Repository navigation
A Serious and Extremely Unfair XRPL Transaction Ordering Exploit Is Still Being Abused — Even After Being Reported Months Ago #670
Replies: 1 comment
|
Thank you for documenting these on-chain examples, @HoneyCreatorB. We have independently analyzed this vulnerability across Mainnet ledgers and just published a formal Amendment Proposal with the mathematical root-cause analysis, additional empirical Mainnet evidence (including 👉 Discussion #679 — Amendment Proposal: Canonical Transaction Ordering Why the wallets you observed (
|
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
I'm posting this because I genuinely think something needs to be done about a serious transaction-ordering issue on the XRP Ledger.
I've been trading on FirstLedger for quite some time, and I've repeatedly seen certain wallets gain an unfair advantage whenever a new AMM pool is created.
I actually reported this issue several months ago and received a response acknowledging my concerns.
I appreciated getting a response, but several months have passed, and I still haven't seen any visible fix or mitigation. More importantly, I continue to observe the same suspicious behavior across new token launches.
I've recently submitted another report with additional on-chain evidence.
At this point, I believe the issue deserves more public attention.
What is happening?
XRPL uses deterministic transaction ordering. However, I've observed that certain specially prepared wallet addresses appear to gain a predictable advantage in the transaction order when a new AMM is created.
These wallets repeatedly seem to secure the very first buying position immediately after the AMM becomes available, even when other traders submit earlier or pay higher transaction fees.
From my observations, this is not simply a matter of someone having a faster connection or paying a higher fee.
It appears that certain traders are deliberately taking advantage of address-dependent transaction ordering to secure favorable positions.
This is an extremely unfair exploit in the context of memecoin launches.
When a token launches, the difference between the first buy and the next few buys can be enormous.
A trader who repeatedly gets the first position can buy tokens at a significantly lower price. Everyone else is left buying after the price has already moved.
How are ordinary traders supposed to compete fairly against that?
Actual on-chain examples
Below are three examples I've collected. In each case, I observed a wallet with a suspicious address relationship to the AMM creator apparently securing the earliest buying position.
The transaction hashes are provided so others can independently review the ledger metadata and verify the execution order.
Evidence 1
AMM creator wallet:
r4PCdxLajHQhjroYyT6PMLh27DxmdzANrC
Reported first-buy wallet:
r4PCdxLajHQ16VjiMmnFu1UMnnZhKpmXZh
AMM transaction:
A7EF1D16307AC57F8D994C928608CA6D55E455C8C1A5AFB3739DEA94D2F1CB4D
Buy transaction:
E7B6018330972159F977EFAA70108CC197A724BD38B729F3982C7C91EDB9B261
Token issuer:
r4tPgvSFTJYMxqLZsz9R6i2mykXUAZ6298
Evidence 2
AMM creator wallet:
rNdzqzavK94Q6TWzbtcaqPXsCinxTyyyYy
Reported first-buy wallet:
rNdzqzavK9KXNpJmCq6Mizg8kjwUwQqu2v
AMM transaction:
C500737E3E8AC0D82606DE60DAF90EA26DD7EAC7AEF8BFEFFB515F744AF78B04
Buy transaction:
B5488F0E86045043DEAE01370FE72ACF3958AB036C6361F109600C9B0A144154
Token issuer:
rJ2jagUzpyVjGWeUNv5fRotw7VzeNt3J53
Evidence 3
AMM creator wallet:
rsxiNgEqMYNttyNVr3R928hgfydJ1tS9np
Reported first-buy wallet:
rsxiNgEqMVzU4RX6NqEypzhEMACXQybtqE
AMM transaction:
7A8D39C227C4A404671D94240E9641C55797DFD4C8C9D5D4EF00BC7677638AFD
Buy transaction:
93CBBB79502D652E2ADE54B1AE5187AE809AF5E446D6AF81718E4A01AF20936C
Token issuer:
rUWh9QNmPbwQDtULiZWRiAxCHZiGb9sAUC
This is much bigger than three examples
These are only a few examples.
I can provide more than 10 additional cases, and potentially as many as 100 examples across different token launches where wallets using this apparent exploit repeatedly secured the first buying position.
Based on what I've observed, I suspect that the people involved are generating and storing large numbers of specially prepared wallet addresses in advance, possibly using significant computing infrastructure.
This doesn't look like random luck to me.
It looks like a deliberate and repeatable strategy.
I estimate that at least 200,000 XRP has been made through this activity
Based on my own tracking, I estimate that wallets associated with this activity have collectively made at least 200,000 XRP in profits.
This is my preliminary estimate, not an independently audited figure. A full review of the relevant trades, costs, transfers and wallet relationships would be needed to establish the exact amount.
Some wallets that I believe warrant further investigation include:
I'm listing these as wallets of concern based on my observations, not as proof that they are all controlled by the same person or that each address has committed fraud.
I believe their activities and potential connections deserve an independent on-chain investigation.
Some of the suspected operators may also be launching their own tokens
This is probably the most concerning part for me.
I've also observed patterns suggesting that some of the people taking advantage of this issue may be involved in launching tokens themselves on platforms such as FirstLedger.
If someone can launch a token, use a predictable ordering advantage to acquire a large position before other traders, and then dump those tokens onto later buyers, that creates a serious risk of coordinated market manipulation.
Ordinary traders may end up buying at inflated prices without realizing that someone else had a systematic advantage from the beginning.
I am not claiming that every suspicious launch is a proven rug pull. But I believe these patterns need to be investigated seriously.
This is not just about who has the fastest trading setup. It's about whether certain participants can repeatedly obtain an advantage that ordinary traders have no realistic way to compete against.
This was reported months ago. Why is it still happening?
As I mentioned earlier, I already raised this issue several months ago and received a response.
I understand that the problem may be related to XRPL's existing canonical transaction ordering mechanism, and that modifying consensus-related behavior may be technically difficult.
But I don't believe "it's difficult to fix" should mean the issue is simply left as it is.
Even if the current mechanism is technically working as designed, that does not automatically mean its economic consequences are fair.
If people can repeatedly exploit the ordering rules to take the earliest positions in new AMM pools, the impact on regular traders should not be ignored.
I'm not expecting developers to change a fundamental part of the ledger overnight.
But I would like to see a serious technical assessment, a discussion of possible mitigations, and some transparency about whether this issue is being actively addressed.
What I'm hoping to achieve with this post
I'm not posting this to teach anyone how to reproduce or abuse the exploit.
In fact, I specifically want to avoid making the situation worse.
What I want is for XRPL developers, validators, security researchers and the wider community to take this seriously.
I would like to see:
I've already contacted the relevant security channels again and am willing to provide additional transaction records privately to qualified researchers.
I genuinely care about the XRPL ecosystem, and I want FirstLedger and other XRPL trading platforms to grow.
But a healthy ecosystem needs fair competition.
A system where a small group of traders can repeatedly secure the first buying position through a predictable ordering advantage is not fair competition.
Even if this behavior is a consequence of the protocol's current design, its potential for abuse should not be dismissed.
I hope the developers and the wider community will take a serious look at this.
If you're an XRPL developer or security researcher and would like to independently review the additional evidence, I'm happy to cooperate.
I would also genuinely like to hear from the community: Should this be treated as an acceptable consequence of deterministic ordering, or as a serious fairness issue that needs to be addressed?
All reactions