Repository navigation
Replies: 1 comment
|
Thanks, good points. In the next update the lock will only stop a click outside from resetting the selection. You can still resize it from the edges and corners and move it, and double-clicking outside starts over. I'm keeping the lock button though, since a lot of people expect a click outside to start a new selection like in Lightshot. If you turn on "Lock the selection automatically" you get exactly the flow you described. |
0 replies
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
I'd like to suggest another improvement to the screenshot selection workflow.
First, thanks for implementing the option to lock the selection immediately after creating it. This was a very useful addition because it prevents accidentally resetting the selection when clicking outside the selected area.
However, I've noticed a usability issue with the current behavior.
1. Locking should not prevent resizing
Currently, when the selection is locked, it also prevents resizing the selected area using the corner and edge handles.
In my workflow, I frequently need to fine-tune the selection after initially drawing it.
Ideally, locking should only prevent accidentally resetting the selection, while still allowing users to resize it freely.
2. Double-click outside the selection to reset
I'd also like to suggest a new interaction:
Double-clicking outside the selected area could reset the selection.
This would return the interface to its initial state, with the screen dimmed and ready to select a new capture area, without having to restart the screenshot process.
3. Could this replace the lock button entirely?
Taking this idea a step further, perhaps the lock button would no longer be necessary.
The selection workflow could become:
Single-click outside the selection: Does nothing, preventing accidental resets.
Drag the corners or edges: Resizes the existing selection.
Drag inside the selection: Moves the selected area.
Double-click outside the selection: Resets the selection, allowing the user to draw a new area.
This would make the selection permanently protected against accidental clicks while keeping it fully editable.
It could also simplify the interface by eliminating the need for a separate lock button.
I think this behavior would make screenshot selection more intuitive and efficient, especially for users who frequently adjust the selected area before capturing.
All reactions