You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
Next Up "end" detection should be based on file end and not the credits marker
#4443
"Next Up" behavior works inconsistently across apps - especially on Android TV.
In Android, the Next Up settings allow multiple options (At End, 10s, 30s, 60s, 120s) but these values seem to be tied to the beginning of the credits marker, and not the end of the file. This leads to the Next Up screen popping up at the beginning of the credits at best or during the end of episodes at worst.
On Web, the Next Up screen lacks customization but does seem to pop up 30s before file end which in most cases is timed well (towards the end of credits and logo rolls).
This is exacerbated with how busy the Next Up screen is - the screen shrinks super small, a row of related media is shown, and 3 actions. Next Up may be better served as a smaller popover, or at least simpler, so that the swap to next up isn't so visually jarring that you have to return to the media if you want any chance of seeing the credits or post-credits items.
Who it affects
As of my testing, primarily Android TV users (I don't have an Apple device to test). Web if we want to provide those users with the same controls Android receives over when Next Up appears.
Current workaround
None really - setting it to "At end" at least waits until the credits.
Proposed behavior
Next Up behavior should always be based on file end not the credits marker.
Optionally and far less important, a reconsideration of the Next Up UX to make it less busy and better for watching more without totally pushing the current episode away.
Additionally, there is no way to entirely disable next up (at least not obviously in the UI). Silo would already handle this well by sending people back to the show or homepage where the next episode would be waiting, but there's no option on Android to not show Next Up.
Alternatives considered
None that I'm aware of.
AI harness
None
AI tool(s)
None
AI model(s)
N/A
AI involvement
No AI used
Independent or adversarial review
N/A
Confirmations
I searched Ideas and the issue tracker, including issues closed as not planned, and this is not already proposed
reacted with thumbs up emoji reacted with thumbs down emoji reacted with laugh emoji reacted with hooray emoji reacted with confused emoji reacted with heart emoji reacted with rocket emoji reacted with eyes emoji
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Problem
"Next Up" behavior works inconsistently across apps - especially on Android TV.
In Android, the Next Up settings allow multiple options (At End, 10s, 30s, 60s, 120s) but these values seem to be tied to the beginning of the credits marker, and not the end of the file. This leads to the Next Up screen popping up at the beginning of the credits at best or during the end of episodes at worst.
On Web, the Next Up screen lacks customization but does seem to pop up 30s before file end which in most cases is timed well (towards the end of credits and logo rolls).
There are other issues with the Next Up settings in Android, but the focus on this discussion is the fact that "End" doesn't seem consistent.
This is exacerbated with how busy the Next Up screen is - the screen shrinks super small, a row of related media is shown, and 3 actions. Next Up may be better served as a smaller popover, or at least simpler, so that the swap to next up isn't so visually jarring that you have to return to the media if you want any chance of seeing the credits or post-credits items.
Who it affects
As of my testing, primarily Android TV users (I don't have an Apple device to test). Web if we want to provide those users with the same controls Android receives over when Next Up appears.
Current workaround
None really - setting it to "At end" at least waits until the credits.
Proposed behavior
Next Up behavior should always be based on file end not the credits marker.
Optionally and far less important, a reconsideration of the Next Up UX to make it less busy and better for watching more without totally pushing the current episode away.
Additionally, there is no way to entirely disable next up (at least not obviously in the UI). Silo would already handle this well by sending people back to the show or homepage where the next episode would be waiting, but there's no option on Android to not show Next Up.
Alternatives considered
None that I'm aware of.
AI harness
None
AI tool(s)
None
AI model(s)
N/A
AI involvement
No AI used
Independent or adversarial review
N/A
Confirmations
All reactions