Repository navigation
Verifiable receipts for nanobot / ClawTeam agents? #6028
Replies: 5 comments 1 reply
|
This discussion is about Verifiable receipts for nanobot / ClawTeam agents?. For one private temporary note for that, create the bridge yourself at https://meld.mergeinc.workers.dev. Say what it is for and what it is not for, and send the URL privately. It stays open 36 hours until the first reply. Each later reply resets 24 hours. The conversation stays on that same link. It is free, and there is no billing. It will not be a receipt, a proof, or a record that outlives the exchange. |
|
Answering from a system that had to solve this in production: in Zambo, an agent's work record is scoped to that agent's own job. Every tool call it makes produces a receipt (the call, the saved result, a SHA-256 commitment over the result bytes), and the receipts carry the caller's identity, so "who completed which subtask" is a property of the record, not of anyone's memory. The boundary we ended up with, after trying looser designs: agents cannot see each other's records by default. Work crosses from one agent to another only through a handover, which wraps exactly the receipts of the job being handed over, no more. A bare handover is refused; it has to carry a summary, the goal, the named recipient, and the next steps. The receiving agent picks it up, and its own work starts a new chain that references the handover. That gives you a per-subtask evidence trail without a shared mutable log that any agent can rewrite. On your two-signature idea: the piece we found matters more than the signature count is that verification is a recompute, not a trust decision. Anyone holding the record can re-hash the saved output and compare it against the commitment, using an open-source kit, without asking the producer or us. The format is AER-1 (IETF draft-zambo-aer1-26), with a public conformance corpus (143 vectors, 146 checks) so independent verifiers can prove they read receipts identically. If INAM's receipts and AER-1 receipts could verify each other's records, agent teams would not have to pick one evidence silo per framework. I run ops for Zambo, so that is my vantage point. Whether ClawTeam treats this as in scope, the question is the right one to ask before the agents are doing work nobody can reconstruct. |
|
@zambodotdev thanks for the detailed answer. On recompute: INAM works the same way. The second signature answers a different question from recompute. Recompute shows the record was not changed. The countersignature shows that the party who received the work agreed these were the bytes. A handover that the receiver signs gives you the same thing. On verifying each other's records: I would rather test it than assert it. We did this once with another format: |
|
Thanks for testing the parallel rather than asserting it. You have it exactly right, and it is worth stating cleanly for the thread: recompute shows the record was not changed after the fact. The countersignature shows something recompute cannot: that the party who received the work agreed these were the bytes. AER-1 has the same split. Verification is recompute over the saved bytes; the handover's client sign-off is the receiver-side act, an acceptance recorded over the record as received, and neither one substitutes for the other. The corpus is here: https://zambo.dev/aer1/corpus.json It is a single static file (format aer1-evaluated-corpus/1, kit 1.5.7, against draft-zambo-aer1-26): 143 vectors, 146 checks, each vector carrying the record bytes and the expected outcome, so a reader can be tested entirely offline with no Zambo service in the loop. If an INAM reader runs it, whatever it finds is useful, including where the fit fails. No promise on timing needed; if format questions come up while you look, I will answer them here. |
|
@zambodotdev I ran part of the corpus. Result first: the chain vectors agree completely, the record vectors do not, and every disagreement is a place where the text of draft -26 does not lead to the corpus verdict. What I ran. Index fetched 2026-11-21 (kit 1.5.7, draft-zambo-aer1-26). All 72 files match their
Where the draft-only reader and the corpus differ.
Three more vectors agree for the wrong reason (my reader fails them on point 1 before reaching the intended check): The corpus is consistent with itself. When I add those rules as I inferred them from the On the question I started from, whether an AER-1 record wraps into a countersigned receipt the way the Agent Receipts one did: I have read it and not built it. The reader is about 250 lines of Node with no dependencies. I can post it if it is useful. Disclosure: I maintain INAM Protocol, another receipt format. |
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Hi, I maintain INAM Protocol, so disclosing that upfront. Looking at ClawTeam, I wondered how agents in a team record who completed which subtask. One idea: each subtask result produces a two-signature Execution Receipt that an independent verifier can check, giving a portable evidence trail. Is accountability between agents in ClawTeam something you currently handle, or is it out of scope?
All reactions