Repository navigation
💡 RFC: System One Decision Models (TypeSafe Jev) — Fast Typed Inference vs. Market Noise & Fee Hurdle #185
NeoNix-Lab
started this conversation in
Ideas
Replies: 0 comments
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Context & Background
Recently, a new paradigm of artificial intelligence models has emerged—epitomized by TypeSafe AI's Jev and "System One" decision architectures.
Unlike traditional Large Language Models (LLMs) that generate autoregressive text tokens, System One decision models discard text generation entirely. Instead, they accept structured inputs and produce typed classifications, choice distributions, and calibrated probabilities in milliseconds at ultra-low compute cost.
Naturally, the algorithmic trading community has begun exploring whether such models can serve as autonomous trading engines.
The Reality Check: Empirical Trading Evidence
Recent independent empirical evaluations on large intraday datasets (such as Siim's benchmark analyzing TypeSafe Jev across ~298,500 intraday trades) revealed a critical finding:
Takeaway: Speed and absence of text hallucinations cannot compensate for the low signal-to-noise ratio of raw financial time series. A fast model predicting noise simply loses capital faster.
Where Could "System One" Decision Models Actually Add Value?
In an institutional architecture like Quant Platform, we see promising secondary roles for fast typed inference models:
Rather than deciding "Buy vs. Sell", a System One model could evaluate:
acting as an execution gate that cancels resting limit orders before toxic flow arrives.
Rapid classification of market volatility states (e.g., Mean-Reverting vs. High-Momentum Breakout) to dynamically adjust cooldown timers (
DecisionIntent:Because our decision interface (ADR-0009) is learner-agnostic, any typed probability output can be directly mapped to a
DecisionIntent, allowing rigorous backtesting against our deterministic fee and slippage models.Open Questions for Discussion
Share your thoughts, experiences, and critical feedback below!
All reactions