-
-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 357
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Ask bus stop quests also for platforms mapped as ways #4341
Comments
Hmm, I see no reason to not do this. |
I think maybe the reason why it has only been nodes so far was that if it is mapped as an area, the chance that bins, shelters and benches would be mapped separately. But on the other hand, I think it is well accepted that |
Bin=yes et al show there's a bin nearby. The node for the bin itself shows the exact location. |
In the Netherlands I now see new quests for bus stops that exist both as ways and as nodes, causing duplication of effort and data. I already did the quests for the nodes. Not sure yet if I should do the same quests for the ways as well. |
See recent discussion in #4690. |
but likely should not be - or should be not described/treated as representing bus stops |
I agree it is incorrect if one uses However, it seems correct tagging to map bus stops with both That being said, I do not see what could be easily done (unless whole of OSM jointly decide to remove PTv1 tagging and go just with PTv2, which seems unlikely currently). StreetComplete specific hacks (e.g. trying to ignore So I agree that not doing anything (i.e. continue asking asking for duplicate information on "duplicate" OSM elements) seems like the best course of action. |
Though mapping them as single object is preferable if someone really wants to map public_transport=platform
or drops bad parts of PTv2 |
The whole reason people map I always though of public_transport=stop_position (and not
Of course (although "modified PTv2" should probably be called PTv3 instead) |
from linked page:
|
I know (hence the disclaimer about it being wrong semantically), what I was trying (unsuccessfully it seems) to explain there is that one cannot use node (like |
Another options are to drop |
Use case
According to the wiki, the tag
public_transport=platform
can be used on nodes, ways, and areas. However, the bus stop questsAddBenchStatusOnBusStop
,AddBinStatusOnBusStop
,AddBusStopLit
, andAddBusStopShelter
are currently only asked for platforms mapped as nodes. Only theAddTactilePavingBusStop
is also asked for ways/areas.Proposed Solution
Update the element filters of all bus stop quests to also include ways.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: