P1818 Narrowing and Widening Conversions

[wg21bot]

P1818R0 Narrowing and Widening Conversions (Lawrence Crowl)

[theres-waldo]

This was looked at by EWG-I in draft form, in July 2019 (Cologne).

Do we want to spend committee time on built-in type issues?

SF	F	N	A	SA
1	6	3	1	0

Do we want to spend committee time on user-defined type issues?

SF	F	N	A	SA
1	6	5	2	0

Given that the R0 paper appeared in the post-Cologne mailing, I assume it's the paper as presented in Cologne, not a revision. Marking as needs-revision accordingly.

[wg21bot]

P1818R1 Narrowing and Widening Conversions (Lawrence Crowl)

[theres-waldo]

EWG-I in Prague

Poll: Given the committee's limited time constraints, spend more time on this problem?

SF	F	N	A	SA
1	3	2	3	0

No consensus to proceed at this time. Note: the quorum in the room was very small (9 people) when this poll was taken.

Next steps for paper: could come back to EWG-I with additional motivation.

[cor3ntin]

Given this had no consensus and some time has passed, I'm closing the issue.
The issue will be reopened automatically if a new revision is uploaded.