Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

[Android] Google Play has removed 70% of all Sticker apps overnight #153

Closed
DaFaack opened this issue Nov 6, 2018 · 23 comments
Closed

[Android] Google Play has removed 70% of all Sticker apps overnight #153

DaFaack opened this issue Nov 6, 2018 · 23 comments

Comments

@DaFaack
Copy link

DaFaack commented Nov 6, 2018

Hey Developers,
I analyzed the "WhatsApp sticker" niche yesterday and noticed this morning that about 70% of the apps where removed.
I instantly took all of the "whatsapp" keywords out my app title, description, screens etc.
I currently would be very careful with sticker apps.
The fact that confuses me the most is that whatsapp want us to develop sticker apps but the Google Play store removes apps with the tags "WAStickerApps" and "WhatsApp".
Does anyone here got bad experiences and has some idea what to do?

@DaFaack DaFaack changed the title [Android] Google Play has removed 70% of all Sitcker apps over night [Android] Google Play has removed 70% of all Sticker apps overnight Nov 6, 2018
@simonzhexu
Copy link
Contributor

Thanks @DaFaack for letting us know. We are going to investigate on this. How can you tell that 70% of the apps are removed? When I search WAStickerApps, I still see a lot of apps that support WhatsApp stickers.

@DaFaack
Copy link
Author

DaFaack commented Nov 6, 2018

I took some screenshots of the available sticker apps yesterday. About 50 - 70% of the apps I screenshottet are no longer available in the Google Play store.
For example:
"Meme Stickers for Whatsapp" with 100.000+ downloads
"StickoText - Sticker Packs For Whatsapp" with 1.000.000+ downloads and
"Sticker Packs for WhatsApp" with 50.000+ downloads.

All of these apps are no longer available

@simonzhexu
Copy link
Contributor

OK. Thanks. For now, I would suggest not putting WhatsApp in the app name or description.

@ptkdev
Copy link

ptkdev commented Nov 6, 2018

My app is available io.ptkdev.wastickers

@nicolasdeory
Copy link

nicolasdeory commented Nov 6, 2018

This happened to me as well. I removed the tag "WAStickerApps" and the app was quickly reinstated. If it gets deleted again I'll remove "WhatsApp" as well.

I don't really think 'WhatsApp' is the problem, since a while ago I published a companion app for "Clash Royale", including that name both in the app name and description, and it hasn't been removed.

I would suggest that the WhatsApp devs should include a "Sticker App Policy" disclaimer somewhere in the official website, so if Google complains, we can just tell them that WhatsApp authorized us to use the trademark name for a sticker (companion) app. @simonzhexu

@simonzhexu
Copy link
Contributor

I have just checked in the latest read me instructing that developers do not use WhatsApp in the app name. Please make changes accordingly. Sorry for the frustrating experience. This is a new area we are exploring so please bear with us.

@simonzhexu
Copy link
Contributor

I would not suggest to remove WAStickerApps from the description though because then users won't be able to find your app through play store search.

@nicolasdeory
Copy link

nicolasdeory commented Nov 7, 2018

The thing is my app got deleted for that exact reason: including "WAStickerApps" in the app description. At least that's what Google said.

@lloydjf
Copy link

lloydjf commented Nov 7, 2018

I have reskinned the app a little bit and published to google playstore. I am using similar keywords in the description and name of the app. Do I need to remove that?
Whatsapp Stickers App

@ptkdev
Copy link

ptkdev commented Nov 7, 2018

@simonzhexu if you copy from Telegram, try copy it GOOD! Create a ios app and android app is very shit method. Yes is frustrating experience and yes whatsapp provide very bad experience for developers and users. Use brain next time for create the next feature copied by telegram.

@JAY0741
Copy link

JAY0741 commented Nov 9, 2018

The thing is my app got deleted for that exact reason: including "WAStickerApps" in the app description. At least that's what Google said.

You need to build a release version of your app for submission to the Google Play Store. Click Build > Generate Signed Bundle/APK. For more information, visit https://developer.android.com/studio/publish/app-signing#sign-apk. Note that Android Studio saves the APKs you build in project-name/module-name/build/outputs/apk. For more information on building your app, visit https://developer.android.com/studio/run/.

https://github.com/WhatsApp/stickers/tree/master/Android
Submit your app
Importantly, when naming your app, it is strongly advised you do not use "WhatsApp" anywhere in the name of your app or in the name field of your app listing on the Google Play Store. However, when preparing your app for submission in Google Play Store, you'll have the option to add description associated with your app and it's okay to mention WhatsApp in the description. WhatsApp can also launch the Google Play Store and perform a search for other sticker pack apps. To help your app appear in this list, also add the keyword WAStickerApps to app's description when setting up your app in the Google Play Store console. You can use additional keywords, but make sure you at least use this one.

To submit your app to the Google Play Store, follow the instructions here:
https://developer.android.com/distribute/best-practices/launch/.

report to google

@0566055455
Copy link

My app got suspended, can you help?

@marioortizmanero
Copy link

You seem to have been affected by a hoax. Check issue #190 . @simonzhexu please check it out

@gbougakov
Copy link

I have a similar issue, but with iOS App Store. My app can't pass App Review because Apple sees it as spam. Please check out #230

@MarsVard
Copy link

I took some screenshots of the available sticker apps yesterday. About 50 - 70% of the apps I screenshottet are no longer available in the Google Play store.
For example:
"Meme Stickers for Whatsapp" with 100.000+ downloads
"StickoText - Sticker Packs For Whatsapp" with 1.000.000+ downloads and
"Sticker Packs for WhatsApp" with 50.000+ downloads.

All of these apps are no longer available

"meme stickers for WhatsApp" was put back up the next day, misunderstanding about "update whatsapp dialog"

@0566055455
Copy link

My app had +900K downloads, removed from using WhatsApp in the title. my other app didnt have much downloads but was removed too for using WhatsApp in the title.

@MarsVard
Copy link

@0566055455 but it seems like you wrote WhatsApp wrong and it's clearly against the WhatsApp brand guidelines.

@0566055455
Copy link

Nope.

@simonzhexu
Copy link
Contributor

Try removing WhatsApp from your app name.

@ptkdev
Copy link

ptkdev commented Nov 15, 2018

@simonzhexu thanks for useless solution

@0566055455
Copy link

0566055455 commented Nov 15, 2018

@simonzhexu My account got terminated, how can I remove WhatsApp from the title now..

Also appdetex support is VERY bad, The worst experience I ever had

@Yleader10
Copy link

@ptkdev please can you share the sticker app source withe me

@hitendobariya
Copy link

My app is available io.ptkdev.wastickers

very good app

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests