P2947 R0 Contracts must avoid disclosing sensitive information

[wg21bot]

P2947R0 Contracts must avoid disclosing sensitive information (Andrei Zissu, Ran Regev, Gal Zaban, Inbal Levi)

[mathstuf]

Forwarded to SG15.

[rogerorr]

SG23 polls taken 2023-11-08

POLL: We support the recommendation in this paper that an implementation shall provide a way for accessors to return no information.

Strongly Favor	Favor	Neutral	Against	Strongly Against
3	0	6	14	1

Weak consensus against

POLL: We want SG15 to investigate a solution to address the concerns of information leaking into binaries.

Strongly Favor	Favor	Neutral	Against	Strongly Against
12	10	2	0	0

Strong consensus

[Bigcheese]

SG15 discussed this 2023-11-09

Polls:
SG15 defers to SG21 the decision on requring the option of anonymizing contracts
as tooling vendors will be able to address this regardless as QoI.

SF	F	N	A	SA
8	8	2	0	0

Consensus

SG15 is interested in producing a document on recommendations for binary anonymization.

SF	F	N	A	SA
9	4	4	0	0

Consensus

[timuraudio]

It is not within SG21's scope to decide whether this is actually a safety & security issue; therefore, SG21 will not consider this paper unless directed to do so by SG23. Since SG23 did not have consensus to do so, this issue can be closed.