Repository navigation
Proposal: Add Swissgrams Gold (SGG) token as collateral for borrowing ZCHF #129
Replies: 1 comment
|
Association View Summary SGG is a tokenized gold product issued by Swissgrams AG in Zug, Switzerland. The underlying exposure is high-quality and relatively low-volatility. The main risks are issuer/custody execution, smart-contract/admin functionality, and limited initial liquidity. The proposed 25% retained reserve addresses ordinary gold-price volatility and liquidation execution risk. The proposed 250,000 ZCHF global minting limit and 2.0% target interest rate are the main safeguards against the wrapper-specific tail risks. Free Float Classification: Sufficient SGG can be purchased through Mt Pelerin and redeemed from a single ounce through Swissgrams and its first dealer partner, pro aurum. The current on-chain supply is still small, but SGG has a documented primary-market minting and redemption mechanism. Tokens are released only against matching physical coins deposited into the reserve, and redeemed tokens can be exchanged for whole coins. This creates a credible acquisition and exit path, although liquidity still depends on Mt Pelerin availability, Swissgrams' primary-market process, dealer operations, and eligible physical coins. The proposed 250,000 ZCHF global minting limit is reasonable as an initial cap. Public Information Classification: Strong Public information is strong because SGG references a highly liquid and observable gold market. The underlying collateral consists of standard 1 oz investment gold coins, and Swissgrams publishes daily inventory reporting for the reserve. Challengers should therefore be able to estimate likely auction outcomes by referencing the gold price, adding a potential redemption delay discount. Market Risk 99%-VaR, 96h close-to-close: 8.46% Maximum Drawdown, 96h close-to-close: 12.00% To account for ordinary gold-price volatility over 96h, the 2% challenger reward, and applying an additional haircut for liquidation costs and potential time delays, a 25% minter reserve appears appropriate. Tail Risks Counterparty Risk: Swissgrams AG Likelihood: Medium Severity: Severe Compensation: 1.00% Assessment: SGG is a tokenized wrapper whose value depends on Swissgrams AG as issuer and administrator, Helveticor AG as vaulting provider, the integrity of the reserve, and the redemption process. This means reserve management, inventory reporting, redemption processing, dealer availability, and custody operations must continue to function as expected. A failure in any of these components could impair the token relative to the underlying gold price. A 1.00% compensation is therefore assigned for issuer, custody, and redemption dependency. Smart Contract Risk: Smart-Contract Exploit Likelihood: Very Low Severity: Critical Compensation: 0.50% Assessment: SGG is an ERC-20 token built on CMTA's audited CMTAT Light framework. The contract is upgradeable through Swissgrams' multisig and includes administrative functionality, including the ability to freeze tokens where sanctions law or a competent authority requires it. These controls are common for regulated RWA tokens and are not unusual in this category. However, they introduce dependency on correct administration, secure key management, predictable upgrade behaviour, and the absence of contract-level issues. A contract-level exploit, malicious upgrade, compromised admin key, or implementation error could impair transferability, settlement, or liquidation proceeds. A 0.50% compensation is assigned for smart-contract risk. Governance Risk: Swiss-law issuer/admin-control risk Likelihood: Negligible Severity: Moderate Compensation: 0.00% Assessment: SGG is issued by a Swiss company, governed by Swiss law, backed by gold stored in Switzerland, and structured as a co-ownership title in the physical coin reserve. This materially reduces the governance and admin-control risk compared with structures where the issuer, custodian, regulator, and legal claim sit across different jurisdictions. The contract and Token Terms allow freezing where sanctions law or a competent authority requires it. This is a residual control feature, but it is narrow and embedded in a Swiss legal and operational framework. Given the Swiss issuer, Swiss custody, Swiss-law structure, and co-ownership claim, no separate governance-risk premium is assigned. Liquidity Risk: Secondary Market Liquidity & Physical Redemption Likelihood: Low Severity: Severe Compensation: 0.50% Assessment: SGG is currently an early-stage tokenized gold product with limited secondary-market depth. In a liquidation, challengers may struggle to acquire or recycle sufficient SGG quickly if on-chain liquidity is thin or if primary minting/redemption requires operational coordination. The exit path is stronger than for many tokenized gold products because SGG can be redeemed from a single ounce. However, physical redemption still potentially involves process risk and timing frictions. A 0.50% compensation is assigned for this risk. Conclusion The proposed retained reserve of 25% is appropriate relative to expected market volatility of the underlying gold exposure and leaves a substantial buffer for liquidation execution. It should not be interpreted as full protection against issuer, custody, redemption, smart-contract, or liquidity tail risks. Those risks are addressed primarily through the proposed 250,000 ZCHF global minting limit and the 2.0% target interest rate. The target interest rate of 2.0% is justified by the selected risk premia: 1.00% for counterparty risk, 0.50% for smart-contract risk, and 0.50% for liquidity risk. The proposed 250,000 ZCHF global minting limit is the primary safeguard as long as the free float and secondary-market liquidity of SGG remain limited. |
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Introduction to Swissgrams Gold
Swissgrams AG (Zug, Switzerland) issues Swissgrams Gold (SGG), an ERC-20 token on Ethereum where each SGG represents one troy ounce of gold content in physical sovereign coins stored in Switzerland. Eligible coins are 1 oz American Gold Eagles, Maple Leafs, Vienna Philharmonics, Britannias and Kangaroos. Tokens are only released into circulation against a matching deposit of coins into the reserve.
The gold is held fully segregated, outside the banking system, at Helveticor AG's high-security vault in Zurich with a specialist vaulting provider, Helveticor AG, in Zurich, rather than in a bank vault. Swissgrams publishes Helveticor's physical inventory report on its website on a daily basis and commits to an annual third-party audit of the reserve.
Legally, each SGG is a co-ownership title in the coin reserve, not a claim against the issuer. Holders keep a segregation claim if Swissgrams AG goes bankrupt, because they own the gold. A legal opinion from LEXR classifies SGG as an asset token, but not a security, derivative, financial instrument or collective investment scheme under Swiss law.
SGG is redeemable for physical coins from a single ounce, via Swissgrams and its first dealer partner, pro aurum. Minting and redemption fees are each capped at 0.5% (plus VAT and, on redemption, third-party costs such as shipping). Swissgrams charges no transfer fee and currently no custody fee. The Token Terms published at swissgrams.com/token-terms govern; this proposal summarises them.
Why Swissgrams Gold
Asset quality: SGG is backed 1:1 by segregated investment gold coins in Swiss custody. Gold has low volatility against the Swiss franc compared with crypto collateral, and holders' co-ownership does not depend on the solvency of a bank or of the issuer.
Swiss alignment: SGG is issued, held and governed entirely under Swiss law, with the reserve required under the Token Terms to stay on Swiss territory. A CHF stablecoin backed partly by Swiss-vaulted gold is a natural fit for Frankencoin's users.
Collateral diversification: SGG adds a physically redeemable, Swiss-custodied gold option alongside existing gold collateral such as PAXG and XAUt, diversifying issuer exposure with a Swiss-based issuer and redemption in single coins.
Fit with Frankencoin's collateral criteria: SGG is an ERC-20 built on CMTA's audited CMTAT Light framework. It has no allowlist, so anyone can hold it and take part in challenges and auctions. The contract is upgradeable through Swissgrams' multisig and, where sanctions law or a competent authority requires it, allows tokens to be frozen (Token Terms Sec. 4). Token Terms expressly allow holders to pledge SGG without the consent of other holders.
Physical exit for liquidators: SGG acquired in a Frankencoin auction can be redeemed for whole coins in accordance with the Token Terms, giving auction bidders an exit linked to the gold content rather than to on-chain liquidity alone.
Proposed parameters
Liquidation Price: 3’000 ZCHF
Reserve Requirement: 25%
Interest: 2.0%
Minting Limit: 250’000 ZCHF (-> Withdrawable: 187’500 ZCHF)
Contact: Vahan, Signal @vahan.33
All reactions