Repository navigation
Silo integration #217
Replies: 4 comments 1 reply
|
Silo support is dropping today with Ether v0.3 |
|
@braedonsaunders Thoughts on something... Now that I've had some time to experiment with Ether's Silo support, I've been thinking about how this could evolve into something even more useful, especially for those of us considering moving away from Plex entirely. One of the things I really appreciate about Ether's Plex integration is the Step Aside functionality. My existing Plex server hosts my local collection, while Ether provides on-demand content. The two coexist nicely, and Step Aside helps ensure that locally available content takes priority. The challenge with Silo is that while Ether now supports Silo clients, my actual Silo installation and Ether's virtual Silo server are still two completely independent servers. Unlike Plex, Silo doesn't offer a unified experience across multiple servers and I highly doubt the Silo developers would consider implementing a feature like that. So here's an idea I'd love your thoughts on. What if Ether could connect to an existing Silo Media Server and incorporate its local library directly into Ether's Silo frontend? For example:
Ideally, viewers would see one unified catalog without needing to switch servers or even know where the content originates. Essentially, it would be a more advanced version of Step Aside, with Ether acting as the bridge between my local Silo server and its own on-demand content. I realize this is considerably more involved than the existing Plex implementation, particularly since Ether would need to handle library discovery, matching, and potentially proxying local playback. But here's why I think it could be interesting: it would allow Ether to provide functionality that Silo itself doesn't offer, without requiring any changes from the Silo developers. For people like me who maintain large local collections and share with numerous remote users, this could be the missing piece that finally makes replacing Plex with Silo practical. Do you think something like this would be technically feasible with Ether's current architecture? Or are there limitations in the Silo protocol that would make it impractical? |
|
Thanks, that's a well-argued idea, and I think it's the right direction. Today Step Aside only works because Plex merges servers in its own apps: Ether just steps out of the way and Plex shows your real server's copy. Silo, Jellyfin and Emby apps don't merge servers, so stepping aside can't work there. The fix is what you describe: Ether uses your existing media server as a source. How I'd shape it:
It's a substantial feature: library sync, matching, and proxied playback per server type. So it isn't in the immediate releases. I'm adding it to the roadmap as a "Media server source", with Silo and Jellyfin as the first targets. If you can share roughly how big your Silo library is and whether your viewers are remote or on your LAN, that helps size the proxying side. |
|
Thanks! I really like this approach, especially the idea of Ether using Silo as a local media source rather than simply hiding duplicate titles. For some background on my setup:
Having Ether check Silo first and use Usenet/debrid only when something isn't available locally would be ideal. I especially like that viewers could continue using a single Ether catalog without needing to know whether the content is coming from Silo or Usenet. One additional consideration (but I don't think it will matter): I also have some InfiniDysk-managed content in Silo (symlinks). I'm guessing Ether would be able to recognized those perfectly fine? I understand this is a substantial feature and not something for the immediate releases, but I'm glad to hear it's going on the roadmap! Thank you |
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Who else would be interested in having Ether work with Silo media server? I'm not a fan of Emby or Jellyfin and while Plex is still the king, Silo is gaining some massive momentum and I honestly believe it will be the new champion of home media servers.
All reactions