Repository navigation
Feature request: Sum a handwritten column of numbers by drawing a line under it (like Apple Notes Math Notes) #228
kamilbunar
started this conversation in
Ideas
Replies: 1 comment
|
Hi, this feature came out on 2.10, so lmk how it works for you. |
0 replies
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Hi Joost, thank you for FineNotes. I use it for work notes and I like how much runs on-device.
Request
Please add a handwritten vertical sum like the one in Apple Notes (Math Notes). You write a stack of numbers by hand, draw a horizontal line under them, and the total appears automatically.
How it works in Apple Notes
Write numbers in a column with the pen.
Draw a horizontal line under the last number.
The total is calculated and shown below the line.
A symbol to the left of a number, such as a minus sign, changes the operation for that line.
The column is evaluated top to bottom.
If you change a number in the column, the total updates automatically.
Apple's guide: https://support.apple.com/guide/ipad/solve-math-with-math-notes-ipadeb38d0f8/ipados
What FineNotes does today
As far as I can tell from the 2.9.x release notes, a handwritten line ending in = is read as math by Grape and opens a maths card. That works well for single-line expressions, but I can't total a list of numbers written one under another.
Why it matters
I take work notes by hand, for example expense lists, quantities and invoice lines. Adding up a short column is something I do all the time. Right now I have to write each number again in a single = expression, or use a separate calculator. This is one of the few things I still miss from Apple Notes.
What I'm not asking for
I don't want a typed-text solution such as the Note Calc plugin. The point is to stay with handwriting and have the sum calculated from the handwritten numbers.
Suggested behavior (open to your design)
Trigger: A roughly horizontal line drawn directly under a column of handwritten numbers.
Recognition: Grape reads each line as a number. It would work with decimals and with a minus sign (or other operators) in the left margin.
Result: The total is shown in the same style as the current maths card, with the glow or the card. It would be nice to also show the recognized numbers, so I can spot a misread digit. "Turn into typed text" would also be handy.
Live update: Editing or erasing a number recalculates the total.
Everything local: On-device only, using Grape. No cloud AI needed.
Possible concerns
A horizontal line is a common stroke (underline, strikethrough, shape). It could help to only trigger when a numeric column sits directly above the line, or to make the gesture optional in settings.
Digit misreads would give wrong totals, so showing the recognized values would build trust.
I'm happy to test pre-release builds and to share some sample pages of my handwriting if that would help. I've also trained Grape on my handwriting, and it works well for me.
I'd like this to work with the way columns are written by hand in Austrian and German offices, for example in a tax advisor's workflow:
Amounts use a decimal comma and thousands dots (1.234,50), and optionally the ,- or ,-- notation for whole amounts.
Each line often has an item name and a date on the left, such as 12.03.2024. Only the right-hand amount column should be summed, and dates and document numbers must not be read as amounts.
Amounts are aligned by the decimal comma, as in ÖNORM A 1080 and DIN 5008. The sum line can be as long as the longest number, not the full text width.
A single line could mean a subtotal and a double line a final total.
Digit shapes follow the Austrian school script: the 7 with a crossbar, the 1 with an upstroke and an open 4.
Thanks for considering my very specific request!
All reactions