You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
What would people think about adding a Calibrate option to Wholphin that automatically figures out the best playback settings for your hardware and TV?
I realize everyone here knows to enable HDR, Dolby Vision, and HDR10+ on their TV, configure their Shield correctly, and tweak Wholphin's advanced settings. This is not for admins. This is for users.
Everyone I know just ends up transcoding things their hardware could probably play natively and better.
How it would work
Wholphin combines three things:
What we know: Identify the hardware and its known limitations. For example, the NVIDIA Shield cannot fully process DV Profile 7 FEL.
What Android reports: Detect display HDR capabilities, codecs, audio formats, refresh rates, etc.
What we can test: Play short samples using different settings, observe decoder errors, dropped frames, playback stability, and conversion paths.
Wholphin could even find one of each relevant video format already in the user's Jellyfin library, rather than requiring bundled test clips for everything.
It then selects and saves the best working settings.
One button, no questions. The TV might flicker or switch HDR modes for a few seconds.
The calibration could have a 'restore stock settings' each time you press it as an option.
Server-side diagnostics
We could also leverage jellyfin-plugin-wholphin to store the last known calibration results and diagnostics per device. We could add the ability to have the plugin queue up a Calibration for a device ID so that the next time a user connects, it starts the diagnostic for them. (obviously, they choose to do it).
As a server admin, it would be incredibly useful to see:
Device, Android version, and detected display capabilities.
Supported codecs and HDR formats.
Calibration results and selected settings.
Decoder failures, fallbacks, and compatibility issues.
Instead of walking someone through settings they don't understand, I could just look at what their device reported.
Diagnostic uploads could happen after calibration, with an option to disable sharing. No need for continuous telemetry.
Considerations
Known hardware limitations eliminate unnecessary tests.
Calibration results can be cached and invalidated after relevant hardware or software changes.
Manual overrides remain available.
Failed tests should never leave playback broken.
The idea is simply to use what we know, discover what we can, and test the rest.
Not everything can be determined automatically, but surely we can get people much closer to an optimal configuration without asking them to understand Dolby Vision profiles.
reacted with thumbs up emoji reacted with thumbs down emoji reacted with laugh emoji reacted with hooray emoji reacted with confused emoji reacted with heart emoji reacted with rocket emoji reacted with eyes emoji
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Description
What would people think about adding a Calibrate option to Wholphin that automatically figures out the best playback settings for your hardware and TV?
I realize everyone here knows to enable HDR, Dolby Vision, and HDR10+ on their TV, configure their Shield correctly, and tweak Wholphin's advanced settings. This is not for admins. This is for users.
Everyone I know just ends up transcoding things their hardware could probably play natively and better.
How it would work
Wholphin combines three things:
Wholphin could even find one of each relevant video format already in the user's Jellyfin library, rather than requiring bundled test clips for everything.
It then selects and saves the best working settings.
One button, no questions. The TV might flicker or switch HDR modes for a few seconds.
The calibration could have a 'restore stock settings' each time you press it as an option.
Server-side diagnostics
We could also leverage
jellyfin-plugin-wholphinto store the last known calibration results and diagnostics per device. We could add the ability to have the plugin queue up a Calibration for a device ID so that the next time a user connects, it starts the diagnostic for them. (obviously, they choose to do it).As a server admin, it would be incredibly useful to see:
Instead of walking someone through settings they don't understand, I could just look at what their device reported.
Diagnostic uploads could happen after calibration, with an option to disable sharing. No need for continuous telemetry.
Considerations
The idea is simply to use what we know, discover what we can, and test the rest.
Not everything can be determined automatically, but surely we can get people much closer to an optimal configuration without asking them to understand Dolby Vision profiles.
Thoughts?
All reactions