Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

FL.2.3 (XBB.1.9.1.2.3) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(198 seqs multiple countries) #97

Closed
Memorablea opened this issue May 25, 2023 · 36 comments
Labels
To be proposed Green light for proposal

Comments

@Memorablea
Copy link

Memorablea commented May 25, 2023

Sub-lineage of:FL.2
Earliest sequence:2023-04-07,Guangdong
Most recent sequence:2023-05-11,USA
Countries circulating:China 70, Ireland 1, England 1, United States 1
GISAID search:T4579A,A17615G,C21998A

sequence

Genomes: EPI_ISL_17545640, EPI_ISL_17584630, EPI_ISL_17615002,EPI_ISL_17625276, EPI_ISL_17625305, EPI_ISL_17625315,EPI_ISL_17625360, EPI_ISL_17625389,EPI_ISL_17625431, EPI_ISL_17625499, EPI_ISL_17625567,EPI_ISL_17625585, EPI_ISL_17632975 ,EPI_ISL_17632976, EPI_ISL_17645472,EPI_ISL_17645513, EPI_ISL_17664527, EPI_ISL_17671914,EPI_ISL_17671919, EPI_ISL_17671944 ,EPI_ISL_17671945,EPI_ISL_17671949,EPI_ISL_17671951, EPI_ISL_17671956,EPI_ISL_17671957,EPI_ISL_17672024,EPI_ISL_17678284,EPI_ISL_17678372,EPI_ISL_17678427,EPI_ISL_17678450, EPI_ISL_17680003, EPI_ISL_17684000,EPI_ISL_17684191, EPI_ISL_17684329, EPI_ISL_17696835,EPI_ISL_17697630, EPI_ISL_17697636, EPI_ISL_17697691,EPI_ISL_17697695, EPI_ISL_17697698, EPI_ISL_17697760,EPI_ISL_17697763, EPI_ISL_17697767, EPI_ISL_17697786, EPI_ISL_17697803, EPI_ISL_17697836, EPI_ISL_17697849-17697850, EPI_ISL_17697880, EPI_ISL_17697883, EPI_ISL_17697914, EPI_ISL_17698013, EPI_ISL_17698015, EPI_ISL_17698032, EPI_ISL_17698034, EPI_ISL_17698046, EPI_ISL_17698073, EPI_ISL_17698078, EPI_ISL_17698087, EPI_ISL_17698104, EPI_ISL_17698123, EPI_ISL_17698226, EPI_ISL_17698233-17698234, EPI_ISL_17698248, EPI_ISL_17698260, EPI_ISL_17698267, EPI_ISL_17698275, EPI_ISL_17698284, EPI_ISL_17698292, EPI_ISL_17700760, EPI_ISL_17703623, EPI_ISL_17703996

UShER Tree:
I directly referenced the UShER tree of @Over-There-Is because it seems to better reflect. I'm sorry for the error, but the UShER tree seems to be dirty.
https://nextstrain.org/fetch/github.com/Over-There-Is/subtreeAuspice/raw/main/subtreeAuspice_genome_39469_cdac30.json
image
image

@Memorablea Memorablea changed the title FL.2 (XBB. 1.9.1.2) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(73 sequences from 4 countries) FL.2 (XBB.1.9.1.2) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(73 sequences from 4 countries) May 25, 2023
@JosetteSchoenma
Copy link

Thank you for making this issue. I was keeping an eye on this one as well, but I got a different and confusing Usher tree with a H146K reversion branch. Would you like to tell me how you made this your tree?

I used this query on GISAID. C11956T, C12789T, -T17124C, A17615G, Spike_H146K plus -G27225a (78 samples) to exclude a branch of mostly samples from the USA, of which I am not sure whether Usher misplaced them.

image
USA branch (XBB.1.9.1)
image
image

And I checked Guandong. It seems to have jumped to around 7% of the samples in week 16, but did not seem to grow after that. 6% in week 18.

@FedeGueli
Copy link

It has been already pre proposed here in #78 and theb transferred to Pango : cov-lineages/pango-designation#2016

@FedeGueli FedeGueli closed this as not planned Won't fix, can't repro, duplicate, stale May 25, 2023
@FedeGueli
Copy link

Once the parental lineage got assigned then we can open #78
or this one.

@Memorablea
Copy link
Author

Thank you for making this issue. I was keeping an eye on this one as well, but I got a different and confusing Usher tree with a H146K reversion branch. Would you like to tell me how you made this your tree?

I apologize. It's like this, I noticed an error while filtering, and the correct UShER tree has been updated.

@Memorablea
Copy link
Author

Once the parental lineage got assigned then we can open #78 or this one.

I understand, as I just said, there was an error in my screening, and I'm sorry. Next, let's wait for #2016

@Over-There-Is
Copy link

It seems unreasonable that the earlier detected sequences are placed on the further place, so I downloaded the json file and edit it manually.

@Over-There-Is
Copy link

Over-There-Is commented May 26, 2023

Hubei+2, Yunnan+1. Totally 77 seq now.

@Memorablea Memorablea changed the title FL.2 (XBB.1.9.1.2) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(73 sequences from 4 countries) FL.2 (XBB.1.9.1.2) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(77 sequences from 4 countries) May 26, 2023
@Over-There-Is
Copy link

Ohio, US+1

@Memorablea
Copy link
Author

Ohio, US+1

Thanks for your contribution, I'll change the title as the sequence grows.

@Memorablea Memorablea changed the title FL.2 (XBB.1.9.1.2) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(77 sequences from 4 countries) FL.2 (XBB.1.9.1.2) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(78 sequences from 4 countries) May 27, 2023
@Over-There-Is
Copy link

South Korea 1, Singapore 1, Shanghai 4(1 from S. Korea, 1 from Vietnam, 1 from Thailand), Hubei 3, Shanxi 1. 88 seq now.
Not only China, US, UK, Ireland, Singapore, S. Korea, but also Vietnam, Thailand, and there was a sequence in Shanghai imported from UAE, totally 9 countries.

@Memorablea Memorablea changed the title FL.2 (XBB.1.9.1.2) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(78 sequences from 4 countries) FL.2 (XBB.1.9.1.2) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(88 sequences from 4 countries) May 31, 2023
@Over-There-Is
Copy link

+1, Sichuan

@Over-There-Is
Copy link

Totally 89 now, but two of them also have N:R189L mutation. S:Q146K is more homoplastic than N:R189L, therefore I believe their gain N:R189L before S:Q146K.

@Memorablea Memorablea changed the title FL.2 (XBB.1.9.1.2) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(88 sequences from 4 countries) FL.2 (XBB.1.9.1.2) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(89 sequences from 6 countries) Jun 1, 2023
@Over-There-Is
Copy link

California+1

@Memorablea Memorablea changed the title FL.2 (XBB.1.9.1.2) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(89 sequences from 6 countries) FL.2 (XBB.1.9.1.2) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(90 sequences from 6 countries) Jun 3, 2023
@Over-There-Is
Copy link

Spain +1

@Over-There-Is
Copy link

Over-There-Is commented Jun 5, 2023

HK+2, and additionally 1 without 11956

@Memorablea Memorablea changed the title FL.2 (XBB.1.9.1.2) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(90 sequences from 6 countries) FL.2 (XBB.1.9.1.2) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(93 sequences from 6 countries) Jun 6, 2023
@Over-There-Is
Copy link

Anhui +1

@Over-There-Is
Copy link

California +1, Shanghai +2(1 from Malaysia)

@Over-There-Is
Copy link

Xinjiang +1, 98 now

@Over-There-Is
Copy link

South Korea +1, from China

@Memorablea
Copy link
Author

Memorablea commented Jun 12, 2023

Open this.@FedeGueli

@Memorablea Memorablea changed the title FL.2 (XBB.1.9.1.2) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(93 sequences from 6 countries) FL.2.3 (XBB.1.9.1.2.3) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(93 sequences from 6 countries) Jun 12, 2023
@FedeGueli FedeGueli reopened this Jun 12, 2023
@FedeGueli
Copy link

Reopened this one. Be aware that in my opinion 146 is very tricky always. i dont see this one clearly faster than other sub-branches.

@Over-There-Is
Copy link

S:Q146K was the largest subbranch, but N:R189L seems growing faster and became the largest subbranch later.

@Memorablea
Copy link
Author

Memorablea commented Jun 13, 2023

I think we should continue to pay attention to it

@Over-There-Is
Copy link

France +1

@Over-There-Is
Copy link

61 seqs from several provinces in China, 1 also have N:R189L (maybe convergent)

@FedeGueli FedeGueli changed the title FL.2.3 (XBB.1.9.1.2.3) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(93 sequences from 6 countries) FL.2.3 (XBB.1.9.1.2.3) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(175 sequences from 6 countries) Jun 18, 2023
@FedeGueli
Copy link

175 as today

@FedeGueli FedeGueli changed the title FL.2.3 (XBB.1.9.1.2.3) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(175 sequences from 6 countries) FL.2.3 (XBB.1.9.1.2.3) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(196 sequences from 6 countries) Jun 27, 2023
@FedeGueli FedeGueli changed the title FL.2.3 (XBB.1.9.1.2.3) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(196 sequences from 6 countries) FL.2.3 (XBB.1.9.1.2.3) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(196 sequences multiple countries) Jun 27, 2023
@FedeGueli
Copy link

Could you compare this one with the other branches of FL.2.3 please? if it shows advantage over N:189 an N:236 and the other ones i think it should be proposed being close to 200 seqs and multiples countries.

@Memorablea
Copy link
Author

198 now

@Memorablea Memorablea changed the title FL.2.3 (XBB.1.9.1.2.3) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(196 sequences multiple countries) FL.2.3 (XBB.1.9.1.2.3) with ORF1ab: K5784R and S: Q146K(198 seqs multiple countries) Jun 28, 2023
@NkRMnZr
Copy link

NkRMnZr commented Jun 28, 2023

There's a branch got S:F456L, follows:
FL.2.3 > G28839T(N:R189L) > T16977C > T22928C(S:F456L)

There's S:Q146K(C21998A)/S:K146Q(A21998C) flip-flop on UShER tree, and is neglected here due to potential artifact. The issue exists when FL.2.3 gets designated.

Query: G28839T, T22928C finds 4, all from Shanghai

Genomes: EPI_ISL_17625561, EPI_ISL_17811306, EPI_ISL_17811318, EPI_ISL_17836662

UShER:
https://nextstrain.org/fetch/genome.ucsc.edu/trash/ct/subtreeAuspice1_genome_30417_bf7650.json?f_userOrOld=uploaded%20sample

There's also another one got S:F490P (on top of XBB's T23019C/S:F490S), follows:
FL.2.3 > ORF1a:S2900L(C8964T), S:F490P(T23030C)
query: T23030C, C8964T, A17615G finds 3 from different provinces.

Genomes: EPI_ISL_17795684, EPI_ISL_17819898, EPI_ISL_17830389

@FedeGueli
Copy link

@Memorablea please propose this one in the main page.

@NkRMnZr please propose the two branches you found with 456 and 490 in two separated issues. thank you

@FedeGueli FedeGueli added the To be proposed Green light for proposal label Jun 28, 2023
@Memorablea
Copy link
Author

@Memorablea please propose this one in the main page.

Home page? Do you mean sars-cov-2-variants or cov-lineages?

@NkRMnZr please propose the two branches you found with 456 and 490 in two separated issues. thank you

And do you mean what NkRMnZr pointed out?

@FedeGueli
Copy link

@Memorablea please propose this one in the main page.

Home page? Do you mean sars-cov-2-variants or cov-lineages?

The main page is the official pango page.

@NkRMnZr please propose the two branches you found with 456 and 490 in two separated issues. thank you

And do you mean what NkRMnZr pointed out?

Yes i mean he/she should propose them both , separately

@Memorablea
Copy link
Author

OK

@Memorablea
Copy link
Author

转移至cov-lineages/pango-designation#2078

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
To be proposed Green light for proposal
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

5 participants