Wrap argument name cause could be err

[matryer]

This might seem a little strange, but I think cause as an argument name to Wrap and Wrapf is unnecessary. I wonder if err might be good enough?

Here are some reasons:

1. it's obvious that we're wrapping an error that caused the need to add context in the first place
2. there's only one argument of type error
3. it is possible the argument is not the 'root' cause, so in a sense, isn't the 'cause'
4. IDE plugins will autofil and most of the time, the variable name would be err so you could just tab past it

Very minor issue, and mainly I'm trying to save myself two key-presses each time I use this (which I will every day).

[davecheney]

I buy the argument in your third point. Feel free to send a PR, don't
forget to update the docs and the package doc and the README. sorry for the
duplication

On Wed, 25 May 2016, 09:12 Mat Ryer, notifications@github.com wrote:

This might seem a little strange, but I think cause as an argument name
to Wrap and Wrapf is unnecessary. I wonder if err might be good enough?

Here are some reasons:

• it's obvious that we're wrapping an error that caused the need to
  add context
• there's only one argument of type error
• it is possible the argument is not the 'root' cause, so in a
  sense, isn't the 'cause'
• IDE plugins will autofil and most of the time, the variable name
  would be err so you can just tab past it

Very minor issue, and mainly I'm trying to save myself two key-presses
each time I use this (which I will every day).

—
You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.
Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub
#32

[davecheney]

Actually, the error passed to Wrap and friends it's the cause. Error x is
caused by error y, and error y may either be the root cause or be
symptomatic of another.

But still send a PR to rename cause to err in the formal parameters. Its
not important enough to be different.

On Wed, 25 May 2016, 09:18 Dave Cheney, dave@cheney.net wrote:

I buy the argument in your third point. Feel free to send a PR, don't
forget to update the docs and the package doc and the README. sorry for the
duplication

On Wed, 25 May 2016, 09:12 Mat Ryer, notifications@github.com wrote:

This might seem a little strange, but I think cause as an argument name
to Wrap and Wrapf is unnecessary. I wonder if err might be good enough?

Here are some reasons:

• it's obvious that we're wrapping an error that caused the need to
  add context
• there's only one argument of type error
• it is possible the argument is not the 'root' cause, so in a
  sense, isn't the 'cause'
• IDE plugins will autofil and most of the time, the variable name
  would be err so you can just tab past it

Very minor issue, and mainly I'm trying to save myself two key-presses
each time I use this (which I will every day).

—
You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.
Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub
#32

[matryer]

ok