Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

ScrollView component parity for Fabric #11152

Closed
181 of 211 tasks
Tracked by #11135
jonthysell opened this issue Jan 31, 2023 · 2 comments
Closed
181 of 211 tasks
Tracked by #11135

ScrollView component parity for Fabric #11152

jonthysell opened this issue Jan 31, 2023 · 2 comments
Labels
API: Completion Area: Component Views Area: Fabric Support Facebook Fabric Area: ScrollView Deliverable Major item tracked for top-level planning in ADO enhancement New Architecture Broad category for issues that apply to the RN "new" architecture of Turbo Modules + Fabric Parity: Fabric vs. Paper RNW Fabric does not look or behave like RNW Paper
Milestone
Backlog

Comments

@jonthysell
Copy link
Contributor

jonthysell commented Jan 31, 2023 •
edited by TatianaKapos
Loading

This task captures the work to reach parity between Paper and Fabric for the native code for the <ScrollView> component.

ComponentView

  1. Create the ScrollViewComponentView (SVCV)
  2. Register the ComponentView in the ComponentViewRegistry

APIs

See latest spec at https://reactnative.dev/docs/scrollview.

ScrollView Props

39/58

API Platform RNW Paper RNW Fabric Notes
  • StickyHeaderComponent
 JS JS
  • alwaysBounceHorizontal
 iOS No No?
  • alwaysBounceVertical
 iOS No No?
  • automaticallyAdjustContentInsets
 iOS No No?
  • automaticallyAdjustKeyboardInsets
 iOS No No?
  • automaticallyAdjustsScrollIndicatorInsets
 iOS No No?
  • bounces
 iOS No No?
  • bouncesZoom
 iOS No No?
  • canCancelContentTouches
 iOS No No?
  • centerContent
 iOS No No?
  • contentContainerStyle
 See View style See View style Supports View Style Props, Layout Props, Shadow Props
  • contentInset
 iOS No No?
  • contentInsetAdjustmentBehavior
 iOS No No?
  • contentOffset
 No SVCV
  • decelerationRate
 No No?
  • directionalLockEnabled
 iOS No No?
  • disableIntervalMomentum
 No No?
  • disableScrollViewPanResponder
 JS JS
  • endFillColor
 Android No No?
  • fadingEdgeLength
 Android No No?
  • horizontal
 SVM Pri 1
  • indicatorStyle
 iOS No No?
  • invertStickyHeaders
 JS JS
  • keyboardDismissMode
 SVM Pri 1
  • keyboardShouldPersistTaps
 JS JS
  • maintainVisibleContentPosition
 iOS No No?
  • maximumZoomScale
 iOS SVM Pri 1
  • minimumZoomScale
 iOS SVM Pri 1
  • nestedScrollEnabled
 Android No No?
  • onContentSizeChange
 SVM Pri 1
  • onMomentumScrollBegin
 SVM Pri 1 Event is topScrollBeginMomentum, Fabric: Code present but commented out?
  • onMomentumScrollEnd
 SVM Pri 1 Event is topScrollEndMomentum, Fabric: Code present but commented out?
  • onScroll
 SVM SVCV
  • onScrollBeginDrag
 SVM Pri 1 Fabric: Code present but commented out?
  • onScrollEndDrag
 SVM Pri 1 Fabric: Code present but commented out?
  • onScrollToTop
 iOS No No?
  • overScrollMode
 Android No No?
  • pagingEnabled
 SVM Pri 1
  • persistentScrollbar
 Android No No?
  • pinchGestureEnabled
 iOS No No?
  • refreshControl
 No No?
  • removeClippedSubviews
 No No?
  • scrollEnabled
 SVM Pri 1
  • scrollEventThrottle
 iOS No No?
  • scrollIndicatorInsets
 iOS No No?
  • scrollPerfTag
 Android No No?
  • scrollToOverflowEnabled
 iOS No No?
  • scrollsToTop
 iOS No No?
  • showsHorizontalScrollIndicator
 SVM Pri 1
  • showsVerticalScrollIndicator
 SVM Pri 1
  • snapToAlignment
 iOS SVM Pri 1
  • snapToEnd
 SVM Pri 1
  • snapToInterval
 SVM Pri 1
  • snapToOffsets
 SVM Pri 1
  • snapToStart
 SVM Pri 1
  • stickyHeaderHiddenOnScroll
 JS JS Mapped to ScrollViewStickyHeader's hiddenOnScroll
  • stickyHeaderIndices
 JS JS
  • zoomScale
 iOS SVM Pri 1

ScrollView Methods

API Platform RNW Paper RNW Fabric Notes
  • flashScrollIndicators()
 iOS No No?
  • scrollTo()
 SVM SVCV Fabric: #11344
SVM SVCV Fabric: #12190
  • zoomToRect()
 No No?

View Props

51/58

API Platform RNW Paper RNW Fabric Notes
  • accessibilityActions
 FEVM Pri 2
  • accessibilityElementsHidden
 iOS No No?
  • accessibilityHint
 FEVM CBCV+CDAP Fabric: #12036
  • accessibilityIgnoresInvertColors
 iOS No No?
  • accessibilityLabel
 FEVM CBCV+CDAP Fabric: #11674
  • accessibilityLanguage
 iOS No No?
  • accessibilityLiveRegion
 Android FEVM Pri 2
  • accessibilityRole
 FEVM CDAP Fabric: #11412
  • accessibilityState
 FEVM CBCV+CDAP Fabric: Partial impl in #11674
  • accessibilityValue
 FEVM CBCV+CDAP Fabric: #12287
  • accessibilityViewIsModal
 iOS No No?
  • accessible
 CVM+FEVM CBCV+CDAP Fabric: #11719
  • collapsable
 Android No No?
  • focusable
 Android CVM CBCV+CDAP Fabric: #11674
  • hitSlop
 JS JS
  • importantForAccessibility
 Android No No?
  • nativeID
 No No?
  • needsOffscreenAlphaCompositing
 No No?
  • nextFocusDown
 Android No No?
  • nextFocusForward
 Android No No?
  • nextFocusLeft
 Android No No?
  • nextFocusRight
 Android No No?
  • nextFocusUp
 Android No No?
  • onAccessibilityAction
 VMB Pri 2
  • onAccessibilityEscape
 iOS No No?
  • onAccessibilityTap
 No CDAP Fabric: #11874
  • onLayout
 VMB Pri 1
  • onMagicTap
 iOS No No?
  • onMoveShouldSetResponder
 JS JS
  • onMoveShouldSetResponderCapture
 JS JS
  • onResponderGrant
 JS JS
  • onResponderMove
 JS JS
  • onResponderReject
 JS JS
  • onResponderRelease
 JS JS
  • onResponderTerminate
 JS JS
  • onResponderTerminationRequest
 JS JS
  • onStartShouldSetResponder
 JS JS
  • onStartShouldSetResponderCapture
 JS JS
  • pointerEvents
 VMB SVCV
  • removeClippedSubviews
 No No?
  • renderToHardwareTextureAndroid
 Android No No?
  • shouldRasterizeIOS
 iOS No No?
  • style
 See Below See Below Supports View Style Props, Layout Props, Shadow Props
  • testID
 FEVM CDAP Fabric: #11412
  • accessibilityPosInSet
 Windows FEVM Pri 2
  • accessibilitySetSize
 Windows FEVM Pri 2
  • enableFocusRing
 Windows JS CBCV+SVCV Fabric: #11323, Focus ring impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • keyDownEvents
 Windows VMB CBCV Fabric: #12146
  • keyUpEvents
 Windows VMB CBCV Fabric: #12146
  • onBlur
 Windows VMB CBCV Paper: Event is registered, but maybe never fired?, Fabric: #11279
  • onFocus
 Windows VMB CBCV Paper: Event is registered, but maybe never fired?, Fabric: #11279
  • onKeyDown
 Windows VMB CBCV+CEH Fabric: #12146
  • onKeyDownCapture
 Windows VMB Pri 1
  • onKeyUp
 Windows VMB CBCV+CEH Fabric: #12146
  • onKeyUpCapture
 Windows VMB Pri 1
  • onMouseEnter
 Windows VMB CEH
  • onMouseLeave
 Windows VMB CEH
  • tabIndex
 Windows CVM Pri 1
  • tooltip
 Windows FEVM Pri 1

View Style Props

28/29

API Platform RNW Paper RNW Fabric Notes
  • backfaceVisibility
 No CBCV+SVCV Fabric: #12115 Impl in CBCV and CV must call updateTransformProps
  • backgroundColor
 CVM SVCV
  • borderBottomColor
 No CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, Border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderBottomEndRadius
 CVM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, Border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderBottomLeftRadius
 CVM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, Border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderBottomRightRadius
 CVM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, Border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderBottomStartRadius
 CVM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, Border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderBottomWidth
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics, but border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderColor
 CVM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, Border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderEndColor
 No CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, Border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderEndWidth
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics, but border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderLeftColor
 No CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, Border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderLeftWidth
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics, but border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderRadius
 CVM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, Border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderRightColor
 No CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, Border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderRightWidth
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics, but border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderStartColor
 No CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, Border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderStartWidth
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics, but border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
No CBCV Fabric: Border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderTopColor
 No CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, Border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderTopEndRadius
 CVM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, Border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderTopLeftRadius
 CVM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, Border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderTopRightRadius
 CVM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, Border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderTopStartRadius
 CVM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, Border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderTopWidth
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics, but border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderWidth
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics, but border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • elevation
 Android No No?
  • opacity
 FEVM Pri 1
  • transform
 FEVM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: #12115 Impl in CBCV and CV must call updateTransformProps

Layout Props

51/53

API Platform RNW Paper RNW Fabric Notes
  • alignContent
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • alignItems
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • alignSelf
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • aspectRatio
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • borderBottomWidth
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics, but border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderEndWidth
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics, but border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderLeftWidth
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics, but border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderRightWidth
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics, but border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderStartWidth
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics, but border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderTopWidth
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics, but border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • borderWidth
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric:#11323, RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics, but border impl in CBCV and CV must call updateBorderProps / updateBorderLayoutMetrics
  • bottom
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • direction
 FEVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • display
 FEVM+NUIM SVCV
  • end
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • flex
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • flexBasis
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • flexDirection
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • flexGrow
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • flexShrink
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • flexWrap
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • height
 VMB+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • justifyContent
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • left
 VMB+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • margin
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • marginBottom
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • marginEnd
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • marginHorizontal
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • marginLeft
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • marginRight
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • marginStart
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • marginTop
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • marginVertical
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • maxHeight
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • maxWidth
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • minHeight
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • minWidth
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • overflow
 NUIM Pri 1
  • padding
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • paddingBottom
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • paddingEnd
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • paddingHorizontal
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • paddingLeft
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • paddingRight
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • paddingStart
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • paddingTop
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • paddingVertical
 CVM+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • position
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • right
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • start
 NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • top
 VMB+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • width
 VMB+NUIM CBCV+SVCV Fabric: RN Core resolves LayoutMetrics
  • zIndex
 FEVM Pri 1

Shadow Props

4/4

API Platform RNW Paper RNW Fabric Notes
  • shadowColor
 No CBCV+SVCV Fabric: #12108, Shadow props impl in CBCV and CV must call updateShadowProps
  • shadowOffset
 iOS No CBCV+SVCV Fabric: #12108, Shadow props impl in CBCV and CV must call updateShadowProps
  • shadowOpacity
 iOS No CBCV+SVCV Fabric: #12108, Shadow props impl in CBCV and CV must call updateShadowProps
  • shadowRadius
 iOS No CBCV+SVCV Fabric: #12108, Shadow props impl in CBCV and CV must call updateShadowProps

Native Component Methods

2/2

API Platform RNW Paper RNW Fabric Notes
  • blur()
 Windows VMB CBCV Fabric: #11323
  • focus()
 Windows VMB CBCV Fabric: #11323

Glossary

See the Glossary to decode the abbreviations above and/or the RNW Fabric Inventory.xlsx.
@ghost ghost added the Needs: Triage 🔍 New issue that needs to be reviewed by the issue management team (label applied by bot) label Jan 31, 2023
@jonthysell jonthysell mentioned this issue Jan 31, 2023
Closed
9 tasks
@jonthysell jonthysell added the Area: Fabric Support Facebook Fabric label Jan 31, 2023
@chrisglein chrisglein added Area: ScrollView Deliverable Major item tracked for top-level planning in ADO enhancement and removed Needs: Triage 🔍 New issue that needs to be reviewed by the issue management team (label applied by bot) labels Jan 31, 2023
@microsoft-github-policy-service microsoft-github-policy-service bot added the Invalid Triage https://github.com/microsoft/react-native-windows/wiki/Triage-Process (label applied by bot) label Jan 31, 2023
@rozele
Copy link
Collaborator

rozele commented Feb 1, 2023

Not captured in props and events, but the scroll wheel functionality is a bit choppy. Is there an easy way to animate WM_MOUSEWHEEL events?

@chrisglein chrisglein removed the Invalid Triage https://github.com/microsoft/react-native-windows/wiki/Triage-Process (label applied by bot) label Feb 1, 2023
@chrisglein chrisglein added this to the Backlog milestone Feb 1, 2023
@ttruongatl ttruongatl mentioned this issue Feb 4, 2023
Closed
@chrisglein chrisglein mentioned this issue May 11, 2023
Closed
@chrisglein chrisglein mentioned this issue Aug 17, 2023
Open
This was referenced Aug 25, 2023
Closed
Closed
Closed
Closed
@YajurG YajurG added Recommend: Backlog Recommend that issue should be given Backlog milestone. and removed Recommend: Backlog Recommend that issue should be given Backlog milestone. labels Aug 31, 2023
This was referenced Aug 31, 2023
Closed
Closed
@jonthysell jonthysell added New Architecture Broad category for issues that apply to the RN "new" architecture of Turbo Modules + Fabric Parity: Fabric vs. Paper RNW Fabric does not look or behave like RNW Paper Area: Component Views API: Completion labels Mar 7, 2024
@jonthysell
Copy link
Contributor Author

Closing this deliverable, all remaining component properties required for parity are now being tracked by individual issues.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
API: Completion Area: Component Views Area: Fabric Support Facebook Fabric Area: ScrollView Deliverable Major item tracked for top-level planning in ADO enhancement New Architecture Broad category for issues that apply to the RN "new" architecture of Turbo Modules + Fabric Parity: Fabric vs. Paper RNW Fabric does not look or behave like RNW Paper
Projects
RNW New Architecture
Status: Done
Milestone
Backlog
Development

No branches or pull requests
4 participants
@rozele @jonthysell @chrisglein @YajurG