Spot resizes itself every time it is opened (elementaryOS 6)

[AnElementaryUser]

Describe the bug
Spot resizes itself every time it is opened.

To Reproduce
Steps to reproduce the behavior:

1. Open Spot
2. Close it.
3. Open Spot again.
4. See that the window is resized.

Expected behavior
It will remember the window size.

Screenshots

General information:

• Distribution: elementaryOS 6
• Installation method: Flathub
• Version [e.g. 0.1.0]: 0.2.2
• Device used [e. g. desktop, phone...]: Desktop

Stack trace:
If applicable, run the application from a terminal and paste relevant log output.

flatpak run --env=RUST_BACKTRACE=full dev.alextren.Spot

Additional context
Add any other context about the problem here.

[AnElementaryUser]

Latest release (0.3) solved this issue.

[xou816]

Hi! Thanks for the report. Looks like we are not always saving the window size to gsettings. Do you see values being updated if you do the following?

flatpak --command=sh run dev.alextren.Spot # runs a shell in the flatpak image
spot 
# resize then close spot / ^C
gsettings get dev.alextren.Spot window-width # should log the last recorded width of the window 

[xou816]

Oops, just a bit late :D I don't remember us fixing anything related to that in the latest version though, so feel free to reopen this issue if you encounter the problem again!

[ghost]

Hi @xou816

Could you please re-open this issue because I am having the same problem but I couldn't find a way to mitigate this?

Thanks.

[xou816]

Sure! Would you mind trying these steps and reporting your results here?

[ghost]

As you said, I manually resized window then closed it.

$ flatpak --command=sh run dev.alextren.Spot
[📦 dev.alextren.Spot ~]$ spot

(spot:7): Gtk-WARNING **: 16:54:27.935: GtkGizmo 0x561a94554bb0 (highlight) reported min width -2, but sizes must be >= 0
[📦 dev.alextren.Spot ~]$ gsettings get dev.alextren.Spot window-width
1179

Then I launched it again and this time I didn't resize it and the number was up.

[📦 dev.alextren.Spot ~]$ spot

(spot:83): Gtk-WARNING **: 16:55:11.489: GtkGizmo 0x5578f67cdb80 (highlight) reported min width -2, but sizes must be >= 0
[📦 dev.alextren.Spot ~]$ gsettings get dev.alextren.Spot window-width
1207

[ghost]

Hi @xou816

Any news about this? Anything I can help with?

[xou816]

Hi! Sorry, forgot about this. I sometimes notice this too, especially when making the window narrow -- I guess Gtk sometimes think it needs to have more space than truly needed.

Otherwise saving and restoring the values seems to work! So maybe the window manager is messing with the size here?

I'll still have to fix a little something, right now the sizes are not saved when quitting using Quit/<Ctrl>Q

[xou816]

Just to be clear, are you observing significant differences in window sizes? I can't tell from OP's gif

[ghost]

saving and restoring the values seems to work

I don't wanna sound dumb but how can I save the values 😅😅

Just to be clear, are you observing significant differences in window sizes? I can't tell from OP's gif

OPs gif is so mysterious 😂 I think there is no proper screen recorder for elementary, that could be why it looks potato.

Back to your question, yes, window sizes change radically between sessions under X11, on wayland not so much. If I force the app to use Adwaita via Flatseal, it doesn't change much. Libadwaita could be causing this but I am out of ideas.

[xou816]

I don't wanna sound dumb but how can I save the values 😅😅

No worries, I meant the thing we tested where the values were updated in gsettings!

But yeah, if it's down to a Wayland/X11 thing or a DE specific, I fear I won't want to look too hard into it... 😄 I'll push a fix for the size not being persisted when quitting, not closing the window.

[xou816]

Almost forgot... again... but I pushed the small fix I mentioned

As for the random resizing, I am not really willing to investigate it much further if all it does is get the size wrong by a small amount, especially if it's some tricky Gtk resizing behavior or a DE issue

[ghost]

Whether it is fixed or not, it is a great application. Thank you!

[bilelmoussaoui]

I am pretty sure this is a gtk issue specific to x11