Repository navigation
Rename Coverage and mass balance? Both already mean something else in other standards #56
slowking0199
started this conversation in
Proposals
Replies: 0 comments
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Two of the standard's core terms already have established meanings in the frameworks MASSIV+ is compared with. In both cases the other meaning is close enough to ours to be misread.
Coverage. In MASSIV+, Coverage is the share of a node's emissions that rests on actual data, declared by the sender itself (§8). Elsewhere the word means something else:
coveragePercentwas the share of the PCF included in the data quality assessment. It was removed in 3.0.coverageunder verification is the level the verification applies to.The GHG Protocol Scope 3 Standard and ESRS don't use the word. They do have the measure that comes closest to ours: the percentage of emissions calculated using data obtained from suppliers or other value chain partners (Scope 3 Standard, chapter 11, and ESRS 2023, E1-6 AR 46(g)). Neither gives it a short name.
An LCA practitioner reading "Coverage 0.8" would take it to mean that the data are 80% representative, or that 80% of the footprint is included after cut-off. We mean that 80% of the emission mass comes from senders that declared it themselves.
Mass balance. In MASSIV+ it means that a node passes on all its emissions, no more and no less, so nothing is counted twice (§5). Elsewhere the word means something else:
Ours is closer to bookkeeping than to any of these. What adds up is responsibility for emissions, not physical material. See MASSIV+ and ISO 22095 (in Swedish).
Proposal
Alternatives considered:
The ISO 14044 wording has so far been checked through secondary sources only, and will be checked against the original.
All reactions