Link filePublic to ac:serviceExpectation

[peterdesmet]

The term https://tdwg.github.io/camtrap-dp/data/#media.filePublic can potentially have a skos link to https://ac.tdwg.org/termlist/#ac_serviceExpectation, although one is a boolean and the other a controlled vocab. Need to assess if it is same, narrow or broader.

[peterdesmet]

@danstowell @baskaufs @edwbaker

Preface: Camtrap DP's media filePath is skos-linked to Audiovisual Core's accessURI, since the terms are clearly related. The Camtrap DP term is narrower, since it does not allow offline resources such as the DOI of a CD. It does allow full URLs and relative paths, which both seem to be accepted by accessURI as well.

Question: Camtrap DP also has a term filePublic. Do you think it is OK to skos-link this to Audiovisual Core's serviceExpectation?

• Camtrap DP: filePublic: false if the media file is not publicly accessible (e.g. to protect the privacy of people).
• AC: serviceExpectation: A term that describes what service expectations users may have of the ac:accessURI. Recommended terms include online (denotes that the URL is expected to deliver the resource), authenticate (denotes that the URL delivers a login or other authentication interface requiring completion before delivery of the resource) published (non digital) (denotes that the URL is the identifier of a non-digital published work, for example a doi.) Communities should develop their own controlled vocabularies for Service Expectations.

The filePublic term is a more narrow interpretation (digital resources only) and it uses "their own controlled vocabularies" as a boolean. true can be mapped to "online". false can arguably be mapped to "authenticate", although the authentication to get access to non-public media file can vary and might not be provided through the provided URL.

[baskaufs]

@peterdesmet I think your argument is pretty convincing that boolean values represent a community-developed controlled vocabulary. So I can't think of any reason not to map them as at least a close match.