Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Modify corridor floors assembly composition. #147

Closed
lcpt opened this issue Jan 19, 2020 · 14 comments
Closed

Modify corridor floors assembly composition. #147

lcpt opened this issue Jan 19, 2020 · 14 comments
Assignees
Labels

Comments

@lcpt
Copy link
Contributor

lcpt commented Jan 19, 2020

20200117_0444_Ryan2Luis_corridor_floors.pdf

@lcpt lcpt self-assigned this Jan 19, 2020
@lcpt lcpt added the STRUCT. label Jan 19, 2020
@lcpt
Copy link
Contributor Author

lcpt commented Jan 20, 2020

We can use 4x6 pine joists as follows:
4x6_pine_joist_imperial_units

@theoryshaw
Copy link
Member

Cool. Thx! Are you still working on the substrate layer sandwich?

image

@lcpt
Copy link
Contributor Author

lcpt commented Jan 20, 2020

Cool. Thx! Are you still working on the substrate layer sandwich?

image

Yes. For the structural point of view I prefer the first sandwich. But, on the other hand, I need to check the strength of the OSB panels. I'm currently working on this.

@lcpt
Copy link
Contributor Author

lcpt commented Jan 21, 2020

Cool. Thx! Are you still working on the substrate layer sandwich?

image

Hi Ryan. In those sandwiches there is a missing OSB layer. We checked the floor sheathing with three 19/32 structural plywood layers:
image

@theoryshaw
Copy link
Member

Thats the question, essentially, can we go down to 2 layers? Perhaps (2) 3/4" layers? The gyp crete provides some fire resistant in these sandwiches, as well.

@lcpt
Copy link
Contributor Author

lcpt commented Jan 21, 2020

OK. Understood.

@lcpt
Copy link
Contributor Author

lcpt commented Jan 21, 2020

Then we need to put the Gypcrete between the two structural layers, otherwise there is no bearing layer in case of fire.

@theoryshaw
Copy link
Member

Sounds good. If we do the following what's the minimum size of the OSB?

image

@lcpt
Copy link
Contributor Author

lcpt commented Jan 21, 2020

We can use a 19/32 OSB panel with the following design capacities:

image

image

@theoryshaw
Copy link
Member

Okay. so to summarize...

We can do?...

4x6 no. 1 pine joists 32" o.c. with the following sandwich...

  • 19/32" osb spanning 32" oc.
  • 3/4" gyp crete
  • acoustical mat
  • 19/32" osb spanning 32" oc.

@lcpt
Copy link
Contributor Author

lcpt commented Jan 22, 2020

Yes, as long as the OSB panels have the capacities showed above.

@theoryshaw
Copy link
Member

@lcpt,

In our previous assembly, we had the following sandwich....

  • 3/4" gyp crete
  • acoustical mat
  • 19/32" osb spanning 32" oc.
  • 19/32" osb spanning 32" oc.
  • 19/32" osb spanning 32" oc.

Is there anyway to go down to 2 layers like the following?...

  • 3/4" gyp crete
  • acoustical mat
  • 3/4" (or thicker, if need be) osb spanning 32" oc.
  • 3/4" (or thicker, if need be) osb spanning 32" oc.

Sorry to ask this again, but the GC has expressed concerns on the constructability of the following sandwich

  • 19/32" osb spanning 32" oc.
  • 3/4" gyp crete
  • acoustical mat
  • 3/4" osb spanning 32" oc.

With this assembly, they would put that first layer of 3/4" down, and that would be the only sheathing during construction. They are worried about large concentrated loads during construction, such as a cart full of drywall.

They also indicated that that top layer of 19/32" would be hard to nail down through the gyp. crete.


It would be ideal to do the following sandwich...

  • 3/4" gyp crete
  • acoustical mat
  • 3/4" (or thicker, if need be) osb spanning 32" oc.
  • 3/4" (or thicker, if need be) osb spanning 32" oc.

..but if it's not possible to us (2) layers of OSB, I think we should just go back the following then.

  • 3/4" gyp crete
  • acoustical mat
  • 19/32" osb spanning 32" oc.
  • 19/32" osb spanning 32" oc.
  • 19/32" osb spanning 32" oc.

@theoryshaw theoryshaw reopened this Feb 12, 2020
@lcpt
Copy link
Contributor Author

lcpt commented Feb 13, 2020

Hi Ryan.

You can use:

  • 3/4" gyp crete
  • acoustical mat
  • 19/32" osb spanning 32" oc.
  • 1 1/8" osb spanning 32" oc.

or go back to the initial solution:

  • 3/4" gyp crete
  • acoustical mat
  • 19/32" osb spanning 32" oc.
  • 19/32" osb spanning 32" oc.
  • 19/32" osb spanning 32" oc.

@lcpt
Copy link
Contributor Author

lcpt commented Feb 13, 2020

We need to adapt detail 4/A800 consequently.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants