SWEET units that are missing from QUDT

[dr-shorthair]

The SWEET ontology is another semantic resource that is widely used in the earth and environment science community. Part of SWEET is a set of unit definitions, primarily in this graph:

https://github.com/ESIPFed/sweet/blob/master/src/reprSciUnits.ttl

I've gone through them and matched most with QUDT concepts. Here are the ones for which there are not QUDT equivalents as far as I can find:

This set are trivial permutations of things already in QUDT:

• reprSciUnits:MYA
• reprSciUnits:ampereSquared
• reprSciUnits:century
• reprSciUnits:kelvinPerMeter
• reprSciUnits:kilogramRadianPerSecond
• reprSciUnits:meterSquaredPerSecondSquared
• reprSciUnits:millenium
• reprSciUnits:million_km2
• reprSciUnits:million_km3
• reprSciUnits:perAmpere
• reprSciUnits:perAmpereSquared
• reprSciUnits:perCandela
• reprSciUnits:perKilogram
• reprSciUnits:perKilogramMeterSquaredPerSecondKelvin
• reprSciUnits:perKilogramMole
• reprSciUnits:perRadian
• reprSciUnits:perSecondCubed
• reprSciUnits:perSecondSquared
• reprSciUnits:perSteradian
• reprSciUnits:perTesla
• reprSciUnits:perVolt
• reprSciUnits:siemensPerKilogram
• reprSciUnits:wattPerMeterSquaredPerSteradianPerWavelength

This one is interesting! (not sure if it is 3-month seasons - which is a cultural artefact)

• reprSciUnits:season

These are ratios and per-volume units that I'm not sure are managed in QUDT

• reprSciUnits:dimensionlessUnit
• reprSciUnits:ratio
• reprSciUnits:ppbv
• reprSciUnits:ppmv
• reprSciUnits:pptv
• reprSciUnits:volumeRatio

These I don't know about

• reprSciUnits:FNU
• reprSciUnits:FTU
• reprSciUnits:FormazinTurbidityUnit
• reprSciUnits:normalizedUnit

In due course QUDT should be supplemented with (most of) these missing items, which are derived from actual usage in that community.

[jhodgesatmb]

I believe that the board decided to cross reference with SWEET back in February.

…

On Thu, Sep 10, 2020 at 3:40 PM Simon Cox ***@***.***> wrote: The SWEET ontology <https://github.com/ESIPFed/sweet> is another semantic resource that is widely used in the earth and environment science community. Part of SWEET is a set of unit definitions, primarily in this graph: https://github.com/ESIPFed/sweet/blob/master/src/reprSciUnits.ttl I've gone through them and matched most with QUDT concepts. These are the ones for which there are *not* QUDT equivalents as far as I can find: - reprSciUnits:FNU - reprSciUnits:FTU - reprSciUnits:FormazinTurbidityUnit - reprSciUnits:MYA - reprSciUnits:ampereSquared - reprSciUnits:century - reprSciUnits:dimensionlessUnit - reprSciUnits:kelvinPerMeter - reprSciUnits:kilogramRadianPerSecond - reprSciUnits:meterSquaredPerSecondSquared - reprSciUnits:millenium - reprSciUnits:million_km2 - reprSciUnits:million_km3 - reprSciUnits:normalizedUnit - reprSciUnits:perAmpere - reprSciUnits:perAmpereSquared - reprSciUnits:perCandela - reprSciUnits:perKilogram - reprSciUnits:perKilogramMeterSquaredPerSecondKelvin - reprSciUnits:perKilogramMole - reprSciUnits:perRadian - reprSciUnits:perSecondCubed - reprSciUnits:perSecondSquared - reprSciUnits:perSteradian - reprSciUnits:perTesla - reprSciUnits:perVolt - reprSciUnits:ppbv - reprSciUnits:ppmv - reprSciUnits:pptv - reprSciUnits:ratio - reprSciUnits:season - reprSciUnits:siemensPerKilogram - reprSciUnits:volumeRatio - reprSciUnits:wattPerMeterSquaredPerSteradianPerWavelength In due course we should supplement the QUDT vocabulary with these missing items, which are derived from actual usage in that community. — You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#231>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AATQRWIJCSIMDLAWYQ3OKELSFFIUXANCNFSM4RGAZA7Q> .

-- Jack

[dr-shorthair]

The alignment should be done from SWEET to QUDT.

I've done a first cut here https://github.com/ESIPFed/sweet/blob/issue217-qudt-alignment/alignments/sweet-qudt-mapping.ttl which will be merged with the main branch of SWEET if ESIPFed/sweet#221 is accepted.
The list above is the set that need to be added to QUDT to allow a complete mapping from SWEET.

[jhodgesatmb]

That inclusion would have to follow the normal unit submission guidelines: https://github.com/qudt/qudt-public-repo/wiki/Unit-Vocabulary-Submission-Guidelines Especially considering that so little information is provided out of the mandatory fields. Jack

…

On Thu, Sep 10, 2020 at 3:40 PM Simon Cox ***@***.***> wrote: The SWEET ontology <https://github.com/ESIPFed/sweet> is another semantic resource that is widely used in the earth and environment science community. Part of SWEET is a set of unit definitions, primarily in this graph: https://github.com/ESIPFed/sweet/blob/master/src/reprSciUnits.ttl I've gone through them and matched most with QUDT concepts. These are the ones for which there are *not* QUDT equivalents as far as I can find: - reprSciUnits:FNU - reprSciUnits:FTU - reprSciUnits:FormazinTurbidityUnit - reprSciUnits:MYA - reprSciUnits:ampereSquared - reprSciUnits:century - reprSciUnits:dimensionlessUnit - reprSciUnits:kelvinPerMeter - reprSciUnits:kilogramRadianPerSecond - reprSciUnits:meterSquaredPerSecondSquared - reprSciUnits:millenium - reprSciUnits:million_km2 - reprSciUnits:million_km3 - reprSciUnits:normalizedUnit - reprSciUnits:perAmpere - reprSciUnits:perAmpereSquared - reprSciUnits:perCandela - reprSciUnits:perKilogram - reprSciUnits:perKilogramMeterSquaredPerSecondKelvin - reprSciUnits:perKilogramMole - reprSciUnits:perRadian - reprSciUnits:perSecondCubed - reprSciUnits:perSecondSquared - reprSciUnits:perSteradian - reprSciUnits:perTesla - reprSciUnits:perVolt - reprSciUnits:ppbv - reprSciUnits:ppmv - reprSciUnits:pptv - reprSciUnits:ratio - reprSciUnits:season - reprSciUnits:siemensPerKilogram - reprSciUnits:volumeRatio - reprSciUnits:wattPerMeterSquaredPerSteradianPerWavelength In due course we should supplement the QUDT vocabulary with these missing items, which are derived from actual usage in that community. — You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#231>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AATQRWIJCSIMDLAWYQ3OKELSFFIUXANCNFSM4RGAZA7Q> .

-- Jack

[dr-shorthair]

Yes - understood. I was just putting the list on record for the moment - I didn't expect it to be processed without more information (though most of them are trivial permutations of things already in QUDT.).