



Produced by David Widger from page images generously
provided by the Internet Archive









THE MAN OF LAST RESORT

Or, The Clients Of Randolph Mason

By Melville Davisson Post

G. P. Putnam's Sons New York And London

1897




PREFACE

IN this _fin-de-sîècle_ time, society has grown liberal, it is said,
and yet he who thrusts a lever under sage customs, or he who points out
the vice of institutions long established, may deem himself happy if he
be permitted to strip against the duellist rather than the mob. Even
if one come new into the courts of the _literati_ with a cloak dyed a
different hue from his fellows, he will scarcely have passed the doorway
ere the taunting challenge, “Do you fight, my lord?”

The author, in a previous volume entitled _The Strange Schemes of
Randolph Mason_, pointed out certain defects in the criminal law, and
demonstrated how the skilful rogue could commit not a few of the higher
crimes in such a manner as to render the law powerless to punish him.
The suggestion was, it seems, considered startling and the volume has
provoked large discussion. A few gentlemen of no inconsiderable legal
learning, and certain others to be classified as moral reformers,
contended that the book must be dangerous because it explained with
great detail how one could murder or steal and escape punishment. If the
laws were to be improved, they said, “would it not be more wisely done
by influencing a few political leaders?”

While such a criticism does not come from any considerable number of
authorities, it has been honestly made and is entitled to consideration.

The vice of it lies, it seems to me, in a failure to grasp the actual
nature of our institutions. It is a maxim of our system that the law
making power of the state rests in the first instance with the people of
the state. This power, for the purpose of convenience, is delegated to
certain selected persons who meet together in order to put into effect
the will of the people.

The so-called law-makers are therefore not law-makers at all, in the
sense of being originators of the law; they are rather agents who come
up from their respective districts under instructions. Such agents are
simply temporary representatives of the citizens of their respective
districts, directly responsible to them and charged with no duty other
than that of putting their will into effect. The agent or delegate
should therefore approach very conservatively any matter upon which the
will of his constituency has not been satisfactorily determined. It is,
then, apparent that the influence which makes or which alters the law
is a force exerted from without. No change in the law can be properly
or safely brought about except through the pressure of public sentiment.
The need for the law must be first felt by the people and the demand for
it made before the legislator is warranted in acting. The representative
would otherwise become a presumptive usurper, afflicting the people
with statutes for which there was no public demand; and such laws, so
improperly obtained, would be without the support of public sentiment
and would be liable to repeal.

Hence it is entirely clear that if the existing law prove to be unjust
or defective, the people must be brought to see and appreciate such
injustice or inadequacy and to demand the requisite modification.

This contention can, as it seems to me, not be gainsaid. It is
respectfully urged that no other method of securing wise changes in
the law can be properly pursued under democratic institutions. To hold
otherwise is to take issue with the wisdom of democracy itself, and with
so rash a champion the writer has no spear to break. Indeed, he makes
this explanation with immense unwillingness, as he feels that he should
not be required to defend a truth so evident. It is like demonstrating
gravely that the earth is round and that sun light is an energy.

Yet he is advised that attention should be called to this matter, lest
the thoughtless condemn upon a hearing _ex-parte_. Indeed, even after
the punishment of _la peine forte et dure_ is gone out these many
hundred years, the good citizen will hardly hold that one guiltless who
stands dumb while hidden evils assail. If men about their affairs were
passing to and fro across a great bridge, and one should discover that
certain planks in its flooring were defective, would he do ill if he
pointed them out to his fellows? If men labored in the shops and traded
in the market confident in the security of their city's wall, and one
should perceive that the wall was honeycombed with holes, could he stand
dumb and escape the stigma of being a traitor? The law makes little
difference in the degree of moral turpitude between the _suppressio
veri_ and the _suggestio falsi_. Both are grievous wrongs. The duty
of the individual to the state is imperative. He cannot evade it and
continue to regard himself as a worthy citizen.

Is there not in all this criticism a faint suggestion of the men who
“darken counsel by words without knowledge”?

Lycurgus taught the laws to the people, Solon taught the laws to the
people. The Roman law provided for a final appeal from the consul to
the people, and the very essence of republican institutions lies, as
has been said, in a recognition of the people as the source of the
law-making power. If the law offers imperfect security and is capable of
revision, the people must be taught in order that they may revise it. If
it offers insufficient security and is incapable of revision, then the
people must be taught in order that they may protect themselves. This
conclusion is irresistible. To counsel otherwise is to share in the
odium of that short-sighted ambassador who urged upon Pericles the
wisdom of reversing the tablet upon which the law was written in order
that the people might not read the decree.

Surely, then, he who points out the vices of the law to the people
cannot be said to do evil, unless the law of the land is to be made by
a narrow patriciate sitting, like the Areopagus of ancient Athens, with
closed doors.

That yesterday in which the enemies of society plied their craft by
means of the jimmy and the dark lantern is now almost entirely past. The
master rogue has discovered, with immense satisfaction, that the labor
of others may be enjoyed, and the results of their labor seized and
appropriated to his uses, without thrusting himself within the control
of criminal tribunals.

Wise magistrates, laboring for the welfare of the race, have been
pleased to write down what should be done and what should not be done,
and have called it “law.” The citizen, having no time to inquire, has
gone about his trade under the impression that these rules were offering
ample protection to his person and his property. But the law, being
of human device, is imperfect, and in this fag end of the nineteenth
century, the evil genius thrusts through and despoils the citizen,
and the robbery is all the more easy because the victim sleeps in a
consciousness of perfect security.

The writer has undertaken to point out a few of the more evident
inadequacies of the law and a few of the simpler methods for evasion
that are utilized by the skilful villain. It must be borne in mind,
however, that more gigantic and more intricate methods for evading the
law and for appropriating the property of the citizen are available.
The unwritten records of business ventures and the reports of courts
are crowded with the record of huge schemes having for their ultimate
purpose the robbery of the citizen. Some of these have been successful
and some have failed. Enough have brought great fortunes to their daring
perpetrators to appal that one who looks on with the welfare of human
society at heart.

The reader must bear in mind that the law herein dealt with is the law
as it is administered in the legal forms of his country, in no degree
changed and in no degree  by the imagination of the author. Every
legal statement represents an established principle, thoroughly analyzed
by the courts of last resort. There can be no question as to the
probable truth of these legal conclusions. They are as certainly
established as it is possible for the decisions of courts to establish
any principle of law.

The reader is reminded that the schemes of skilled plotters, resorted
to for the purpose of defeating the spirit of the law, are, for the most
part, too elaborate and too intricate to be made the subject of popular
discussion. An attempt to explain to the but half-interested layman
plots of this character would be as vain as an attempt to demonstrate
an abstract problem in analytical mechanics. The knaves who have been
pleased to devote their energies and their capacities to problems of
this nature are experts learned and capable, and against these the
average man of affairs can defend himself but poorly. He may be warned,
however, and the author will have accomplished his purpose if he
succeeds in identifying the black flag of such pirate crafts.

In the present volume he has deemed it wise to continue to utilize as
his central figure the lawyer, Randolph Mason,--a rather mysterious
legal misanthrope, having no sense of moral obligation, but learned in
the law, who by virtue of the strange tilt of his mind is pleased to
strive with the difficulties of his clients as though they were mere
problems involving no matter of right or equity or common justice.

This emotionless counsellor has already been introduced to the public.
He has been described as a man in the middle forties. “Tall and
reasonably broad across the shoulders; muscular, without being either
stout or lean.” His hair was thin and of a brown color, with erratic
streaks of gray. His forehead was broad and high and of a faint reddish
color.

His eyes were restless, inky black, and not over large. The nose was big
and muscular and bowed. The eyebrows were black and heavy, almost bushy.
There were heavy furrows, running from the nose downward and outward to
the comers of the mouth. The mouth was straight, and the jaw was heavy
and square.

“Looking at the face of Randolph Mason from above, the expression in
repose was crafty and cynical; viewed from below upward, it was savage
and vindictive, almost brutal; while from the front, if looked squarely
in the face, the stranger was fascinated by the animation of the man.
and at once concluded that his expression was at the same time sneering
and fearless. He was evidently of Southern extraction and a man of
unusual power.”

This counsellor, keen, powerful, and yet devoid of any sense of moral
obligation, is possessed of this one idea---that the difficulties of men
are problems and that he can solve them; that the law, being of human
origin, can be evaded; that its servants, being but men like the others,
may be balked, and thwarted and baffled in their efforts at a proper
administration of this law.

It is the age of the able rogue, and, in examining his rascally schemes,
the writer has finally come to believe that the ancient maxim, which
declares that the law will always find a remedy for a wrong, is, in this
present time of hasty legislation, not to be accepted as trustworthy.


_(See the learned opinion of Mr. Justice Matthews in the case of Irwin
vs. Williar, no U. S. Reports, 499; the case of Waugh vs. Beck, 114 Pa.
State, 422; also Williamson vs. Baley, 78 Mo., 636; 15 B. Monroe, Ky.
Reports, 138. See also, in Virginia, the case of Machir vs. Moore, 2
Grat., 258.)_




THE GOVERNOR'S MACHINE




I

THERE was something on the Governor's mind, and when this condition
obtained, interesting events had usually followed in the far Southwest.
This highly mystic mental status had preceded the efforts of a Federal
Court to compel him to act under a mandamus, and the result was history.
It had preceded a memorable conflict between the legislature at large
and His Excellency, the Governor, also at large, and immediately
thereafter a certain statute had sprung into existence prohibiting the
massing of State troops within one hundred miles of the Capitol during
the sitting of the Solons of the Commonwealth; but it was a law after
the fact. It had preceded also the mercurial efforts of the so-called
patriotic orders to impeach the Executive for malfeasance, misfeasance,
and nonfeasance,--an effort that had brought to its instigators only a
lurid and inglorious rout.

The Governor was standing at the eastern window of his private office
looking out at the monotonous brown tablelands stretching away to the
foothills of the blue mountains that marked the outer limits of his
jurisdiction. He was a young man, this Governor, with the firm, straight
figure of a soldier and the gracious bearing of important ancestry. His
eyes were brown, and his hair and Van <DW18> beard were brown also--all
indicative, say the sages, of precisely what the Governor was not.
He was perfectly groomed. Every morning when he walked down to the
State-house he was the marvel and the fastidious spotless idol of the
far Southwest.

One would have imagined that this handsome fellow had just stepped
out from a smart New York club, could he have forgotten that such
an institution was almost a continent to eastward. The Governor had
maintained that it was quite possible to live as a gentleman should
wherever Providence had provided Chinamen and water, and that the matter
was not entirely hopeless if the Chinamen were not to be had, so the
water remained.

It was true indeed that the Executive had maintained his customs with
no little pain against the divers protests of gods and men, ofttimes
wrought in silence, but not infrequently urged fiercely in the open.
But the Governor was not one with whom meddling folk could trifle and
preserve the peace. This fact certain bad men had learned to their hurt
west of the Gila, and divers evil-disposed persons regretted and were
buried, and regretted and remembered south of the Pecos. So that in time
this matter came to be regarded as a peculiarity, and passed into
common respect as is the way with the peculiarities of those expeditious
spirits who shoot first and explain afterwards.

The Governor was aroused from his reverie by his private secretary who
came in at this moment from the outer office.

“Governor,” said the young man, “there is a strike at the Big Injin.”

“Well,” replied the Executive, “telegraph the sheriff.”

“But,” said the Secretary, “the sheriff has just telegraphed us.”

“Then,” continued the Executive, “send a courier to Colonel Shiraf.”

“But Colonel Shiraf is out on the Ten Mile.”

“In that case,” said the Governor, “you must go up to the mines, and
if the dignity of the Commonwealth needs to be maintained, you will
maintain it, Dave. You should find some troops at the post, some herders
at the cattle ranch, and a very large proportion of the State Guards, by
this time quite drunk, at a horse fair in Garfield County. If they are
required, notify me.”

As the secretary turned to leave the room, the Governor called him
back. “Dave, my boy,” he said, “peace in this Commonwealth is a sacred
thing--a superlatively sacred thing, so sacred that we are going to
have it if thereby the word 'census' becomes a meaningless term; and
remember, my boy, that the State is very expeditious.”

The secretary went out and closed the door behind him, while His
Excellency, Alfred Capland Randal, forgetting the report, turned back
to the window. The air from the great brown plain came up dry and hot;
above the blue mountains the sun looked like a splotch of bloody red,
and over it all brooded the monotonous--the almost hopeless silence of
the far Southwest.

The something on the Governor's mind was a something of grave import,
for which he could evidently find no solution, and presently he began
to pace the length of his private office with long strides, and with his
hands thrust deep into his pockets.

Suddenly the door opened and a Chinaman entered with a telegram. The
Governor looked up sharply, and taking the envelope tore it open with
evident unconcern. When his eyes ran over the message he drew in a deep
breath, and, seating himself at a table, spread out the paper before
him. This was the advent of the unexpected, for which Mr. Randal was not
quite prepared, and this his manner exhibited to such a degree that
the stolid Celestial wondered vaguely what was up with the big foreign
devil.

“Our train stops at El Paso,” ran the telegram, “you will come up, won't
you?--M. L.”

The Governor stroked his Van <DW18> beard, and the fine lines came out on
his face. “Of all times,” he muttered. Then he turned to the Chinaman.
“Have my overcoat at the depot at six. I am going to El Paso, and shall
not return until late.”

The Chinaman vanished, and the Executive crushed the telegram in his
hands, thrust it into his pocket, and resumed his march up and down the
private office.

This Governor was the crowning achievement of a machine. He was the
elder son of an ancient family in Massachusetts, and had been reared and
educated in an atmosphere of culture. It had been the intention of his
family to have him succeed his father with the practice of the law,
but the plans of men are subject to innumerable perils, and it soon
developed that young Mr. Randal was not at all adapted to the duties of
a barrister. Indeed it was very early apparent that nature had intended
this man for the precarious vagaries of a public life. He was magnetic,
generous, with a splendid presence, and the careless, speculative spirit
of a gambler. In truth, Alfred Capland Randal was a politician _per
se_. While in college he had been a restless element, injecting the
principles of practical policy into everything he touched, from the
Greek-letter fraternities to the examinations in Tacitus, and all with
such reckless, jovial abandon that divers sage members of the faculty
speculated with much wonder as to which particular penal institution
would be his ultimate domicile.

At times the elder Randal had been summoned to attend these grave
sittings of the faculty, and straightway thereafter the rigid New
England lawyer had lectured his son at great length and with bitter
invective, to which the young man attended in a fashion that was
amiable, and immediately disregarded in a fashion that was equally
amiable. Thus in the Puritanic bosom of the father the conclusion grew
and fattened and matured that the eldest scion of his house was an
entirely worthless scapegrace, while the son was quite as certain that
his father was a very sincere, but an entirely misguided old gentleman.

The result of these divergent opinions was that on a certain June
evening young Randal sat down upon a bench in the park of his father's
country place with the express purpose of planning his career. Out of
the confidence of youth he determined upon two ultimate results. One
was, of course, wealth, and the other was an elaborate and entirely
proper wedding ceremony with a certain Miss Marion Lanmar. This young
lady, Randal had met at a football game at Harvard, and afterward in New
York, where she resided with her aunt, Mrs. Hester Beaufort.

The gigantic confidence of youth is certainly a matter of sublime wonder
to the gods. One at all familiar with the ways of things would have at
once pronounced both results quite impossible to the improvident young
man. But from the standpoint of exuberant youth there seemed to be no
important obstacles except the possible delay, and this was not very
material, as the world was young and these were things to be had in the
farther future.

For the present, Randal determined to organize a political machine and
transport it into one of the remote Western States. The East offered
no theatre for his talents; it was closely organized; its political
machinery was too strong for him to hope to oppose it. He would be
crushed out in the first skirmish.

Nor could he hope for early recognition by allying himself to any one
of the established organizations. These were crowded with deserving men,
and besides, he had no intention of serving as a political apprentice.
He had ability, he believed, as a political strategist, and he proposed
to operate free and untrammelled in a big, breezy arena.

Having determined upon a course, young Randal at once proceeded to put
it into operation. He held a council of war at the Plaza on Fifth Avenue
with two of his college associates, a stranded gambler, called for
convenience “Billy the Plunger,” and an old Virginia gentleman named
Major Culverson. The council sat in secret session for three days,
and the result was that the machine moved out into the Commonwealth of
Idaho, and began to operate. But the manners and customs of the West
were varied and mystic, and with the following summer the machine, badly
shaken, moved over into Nevada. Here, at Tulasco, on the Central Pacific
Railroad, the first college man deserted and, helped by his father,
returned with great penitence to the civilized East.

The machine passed on across the Humbolt River and proceeded to attempt
to shape the political destinies of Nevada. But disaster was following
in its wake, and, after an active and turbulent but quite unprofitable
career of a few months, it moved southward, battered and beaten, but
unconquered.

On the night of the third of October, the machine tramped into
Hackberry, on the Southern Pacific, and while men slept, the second
college man, concealing himself in a freight car, set out for the
Atlantic coast, cursing with lurid language all that part of the
continent lying west of the Mississippi.

On the following morning the machine held its second great council, but
this time it sat in desperate conclave above the Cow-Punchers' Saloon
in the town of Hackberry, facing a condition and not a theory. But
three members remained--Randal, the dauntiess Culver-son, and Billy the
Plunger.

The gambler was for organizing a faro bank, and working the towns down
the Gila, but as the bank had no funds, and the death rate usually
attendant upon such ventures in this primitive country was enormous,
his plan was held impracticable, and at four o'clock in the afternoon he
ceased to urge the wisdom of his scheme, and after having announced with
great solemnity that he was game to any limit the gang wanted, he lapsed
into the capacity of a spectator.

The Major advised moving south into Mexico, but as he seemed to have
no definite idea of what should be done when Mexico was reached, and it
finally appearing that moving south was simply a fad with Culverson, the
plan was likewise abandoned.

Young Randal, fired by his unabated purpose, urged the wisdom of trying
a round with the political fortunes of Arizona, but it was demonstrated
that he was considering a major venture, having for its object huge
honor, while at present there was crying need for some minor venture
that would probably result in the necessaries of life and a few hundred
dollars. Accordingly, at three o'clock in the morning, the machine
decided to assume, for a time, the vocation of the cattle herder, and
accept employment with a certain stock king of New Mexico.

It was understood, however, that this digression should be temporary,
and should be abandoned just as soon as the machine should feel able to
resume its original purpose. It was at this point in the deliberations
of the conclave that Major Culverson made his famous statement, to wit,
that the gates of hell could not ultimately prevail against a political
machine composed of a Massachusetts Yankee, a dead game sport, and an
old Virginia gentleman.

From this time forth the career of Randal's machine was a concatenation
of fortunes and misfortunes, principally the latter, quite incredible.
But the three men clung together, and a single enthusiastic purpose is
a marvellous motor power, so that when Fate finally lent a helping
hand, the machine became a something of importance in the affairs of a
Southwestern Commonwealth. Once on the upward way, the ability of Randal
and the daring energies of his associates carried it forward with great
strides, so great that on the evening of the day with which this history
has to do, the Massachusetts Yankee was the Governor of a State, the
Major was Auditor, and Billy the Plunger, now known by his signature as
Ambercrombie Hergan, was Secretary of State.

The sun had gone downward from sight behind the far mountains, now
changed from blue to a murky gray. The Governor, recalled to a sense
of the hour, closed his mahogany desk, locked the door of his private
office, and walked leisurely out through the State-house. As he passed
down the steps of the Capitol he met the Auditor coming up.

“How are you, Al?” said the Auditor.

“Charmed,” replied the Governor.

“Ah,” said the Major, with great ceremony, “you may be charmed, sir,
but to me, sir, yuur face wears the haunted look of one who holds three
nines against what he strongly suspects to be a pat hand.”

“Sage,” said the Governor, bowing, “I tremble for my hidden thoughts.”

“You're a fool,” said the Major, stepping up beside the Executive. “I
want to know where you are going.”

“I!” said the Governor, “I am going to the southeast. Do you see
that little railroad? I am even now about to commit myself to its
irresponsible mercies.”

“You must not go, Al,” continued the Auditor. “Attend, I will nominate
the reasons. First, there is a julep party at my palatial residence.”

“Insufficient,” said the Governor.

“Second, there is a strike at the Big Injin.”

“Insufficient,” said the Governor.

“And third,” continued the Auditor, lowering his voice, “Honorable
Ambercrombie Hergan is at this very hour in the second room of Crawley's
Emporium, playing the taxes of Bolas County, and losing them, sir,
losing them.”

The Governor's face grew hard, and his remarks for a moment were quite
unprintable. Then he turned to the Auditor.

“Ned,” he continued, “you must get him out, and take him up to my
residence. I will be here by ten o'clock. I am compelled to go to El
Paso. I can't get out of it. I am compelled to go.”

“Compelled?” ejaculated the Major, “who, in the name of all the living
gods, is compelling you? He must be greater than the railroads, greater
than the legislature, greater than the Federal Court. Compelling the
Honorable Alfred Capland Randal? Shade of the blooming Witch of Endor!”

“Ned,” said the Governor slowly, “I will explain it all just as soon
as I can. In the meantime you must help me. You must get him out. Won't
you, Ned?”

The Governor put his hand on the Auditor's shoulder, just as he had done
a thousand times before when he needed the help of this unusual man.
And, just as he had done a thousand times before, the Major declared
that the Executive was a “damned rascal” and a “no account youngster,”
 and that he would not do it, when all the time he knew deep down in his
heart that he loved this straight young fellow better than any other
thing in the world, and that presently he was going to do exactly what
he said he would not do.

The Governor knew this also, for he ran down the steps without stopping
to interrupt the amiable flow of the Auditor's depreciatory remarks.

At the depot he found the Chinaman, Bumgarner, waiting with his coat.

That such a primitive Celestial should be saddled with such a name arose
entirely from the pious instincts of the Major. It happened that the
Virginian was standing in a crowd at the corner near Crawley's Emporium
when the Chinaman first appeared, having tramped from the coast. The
Major, who was slightly in his cups, called the Chinaman over to the
corner, and inquired by what appellation he was known, to which the
foreigner responded that he was called Fu Lun. “Fu Lun!” shouted the
Major, fiercely, “a name smacking of the devil, and not to be tolerated
in a Christian State.” And then turning to the crowd, “Gentlemen,” he
continued, “behold! I do a goodly missionary work. I rebuke the evil
spirit dwelling in the bosom of this heathen. I give it a Christian
name. I name it Bumgarner.”

Thus the first evidence of civilization fastened upon the Celestial,
and, as the Major's mandate was not to be disregarded, as “Bumgarner”
 the Chinaman had gone.

The journey to El Paso was not an idle one for the Governor. In a very
short time he should be in the presence of Miss Marion Lanmar and
her aunt Mrs. Beaufort, and, of all times since their first eventful
meeting, this was the very time he was not prepared for an interview.
Prior to the notable exodus of the machine to Idaho, Randal had called
upon Miss Lanmar, who was at that time a very young woman in college.
The two were quite important, quite enthusiastic, and pitiably ignorant
of the world's ways.

This last meeting to them seemed big with fate, and was dramatic to the
limit of a playactor's rehearsal. Youth lent to it all the glamour of
romance. To Miss Lanmar young Randal was her chivalrous knight-errant,
on the eve of his departure into a wild and unknown land full of
mysterious peril, in quest of wealth and fair fame, all for her. To
Randal she was the Lily Maid of Astolat, whom it was fate that he should
worship with noble deeds until he won. It was all in strict accord with
romantic custom in such cases made and provided, and terminated quite in
keeping with the ideal conventions.

When the door had closed upon the handsome young fellow whom Miss Marion
Lanmar had promised to love for ever more, that young lady remained
standing motionless by the mantel shelf, her face very white, and her
heart very desperate and very true. To the dainty Miss Lanmar it was all
very real, and by no means the pretty little comedy which the world out
of its practical wisdom would have known it to be.

To Mr. Alfred Randal, as he passed down the steps of Mrs. Beaufort's
residence on the avenue, the world was now a vast arena, into which he
was going, armed and knighted with his lady's colors on his helm. His
heart beat high in his bosom. He would be a factor in great affairs;
the hour would come when he would return, famous, wealthy past belief,
announced by the heralds. He could not know that he was but another
character in that sweet old fairy story which men and women have striven
to act over and over again before they learn with dumb horror how
pitiless and how practical are the ways of Providence.

Yet the wise man who accompanies the youth to the gateway of the arena
will not say: “To-morrow Circumstance will beat you from your horse
and tramp you under, and instead of returning victor, you will return a
<DW36>.” Although the wise man knows full well that of all results this
latter is most probable, yet he will not say it, because the enthusiasm
of youth is a marvellous power, difficult to estimate, and what it may
accomplish no man can tell.

The Governor had not seen this young woman after that night, but he had
clung to his intention with the determination of a man who has a single
object in life. An intermittent correspondence had been maintained, but
after years this intention to wed Miss Lanmar had become rather an ideal
something, and in this there was peril. But a few weeks before, he had
intimated vaguely, that he was now a person of some local importance,
and with no inconsiderable prospects of wealth, and to this Miss Lanmar
had intimated quite as vaguely that she was waiting. But in it all
there, seemed to be a powerful, albeit somewhat indistinct doubt. Years
had passed, and years had a way of working frightful changes in people.
The Miss Lanmar of to-day could not be the school-girl whom he had
known.

The Executive leaned back in a seat of the stuffy little coach and
speculated with grave concern At any rate, this alliance was now
quite impossible. Complications had been thrust in; a duty, or what
he conceived to be a duty, had sprung up, and this duty it was not his
intention to evade.




II

THE Governor walked gravely down the long platform at El Paso, looking
up at the windows of the Pullmans, wondering, rather indistinctly, how
he should be able to recognize the irridescent princess of his romantic
youth. A <DW64> porter touched him on the arm and inquired if he was
Governor Randal. The Executive replied that he was, whereupon the <DW64>
with much profound obeisance announced that Miss Lanmar was waiting in
the drawing-room of the opposite Pullman.

The Governor sprang up the steps of the coach. As he entered, a young
woman, wearing a dark travelling dress, came forward to meet him. She
was of medium height, with heavy brown hair, fine eyes, arched brows,
and quite a faultless nose. But the great charm of the woman was her
splendid bearing, and her instinctive culture.

Just how this meeting began Alfred Randal could never afterwards quite
recall. He could remember in vivid details the first picture of this
superb woman as she arose to greet him, but then, just then, the love
of his youth that had seemed to sleep under an anaesthetic for so many
years, suddenly woke into glorious life, and gushed into his heart
and overran his senses with its marvellous vitality. What transpired
thereafter was provokingly indistinct. He remembered being presented to
the aunt, Mrs. Beaufort, and her astonishment, and her incredulous
query as to whether he lived in this “terrible country” to which he had
replied that he could not be said to live, but that it was his part to
exist in this rather primitive land. He remembered that the three sat
together in the drawing-room of the coach and talked of his return to
New York, of his ultimate success, and his assured future. He remembered
also that for the time he had forgotten the grave difficulty in the way
of such a future and his stern decision made but a few minutes before.
He remembered also that through it all he had been very foolish and very
confident and idiotically happy, and how at the parting he had kissed
Miss Lanmar's hand and blushed like a school-girl, and then jumped down
from the moving train at the peril of his life.

The Governor stood upon the platform and watched the great train as
it thundered away in the distance. The interview which had just ended,
although a thing apparently unreal, had swept him out from under the
influence of an illusion that had served to make his life in the great
Southwest bearable, even happy. From this time forth it could never
be what it had been. The man felt like one who, having been so long a
captive in a dungeon that he was half content, and his memories of
the world had become vague and unreal, is suddenly and without warning
lifted into the sunshine of the great glorious world and held there
until his heart is filled to drunkenness with the beauty of it all, and
then, ruthlessly and on the instant, is thrust back into the rayless
gloom of his dungeon.

Randal stood for a time looking at the rows of dim lights scattered
about the station like dismal fireflies. Then he crossed to the freight
train upon which he was to return and climbed up into the cab with the
driver.

“What time shall we get in?” he asked.

“By the top of the night, Governor, if we have luck,” answered the
driver, pulling open the throttle.

The engine snorted and pounded along in the dark like some huge beast.
The Governor sat in the cab window and looked out. The night air was
sweet and cool, his face was hot. Two hours before he had decided what
he should do, and dismissed the matter; but new and powerful elements
had arisen and ordered him to rehear and decide anew.

Ambercrombie Hergan had lost and wasted the money of the State. There
was now a deficit in his accounts of some fifty thousand dollars. There
was no way by which this loss could be met unless Randal should pay it,
and to do this would take everything he had on earth. It would mean the
sacrifice of his mining stock, which, if held, promised great returns.
It would be ruin, utter ruin, to make good the loss; yet the gambler,
although a gambler, was his friend, and two hours before he had not
hesitated at all.

Motives, mighty, selfish motives, which until this hour he had beaten
back, now leaped up clamoring to be heard, howling for time against his
decision, time to show the right of their cause, the wisdom of it, the
ultimate justice of it. Something asked him roughly what right had he to
jeopardize the future of this woman who loved him. What right had he to
deceive, to sacrifice her? Who was Hergan that he should be considered
against this woman? Who, but a reckless and improvident adventurer? It
was not his own happiness urged the something; that would be a matter of
little moment. It was the happiness of another, and that other was true,
innocent of wrong, superlatively just. What contrast could be drawn
between the woman and this gambler? Duty? What duty could he owe to
the irresponsible Hergan that could approach in the slightest part the
measure of the duty which he owed to the woman who had trusted him for
so many years, and waited, and loved him?

Yet against all this, certain pictures came up from the past,--vivid,
proclaiming a mighty truth, a truth which the man knew and acknowledged
in his heart, the truth that if these positions were reversed, Hergan,
gambler though he was, would not hesitate for a moment. Had he hesitated
that morning in the Rio Grande when Randal's horse had fallen and
was being swept down with the current, carrying his master under him,
tangled in the stirrup strap? Had he hesitated when it became necessary
deliberately to steal and burn the bogus ballots in Garfield County,
when to do so seemed little less than deliberate suicide? Had he
hesitated that terrible day on the Rio Sonora, when there was no time
for warning, but time only to spring forward and take the knife in his
shoulder? Had this man ever hesitated when the welfare of Randal was
at stake? Would he not gladly, and without comment, give up his life
to-morrow if the Governor should ask it of him?

The Governor passed his hand across his forehead and closed his eyes.
When he opened them he had decided, and against this second decision
there should be now no appeal and no rehearing.




III

THE Secretary of State was far removed from the ordinary. He was one of
those not infrequent persons whom men are quite unable to classify. At
times he arose far beyond the limits set for him by his associates,
and at times he dropped far below. There was about the man a sort of
indefinite reserve that impressed his fellows and inspired confidence
in those positions requiring rash and apparently impracticable moves.
Ordinarily, in commonplace affairs, his judgment was not considered
sound, or even valuable, and at such times no one would have thought for
a moment of advising with this man. It was only when sound common-sense
could see no way out that the machine appealed to Hergan, and at such
times he came forward with some freak venture which was frightfully
perilous and never ordinary, and never quite a failure.

Success, usually arose, however, not from the ultimate wisdom of
Hergan's plans, but from the fact that his unique move would throw the
affair into a sort of convulsion resulting in a new situation, and this
new situation the sound judgment of his fellows would usually be able to
control. The counsel of Ambercrombie Hergan was a protean agent.

The grave vice in the character of the Secretary of State lay in the
fact that he possessed no idea of perspective. He would wager his last
dollar with the same joyous unconcern with which he had wagered his
first, and he would have staked the entire Southwest, if he possessed
it, as readily as a Mexican peso, upon the turn of a card or the result
of a horse race. As to the antecedents of the Honorable Ambercrombie
Hergan, even conjecture was silent. He had come up from a mysterious
substratum of New York,--for what, and by reason of what, no man
inquired. This mighty new land traced no records and propounded
no questions. The arena stood open with its doors thrown back. Any
combatant who pleased could enter. Heralded or unheralded, it mattered
not. Good or bad, learned or ignorant, of yokel blood or princely
lineage, it mattered not. If he were fittest, he could win.

From this organic defect of his mental build, and not from evil animus,
had resulted the sad state of the Secretary's accounts. He had never
entirely appreciated the important distinction between his own money
and that which belonged to the Commonwealth. He had been thoughtless,
reckless, unconcerned, until now he was hopelessly involved. Yet even
at this stage when his term of office was fast drawing to a close, he
failed to appreciate the gravity of his position, and treated the matter
with good-natured unconcern, as of no moment.

The Auditor and Secretary of State sat together in the Governor's
library awaiting his return. In appearance the Auditor was a muscular
little man of most marvellous vitality, with a fierce white mustache,
and a fund of quaint oaths and semi-dramatic phrases hugely expressive
and at times artistic; while the Honorable Ambercrombie Hergan was very
tall and very broad, with a shock of heavy black hair, wide jaws, and a
big crooked nose. Far back in his youth this nose had been straight,
but one night, in a barroom on the Bowery, a difference of opinion had
arisen over some inconsequential matter, and thereafter the gambler's
nose had assumed a contour not contemplated in the original design.

The Major was talking, and pounding the table vigorously, when the
Chinese servant entered with a tray and some glasses. The Virginian drew
himself up and stepped back from the table.

“Well, Bumgarner,” he said, “I hail your resurrection; I glory in your
return to life. You have been dead no inconsiderable period, sir.”

The Chinaman replied that he had been engaged in a laborious but
unsuccessful hunt for the bottle of Angostura bitters.

“Angostura bitters?” cried the Major, “marvellous, inscrutable heathen!
Will you deign to reveal your reason for requiring the Angostura
bitters?”

The Celestial responded that he presumed bitters was an element
requisite to the rather mysterious drink which he had been requested to
compound.

“Hear him, hear him!” thundered the Major, as though addressing some
present but invisible avenging demon; “hear the vandal! Bitters in a
julep! Mighty, intelligent shade of Simple Simon! Attend and observe the
idiocy of this savage!” Then he crossed to the astonished Chinaman and
took him gently by the collar.

“Bumgarner,” he said softly, “you are a frightful example of man's
neglect. You have been trained by a Massachusetts Yankee. Ergo, your
lack of knowledge is sublime. Bitters you might put in a plebeian gin
fizz, and be happy thereafter. Bitters you might put in a high ball of
whiskey, and live thereafter. But bitters in a julep, _magnum sacrum!_
the gods would crush you! Bumgarner, you are an awful throbbing error,
and you have had a providential escape from death. Now,” continued the
Major, seizing the Chinaman by the shoulder and turning him toward the
door, “you may depart, and burn a few joss sticks, and ponder upon my
remarks.”

The almond-eyed Celestial vanished, wondering vaguely if it had not been
better to remain in San Francisco and launder shirts in a cellar than to
attempt to cater to the depraved taste of such incomprehensible foreign
devils.

“Now, Bill,” continued the Major, seating himself at the table, “I want
to know what you are going to do.”

“About what?” asked the gambler.

“About this money which you owe the State,” said the Major. “Do you
realize, sir, that our stand in the Southwest is just about closing, and
that we have got to square up and pull out?”

“I reckon so,” replied the gambler, as though it were a matter of no
importance.

“You reckon so! You irresponsible truck horse! You reckon so!”
 snorted the Major. “You will cease to indulge in the dainty pastime of
speculation when you get a log-chain on your leg and a striped suit on
your back.”

The Secretary of State laughed. “Something will turn up,” he said.

“Ambercrombie Hergan,” said the Major, pounding the table with his hand,
“for a broken, a branded, a long-suffering cow pony of Satan, you have
the blindest, most stupendous Presbyterian faith in Providence of any
white creature ambling south of the Central Pacific Railroad; but
you're sweetening on a bluff this hand, and I am going to call you.”

The gambler's face grew serious. “What are you prodding for, Ned?” he
asked.

The Auditor leaned forward on the table. “You are planning to slide
out,” he said, “and it don't go.”

“Would it hurt you or Al?” asked the gambler anxiously.

The Auditor reached over and placed his hand on Hergan's arm. “It would
not hurt me,” he continued, “and it would be no bones if it did, but
it would hurt the boy, and he must not be hurt. Don't you know that the
moment you are gone, Randal will sacrifice everything he possesses and
pay up the deficit? And that would ruin him.”

The gambler's face lengthened. “I had not thought about that,” he said
slowly, “but you are right, he would do that. He is that sort of a man.
I have been a fool, an infernal fool, but I did not think about the boy
getting hurt, not once.” The man shut his teeth tight together and the
big muscles swelled out on his jaws.

The Auditor sat and watched the man across the table from him, and
admired his iron nerve in the terrible struggle to decide between
himself and the welfare of his friend. The man was evidently suffering.
His face showed it plainly; the battle must be a bitter one. The Auditor
wondered how it would result. He pitied the man, and in spite of all,
half hoped that he would decide to save himself.

Presently the gambler turned slowly and lifted his face, white, haggard,
ten years older than he had been an hour before.

“I don't see how to keep him from doing it,” he muttered; “I don't see
how.”

The Auditor started. This man had not been thinking of himself at all.

“You see,” continued Hergan. “I am about fifty thousand short, and there
is no way to raise that much money,--no way in God's world. If I slide
over the Rio, Al will pay it to keep them from extraditing me; and if I
stay here, he will pay it to keep them from sending me to the Pen. It's
the devil's own trap, and works both ways.”

“Who got the money, Bill?” asked the Auditor.

“Crawley, and old Martin, of the Golden Horn Mining Company. Crawley got
most of it.”

“A plague of fat old gamblers,” said the Major, solemnly; “they are both
as rich as they are mean, and as mean as they are crooked.”

At this moment the door opened and the Governor entered.




IV

THE Executive stopped for a moment and scrutinized his visitors
quizzically; then he laughed. “May I inquire, gentlemen, whence arises
this gloom?”

The Auditor bowed low. “Good sir,” he said, “your Excellency fails to
distinguish between gloom and the gravity of sages.”

“If the funereal,” replied the Governor, “be a _sine qua non_ of the
converse of the wise, then there has been here this night great cause
for envy on the part of Solomon, the Son of David, King of Israel; for
such gloom I have not met with in a world of evil days.”

“And, sir,” responded the Auditor, waving his hand like a barbaric
king, “if absence of respect for the dignity of the thoughtful be a
symptom of organic mental defect, then there is now here, in truth,
great cause for envy upon the part of Wamba, the Son of Witless, the
Son of Weatherbrain. For such amiable impudence is marvellous to
contemplate.”

“Boys,” said the gambler rising, “if you will kindly come down out
of the clouds, I will be much obliged to you both, because I have got
something to say, and this is just as good a time to say it as any.”

The Auditor resumed his seat at the table. The Governor took up a chair,
moved it back deliberately into the shadow of the room and sat down.

“It is like this,” continued the gambler, “we three have stood in for a
long time, and I guess we know each other pretty well. We did n't take
no oath to stand by each other when we started, but I reckon that is
what we calculated to do. Anyway that is what we did do. If we had n't a
done it, we would n't have been deuce high in this Southwest. I did n't
have no faith in Al's machine when it started; I thought it was a wild
goose chase, but I did n't say nothing, because I had nothing to lose.
I was broke, and anything coming my way was pure velvet, so I joined in
and come out here.

“Since that time we have had our ups and downs, if God's creatures ever
had 'em. We have lied a lot, and we've stole some, and we've starved
most of the time, and we have been poor and miserable and broke, but we
have played fair with each other, and we have never stacked the pack
nor dealt from the bottom. Then, one day, the luck turned and we won out
through the roof, just like it always does if you stay long enough and
keep doubling the bet. You two were elected, and Al appointed me.

“I reckon none of us are going to forget the hell that appointment
raised. They said I was an ignorant understrapper, a short card gambler,
and a leary element; and it was true, every blooming word of it Then the
newspapers pitched into Al; they said that it was to be hoped that the
new Governor would now have 'the moral courage to at least suppress
the shady member of his machine'--them are the very words; I'll never
forget 'em, and they meant me.

“I guess I went to you boys, and told you I had better keep out, but I
reckon I did n't put up a very stiff case, because I was hot at the row.
I would n't have cared if the howlers had been better men than I was,
but I knew they were all just the same kind of cattle--unbranded,
straggling steers, gathered up from anywhere but a good place. As for
being shady, there was n't a man between the Gila and the Pecos white
enough to pass an Eastern grand jury, and as for being a gambler, there
was n't a mother's son of the batch that would n't have coppered his
soul on a black jack if the bank would have cashed it for a dollar.”

Hergan paused for a moment and looked at the Auditor. Then he added,
“Exceptin' of course, you and Al.”

“Then,” the gambler went on: “I guess Al got mad. He made a little
speech; we was all there, and it was mighty good talk to hear. He
said there had n't been no 'invidious distinctions'--them were his
words,--during all the years when nothing had come our way but just one
dose of bad luck after another until we reckoned there was n't no God at
all,--least ways, if there was any, that He did n't operate south of
the Central Pacific Railroad, and now when we had finally landed on our
feet, there was n't going to be no 'invidious distinctions.' I am bound
to say that it seemed mighty good to hear Al talk like he did, and I
went ahead and let him appoint me.”

The Secretary of State moved a little nearer to the table, and an
almost imperceptible shadow flitted across his face. “All the time,” he
continued, “I knowed it was wrong. I knowed that what the mudslingers
were sayin' was gospel. I knowed that I was n't fit for the job no more
than a Chinaman is fit for a pope. I knowed that the gambler in me was
ground in, and the other was just only rubbed on the outside, and that
the gambler part was going to run things,--and it did.”

The man paused for a moment and turned to the Governor. “Now,” he said,
“I have come to the point, and it's this: I got into this hole and I am
going to get out of it; it's my game now; I am not going to stand any
side bets. You have both got to promise me right here that you will keep
your hands off this matter,--clear off--unless I say it goes.”

The gambler stopped, rested his arms heavily on the table and looked at
his companions. The Virginian and the Executive were silent; both men
realized fully the true import of Hergan's demand. He was seeking to
prevent any sacrifice on their part; that was all, and if he had been
the most skilful diplomat in the world, he could not have moved more
adroitly.

The Governor looked up at the massive face of the gambler, marred by
evil circumstance and the riot of dissipation, and wondered--as he had
wondered many a time before,--at the splendid unselfishness of this
man. From whence could have come this flower of nobility? The life of
Ambercrombie Hergan had been sterile soil indeed for such a plant as
this. How could it be in the economy of men that such princely fidelity
obtained alone even without trace of the common attendant virtues?

For the obligations of the law Ambercrombie Hergan had no regard. For
the obligations of the citizen he had no regard. Even for the common
obligations of morality he maintained the most stolid unconcern. Honesty
was a name to him, and right and duty and honor were merely names to
him. Yet blooming in the barren garden of this gambler's heart was
something fairer than them all.

“Well,” asked Hergan, with a trace of anxiety in his voice, “are you
going to promise?”

The Governor arose. “This is a very serious matter,” he said slowly; “we
must be given a few minutes in which to decide.”

“That 's fair enough,” replied the gambler. “You two can go into the
other room. I'll wait.”

The Auditor and the Executive retired, and the Secretary of State
resumed his seat beside the table, the suggestion of a smile on his
face, he knew perfectly that if he could secure the promise of his
companions it would be maintained inviolate.

Presently the door opened and the two men entered. “Bill,” said the
Governor, “we promise.”

The gambler arose, and stretched his long limbs like one relieved from
the weight of a crushing burden. Then he turned to his companions.
“Boys,” he said almost gaily, “I may as well tell you now that I am
going to New York Saturday night.”

“And I may add,” responded the Governor, “that I am going Friday night.”




V

YOU see,” the Governor was saying,” the failure of this bank in San
Francisco has wiped out every penny I had in the world. On the fourth
day of next March I will be poorer than the ordinary drayman. So poor
that I must begin all over again, and I have no heart to do it.”

Miss Marion Lanmar was silent. Her bands rested upon the great aims of
the chair in which she was seated. Her face might have been a cast; it
was so very motionless.

“I should not mind if it were not for you,” the young man went on. “I
mean,”--he hesitated for a moment,--“if I had never seen you; if I had
never known you. But now the effort would seem so miserably inadequate,
if it were not made for you. I have loved you and lived for you too
long. I have grown accustomed to you as the mighty incentive. Every path
that I have travelled has had you waiting at the end. Every battle I
have fought has seemed to hold your happiness in its balance. Even the
meagre gains of all the weary commonplace days have been to me so much
or so little added to the kingdom of the queen. So I could have gone on
to the end, but now, without you I have no heart at all.”

The man leaned over and rested his arm on the mantel-shelf. “I have read
somewhere,” he continued, “how the evil fiend strove to destroy a man
whom he hated; how he robbed him of his wealth, of his friends, of his
fair fame, and how the man worked on, laughing in the demon's face, and
how it all failed, until one morning the evil fiend reached down into
the man's heart and plucked the motive out of his life, and then the
man threw away his tools and came and sat in the doorway of his shop. I
suppose it is all very cowardly, to talk as I am talking, but it would
be very much worse, I should think, to deceive myself and you.” The
woman did not answer. She was looking into the fire. The little blue
flames in the wide fireplace danced up and down upon their bed of coal
in impish merriment at all the trouble of men's lives.

Presently the man began again. “Yet a woman cannot wait always,” he
said, “and I have no right to ask it of you. I must step aside out of
your life and beg to be forgotten. It is a terrible ordeal for one who
has gone down into the _melée_ with his lady's colors on his helm to
return beaten and overthrown and say, 'This quest is not for me.' It is
hard to have the hope of one's life battered out and to live on in the
world, and yet men do, and I shall, I presume.

“We are taught in youth that the world is a happy place, and I judge
that it is a bit of illusion, like the black goblin and the fairies, and
yet we all try very hard to believe the old housewife tales, and cling
to them, and give them up grudgingly and with regret. I shall always
remember how very sorry I was when I first realized that there really
were no fairies. I was only a child, but it made me unhappy for days.
It seemed to put all my reckoning out of joint. And so I have always
believed that happiness existed in the world, and that it came to men
somewhere in their lives about as the beautiful princess comes in the
fairy stories. It never occurred to me to doubt its coming. True, it
never came, but everything that did come seemed only to prepare a way
for its coming at some day farther on. Now I see that this is just an
illusion like the others, and I confess that the discovery has jarred me
frightfully.”

The man's voice wavered for a moment; then it grew stronger. “I don't
quite see how the world can ever seem a beautiful place after to-night.
The sky may be very blue indeed, but the man whose eyes ache will not
look up to see it. The birds may sing gloriously in the trees, but the
man whose heart is an empty house will not care at all.”

Randal stopped and looked down at the woman. He noticed how very soft
and heavy her brown hair was, and how delicate and slender her hands
were. He noted vaguely, too, the artistic effect of the folds of her
gown and the shadows on her face.

“Marion,” he said, “If I did not love you better than any other thing in
the world, I would not be urging these bitter arguments against my own
happiness. I would not be so desperately anxious about your welfare. I
should not be so fearful of the future. I should take the chance without
the hesitation of a moment. But the very depth of my love makes me a
coward. I could not bear to see you subject to all the evil things that
come with poverty. I know what a frightful plight it is--how it crushes
out the sweetness and the nobility of one's life, how it squeezes the
heart, day after day, until it finally becomes a dry husk in one's
breast.”

Randal's voice was now thick with emotion. “Marion,” he said, “do you
hear me? Do you believe me?”

The woman's hands tightened on the great arms of the chair, and for a
moment she was silent; then she began to speak, slowly and distinctly.

“I do not know.” she said. “I must have time to think. Yet I have
believed you all these years. I must believe you now. Yes, I do believe
you now. But you are wrong, frightfully wrong. You forget that a woman
is a human being with a heart. You think I am afraid of the world,
afraid of poverty, afraid of life as God makes it, as God wills it; that
I am a fragile something that the rain and the sunlight would ruin if it
touched; that I am a something more or less than you, a something that
requires ease and luxury and all the gilded stage-setting of wealth--and
you are wrong. If I love you, of what value to me are all those other
things without you? If I love you, it is not all these things I want--it
is you. I ask you to answer this, and by what is true in your heart,
know what is true in mine: Would you be happy with all that wealth can
give you and without me?”

“No,” said the man, “not after to-night. No.”

“No more would I,” added the woman.

The heart, as it is said, speaks clearer to the heart when tongues are
silent, and it is said that grief and happiness when riding high in
their meridian have no need for the cumbrous medium of language.

After a long silence, Miss Lanmar began again. “Men cannot understand,”
 she said; “a woman's heart is so miserably strange. Things either slip
around it, leaving no mark at all, or they sink in and become a very
part of the woman's heart itself. There is no middle ground; no half
joy; no middle hurt. So it comes about that if one's image creeps into
her heart, it must remain. True, the world may never know; the world is
very stupid. But for all that, the woman's heart will hold its tenant,
and when she is alone or in the dark, she will know and feel its
presence. It may be that the woman will pray to be rid of the evil
thing, or it may be that she will pray to hold it always as a gift of
good, but be that as it happens, the woman's heart will remain forever
helpless to evict its tenant.

“Is it strange, then, if I love you, that I should want to go with you
and live with you, and be with you always, and make your joys and your
burdens my joys and my burdens, and have a share and an interest in
everything that comes to you? Is it strange that I should hold wealth or
place or even honor as nothing against you? Is it strange that I should
be miserable, thoroughly, utterly miserable with every other thing in
the world, and you denied?”

The woman's voice faltered and broke; her hands relaxed, and began to
slip from the great arms of the chair. The man came over, and knelt down
beside her and put his arms around her.

“Marion, dear heart,” he said, “you do love me. You will trust me a
little while,--just a little while?”

The woman's head slipped down on his shoulder. “Love you!” she murmured,
“I have always loved you. Surely I shall always love you. But when you
are gone, the world is so empty, so miserably empty!”




VI

I THOROUGHLY appreciate everything I you have mentioned, Mr. Hergan,”
 said the clerk Parks, “but it is quite impossible. Mr. Mason is entirely
inaccessible. I should not dare interrupt him.”

“Look here, my friend,” responded the gambler. “I have heard this same
talk every day for the last week, and it don't go any longer. I have
got to see this lawyer, and I have got to see him now. Do you understand
me?”

“Oh, yes,” replied the clerk, with a faint smile, “I understand you
perfectly, but it is entirely useless to urge the matter any farther.
The business with which Mr. Mason is at present engaged is of great
magnitude. He would not permit an interview at all. I am very sorry,
but, of course, I can do nothing for you.”

The gambler did not respond. For a few moments he was silent. Then he
put his hands into the inside pocket of his coat and drew forth a rather
battered leather pocket-book. He held the pocket-book under the table,
opened it slowly, and selecting a fifty-dollar bill from among a number
of others, laid it gently on the table.

“There,” he said, “is my ante. I want in the game.”

The eyes of the clerk began to contract slowly at the corners.

“My dear man,” he said, “I should like to do this for you, but I don't
see how I can. I don't believe Mr. Mason would even listen to me just
now. I don't----”

“Wait,” responded the gambler; “I sweeten it.”

Thereupon he selected another bill from the pocket-book and spread it
out carefully beside the other upon the table.

The little bald clerk began to drum on the chair with his fingers. His
eyes wandered from the money to the door of Mason's private office, and
back again. Presently he turned to the gambler.

The Hon. Ambercrombie Herman held up two fingers. “Don't call,” he said,
“I tilt it to one hundred and fifty.” And he added another bill to the
two, and pushed the money across the table to the clerk. Then he closed
the pocket-book deliberately and replaced it in his coat.

Parks arose, picked up the money without a word, and passed into
Randolph Mason's private office, closing the door carefully behind him.
In a very few moments the clerk returned. He came up dose to the gambler
and put his hand confidentially on his shoulder.

“My friend,” he said, in a low tone, “you are not a fool. I have told
some lies to get you this interview. Look sharp, and say as little as
possible.”

“What lies?” asked the gambler, arising.

“Such as were useful,” responded the clerk. “Quite too tedious to
enumerate. Please walk into Mr. Mason's office, sir, and remember that
you are my brother-in-law. Answer the questions which are put to you,
and don't volunteer talk. It is n't wise.”

The gambler opened the door to Randolph Mason's private office and
entered.




VII

HE Secretary of State came slowly down the steps from Randolph Mason's
office. At the entrance to the great building he stopped and looked up
and down the busy, jostling thoroughfare. It had been but a few years
since he was a grain in this vortex, and now that past seemed ages
removed. He was not conscious of anything of interest in the very
familiar scene. Just why he had stopped to look, this man would not
have been quite able to explain. In truth, he was striving to obtain his
mental bearings. He had been flung violently upon another view point,
and he was endeavoring to comprehend the loom of this new land. His
sensations were not unlike those of one who but an hour before had gone
into the operating room of a surgeon, walking as he believed to his
death, and now returned with the tumor dissected out, and the hope of
life big in his bosom. The world was an entirely different place from
what it had been some hours before, and the gambler's steps were firmer,
and his ancient careless spirit had returned.

At this moment, as it pleased Fate, a cab stopped before a broker's
office on the opposite-side of the street, and the Governor stepped out.
The gambler darted across and caught his companion by the shoulder. The
Governor turned suddenly.

“Well,” he said, in astonishment, “is this an assault _vi et armis?_”

“No,” said the gambler. “It's worse than that, Al. It's a mandamus. You
are not to go in that broker's office.”

“Not to go in?” echoed the Executive. “Why not?”

“Al,” said the gambler, grinning like a Hindoo idol, “I said this here
was a mandamus. I guess the judge don't ever explain 'why not' in a
mandamus.”

“Good chancellor,” replied the Governor, with mock gravity, “I resist
the order.”

“On what ground?” said the lion. Ambercrombie Hergan, with such a sage
judicial air as might obtain with a truck horse.

“First,” replied the Governor, “that the mandamus was improvidently
awarded. Second, that the Court issuing the writ was without
jurisdiction. And, third, that the act sought to be restrained is not
entirely ministerial, but one largely within the discretion of the
officer.”

“All them objections,” said the gambler, “this Court overrules.”

“But,” continued the Executive, “in this case the mandamus cannot lie. I
move to quash the writ.”

“But it does lie,” asserted the powerful devotee of fortune, hooking his
arm through that of the Executive and turning him down the street, “and
she can't be squashed.”

The Governor had observed the very great change in the man, and knowing
the Honorable Ambercrombie Hergan, he knew that this erratic person
had chanced upon some solution for his dilemma--strange and but
half-practical, the Governor had no doubt, but certainly not
commonplace, and so he made no further offer of resistance.

“Al,” said the gambler, hurrying his companion through the crowded
street, “do you know where you are going?”

“I have n't the slightest idea,” observed the Governor, with greatest
unconcern.

“Well, I'll tell you. You are going first to the hotel, then to the
railroad, then to the Southwest, and you have just fifty-nine minutes
between you and the train.”

The Governor stopped short. “I can't go, Bill. I must sell these
stocks.”

“That's just the point,” said the gambler. “You aint going to sell
them stocks. That's why I issued this here mandamus.” And he seized the
Executive by the arm and fairly dragged him across the street.

“Bill,” protested the Governor, “Bill, this is all nonsense. It don't
go.”

“Everything goes,” said the gambler. “Come on. We have lost three of
them fifty-nine minutes already.”




VIII

THE Emporium of Crawley was not quite a trading-place as the Greek
root of the word would indicate, unless transactions in which the
unwary bartered his gain for experience, and the great unscrubbed of the
Southwest pitted their wage against the riot of dissipation, could be
held to partake of the nature of commerce. It was a fad with Crawley to
assert that his Emporium was a clearinghouse,--a rather grim jest, heavy
with truth. Indeed, all the currency of this primitive land seemed to
pass, sooner or later, through the mammoth establishment of First Class
Crawley, and in season and out of season as the dollar went through, a
portion paused and remained in the fingers of the proprietor. And for
this, also,--as the common-law pleader would put it,--truth clung to the
pet declaration of Crawley.

When the population gathered night after night under the roof of his
Emporium, their troubles came also; and when the smoke grew thick and
the tanglefoot whiskey began to assert itself, there were other things
to clear up beside matters of currency. Matters of consequence and
matters of no consequence were cleared by the same rapid, drastic
measures. Bad men here decided who was the worst or the best, as they
were pleased with the term. The henchmen of rival cattle kings submitted
the vexatious question of a brand on a stray heifer to this court of
instant resort and quick decision, and other concerns of the citizen,
affecting perhaps his truth, or honor, or ability for a vice, were
determined suddenly and for all time without the wrangling of counsel or
the tedium of courts.

If a Mexican was so short sighted as to slip his knife into a
tenderfoot, some one shot the Mexican, and the crowd “lickered up.” If
the faro dealer killed his man, it was usually because the man needed
killing, and certainly the faro dealer was the best judge of this.
On the contrary, if one shot the dealer, this was considered a public
calamity, demanding an explanation, since the dealer was a _quasi_
public functionary, and the convenience of the citizen required that the
game should continue. One's life was perhaps the cheapest thing below
the Central Pacific Railroad, and it was entirely the duty of the
individual to see that it was maintained. If one was unsteady on the
trigger, or caught napping on the draw, one was held to have died by
virtue of contributory negligence.

To be sure there was law, and machinery for its execution; but the
machinery was liberal, and had ideas of its own, and the law adhered
with supreme unconcern to its maxim--_De minimis non curat lex_.

First Class Crawley had been splendidly trained for the duties of his
position. If Fortune had been moving of design, she could not have
schooled him better for such a life. Some thirty years before, he had
been a sutler with the Army of the Potomac--not the sutler of romance,
but the sutler of reality; following the army bravely, but at such a
distance to the rear as to be at all times extremely safe, and exacting
for his valuable public service every gain that human ingenuity could
discover. It was no wrong in the mind of Crawley to cheat the common
soldier out of his eyes; belike the soldier would be shot on the
morrow, and then all opportunity to cheat him would cease, and if prior
opportunity had not been seized and enjoyed, Crawley would regret.

When the “bitterness of death” had passed, Crawley became a justice
of the peace in Ohio. Here the field for his talent was broader, and
Crawley arose and spread like the bay tree of Biblical record. Crawley
held it as a basic principle that the machinery of human justice could
not be maintained without ample sinews of war. It was best, to be sure,
if these sinews could be wrested from the wrong-doer, but, failing that,
the innocent must contribute. Every litigant was presumed to proceed at
the peril of costs. The matter of costs was one vital to Crawley, and
loomed constantly. The right or justice of a cause was never for a
moment permitted to obscure it. If the plaintiff was impecunious, then
the decision must be against the defendant, else the costs could not be
had, and _vice versa_ as it had pleased Providence to place substance.

This was a high conception of human justice; since it passed by the
trivial controversy of the litigants, and placed the burden of legal
procedure upon the one best able to support It. First Class Crawley
maintained further that it was the part of wisdom in a government
promptly to release the criminal who “shelled out,” since the revenues
of the State arose largely from the fines imposed upon the evildoer, and
it was certainly quite useless to retain the criminal at public expense
after having squeezed him thoroughly, when he could be returned to
society and squeezed again later on.

Crawley might have been the father of a school, had he not found the
school in Ohio established to his uses. Consequently his fame was local,
and his methods being of ancient origin in this Commonwealth, provoked
no comment, and indeed he might have passed on, with the usual career
of such ambitious spirits, to a seat in the legislature, had he not
unwittingly crossed into a neighboring State in order to attend a
reunion of the Grand Army of the Republic. Here one, smarting from a
hurt, pounced down upon him with a warrant for a felony, and that same
night the visiting justice was a guest of the State. But First Class
Crawley was no man of feeble resources, and two days later he gave a
straw bond and vanished like a newspaper war cloud.

In the Southwest, Crawley was a person of importance--a court of last
resort on all matters, barring none. If bets were made, Crawley was
umpire. If questions w ere argued, Crawley was judge. If one wanted
advice, one went to him. If one wanted information, one went to him; and
if one needed money, one went always to First Class Crawley, and put up
everything but his life. No function was complete without the presence
of this celebrity, be it bull tight or prize fight, or dog fight, or a
prearranged resort to the arbitration of the Winchester. Crawley was a
great man, in counterdistinction to a bad man. Personally, he neither
quarrelled nor fought, and one would have no more considered shooting at
Crawley than he would have considered shooting at his grandmother. This
proprietor of the Emporium maintained his position, not by virtue of
arms and skill in their use, but by virtue of an interesting something
which passed with him for an intellect.

Consequently, when he and Hiram Martin, of the Golden Horn Mining
Company, sat down in the private gambling room of the Emporium to a
private interview with the Honorable Ambercrombie Hergan, they were
expecting to realize from the time expended. They were both attentive
and interested, since the reckless Secretary of State was known in the
lingo of the guild as an “easy member.” If he had money, or could obtain
money, it would eventually fall into their clutches as it had always
done. Hence their interest was genuine.

“Boys,” said the Secretary of State, “I have a scheme to make a stake,
and I want you in on it. I have been over in the East, and I have got it
all figured out, and it's a cinch.”

The owner of the Golden Horn folded his hands over the vast expanse of
his stomach and smiled benignly. He knew all about the usual combination
of circumstances set down in the elegant diction of the gambler as a
“cinch.”

He was an expert upon things of this sort, but he volunteered no
information, and no comment. He merely smiled and murmured “Yes,” in a
voice which reminded one of oil being poured from a very full barrel.

“You see,” continued the Honorable Ambercrombie

Hergan, “it's this way. There is a broker in Chicago who is a friend of
mine. I saved him from the jug when he was a kid, and he never forgot
it. Well, he went to Chicago, raked together a bunch of money, and
bought a seat in the Stock Exchange. He was lucky, and now he is away
up. He is on the inside, and he says that there is going to be a big
raise in oil stocks; that the Standard Oil Company has been forcing it
down in order to squeeze out the little dealers, and that they are right
now at the bottom, and when they let go, it will fly back to a dollar.”

At this point in the narrative, Crawley murmured “Yes,” then leaned back
in his chair and closed his eyes. He was not quite ready to puncture
Mr. Hergan's balloon, and it was not his way to offer objections to
unfinished propositions.

“Now,” said Hergan, leaning over and resting his arms on the table, “the
plan is to form a big pool and buy oil, and make enough at one haul to
go back to civilization and live like a king. That is the scheme, boys.
It's good.” First Class Crawley opened his eyes slowly, and putting out
his fat hand, began to caress the green cloth on the little round poker
table.

“Billy,” he said slowly, “I expect that is a good scheme, and I expect
there is money in it,--may be tubs of money, but me and Martin aint
speculators; we never so much as saw a ticking machine in our life. We
don't know anything about new-fangled ways to get rich. We're both old
fogies,--just common old fogies, and I reckon we had better stay out. Of
course, I aint knocking on the scheme. It looks good, mighty good, but
me and Martin aint young any longer; we're getting old and heavy on
our pins, and we aint got no nerve like we used to have. Still I aint
knocking. Me and Martin would like to see you make a pile of money,
would n't we, Martin?”

“Yes,” gurgled the owner of the Golden Horn, “we would that.”

The Honorable Ambercrombie Hergan straightened up and thrust his hands
into his pockets. “Of course, boys,” he said, “it's a gamble, but it's
a ten-to-one shot better than a faro bank. If it goes our way, we will
have all kinds of money; if it goes the other way, we are skinned to a
standstill. I am tired of little gambles, and I am going to make one big
play if I eat snowballs for the next twenty years. I would like to have
you boys in, but if you don't believe that the thing is easy to beat,
you can stay out.”

An inspiration came to First Class Crawley, and he seized it with the
avidity of a shark. “Billy,” he said, with amiable confidence, “you
have no better friends in this here country' than me and Martin--has he,
Martin?”

“No,” muttered the fat owner of the oleaginous voice, “he aint.”

“And me and Martin,” the proprietor went on, “would go in anything
in the world that you wanted us to go in, and it would n't make no
difference to us what it was, if you said it was a good thing. But me
and Martin are pretty nigh sixty, and if we would go broke, we could
never get on our feet no more. We are skeery, Billy; me and Martin are
skeery, but we are ready to do anything for you that we can. We are
ready to help you any way you want to be helped, because you are dead
game, Billy,--that's what you are--you're dead game.”

The wary Hiram Martin was totally in the dark as to what Crawley was
probing for, but he had unlimited confidence in the proprietor of the
Emporium, and he assented blandly. Crawley, he knew, followed no cold
trail; Crawley worked no salted lead, and if he stooped to “crook the
pregnant hinges of the knee,” there was something in it for Crawley, and
at no great distance.

“Well,” responded the Secretary of State,

“I am obliged to you both, but I guess there is nothing I need just now.
Of course, I, have got to raise a bunch of money for this deal, but I
sort of arranged that in New York.”

The ulterior motive of Crawley was now quite clear to the owner of the
Golden Horn. Hergan would require money,--perhaps a large sum for his
venture. If good security could be given, there was no reason why they
should not advance the cash at a large and comfortable discount.

The officer of the Commonwealth moved his chair back from the table as
an indication that the secret conference was at an end. As he did so,
the proprietor of the Emporium leaned over and spread out his fat hands
on the green cloth.

“Billy, old man,” he said, in a voice that indicated gentle reproach,
“there was no necessity for you to go among strangers to raise any money
you wanted; me and Martin have saved up a little, and me and Martin
would be glad to let you have it if it is any accommodation, would n't
we, Martin?”

First Class Crawley failed to add that both he and Martin would require
the trifling detail of a substantial surety, but they concluded shrewdly
that if Hergan could raise money in New York, he had obtained some
first-class support, and if this security were sufficient for an Eastern
bank, it was amply sufficient for all purposes known to commerce. Hence
the apparently unconcerned Martin consented most amiably.

The Honorable Ambercrombie Hergan settled back in his chair and grew
thoughtful. “I aint closed the loan,” he said, after some little
consideration, “and I would just as leave borrow it of you, boys. The
fact is, I would a little rather borrow it of you. I am paying pretty
stiff for the money, and I would rather pay my friends than the Yankees
in the East.”

“Yes,” observed the unctuous mining magnate, although he had not
intended to speak at all.

“But,” continued the Secretary of State, “I reckon you would n't like to
put up as much as I need. I am going to crowd the bank this once.”

“Well, Billy,” drawled the proprietor of the Emporium, “I expect me and
Martin can make it up for you. If we aint got enough, we can get some
around and piece out. Least ways, we will try. About what sum might you
need?”

“I reckon,” responded Hergan, “that I shall want about fifty thousand.”

The hands of Hiram Martin tightened over his stomach, and for a moment
Crawley studied the ceiling with placid indifference. He had turned
Hergan into his own channel, and the transaction being assured, it was
now the part of wisdom to affect gravity. Presently he spoke, slowly
and anxiously: “That's a powerful big wad of money. Still, me and
Martin----” Here he stopped short and turned to his companion.

“Powerful big,” echoed the mine owner, and volunteered no further
observation. He understood First Class Crawley as few men are
understood, and such observations were quite useless between them,
except for the effect upon the victim at hand.

“Still,” continued the proprietor of the Emporium, “I expect we can
raise it some way. About what terms do you allow on?”

“I guess thirty days will be long enough,” responded Hergan. “Thirty
days at twelve per cent, is how I have been figuring it.”

“Yes,” drawled the gambling king, “and the security?”

“Well,” said the Secretary of State, “I have calculated to give the
Governor and Culverson.”

“They are good, I reckon,” observed the wary Crawley. “Aint they good,
Martin?”

“Might be worse,” responded the oily owner of the Golden Horn, “but it
aint that. It's the rate. Seems like mighty little on a short loan.”

“It is mighty little,” continued Crawley, after a silence of some
moments. “We would have to give more than that for what we borrowed
'round. There would n't be nothing in it for us, Billy,--not a cent to
me and Martin.”

“I tell you what I'll do,” put in the Honorable Ambercrombie Hergan,
abruptly, as though the idea was new and sudden in its coming, “I'll
give you twelve per cent, for the money for a month, and I will enter
into an agreement to turn over to you two one-eighth of what I win on
the gamble.”

Crawley was very grave. The proposition pleased him hugely, but emotions
found no expression with him. To loan fifty thousand dollars on good
security at an enormous rate of interest, and in addition to have a
substantial share in a speculation without standing to lose a cent, was
a condition of affairs not likely to arise with much regularity in the
span of a gambler's precarious life. Yet Crawley was not anxious. To
the spectator he was sad and unconcerned. He knew quite well that this
proposition was Hergan's ultimatum, and he was going to accept, but
desired to appear to accept rather as a matter of kindly feeling toward
Hergan than by reason of the fact that the inducement had increased.

“Billy,” he said slowly, almost sadly, “me and Martin don't want to make
anything off of you, and we will try to fix it any way you want it. If
you want to arrange the thing that way, why it suits us--it suits me and
Martin.”

“All right,” responded the Secretary of State, getting up from the
table. “I'll go over to the Governor's house and have Al fix the papers.
The sooner I get it, the better chance I'll have to win a stake.”

“Billy,” called the proprietor of the Emporium, as the official of
the Commonwealth was passing out through the door, “just make the note
payable to Martin.”

The Honorable Ambercrombie Hergan nodded his assent, and departed,
leaving the fat gambling kings of the Southwest to prolong the secret
session.

When the door was closed, First Class Crawley turned to his companion,
his little gray eyes slipping around in their puffy sockets.

“Martin,” he said, “aint he a mark?”

The stomach of the rotund Martin undulated like a rubber bag filled with
fluid. “Of all damn fools,” he gurgled.

“Were it clear?” inquired the proprietor of the Emporium.

“Plain as a speckled pup,” responded Martin, “except the note.”

“You see,” said First Class Crawley, turning around in his chair, “you
live in New Mexico, and I wanted the note in your name so that if we had
to sue we could get it in the United States court. You can't ever tell
what the State courts are going to do with you, but old Uncle Sam's
courts don't stand no flim-flam.”

“Crawley,” announced the owner of the Golden Horn, “Crawley, you are
built like a white man, but you have got a head on you like a Yankee.”

When the Honorable Ambercrombie Hergan returned to the Governor's
residence he found that celebrated official and Major Culverson in the
library. The irrepressible Major was engaged in presenting a lurid
and highly dramatic history of how he had straightened the tangled
exigencies of the Commonwealth during the absence of his associates,
and how, by virtue of his magnificent personality, the entire Southwest,
from the borders of lower Utah to the Rio Grande, was now the placid
abode of peace and fraternal good-will. He stopped short as the
Secretary of State entered, and bowed. Then thrusting his hand into
the front of his coat, he exclaimed, with the affected manner of a
tenth-rate actor, “Good morrow, good gambler.”

“Top chop,” responded the Honorable Ambercrombie Hergan. “And a
favorite.”

“I opine,” continued the Major, “I opine, sir, from your gladsome tone
that the fat sharks have been successfully harpooned.”

“Gentlemen,” said the Secretary of State, dropping into a chair by the
table, “the reports of this race will announce that Hiram Martin and
First Class Crawley 'also ran.'”

“Which being translated,” observed the Governor, “means that these
gentlemen will advance you the money on the line suggested by your New
York lawyer.”

“Yes,” said the gambler. “You are to fix up the papers, and I am to go
down there to-night. Everything turned out just like Randolph Mason
said it would. If the rest goes through as slick, we will be riding in
carriages.”

“Produce the sealed orders,” said the Governor, partaking of the mock
dramatic atmosphere.

The Secretary of State drew a big envelope from his pocket and threw
it down on the table. The Executive leaned over, opened the paper, and,
after having examined it carefully, took up a pen and began to write.

Major Culverson wandered over to the window and looked out at the hot,
monotonous, sterile country. “I wonder,” he murmured, “if this is really
the passing of the Honorable Ambercrombie Hergan?”





IX

THE audience in the court-room arose and remained standing until the
judge in his black silk robe had entered and taken his place on the
bench. Then the audience resumed its seat, and the clerk began to read
the proceedings for the previous day. The ceremony attendant upon the
sitting of the Circuit Court of the United States carried with it an
impressive sense of majestic, imperial authority, and an air of grave,
judicial deliberation. It was the Government of the United States of
America, the spirit of supreme order and law moving through its servant,
and, next to the Great Ruler of Events, it was greatest. It had assumed
for the good of men the right to sit in judgment, and to say wherein lay
the justice of their complicated quarrels. Before it, every man's cause
was of equal import, and every man was of equal stature; bond or free,
one stood before it naked of influence, and with his shoulder made as
high as the shoulder of his fellow.

This is the theory. If it fails, it is because the law at best is but a
human device, and its servants, after all, are but men like the others.

The building in which the Federal Court held its session was a
substantial, handsome structure, and maintained a strange contrast to
the town in which it stood. The town was rough, miserable, uncouth;
the temporary habitation of men, struggling ever with the relentless
_ananke_ of things; in equal contrast to the officers of this court
was the audience in the great court-room. They were the pioneers of
civilization; a motley crowd in which the best and worst of human
society was mixed and intermixed. They were, for the most part, bronzed,
bearded, fearless examples of the inexorable law of the survival of the
fittest, but not all. Some were the reckless advance agents of those
hardy vices that follow close in the wake of empire,--devils too
villainous to be tolerated in the cities of the East, and too bold and
too wary to be stamped out by the deliberate machinery of the law.

Against these the officers of the court bore some evidence of polish.
They were exact, calculating men, bred to respect order, and obey and
maintain the customs of law. The contrast was significant, and one
recalled and understood the constant bitter conflict between the
judicial tribunals of the State and the judicial tribunals of the
Federal Government, bitterly waged and as yet undecided. From one
standpoint, this was the calm tribunal of the supreme power of the
land, providing the same rights and remedies on the very border of
its jurisdiction that it provided at the capital itself, favoring no
condition and acting as even-eyed as nature.

On the other hand, one understood how the remote Commonwealth held this
court to be the tribunal of a far off imperial government, seeking to
enforce laws and customs foreign and repugnant to the laws and customs
of its people. To them the Federal judge was a king's governor,
travelling with his retinue over a subjugated province, and enforcing
his edict by virtue of foreign armies quartered convenient to his hand.
And looking on from this point of view, one understood why the outpost
State hated this court so bitterly, and whence arose the fierce
clamor against it. One understood how the far West smarted under its
injunctions, and denounced them as the royal mandates of an emperor's
consul, and how the far South collided with this tribunal and cried out
against it to the Congress of the United States in a memorial clanging
like a bell.

So the conflict was easy to understand, and it was easy to appreciate
how large the spectre of discord loomed, and most difficult indeed to
force the problem to some happy end.

When the clerk had finished, the marshal called the jury, and struggled
bravely, but at times unsuccessfully, with the marvellous tangle of
names. Indeed, if the list of this panel had been placed before a
student of philology, he would have required no further history of the
civilization of the Southwest. When the marshal had ended, the judge
directed that the jury should be dismissed until two o'clock, and when
order was again restored, the judge turned and looked down gravely from
the bench.

“This court,” he said, “is ready to pass upon the matter taken under
advisement yesterday afternoon. It seems that one Hiram Martin, a
citizen of and a resident in the State of New Mexico, brought an action
in this court against Ambercrombie Hergan and others to recover the sum
of fifty thousand dollars, money, as it is said, borrowed by the said
Hergan. The declaration contained the common counts _in assumpsit_, with
which was filed, in lieu of the bill of particulars, a promissory
note, made by the said Hergan to the said plaintiff, calling for fifty
thousand dollars, and endorsed by one Randal and another Culver-son.
This note, in addition to the matter usually had in such instruments,
recited that it was given in accord with a certain agreement of even
date therewith, made and entered into by the parties to the said
note. The case coming on for trial, the defendants, by their attorney,
appeared and filed their plea exhibiting the said agreement, maintaining
that the said note was given for money loaned for the purpose of being
used in a gambling venture, and was, therefore, void at law. An issue
being had upon the said plea, the case was put to trial, and the said
agreement having been admitted, the defendants, by their attorney, moved
this court to exclude the evidence, and direct the jury to find for the
defendants; which motion this court took time to consider.

“The facts herewith concerned are involved in no controversy, and
the agreement being couched in plain terms, admits of no doubtful
construction. It would seem that the defendant Hergan called at the
gambling house of one Crawley, a resident of this State, and requested a
private interview with the said Crawley and the plaintiff; that in this
interview Hergan explained that he was considering what it pleased him
to denominate 'a gambling venture in oil,' and solicited the two men to
join him in the venture. This they declined to do, but suggested
that they would advance to Hergan such money as he might need upon a
promissory note with good security.

“It appears that some controversy arose as to the rate of interest to be
paid; and a division of the profits was suggested in lieu of the larger
per cent. This matter was finally concluded by the plaintiff and the
said Crawley advancing the said sum, and taking therefor the note filed
in this cause, and in addition thereto entering into this agreement in
writing with the said Hergan, wherein it is set forth that the money
loaned is to be used by the said Hergan for the express purpose of 'a
gamble in oil,' and for no other purpose; and that if any profit should
result from said gambling venture, the said plaintiff and the said
Crawley were to receive one-eighth of said profits. It seems that the
money was paid and presumably used by Hergan for the purpose as stated.
Afterward the note was presented for payment, and being refused, was
duly protested, and later sued upon in this court.

“It is maintained by the defendants that this transaction was contrary
to public policy, and that the money, having been loaned for a known
illegal purpose, cannot be recovered in a judicial tribunal, but falls
Within the purlieus of those matters which are _par se ex turfe causa_,
and for which the law provides no remedy. On the contrary, it is urged
by counsel for the plaintiff that the transaction as between the parties
to this suit was entirely commercial and innocent; that the plaintiff is
a mere lender of money in a _bona fide_ transaction, and is in no wise
a party to any illegal proceeding, and that the mere use to which the
money was put is a matter of no moment.

“The law, being for the welfare and the protection of human society,
refuses to recognize and enforce certain contracts had among its
citizens, when those contracts are founded in moral turpitude or
inconsistent with the good order or solid interests of society.

“'No people,' declares Chancellor Kent in his _Commentaries_, 'are
bound or ought to enforce or hold valid in their courts of justice any
contract which is injurious to the public rights or offends their morals
or contravenes their policy or violates a public law.' Hence contracts
having an illegal or immoral consideration, or tending to the violation
of law or the debauching of public morals, are held to be _contra bonas
mores_, and are void.

“It is said that the object of all law is to suppress vice, and to
promote the general welfare of society, and it does not give its
assistance to persons to enforce a demand originating in their breach or
violation of its principles and enactments. It is not necessary that the
law expressly prohibit or enjoin an act. It may impliedly prohibit or
enjoin it. In either case a contract in violation of its principles is
void under the wholesome maxim _ex turpi causa non oritur actio_.

“It may happen, and, indeed, frequently does happen, that the individual
suffers great hurt from this sweeping policy of the law, but it is held
that the good of the commonwealth rises above the mere benefit of the
individual citizen, and that where the welfare of the whole of society
is involved, the law will not pause to consider the injury entailed upon
the mere unit. Hence the policy of government in the exigencies of
war, when protection must be had against violence, and the policy of
government in the peaceful administration of the law, when protection
must be had against vice.

“Thus gambling, wagering, and all gambling and wagering contracts
and transactions are illegal as against public policy, since they are
repugnant to the well-being of society, fraught with vice, pregnant with
demoralization, and corrupting alike to the youth and to the aged, as
they inspire a hope of reward without labor.

“It is significant that in matters of this nature human society has been
progressive. Under the common law of England wagers were not unlawful
or unenforceable, but the statute of 9th Anne followed and altered the
common law, and the statutes of 8th and 9th Victoria altered it yet
farther, and in the United States every separate Commonwealth has its
respective statute striking at this vice.

“I think it will not at this day be denied that all transactions in
stocks, by way of margin, settlement of differences, and payment of
gains or losses, without intending to deliver the stocks, is a gambling
or wagering operation which the law does not sanction, and will not
carry into effect; and it has been held in the Supreme Court of the
United States in the case of Irwin vs. Williar, 'If under the guise of
a contract to deliver goods at a future day the real intent be to
speculate in the rise or fall of prices, and the goods are not to be
delivered, but one party is to pay to the other the difference between
the contract price and the market price of the goods at the date fixed
for executing the contract, the whole transaction is nothing more than
a wager, and is null and void.' And that 'Generally in this country
wagering contracts are held to be illegal and void as against public
policy.'

“Indeed the courts of the land have gone to the extremity of denouncing
in no uncertain terms the dangerous character of these illegal ventures.
Judge Blauford, in the case of Cunningham vs. The National Bank of
Augusta, in speaking of these transactions termed 'futures,' declares:
'If this is not a speculation on chances--a wagering and betting between
the parties, then we are unable to understand the transaction. A betting
on a game of faro or poker cannot be more hazardous, dangerous, or
uncertain. Indeed it may be said that these animals are tame, gentle,
and submissive compared to this monster. The law has caged them and
driven them to the den. They have been outlawed; while this ferocious
beast has been allowed to stalk about in open mid-day with gilded signs
and flaming advertisements to lure the unhappy victim to its embrace
of death and destruction. What are some of the consequences of these
speculations in 'futures'? The faithful chroniclers of the day have
informed us, as growing directly out of these nefarious practices,
that there have been bankruptcies, defalcations of public officers,
embezzlements, forgeries, larcenies, and deaths. Certainly no one
will contend for a moment that a transaction fraught with such evil
consequences is not immoral, illegal, and contrary to public policy.'

“In so far as this doctrine is concerned with the case at bar, it is
certain that the parties understood and intended that the money loaned
should be used for the purpose of engaging in an illegal speculation in
oil,--'a gamble in oil,' as it is termed in the agreement, and that such
gambling transactions are against public policy and the law of the land.
But it is contended by learned counsel that all this can have no bearing
upon the case at bar for the reason that in the cases heretofore cited
announcing these conclusions of law, the litigants were the parties who
dealt with or for each other, and were the immediate parties engaged in
an unlawful gambling venture, and the ones to gain or lose directly
by the venture, and not a mere stranger who loaned money to another to
engage in such transactions, and having but an undetermined interest in
the result; and that the law will not lend its aid to a further wrong.
The defendant having committed one wrong cannot be permitted to use his
first wrongful act as an instrument whereby to effect a second wrongful
act.

“The objection is ingenious, but I judge fully met by the declaration
of Lord Mansfield in Holman's case: 'The objection,' said the learned
judge, 'that a contract is immoral or illegal as between plaintiff and
defendant, sounds at all times very ill in the mouth of the defendant.
It is not for his sake, however, that the objection is allowed, but it
is founded on the general principle of policy which the defendant has
the advantage of, contrary to the real justice as between himself and
plaintiff, by accident, if I may so say. The principle of public policy
is this: _ex dolo malo non oritur actio_. No court will lend its aid to
a man who founds his cause of action upon an immoral or illegal act.
If from the plaintiff's own statement or otherwise the cause of action
appear to arise _ex turpi causa_, or the transgression of a positive law
of this country, then the court says he has no right to be assisted. It
is upon that ground the court goes, not for the sake of the defendant,
but because it will not lend its aid to such a plaintiff.'

“This claim of the plaintiff to this action is unsound for the further
reason that any promise, contract, or undertaking the performance of
which would tend to promote, advance, or carry into effect an object
or purpose which is unlawful, is itself void and will not maintain
an action. The law which prohibits the end, will not lend its aid in
promoting the means assigned to carry it into effect. Nor is it
possible for an act contrary to law to be made the basis of a contract
enforceable in courts of law. Hence when one lends money to another for
the express purpose of enabling him to commit a specific unlawful act,
and such act be afterwards committed by means of the aid so received,
the lender is a _particeps criminis_, and the law will not aid him to
recover money advanced for such a purpose, and much less would it assist
him, if, as in this case he retained an interest in the result of the
venture.”

It was very unusual for counsel to interrupt the judge in the delivery
of his opinion, but at this point the attorney for Martin arose.

“If your honor please,” he said, “this court is taking away the remedy
of the plaintiff, and permitting the wrong to stand. Does this court
reverse the ancient doctrine upon which the theory of human justice has
its eternal basis, the ancient doctrine that the law will always provide
a remedy for a wrong?”

The faintest shadow of a smile flitted over the judicial face.

“That sage maxim: '_lex semper debit remédiant_,'” answered the judge,
“is a gigantic error couched in very good law Latin. The motion to
exclude the evidence is sustained, and the jury will find a verdict for
the defendants.”




X

THE Governor's machine marched gravely out of the Circuit Court of the
United States and down the wide steps, the Major leading, the Executive
following second, and the Honorable Ambercrombie Hergan bringing up
the rear, every man as silent and as solemn as a Japanese diplomat. The
machine passed through the great arched doorway and directly across the
street to “The Happy Maria” saloon, an institution with a variegated
past. The machine filed in through the door and lined up before the bar
as mysteriously as a country delegation in a caucus.

The Bartender of “The Happy Maria” was a lame actor from St. Louis. When
he turned and beheld the solemn array, he stepped back and tapped his
forehead tragically with his fingers.

“Ha!” he muttered, “it is Ulfius and Brastias and Sir Bedivere.”

To this no response was made, except that the Major raised his hand and
pointed to the bottle of “Dougherty” reposing on the second shelf beside
the box of “scrap” and the proprietor's pistol-belt. The bartender
hurried forward, took down the bottle, placed three little glasses on
the bar and began to fill them. When he came to the third glass, he
paused and set down the bottle. A puzzled expression gathered on his
face. He thrust his forefinger into his mouth and began to lisp:

               “Be there two or be there three

                   In our king's companee?”

The Major turned just in time to catch a glimpse of the Governor as he
vanished in a telegraph office next door; then he swung around toward
the barkeeper with the dramatic abandon of a professional at a benefit.

“Pour on, good seneschal,” he cried; “it is the man who would be
married. He hastens with glad tidings to the well beloved. He will
return.”


_(See the famous opinion of Henry St. George Tucker, President of the
Supreme Court of Virginia, in the leading case of Gallego's Executors
vs. Attorney General, 3 Leigh, 450; also the opinion of John Marshall,
Chief Justice of the United States, in the case of the Trustees of
the Philadelphia Baptist Association el at. vs. Hart's Executors, 4
Wheaton's U. S. Reports, 330; also Knox vs. Knox's Executors, 9 W. Va.,
125; 2y W. Va., 109, and cases cited.)_




MRS. VAN BARTON




I

ALL this,” said Randolph Mason,” is the veriest nonsense.”

The younger Mrs. Van Bartan straightened up in her chair and looked
sharply at the counsellor. She was a woman of magnificent presence,
with a great fleece of yellow hair, fine eyes, and regular, clear-cut
features.

“Do you mean that it is not the truth?” she asked.

“Half truth,” responded Mason.

“Then,” said the woman, smiling, “it is only half nonsense.”

“Madam,” said Randolph Mason, “if you desire my aid, you must explain
this entire matter. I do not choose to guess riddles.”

“I have told you,” began the young woman, slowly, “that my husband and
myself reside with his mother in a certain city of the Virginias; that
his father is dead, and, by his will, left his entire property to the
elder Mrs. Van Bartan--my mother-in-law; that was all true.”

The counsellor nodded.

“The other part,” she went on, “I was trying to put into a 'hypothetical
case '--is n't that what you call it?”

She hesitated for a moment.

“It is hard to tell, and I was only trying to save myself, but I suppose
the surgeon is quite useless if the wound is not fully revealed. If you
will listen to me I will explain. It is hard to tell, and it hurts, but
everything is at stake, and if I lose now I lose everything. It will
simply mean that I have made sacrifice after sacrifice for nothing at
all. One shrinks from putting one's heart upon a dissecting table
where the valves may be pinned back and pried into with the point of
a scalpel, and so one struggles with a hurt until it finally aches so
bitterly that the expert must be had. Then one goes to the surgeon or
the priest or the lawyer, and takes an anaesthetic while he cuts it
out.”

“Madam,” said Randolph Mason, “you talk like a diplomat: you say nothing
at all.”

The younger Mrs. Van Bartan unbuttoned her coat and threw it back with
the air of one who has ultimately decided to keep nothing in reserve.

“I have been married three years,” she began, “my father's name is
Summers. In the good days of Virginia our family was wealthy, but of
late years we have met with one disaster after another until the
family became very poor, and the effort to maintain an appearance of
respectability was a nipping struggle indeed.

“About this time the coal industries of West Virginia began to develop,
and our city became a manufacturing centre. This brought in many Eastern
capitalists, among them Michael Van Bartan, who established great iron
mills, out of which he made a vast fortune. Shortly thereafter he died,
leaving his widow and one son, Gerald Van Bartan.

“This woman I have never quite understood. After the death of her
husband, she maintained their country place in almost profligate
magnificence, but she has always seemed terribly disappointed in her
son. He was a good, easy-going fellow, and his mother, an ambitious,
restless woman, had great plans for his future. But, failing that, and
being a person of shrewd instinct, she set about finding for him an
ambitious wife, who would probably be able to succeed where she had
failed. But while the mother was striving to select a suitable woman for
her purpose, the son paid court to me,--and I married him.”

The young woman paused for a moment, and the lines of her mouth
hardened. Then she went on:

“He was not quite the person with whom I had hoped to spend my life, but
he had wealth, and we were so miserably poor,--and, I judge after all,
one is never permitted to do just what one wishes in this weary world.
This marriage was a bitter disappointment to Mrs. Van Bartan, but she
was a woman with the resources of an empress. She came at once to me,
and, with the kindest and most gracious courtesy, welcomed me as her
daughter, and began at once to shower upon me the most substantial
evidences of her good will. We were taken to live with her at the
country place, and everything was done that a shrewd woman could imagine
to bring me completely under her influence, and, through me, to move
my husband to the effort which she desired. But it was all an utter
failure.

“I appreciated thoroughly the incapacity of Gerald Van Bartan, and said
as much to his mother. I went deliberately to her and pointed out how
very vain her ambition was, and how certainly it must come to nothing. I
said how difficult it was for men to lift themselves even the least bit
higher than their fellows; how it required years of labor and selfdenial
and courage. I reminded her that my husband had not one of the qualities
necessary for such work; that he was not industrious, and not ambitious
she knew well; that the habits of the man had been formed, and this work
could not be now undone.

“Then I blundered like a fool. I said that wealth had caused these
habits to become fixed, and that we must accept him as his luxurious
life had made him; that if he had been thrown out to struggle with
poverty, some qualities might have been developed, but that he had never
been forced to feel the necessity for an effort, and consequently he
had never called his faculties into use, nor could he now since the
necessity did not arise. I begged her to abandon the effort as vexatious
and entirely hopeless.

“To all this the elder Mrs. Van Bartan listened attentively and made no
comment. When I had finished, she laughed, and said that I had entirely
misapprehended her intentions toward her son; that she had no object
in life but to make us as happy as it were possible to do, but that one
could not tell what conditions might arise, and she had wished simply to
put her son in a position to care for himself and me, if it ever should
be necessary. Then she stroked my hair, as she might have done to a
child, and bade me not worry over trifles. I now congratulated myself
that the matter was finally settled, but I was fearfully wrong. I
had read this remarkable woman poorly. Although again beaten, she was
unconquered, and she determined upon a final desperate move. Perhaps
my foolish prattle, furnished the suggestion, but it is rather more
probable, I think, that her master mind evolved the plan out of what she
considered a desperate condition.”

The woman's face was now grave, and she seemed deeply in earnest.

“It was the plan of Mrs. Van Bartan to convince my husband and myself
that future poverty was impending, but just how to make this impression
strongly probable, was a matter of great difficulty, and one which she
appreciated fully. In order to do this effectually, it was necessary for
her, in some manner, apparently to dispose of her property, and at the
same time actually to retain it in possession.

“This was a difficult problem, but difficult problems were not appalling
to Mrs. Van Bartan, and she finally determined upon this shrewd scheme.
She would make a will, leaving her entire estate at her death to the
church of which she was a member, and entirely disinheriting my husband.
This will could have the effect she desired, and at the same time leave
her unhampered in the use of her property, and free to destroy this
will or make another at her pleasure. This is now her plan. How I have
discovered it is not of importance, since it is a part of her plan in
this matter to have me suspect her intention and finally to have me
believe that she has decided to cut us off without a dollar. Having
determined upon this move, she will carry it through with the skill of a
master strategist. She will have the paper drawn by her legal adviser
in the presence of witnesses; she will declare her intention to the most
substantial people of our city, and will take good care to see that her
act is made known through the most reliable sources. There will be no
blunder anywhere,--Mrs. Van Rartan does not blunder.”

“Has this will been drafted?” asked Randolph Mason.

“No,” replied the young woman, “but it will be made soon. Mrs. Van
Bartan is now preparing public opinion for her act. She is far too wise
to hurry.”

“I see no danger in all this,” said Mason, “since it is not this woman's
intention to really disinherit her son. Ultimately she will destroy this
document or make another.”

“But,” said the young woman, bending forward in her chair, “Mrs. Van
Bartan is afflicted with an aortic aneurism, and may drop dead at any
moment. This she refuses to believe, and although she has been examined
by celebrated specialists, she stoutly asserts that her health is as
good as it ever was in her whole life.

“Now suppose she makes this will and dies suddenly without having an
opportunity to make another. What then? Her intention will not help us.
This will holds, and we are left entirely without a dollar in the world.
Now, what am I to do to save us? It is of no use to go to Mrs. Van
Bartan. She is an iron woman. She has her plan, and Heaven could not
change her in the least. I must do something. It all depends on me, and
I don't know which way to turn. You must show me some way; you must do
something.”

Randolph Mason turned around in his chair and looked squarely at the
young woman.

“Madam,” he said, “you have neglected to tell me the most important
matter.”

“Oh, no, sir,” responded the younger Mrs. Van Bartan, “I have told you
everything.”

“By no means,” said Mason. “You have said that Mr. Van Bartan is not the
man with whom you had hoped to spend your life. Who is that man?”

The young woman looked down at the floor and was silent.

“Well,” she said, “I don't know that I meant quite that. I was meaning,
you know, that there were other considerations moving me to this
alliance beyond mere affection. I did not say that I loved some one
else, did I? Did I say I loved some one else?”

“You evade,” said Mason, bluntly. “It is the weakling's method of
confession, and as well the fool's method.”

The blood came into the face of the younger Mrs. Van Bartan, and she
looked up resolutely.

“You don't spare me at all,” she said, bitterly. “You pry out
everything, even the very heart linings. Suppose I did love some one
else, what has that to do with this matter? That is all over and past
and gone. Can't I permit it to sleep and be forgotten? Suppose there was
another man? Suppose there is now? Must I empty out his heart too? Can't
I spare him? Can't I leave him out of this?”

“I am waiting, madam,” said Mason, quietly.

The young woman passed her hand downward over her face, as though to
remove something that was clinging to her.

“If you must know,” she said slowly, “his name is Dalton, Robert Dalton,
a member of the law firm of Carpenter, Lomax, & Dalton, of our city. He
is said to be an able lawyer. He is the elder Mrs. Van Bartan's legal
adviser, but I have no right to tell you all this. It is unjust to him.
and unjust to me, and unfair to us all.”

“And he still loves you?” said Mason, with the blunt indifference of a
surgeon who thrusts his thumb into a wound.

The young woman threw back her head. “You are brutal,” she cried, “to
ask such a question, and I should be a fool, a miserable, contemptible
fool if I should answer.”

“But you have answered it, madam,” replied Randolph Mason.

The younger Mrs. Van Bartan covered her face with her hands, and began
to sob. The counsellor sat and watched her, as an expert might watch an
intricate piece of machinery that he was testing. There was no emotion
of any sort visible in his face--nothing at all, except the intense
interest of the expert.

Presently Mason leaned back in his chair. The result was evidently
satisfactory.

“Is this man married?” he asked.

The woman did not answer. She simply pressed her hands tighter against
her face. The counsellor waited for a few moments. Then he repeated:

“Is this man married?”

The woman's hands trembled violently. “No,” she sobbed, “and he never
will be.” The lines in the face of Randolph Mason grew deep and resolute
as one has seen the lines in the face of a great physician when, in some
desperate case, he finally turned from the bedside of the patient in
order to write the prescription upon which he had decided.

“Madam,” he said, in a voice that was firm and admitted of no protest,
“this man Dalton is perhaps a person of some learning. Since he is your
mother-in-law's legal adviser, he will have the matter in his hands. He
is under your influence. Could a problem be more simple? You have but to
go to him and say what you have said to me. He will know what to do.”

She dropped her hands in astonishment.

“Go to him? Go to him?” she repeated.

“Yes,” said Mason, “and tell him the truth,--and wait.”

“But,” began the younger Mrs. Van Bartan, “how could he help me? What
could----”

“Madam,” interrupted Mason, rising, “this is your coat, I believe.
Permit my clerk to assist you to your carriage.”




II

Robert dalton was of good blood, having descended from colonial
families of degree. He was perhaps in his middle thirties, in appearance
no usual man, straight as a spire, with a powerful face in which every
feature seemed prominent; hair rather prematurely gray, and soft and
clinging as a woman's, and withal a manner courtly to such a degree that
the young, and those others unskilled in divining the natures of men,
associated with Mr. Dalton relations of a so-called romantic nature.
This conclusion was grossly erroneous, and led to much profitless
gossip. In fact, Robert Dalton was a stern and practical man of large
legal acquirements, with no more romance in his composition than a ship
carpenter. In the practice of his profession he was always cold, clear
headed, and technical, believing no man, and fearing no man; in truth,
the wags asserted, his courtesy was in itself a libel, because of
all members of the bar no one was more rigid, more exacting, or more
relentless than Robert Dalton, of Carpenter, Lomax, & Dalton.

The mental build of young Dalton rendered him especially valuable as
a chancery lawyer, and this department of the business he gradually
assumed until it was almost entirely in his hands. For years he drafted
all difficult pleadings, especially difficult under the rigid practice
of the common law obtaining in the Virginias. He drafted likewise all
deeds, wills, and papers of like tenor, with such unusual care and skill
that he rapidly gained a reputation,--the sort of reputation which it
usually requires a lifetime to establish, and the value of which is
above rubies.

When the judges spoke of him they said, “If Mr. Dalton prepared this
paper it is probably correct.”

It would be unwise to attribute to young Dalton an utter disregard
for social relations. The error of such an assertion would readily
be detected by those who knew him. In fact, he was usually present at
prominent social functions, and largely sought after by reason of his
magnetic nature and the charm of his vigorous mind.

The father of young Dalton had been a man of improvident habits, and,
immediately upon the death of his wife, squandered his large estate
in the riot of dissipation, so that his son inherited nothing but a
dilapidated manor-house and a single slave. This servant, a pure <DW64>,
was deeply attached to young Dalton, and the two continued to reside in
the manor-house near the city suburbs, the <DW64> acting as cook, valet,
and man-of-all-work. This manor house was one of the first built in
the Virginias. It was surrounded by a long, ill-kept lawn, in which
the ancient knotted oaks seemed to stand guard over the memory of some
departed greatness. The house itself, covered with the green Virginia
creeper, was little better than a ruin. The plaster had fallen away from
the great pillars, and the walls were cracked, in places, almost to the
roof.

Strangely enough, Robert Dalton never attempted to repair the estate,
taking pride rather in its air of decay. This statement is not entirely
accurate. He did, indeed, fit up the ancient drawing-room for the
purposes of a library, thrusting in rows of bookcases beside long
antique mirrors and mahogany window seats. These bookcases were
filled entirely with reports of courts, late digests, the decisions of
tribunals of last resort, and volume after volume on wills, contracts,
and corporations, but scarcely a volume on standard or current
literature. For these latter he had no inclination, and, as he
apologetically explained, no time.

In this library, Dalton did most of his legal work, obtaining here
freedom from interruption and the quiet which he required.

As the city developed, this neglected suburban street was seized upon
and assumed as the fashionable quarter by the wealthy Eastern families.
They paved it far into the country, and ruthlessly wiped out the
splendid old homesteads, erecting on their ruins ostentatious palaces
with prim lawns, reminding one not a little of that civilized vandalism
which would cut out from its frame the superb painting of a landscape
and replace therein a practical and entirely accurate map of the same
landscape.

These wealthy families swept out, too, the old social customs of this
city, setting up elaborate formalities and impoverishing standards of
dress and entertainment.

The recognized leader was Mrs. LeConte Dean, the wife of a nail
manufacturer of vast wealth. Her receptions were the society events.
Indeed, it has been said that recognition by this newly rich importation
determined one's social status.

The Van Bartans were another of these wealthy families coming directly
from the city of New York. The father had founded gigantic iron mills
from which he had gathered a princely revenue. Upon his death, the wife,
a grim woman of frightful prejudices, had continued to maintain their
country place in sumptuous, albeit rather frigid, elegance. They had one
child, Gerald Van Bartan, an utterly worthless young man of extravagant
habits and wandering aims; nevertheless, a youth of generosity and
kindly impulses. The boy was a source of ceaseless vexation to his
mother.

Carpenter, Lomax, & Dalton were her solicitors; especially Robert
Dalton, in whom she reposed the greatest confidence, and not
infrequently she spoke to him at great length of her difficulties with
her son, and usually concluded by working herself into a towering rage.

When one morning in the early autumn it was announced that Gerald Van
Bartan was very shortly to wed Miss Columbia Summers, a young lady of
great beauty and of aristocratic lineage, but of reduced and nipping
finances, the city was very justly indignant. Robert Dalton had for
many years paid court to this young woman, and the self-constituted
match-makers had long since entered up their decree in this matter and
dismissed it, and they resented, as almost a personal affront, the going
afield of their plans.

Thereupon idle folk prattled of the great blow to Dalton, his broken
heart, and other drivel. There was no evidence that Robert Dalton
had any other than a passing interest in this matter, and neither his
partners nor those others intimately acquainted with the man suspected
that this gossip contained any element of truth Indeed, he had come to
be regarded as of stoical build.

When this rumor came to the ears of Mrs. Van Rartan, she received it
with almost suspicious composure, and a few days later sent for Dalton,
her solicitor, and inquired if she could dispose of her entire property.
To this Dalton replied that she could, the title to all property having
passed to her by virtue of her husband's will, of which she was the sole
beneficiary. Thereupon she smiled, and said that she might require his
services further on.

The wedding and receptions which followed were great social functions,
and for three years thereafter Mrs. Van Bartan maintained the two
young people in the veriest profligate magnificence, the elder woman
anticipating every wish of the younger, and heaping upon her the
costliest gowns and jewels to be had.

During this time, Carpenter and Lomax watched Dalton closely, but they
could detect no change in the man, except perhaps that he was even more
rigid and exacting in his professional transactions.

Thus matters continued without event until the night set apart for the
first autumn reception of Mrs. LeConte Dean. These were annual events
of great revelry, and largely attended. The night was unpropitious, raw,
and foggy, as October nights usually are in this region, but this in no
wise interfered with the occasion; indeed, it was long remembered as one
of startling magnificence.

This reception Robert Dalton determined not to attend, partly because he
avoided as far as possible every gathering at which he might be thrown
with the younger Mrs. Van Bartan, but principally because the firm had
an important case in the Federal Court then sitting, and he had been
asked to prepare an elaborate decree for the following day.

After determining to remain at home, Robert Dalton went into his
library, gathered his books of reference from their cases, and began the
preparation of his legal paper. This decree he found more difficult to
draft than he had anticipated, and, striving to adjust its intricate
matters, he became more and more absorbed until he was entirely
unconscious of his surroundings and of the time that had elapsed.

Finally he arose in order to refer to some report that was not within
reach of his hand. As he turned to the light he beheld a woman, wrapped
in the folds of a long party cloak, standing with her hand on the door,
as though she had just entered. Dalton was so utterly astonished that he
literally rubbed his eyes to ascertain if he were not the victim of an
illusion. Whereupon the woman threw back her cloak, and advanced to the
table, when he perceived to his amazement that it was the younger Mrs.
Van Bartan. To this man she seemed a daughter of the very gods in the
full bloom of womanhood. The rich velvet cloak thrown back from her bare
shoulders, the ball dress clinging like puffy webs to a form that his
brooding mind had idolized; her eyes illumined, and her splendid hair
wound in loose coils above her dainty head.

It would all be very weary to set out in detail what occurred on this
October night; how the younger woman explained that she had finally
divined the intention of the elder Mrs. Van Bartan, and how she had
hoped to see Dalton at the LeConte Dean's, and not finding him had
slipped away, and, availing herself of the foggy night, had been driven
unattended to his house in order to implore his aid; how she came and
stood beside him, and pointed out the dread results sure to follow the
elder Mrs. Van Bartan's unnatural intentions,--results disastrous to
her and to hers. Gerald Van Bartan was worthless, she knew that; he had
never been taught to work; he was now too old to learn; it would mean
poverty, grinding poverty, and shame worse than all; and her father,
aged and broken in health, and the others of them, all dependent upon
her, would be thrown out to huddle in beggary, literally, beggary.

How Dalton replied that there was nothing he could do; reminding her
that the elder Mrs. Van Bartan was a woman of iron will, of stern
resolve, of relentless determination, and that neither he nor any other
living man could affect her. And how like a woman she answered that he,
Dalton, would be sent for to make the will, and that he must save her
some way, she did not know how,--he would know, he was shrewd, he was
a great lawyer, he could certainly find some way; this she knew, and he
must do it.

And how he labored to show her that there was nothing he could
do--absolutely nothing; that the whole thing was hopeless, thoroughly,
utterly hopeless; and then how she came to him and put her bare white
arms around him and looked up into his face, the big tears shining in
her glorious eyes, and said that if this were true, then she proposed
to tell him all the truth, the truth that she loved him, him only in all
the wide world, him always from her very childhood, and that for others
she had made this sacrifice; and how great, how awful a sacrifice it had
been, men could not understand. How he coldly loosed her arms, although
to do it wrenched his very heart loose; although he would have given his
life gladly to have taken her in his embrace if only for a moment, and
told her how he understood and how he loved her for it, and how he would
always love her to the very end of all things; but, instead, how he had
sternly led her out to the carriage and forced her to leave him, and
how he turned back into the library with his head swimming and his heart
pounding like a hammer, and fought the whole thing out through the long
October night, until the dawn crept in and the birds began to chirp in
the Virginia creeper.

Some weeks later, as was anticipated, the elder Mrs. Van Bartan summoned
Robert Dalton to her residence in order to prepare her will. Upon his
arrival he found Simon Harrison, President of the First National Bank,
and David Pickney, a steel manufacturer, both prominent citizens of
unquestioned integrity; also the late Milton South, a most estimable
physician. At Mrs. Van Bartan's request, Robert Dalton prepared the will
in the presence of these three persons. When he had finished he handed
the paper to the testatrix, who thereupon read it aloud in the presence
of all, declared it entirely correct, and affixed her signature. As is
customary, Dalton requested the three gentlemen to converse with the
testatrix and satisfy themselves that she was in proper mental
condition. This they did at some length, and not unskilfully, all being
men of good sense. Afterward Harrison and Pickney subscribed their names
as witnesses in the manner prescribed by the statute. Mrs. Van Bartan
then placed the will in an envelope, sealed it with her own hand in the
presence of all, and gave it to Simon Harrison to retain until after her
death.

On the seventeenth day of December following, Mrs. Van Bartan died
suddenly, and some days thereafter the will was opened and read at her
late residence by Simon Harrison, executor. Gerald Van Bartan and his
young wife were present, as was also Robert Dalton, and those others who
had been with the deceased when the will was drawn. The elder members
of the law firm, Carpenter and Lomax, were likewise present, and, at the
request of Harrison, the Episcopal minister, Rev. Mr. Boreland, and his
counsel, an obscure practitioner named Gouch.

The will was short, leaving the entire estate, real and personal, naming
it specifically, for some religious purpose; and, in a spirit of grim
jest, it would seem, one dollar each to her “beloved children,” Gerald
Van Bartan and Columbia Van Bartan, his wife.

The effect of this will upon the two young people, as the executor
slowly read its provisions, would require a dramatist of no little
stature to describe. The woman's face grew drawn and bloodless. The
man's knees seemed to give way, and he would have fallen had he not been
helped to a chair.

Dalton, men did not notice, for he was a skilful actor. When the
executor had finished, Mr. Lomax plucked Carpenter by the arm, and
inquired, in a low voice, if he had noticed any defect in the will.
Carpenter replied that he had not, but that he had paid little attention
to its form, whereupon Lomax requested him to examine it closely. The
elder counsellor stepped up beside Harrison and began to go carefully
over the instrument. Presently he stopped in amazement, and put his
finger down on the paper.

“This will,” he said, “is utterly void.”

At the word, the blood surged back into Columbia Van Bartan's face. She
took two steps toward Robert Dalton, then turned and buried her face in
the folds of a heavy curtain. Dalton was cool and entirely incredulous.

“I think you are very much mistaken, Mr. Carpenter,” he said quietly.

“Mistaken?” answered the counsellor. “Why, this bequest is made simply
to 'St. Luke's Episcopal Church.' That organization is neither an
individual nor a corporation; it has no recognized legal existence. And
this request must fail for want of a devisee.”

At this point Harrison, who was a slow but very careful man, interrupted
and explained with great accuracy that the will was in every detail
exactly as the testatrix had desired it; that even the language used was
her language; that she had said “St. Luke's Episcopal Church,” and
that Mr. Dalton had written it in the instrument precisely as Mrs. Van
Bartan had said, and that there could be no possible error either by
accident or design.

Carpenter was about to reply, when Lomax, noticing his excitement,
stepped in between Harrison and the elder attorney, and pointed out at
great length that this was all no doubt true, but that, under the law,
an indefinite religious organization, could not take a bequest; that
this was not generally known to those unfamiliar with legal business,
but that Mr. Dalton should have known that, in order to devise property
to a religious organization, it must be given to a board of trustees,
or to a certain person or persons, named in the will, for a specific
and accurately determined purpose; that this, Mr. Dalton should have
explained, and that his writing down the exact words of Mrs. Van Bartan
had defeated her intentions, and rendered this bequest void.

“But, sir,” put in the attorney Gouch, pompously, “the testatrix's
intention must control. I see no----”

“Come, come, my good man,” cried Carpenter, angrily, “this is what is
known in Virginia as a 'vague and indefinite charity.' Such bequests
have been held void for almost a century. Why Silas Hart attempted to
create such a devise as early as 1790, and John Marshall, Chief Justice
of the United States, held it void at law. Twenty years later.
Joseph Gallego attempted to bequeath a similar charity to the Roman
Catholic Church at Richmond, and Henry St. George Tucker, President of
the Supreme Court of Virginia, in a famous opinion, held that it must
fail, and from that time until the present the courts of this country
have been passing upon this common error of testators and their
incompetent advisers.”

Robert Dalton looked up anxiously. “In what cases?” he stammered.

“What cases!” almost shouted the elder counsellor, for he had now
lost his temper completely. “What cases, you bungler! Ask the veriest
pettyfogger; ask the commonest justice of the peace, but do not
catechise me.” And after having delivered himself of this venom, he
seized his hat and cane and stalked out of the house. He was greatly
enraged to think that a man of Dalton's learning, a member of a firm of
high standing, should make such a stupendous blunder.

Later in the day Robert Dalton came to the office and requested
Carpenter and Lomax to join him in his private room. His face showed
plainly the evidences of a great mental strain. When they were together
he closed the door, and, turning to them, said that he had examined the
question which they had raised, in regard to Mrs. Van Bartan's will, and
he was now satisfied that he had made a prodigious error in drafting
the instrument; that as his mistake would deprive a powerful church of
a vast estate, endless criticism of a most acrimonious character would
follow; that it was not just for any part of this criticism to fall
upon the shoulders of either Carpenter or Lomax, and, therefore, he
had determined to publicly withdraw from the firm. To this they made
scarcely a courteous objection, and Dalton accordingly withdrew,
publishing an announcement thereof in the daily papers.

The report of a great error in Mrs. Van Bartan's will spread through the
city with the marvellous rapidity of an evil rumor. The vials of bitter
criticism were poured out upon the head of Robert Dalton. Men declared
that they had long suspected that he was a sham, a posing ignoramus, a
dangerous blunderer.

The executor, Harrison, as was his duty, attempted to execute the
charitable bequest, but, of course, failed. Whereupon the press of the
city stood up in the market-place like the selfcomplacent Pharisee and
declared that in this day mistakes were crimes; that it was not enough
for an attorney to do the best he knew,--it was his duty to know; it was
not enough for an attorney to be honest, he must he likewise competent;
that the law was a learned profession in which the bungler was equally
as dangerous as the knave; that vast estates were conveyed by will, and
how easily by mistake or design a lawyer could destroy the testator's
most sacred wish; he could rob the helpless of his right, the dependent
of his inheritance, or the charitable institution of its patron's aid,
and all this without color of criminal wrong. The law, it asserted,
punished with relentless hand the man who blundered in positions of
trust; it punished with awful penalties the man who blundered in the
heat of passion, but it had no censure, no sting, no scourge for the man
who blundered at the bedside of the dying.

Thus was Robert Dalton's fame as a lawyer damned into the veriest
blackness.




III

ON a certain bleak Thursday of January, Randolph Mason sat in his
office, absorbed in the study of a great map which was spread out on his
table. The day was so dark and lowering that the electric light above
the table had been turned on. Presently the door opened and the little
clerk Parks looked in. He watched the lawyer for a few moments intently;
then he withdrew his head. A few minutes later, the door again opened
and a woman entered, and closed it behind her. She stopped and looked
at the counsellor, bending over his map. The picture was not a pleasant
one. The man's streaked, gray hair was rumpled, and his heavy-muscled
face under the glare of the light was rather more brutal than otherwise.
Then she crossed to the table and threw a newspaper down on the map.

“Will you kindly read that marked paragraph?” she said.

Randolph Mason looked up. For a moment he did not recall the woman, her
face was so very white. Then he recognized his client, Mrs. Van Bartan.

“You will pardon me, madam,” he said. “I am deeply engaged. Kindly come
here tomorrow.”

“I have to regret,” said the woman, “that I ever came here at all. Will
you please read that paragraph?” And she put her finger down on the
newspaper.

The counsellor looked at the paper.

“We notice by to-day's _Herald_,” it ran, “that Robert Dalton, Esq., has
sailed for Japan, where it is said he will become a legal instructor in
one of the national universities. Mr. Dalton, it will be remembered, is
the attorney whose stupid blunder invalidated the Van Bartan will, and
it is to be hoped that he will prove more efficient in the service
of the Mikado. The bar of the Virginias cannot be said to regret Mr.
Dalton's departure. He was grossly incompetent, and just such men bring
the legal profession into disrepute.”

“What of all this?” said Mason. “You obtained what you desired. Why do
you harass me with this nonsense?”

“I obtained it,” repeated the woman, bitterly. “Yes, thanks to your
devilish ingenuity, I obtained it, but at what a cost! I have the money,
but it is daubed over with the blood of a man's heart It has the price
of a man's honor stamped on the face of every coin. I hate it all.
Everything I see, every thread that touches me, taunts me with the shame
of such a sacrifice.”

The woman's voice was firm, but her figure trembled like a tense wire.

“Madam.” said Randolph Mason, “you annoy me. I have no interest in this
drivel.”

“No interest in it?” cried the woman. “You, you have no interest in it?
Was it not you who did it? You and the devil himself? You concocted this
plan. You said go to him, and tell him, and he would know what to do.
Your fiendish ingenuity saw what would result, but you did not tell me.
You did not tell me that this man would be compelled to rip his life
in two like a cloth to save me, and that he would do it. If I had known
this, do you suppose that I would have gone on for a moment? Do you
suppose that I wanted wealth, or ease, or luxury, at the cost of a man's
hope and fame and honor? I tell you, you miserable blunderer, this thing
cost too much.”

“Chatter,” said Mason, rising.

“Chatter!” cried the woman, beating her hards on the table. “Do you call
this chatter? I charge you,--do you hear me, I charge you with the ruin
of this man's life.”

“Madam,” said Randolph Mason, “the vice of your error lies in the fact
that you should have consulted a priest. I am not concerned with the
nonsense of emotion.”

Then he turned abruptly and walked out of the room.

_(See Amer, and Eng. Enc of Law. vol. ii., page 926, and the cases
there discussed; see also State us. Richardson, S.C. 35 Lawyers' Reports
Annotated, 238, and cases there cited; also Constitution of the United
States, Art., and the Constitution of West Virginia Art. 3, Sec. 5.)_




ONCE IN JEOPARDY




I

THE sheriff stopped on the steps of the court-house, pushed his straw
hat back from his forehead, moved his eyeglasses up a little closer
to his fat face, and began to contemplate the limits of his official
jurisdiction, with the air of one about to deduce a law.

The little county seat on Tug River slept in a pocket. Behind it and
on every side except the river were great mountains, half-hidden by a
gigantic cloak of fog. On the opposite side, from the great coal plants
of the Norfolk and Western Railroad a counter-canopy of smoke arose,
dense and voluminous, and stretched itself like a black hand out over
the town and across to the fog of the mountain. Man, it seemed, had
conspired with nature to cover up and hide the town of Welch.

“Strange,” drawled the sheriff, “strange, that a white man should be
willing to leave a paradise like this, and with river water in his
stomach too.” Then he chuckled comfortably.

The sheriff of the county of McDowell was all right. He represented the
entire machinery of the law obtaining south of Tug River, and he carried
the momentous responsibility with the languid grace of a bank clerk at a
charity german.

The sheriff was a Virginian. But, marvel of marvels, he was a Virginian
without a title. He was plain W. M. Carter. The statement is not quite
accurate. Among the boys he was “White” Carter. But he was no “colonel”
 and no “major,” and he gloried in the distinction and guarded it well.
The sheriff was a comfortably fat man and most genial. His eyes were
round, blue, and dreamy, and he never hurried. He was never abrupt or
a jarring element. He slipped easily into any position and filled it
up without a ripple, as water slips in and fills up the outlines of a
vessel.

Still the sheriff was all right. When he looked out of his dreamy blue
eyes through his rimless nose glasses at a <DW64> miner who had used his
razor as an adjunct to an argument, and mildly requested the <DW64> to
accompany him to the confines of the county jail, it was as certain as
the advent of death that the <DW64> would obey, and obey without comment.
And when the sheriff mounted his “murky dun” horse and passed up into
the mountains for the purpose of inducing a moonshiner to come down
to civilization and submit his rights to the decision of a judicial
tribunal, it was a matter of familiar history that the moonshiner always
came.

To the inquiring stranger, no man seemed a native of McDowell.

This impression arose from the fact that the stranger adhered to the
railroad and the coal towns which sprang up in its wake, and in these
every man came from somewhere. The railroad had brought in the coal
companies, and the coal companies had brought in the <DW64>s, and thus
towns sprang into existence, and the usual rough, expeditious methods
of civilization began. Then came the politician and the adventurer, and
mixed in merrily, and from that time forth the county of McDowell was
industrial and Republican, and everything “went.” But a few years back,
before the section hands on the Norfolk and Western Railroad cut through
from the county of Mercer, there was a population in McDowell that was
not Republican, and that did not “go.” They were long-limbed, indolent,
and “handy men” in a fight. They made corn whiskey when they pleased,
and voted the Democratic ticket when they saw fit, and accounted to
no one. The revenue officer came, and looked up at the great mountains
covered with the giant oaks of a century, concluded that the laws were
not being violated, and so reported to the Government. It was vastly
more comfortable than going up into these same mountains not to come
down at all, or maybe to come down with a squirrel bullet under the
ribs. In his day and generation the revenue officer was a wise man.

Here the citizen was born as it happened, lived as he could, and died
as the necessity arose, and the outside world neither knew nor cared nor
concerned itself with it. These were not bad people. Morally they were
as good as the sun warmed. Their life bred no shams. If they loved each
other, they lived together and were happy, and if they hated each other,
they fought it out The feud has been usually overdrawn. It existed in
truth, but it rarely resulted in anything more than a “fist fight” at a
grist mill, but when it grew serious, it grew very serious indeed. The
mountaineer always shot to kill. He was no man of half measures; it was
a free, open, breezy war, and perhaps it was as healthy fighting as any.
At his worst, the native moonshiner was a better man than the imported
miner at his best. Up in the fog of the mountains men were killed; down
in the smoke of the coke ovens they were murdered; and between the two
words there is a distinction as big as the honor of a people.

The “killer” was common in McDowell, but the suicide was not, perhaps
because men rarely take their own lives in the mountains. It is a
trick of jaded civilization obtaining in congested cities, unknown and
unpractised by the dwellers among the hills. Men died in the mountains,
but by the hand of others.

So the sheriff was puzzled. That morning the body of Brown Hirst,
manager of the Octagon Coal Company, had been picked up in the muddy
waters of Tug River, just below the bridge. Above, on the railing of
the bridge, his coat and vest had been found, folded and apparently
laid carefully over a girder. The bridge was very high above the
rocky stream, and the body of the man was badly crushed--almost beyond
recognition. The man had evidently jumped from the bridge with the
deliberate intention of taking his own life. All this the sheriff had
heard as he rode into the town. But rumors are lurid, the sheriff knew,
and he concluded to go at once to the prosecuting attorney. He wanted
the tale straight from some one who could pry the facts free from the
fiction. On the steps of the court-house the sheriff had paused for a
moment and made some observations to himself. But a crowd was beginning
to gather in the street below, and the sheriff, being fully aware that
this portended a demand for his opinion and not being pleased to express
one, he turned abruptly and passed into the court-house.

The man of order walked leisurely down the hall to the office of the
prosecuting attorney and entered. A thin, red-haired girl was pounding
a typewriter with the energy of a two-horse-power engine.
Conventionalities were abbreviated in McDowell. The sheriff sauntered
in.

“Where's Jeb?” he drawled.

The red-haired girl paused for a moment and jerked her thumb over her
shoulder. “In there,” she said, “busy.” Then she went on.

Miss McFadden was an economist; she wasted no words. The sheriff threw
open the door, and walked into the private office. The prosecuting
attorney turned around from the window.

“Hello, White!” he said, “you are the very man I want.”

“Which indicates,” drawled the sheriff, “that you are a young person of
great discernment.”

“When one needs horse sense,” said the prosecuting attorney, “your
acquaintance is valuable. At other times it is a luxury.”

“Together,” observed the sheriff, mildly, “we create a sort of
equoasinus intellectual atmosphere, I suppose.”

The attorney took up a chair and placed it by the window.

“Sit there,” he said, “and listen.” Then he closed the door, and,
crossing the room, began to open the safe by his desk.

The sheriff sat down meekly and turned his dreamy blue eyes on the young
lawyer.

The prosecuting attorney of the county of McDowell was an imported
article. Like the ancient wise men, he came from the East, but the
manner of his coming was not quite that of the early sages. The sheriff
had come up from the hills of Virginia, while the prosecuting attorney
had come up from the sea. Not that this young scion of the law' was a
sailor or the son of a sailor, but on a certain summer afternoon at a
certain fashionable resort, Fate suddenly threw away the toys with which
she had been amusing him, and he immediately realized that the world was
a common treadmill instead of a breezy French drag.

It was a stiff shock, but the spine of young Mr. Huron was good, and
instead of stepping off the pier, at ten o'clock of that same night
he was demonstrating to a certain wealthy senator who had large
coal interests in West Virginia that it would be the part of no
inconsiderable wisdom to send a bright young fellow with a legal
education down into this great mining region for the purpose of
investigating the land titles, and for the purpose of keeping an eye
on the industries generally, and, as it is said in the law, “for other
purposes.”

The old senator was by no means blind to the very slight efficiency
of raw material, but he had a heart hidden away under his coat, and at
thirty minutes past eleven he was convinced. So J. E. B. Huron came into
the county of McDowell, nailed up his shingle, and stepped down into the
_melée_.

The opening chapters of his legal career were blue-tinted histories, but
the material in the backbone of young Mr. Huron was splendid material,
and he remained. The perception of this man of the law was no dwarfish
growth, and he used it like the wise. McDowell was Republican by 1600,
and “White” Carter was big boss; _post hoc ergo propter hoc_. J. E. B.
Huron was a Republican of ancient affiliation, and more specifically
he was right hand man to White Carter. This wisdom was not without its
reward. The convention that nominated Carter for sheriff, nominated
Huron for prosecuting attorney, and the big boss pulled his man through
in spite of splits, and splits, and independent tickets. The prosecuting
attorney was a handsome young fellow with a good level head. He knew the
value of the sheriff, and he held to him.

The prosecuting attorney took some papers from the safe, drew up a
chair, and sat down by the sheriff.

“You have heard of Hirst's suicide?” he said.

The sheriff nodded. “All but the antemortem note,” he drawled.

The prosecuting attorney smiled. “How did you know there was a note?”

“Jeb,” said the sheriff, “it is a part of the etiquette of suicide. No
man effects his exit without a parting word. It would be bad form, Jeb,
frightfully bad form.”

“So you guessed it?”

“No,” replied the sheriff, wearily, “my gray matter was allowed me for
the purpose of utility. I concluded.”

The prosecuting attorney selected a letter from the package of papers
and passed it over to the sheriff. That official examined the envelope
carefully, then he slowly opened it and spread the enclosed letter out
on the desk before him.

“Octagon Coal Company,” he read slowly, “Miners and Shippers of Coal
and Coke, Welch, West Virginia. Robert Gilmore, President. Brown Hirst,
Business Manager. All agreements are contingent upon strikes, accidents,
and other delays unavoidable or beyond our control.”

The sheriff paused for a moment. “Written at the office,” he observed,
“with a pen, on the company's stationery.”

The guardian of order removed his eyeglasses, wiped them carefully,
replaced them on his nose, and continued:

“The officers of the law are informed that I, Brown Hirst, have taken my
own life, deliberately and at a time when I am in the full possession of
my faculties. My reasons for so doing are of no importance to the law,
and are accordingly withheld. This statement is made merely for
the purpose of preventing any inference of murder, and for no other
purpose.--Brown Hirst.”

The sheriff replaced the letter in its envelope. “That,” he said, “Is a
sensible communication. By the very highest flame on the altar of folly,
it is an exceedingly sensible communication. Where did you find it?”

“The coat and vest,” replied the lawyer, “were found lying carefully
folded over the railing of the bridge. This letter was in the breast
pocket of the coat. Hirst evidently went about his death with great
deliberation. Still, I see no motive for suicide.”

“Jeb,” drawled the sheriff, “you are _long_ on motives. Everything must
have a motive stamped in red ink on its face. Can't you allow an obscure
citizen to change his permanent residence and retain his reasons? The
gentleman has said in his communication that his reasons are of no
moment to the law. Can't you take the gentleman's word for it? It is n't
courteous, Jeb. By the way, where is the corpse of the decedent?”

“Within the sacred jurisdiction of the coroner.”

“And the medical fraternity?” inquired the sheriff.

“Doctor Hart is over in Jacktown putting the finishing touches, it is
said, on old Pap Dolan, so the coroner called in a miracle doctor from
Cincinnati.”

The sheriff chuckled. “Miracle doctor,” he drawled, “is good--is very
good.”

The prosecuting attorney assumed the air of an instructor.

“Healers,” he began, “may be set down, for the purposes of a proper
classification, under three great heads or grand divisions, namely,
'yarb doctors,' 'old-line practitioners,' and 'miracle doctors.' Under
the first class may be grouped those persons who seek to effect cures
by means of the virtues of shrubbery, as well as that vast army of rural
healers known along the watershed of the Alleghanies as 'bleeders' and
'steamers.' Under the second great division are included those grave
professional persons supposed to be learned in the mysteries of the
human economy, who, for a fixed consideration, guess at the ill, and
thrust in a chemical: while the third and final division is composed of
those mysterious healers who affect to thwart dissolution by means of
marvellous knowledge or marvellous skill peculiar to themselves.

“The species of the first grand division infest all that great tract of
country bounded by a timber line. The second great class obtains in the
cities and villages, and affect buggies, drugs, and sombre dress.
The third class is a by-product of congested civilization, and begins
usually with a patent lotion, and ends usually with a hospital.”

White Carter waved his fat hand. “But, if your honor, please,” he
interrupted, “what did the miracle doctor say?”

“He said,” replied the prosecuting attorney, “that Brown Hirst was a
compound fracture from the sustentaculum tali to the tripod of Haller;
and from the tripod of Haller to the corpus callossum, he was a simple
fracture.”

“Horrible,” drawled the sheriff.

“And he said further,” continued the man of the law, “that the
suiciding decedent was probably afflicted with some species of psychical
neurosis.”

“_Domine miserere!_” murmured the guardian of order. “So the travelling
Æsculapius testified, and as the coroner was quite unable to spell the
craft terms, he simply wrote down in the record that Doctor Leon Dupey
of Cincinnati, after a careful examination, had pronounced Brown Hirst
dead, which was far less prolix and entirely true.”

“That coroner,” observed White Carter, “should be United States Senator
from Kansas.”

Huron took up the note and put it with the other papers.

“I judge this to be a plain case of suicide,” he said. “I have carefully
compared the writing with these letters. It is certainly Brown Hirst's
writing. Still, men do not act without a motive, and I see no
justifiable motive.”

“Well,” said the sheriff, “I happen to know that financially the Octagon
Coal Company is somewhat 'groggy.' How will that answer for a motive _ad
interim?_ Or, as the sensible would say, in the meantime?”

“Good,” said the prosecuting attorney. Then he took a pencil from
his pocket, and wrote on the back of the decedent's letter “Suicide.
Motive--business depression,” and replaced the papers in the safe.

The sheriff arose. “The legend you have subscribed is probably correct,”
 he drawled, “but the ways of Providence are varied and mystic, and I
think I shall make some observations in my own right.” Then he went out.




II

IT is quite plain,” said Randolph Mason, “that you have fallen into
the usual blunder of the common rogue. If you had wished to rob the
insurance companies, you could easily have accomplished your end without
perpetrating this crime, and thus assume the hazard of discovery and
criminal prosecution.”

Robert Gilmore looked sharply at the counsellor.

“You mean that I am seeking advice late?”

“Precisely,” said Mason. “It is the characteristic error of the
witless.”

“Well,” observed the coal operator, “in desperate positions one usually
relies on one's-self; confederates are dangerous, and usually expert
advice is difficult to obtain.” Then he laughed. “I could not advertise
for sealed bids on how the thing should be done. I did the best possible
under the circumstances, and I rather thought that I had made a clean
job of it.”

“That delusion,” muttered Mason, “is common with the amateur. Indeed, it
is the mark of him. This killing was useless. You could have gotten on as
well without it.”

The keen, gray eyes of Robert Gilmore twinkled. “I should be interested
to know how?” he said.

“At this late hour,” answered Randolph Mason, “my advice upon that
point can be of no importance. Suggestions after the fact are of little
interest and of no value. You have now to consider some method by which
you may place yourself permanently beyond the reach of the law. This is
no problem of slight moment, and, in order to meet it properly, I must
know the details of this blundering business.”

The coal operator's face grew grave and thoughtful. “I presume,” he
began, “that the priest and the attorney are accustomed to require
details and accurate confessions. I am president of the Octagon Coal
Company, as I have said, and reside in the city of Philadelphia, where
I have been engaged in active business for several years. My life beyond
that time cannot be a matter of any special importance. I may add,
however, that I had been engaged with a foreign company as a fire
insurance adjuster for the State of Illinois for some years before
coming to the East. It was while acting as an adjuster of losses that I
first met with Brown Hirst.

“An unusually large fire occurred in one of the suburban towns near
Chicago, destroying almost an entire block, and I was sent out by my
company to adjust the loss. Upon my arrival in the town I found what I
believed to be evidence of a gigantic fraud. The block had been leased
for a year by one John Hall for the purpose of doing a mammoth general
business with a great number of different departments, and almost before
Hall had opened his doors to the public this fire occurred. There was
no explanation of how the fire originated. When first noticed by the
police, about three o'clock in the morning, the building was blazing
fiercely in a dozen places, and under such headway as to be impossible
to control. The local fire department was unable to prevent the loss of
the building, but fortunately a heavy rainstorm set in and prevented a
total loss of the stock.

“In conversation with Hall, I discovered that not one domestic company
had a dollar on the building or its stock, but that the entire insurance
was carried in my company and a number of London companies usually
associated with it, and for whom I acted as general adjuster. This was
of itself a suspicious circumstance, since the insured would not be
subject to the inquisition of numberless representatives of convenient
local companies, and in a legal fight would have the prejudice against a
remote company in his favor, and, further, he would have but one man to
deal with.

“I observed immediately that Hall was a person of much shrewdness. He
talked little, but what he had to say was exceedingly free from any
suggestion of concealment or obscurity. When I came to examine the
unburned stock, my suspicions were confirmed. It was composed entirely
of bulky merchandise, evidently selected with a view to a fire.

“The manner of its arrangement in the building was exceedingly
suspicious. The boxes had been piled up before the windows in such a
manner as to prevent the firemen from entering the building even after
the iron bars had been cut, and the arrangement was such that when the
fire should gain headway and the windows be opened, the position of the
boxes would act as a sort of flue and thereby greatly assist the fire.
It was all exceedingly well planned, and if the building had been
entirely consumed, detection would have been impossible. Nothing could
have prevented this but the unforeseen storm, and had it not occurred
just when it did, Hall's scheme would have proved a masterpiece of its
kind.

“I gave the public no intimation of my conclusions concerning the
incendiary nature of the fire, but when the investigation was concluded,
I took Hall to the hotel, and told him frankly that my company would
not pay the loss, as it was quite evident that it was all a shrewdly
arranged scheme to defraud. I pointed out the suspicious circumstances,
and the irresistible conclusion that flowed from them, and said plainly
that Hall would do well to escape criminal prosecution.

“To my utter astonishment, the man expressed no surprise whatever.
When I had finished, he asked me a few searching questions intended
to determine the thoroughness of my investigation, and when he was
satisfied upon that point, he drew his chair up near to the table at
which I was seated, and quietly proposed to divide the insurance if I
would join with him and make the proper sort of report to my company.

“In handling this proposition, Hall was marvellously skilful. He assumed
to treat the matter purely as a business arrangement. He said that
the loss, although big to us, was a very small matter to the wealthy
companies which I represented, and would not be felt by them, and would
cause no man any appreciable hurt; that he had gone to infinite
pains and no little expense to perfect his plan, and nothing but the
unfortunate storm could have prevented its complete success; that he
had never intended to divide with any one, but accident against which he
could not guard had placed me in a position to secure a portion of the
very considerable sum which he had gone to so much trouble and expense
to obtain, and, appreciating this new necessity, he was quite willing
to allow me an equal division of the gain. At no time during his entire
conversation was there any suggestion of danger or any allusion to any
risk, criminal or otherwise.

“It is unnecessary, I judge, to weary you with further details. Under
the remarkable handling of this man, the element of substantial wrong
seemed to disappear from the transaction, and the result was that I
finally consented to join with him. He claimed two hundred thousand
dollars. I reported to the company a complete loss, but advised a
settlement at not more than one half of the sum claimed. This finally
led to an adjustment at about one hundred and twenty thousand dollars,
without the least suspicion of a community of interests between us.

“It would not be quite true to assume that I easily fell in with Hall's
plan, although in point of time it would seem so. Financially, I was
in a bad way; from childhood I had been poor; always poor. In money
matters, things invariably went wrong. Every hazard I had taken, every
speculation in which I had entered, had always lost, no matter how
substantial it seemed. At this time I was rather desperate, I presume.
At any rate, I joined with the scheme, and it succeeded without a jar.

“Thus I came to know Brown Hirst under his alias. We divided the money
and deposited it with a trust company in Philadelphia until such time
as we might safely join in some one of the numerous ventures which Brown
Hirst was continually planning. But he was no dreamer, this Hirst. He
knew fully the great virtue of deliberation, and insisted that I
remain with the insurance company for at least a year, and then secure
employment with another company on some reasonable pretext, and then by
some error be discharged from this company, and if possible join with
another, until finally I should drift out of the business without being
subject to speculative comment.

“These suggestions of Hirst I followed to the letter, and they resulted
as he anticipated. I had now great confidence in the ability of this
remarkable man. The details of his plans were as accurate as the pieces
of a machine, and they seemed never capable of failure.”

The coal operator paused and rested his hands on the arms of his chair.

“Even now,” he said, “I consider Brown Hirst to have been the ablest man
I ever saw.”

Randolph Mason was silent. His face indicated rather more of weariness
than of interest. Perhaps the story in its substance was very old to
him.

“On the first day of September, 1893, I joined Brown Hirst in
Philadelphia, and here he unfolded a number of gigantic plans, among
others one for defrauding life insurance companies, which we finally
decided to attempt. I do not now recall that I felt any real repugnance
to the moral obliquity of these ventures. The mastermind of Hirst seemed
to sweep out any moral consideration, by simply ignoring it utterly.
When Hirst planned, it was all business, and, according to the ethics
of business, quite as right as any. Indeed, the man was so phenomenally
successful where I had always failed, that I never once dreamed of
objecting to any plan which he deemed wise.

“As I have said, Brown Hirst was as practical as a blue print. He used
to assert that of all vices haste was the most abominable, and that
before seeking to effect our venture it would be the part of wisdom to
engage in some legitimate business for a few years in order to establish
a reputation as a substantial business firm. Then our plans would be rid
of the suggestion of adventurers. Besides, it would give us financial
rating and substantial standing in the community in which we should
begin our fraudulent operations, and as well, in the meantime, we could
prepare our motives, which, Hirst asserted, should always be furnished
ready-made to the public when investigation began.

“We accordingly determined to purchase and operate a coal plant in West
Virginia. This business was suited to our purpose rather better than any
other, because men were continually coming and going in this business.
Unknown companies were formed in remote cities and operated merely with
an agent. The firm was rarely investigated to any very great degree, if
it promptly met its obligations, and there being little opportunity for
fraud, a good business standing could be easily secured by any manager
who was reasonably expeditious in his transactions.

“We secured a charter for the Octagon Coal Company, purchased a plant on
the Norfolk and Western Railroad in the county of McDowell, and began to
operate with Brown Hirst as manager and myself president of the presumed
Philadelphia company.

“Hirst was, as I have said, a man of fine business sense, and very
shortly began to make money. We enlarged the plant, and soon came to
be considered a firm of importance. When it grew apparent that we could
succeed at a legitimate business, I began to urge Hirst to abandon his
dangerous venture entirely, and devote his splendid abilities to the
development of the coal industry; but he only laughed, and bade me
remember that all this required work, and it was not his intention to
spend his life at work.”

“Sir,” said Randolph Mason, interrupting, “you are overlooking the
important matter in your disclosure. What was this insurance scheme?”

“Oh. yes,” said the coal operator, “I was coming to that. It was our
plan to secure heavy insurance on the life of Hirst, making his wife the
beneficiary, and later have him disappear under circumstances indicating
suicide.”

“That plan,” said Mason, drawing down the heavy muscles of his mouth,
“is ancient, and infantile, and trite; worthy of blunderers--children
and blunderers.”

Gilmore looked at the lawyer for a moment critically, then he continued.
“I presume the scheme is not new, but I rather think Hirst's plan for
carrying it into effect was somewhat novel and unusually practical. At
the time Hirst proposed this scheme he was unmarried, and, as a cold
business proposition, he said that I should select some woman--any woman
agreeable to me, whom I should like as a wife, then he would marry her,
insure his life for her benefit, make his exit, and afterwards I should
marry the woman and send half of the insurance money to him in Spain or
Italy, where he had determined to take up his permanent residence.

“He urged that it would be best to keep the woman totally ignorant
of our plan, so that if anything should go wrong, she could not be
implicated in a conspiracy, and, therefore, could not be prevented from
obtaining the insurance as, she being the sole beneficiary and no fraud
on her part being possible, any suspected or even assured fraud on my
part would not void the policy payable to her, provided he, Hirst, could
not be found within seven years.

“Hence, two considerations were necessary in selecting the woman. First,
she must be so situated as to reduce suspicion of her to the minimum.
And, second, she must be one whom I could marry as Hirst's widow and
thereby obtain the money. This part of the plan was allotted to me to
complete. You will now see with what a remarkable man I was associated,
and how little regard he entertained for the customs of human society.

“In leaguing myself with this man's fortune I blundered fatally.
My nature was entirely different. I could not shut out the natural
emotions. I could not crowd out the human in me. I was no calculating
machine like this man Hirst, and in carrying out my portion of the
venture I made a frightful mistake.

“I am not now going into the details of that mistake. It will be
sufficient for the purposes of this interview to say that the woman
whom Hirst finally married was a good woman, the daughter of a venerable
churchman residing in one of the suburban towns of Philadelphia,--such
a good woman that no sooner had the ceremony taken place than I began to
regret having associated her with such a cold-blooded villain as Brown
Hirst, and as the days ran by, that regret grew into a very passion of
remorse.”

The man paused for a moment, raised his elbows up on the arms of his
chair and locked his fingers.

“I guess it was a sort of Providential judgment,” he continued, “if such
things are supposed to be in this practical time. I avoided the woman
as far as possible, and strove to conceal my terrible regret, but it was
quite useless. Hirst knew almost before I realized the feeling myself,
and harshly bade me remember that this was business, and no matter of
maudlin sentiment. He had no feeling whatever for the woman, and if I
could wait for a little time the plan would very shortly give her to me.
He warned me against what he was pleased to call 'nonsense,' and I must
admit that the powerful personality of this man forced me into a sort of
stolid subjection to his will. But the feeling for the woman remained,
and I hated Hirst.”

Randolph Mason put out his hand as though to interrupt the speaker, but,
appearing to reconsider, suddenly withdrew it and nodded to the coal
operator to continue. The young man took no notice of the interruption.

“Hirst,” he went on, “like the master spirit that he was, proceeded to
put the details of his plan into operation. From time to time he applied
to the best companies in the country for insurance, and as he was
considered a good risk, a man of fine physique, and in charge of a
substantial business, he presently secured about two hundred thousand
dollars on his life. These policies he carried for two years in order
to avoid the suicide clause, and in order to render them as nearly
incontestable as possible.

“Finally, every arrangement having been completed, the time drew near
when Brown Hirst determined to make the final movement in his scheme.
But during these two years my hate of this man had not been idle. I
don't know just what possessed me. I had no good reason to hate him.
It was all, as he said, a business matter,--details in a pure business
matter. But I did hate him, and, unconsciously, one does not know just
how. I determined to take a part in his plan. I determined to make the
play real. This determination was no sudden resolve; it seemed rather
to evolve slowly until it finally became a fixed purpose. The motive
for the supposed suicide, Hirst had by no means overlooked. It was to be
impending financial ruin, and during the past year immediately preceding
his death Brown Hirst drew great sums from the business, and finally
mortgaged and remortgaged the entire coal plant and applied the money
to the payment of his heavy insurance, so that at the time of his
disappearance the business would be in a state of financial collapse,
and the motive for his rash deed would be adequate and thoroughly
apparent.

“During all this time, Hirst operated in McDowell near the county seat
of Welch, his wife remaining for the most part with her father, while I
maintained a city office in Philadelphia. On the day set apart for the
disappearance of Brown Hirst, there was a stockholders' meeting of our
company at its principal office in West Virginia. It was a sham, but it
was rumored that the purpose of this meeting was to discuss some measure
that would relieve our business from impending ruin. This was the
purpose made public. The real purpose was to account for my presence
in McDowell. It was a part of Hirst's plan that I should remain behind
after his disappearance in order to see that everything was properly
arranged, and then take a night train for the East.

“The preliminary details of that night's work were splendidly managed.
We met together at the office of the company. Here Hirst wrote a letter
explaining that he was about to take his own life, and placed it in the
pocket of his coat.

“Then he took a bundle of men's clothing, in which he intended to make
his escape from the country. This bundle consisted of a grimy coat such
as the ordinary miner wears, in the pockets of which he had placed a
package of bank notes, a pocket-book containing a New York draft and a
memorandum of his insurance policies.

“The trousers, shoes, and other articles of this disguise Hirst wore
when he left the office, it being his intention to leave his usual coat
and vest on the bridge over Tug River, as evidence of the suicide, and
then, assuming the remainder of his disguise, slip out to Cincinnati on
the night freight.

“From the office we went directly to the bridge over Tug River, for the
reason, as Brown Hirst always maintained, that in order to leave perfect
circumstantial evidence it was absolutely necessary to actually do as
far as possible the things which one desired the public to believe one
had done.

“It was perhaps two o'clock, and very dark and wet. It had been raining
for almost a week. This was largely in our favor, since the river
at flood is deep and rapid, and a body lost in it when the water was
running high would not probably be recovered at all, as we had noticed
was the case with lumbermen not infrequently drowned; hence we had
selected the time of heaviest rains in this region in order that the
loss of the body should not seem a matter of unusual moment.

“It might be as well to explain that when Tug River is swollen by rains
its channel beneath the bridge is very deep and rapid nearest its east
shore, while near the west shore its bed is higher and covered with
immense bowlders; thus anything thrown into this river on its east
side would probably be carried away and lost, while if dropped from the
bridge on the west side it would probably lodge among the bowlders, and
remain after the high water had subsided.

“As I have said, it was very dark, and the roar of the waters was
something frightful, but we were quite familiar with the bridge, and,
becoming accustomed to the darkness, presently came to see sufficiently
for our purposes.

“Hirst went directly to the span of the bridge nearest the east shore,
and, removing his coat and vest, placed them across one of the girders.
Then he began to undo the bundle in order to put on the miner's clothing
which he had brought with him.

“This was my opportunity, and I suggested that we first walk to the
other side in order to make sure that the bridge was entirely clear.
He immediately put down the bundle and came up to me. I do not now know
whether there was in his mind any trace of suspicion, but I do know that
at this suggestion the man seized my arm and tried to look into my face,
and I am certain that had it been light he would have discovered the
treachery which I was contemplating. But it was dark, and the man said
nothing except to curse the night. He was exceedingly profane, this
Hirst, and as we walked the length of the bridge, he holding my arm
and damning the night in half whispers, I somehow felt that this man
appreciated in a vague way the doom that was impending. But I presume
that this was simply an impression arising from the intense strain under
which I was laboring.

“As we were about to return, I pointed to the white surf, breaking on
the bowlders below. The man, still holding my arm, stopped, leaned over
the low railing, and peered down into the water. This was the position
into which I had hoped to trap him, and, wrenching my arm loose
suddenly, I struck him heavily between the shoulders. The man plunged
forward over the railing, clutching wildly at the air, but he uttered no
cry. and his body whirled downward into the blackness below.

“I clung to the railing and strove to see where the body would strike,
but it was folly. The bridge was high above the rough stream, and I
heard only the dull splash that told of his death.”

The eyes of the coal operator seemed to stretch at the corners, and a
dull gray spread over his face.

“I should like to be rid of that scene,” he continued after a moment.
“It is frightfully vivid. Every detail of it seems to have been
photographed on my brain, and it runs before me like the pictures in
a vitascope. Men sometimes forget such things, it is said, but, in the
name of Heaven, how? Why, I can see him any moment in the dark. I can
see his strained white face mad with horror, I can see his clutching
hands, I can feel in my own throat just how the terror of death choked
in his, and I know, I know----”

Randolph Mason struck his clenched fist heavily on the table. “Sir,” he
said sharply, “you will kindly omit this drivel. Give me the facts just
as they occurred. You may reserve your melodrama for the purposes of a
copyright.”

Gilmore started and threw up his head as though some one had suddenly
dashed ice-water in his face. He put his hand up to his forehead and
pressed his fingers hard against the skin; then he straightened in his
chair and seemed to gain his self-control.

“Well,” he went on, “I went back to the east side of the bridge, threw
the bundle over into the river, slipped through to the Chesapeake and
Ohio on one of the night freights, and by noon of the same day I was in
Philadelphia.

“That afternoon the city office was advised of Brown Hirst's suicide.
We immediately wired the prosecuting attorney for details, and were
informed that he had jumped from the bridge, leaving a note in his
pocket which explained that he had taken his own life. The body was
shipped to Philadelphia, as his wife directed. Almost immediately I began
to close the affairs of the Octagon Coal Company, and very shortly after
the funeral I called upon Mrs. Hirst in order to take the preliminary
steps looking toward the collection of her husband's insurance.

“Here my plan struck and went to pieces like a vapor. The wife of Brown
Hirst was a good woman, and I had failed to foresee what she would
do under circumstances of this nature. To my utter astonishment, she
informed me that the representatives of the insurance companies had been
to see her and had asked time in which to investigate the case, and that
she had gladly concurred in their request. And then, like a woman, she
declared that there was no reason why her husband should commit suicide,
and that she did not believe he had done so, but that, if he had
deliberately taken his own life, she would not touch one dollar of the
insurance money; that she would have nothing bought with life. If it
could be shown that her husband was murdered, as she believed, then she
saw no reason why she should not claim the insurance; but if, on the
other hand, it proved true that he had planned to defraud the life
insurance company for her benefit, and, pursuant to that awful plan,
had hurled himself into eternity, then she would starve in an almshouse
before she would touch a penny of the money.

“This statement struck me with the crushing power of an axe stroke. The
world seemed to pass out from under me. I saw every hope of the future
vanish. I realized in a flash, as one is said to do at the grave's edge,
in what a prodigious error I had been engaged.”

There must have been some suggestion of annoyance on the counsellor's
face, for the coal operator stopped short and moved uneasily in his
chair.

“I was about to forget your instructions,” he explained, with a shade of
apology in his voice; “it is rather hard to crowd one's emotions out of
a desperate, personal narrative like this, although, of course, it is
all nonsense to rant about it.

“To be brief, I was totally unable to shake this woman's purpose, and I
returned to the city knowing that a tireless investigation was about to
begin. I have not waited to see the result of this investigation. I know
that the insurance companies and this unusual woman will leave no stone
unturned in order to discover just how Hirst came to his death, and I am
not fool enough to think that they will eventually fail. I don't believe
any of the bosh about murder crying from the ground, but I am entirely
convinced that it is almost impossible to cover a crime so that human
ingenuity cannot trail down the man who committed it.

“I judge that I was not intended for business of this sort. I cannot
fight out in good order. With me a retreat is a rout. I have abandoned
everything. I have thrown away every plan. I am trying now to save
myself from the hangman, or at least the penitentiary. I have not waited
to be caught; I have come to you at once.”

The man seemed to relax and settle back in his chair.

“Now,” he added, with the utter dependence of a patient stretched upon
the table of the surgeon, “you must save me.”

The eyes of Randolph Mason flattened as though they were being pressed
down from above, and the lines of his face deepened and widened into
rugged furrows.

“There are two methods of evading the law,” he said. “The escape _ipso
jure_ planned before the fact; and the escape _ipso jure_ after the
fact. The first is a matter of no great difficulty, and may easily be
prepared by any man reasonably conversant with the law of the place of
his intended act, and if skilfully arranged need contain no element of
hazard whatever. The latter is far more difficult, and must be handled
with some care in order to reduce the element of peril to its minimum.
In the first, one constructs the facts to suit the defects in the law,
and if executed with any degree of intelligence, the criminal actor has
nothing whatever to fear, and the law is as harmless as a painted devil.

“In the latter, the expert must take the facts as circumstance and the
blundering criminal agent have made them, and strive to adapt these
prepared facts to the law as it stands, which is a far more difficult
proceeding, and not infrequently attended with disastrous results. Hence
the skill of certain criminal lawyers, and the long technical legal
battles with which the books are crowded.

“As for you, sir, the scheme in which you have been an actor was
abominably planned, and more abominably executed. The most drivelling
intelligence should have seen peril staring out from every infantile
move made by you and this stupendous blunderer Hirst. You have taken
an old, time-worn plan, teeming with dangers, and, not content with its
frightful hazards, you and this witless Hirst have added one complicated
peril after another until you have finally constructed a masterpiece of
idiocy that in its complex nonsense approaches the sublime.

“I wonder, sir, that you have not gone to the authorities and requested
an execution. It would be a fitting sequel to your atrocious errors.”

The face of the counsellor was ugly with a sneer.

“Your seeking counsel at once stands out as your one intelligent act.
It is marvellous discretion, Judged by your narrative; marvellous and
unexpected. Let us hope that your period of mental aberration is past.”

Then he arose and stood looking down at the man who, like many another,
had striven to throw the machinery of human justice out of its proper
gear, and had simply succeeded in tangling himself in its complicated
wheels.

“In order to save you now,” said Randolph Mason, “we must move quickly.
These great insurance companies have the ablest detective service of the
world. With such a bungle as you have made, it is merely a question of a
few weeks until they will succeed in fastening this murder upon you, not
directly perhaps, but sufficiently to warrant your arrest, and then you
must take your hazards with a jury. The man who to-day hopes to cover
his crime well enough to baffle the keen and tireless search of a great
life insurance company must be governed by something vastly nearer to an
intelligence than that upon which you and the decedent Hirst depended.

“At this stage of your blunder there are but two ways by which it is
possible to put you absolutely beyond the reach of the law. Death is one
way, and we will pass that. The other I am now going to bring to your
aid. With it the greatest care and haste are vital. At nine to-night you
must be here prepared to put yourself wholly in my hands. I shall have
every arrangement complete by that time.”

Mason stopped short, and put his hand down heavily upon the table.

“Now, sir,” he said, bluntly, “it will be entirely useless for me to
attempt the drastic measures necessary in your case unless you are
prepared to act under my fingers like a machine. Can you do that?”

“Yes,” said the man, wiping the perspiration from his face.

“Then,” said Randolph Mason, opening the door of his private office, “go
down to your hotel and sleep; and if you please, sir, do not think, or,
to be more accurate, do not attempt to think. Your thoughts, as has been
demonstrated, are of no value to you, and I assure you, sir, they will
be quite useless to me.”

Then he closed the door after the departing criminal and went back to
his desk.




III

THE sheriff was riding slowly down the narrow mountain road to the ford
over Tug River,--“Jim's Ford” the natives of McDowell had dubbed this
crossing far back when the dry ginseng root was a legal tender for all
debts public and private southwest, as the crow flies, from the county
of Mercer. Whence the name had come, and by reason of what, tradition
was silent. No doubt the original Jim had dwelt in this rugged gorge,
and by accidental hap had given his name to this rocky ford that lived
on and proclaimed him long after the man had passed out into the hands
of the Wind.

To the <DW64> miner, seven miles up at the town of Welch, this rugged
crossing, studded with great bowlders, was respectfully referred to as
“Hell's Gap,”--respectfully, for no other reason than that the <DW64>s
were superstitious, and the mammoth gorge, silent as the grave floor,
and deep and foggy except in the long summer afternoons, was calculated
to conjure every grim phantom set down in the African catalogue.

The sheriff pulled up his “dun” horse suddenly, and threw his leg over
the pommel of his saddle. Just below him in the ford of the river was
a man wading out into the water,--a tall mountaineer, bare-headed, his
dress indicating a rather equal compromise between the barbarity of the
village and the barbarity of the mountain. For upper garment he wore the
red-fringed hunting shirt of his fathers and his grandfathers and on;
and for nether garment, the blue overalls purchased at the country store
for a haunch of venison or a bundle of hides. The mountaineer was tall,
rugged, and powerful,--a proper inhabitant for such a place.

“Spitler Hamrick,” murmured the sheriff.

“By every limping god! The toughest pine knot in the mountains of
McDowell. I wonder what the old wolf is looking for.”

Then he tightened his knee on the pommel of the saddle and a slow smile
crept over the features of the sheriff. “By my troth'” he drawled, “it
is certain that Spitler is no Vere de Vere. Still, if blue blood ran
to back, and bunches of muscles on the shoulders, Spitler's claim to
princely lineage would be unquestioned.”

White Carter stopped short, and adjusted his eye-glasses. The
mountaineer had gathered up a bundle from the river and was turning to
wade ashore. The man did not at once see the sheriff; he was looking
down into the water in order to avoid slipping on the smooth stones.
When he stepped on to the rocky bank of the river, the sheriff called.
At the sound, the mountaineer dropped the bundle and jerked up a
Winchester that lay nearby against a bowlder. It was an act after the
custom of the mountains. One armed himself first, and observed the “lay
of the land” afterwards.

White Carter remained perfectly motionless. “I would n't shoot,
Spitler,” he drawled, “it's vulgar.”

The mountaineer dropped the butt of his rifle on the stones, and looked
up in astonishment. “Smoky hell!” ejaculated the mountaineer, “it air
the sheriff. Smoky hell!” The refrain was a nervous idiom with Spitler
Hamrick.

White Carter put his hand into the pocket of his coat, took out a
pipe, knocked the ashes from the bowl and began to fill it with
great deliberation. This act, remaining after the red man had passed,
proclaimed a status of dignified truce.

The play of action faded from Hamrick's face, leaving it stolid, heavy,
prodigiously indifferent. It was the mountain's stamp on its minion, the
silence, and the abominable indifference of the rugged earth ground into
the faces of the men who struggle for life on her stony breast.

“Hot,” observed the sheriff, crowding the bowl of his pipe and thrusting
the tobacco down with his broad thumb.

The mountaineer folded his arms over the muzzle of his rifle and leaned
upon it heavily.

“Yas,” he responded, “warmish,”

It was the full measure of salutation, and the full measure of
introduction to all matters, important or unimportant, on the watershed
of the Alleghanies. In the mountains no man hurried with his speech.
There was time to be fully understood, and time to answer fully; then
what one did afterwards, one was not so likely to regret. In the flat
lands men are not so wise, perhaps.

The sheriff struck a match on his saddle skirt, lighted his pipe, and
puffed a cloud of blue smoke rings out over the placid ears of the
“murky dun.” Presently he took the pipe stem from between his teeth and
looked down at the solitary proprietor of Jim's Ford.

“Spitler,” he drawled, “what 's in the bundle?”

“Ye kin look,” responded the mountaineer with prodigious unconcern.

The sheriff replaced his pipe and lapsed into silence for a moment. Then
he said:

“Where did you find it, Spitler?”

“I reckin ye saw,” replied the scion of the house of Hamrick.

The guardian of order looked up at the blue sky over the top of his nose
glasses. Then he looked down. “Spitler,”--he said softly.

The mountaineer interrupted. “Sheriff,” he growled, “old Spitler Hamrick
don't stand no shammackin' round the bush. Smoky hell! He aint never
stood it. Things air goin' to be like this: ye kin mosey' down here and
git this bundle, air ye kin ride on. But ye can't set on you hoss and
jaw. Smoky hell! Ye can't set on you hoss and jaw.”

There was no circumlocution, no trick of equivocation, no shadow of
obscurity in the speech of the denizen of Hell's Gap He used words for
the purpose of expressing exactly what he believed to be true, and for
no other purpose. This the sheriff knew, and others had learned and
remembered by certain long glistening scars, covered afterward with the
red flannel of their hunting shirts.

White Carter removed his knee from the pommel of his saddle and slipped
down to the ground. Here he paused for a moment, knocked the ashes from
his pipe and replaced it in his pocket. Then he clambered down the steep
bank to the river. The proprietor of Jim's Ford looked on with mighty
indifference. The sheriff took up the bundle without a word, returned to
his horse, and unbuckling the “throat latch” of his bridle, strapped the
bundle to the horn of his saddle. Then he placed his right foot in the
stirrup and turned to the mountaineer.

“Spitler,” he drawled, “we found a dead man in Tug the other day. I
think this is his coat.”

The mountaineer looked up from the muzzle of his Winchester. “Were there
lead in him?” he asked.

The sheriff flung his leg over the saddle and gathered up his bridle
from the horse's neck.

“No bullet holes,” he answered.

“Then,” said the giant Hamrick, “he were not killed in the hills.”




IV

IT was the first Monday of July, and the grand inquisitors of the
county of McDowell were in laborious session. It was hot in Welch,--so
hot that the sheriff had purchased a linen coat and departed for
Atlantic City on a ten-dollar excursion, leaving the deputy, Salathiel
Jenkins, to swelter with the grand jury. So hot that J. E. B. Huron,
prosecuting attorney by selection of the Commonwealth, resorted to
expressions not quite profane but nipping close to the border. So hot
that the foreman from Charity Fork made continual odious reference
to that historic locality over which Lazarus passed in the bosom of
Abraham.

The grand jury was a body mightily out of harmony with its inquisitorial
affairs, especially on this sweltering Monday when the mercury was
mounting heavenward. The members of the grand jury had removed their
coats, they had unbuttoned their shirts, they had rolled up their
sleeves to the limit over their great brown arms. It was hot--this grand
jury. But it was jovial and good-natured, sixteen freeholders of the
bailiwick turning aside for a day to bolster up the peace and dignity of
the State. The characteristic apparel of the farmer, the hunter, and the
miner was on this grand jury, but there were no collars; not even the
“biled shirt” of notorious report. If one had spoken of a haberdasher or
essayed to enumerate his wares in the land south of Tug River, he would
have been regarded as a purveyor of “green furrin jabber,” or been
pitied as a hopeless victim of idiot mutterings.

Thus do men hoot the customs of their fellows when in conflict with
their own. One looking at this grand jury as an exhibit would have gone
away regretting that the chief fad of Delilah had not been handed down
in the county of McDowell, just as the jury would have wondered why the
funny little man divided his hair in the middle like a woman and wore a
tight band around his neck and a stiff breastplate of cloth and starch
over his ribs, when he could dress like a Christian, and be comfortable.

At two o'clock the sage body had concluded its inquisition, and was
resting ponderously while the foreman. Abe Collister, of Charity
Fork, was slowly and with infinite pain affixing his signature to the
indictments. It was no small labor for one whose fingers were thick and
broad and accustomed to implements little slighter in proportion than
the handle of an axe or the stock of a Winchester.

The facial contortions of this good freeholder as he strove in a
clerical capacity would have won for him applause and fortune and wide
repute in the cast of a comedy. It was Fate's way, better than genius
could imitate, but no audience to see.

It is the function of bodies of this sort to be severe, and it is their
way to be most amiable. The prosecuting attorney, it was maintained,
ought to know what he wanted. He was paid to know. It was his business.
If he thought it wise to send in witnesses charging one with a crime,
then the charge should be found. This conclusion was a splendid working
hypothesis, pregnant with expedition, but not quite in accord with the
ideal _jus_.

So the grand jury rested as the afternoon grew apace, while the
scripturian from Charity Fork toiled, and the prosecuting attorney
went down to his office in order to “see if there was anything else he
wanted.” It was at this hour of lull, that a nervous little man hurried
into the office presided over by the industrious daughter of the house
of McFadden, and inquired for Mr. Huron. The red genius replied that he
was busy. According to this oracle, young Mr. Huron was always busy. His
continual status was one of tireless toil,--as continuous as a mortgage,
and as tireless as a gas meter.

Just then the prosecuting attorney came out on his way to the grand jury
room. The little man rushed up and demanded an immediate audience. The
two returned to the private office and closed the door. Here the little
man looked at his watch and announced that things would have to
be rushed, and launched into the subject. He explained with almost
breathless rapidity that he was a detective from New York, representing
Loomey's Agency. As he talked, he threw back his coat revealing a
badge which Mr. Huron did not stop to examine. He said that he had been
working on the case of Brown Hirst; that he had finally discovered
that Hirst had been murdered, foully murdered by one Robert Gilmore,
president of the Octagon Coal Company; that he had the case tightened
around Gilmore beyond the remotest shadow of probability; that Gilmore,
it seemed, had by some means learned of the damning evidence gathering
against him, and was attempting to fly from the country; that he had
left Philadelphia disguised as a cattle drover, and would pass through
Chares-ton, West Virginia, at midnight on the Chesapeake and Ohio
Railroad, and if he was not then arrested, he would probably escape
entirely, or, at the least, subject his trailer to the expense and the
tedium of an extradition; hence the detective had hurried to Welch in
order to secure an indictment at once and return to Charleston in a
position to arrest the man and hold him under a legal warrant that would
be valid and unquestioned.

He explained that he must leave at three o'clock in order to reach the
Chesapeake and Ohio Railroad in time, and requested that he be permitted
to go at once before the grand-jury, which he had learned was now in
session.

The prosecuting attorney listened in astonishment, but he was a man
familiar with the startling surprises of criminal investigation, and
he set himself to act with the expedition which the matter required. He
went at once to the grand jury with the detective, and explained that he
had just received information tending to the conclusion that Brown
Hirst had been murdered; that the witness with him was John Bartlett, a
detective from New York, who had worked up the case and would give full
information concerning the facts of the crime. He then added that as Mr.
Bartlett would be compelled to leave within the hour, he would return
to his office and prepare an indictment for murder. In the meantime the
grand jury could determine whether the information was sufficient to
sustain the charge, and, if so, the indictment would be ready and Mr.
Bartlett could return to Charleston without unnecessary delay.

Then he withdrew, and the grand jury of McDowell, braced by the gust of
sudden sensation, straightway forgot how very warm it was and began to
put itself into a state of ponderous bovine expectancy.

The witness Bartlett sat down by the table, took out his watch, looked
at it anxiously, then snapped the case and returned it to his pocket.

The foreman put down his pen very carefully, mopped his wet face with
a great red cotton cloth, and strove to assume the gravity of his
position.

“Your name's Bartlett, stranger?” said the scripturian, feeling that
it was becoming for him to set the wheels of judicial investigation in
motion, but not quite certain of the method. “You are a detective man:
and I 'low you know all about this here little trouble?”

The latter part of the query was a stock question with the foreman. All
day long, every crime, from homicide to assault and battery, had been
dubbed by this arch inquisitor as “this here little trouble.” If there
was any big trouble south of Tug River, it was not deemed to be within
the purlieus of the _lex scripta_ or the _lex non scripta_ of the county
of McDowell.

The detective saw the open opportunity to thrust in his testimony as a
narrative, and seized it. He leaned over on the table, assured himself
of the attention of the jury, and began to talk.

He told how he had trailed this matter down; how the Octagon Coal
Company was financially on the verge of ruin, and it was his theory that
Gilmore, as president, had been stealing largely from the company;
that Hirst had finally suspected this theft and had summoned Gilmore to
McDowell; how the dangerous man had obeyed the summons, had quarrelled
with Hirst in the office, finally killed him, and in order to cover the
crime had carried the body to the bridge and thrown it over, arranging
the evidence to appear like a suicide. He painted in lurid colors the
desperate character of this man Gilmore; he pointed out how fearful of
arrest the murderer of Hirst was, at that very hour hurrying westward in
order, as he believed, to put himself beyond the reach of the law.

The witness talked on glib and shrewdly, and while he talked, the jury,
unfamiliar with the rules of evidence, grew indignant and bitter, and
fired with a sense of the gigantic outrage.

Presently the door opened and the prosecuting attorney entered with the
indictment.

“Are you ready to vote on the matter, gentlemen?” he asked.

The foreman nodded slowly. “I guess we are, Jeb,” he answered.

“Then,” responded the prosecuting attorney, “Mr. Bartlett and myself
will withdraw.”

The witness arose and followed Mr Huron out of the jury room.

When the door had closed, the chief inquisitor from Charity Fork picked
up the indictment., turned it over curiously in his ponderous hand, and
then laid it down on the table with the back up. Then he took up his
pen and jabbed it down into the ink pot.

“Boys,” he observed, cheerily, “the Good Book says, 'None shall escape,
no not one.' What about this here one?”

“I reckon,” drawled Uriah Coburn, sage and philosopher, and most
venerable member from Injun Run, “I reckon the Good Book air right, I
reckon we better flop him.”

“Flop” was an accurate idiom in McDowell, and, being translated, meant,
“to throw heavily.”

To this the grand jury agreed with many and various methods of assent.
So the member from Charity Fork took a new grip on his pen, thrust his
tongue out of the corner of his mouth, and slowly and with great labor
inscribed on the back of the indictment this legend, big with the
injured dignity of the Commonwealth: “A True Bill. Abraham Collister,
Foreman.”




V

AT high noon on the following day Salathiel Jenkins, chief deputy of
the absent Carter, was a voluble factor in McDowell. He explained with
many a dash of color just how “me and Bartlett” had taken the fleeing
Gilmore from a midnight train and transported him to the jail at Welch,
where he now languished. How brave they had been, how expeditious, and
how marvellously successful in each of their desperate moves. Salathiel
Jenkins was a young person who considered himself of huge importance to
the economy of nature,--an opinion with which the world at large failed
to concur. The conservative Carter had expressed it all long ago when he
remarked with immense gravity that Salathiel Jenkins was not wise. But
the deputy's potential was high, and he talked. He explained that
the prisoner had employed legal counsel, with whom he had been in
consultation since his arrival in the town. He explained that Mr.
Bartlett had advised the prosecuting attorney to force the case to a
trial at once in order to avoid an application for bail, and in order
to prevent the prisoner from being unduly assisted by any accomplice he
might have in the East.

He explained that the evidence against Gilmore was overpowering, that
there were witnesses who knew something of the matter, and he had the
subpoenas in his pocket.

He explained that John Bartlett was the greatest detective in the
Republic, and that the days on earth of Robert Gilmore were growing
lamentably short. The self-importance of young Mr. Jenkins gushed
and bubbled and expanded until it threatened to bulge his anatomical
proportions, and he talked and he talked. He descanted with acrimonious
criticism upon the fact that Mr. Huron had asked for time in which to
examine the evidence, and that he and the great Bartlett had labored to
convince him that the case should be put to trial at once, and that they
had had a lot of trouble, but that it was all right now, and when court
convened in the morning the case would be called and pushed, and
he gloried in the fact that he and Bartlett had assumed large
responsibility for this splendid expedition.

It thus came about that the court-room was so crowded on the following
morning that the judge as he came down to his bench had literally
to elbow his way through. The details of this morning's procedure
demonstrated that while the deputy Jenkins had talked he had been
telling the truth. After the docket was called, the prosecuting attorney
arose and requested that a jury be empanelled for the trial of the case
of the State vs. Gilmore.

The judge expressed some surprise at this unusual haste, and intimated
that if an objection was urged he would continue the case to a later day
of the term. To his surprise, however, counsel for Gilmore replied that
he was quite ready for trial.

Whereupon a jury was had and the case ordered to proceed. The opening
statement of the prosecuting attorney was frank. It gave the history of
the case as he had heard it from Bartlett, admitting freely that he
had been unable to investigate the matter personally, but upon his
information he was convinced that the prisoner was guilty.

To this the counsel for Gilmore replied that the State was laboring
under a stupendous delusion; that Mr. Gilmore was a gentleman of
standing, and that it would quickly appear that there was no cause for
subjecting his client to the odium of a criminal prosecution.

The spectators were not a little disgusted with the tame proceedings.
They had expected a keen and spirited struggle with the startling
thrusts and parries of a bitter legal affair. They had hoped to hear the
steel grate, and to see the blades dart forward and bend and fly back,
as the champion of the State and its enemy strove for some master
vantage. They hoped for the fierce interests and the quick sharp thrills
incident to the grim fight of a desperate criminal for his liberty and
his life, and they were disgusted.

Their strong pugnacious spirit sympathized with Gilmore and damned his
counsel. In the picturesque speech of an auditor from “Dog Skin,” “The
lawyer was a quitter.”

The case progressed with almost exasperating insipidity.

The prosecuting attorney proceeded with great deliberation, and with the
air of one who maintains a thunderbolt in reserve. He proved the death
of Brown Hirst by the coroner and others; he introduced the books of the
company showing its financial standing; and put in such other matters of
unimportant evidence as were easily at hand. To all this the counsel for
Gilmore made no objection. To the observer, he was stupidly indifferent.

The prosecuting attorney then placed the detective John Bartlett on the
stand. Bartlett explained with great volubility that he was a member of
Latency's Detective Agency; that he had learned of the mysterious death
of Brown Hirst, and hoping to obtain the reward offered by Hirst's
widow, had gone to her and requested permission to investigate the case.
He explained that he had learned that the Octagon Coal Company was in
desperate financial straits; that the president, Robert Gilmore, who
resided in the city of Philadelphia, had been in the county of McDowell
on the night of Hirst's death, and from these data he had formulated his
theory to the effect that Gilmore had been stealing from the company;
that this fact had been discovered by Hirst, and that they had come
together in McDowell for the purpose of discussing this matter; that
there the two men had quarrelled, and the result was that Hirst had been
killed and his body thrown into the river, and the evidence of suicide
manufactured by Robert Gilmore.

The detective explained further that being advised that Robert Gilmore
intended to leave Philadelphia for St. Louis, and fearing that it was
an attempt on the part of the president of the Octagon Coal Company
to escape from the country, he had hurried to McDowell and secured an
indictment.

Upon cross-examination it at once appeared that this detective had no
knowledge of any fact whatever, but was merely speaking from certain
conclusions which he was pleased to call his theory. The attorney for
the defense moved to strike out the evidence of this witness, which was
accordingly done, much to the chagrin of John Bartlett, detective, and
Salathiel Jenkins, deputy-in-extraordinary to the sheriff of McDowell.

The prosecuting attorney then proceeded to spring his sensation.
He announced to the court that during the night Gilmore had made a
confession to Mr. Jenkins, the deputy, and that he desired to have
Mr. Jenkins sworn and his testimony introduced. Accordingly the
irrepressible Jenkins, by virtue of an oath properly administered, was
transformed into a witness for the State of West Virginia.

Before the witness was permitted to launch into his marvellous story of
the self-condemnation of Robert Gilmore, the attorney for the defense
arose and demanded permission to inquire into the circumstances under
which the alleged confession had been obtained. The judge replied that
such inquiry was entirely proper, and the attorney for the defense
began.

The ways of Providence are without premonition. At the first onslaught
of the attorney for Gilmore, the importance of the testimony of
Salathiel Jenkins vanished like a New Year's resolution. Yes, he had
gone to the prisoner together with John Bartlett; he had explained
that he was the deputy sheriff of the county of McDowell; that he was a
person of influence; that the prisoner was in grave peril; and that, if
a full confession were made, he, Jenkins, would induce the authorities
of the law to deal leniently with the prisoner. He was a person of
importance, he said, and, in the absence of the sheriff, the first
guardian of all the law and order in the county of McDowell; if the
prisoner would confess, he, Salathiel Jenkins, could save him from the
hangman, and he would do it.

These were the conditions under which the alleged confession was made.

At this point in his narrative, the attorney for the prisoner stopped
the witness, and objected to the introduction of the confession as
having been improperly obtained. The court very promptly sustained the
objection, and directed the witness to stand aside.

The prosecuting attorney arose and asked the court to _nolle_ the
indictment and permit the case to be dismissed. The judge reminded him
that the case was at trial, and that such action could not now be taken;
that the request should have been made before a jury was called; it was
now too late, since the control of the cause had passed from the hands
of the State.

Young Mr. Huron, prosecuting attorney of the county of McDowell, was
lost, rudderless, upon an unknown sea. He arose and explained that he
had not had an opportunity to investigate the evidence; that he had not
spoken with the witnesses; that he had depended upon John Bartlett
and the confession made to Salathiel Jenkins in order to convict the
prisoner, and that, failing with these, he had no further evidence to
introduce.

The court interrupted this speech of explanation, and reminded the
attorney that the State could not urge such excuses; that the prisoner,
having been put to the hazard of a defense, was entitled to have his
cause legally determined; a _nolle prosequi_ could not now be entered,
and the case must proceed.

To this the young attorney, having recovered his composure, replied that
the State had nothing more to offer, and resumed his seat.

The counsel for Gilmore at once moved the court to direct a verdict of
not guilty, which was accordingly done and the prisoner discharged.

Mystic, and varied, and without premonition are the ways of Providence.
When the <DW64> miner went down into the sunless temples of the earth on
this Wednesday of July, Salathiel Jenkins was a person of high estate,
crowding mightily the orbit of his employer. And when the <DW64> miner
came up at evening, this same Salathiel Jenkins was a crestfallen
underling, shrinking like a rotten value. The ordeal was frightful. The
pride of young Mr. Jenkins had gone through a process of sublimation
most excruciating. And yet how abominably indifferent nature was. The
books in the office of the sheriff were the same. The trees, the river,
and indeed the entire outside world were quite as large as they had
been. Only the importance of the deputy had shrunk, and was shrinking.
Master of folly! Would it stop short of microscopic? The vice of his
yesterday loomed clear-cut like the angles of a wall. He had talked,
talked. It was the deadliest error. In the name of that notorious Simon
of infantile record, was there no God to save the witless from himself?

The crowd passed out of the court-room, and, sauntering down by the
office of the miserable deputy, paused to harpoon him as it drifted
by. The weather was fine for scaffold building, it observed. Would the
deputy spring the trap in the absence of his chief? it was interested
to know. Could he tie a hangman's knot? Would he be pleased to have the
gracious assistance of his fellows? And more ingenious proddings, while
the weary Jenkins perspired and shrunk, but was silent. This he had
learned: like as the great lessons of life by hap learned too late.

And that same night John Bartlett and Robert Gilmore hurrying eastward
in a Pullman car on the Chesapeake and Ohio Railroad remarked with large
favorable comment that the ancient doctrine of _lex vigilantibus non
dormientums subvenit_ was marvellously true in this practical time.




VI

ON the night of the seventeenth day of July the judge of the criminal
court of McDowell walked into the office of the sheriff. He was in no
altruistic mood, this jurist. Since his fortunate political affiliations
had thrust him into a high estate his dignity sat upon him heavy as a
fog. He had been sent for. It was thoughtlessness approaching near to
disrespect. When the tall jurist entered, the crowd in the office of
White Carter arose.

“Judge,” drawled the sheriff, coming forward, “you must pardon the
centurion for taking this liberty with the tribune, but we were holding
a secret war council, and presently required the fountain of law. I am
sure you won't mind, Judge.”

The fountain of law flung aside his injured feeling with a wave of his
slim hand.

“It is all right, Carter,” he observed. “But why the conclave? Good men
should be abed.”

“'Day unto day uttereth speech,'” drawled the sheriff, “and night unto
night showeth knowledge. And just here the hurt lies. The boys have been
crowding the day and shirking the night turn.”

Then he stepped back by his companions and added: “Young Mr. Huron we
will overlook as familiar in your honor's forum. The other gentleman is
Mr. Hartmyer Belfast, in the secret service of the New York life
insurance companies.”

The judge nodded cordially and sat down by the table. The others also
resumed their seats, while the sheriff removed his eye-glasses, placed
them carefully on the forefinger of his fat right hand, and began to
explain.

“While I was absent, I believe, one Robert Gilmore was indicted here and
tried for murder, which trial resulted in a verdict of not guilty, the
evidence being insufficient to sustain the charge. It now appears
that Gilmore did kill Hirst, and that he can now be convicted with the
evidence in the possession of Mr. Belfast and myself.”

The judge elevated his eyebrows, but volunteered no comment.

The sheriff continued. “At the time of Hirst's death I was not quite
certain that it was suicide. The coat and vest found on the bridge did
not correspond to the trousers and shoes of the deceased, which were the
ordinary rough articles worn by the miners. There was no explanation for
such dress on the part of Hirst. Later I found a miner's coat at Jim's
Ford which corresponded to the other clothing of Hirst. This coat had
been tied in a bundle and thrown into the river above--probably at the
bridge. Stitched in the lining was a pocket book belonging to Brown
Hirst containing some money and a draft on New York, together with a
memorandum of a number of life insurance policies. These matters led me
to believe that Hirst had planned to secure the insurance on his life by
arranging a counterfeit suicide, but by some means the plan had failed
after the evidence had been prepared and he had come to a violent death,
probably by the hand of another.

“But the matter was involved in mystery, and I deemed it best to retain
my conclusions until further developments should appear. I wrote to the
various companies with which Hirst was insured, explaining the facts
which I had determined. They replied that the matter was in the hands of
Hartmyer Belfast, their secret agent, and that I would be advised when
the investigation was complete.

“A few days since the companies wired me that Mr. Belfast might be
expected to appear in my county at any time, and yesterday he called
upon me.”

The sheriff moved a little closer to the table, and the drawl seemed to
slip out of his speech.

“It can now be shown that Robert Gilmore came to McDowell for the
purpose of assisting Hirst to manufacture evidence of a suicide; that he
went with him upon the bridge, and after enticing Hirst to the rail of
the bridge, suddenly threw him over into the river. The train men can
be produced who saw Gilmore when he arrived and when he departed on the
night of the murder. All of this evidence has been carefully prepared.
In addition, it can be shown that immediately after his trial, for some
mysterious reason Gilmore went directly to Philadelphia and arranged
for a conference with the widow of Brown Hirst. Of this Mr. Belfast had
notice, and, by request of Mrs. Hirst, he was present, concealed in
an adjoining room. This conference between Gilmore and Mrs. Hirst was
remarkable. The man was deeply affected, and said that he had come to
tell her the entire history of his villainy, because he loved her, had
loved her always, and now knew that he could never have her. Whereupon
he explained that Hirst and himself had planned to rob the insurance
companies; that Hirst's marriage to her was part of the scheme, but
that he, Gilmore, had grown to love her, and to regret his action in
procuring the marriage, and so frightfully had this grown upon him that
finally he had killed Hirst.

“He then explained the minute circumstances of the death, adding that he
had been tried and acquitted, and would now leave the country, but that
something in his bosom would not rest until he had told her the entire
truth. So we have now, I judge, a complete case, together with the
confession, which, I am told, will be quite proper evidence, and
with such a case there can now be nothing in the way of Gilmore's
conviction.”

“Nothing at all,” observed the judge, dryly, “except the Constitution of
the United States of America.”

The sheriff sat down suddenly and replaced the eye-glasses on his fat
nose.

“You mean,” said the prosecuting attorney, “that the prisoner cannot be
put twice in jeopardy for the same offense?”

“Unless,” responded the judge, “the judicial machinery in McDowell can
be held exempt from the Constitution of the State and the Constitution
of the Federal Government, a conclusion,” he added, with prodigious
gravity, “in which I should rather hesitate to concur upon a casual
hearing. Having been once properly tried for murder, this man cannot be
again tried for the same offense.”

“It has been held,” said the prosecuting attorney, “that where the first
trial was procured by the fraud of the prisoner, the case did not come
within the provisions of the Constitution.”

“True,” replied the judge, “there is an early case in Virginia, and
later cases of record, but the fraud must be gross and apparent. What
fraud could be shown here? The indictment was properly found, the trial
was regular, no suspicion of conspiracy attaches to the officers of the
State, nor can it be shown that even misstatements were made, unless
a plain conspiracy can be shown on the part of this detective, John
Bartlett.” Then he turned to the secret agent of the life insurance
companies. “How about this Bartlett?” he asked.

“So far as I can learn,” replied the detective, “Bartlett made no false
statements. He is a member of Loomey's Agency in New York. It is true
that he called on Mrs. Hirst and requested permission to investigate the
case. What he stated to the prosecuting attorney as facts were facts.
Of course, his theory was wrong, and his deductions incorrect; but for
these, I presume, he could not be held responsible. I have investigated
the matter with care, and while it is extremely probable that this trial
was shrewdly procured by Gilmore, yet it has been so skilfully handled
that no fraudulent proceeding could be shown on the part of Bartlett,
although I am quite certain of his villainy.”

The sheriff rubbed his hands with the bland unction of a Hebrew at a
“fire sale.”

“Jeb,” he drawled, “I guess you're it. I guess the thing is all over but
the shouting.”

“Well,” responded the prosecutor, “I judge there are others. How about
the lamented Jenkins, erstwhile representative of the sheriff of
McDowell? Is the young man Absalom safe?”

A faint ripple of merriment spread over the fat face of the sheriff.
“Boys,” he mused, “it was a keen flim-flam. Let us quietly disperse, and
endeavor to live it down.” Then he added wearily. “It may be good to be
good, but it is safer to be smooth.”

The judge arose. “Mr. Gilmore has been tried and acquitted,” he
observed. “The record is complete. He cannot be held again to answer
for this crime, even though he be pleased to proclaim his guilt from the
housetops.”

“Then,” said the detective, with the dreary deliberation of one retiring
from a failing cause, “this murderer cannot be punished.”

The dreamy blue eyes of White Carter swam listlessly

“Perhaps,” he drawled, “when the gentleman shall have passed the
melancholy flood with that grim ferryman whom poets write of unto the
Kingdom of Perpetual Night.”

_(See Code of West Virginia, Chap, cxxiv., Sec. 14, Chap, cvi., Sec. 25;
also Chap. cxxv. See any good text book on Landlord and Tenant. The
case also of Martin Admix vs. Smith it al., 25 West Virginia, 579, and
casts cited.)_




THE GRAZIER




I

THE driller of the Bonnie Mag No. 3 had been keeping his weather eye
on the public road all the long summer afternoon; exacting and laborious
duties had obtained under the shadow of the oil derrick on this
nineteenth day of August, quite sufficient to have distracted the
attention of the ordinary man, but through it all the driller had
maintained his watch. The pumper, a grimy mortal, who regarded the
monster oil company as the sole and omnipotent power of the universe,
had marked this apparent anxiety of the driller, and inquired, with some
trace of humor, if that gentleman was expecting to see grease gush
up out of the road. To which the driller had responded with barbaric
profanity that the pumper had been employed to pump, and that he might
hold his position by holding his tongue, but not otherwise. A suggestion
that banished all levity from the speech of the pumper. Besides, there
was a red glint in the eyes of the driller, and the underling of the
great oil company appreciated perfectly the full significance of the
sign. He had noticed it before on divers eventful occasions, especially
on a certain morning when being interrupted by an order of the Circuit
Court, the driller had promptly suggested to the deputy sheriff that
he might go to the infernal regions with his injunction; and instead of
suspending operations until the legal forum could determine the title
to the realty, he had complied with his contract by pushing his well
through to the Gordon sand.

It was true indeed that the Circuit Court had attached t he body of the
driller and bringing him up before its august presence fined him two
hundred dollars for contempt, but the old man had paid over the money
without the hesitation of a moment and immediately thereafter consigned
the Circuit Court to the same heated region originally suggested to the
deputy sheriff.

The sun had gone down, and the twilight was beginning to gather on the
oil field. The shadows darkened across the long sloping valley, and the
great derricks in the half light looked dark and gaunt and threatening
like some grim engines of war. It was now difficult to observe the
highway from the oil wells far up on the hill side, and the driller,
who evidently intended to maintain his surveillance of the county
thoroughfare at any cost, stepped out from the shadow of the derrick and
began to wipe his hands on the grass; when he had finished he turned to
the pumper. “Just keep your eye on that cable,” he said curtly, “I'll be
back when you see me coming.” Then he turned and walked slowly down the
path to the road.

The soft breath of wind creeping up from the North through the rift in
the low hills brought with it no sound, save the dull ceaseless thump
of the engines drawing streams of liquid wealth from a thousand narrow
arteries leading down into the bosom of the earth. This great industry,
not content with changing the civilization, had changed also the very
face of the land; two years before this fluttering summer breeze had
carried with it the murmur of ripening corn fields, the sweet odor of
quiet pasture land where herds of fattening cattle wandered through
fields of blue grass. Now, the lands were marked with wagon roads,
studded with the rough shanties of the pumpers and the gigantic wooden
tanks of the great oil companies; and here and there, like the twisted
ugly back of some huge serpent, a black pipe line stretched its
interminable length across the broken country. Greed ruled the world,
and beauty, like many another gift of nature, was battered out under his
hammer.

The oil driller stopped at the road side and leaned his long body on the
rail fence. He was a thin, old man, with sharp, emaciated features, his
hair and iron-gray beard were matted with oil, and his long arms, bare
to the elbow and burned black by the sun, glistened greasy as the piston
of his engine. The ancient workman kept his watch in dead silence, and
beyond this his face showed no interest. This man belonged to that iron
type upon which the world has depended so much for its civilization,
that type which no matter where placed toils on in its station like
a machine, unquestioning, tireless, reliable as a law. In the rank of
their legions it had extended the rule of the Caesars; on the broad
decks of the men-of-war it had widened the dominion of Great Britain;
and in the mines and mills and forests of America it had reared and
maintained and enriched a Republic; growing greater than them all.

Presently in the deepening twilight a huge shadow appeared at the foot
of the long hill, and the driller heard distinctly the sound of a horse
coming leisurely up the sandy road. As it approached, the indefinite
shadow took on a clear and decided outline, until one in the position
of the driller could have seen that it was an enormous man, riding a
red roan horse. The man was leaning forward, his head down and his hands
resting on the pommel of his saddle, while the bridle reins dangled
loose in his fingers. When they were opposite, the driller spoke.

“Is that you, Alshire?” he said.

The giant threw bark his great shoulders and stopped his horse with
a wrench on the bridle “Morg Gaston!” he announced with some trace of
surprise in his voice, then he added, half-apologetically, “what's the
good word with you?”

The driller climbed heavily over the big staked-and-ridered fence, “I
saw you go down this morning,” he said, “and I have been watching for
you back; I want to tell you something.”

Then he came over to the middle of the road and rested his greasy chin
on the mane of the red roan.

“Hell of a high horse,” said the driller.

“Seventeen hands,” responded the giant.

The old man ran his eyes slowly over the immense proportions of the
traveller, his deep, powerful chest, his broad, thick shoulders and his
massive limbs almost grotesquely huge.

“You are not little yourself,” he observed, as though announcing a
discovery, “and I am darned glad of it, leastways I was darned glad of
it that morning old Ward's rotten derrick blowed down, and you chanced
along and lifted her off me. I was pinned under them timbers like a
rat.”

The man laughed, but his face in the dark was not merry. The driller
extended his close inspection to the horse; when he had finished he
stepped back in the road and an expression of intense admiration spread
itself over his rugged features.

“By jolly!” he said, “you are a pair to draw to.”

The giant patted the withers of the great horse.

“Cardinal is a good colt,” he replied, “good as they grow.”

The driller stood for some moments gazing almost worshipfully at the
pair; then he straightened suddenly and coming up close to the horse
rested his arms, wet with petroleum, on the pommel of the saddle.

“Alshire,” he said, lowering his voice, “the Company thinks there is
grease under your land. I was up to see the manager last night, and
while I was there the engineers came in with the maps, and they all
agreed that the head of the pool was about under your farm. You are
nigh on to three miles east of the development, but the belt is surely
running your way; this here last well that the Company plugged is forty
barrels better than the No. 1 five hundred feet west; and I'll tell
you another thing, there ain't no more boring in this region until the
Company gets its clutches on all this land laying to the east, yours
included. My instructions is to make this last one dry, and move over
into Ohio.”

The great Alshire bent over and placed his broad hand on the greasy
arm of the driller. “I'm obliged to you, Morg,” he said slowly. “I'll
lookout.”

“By jolly!” continued the old workman, “you better had, they are a
smooth set of divels, and whatever you do, keep your mouth plugged. I
ain't never given the Company the double cross before, but I could n't
see them skin you, by jolly, I could n't!”

The old driller spoke rapidly, as though half ashamed of his treason,
and when he had finished turned and began climbing the high fence.

“Morg,” called the giant. “Morg.”

“That's all right,” answered the driller, as he vanished up the dark
hill side, “just keep your mouth plugged; that's all right.”

The giant touched his horse in the flank with his heel and rode on.

Rufus Alshire was a grazier, a business almost exclusively followed in
this magnificent grass country. Many years before, his greatgrandfather,
an English Tory, had fled into this inland country in order to escape
certain unpleasant relations with the colonial government. Here he had
builded an enormous log manor-house, and surrounding himself with rather
worthless retainers, maintained a sort of baronial existence. Others
followed, and after a time the country was cleared and came to be
divided into great tracts of pasture land, owned by these powerful
families. But the elements of the feudal system, although suffering some
modifications, remained. The tenants were, for the most part, born and
reared on the stock land, and were almost fixtures.

The descendants of this independent ancestry continued to reside as near
to the central part of their estate as possible, and maintained huge
residences, rough at times and not quite comfortable perhaps, but always
enormous. The nature of the country being especially adapted to the
fattening of beef cattle, this industry soon came to be the exclusive
business of this powerful people. It was a profitable and supremely
independent industry, and gave wide play to the baronial instincts of
the Anglo-Saxon; who, even after the golden time of his race had gone
out so many hundred years, still loved the open sky, and the blue hills,
and the monster oak trees, and hated in his heart with a stubborn bitter
spirit of rebellion the least shadow of restraint. He was willing to
serve God if need be, but while he lived he would not serve men. In
stature the descendants of the long dead Saxon were huge specimens
of the race, almost as big of limb as the fabled barbarians of Lygia;
powerful men, whom close and intimate relations with the mother nature
kept strong and immensely vital to the very evening of life. But withal
the hospitality of the Saxon was profligate, his impulses were kindly,
and he was quite content to leave the affairs of government and the
problems of civilization to other hands, provided the minions of these
powers held their feet back from his soil.

The twilight had deepened into night; on the crest of the far-off hills
the great oak trees stood outlined against the sky like mighty silent
figures waiting for some mystic word that should call them into life.

The rim of the moon was rising slowly from behind the oil field, red
like battered brass; the road, covered with shifting light and shadow,
stretched across the rolling country like a silver ribbon. The grazier
rode slowly, his hands hanging idly at his sides, and his face set with
deep thought; from time to time he raised his ponderous right hand and
struck it heavily against the tree of his saddle as though to indicate
thereby some important decision finally reached, but as often he dropped
the hand back to its place.

The important information of the oil driller had added a mighty element
to the matters with which he was evidently concerned. The horse, left to
his own inclinations, quickened his pace and presently the shadow of a
huge house loomed upon the crest of the hill at the roadside. The horse
stopped at the gate, and the man. aroused from his reverie, dismounted
slowly, and opening the gate led the horse through; as he closed the
gate he stopped for a moment and rested his enormous elbow on the
latch. “Well,” he said, as though announcing his temporary conclusion to
himself, “I'll ship the cattle to-morrow, and I'll see Jerry.”




II

FROM the earliest record of events, either sacred or profane, the genus
Bos has been associated with the history of the landowner. The Ancient
Egyptian saw in him certain traces of divinity, and honored it with
proper recognition. The lamented Job, erstwhile poet of calamity,
found time amid the recording of his numerous disasters to set down
his venerable appreciation of the species; and the pagan Homer, while
singing of gods and men, remembered to sing also the virtues of the
noble bullock; and the painters, too, from Claude Lorraine to Rosa
Bonheur, have deigned to consider the artistic importance of the
domesticated kine; treating him first as a necessary adjunct to a
landscape, and later as a central figure in the scene. He has had his
part, say the records, not infrequently with the plans of men, virtuous
and otherwise. A certain wily barbaric general used him well in a
difficult emergency, and the patriarch Jacob used him in a shrewd
physiological experiment, which he had probably learned at Padan-aram
in his salad days; an experiment that added much to the worldly worth of
the good father, but detracted not a little from his fame.

When the sun climbed up from behind the broad eastern hillside on the
following morning it looked down upon Rufus Alshire, who, far more
expeditious than itself, had already set himself to the affairs of the
day; before the dawn he had brought the cattle from their beds in the
cool pasture land, weighed them at his scales and turned them out in the
road on their journey to the shipping station some ten miles away. The
herd strayed leisurely along the highway. The giant Alshire rode through
the drove, keeping the bullocks moving slowly; while following the herd
barefoot in the dust, was one of his retainers, a half-witted youth,
wearing an ancient straw hat, a shirt originally of the material called
“hickory,” but now patched in variegated colors, and blue cloth trousers
well worn and frayed. As the youth tramped along he sang in a high
piping voice one of those simple little songs which the playing children
sing, and by way of illustration danced up and down and whipped the dust
with a long hickory switch. On his heart was no shadow of the cares of
men, and for this reason, perhaps, under his torn shirt was two-thirds
of the happiness of the world.

As the herd wandered along under the great oaks that lined the roadway
and the rays of the morning sun crept down through the green leaves,
making queer mottled spots on the sleek cattle and brilliant shifting
patches on the dewy grass, one looking on could easily have come to
believe that the world had turned back some several hundred years, and
this was a grassy forest glade of merry England, and the herd, cattle
of the gruff, gigantic Saxon who rode among them on his huge red horse,
scowling under his black brows and cursing by St. Withold and St.
Dunstan and the soul of Hengist the evil times of the Conqueror that
forced him to drive his herd into the thick forest at daybreak in order
to preserve it from the marauding cut-throats of a Norman baron; and
he would have looked close for great stones half-bedded in the moss,
lasting monuments to the weird and bloody rites of some stern Druid
colony long dead; and then glanced up sharply to see if that patch
of thicker green in the deeper woods were not indeed the coat of some
gallant outlaw whose bosom was English, and who stood ready with his
yew bow and his cloth-yard shaft to join the huge Saxon in his stubborn
fight against the bloody followers of Duke William of Normandy; and when
the herd had wandered by one would have leaned over in the road to see
if there was not a brass collar soldered fast around the neck of the
happy cowherd, graven in Saxon letters with this inscription: “Zaak, the
son of Jonas, is thrall to Rufus of Alshire.”

The cheery sunshine under the dear arch of blue, with its homely noises
of awakening life and its cool breath, ladened with the fresh odor
wafted from meadows of clover springing up with sweet new blossom after
the harvest, all so conducive to careless, joyous existence, failed
utterly to remove any portion of the anxiety from the face of the
grazier.

He sat listlessly in his saddle, with his gray eyes half-closed and the
muscles of his face drawn down in furrows; the red roan, trained from
his colt days, assumed the duties of his master, and moved carefully
among the cattle; his equine intelligence appreciating that it was a
part of his duty to the indolent master, to see that the drove kept
moving slowly, and that no bullock stopped to crop the wet grass by the
roadside, or fight with his fellow.

The watches of the night had brought to Rufus Alshire no solution of the
matter with which he had struggled so persistently during the evening
before. He was acting, it was true, upon his temporary plan, but that
seemed but an incident in the main vexatious problem.

The giant was now entirely oblivious of his environment, and deep in his
troublous matter he spoke aloud. “If I could only hold the title,” he
muttered, and then, as if realizing the folly of his hope, he gripped
the tree of his saddle with his hand and straightened his mighty foot
suddenly in the stirrup. The leather snapped under the great weight, and
the iron stirrup dropped into the road. The red roan stopped short, and
the huge Alshire, pronouncing some severe malediction on his ponderous
size, dismounted, picked up the stirrup and tied it to the strap. Then
he slipped the bridle rein over his aim and, walking along beside the
horse, began to examine the herd with the critical eye of an expert, and
comment thereon with the artlessness of a child.

“Beef for the British.” he said, “and as good beef as John Bull ever put
under his ribs. They are broad on the backs and deep in the brisket and
heavy in the quarters, and every black calf of them made the beam kick
sixteen hundred pounds.”

The grazier slapped his horse fondly on the neck. “They 'll please the
Jews, won't they, boy?” The red roan pricked up his ears and rubbed his
nose against his master's arm, as though this statement was quite in
accord with his own private views of the matter. “They will ship well
over the sea.” The giant laughed. “And by gad! if the rotten ships hold
together the black brutes will get a blamed sight nearer to the Queen
than most of the little snobs ambling around in the East.”

The herd of Rufus Alshire belonged to that species of beef cattle
termed Polled-Angus, native to the lowlands of Scotland; a breed of
comparatively recent importation. They were fine bullocks, full, round,
and comely in form; hornless, trim of head and neck, and with coats as
black as the fabled spirit of midnight. The law of natural selection had
finally indicated this breed as best adapted to the conditions of the
West Virginia grazier. It was hardy, easily maintained, and endured the
rigor of the winter without distress, beside it was quick to mature and
gained flesh rapidly, and then, too, the absence of horns rendered it
easier to handle and far less dangerous.

The horn, a necessary and powerful weapon in the wild state, was in the
state of domestication a useless incumbrance Hence nature, laboring for
the convenience of men, thrust in and produced the Polled-Angus.

The business of the grazier had been progressive. The powerful
landowner, who in the autumn purchased his cattle from the stockmen of
the interior counties, had ever encouraged the cultivation of the breed.
For many years the short horn Durham had been the great cattle of this
inland country. It was an old race; old in England when the Scandinavian
and the Dane swarmed over the river Tees. But the breed, though
excellent, was rather slow to mature and not adapted to severe winters,
and the breeder awakened to the needs of his market and casting about
for an animal better adapted to his uses chanced upon the Hereford,
first imported by the elder Clay of Kentucky. And the Hereford became
the chief bovine of the grazier. He was old, too; old on the north side
of the river Wye in the tenth century, and ancient of record, it is
said, in the law of Howell the Good; but while a fine beef animal, he
preserved one defect, the massive horn. Still he maintained his place,
until on a certain autumn morning at a fat cattle show in Chicago,
the good wife of a powerful Virginia grazier, on a quest for the ideal
bullock, pointed down into the stock ring at the splendid Polled-Angus
and said, “There he is, but he don't look human.” And there he was
indeed, broad, and shiny black, and hornless as a man's palm--nature's
answer to the breeder's dream.

The great tawny sun climbed high in the heavens; the heat of the day
settled down over the living earth like an invisible mantle; the crisp
freshness of the morning breeze had given place to the monotonous hot
air of midday. The dust arose in clouds from under the feet of the herd,
and the cattle themselves, warm and vexed with the irksome travel, were
restless and difficult to control. The great Al-shire and his huge horse
moved here and there through the drove, white with dust; while the happy
thrall plodded along behind the herd, whistling merrily and turning from
time to time to strike some lagging bullock, and shout with childish
glee “Go along you fat feller; to-night you will ride on the steam-cars,
and to-morrow the British will eat you.” And passing a slight inaccuracy
in the matter of time, the witless Zaak was entirely correct. To him
the steam-cars were marvels from wonderland, and the British was some
far-away gigantic monster with a mighty, insatiate maw.




III

THE young man closed the door to the private writing-room of the club,
and coming back to the table drew a chair up beside his companion and
sat down.

“Rufus,” he said, “how did you get in so deep?”

“Well,” responded the grazier, looking down at the floor. “I am an ass,
Jerry, just a natural ass. I was all right, doing well and living like
a lord, until I endorsed for that lumber company. When it grew shaky,
I tried to save myself by borrowing money and holding it up until the
panic was over, but I could n't do it, and when the thing failed I had
the notes to meet. I did n't want to be sued, so I borrowed the money.
It was a big sum, almost as big as I was worth, but I thought that the
men from whom I borrowed the money would not push me, and that probably
I could pull through some way. I might have known that the crash would
come, but it is natural, I judge, to postpone the evil day.”

“Have your creditors instituted legal proceedings?” asked the young man.

“Not yet,” replied Alshire. “On Thursday I was at the county seat
looking after my taxes, and while there William Farras, who is a local
manager for the oil company, took me aside and said that through some
business transactions my notes had come into his hands, and added that
he hoped that I was in a position to pay them, as he was hard up and
would require a considerable sum of money at once. On the way home in
the evening I had the conversation with the driller of which I have
spoken; and his statement made the scheme as plain as day light. The
company believes that the pool is under my land, and, wishing to secure
the property, it has bought up my outstanding notes. The plan is to sue
me at once, sell the land, and buy it in.”

The giant spoke slowly, the great muscles of his face set, and his eyes
hard. He raised his ponderous clenched hand and brought it slowly down
on his knee. “I shipped the cattle,” he added, “to prevent their being
attached, and I have gone over the whole thing from end to end, and by
every devil in hell I don't see any way to stop their game.”

Jerry Van Meter arose and went over to the window. He was mightily
affected by the hopeless position of his friend, and in his breast his
heart was heavy. The condition of things was reversed. From his very
babyhood he had gone to the giant with his troubles, and the giant
had always found some way out. Now the man had come to him, and he was
helpless. He looked at the huge grazier sitting motionless with his face
in his hands, and the tears gathered in his eyes. Van Meter knew too
much of the world not to know that the man was ruined. Finally he turned
to his companion.

“Rufus,” he said, “we will walk down to my office and see what can be
done.”

It was merely a weakling move for delay. In his heart the young man knew
that the matter was hopeless.

The two men arose and passed out of the club.

The life of Jerry Van Meter had been crowded with events quite as varied
and rapid of incident as that of Sinbad the Sailor. His parents, who
resided on a small farm near Rufus Alshire's estate, had died when the
child Jerry was quite an infant, and the huge grazier had assumed
the guardianship of the youth. Under his direction the boy had been
educated, and finally installed as a bank clerk in one of the small
towns. But the spirit of adventure was big in the breast of the youthful
Jerry, and one morning he closed the ledger carefully and vanished into
the Northwest. Here he pulled teeth for an itinerant dentist, drummed
for a soap house, and travelled with a circus. But he had a fortunate
star, not at all times obscured; and when the boom struck St. Paul,
Jerry drifted in, bought far and wide, and carried out with him ten
thousand dollars in gold, which he promptly dropped in a bucket-shop
in Chicago. A letter to the good genius Alshire brought a check for one
hundred dollars and nine pages of advice.

With this money in his pocket, Jerry passed over on to the Pacific
coast. Here he mixed drinks in a bar-room, and officiated in the
important capacity of night clerk to a restaurant, until his star came
up again, and when it did, Jerry chanced on an abandoned claim that
netted him seven thousand dollars. He returned to Alshire the one
hundred dollars and the well-worn but badly-heeded letter of advice,
and set out for the East. In St. Louis he became deeply interested
in certain horse races, and ten days later he landed in the Virginias
bronzed, bearded, and broke. The giant Alshire laughed at the escapades
of this youth until his sides ached, gave him another check and the
ancient letter of advice with various amendments, and the restless Mr.
Van Meter dropped down into the metropolis of New York. Here his star
gave evidences of constancy, and he became an insurance broker and a man
of affairs.

The two men walked slowly down the steps of the club and across the busy
thoroughfare. As they stepped up or the opposite curb they were startled
by a sharp cry, and turning suddenly they saw a little man stumble and
fall forward in the street directly in front of an approaching mail
wagon. The great horses were almost upon him, bearing down in a long
sweeping trot. The driver at the moment was not looking, but it was too
late for him to prevent the impending accident even if he had been. The
giant Alshire ran out into the street, caught the horses and threw his
ponderous weight against the iron bits. The heavy Percherons reared
and fell back on their haunches, the tongue of the wagon shot forward,
grazing the giant's shoulder, and the wheels stopped for a moment almost
against the body of the prostrate man. In that moment Van Meter dragged
the hapless pedestrian from beneath the belly of the horses. The giant
stepped quickly aside, and the horses, plunging forward heavily on the
cobble stones, passed on down the street, while the half-dazed driver
did not even look back to ascertain what had really occurred.

The little man wiped the dust from his hat with the sleeve of his coat
and looked up at his deliverers.

“Well,” he said, “Randolph Mason came near to losing his clerk. I guess
I stumbled on that infernal rail.”

A great light came into the face of Jerry Van Meter. He came up close
to the little man and caught him by the shoulder. “Randolph Mason!” he
said, “Is Randolph Mason in New York?”

“Yes,” responded the little man. “I am his clerk. Parks is my name. Mr.
Mason is here, but----” Then he stopped short.

The now excited Van Meter shook the little man almost roughly by the
shoulder.

“Good,” he cried, “good, we must see him at once.”

The clerk Parks looked down at his soiled clothes and the dust on his
bruised hands.

“Gentlemen,” he said slowly, “it is against the strict order of the
physicians, but, under the circumstances, I don't quite see how I am
going to refuse.”




IV

RANDOLPH MASON leaned forward and struck his hand heavily on the arm of
his chair.

“Forty thousand,” he said sharply, “you owe that sum, sir?” His face
looked old, sunken, and furrowed with heavy dark lines, but his eyes
shone under his shaggy brows.

“Yes,” responded the grazier, “fully that much.”

“To secure that amount in cash,” continued Mason, “it will be necessary
to deal with some bank or savings institution of which the president
or some powerful director is an attorney-at-law. This condition will be
found to obtain in almost any one of the small towns of the country, and
if my directions are followed strictly, the plan can be carried out and
the money secured in a very few hours. The plan is simple and easy. In
the first place----”

“But,” said the giant Alshire, “I don't want other men's money. I don't
want to commit a crime.”

The veins in the forehead of Randolph Mason grew black with anger.

“Commit a crime!” he cried. “No man who has followed my advice has ever
committed a crime. Crime is a technical word. It is the law's name for
certain acts which it is pleased to define and punish with a penalty.
None but fools, dolts, and children commit crimes.”

“Well,” responded the grazier, “whether the plan you are about to
propose is a crime or not, it is certainly a moral wrong, and I have no
desire to rob a bank by committing even a moral wrong.”

Randolph Mason arose slowly and pointed his finger at the huge Alshire.

“The old story,” he sneered, “child afraid of a goblin. Moral wrong! A
name used to frighten fools. There is no such thing. The law lays down
the only standard by which the acts of the citizen are to be governed.
What the law permits is right, else it would prohibit it. What the law
prohibits is wrong, because it punishes it. This is the only lawful
measure, the only measure bearing the stamp and the sanction of the
State. All others are spurious, counterfeit, and void. The word moral is
a pure metaphysical symbol, possessing no more intrinsic virtue than the
radical sign.”

“I beg your pardon, Mr. Mason,” said Van Meter thrusting into the
conversation, “but I am quite certain that you mistake the request of
my friend. He is not attempting to secure any sum of money. He simply
desires to retain the title to his land and prevent its sale, until he
can determine the extent of its oil production.”

“For what length of time?” asked Mason.

“Well,” said the grazier, “I scarcely know. One year might be time
enough, or even less than one year; while, on the other hand, it might
require several years. You see, if I can prevent the land from being
sold, and keep it in my name until the territory is developed, then if
oil is found in paying quantities I can meet all these notes, and if
the land is dry I am no worse off. At any rate, I want to hold on to the
land and see.”

“Are there judgments of record against you?” inquired Mason.

“Not yet,” replied Alshire, “but Farras is preparing to sue on the notes
and rush the sale through. Can I stop him; can I hold the sale off?”
 There was anxiety in the grazier's voice.

Randolph Mason began to walk to and fro across the room with an unsteady
nervous stride.

“Easy,” he muttered, “easy as learning to lie.” Then he stopped by the
table and looked flown sharply at the great Alshire.

“Have you two friends,” he asked, “nonresidents of your State, whom you
can trust?”

“Yes,” responded the grazier, “Mr. Van Meter here in New York, and
Morgan Gaston now in Ohio, they will both stand by me.”

“Then,” said Mason, “listen to me, and do as I advise, and the sale of
your property will be as far distant years from to-day as it seems this
afternoon. First make an oil lease for a long term, say thirty years,
to your non-resident friend of Ohio, giving him all the oil privileges,
but, for your own protection in case of the death of the lessee,
incorporate in the instrument a clause permitting the lessor the right
to annul the lease at any time by the payment of a small sum. Have the
instrument show also that the entire compensation for the lease has
been fully paid in advance. Then make another lease renting all your
remaining property rights to your friend Mr. Van Meter of this city.
Have this second lease for a similar term and of similar provisions to
the first, and the entire compensation for it likewise paid in advance.
Then you have but to record the instruments, employ an attorney, and
sit down in the shadow of your house. The hair on your head will have
thinned vastly before the litigation over your complicated affairs
terminates in a final decree of sale.” Rufus Alshire leaned forward
listening eagerly. “But won't Farras sue me,” he asked, “won't he attack
the leases?”

“Certainly,” said Mason, “he will at once do one of two things; either
he will bring an action at law on the notes, or he will attempt to
embrace the whole matter in a chancery suit. If he sues at law, resist
and attempt to fight through the superior courts. When he finally
obtains a judgment at law in your State, he will be compelled to resort
to a suit in chancery for the purpose of selling the land. In either
event he must come finally into a court of chancery and include the
holders of these leases as parties defendant to his action. When this is
done, the non resident lessees are not to appear, and he will be able to
obtain service on them only by an order of publication. You alone will
fight this chancery suit through the lower and superior courts, and just
before a sale of the land is ordered by the court of last resort, one
of the non resident lessees mast appear, and by virtue of the statutory
provision applying to such cases, file his bill of review and open up
the whole matter, enjoin the sale, fight the case over again and again
through the superior court. When this new litigation finally draws
near to a close and the land is again ordered sold, the remaining
non-resident must appear, bring his action in the Circuit Court of the
United States, enjoin the sale, and proceed with his fight.

“By this time,” continued Mason, placing his bony hand on the giant's
shoulder, “there will probably be gray streaks in your beard, and if
you wish to run this litigation on into eternity, you will have only to
produce some collateral heir.”

The huge Alshire looked up at the strange man beside him. “Is all this
possible?” he asked in astonishment.

Randolph Mason did not at once answer; he walked stumblingly across
the room to his chair and sat down by the table. His form was thin and
gaunt, and along the border of his forehead the veins were purple and
swollen. After a time he turned toward the powerful grazier, his face
ugly with a sneer. “To the law,” he said, “all things are possible--even
justice.”




V

ONE morning in the early winter the red roan horse, with his head over
the high fence of his pasture, saw two men standing in the neighboring
meadow contemplating in silence a gigantic derrick. One he immediately
recognized as his master Rufus Alshire, and the other resembled in a
very large degree a certain obnoxious person who on a memorable summer
night had smeared his well kept mane with most disagreeable petroleum.

Presently the grazier spoke. “I judge that it will not now be necessary
for Jerry to invoke the tedium of Federal tribunals, there seems to be
grease enough here to pay everything and wind up the lawsuits.”

The driller looked up at the oil streaming down from the timbers of the
derrick; then he made a mighty angular gesture with his bare right arm.

“By jolly!” he said, “there is money enough in that hole to pay off the
national debt.”




THE RULE AGAINST CARPER




I

CARPER did not recall that he had ever noticed the ugly details of the
courtroom before,--the high, soiled ceiling, the rows of benches, worn,
broken, empty as a fool's heart, the clerk's desk, and the presumptuous
bench of the judge; the long tables, too, for the attorneys, heaped with
papers, books, and dusty covers, a farrago of disorder--how ugly they
were!

Carper looked up at the judge. The man's black silk robe fell away in
sharp straight folds; he sat erect like a bronze cast, his face turned
half toward the window in order that he might better read the paper
before him. How power had changed this face! Carper remembered idly
that, years before, the face of this man had been sweet, tender, lit
with kindness. Now it was as hard as white ivory.

The attorneys at the table were talking in subdued whispers; Carper did
not hear; he was wondering vaguely if the long slim fingers of the judge
ever ached as his head was aching. The conjecture was unique.

It was difficult for Carper to realize his position. His clothing was
certainly better than that of any other man in the court-room, He was
quite certain that his face was the same powerful, clean-cut, immobile
mask that it had been always. The world did not know, it did not even
suspect. If one had asked the clerk yonder for a financial rating on
Russell Carper, the clerk would have shrugged his shoulder and written
six figures on the margin of his record.. Yet this was the end,--the
end.

Over by the window stood a prisoner in the custody of the marshal.
The man was poor, miserably poor; his clothes were clean, threadbare,
ancient as the law. Carper knew the story. The man was a little
shopkeeper; his wife was ill,--dying, the deputy said. There were
children, too, hungry, naked, absurdly miserable, and the crime,--some
petty revenue infraction. He would be presently required to pay his
fine, and, failing that, would be locked up in a cell. It was the law,
heartless as an image. Yet Carper wondered listlessly if one from beyond
the world's rim on the quest of the good would not take this man, and
leave the others, leave all the others--the judge with his blue-veined
patriciate face, the clerks with their lank jaws, the attorneys, with
their expression of abominable indifference, and himself. Well, the
machinery of human justice was awry. Then he wondered at the condition
that bred this surmise. How was it possible to reflect so indolently
upon the condition of another when his own was perilous. Still, such
speculations obtained with men, it is said, in great crises, and at the
grave's edge.

Presently the judge laid down his papers and began to speak. Carper
heard him as one speaking a long distance away. At first the words
seemed indistinct and without meaning; then he caught them full, as one
waking suddenly catches and understands the conversation of his fellow.

“Our commissioner's report,” the judge was saying, “shows that this
receiver has now in his custody three hundred and seventeen thousand
dollars belonging to the stockholders of the Massachusetts Iron Company.
At a former term of this court an order was entered directing the
receiver to distribute this fund in accordance with a previous decree.
At that term this order was resisted upon the ground that the decree
was not sufficiently explicit; which objection the court, upon
consideration, overruled. Later, the payment was sought to be held back
upon the ground that this order was improvidently awarded, and a motion
made to revoke, which was also overruled. And still later innumerable
technical objections have been offered by the attorney for the receiver,
all of which this court considers insufficient and trivial.”

At this point one of the attorneys for Carper arose. “If your honor
please,” he said, “we ask to be heard in defense of our client. We think
that it can yet be shown that this order should not be enforced.” Then
he sat down.

The blue veins in the face of the jurist grew darker. “Gentlemen,” he
continued, “cannot now be heard. The time of this court has already been
much consumed by unprofitable argument. On yesterday the stockholders
of the Massachusetts Iron Company applied for a rule, requiring Russell
Carper, receiver, to appear and make answer, if any he has, why he
should not be attached and punished for contempt in disobeying the
orders of this court. The rule I have ordered to issue returnable
tomorrow morning at ten o'clock.”

The judge handed the paper down to the clerk, and directed the next case
to be called. Then he leaned back in his chair with the huge unconcern
of one well removed from the grip of his fellows.

It was the end. But to Carper it was all as unreal as the yesterday. He
seemed to be out of the scene, and, for that, out of himself, an idle
spectator. His attorneys were whispering gravely. They were telling him
that the game was now played out. There was nothing more to do. He must
direct his banker to pay over the money. Even these hired fighters
did not suspect; they presumed the delay was favorable to some deal in
stocks. The truth--only he, Carper, knew the truth. There was grim humor
in the huge deception.

On the way out of the court-room Carper stopped and handed the clerk the
only bill in his pockets. It would pay the fine of the shopkeeper. The
whole thing was an immensely clever little comedy, and he wanted to see
the sunshine come back into the shopkeeper's face.

CARPER had been given the long afternoon to arrange some scheme, to
plan some way out, but he allowed it to slip by like any leisure day.
His mind was indolent, absurdly indolent. In all the other crises of his
life, it had been restless as a blown wave. This day it was sluggish.
Realizing the end, it had folded its arms. It was difficult to
appreciate that his career was ripped off like a rotten seam. That
afternoon his broker had talked confidentially of a certain railroad
venture. Men from the West had begged the use of his name in the
organization of a trust embracing the copper mines of a State. He had
been asked to contribute to a great charity. This night, the last night,
in his library there was yet no sign of that ruin which sat by the
hearthstone. The fire was warm; the surroundings wore luxurious; the
shelves were filled with books; from the walls the stern faces of his
forbears looked down, haughty, relentless as their lives had shown.
It was difficult to realize that he was an embezzler and a bankrupt,
suspended above a vacuous abyss by a line that the to-morrow would cut
short.

For five years he had been the receiver of the Massachusetts Iron
Company. In those five years he had bought and sold on the street with
the abandon of a master. He had used the funds of this company as a
workman would use a tool left lying in his shop. He had won great sums,
and he had lost until the very earth seemed slipping away beneath him.

Then the slump in the stocks of a great railroad system caught him, and
he had put in every dollar of this trust fund and watched it vanish like
a vapor. Still, no one knew. Carper's reputation stood on the street
flawless, perfect in outline, an empty shell--but no one knew.

When the stockholders of the Massachusetts Iron Company finally demanded
a reorganization, he had employed the best legal talent and thrust in
every delay of the law. The fight had gone on year after year, from
court to court. Orders had been entered and dissolved; decrees had been
made and reversed; hearings had been granted by superior courts, and
rehearings, but the end, long delayed, came finally.

The stockholders had applied for a rule. It was the most summary
proceeding known to the law. To-morrow he must pay the money, or go to
prison a felon. The end loomed like the ragged outlines of a cliff.

To Carper this end seemed atrociously unjust. He had worked so hard, so
hard: the best that was in him; the good days of his life had been given
up to this labor It had been his boyhood dream to be a factor in great
affairs,--the bitter labor of his youth, and, in part, the realization
of his middle life. He had cut every other thing away with a hand that
never once had trembled. It was his right to win, if there was any
justice anywhere. But to-morrow was the end. To-morrow the court would
strip him naked as a bone.

He had heard many a sleek pastor discourse glibly upon the eternal
justice of Providence. Then he believed it cant with a smattering of
truth. Now it was entirely clear that it was cant--but false; a pleasant
lie like the housewife tale of fairies.

Carper took the cigar from between his teeth and dropped it on the
hearth. The game of life was an ugly game. He confessed that he had lost
interest in its play. Now that the thought suggested he saw that he had
been losing interest all along. It was inertia he had been fighting--the
plague of inertia, and for no gain at all. It was a world where, if one
sat still, one wasted with monotony; and if one labored, it was only for
the purpose of building ships to fly in the air, which, when they were
all completed, sat stupidly on the earth or by hap toppled heavily upon
the builder, crushing out his heart. He could not understand why men had
sometimes said that life was good.

Carper had looked, he believed, into not a few chambers of the temple.
The same hooded shape sat in each. If fame was given, the skull was
pretty generally crushed with the crown. If wealth was given, the back
was broken with the weight. If love was given,--yes, the heart was
usually broken with it,--love!

Carper arose and went over to a cabinet in the wall, unlocked the door
and took out a big photograph, which he brought over to the fire. It was
the picture of a woman, young, beautiful, quivering with the power of
life; the mass of dark hair was caught back from her forehead; the eyes
were wide, clear, transparent; the nose was straight as the edges of a
die, and the throat round, full, marvellously moulded. In the set of the
head there was pride of lineage, and the relentless rigor of purity.
It was a fine face looking out from a blameless life, strong, innocent,
exacting as a child.

The man placed the picture on the mantelshelf, and sat down by the
fire. That day was now seven years gone,--seven years! Yesterday was no
farther back. Every detail was clear. The shock had stamped them on the
lining of his heart. He had loved this woman as a man loves just one
time. He was trusting his very life to her keeping; he was going to her
for everything that woman could give; all of sweet fellowship, all of
tender sympathy, all of love. She was the only woman in the world. The
expression is a platitude, but the fact was as real to Carper as the
green trees and the sunlight. One could no more have convinced this man
that other women held some of the charms of life, than one could have
convinced him that light was a liquid. His love had gained the power of
a religion; it had gone, farther---it had gained the majesty of a law.

Then the blow came. Carper had gone to this woman with a case of jewels,
the profit of a venture. He remembered how happy she had been: how the
light of trustfulness danced in her eyes; how she had carried the jewels
to the window in order to see the great rubies change to blood-drops,
then she had turned with a playful smile and asked him how he had made
so great a sum, and he, like a miserable fool, had blurted out that it
was a part of his gains in a deal on the street,--a deal in which he
had ruined a little banking house by seizing the vantage of its ignorant
mistake. It was the master blunder.

Carper remembered how the blood faded from this woman's face, leaving it
ashen gray; how the dull ache of pain gathered in her eyes; how she had
come over to him and dropped the jewels slowly into their case, and,
without a word, had gone back and sat down by the window. And he knew
that the woman of his love was gone out beyond the reach of his fingers.
The leash of his love had slipped off and snapped back in his hands.

He remembered the effect upon himself as something entirely foreign to
that which writers attribute to men under similar conditions. There
was no benumbing horror; no desire to make any violent demonstration of
feeling. There was merely a vague loss of strength, as though the
bottom of the fountain of vital force had dropped out, and then he grew
sick--physically sick. The material man was hurt first, and collapsed,
much as it would have done if shot through the stomach with a shell. He
felt none of that exaggerated emotion affected by the play-actor.

It was the commonplace sickness of a frightful physical blow.

When the nausea had passed, he had gone over to her and begged to know
what it all meant, although he knew quite as well as she. The woman had
looked at him with her wide eyes deadened with pain, and said that she
had believed him ah honorable man, and had loved him for it, but that
now she knew the truth, and she would never be wife to a dishonest man.

He had made his argument then, and it was good. The venture was
perfectly legitimate, so recognized and treated by the business men
of the land,--nay, more, it was so regarded by the law. These were the
standards; there was no other. The customs of business and the law were
the rules of right in the marketplaces. Their wisdom was unquestioned.
It was the result of all the experience of the race, the conclusion of
wise men, laboring with conditions as they were. Had she a right to say
that these standards were wrong? He appealed to her sense of fairness.
Was she better able to pass upon the right of this transaction than all
the merchants learned in the customs of trade,--than all the jurists
learned in the wisdom of the law? Was she better able?

Carper pointed out that she lived in an atmosphere of purity high above
the din of the fight for life; a land of refined right, refined justice,
refined honor, magnificent, but not the world. The world had no perfect
code; it was no perfect place; it was not intended to be so, else it
would have been so made. It was an indifferent place, governed by the
inexorable law of the survival of the fittest, wherein men struggled for
footing and the comforts of life. One must conform to conditions as they
were, or go to the wall. It was folly, it was idiocy, it was madness to
do otherwise.

Trade was like nature--pitiless. There was no measure of consideration
for the weakling or the fool. The fight was bitter, remorseless, subject
to dangerous shifts. If one was caught and broken, the blame was with
the sorry scheme of things, and this a Divine Intelligence maintained,
and men could not question that Divine Intelligence. This condition of
the world might not be purest or happiest, but it was the condition of
the world. It was God's way. Was it wise to call it evil?

Then he shifted. He bade her remember that she had promised to go
through life with him. It was a contract she had no right to break.
The position she was taking was a frightful contradiction. She was
reprehending the customs of trade, and yet there was not a merchant in
the market-place who would repudiate his contract. She was charging the
law with failure to appreciate the highest shades of right, and yet
she was about to do what the law, even in its grossness, recognized and
punished as a wrong. She could not stand upon this ground, and do as
she was doing. Even if he had done wrong, was she to punish him by doing
wrong also? The vice of her position cried out. Her promise had
been given. It was immutable. It was her affair to know her mind, to
determine what she wanted to do. She had known him for years. In those
years there had been ample time to investigate, to conclude, to decide.
No one had abridged the freedom of her agency. She had finally become
a party to this contract. Could she repudiate it now, like the common
rogue in whom principle was wanting?

He bade her remember the gravity of this contract. It involved her life,
his life, mayhap the lives of others. He had been shaping everything to
this end. Had she the right to ruthlessly destroy all? What would she
think of one who having contracted to accompany another into an unknown
land should suddenly abandon him on the purlieus of the country? What
would she think of one who had contracted to go with another into
an unknown sea, and should, when that other had made his ship ready,
abandon him at the water's edge? Was she doing better than these?

The woman had not answered at all; dark circles had gathered around her
eyes, and the full muscles of her throat relaxed and sank.

Then Carper remembered how he had knelt down beside her and taken her
hand in his own,---her hand, limp, cold, a dead thing.

Besides, he had gone on, he loved her; she was the only woman in his
heart. There could never be another. Day and night, and every day and
night, his heart cried for her like a tortured child! There was nothing
else in all the wide world to live for, to strive for. He had grown to
associate her with every hope, every emotion, every ambition, of his
life. How should he live on without her! What should he do with his
empty days! Pride might carry him crippled through a few, but, there was
a limit to the endurance of a man, and what then--what of his empty days
then?

If he had been doing wrong, God could find some way to punish him
outside of her love. Besides, if he was doing wrong, he needed her the
more. He needed her to round out his life, to add honor and purity and
right. God had sent her to do this work of good. Was she going to refuse
merely because the world was not the sort of place which she believed it
to be? Master of Life! the world would be abominably empty without her.
He would go anywhere she wished; do anything, be anything, she wished.
It was not the applause of men that he wanted in this life, nor the
multitude of things. It was her hand on his own; her voice in his ears;
her image in his heart forever. He could never get back again to his
view-point.

She had loosed the mouth of something in his bosom that clamored for
her. It would be content with no other. It would hush for no other. His
heart was aching now with the cry. What a place of torture it would be
tomorrow, and the next year, and the next.

The tears had rained down this woman's face, but she had shaken her
head.

That day was now seven years gone--seven years! Yesterday was no farther
back. Well, well! He had been only partly right. The woman's face in his
heart he had walled up. The cry for her he had silenced with the opiates
of greed. Still they were both there and alive. To-night the wall had
slipped away and the anaesthetics were powerless. It was no matter.
After all, had she done well? She had lived on, spotless, pure, alone;
and he had lived on--to this. Had she done well? That question it was no
right of his to answer.

Carper got up from his chair, took the picture from the mantel, broke
it across the face and dropped the pieces into the fire. It was not
necessary for the marshal's deputy to speculate about this picture.

Then he went over to the cabinet and took out a pack of letters, old,
yellow, tied with a faded ribbon, and, selecting one at random, sat down
in his chair to read it through. “Dear Heart,” it ran at the beginning,
and at the end “I am unutterably lonely, and I love you.” Yes, he
recalled the circumstances of its writing well. Then he replaced it
with the others and laid them all gently on the fire. They should not be
pleasant reading for the marshal.

He had come down into the world, with his heart shredded and every shred
aching like a nerve, and from that day he had flown the black flag of
piracy. Among all the buccaneers of the street, the hand of none had
been heavier, and the brain of none had been keener than his own. From
that day every man who had passed up a prisoner on to the deck of his
galleon, had walked the plank. The muscles of his face grew tense with
the thought.

Somewhere in the house a clock struck ten. Carper arose and walked
backward and forward across the room. The spirit of fierce resistance
was beginning to awaken. He would not be stripped like a weakling. He
would fight, fight--but how? It was hopeless to dream of raising the
money. That plan had been discarded long ago. Vain vaporing! There was
no way remaining but Brutus's way--the road out into the vastness of
eternity was open! The exit was easy. Why should he lag back? Surely he
must go later on. For years the world had been a good place to get out
of--for seven years.

The man opened a drawer at the bottom of the book-case and took out a
weapon--an ancient duelling pistol of his grandfather. He carried the
weapon to the table, wiped it carefully, and began to load it. When he
had finished, he went over to close the door. On the threshold lay one
of the evening papers of the city. Carper picked it up and brought it
with him to the light. The headlines caught his attention. It was the
story of a great bank defaulter who had gone free by reason of some
defect in the law shrewdly pointed out by a lawyer, Randolph Mason.

He remembered the man as a remarkable legal misanthrope. He had heard of
him in the Federal courts. Somewhere he had this man's address, jotted
down one morning when the administrator of an estate walked out of the
Federal court a confessed gigantic thief, but, by this man's counsel,
beyond the reach of the law.

Carper looked through one of the files on his table--yes, here was
the residence number. The man leaned over and rested his arm on the
mantel-shelf. One might not do ill to go; there was time ample. One
could come back to the thing of steel later on.

Carper turned suddenly, put on his coat and hat, and passed out into the
street, closing the door and locking it carefully behind him. Then he
called a cab, gave the number to the driver, and leaned back heavily
against the cushion.




II


THIS is the place, sir,” said the cabman.

Before him was lighted. The door was standing open. The brougham of a
surgeon was beside the curb. He walked slowly up the great steps to the
door. There was an indescribable something in the air which seemed to
presage calamity; there were sounds as of persons hurrying with some
desperate matter.

As Carper put up his hand to touch the bell, two men came out into the
shadow of the hall.

“It is a bad case of acute mania,” one was saying. “I have given him two
hypodermics of morphine, and he is still raving like a drunken sailor.”

Carper's hand dropped to his side. He turned slowly and passed down the
steps into the street. He had not been noticed by the busy surgeons.

Carper stepped out. At the curb he stopped for a moment and looked up
and down the avenue. Well, it was justice. For seven years he had flown
the black flag of piracy. Among all the buccaneers of the street, the
hand of none had been heavier, and the brain of none had been keener
than his own. Every man who had passed up a prisoner on to the deck of
his galleon, had walked the plank. It was now his turn. It was justice.

Carper spoke to the cabman. Then he stepped in and closed the door.

The man of last resort was probably gone. There was now no resort but to
the steel thing on the table.


THE END.









End of Project Gutenberg's The Man of Last Resort, by Melville Davisson Post

*** 