Repository navigation
Separate rest time between exercises (transition rest) #487
YannLoreth
started this conversation in
Ideas
Replies: 1 comment
|
Thanks a lot for implementing this in 1.4.5, and for the credit in the release notes, that was a nice surprise. I’ve been using “Rest before the next exercise” (per exercise and from the global setting) and it does exactly what I was hoping for: the transition between exercises is no longer treated like a rest between sets. Everything I’ve tested so far works as expected. |
0 replies
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Hi, and thanks for openGym! I've been self-hosting it on a Raspberry Pi for my partner and me, and it's been great so far.
The idea
Since the rest timer started running after the last set of an exercise too (the changelog entry "The rest timer skipped the last set of every exercise"), there's a rest before the next exercise, using that exercise's rest. That's a real improvement, but the break before the next exercise is often not the same as the break between sets of the same exercise. For example:
90 s between sets of curls, but 2 to 3 min before a heavy compound lift, to set up the station, load the bar and recover.
3 min between heavy squat sets, but only 60 s before a light accessory exercise.
Right now the workarounds are to switch the exercise to pyramid mode just to give its last set a different rest, or to scroll the rest wheel by hand every session.
How it could work
In #392 you mentioned that warm-up sets can already have their own rest time. A transition rest could follow the same pattern:
A global setting next to the rest timer ("Rest between exercises"), defaulting to "Same as the exercise's rest" so nothing changes for anyone who doesn't touch it.
Optionally, an override in each exercise's settings ("Rest before the next exercise").
Supersets keep their "Rest after each round" as they are.
The lookup order for the rest after an exercise's last set would be: exercise override, then global transition rest, then today's behaviour.
Thanks for considering it!
All reactions