortress of Maubeuge; and the determined attempts
of the enemy to get round my left flank assured me that it was his
intention to hem me against that place and surround me.  I felt that
not a moment must be lost in retiring to another position.

I had every reason to believe that the enemy's forces were somewhat
exhausted, and I knew that they had suffered heavy losses.  I hoped,
therefore, that his pursuit would not be too vigorous to prevent me
effecting my object.

The operation, however, was full of danger and difficulty, not only
owing to the very superior force in my front, but also to the
exhaustion of the troops.

The retirement was recommenced in the early morning of the 25th to a
position in the neighbourhood of Le Cateau, and rearguards were ordered
to be clear of the Maubeuge--Bavai--Eth road by 5.30 a.m.

Two Cavalry Brigades, with the Divisional Cavalry of the Second Corps,
covered the movement of the Second Corps.  The remainder of the Cavalry
Division with the 19th Brigade, the whole under the command of General
Allenby, covered the west flank.

The 4th Division commenced its detrainment at Le Cateau on Sunday, the
23rd, and by the morning of the 25th eleven battalions and a Brigade of
Artillery with Divisional Staff were available for service.

I ordered General Snow to move out to take up a position with his right
south of Solesmes, his left resting on the Cambrai--Le Cateau road
south of La Chaprie.  In this position the Division rendered great help
to the effective retirement of the Second and First Corps to the new
position.

Although the troops had been ordered to occupy the Cambrai--Le
Cateau--Landrecies position, and the ground had, during the 25th, been
partially prepared and entrenched, I had grave doubts--owing to the
information I received as to the accumulating strength of the enemy
against me--as to the wisdom of standing there to fight.

Having regard to the continued retirement of the French on my right, my
exposed left flank, the tendency of the enemy's western corps (II.) to
envelop me, and, more than all, the exhausted condition of the troops,
I determined to make a great effort to continue the retreat till I
could put some substantial obstacle, such as the Somme or the Oise,
between my troops and the enemy, and afford the former some opportunity
of rest and reorganisation.  Orders were, therefore, sent to the Corps
Commanders to continue their retreat as soon as they possibly could
towards the general line Vermand--St. Quentin--Ribemont.

The Cavalry, under General Allenby, were ordered to cover the
retirement.


The Guards at Landrecies

Throughout the 25th and far into the evening, the First Corps continued
its march on Landrecies, following the road along the eastern border of
the Forêt de Mormal, and arrived at Landrecies about 10 o'clock.  I had
intended that the Corps should come farther west so as to fill up the
gap between Le Cateau and Landrecies, but the men were exhausted and
could not get farther in without rest.

The enemy, however, would not allow them this rest, and about 9.30 p.m.
a report was received that the 4th Guards Brigade in Landrecies was
heavily attacked by troops of the 9th German Army Corps who were coming
through the forest on the north of the town.  This brigade fought most
gallantly and caused the enemy to suffer tremendous loss in issuing
from the forest into the narrow street of the town.  The loss has been
estimated from reliable sources at from 700 to 1,000.  At the same time
information reached me from Sir Douglas Haig that his 1st Division was
also heavily engaged south and east of Maroilles.  I sent urgent
messages to the Commander of the two French Reserve Divisions on my
right to come up to the assistance of the First Corps, which they
eventually did.  Partly owing to this assistance but mainly to the
skilful manner in which Sir Douglas Haig extricated his Corps from an
exceptionally difficult position in the darkness of the night, they
were able at dawn to resume their march south towards Wessigny on Guise.

By about 6 p.m. the Second Corps had got into position with their right
on Le Cateau, their left in the neighbourhood of Caudry, and the line
of defence was continued thence by the 4th Division towards
Seranvillers, the left being thrown back.

During the fighting on the 24th and 25th the Cavalry became a good deal
scattered, but by the early morning of the 26th General Allenby had
succeeded in concentrating two brigades to the south of Cambrai.

The 4th Division was placed under the orders of the General Officer
Commanding the Second Army Corps.


Wednesday, August 26

On the 24th the French Cavalry Corps, consisting of three divisions,
under General Sordêt, had been in billets north of Avesnes.  On my way
back from Bavai, which was my "Poste de Commandement" during the
fighting of the 23rd and 24th, I visited General Sordêt, and earnestly
requested his co-operation and support.  He promised to obtain sanction
from his Army Commander to act on my left flank, but said that his
horses were too tired to move before the next day.  Although he
rendered me valuable assistance later on in the course of the
retirement, he was unable for the reasons given to afford me any
support on the most critical day of all, viz., the 26th.

At daybreak it became apparent that the enemy was throwing the bulk of
his strength against the left of the position occupied by the Second
Corps and the 4th Division.

At this time the guns of four German Army Corps were in position
against them, and Sir Horace Smith-Dorrien reported to me that he
judged it impossible to continue his retirement at daybreak (as
ordered) in face of such an attack.

I sent him orders to use his utmost endeavours to break off the action
and retire at the earliest possible moment, as it was impossible for me
to send him any support, the First Corps being at the moment incapable
of movement.

The French Cavalry Corps, under General Sordêt, was coming up on our
left rear early in the morning, and I sent an urgent message to him to
do his utmost to come up and support the retirement of my left flank;
but, owing to the fatigue of his horses he found himself unable to
intervene in any way.

There had been no time to entrench the position properly, but the
troops showed a magnificent front to the terrible fire which confronted
them.

The Artillery, although outmatched by at least four to one, made a
splendid fight, and inflicted heavy losses on their opponents.

At length it became apparent that, if complete annihilation was to be
avoided, a retirement must be attempted; and the order was given to
commence it about 3.30 p.m.  The movement was covered with the most
devoted intrepidity and determination by the Artillery, which had
itself suffered heavily, and the fine work done by the Cavalry in the
further retreat from the position assisted materially in the final
completion of this most difficult and dangerous operation.

Fortunately the enemy had himself suffered too heavily to engage in an
energetic pursuit.


I cannot close the brief account of this glorious stand of the British
troops without putting on record my deep appreciation of the valuable
services rendered by General Sir Horace Smith-Dorrien.

I say without hesitation that the saving of the left wing of the Army
under my command on the morning of the 26th August could never have
been accomplished unless a commander of rare and unusual coolness,
intrepidity, and determination had been present to personally conduct
the operations.

The retreat was continued far into the night of the 26th and through
the 27th and 28th, on which date the troops halted on the line
Noyon--Chauny--La Fère, having then thrown off the weight of the
enemy's pursuit.

On the 27th and 28th I was much indebted to General Sordêt and the
French Cavalry Division which he commands for materially assisting my
retirement and successfully driving back some of the enemy on Cambrai.

General D'Amade also, with the 61st and 62nd French Reserve Divisions,
moved down from the neighbourhood of Arras on the enemy's right flank
and took much pressure off the rear of the British Forces.

This closes the period covering the heavy fighting which commenced at
Mons on Sunday afternoon, 23rd August, and which really constituted a
four days' battle.

At this point, therefore, I propose to close the present despatch.

I deeply deplore the very serious losses which the British Forces have
suffered in this great battle; but they were inevitable in view of the
fact that the British Army--only two days after a concentration by
rail--was called upon to withstand a vigorous attack of five German
Army Corps.

It is impossible for me to speak too highly of the skill evinced by the
two General Officers commanding Army Corps; the self-sacrificing and
devoted exertions of their Staffs; the direction of the troops by
Divisional, Brigade, and Regimental Leaders; the command of the smaller
units by their officers; and the magnificent fighting spirit displayed
by non-commissioned officers and men.

I wish particularly to bring to your Lordship's notice the admirable
work done by the Royal Flying Corps under Sir David Henderson.  Their
skill, energy, and perseverance have been beyond all praise.  They have
furnished me with the most complete and accurate information which has
been of incalculable value in the conduct of the operations.  Fired at
constantly both by friend and foe, and not hesitating to fly in every
kind of weather, they have remained undaunted throughout.

Further, by actually fighting in the air, they have succeeded in
destroying five of the enemy's machines.

I wish to acknowledge with deep gratitude the incalculable assistance I
received from the General and Personal Staffs at Headquarters during
this trying period.

Lieutenant-General Sir Archibald Murray, Chief of the General Staff;
Major-General Wilson, Sub-Chief of the General Staff; and all under
them have worked day and night unceasingly with the utmost skill,
self-sacrifice, and devotion; and the same acknowledgment is due by me
to Brigadier-General Hon. W. Lambton, my Military Secretary, and the
Personal Staff.

In such operations as I have described, the work of the
Quartermaster-General is of an extremely onerous nature.  Major-General
Sir William Robertson has met what appeared to be almost insuperable
difficulties with his characteristic energy, skill, and determination;
and it is largely owing to his exertions that the hardships and
sufferings of the troops--inseparable from such operations--were not
much greater.

Major-General Sir Nevil Macready, the Adjutant-General, has also been
confronted with most onerous and difficult tasks in connection with
disciplinary arrangements and the preparation of casualty lists.  He
has been indefatigable in his exertions to meet the difficult
situations which arose.

I have not yet been able to complete the list of officers whose names I
desire to bring to your Lordship's notice for services rendered during
the period under review; and, as I understand it is of importance that
this despatch should no longer be delayed, I propose to forward this
list, separately, as soon as I can.

I have the honour to be,
  Your Lordship's most obedient Servant,
    (Signed) J. D. P. FRENCH, Field-Marshal,
       Commander-in-Chief, British Forces in the Field.


17th September, 1914.

MY LORD,

In continuation of my despatch of September 7th, I have the honour to
report the further progress of the operations of the Forces under my
command from August 28th.

On that evening the retirement of the Force was followed closely by two
of the enemy's cavalry columns, moving south-east from St. Quentin.


Saturday, August 29

The retreat in this part of the field was being covered by the 3rd and
5th Cavalry Brigades.  South of the Somme General Gough, with the 3rd
Cavalry Brigade, threw back the Uhlans of the Guard with considerable
loss.

General Chetwode, with the 5th Cavalry Brigade, encountered the eastern
column near Cerizy, moving south.  The Brigade attacked and routed the
column, the leading German regiment suffering very severe casualties
and being almost broken up.

The 7th French Army Corps was now in course of being railed up from the
south to the east of Amiens.  On the 29th it nearly completed its
detrainment, and the French 6th Army got into position on my left, its
right resting on Roye.

The 5th French Army was behind the line of the Oise between La Fère and
Guise.

The pursuit of the enemy was very vigorous; some five or six German
corps were on the Somme facing the 5th Army on the Oise.  At least two
corps were advancing towards my front, and were crossing the Somme east
and west of Ham.  Three or four more German corps were opposing the 6th
French Army on my left.

This was the situation at 1 o'clock on the 29th, when I received a
visit from General Joffre at my headquarters.

I strongly represented my position to the French Commander-in-Chief,
who was most kind, cordial, and sympathetic, as he has always been.  He
told me that he had directed the 5th French Army on the Oise to move
forward and attack the Germans on the Somme, with a view to checking
pursuit.  He also told me of the formation of the Sixth French Army on
my left flank, composed of the 7th Army Corps, four Reserve Divisions,
and Sordêt's Corps of Cavalry.

I finally arranged with General Joffre to effect a further short
retirement towards the line Compiègne--Soissons, promising him,
however, to do my utmost to keep always within a day's march of him.

In pursuance of this arrangement the British Forces retired to a
position a few miles north of the line Compiègne--Soissons on the 29th.


Change of Base

The right flank of the German Army was now reaching a point which
appeared seriously to endanger my line of communications with Havre.  I
had already evacuated Amiens, into which place a German reserve
division was reported to have moved.

Orders were given to change the base to St. Nazaire, and establish an
advance base at Le Mans.  This operation was well carried out by the
Inspector-General of Communications.

In spite of a severe defeat inflicted upon the Guard 10th and Guard
Reserve Corps of the German Army by the 1st and 3rd French Corps on the
right of the 5th Army, it was not part of General Joffre's plan to
pursue this advantage, and a general retirement on to the line of the
Marne was ordered, to which the French forces in the more eastern
theatre were directed to conform.

A new Army (the 9th) had been formed from three corps in the south by
General Joffre, and moved into the space between the right of the 5th
and left of the 4th Armies.

Whilst closely adhering to his strategic conception to draw the enemy
on at all points until a favourable situation was created from which to
assume the offensive, General Joffre found it necessary to modify from
day to day the methods by which he sought to attain this object, owing
to the development of the enemy's plans and changes in the general
situation.

In conformity with the movements of the French Forces, my retirement
continued practically from day to day.  Although we were not severely
pressed by the enemy, rearguard actions took place continually.


South of Compiègne

On the 1st September, when retiring from the thickly wooded country to
the south of Compiègne, the 1st Cavalry Brigade was overtaken by some
German cavalry.  They momentarily lost a Horse Artillery battery, and
several officers and men were killed and wounded.  With the help,
however, of some detachments from the 3rd Corps operating on their
left, they not only recovered their own guns, but succeeded in
capturing twelve of the enemy's.

Similarly, to the eastward, the 1st Corps, retiring south, also got
into some very difficult forest country, and a somewhat severe
rearguard action ensued at Villers-Cotterets, in which the 4th Guards
Brigade suffered considerably.

On September 3rd the British Forces were in position south of the Marne
between Lagny and Signy-Signets.  Up to this time I had been requested
by General Joffre to defend the passages of the river as long as
possible, and to blow up the bridges in my front.  After I had made the
necessary dispositions, and the destruction of the bridges had been
effected, I was asked by the French Commander-in-Chief to continue my
retirement to a point some 12 miles in rear of the position I then
occupied, with a view to taking up a second position behind the Seine.
This retirement was duly carried out.  In the meantime the enemy had
thrown bridges and crossed the Marne in considerable force, and was
threatening the Allies all along the line of the British Forces and the
5th and 9th French Armies.  Consequently several small outpost actions
took place.


Saturday, September 5

On Saturday, September 5th, I met the French Commander-in-Chief at his
request, and he informed me of his intention to take the offensive
forthwith, as he considered conditions were very favourable to success.

General Joffre announced to me his intention of wheeling up the left
flank of the 6th Army, pivoting on the Marne and directing it to move
on the Ourcq; cross and attack the flank of the 1st German Army, which
was then moving in a south-easterly direction east of that river.


The Advance

He requested me to effect a change of front to my right--my left
resting on the Marne, and my right on the 5th Army--to fill the gap
between that army and the 6th.  I was then to advance against the enemy
in my front and join in the general offensive movement.

These combined movements practically commenced on Sunday, September
6th, at sunrise; and on that day it may be said that a great battle
opened on a front extending from Ermenonville, which was just in front
of the left flank of the 6th French Army, through Lizy on the Marne,
Mauperthuis, which was about the British centre Courtecon, which was
the left of the 5th French Army; to Esternay and Charleville, the left
of the 9th Army under General Foch, and so along the front of the 9th,
4th and 3rd French Armies to a point north of the fortress of Verdun.

This battle, in so far as the 6th French Army, the British Army, the
5th French Army, and the 9th French Army were concerned, may be said to
have concluded on the evening of September 10th, by which time the
Germans had been driven back to the line Soissons--Reims, with a loss
of thousands of prisoners, many guns, and enormous masses of transport.

About the 3rd September the enemy appears to have changed his plans and
to have determined to stop his advance South direct upon Paris; for on
the 4th September air reconnaissances showed that his main columns were
moving in a south-easterly direction generally east of a line drawn
through Nanteuil and Lizy on the Ourcq.  On the 5th September several
of these columns were observed to have crossed the Marne; whilst German
troops, which were observed moving south-east up the left bank of the
Ourcq on the 4th, were now reported to be halted and facing that river.
Heads of the enemy's columns were seen crossing at Changis, La Ferté,
Nogent, Château Thierry, and Mezy.

Considerable German columns of all arms were seen to be converging on
Montmirail, whilst before sunset large bivouacs of the enemy were
located in the neighbourhood of Coulommiers, south of Rebais, La
Ferté-Gauchér, and Dagny.

I should conceive it to have been about noon on the 6th September,
after the British Forces had changed their front to the right and
occupied the line Jouy-Le Chatel--Faremoutiers--Villeneuve La Comte,
and the advance of the 6th French Army north of the Marne towards the
Ourcq became apparent, that the enemy realised the powerful threat that
was being made against the flank of his columns moving south-east, and
began the great retreat which opened the battle above referred to.



_Here follows the account of the Battle of the Marne._




APPENDIX II


ORDER OF THE DAY

AUGUST 29TH, 1914.

  _Issued to the Troops under his command by the General
  Officer Commanding the Second Corps._


As it is improbable the troops of the 2nd Army Corps understand the
operations of the last few days, commencing on the 21st instant with
the advance to the line of the Mons Canal and ending with a retirement
to our present position on the River Oise about Noyon, the Commander of
the Corps desires to let troops know that the object was to delay the
advance of a far superior force of the enemy to enable our Allies to
conduct operations elsewhere.  This object, owing to the skilful
handling of the Commanders of units and the magnificent fighting spirit
shown by all ranks against overwhelming odds, and in spite of very
heavy casualties, was achieved, and the French Army is now reported to
be advancing.

That the losses were not greater in the retirement from the
Hancourt--Caudry--Beaumont--Le Cateau position on the 26th instant is
due largely to the support given by French troops, chiefly General
Sordêt's Cavalry Corps, operating on the West flank of the British
troops, and we may well be thankful to our gallant comrades in arms.

General Sir Horace Smith-Dorrien, whilst regretting the terribly heavy
casualties and the weary forced marches, in which it has been
impossible to distribute the necessary amount of food, begs to thank
all ranks and to express his admiration of the grand fighting and
determined spirit shown by all ranks, and his pride in being allowed to
command such a splendid force.

He is sure that whenever it is thought necessary to again assume the
offensive the troops will be as pleased as he will himself.

The following messages have been received from the Commander-in-Chief,
Field-Marshal Sir John French, to publish to the troops of the 2nd Army
Corps--the first dated 25th August.


(1)

"_Special Army Order._

"I have received the following telegram from the Secretary of State for
War:

"'LONDON, 25-8-14.

"'Congratulate troops on their splendid work.  We are all proud as
usual of them.'

"In making this message known to the troops under my command, I wish to
express to them my heartfelt thanks for, and my profound admiration of,
their magnificent bearing and conduct during the fighting of the last
two days.

"The most difficult operation which an army can be called upon to carry
out was rendered necessary by the general strategic situation of the
allied forces extending over an enormous front.

"I can only tell you that it was most brilliantly and successfully
performed.  This happy result was entirely due to the splendid spirit,
efficient training, and magnificent discipline of regimental officers
and men, and the fine skill displayed by the higher commanders in the
direction of the troops."


(2)

"28TH AUGUST, 1914.

"A a 67.  Following message from Lord Kitchener to C.-in-C. will be
communicated to all troops.  Begins: 'The First Lord asks me to
transmit to you the following message from the Home Fleet:--"The
officers and men of the Grand Fleet wish to express to their comrades
of the Army admiration of the magnificent stand made against great
odds, and wish them the brilliant success which the Fleet feels sure
awaits their further efforts."  Ends.


(3)

"No. 28 G.  Following from Lord Kitchener to C.-in-C.  Begins: 'Your F
37.  Your troops have done marvellously well under their Commanders
during severe attacks which they have had to withstand practically
alone.  Express to them all the thanks of the King and Government.'
Ends."



  PRINTED BY CASSELL & COMPANY, LIMITED, LA BELLE SAUVAGE, LONDON, E.C.
  F.40.816



[Illustration: MAP OF COUNTRY FROM MONS TO PARIS]











End of Project Gutenberg's The Retreat from Mons, by A. Corbett-Smith

*** 