Deprecate mismatched collation comparison for uniquness validator

In MySQL, the default collation is case insensitive. Since the
uniqueness validator enforces case sensitive comparison by default, it
frequently causes mismatched collation issues (performance, weird
behavior, etc) to MySQL users.

https://grosser.it/2009/12/11/validates_uniqness_of-mysql-slow/
#1399
#13465
gitlabhq/gitlabhq@c1dddf8
huginn/huginn#1330 (comment)

I'd like to deprecate the implicit default enforcing since I frequently
experienced the problems in code reviews.

Note that this change has no effect to sqlite3, postgresql, and
oracle-enhanced adapters which are implemented as case sensitive by
default, only affect to mysql2 adapter (I can take a work if sqlserver
adapter will support Rails 6.0).

activerecord/CHANGELOG.md

@@ -1,3 +1,11 @@
+*   Deprecate mismatched collation comparison for uniquness validator.
+
+    Uniqueness validator will no longer enforce case sensitive comparison in Rails 6.1.
+    To continue case sensitive comparison on the case insensitive column,
+    pass `case_sensitive: true` option explicitly to the uniqueness validator.
+
+    *Ryuta Kamizono*
+
 *   Add `reselect` method. This is a short-hand for `unscope(:select).select(fields)`.
 
     Fixes #27340.

activerecord/lib/active_record/connection_adapters/abstract_adapter.rb

@@ -506,7 +506,7 @@ def raw_connection
         @connection
       end
 
-      def default_uniqueness_comparison(attribute, value) # :nodoc:
+      def default_uniqueness_comparison(attribute, value, klass) # :nodoc:
         case_sensitive_comparison(attribute, value)
       end
 

activerecord/lib/active_record/connection_adapters/abstract_mysql_adapter.rb

@@ -453,6 +453,20 @@ def primary_keys(table_name) # :nodoc:
         SQL
       end
 
+      def default_uniqueness_comparison(attribute, value, klass) # :nodoc:
+        column = column_for_attribute(attribute)
+
+        if column.collation && !column.case_sensitive?
+          ActiveSupport::Deprecation.warn(<<~MSG.squish)
+            Uniqueness validator will no longer enforce case sensitive comparison in Rails 6.1.
+            To continue case sensitive comparison on the :#{attribute.name} attribute in #{klass} model,
+            pass `case_sensitive: true` option explicitly to the uniqueness validator.
+          MSG
+        end
+
+        super
+      end
+
       def case_sensitive_comparison(attribute, value) # :nodoc:
         column = column_for_attribute(attribute)
 

activerecord/lib/active_record/validations/uniqueness.rb

@@ -63,7 +63,7 @@ def build_relation(klass, attribute, value)
           if bind.nil?
             attr.eq(bind)
           elsif !options.key?(:case_sensitive)
-            klass.connection.default_uniqueness_comparison(attr, bind)
+            klass.connection.default_uniqueness_comparison(attr, bind, klass)
           elsif options[:case_sensitive]
             klass.connection.case_sensitive_comparison(attr, bind)
           else

activerecord/test/cases/validations/uniqueness_validation_test.rb

@@ -314,6 +314,51 @@ def test_validate_case_insensitive_uniqueness_with_special_sql_like_chars
     assert t3.save, "Should save t3 as unique"
   end
 
+  if current_adapter?(:Mysql2Adapter)
+    def test_deprecate_validate_uniqueness_mismatched_collation
+      Topic.validates_uniqueness_of(:author_email_address)
+
+      topic1 = Topic.new(author_email_address: "david@loudthinking.com")
+      topic2 = Topic.new(author_email_address: "David@loudthinking.com")
+
+      assert_equal 1, Topic.where(author_email_address: "david@loudthinking.com").count
+
+      assert_deprecated do
+        assert_not topic1.valid?
+        assert_not topic1.save
+        assert topic2.valid?
+        assert topic2.save
+      end
+
+      assert_equal 2, Topic.where(author_email_address: "david@loudthinking.com").count
+      assert_equal 2, Topic.where(author_email_address: "David@loudthinking.com").count
+    end
+  end
+
+  def test_validate_case_sensitive_uniqueness_by_default
+    Topic.validates_uniqueness_of(:author_email_address)
+
+    topic1 = Topic.new(author_email_address: "david@loudthinking.com")
+    topic2 = Topic.new(author_email_address: "David@loudthinking.com")
+
+    assert_equal 1, Topic.where(author_email_address: "david@loudthinking.com").count
+
+    ActiveSupport::Deprecation.silence do
+      assert_not topic1.valid?
+      assert_not topic1.save
+      assert topic2.valid?
+      assert topic2.save
+    end
+
+    if current_adapter?(:Mysql2Adapter)
+      assert_equal 2, Topic.where(author_email_address: "david@loudthinking.com").count
+      assert_equal 2, Topic.where(author_email_address: "David@loudthinking.com").count
+    else
+      assert_equal 1, Topic.where(author_email_address: "david@loudthinking.com").count
+      assert_equal 1, Topic.where(author_email_address: "David@loudthinking.com").count
+    end
+  end
+
   def test_validate_case_sensitive_uniqueness
     Topic.validates_uniqueness_of(:title, case_sensitive: true, allow_nil: true)
 

activerecord/test/schema/schema.rb

@@ -8,6 +8,13 @@
   #                                                                     #
   # ------------------------------------------------------------------- #
 
+  case_sensitive_options =
+    if current_adapter?(:Mysql2Adapter)
+      { collation: "utf8mb4_bin" }
+    else
+      {}
+    end
+
   create_table :accounts, force: true do |t|
     t.references :firm, index: false
     t.string  :firm_name
@@ -266,7 +273,7 @@
   end
 
   create_table :dashboards, force: true, id: false do |t|
-    t.string :dashboard_id
+    t.string :dashboard_id, **case_sensitive_options
     t.string :name
   end
 
@@ -330,15 +337,15 @@
   end
 
   create_table :essays, force: true do |t|
-    t.string :name
+    t.string :name, **case_sensitive_options
     t.string :writer_id
     t.string :writer_type
     t.string :category_id
     t.string :author_id
   end
 
   create_table :events, force: true do |t|
-    t.string :title, limit: 5
+    t.string :title, limit: 5, **case_sensitive_options
   end
 
   create_table :eyes, force: true do |t|
@@ -380,16 +387,16 @@
   end
 
   create_table :guids, force: true do |t|
-    t.column :key, :string
+    t.column :key, :string, **case_sensitive_options
   end
 
   create_table :guitars, force: true do |t|
     t.string :color
   end
 
   create_table :inept_wizards, force: true do |t|
-    t.column :name, :string, null: false
-    t.column :city, :string, null: false
+    t.column :name, :string, null: false, **case_sensitive_options
+    t.column :city, :string, null: false, **case_sensitive_options
     t.column :type, :string
   end
 
@@ -876,8 +883,8 @@
   end
 
   create_table :topics, force: true do |t|
-    t.string   :title, limit: 250
-    t.string   :author_name
+    t.string   :title, limit: 250, **case_sensitive_options
+    t.string   :author_name, **case_sensitive_options
     t.string   :author_email_address
     if subsecond_precision_supported?
       t.datetime :written_on, precision: 6
@@ -889,10 +896,10 @@
     # use VARCHAR2(4000) instead of CLOB datatype as CLOB data type has many limitations in
     # Oracle SELECT WHERE clause which causes many unit test failures
     if current_adapter?(:OracleAdapter)
-      t.string   :content, limit: 4000
+      t.string   :content, limit: 4000, **case_sensitive_options
       t.string   :important, limit: 4000
     else
-      t.text     :content
+      t.text     :content, **case_sensitive_options
       t.text     :important
     end
     t.boolean  :approved, default: true