Merge pull request #33 from Axelrod-Python/marc-updates

A variety of edits for the paper
Axelrod-Python · May 17, 2017 · 50ddd2f · 50ddd2f
2 parents efa8e1d + c7b6d87
commit 50ddd2f
Show file tree

Hide file tree

Showing 109 changed files with 1,364 additions and 939 deletions.
diff --git a/img/ALLCorALLD_v_Cooperator.pdf b/img/ALLCorALLD_v_Cooperator.pdf
diff --git a/img/ALLCorALLD_v_Defector.pdf b/img/ALLCorALLD_v_Defector.pdf
diff --git a/img/ALLCorALLD_v_TfT.pdf b/img/ALLCorALLD_v_TfT.pdf
diff --git a/img/Alternator_v_ALLCorALLD.pdf b/img/Alternator_v_ALLCorALLD.pdf
diff --git a/img/Alternator_v_Cooperator.pdf b/img/Alternator_v_Cooperator.pdf
diff --git a/img/Alternator_v_Defector.pdf b/img/Alternator_v_Defector.pdf
diff --git a/img/Alternator_v_GTFT.pdf b/img/Alternator_v_GTFT.pdf
diff --git a/img/Alternator_v_PSO_Gambler_2_2_2.pdf b/img/Alternator_v_PSO_Gambler_2_2_2.pdf
diff --git a/img/Alternator_v_Random.pdf b/img/Alternator_v_Random.pdf
diff --git a/img/Alternator_v_TfT.pdf b/img/Alternator_v_TfT.pdf
diff --git a/img/Alternator_v_WStLSh.pdf → img/Alternator_v_WSLS.pdf b/img/Alternator_v_WStLSh.pdf → img/Alternator_v_WSLS.pdf
diff --git a/img/Alternator_v_ZD-Extort-2.pdf b/img/Alternator_v_ZD-Extort-2.pdf
diff --git a/img/Calculator_v_ALLCorALLD.pdf b/img/Calculator_v_ALLCorALLD.pdf
diff --git a/img/Calculator_v_Arrogant_QLearner.pdf b/img/Calculator_v_Arrogant_QLearner.pdf
diff --git a/img/Calculator_v_Random.pdf b/img/Calculator_v_Random.pdf
diff --git a/img/Cooperator_v_ALLCorALLD.pdf b/img/Cooperator_v_ALLCorALLD.pdf
diff --git a/img/Cooperator_v_GTFT.pdf b/img/Cooperator_v_GTFT.pdf
diff --git a/img/Cooperator_v_PSO_Gambler_2_2_2.pdf b/img/Cooperator_v_PSO_Gambler_2_2_2.pdf
diff --git a/img/Cooperator_v_Random.pdf b/img/Cooperator_v_Random.pdf
diff --git a/img/Cooperator_v_TfT.pdf b/img/Cooperator_v_TfT.pdf
diff --git a/img/Cooperator_v_ZD-Extort-2.pdf b/img/Cooperator_v_ZD-Extort-2.pdf
diff --git a/img/Defector_v_Alternator.pdf b/img/Defector_v_Alternator.pdf
diff --git a/img/Defector_v_Cooperator.pdf b/img/Defector_v_Cooperator.pdf
diff --git a/img/Defector_v_Defector.pdf b/img/Defector_v_Defector.pdf
diff --git a/img/Defector_v_TfT.pdf b/img/Defector_v_TfT.pdf
diff --git a/img/Defector_v_WStLSh.pdf → img/Defector_v_WSLS.pdf b/img/Defector_v_WStLSh.pdf → img/Defector_v_WSLS.pdf
diff --git a/img/Random_v_ALLCorALLD.pdf b/img/Random_v_ALLCorALLD.pdf
diff --git a/img/Random_v_Cooperator.pdf b/img/Random_v_Cooperator.pdf
diff --git a/img/Random_v_Defector.pdf b/img/Random_v_Defector.pdf
diff --git a/img/Random_v_GTFT.pdf b/img/Random_v_GTFT.pdf
diff --git a/img/Random_v_PSO_Gambler_2_2_2.pdf b/img/Random_v_PSO_Gambler_2_2_2.pdf
diff --git a/img/Random_v_Random.pdf b/img/Random_v_Random.pdf
diff --git a/img/Random_v_TfT.pdf b/img/Random_v_TfT.pdf
diff --git a/img/Random_v_ZD-Extort-2.pdf b/img/Random_v_ZD-Extort-2.pdf
diff --git a/img/WStLSh_v_TfT.pdf → img/WSLS_v_TfT.pdf b/img/WStLSh_v_TfT.pdf → img/WSLS_v_TfT.pdf
diff --git a/img/average_rank_vs_population_size_coexist.pdf b/img/average_rank_vs_population_size_coexist.pdf
diff --git a/img/average_rank_vs_population_size_invade.pdf b/img/average_rank_vs_population_size_invade.pdf
diff --git a/img/average_rank_vs_population_size_resist.pdf b/img/average_rank_vs_population_size_resist.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_10_invade.pdf b/img/boxplot_10_invade.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_10_resist.pdf b/img/boxplot_10_resist.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_11_invade.pdf b/img/boxplot_11_invade.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_11_resist.pdf b/img/boxplot_11_resist.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_12_invade.pdf b/img/boxplot_12_invade.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_12_resist.pdf b/img/boxplot_12_resist.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_13_invade.pdf b/img/boxplot_13_invade.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_13_resist.pdf b/img/boxplot_13_resist.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_14_invade.pdf b/img/boxplot_14_invade.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_14_resist.pdf b/img/boxplot_14_resist.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_2_invade.pdf b/img/boxplot_2_invade.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_3_invade.pdf b/img/boxplot_3_invade.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_3_resist.pdf b/img/boxplot_3_resist.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_4_invade.pdf b/img/boxplot_4_invade.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_4_resist.pdf b/img/boxplot_4_resist.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_5_invade.pdf b/img/boxplot_5_invade.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_5_resist.pdf b/img/boxplot_5_resist.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_6_invade.pdf b/img/boxplot_6_invade.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_6_resist.pdf b/img/boxplot_6_resist.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_7_invade.pdf b/img/boxplot_7_invade.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_7_resist.pdf b/img/boxplot_7_resist.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_8_invade.pdf b/img/boxplot_8_invade.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_8_resist.pdf b/img/boxplot_8_resist.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_9_invade.pdf b/img/boxplot_9_invade.pdf
diff --git a/img/boxplot_9_resist.pdf b/img/boxplot_9_resist.pdf
diff --git a/img/correlation_heatmap_coexist.pdf b/img/correlation_heatmap_coexist.pdf
diff --git a/img/correlation_heatmap_invade.pdf b/img/correlation_heatmap_invade.pdf
diff --git a/img/correlation_heatmap_resist.pdf b/img/correlation_heatmap_resist.pdf
diff --git a/img/number_of_match_outcomes.pdf b/img/number_of_match_outcomes.pdf
diff --git a/img/number_of_stochastic_match_outcomes.pdf b/img/number_of_stochastic_match_outcomes.pdf
diff --git a/main.pdf b/main.pdf
diff --git a/main.tex b/main.tex
diff --git a/nbs/main.ipynb b/nbs/main.ipynb
diff --git a/src/abbreviations.py b/src/abbreviations.py
@@ -16,7 +16,7 @@
 abbreviations["CollectiveStrategy"] = "CS"
 abbreviations["Two Tits For Tat"] = "2TfT"
 abbreviations["Tit For 2 Tats"] = "Tf2T"
-abbreviations["Win-Stay Lose-Shift: C"] = "WStLSh"
+abbreviations["Win-Stay Lose-Shift: C"] = "WSLS"
 abbreviations["Win-Shift Lose-Stay: D"] = "WShLSt"
 abbreviations["FSM Player: [(0, 'C', 7, 'C'), (0, 'D', 1, 'C'), (1, 'C', 11, 'D'), (1, 'D', 11, 'D'), (2, 'C', 8, 'D'), (2, 'D', 8, 'C'), (3, 'C', 3, 'C'), (3, 'D', 12, 'D'), (4, 'C', 6, 'C'), (4, 'D', 3, 'C'), (5, 'C', 11, 'C'), (5, 'D', 8, 'D'), (6, 'C', 13, 'D'), (6, 'D', 14, 'C'), (7, 'C', 4, 'D'), (7, 'D', 2, 'D'), (8, 'C', 14, 'D'), (8, 'D', 8, 'D'), (9, 'C', 0, 'C'), (9, 'D', 10, 'D'), (10, 'C', 8, 'C'), (10, 'D', 15, 'C'), (11, 'C', 6, 'D'), (11, 'D', 5, 'D'), (12, 'C', 6, 'D'), (12, 'D', 9, 'D'), (13, 'C', 9, 'D'), (13, 'D', 8, 'D'), (14, 'C', 8, 'D'), (14, 'D', 13, 'D'), (15, 'C', 4, 'C'), (15, 'D', 5, 'C')], 0, C"] = "TF1"
 abbreviations["FSM Player: [(0, 'C', 13, 'D'), (0, 'D', 12, 'D'), (1, 'C', 3, 'D'), (1, 'D', 4, 'D'), (2, 'C', 14, 'D'), (2, 'D', 9, 'D'), (3, 'C', 0, 'C'), (3, 'D', 1, 'D'), (4, 'C', 1, 'D'), (4, 'D', 2, 'D'), (5, 'C', 12, 'C'), (5, 'D', 6, 'C'), (6, 'C', 1, 'C'), (6, 'D', 14, 'D'), (7, 'C', 12, 'D'), (7, 'D', 2, 'D'), (8, 'C', 7, 'D'), (8, 'D', 9, 'D'), (9, 'C', 8, 'D'), (9, 'D', 0, 'D'), (10, 'C', 2, 'C'), (10, 'D', 15, 'C'), (11, 'C', 7, 'D'), (11, 'D', 13, 'D'), (12, 'C', 3, 'C'), (12, 'D', 8, 'D'), (13, 'C', 7, 'C'), (13, 'D', 10, 'D'), (14, 'C', 10, 'D'), (14, 'D', 7, 'D'), (15, 'C', 15, 'C'), (15, 'D', 11, 'D')], 0, C"] = "TF2"

diff --git a/tex/bibliography.bib b/tex/bibliography.bib
@@ -1,3 +1,16 @@
+@article{stewart2013extortion,
+  title={From extortion to generosity, evolution in the iterated prisoner’s dilemma},
+  author={Stewart, Alexander J and Plotkin, Joshua B},
+  journal={Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
+  volume={110},
+  number={38},
+  pages={15348--15353},
+  year={2013},
+  publisher={National Acad Sciences}
+}
+
+
+
 @article{Lee2015,
     author = {Lee, Christopher and Harper, Marc and Fryer, Dashiell},
     doi = {10.1371/journal.pone.0120625},
@@ -246,6 +259,17 @@ @article{Adami2013
 	year = {2013}
 }
 
+@article{adami2016evolutionary,
+  title={Evolutionary game theory using agent-based methods},
+  author={Adami, Christoph and Schossau, Jory and Hintze, Arend},
+  journal={Physics of life reviews},
+  volume={19},
+  pages={1--26},
+  year={2016},
+  publisher={Elsevier}
+}
+
+
 
 @article{Li2014,
     author = {Li, Jiawei and Kendall, Graham and Member, Senior},

diff --git a/tex/change_of_rank_coexist.tex b/tex/change_of_rank_coexist.tex
@@ -2,19 +2,21 @@
 \toprule
          Player &      2 &      4 &      6 &      8 &     10 &     12 &     14 \\
 \midrule
-             CS &    1.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 &    2.0 \\
-       Defector &    2.0 &   78.0 &   99.0 &  106.0 &  110.0 &  113.0 &  120.0 \\
-     Aggravater &    3.0 &   91.0 &  105.0 &  111.0 &  122.0 &  125.0 &  128.0 \\
-       Predator &    4.0 &    2.0 &    4.0 &    4.0 &    4.0 &    4.0 &    4.0 \\
-      Handshake &    5.0 &    6.0 &    5.0 &    6.0 &    6.0 &    6.0 &    6.0 \\
-            TF2 &    9.0 &    4.0 &    3.0 &    2.0 &    2.0 &    2.0 &    1.0 \\
-            TF1 &    7.0 &    3.0 &    2.0 &    3.0 &    3.0 &    3.0 &    3.0 \\
-       Prober 4 &    6.0 &    5.0 &    6.0 &    5.0 &    5.0 &    5.0 &    5.0 \\
-    ZD-Extort-4 &   16.0 &  102.0 &  117.0 &  129.0 &  141.0 &  143.0 &  145.0 \\
- ZD-Extort-2 v2 &   41.0 &  118.0 &  135.0 &  151.0 &  152.0 &  152.0 &  153.0 \\
-    ZD-Extort-2 &   43.0 &  117.0 &  136.0 &  149.0 &  151.0 &  151.0 &  152.0 \\
-       ZD-SET-2 &  100.0 &  110.0 &  110.0 &  108.0 &  106.0 &  106.0 &  108.0 \\
-      ZD-GTFT-2 &  112.0 &   82.0 &   80.0 &   77.0 &   75.0 &   75.0 &   74.0 \\
-       ZD-GEN-2 &  113.0 &   85.0 &   81.0 &   82.0 &   79.0 &   77.0 &   76.0 \\
+             CS &    1 &    1 &    1 &    1 &    1 &    1 &    2 \\
+       Defector &    2 &   78 &   99 &  106 &  110 &  113 &  120 \\
+     Aggravater &    3 &   91 &  105 &  111 &  122 &  125 &  128 \\
+       Predator &    4 &    2 &    4 &    4 &    4 &    4 &    4 \\
+      Handshake &    5 &    6 &    5 &    6 &    6 &    6 &    6 \\
+\midrule
+            \textbf{TF2} &    9 &    4 &    3 &    2 &    2 &    2 &    1 \\
+            \textbf{TF1} &    7 &    3 &    2 &    3 &    3 &    3 &    3 \\
+       Prober 4 &    6 &    5 &    6 &    5 &    5 &    5 &    5 \\
+\midrule
+    ZD-Extort-4 &   16 &  102 &  117 &  129 &  141 &  143 &  145 \\
+ ZD-Extort-2 v2 &   41 &  118 &  135 &  151 &  152 &  152 &  153 \\
+    ZD-Extort-2 &   43 &  117 &  136 &  149 &  151 &  151 &  152 \\
+       ZD-SET-2 &  100 &  110 &  110 &  108 &  106 &  106 &  108 \\
+      ZD-GTFT-2 &  112 &   82 &   80 &   77 &   75 &   75 &   74 \\
+       ZD-GEN-2 &  113 &   85 &   81 &   82 &   79 &   77 &   76 \\
 \bottomrule
-\end{tabular}
+\end{tabular}
diff --git a/tex/change_of_rank_invade.tex b/tex/change_of_rank_invade.tex
@@ -2,21 +2,23 @@
 \toprule
                Player &      2 &      3 &      4 &      5 &      6 &      7 &      8 &      9 &     10 &     11 &     12 &     13 &     14 \\
 \midrule
-                   CS &    1.0 &    1.0 &    2.0 &   11.0 &    9.0 &   11.0 &   13.0 &   21.0 &   16.0 &   22.0 &   17.0 &   25.0 &   23.0 \\
-             Defector &    2.0 &   43.0 &   80.0 &   91.0 &   89.0 &   87.0 &   87.0 &  103.0 &   97.0 &  105.0 &   94.0 &  103.0 &  101.0 \\
-           Aggravater &    3.0 &   50.0 &   89.0 &   99.0 &  102.0 &  103.0 &  108.0 &  113.0 &  114.0 &  115.0 &  115.0 &  116.0 &  117.0 \\
-             Predator &    4.0 &    8.0 &   24.0 &   35.0 &   28.0 &   33.0 &   31.0 &   43.0 &   36.0 &   43.0 &   34.0 &   45.0 &   35.0 \\
-            Handshake &    5.0 &   17.0 &   40.0 &   46.0 &   43.0 &   46.0 &   46.0 &   49.0 &   48.0 &   49.0 &   47.0 &   50.0 &   49.0 \\
-       Evolved FSM 16 &   31.0 &   11.0 &    6.0 &    2.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 \\
-    PSO Gambler 2\_2\_2 &   29.0 &   14.0 &   10.0 &    6.0 &    4.0 &    2.0 &    2.0 &    2.0 &    2.0 &    2.0 &    2.0 &    2.0 &    2.0 \\
- EvolvedLookerUp2\_2\_2 &   33.0 &   18.0 &   11.0 &    9.0 &   10.0 &    6.0 &    6.0 &    5.0 &    3.0 &    5.0 &    3.0 &    3.0 &    3.0 \\
-          Evolved ANN &   20.0 &   10.0 &    8.0 &    7.0 &    8.0 &    5.0 &    3.0 &    3.0 &    4.0 &    3.0 &    4.0 &    4.0 &    4.0 \\
-        Evolved ANN 5 &   21.0 &    9.0 &    7.0 &    8.0 &    7.0 &    4.0 &    5.0 &    4.0 &    5.0 &    4.0 &    5.0 &    5.0 &    5.0 \\
-          ZD-Extort-4 &   16.0 &   81.0 &  107.0 &  120.0 &  135.0 &  136.0 &  142.0 &  140.0 &  142.0 &  142.0 &  144.0 &  144.0 &  145.0 \\
-       ZD-Extort-2 v2 &   41.0 &  105.0 &  126.0 &  140.0 &  152.0 &  152.0 &  153.0 &  152.0 &  153.0 &  153.0 &  153.0 &  152.0 &  153.0 \\
-          ZD-Extort-2 &   43.0 &  107.0 &  125.0 &  139.0 &  151.0 &  151.0 &  152.0 &  153.0 &  152.0 &  152.0 &  152.0 &  153.0 &  152.0 \\
-             ZD-SET-2 &  100.0 &  111.0 &  117.0 &  117.0 &  122.0 &  127.0 &  131.0 &  128.0 &  131.0 &  131.0 &  130.0 &  132.0 &  131.0 \\
-            ZD-GTFT-2 &  112.0 &   92.0 &   82.0 &   80.0 &   81.0 &   82.0 &   84.0 &   72.0 &   81.0 &   71.0 &   78.0 &   72.0 &   70.0 \\
-             ZD-GEN-2 &  113.0 &   96.0 &   87.0 &   83.0 &   85.0 &   88.0 &   90.0 &   82.0 &   87.0 &   82.0 &   86.0 &   83.0 &   91.0 \\
+                   CS &    1 &    1 &    2 &   11 &    9 &   11 &   13 &   21 &   16 &   22 &   17 &   25 &   23 \\
+             Defector &    2 &   43 &   80 &   91 &   89 &   87 &   87 &  103 &   97 &  105 &   94 &  103 &  101 \\
+           Aggravater &    3 &   50 &   89 &   99 &  102 &  103 &  108 &  113 &  114 &  115 &  115 &  116 &  117 \\
+             Predator &    4 &    8 &   24 &   35 &   28 &   33 &   31 &   43 &   36 &   43 &   34 &   45 &   35 \\
+            Handshake &    5 &   17 &   40 &   46 &   43 &   46 &   46 &   49 &   48 &   49 &   47 &   50 &   49 \\
+\midrule
+       Evolved FSM 16 &   31 &   11 &    6 &    2 &    1 &    1 &    1 &    1 &    1 &    1 &    1 &    1 &    1 \\
+    PSO Gambler 2\_2\_2 &   29 &   14 &   10 &    6 &    4 &    2 &    2 &    2 &    2 &    2 &    2 &    2 &    2 \\
+ EvolvedLookerUp2\_2\_2 &   33 &   18 &   11 &    9 &   10 &    6 &    6 &    5 &    3 &    5 &    3 &    3 &    3 \\
+          Evolved ANN &   20 &   10 &    8 &    7 &    8 &    5 &    3 &    3 &    4 &    3 &    4 &    4 &    4 \\
+        Evolved ANN 5 &   21 &    9 &    7 &    8 &    7 &    4 &    5 &    4 &    5 &    4 &    5 &    5 &    5 \\
+\midrule
+          ZD-Extort-4 &   16 &   81 &  107 &  120 &  135 &  136 &  142 &  140 &  142 &  142 &  144 &  144 &  145 \\
+       ZD-Extort-2 v2 &   41 &  105 &  126 &  140 &  152 &  152 &  153 &  152 &  153 &  153 &  153 &  152 &  153 \\
+          ZD-Extort-2 &   43 &  107 &  125 &  139 &  151 &  151 &  152 &  153 &  152 &  152 &  152 &  153 &  152 \\
+             ZD-SET-2 &  100 &  111 &  117 &  117 &  122 &  127 &  131 &  128 &  131 &  131 &  130 &  132 &  131 \\
+            ZD-GTFT-2 &  112 &   92 &   82 &   80 &   81 &   82 &   84 &   72 &   81 &   71 &   78 &   72 &   70 \\
+             ZD-GEN-2 &  113 &   96 &   87 &   83 &   85 &   88 &   90 &   82 &   87 &   82 &   86 &   83 &   91 \\
 \bottomrule
-\end{tabular}
+\end{tabular}
diff --git a/tex/change_of_rank_resist.tex b/tex/change_of_rank_resist.tex
@@ -2,19 +2,21 @@
 \toprule
          Player &      2 &      3 &      4 &      5 &      6 &      7 &      8 &      9 &     10 &     11 &     12 &     13 &     14 \\
 \midrule
-             CS &    1.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 &    1.0 \\
-       Defector &    2.0 &   29.0 &   55.0 &   79.0 &   94.0 &   97.0 &   98.0 &   98.0 &  102.0 &  101.0 &  103.0 &  100.0 &  102.0 \\
-     Aggravater &    3.0 &   42.0 &   71.0 &   97.0 &  101.0 &  106.0 &  107.0 &  111.0 &  113.0 &  113.0 &  116.0 &  115.0 &  115.0 \\
-       Predator &    4.0 &    2.0 &    3.0 &    3.0 &    3.0 &    4.0 &    4.0 &    4.0 &    4.0 &    4.0 &    4.0 &    4.0 &    4.0 \\
-      Handshake &    5.0 &    4.0 &    5.0 &    5.0 &    5.0 &    5.0 &    5.0 &    6.0 &    6.0 &    6.0 &    6.0 &    6.0 &    6.0 \\
-            TF1 &    7.0 &    3.0 &    2.0 &    2.0 &    2.0 &    2.0 &    2.0 &    2.0 &    2.0 &    2.0 &    2.0 &    2.0 &    2.0 \\
-            TF2 &   10.0 &    5.0 &    4.0 &    4.0 &    4.0 &    3.0 &    3.0 &    3.0 &    3.0 &    3.0 &    3.0 &    3.0 &    3.0 \\
-       Prober 4 &    6.0 &    6.0 &    6.0 &    6.0 &    6.0 &    6.0 &    6.0 &    5.0 &    5.0 &    5.0 &    5.0 &    5.0 &    5.0 \\
-    ZD-Extort-4 &   19.0 &   68.0 &   98.0 &  106.0 &  108.0 &  114.0 &  115.0 &  115.0 &  118.0 &  118.0 &  117.0 &  118.0 &  117.0 \\
- ZD-Extort-2 v2 &   49.0 &   98.0 &  111.0 &  121.0 &  123.0 &  124.0 &  124.0 &  130.0 &  130.0 &  132.0 &  134.0 &  132.0 &  134.0 \\
-    ZD-Extort-2 &   50.0 &   97.0 &  112.0 &  123.0 &  124.0 &  125.0 &  123.0 &  126.0 &  131.0 &  131.0 &  132.0 &  133.0 &  133.0 \\
-       ZD-SET-2 &  108.0 &  105.0 &  104.0 &  104.0 &  103.0 &  103.0 &  100.0 &  100.0 &  101.0 &   99.0 &   98.0 &   98.0 &   98.0 \\
-      ZD-GTFT-2 &  112.0 &   95.0 &   88.0 &   84.0 &   75.0 &   72.0 &   71.0 &   73.0 &   71.0 &   71.0 &   67.0 &   68.0 &   68.0 \\
-       ZD-GEN-2 &  114.0 &   96.0 &   89.0 &   86.0 &   77.0 &   75.0 &   72.0 &   74.0 &   72.0 &   72.0 &   68.0 &   69.0 &   69.0 \\
+             CS &    1 &    1 &    1 &    1 &    1 &    1 &    1 &    1 &    1 &    1 &    1 &    1 &    1 \\
+       Defector &    2 &   29 &   55 &   79 &   94 &   97 &   98 &   98 &  102 &  101 &  103 &  100 &  102 \\
+     Aggravater &    3 &   42 &   71 &   97 &  101 &  106 &  107 &  111 &  113 &  113 &  116 &  115 &  115 \\
+       Predator &    4 &    2 &    3 &    3 &    3 &    4 &    4 &    4 &    4 &    4 &    4 &    4 &    4 \\
+      Handshake &    5 &    4 &    5 &    5 &    5 &    5 &    5 &    6 &    6 &    6 &    6 &    6 &    6 \\
+\midrule
+            \textbf{TF1} &    7 &    3 &    2 &    2 &    2 &    2 &    2 &    2 &    2 &    2 &    2 &    2 &    2 \\
+            \textbf{TF2} &   10 &    5 &    4 &    4 &    4 &    3 &    3 &    3 &    3 &    3 &    3 &    3 &    3 \\
+       Prober 4 &    6 &    6 &    6 &    6 &    6 &    6 &    6 &    5 &    5 &    5 &    5 &    5 &    5 \\
+\midrule
+    ZD-Extort-4 &   19 &   68 &   98 &  106 &  108 &  114 &  115 &  115 &  118 &  118 &  117 &  118 &  117 \\
+ ZD-Extort-2 v2 &   49 &   98 &  111 &  121 &  123 &  124 &  124 &  130 &  130 &  132 &  134 &  132 &  134 \\
+    ZD-Extort-2 &   50 &   97 &  112 &  123 &  124 &  125 &  123 &  126 &  131 &  131 &  132 &  133 &  133 \\
+       ZD-SET-2 &  108 &  105 &  104 &  104 &  103 &  103 &  100 &  100 &  101 &   99 &   98 &   98 &   98 \\
+      ZD-GTFT-2 &  112 &   95 &   88 &   84 &   75 &   72 &   71 &   73 &   71 &   71 &   67 &   68 &   68 \\
+       ZD-GEN-2 &  114 &   96 &   89 &   86 &   77 &   75 &   72 &   74 &   72 &   72 &   68 &   69 &   69 \\
 \bottomrule
-\end{tabular}
+\end{tabular}