Vs2019 Support

[christiantippner]

Are you planning support for Visual Studio 2019.
Microsoft has implemented a new StartDialog. But i miss a full configurable start page like yours.
Please inform us about your planning.

Thanks a lot
Christian

[stijnherreman]

The VS 2017 documentation mentions how to customize the start page with the Visual Studio SDK, but the VS 2019 documentation does not. So I assume it's currently not possible for this extension to support VS 2019.

There's a request on Developer Community to reintroduce the start page.

[Danielku15]

I also doubt that I will be able to port this over. I haven't seen any extension system for the new launcher dialog yet. During the evaluation time of VS2019 I submitted requests that Microsoft adds an own Tab to the launcher with similar functionality as in BetterStartPage, but nothing happened.

[Danielku15]

I checked today a bit the implementation of Microsoft on the new launch dialog. Again with some hacks it is likely adjustable and extendable with a custom UI. I quickly made an extension that patches the dialog to make the MRU list 50% transparent and maximize the window:

Technically it would work even though it takes a few seconds until the layout of the quick start window changes. I will need to check if I can make Visual Studio auto-load my extension faster but I fear with the async loading of extensions it is not possible any faster.

I'm currently thinking of how the UI could look like. If there is really interest from the market I could have a closer look to bring a 2019 version of Better Start Page.

[magicmayhem]

It would be really great if you could work on this. It's a real step backwards from Microsoft not to have a custom start page.

[confusedsushi]

Is it possible to add a custom entry to Tools -> Options -> Environment -> Startup -> On startup, open:?

If so, why not create your very own startup page? Simply open a Window which renders some HTML similar to the old BetterStartPage.

[czuck]

I suggested the feature int he Developer Community for VS, if enough people vote it up it up..
https://developercommunity.visualstudio.com/idea/598272/allow-customization-of-start-page.html

[jdkoehler]

@Danielku15 What if, as a quick-and-dirty work-around, you updated BetterStartPage to work in Visual Studio 2019 with Start Page on startup already installed?

[Danielku15]

I created yesterday a small prototype of BetterStartPage for VS2019 and the patching works. The main drawback is that since VS2019 all extensions are loaded asynchronously in the background. This means also for BSP that it is loaded delayed. As a result the Quick Start Window is showing some time the original VS version, and then my extension kicks in and restructures the UI.

Here a small demo Gif: https://coderline.net/bsp2019.gif

I'm not really convinced that this is really a good solution as it is too slow. I think an alternate solution would be better. Like the "Start Page on startup" but with a BSP inside.

Update 1:

The "Start Page on startup" approach works a bit better. Extensions get loaded faster and I can simply trigger an open of the Quick Start Window:

The adjustments I made so far are:

• I made the window resizable
• I remember the position and size of the window to restore it upon next launch. Proper multi-monitor handling to prevent out-of-screen window is outstanding
• I replace the "Open Recent" area with a tab control where I place BSP and the Open Recent.

TODOs would be:

• Fix some issues I detected on the solution open behavior (use correct VS2019 command to open solution)
• Proper styling of tabs and BSP to match the theme.
• Port the File > Open Favourite menu item to VS2019

Update 2

I made a small UI draft how it could look like finally. I think I might go for the all-in-one. It does not hide anything and devs have large screens anyhow.

** With Tabs **

** All in One **

[Danielku15]

I pushed my initial changes to GitHub and deployed an early-access version to the Marketplace. There is still a bit to do, but you can already let me know if it fits your needs and what you'd like to have changed.

https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=Danielku15.BetterStartPage2019

[SylwesterZarebski]

For me, extension for VS 2019 (16.1.3) is not working. Window is not resizeable, i could not add any project, import do nothing. How can i help to debug this problem?

[Danielku15]

If there are catched exceptions in the plugin you should find infos in the ActivityLog of Visual Studio: https://devblogs.microsoft.com/visualstudio/troubleshooting-extensions-with-the-activity-log/
Is your error here related to #43 that you reported or additionally?

[SylwesterZarebski]

That is another problem. I thought that importing old configuration could help, but sadly, no.

As for errors, there are errors after loading extension, but i'm not sure if these are from this extension or some other:

N#	Type	Description	GUID	Hr	Source	Time (UTC)
1505		Importing pkgdef file          c:\users\sylwek\appdata\local\microsoft\visualstudio\16.0_963bad19\extensions\ogzdt31d.2nh\betterstartpage.pkgdef			VisualStudio	2019/06/17 09:42:52.153
1506		Saving pkgdef cache meta data			VisualStudio	2019/06/17 09:42:52.154
1507		Saving pkgdef cache time stamp			VisualStudio	2019/06/17 09:42:52.154
1508		Newest node in pkgdef cache          Software\Microsoft\VisualStudio\16.0_963bad19_Config			VisualStudio	2019/06/17 09:42:52.200
1509		InitializeCache: Post initializing cache			VisualStudio	2019/06/17 09:42:52.200
1510		PkgDefManagement startup complete			VisualStudio	2019/06/17 09:42:52.201
1511	ERROR	Failed to read Version		80070002	VisualStudio	2019/06/17 09:42:52.225
1512	ERROR	Binding Redirect / CodeBase entry from configuration hive is malformed, ignoring.          Software\Microsoft\VisualStudio\16.0_963bad19_Config\RuntimeConfiguration\dependentAssembly\bindingRedirection{BB256134-B73E-47AA-93B4-C49FF433E5B1}

[SylwesterZarebski]

Otherwise there are no distinct errors besides UI libraries:

N#	Type	Description	GUID	Hr	Source	Time (UTC)
1560	ERROR	Loading UI library	{2FFE45C4-5C73-493C-B187-F2E955FF875E}	800a006f	VisualStudio	2019/06/17 09:42:53.629
1561	ERROR	Error loading UI library for package Microsoft.VisualStudio.LanguageServices.TypeScript.TypeScriptPackage, Microsoft.VisualStudio.LanguageServices.TypeScript, Version=16.0.0.0, Culture=neutral. HrLoadNativeUILibrary failed with 0x800a006f.

[jdkoehler]

I'm having the same problems as @SylwesterZarebski. I've tried it on four different Windows 10 machines.

[SylwesterZarebski]

Start screen looks like (using dark theme):

Above screen is taken from another PC. Extension has version 2.0.0 (preview) from marketplace.

[Danielku15]

I just published a 2.0.1 with various improvements. I hope this resolves some issues:

• For the "not working at all" I only found one potential cause but I'm not sure if it is solved, please update and try again.
• Some style fixes were made for dark theme. (style is not yet final anyhow)
• Resizing should work again
• Config import from old BSP versions should work now again.
• Attempt to fix duplicate Quick Start Windows when launcher is used instead of empty environment startup.

Please update and have a look if the basics are working now.

[SylwesterZarebski]

Thanks, extension is working.

I found only one slight bug. When upgraded from 2.0.0, there is configuration mismatch and extension gives popup to reset configuration. Then extension do not react to anything, looks like reset is not successful or internal config is not properly initialized. Restarting VS is sufficient to bring everything to normal.

[jdkoehler]

2.0.1 is working for me. On four machines, I did three upgrades and one "clean" (uninstalled then installed) and all worked with no issues. Imported a BSP configuration from VS2017 and it also worked!

[Danielku15]

When upgraded from 2.0.0, there is configuration mismatch and extension gives popup to reset configuration.

Yes, this is possible. They got somehow incompatible with the settings-serialization I use. I had to revert some things to be compatible with the export/import files. But clean installations should work. I decided to reset the configuration in case of an error in the settings loading.

2.0.1 is working for me. On four machines, I did three upgrades and one "clean" (uninstalled then installed) and all worked with no issues. Imported a BSP configuration from VS2017 and it also worked!

Great to hear. Then I can go forward with making it better from the UX. The UI still feels a bit prototype-ish. I want to align it better with Visual Studio.

[SylwesterZarebski]

@Danielku15 commented on 18 cze 2019, 16:05 CEST:

[...] The UI still feels a bit prototype-ish. I want to align it better with Visual Studio.

That would be great!

[stijnherreman]

I've just installed 2.0.1, didn't have an earlier version installed but imported the VS 2017 config. Initially the default Startup dialog is centered, but then the extension dialog appears in the top left corner.

I can move the dialog, but the position is not remembered when closing and restarting VS. It does remember the size of the dialog.

When closing the dialog, Visual Studio itself appears and I can move the second dialog that was still in the top left corner. Looks like the extension dialog is opened twice.

Please let me know if there's any other information you need to investigate this issue.

[jdkoehler]

I've just installed 2.0.1, didn't have an earlier version installed but imported the VS 2017 config. Initially the default Startup dialog is centered, but then the extension dialog appears in the top left corner.
{...remainder deleted...}

I had that same problem. The issue that Visual Studio is opening it's Start window and BSP is also opening it's Start page.

To fix that, start VS, close the BSP Start page (it's the one without the "Continue without code -->" link. Then in the VS Start Window (the one with the "Continue without code -->", click that link. Then in Tools > Options > Environment > Startup: Set "On startup, open:" to "Empty environment" then click "OK". Close and restart Visual Studio and see if that fixes it for you.

[SylwesterZarebski]

I just spot i have similar problem. Window position and height are not saved, only width. After opening start window is shown at the same position with reset height.

[stijnherreman]

Thanks @jdkoehler that fixed the duplicate dialog and odd positioning. The positioning is still not ideal and it isn't remembered, but it's a lot better.

[Danielku15]

@stijnherreman This information should be enough, I have an idea where the misplacement in your scenario came from. The plugin works currently best if you use the startup type "Empty Environment" as described in the extension readme, this should also solve the issue on the misplacement and duplicate dialog. I will try to improve the situation, but as highlighted earlier in this issue, the extension loading delay makes BSP2019 not so nice to use. It takes quite a bit until you get the options you would expect.

You can follow the progress on the outstanding part in PR #42

In 2.0.1 I changed from a "remember position" approach to a "center in main window" or "center on screen" approach. Remembering the position has a risk of misplacement on multi-screen scenarios.

[SylwesterZarebski]

Centering is not really centered. It is off to right by about 150 px. Try setting width at full screen width, close and reopen VS, and opened start window will be moved right from original centered position.

[Danielku15]

I just published version 2.0.2 of the extension. What is included:

• [Fix] Quick Start Window does not open multiple times anymore in case "Empty Environment" is not used
• [Fix] Quick Start Window is properly centered now
• [New] New Look & Feel that is more in-line with Visual Studio
• [New] The old "Edit Mode" was replaced by context menus and a small [⋮] menu button.

Looking forward to get your feedback.

[SylwesterZarebski]

Thanks a lot! It looks great.

Maybe some polishing could be done with popup windows - group new/edit or settings to be in line with VS theme - maybe inline edit would be simpler?

[SylwesterZarebski]

PS. Start Window still not really centered and do not save height when closed. I use 'Empty Environment' settings.

[Danielku15]

Maybe some polishing could be done with popup windows - group new/edit or settings to be in line with VS theme - maybe inline edit would be simpler?

Yes, some polishing can still be done. I still need to do some research on what resource keys Visual Studio is using and if I can actually import them somehow. I removed inline editing exactly because it is not simpler. It brings in quite a complexity, that's why I decided to remove the old inline-editing via "edit mode".

PS. Start Window still not really centered and do not save height when closed. I use 'Empty Environment' settings.

I cannot confirm this in any of my tests on my 3 environments. Also according to the code the centering leaves no doubt in centering:

BetterStartPage/BetterStartPage.Vs2019/View/QuickStartWindowWrapper.cs

Lines 139 to 149 in 1839d4e

	var mainWindow = Application.Current?.MainWindow;
	if (mainWindow != null && mainWindow != _instance && mainWindow.Visibility == Visibility.Visible)
	{
	_instance.Left = mainWindow.Left + (mainWindow.ActualWidth - _instance.Width) / 2;
	_instance.Top = mainWindow.Top + (mainWindow.ActualHeight - _instance.Height) / 2;
	}
	else
	{
	_instance.Left = Screen.PrimaryScreen.WorkingArea.Left + (Screen.PrimaryScreen.WorkingArea.Width - _instance.Width) / 2;
	_instance.Top = Screen.PrimaryScreen.WorkingArea.Top + (Screen.PrimaryScreen.WorkingArea.Height - _instance.Height) / 2;
	}

Do you maybe have any special setup? e.g. some High DPI display, portrait mode etc? Also be sure that you do not have any old version of BSP in parallel.

[SylwesterZarebski]

On two my systems with 2.0.2 version it looks like:

It is not centered.

Only start window set as 'Start window' is centered. When set as 'Empty environment' it is not.

Also saving height do not work in both settings.

[SylwesterZarebski]

Maybe this is not working?:

BetterStartPage/BetterStartPage.Vs2019/BetterStartPagePackage.cs

Line 70 in 1839d4e

QuickStartWindow.DialogCreated += (s,e) => QuickStartWindow.Instance?.PatchDialog();

                QuickStartWindow.DialogCreated += (s,e) => QuickStartWindow.Instance?.PatchDialog();
                if (QuickStartWindow.Instance == null)
                {
                    showStartWindowCommand?.Invoke();
                }

[Danielku15]

On two my systems with 2.0.2 version it looks like:

Unless you "censored" all your projects this looks to me like that there is a lot more not working than just the aligning. There are no recent projects, no favourite projects etc.

Maybe this is not working?:

No, if this would not be working the whole extension would not work. You would not see anything of BSP. The PatchDialog is the piece of code that also adds the "Open favourite" area.

Only start window set as 'Start window' is centered. When set as 'Empty environment' it is not. Also saving height do not work in both settings.

We have been that far, this level of details does not help finding out what is going wrong. Unless really some more people report the same behavior I think it might be a problem specific to your environments that I do not have.

Maybe you can clone the repository, switch to the vs2019 branch and give it a shot with debugging the extension. I will also try to add some more logging in the next version that will tell us maybe why the positioning is not working as expected.

[SylwesterZarebski]

Sorry, i've "censored" image ;-). This is working perfectly.

As 'not working' i mean it is not working as expected, eg. in DialogCreated event setting some of properties not behave as it should.
I've try to debug extension, but it is "black magic" at this moment, thus it could last long...

[Danielku15]

@SylwesterZarebski I just published version 2.0.4 to the marketplace. It would be great if you can start your Visual Studio with /Log and provide the activitylog. I hope by the newly added logging information I can find out why the window is not positioning was it should.

[SylwesterZarebski]

Ok, text from log for source BetterStartPage:

description

Ensure GetToCode package is loaded
GetToCode package loaded, resolving ShowStartWindow Command
Show Start Window command loaded
Registering 'Open favourite' command
Command registered
Registering to Quick Start Window event
Quick start window not open, triggering show start window command
Begin Patching Quick Start Window
Restoring window width 1524
Restoring window height 710
Positioning window based on main window. MainWindow[96,92,1936,1056], QuickStartWindow[1524,710]
Quick Start Window positioned to: 302,265
Searching for ProjectMruGrid in Quick Start Window
ProjectMruGrid found, reorganizing layout and injecting BetterStartPage
Patching done1

VS window is maximized and system taskbar is on top.

[SylwesterZarebski]

I've tested some combinations and i think i got it. It looks like VS coordinates are wrong when maximized - they are not maximised ones, but state from before maximisation.

[Danielku15]

Okay, I think this will help me making a fix. I was partially able to reproduce a mispositioning on my side. Looks like this is a strange behavior in WPF. The location and size properties might be the ones from an unmaximized state. I will rework the logic to take the window state into account.
https://stackoverflow.com/questions/4806088/how-can-i-find-the-position-of-a-maximized-window

[Danielku15]

@SylwesterZarebski Please update to 2.0.5 and let me know if you still experience the resizing and positioning infos.

[SylwesterZarebski]

Now it looks perfect. There is only height saving problem - it is always 710...

[stijnherreman]

Positioning is fine now with 2.0.5
I lost my config after updating from 2.0.1 to 2.0.5, but simply imported it again from the VS 2017 export and it persists through sessions, so I can't give any debugging info.

Thank you for the work so far, this extension gives a significant productivity boost.

[stephane-albus]

When I change the "Project Display Mode" from Large to something else it works but at the next launch of VS it returns to Large mode.

[SylwesterZarebski]

VS 2019 version 16.2.0 bring saving start page positions/size with maximization support recently, thus i think it could be safely deleted (in extension code) or disabled if this version (and above) is detected.
Now there is some minor problems when VS saves maximisation state, but extension bring back old position (from before maximisation), but width is as maximised.

[farangkao]

In General works good for me with 2.0.5,
few minor problems:

• Sometimes the Original Dialog appears (especially on Startup), but not big deal once closed and reopened, the Better Start Page is shown
• The Settings "Project Display Mode" seems not to be saved permanently, or not reapplied.