You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
case'stop':
// A terminal stop that produced no content blocks is a degenerate// provider completion, not a successful (empty) assistant message.if(message.content.length===0){return{kind: 'error',failure: {message: `model "${message.model}" returned a completed response with no content`,code: EMPTY_RESPONSE_CODE,},}}return{kind: 'stop'}
reacted with thumbs up emoji reacted with thumbs down emoji reacted with laugh emoji reacted with hooray emoji reacted with confused emoji reacted with heart emoji reacted with rocket emoji reacted with eyes emoji
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Summary
当模型以
stop结束、且响应内容只有思考块(thinking)而没有任何text块时,DSH 把它判为成功并原样落盘;用户界面上只出现一个折叠的思考过程,没有回答气泡,也不触发重试。空响应判定只在「一个内容块都没有」时才生效,thinking-only 从旁边溜过去了。影响:任何带长思考的模型(尤其思考预算高、或长提示把答案先写进思考段的情况)都可能偶发「发送后没有任何回复」。用户侧无报错、无提示,只能反复追问。
Environment
0.2.2-rc.339163dd30f(2026-11-13,merge PR DSH | dsh-hypercompact | byte-budget context compaction with no LLM call, and byte-exact recall #8422)dsh web/ Web 客户端wincodeprovider,deepseek-v4-1-flash-261017anthropic-messagesReproduction
稳定复现的证据来自会话记录(
~/.dsh/sessions/<workspace>/session-<id>/session.v4.jsonl.zstd,多帧 zstd,需按28 b5 2f fd魔数切帧逐帧解压):同一会话内 7 个
stopReason=stop的 step 统计:两个失败 step 的
content数组只有{type:'reasoning'}一个元素,stopReason为stop(不是length、不是error),且reasoning.text末尾原样包含本应作为正文的完整回答。Current behavior
packages/llm/llm-pi-ai/src/stream.ts:103-116:content只有一个reasoning块时content.length === 1,不满足=== 0,直接返回{ kind: 'stop' }。后果链:EMPTY_RESPONSE不进 retry。该码本在默认可重试集合内(packages/llm/llm/src/retry-policy.ts:19-25:EMPTY_RESPONSE/RATE_LIMIT/SERVER/TIMEOUT/TRANSPORT),但因为走了stop分支,重试策略根本不介入。surfaceOp: 'append'的正常assistant/message,不产生llm/retry事件、不产生错误。packages/client/ui-chat/src/client/conversation-nodes/turn-process.ts:56-58用block.text.trim() !== ''判可见,reasoning也算可见,于是该消息在界面上呈现为折叠思考块 —— 正文气泡本来就不存在。该行为是被测试显式锁定的,不是遗漏:
packages/llm/llm-pi-ai/tests/convert.spec.ts:892-895用例引入于
207aab9d8d(2026-07-24,fix(llm): classify empty model completions as retryable EMPTY_RESPONSE)。当时的设定「任何块都算内容」在不产生独立思考通道的模型上成立;对带 thinking 通道的模型,这个前提已经不成立。Expected behavior
stop且内容中不存在任何非 thinking 块(即只有reasoning/thinking)应判为EMPTY_RESPONSE,进入既有可重试路径,由重试策略重新生成正文;若重试耗尽,用户应看到明确错误,而不是静默的空回答。判定建议:
(
message.content的实际块类型名请以AssistantMessage的类型定义为准,thinking与reasoning在不同协议层命名不一致。)注意:改动同时必须修订
convert.spec.ts:892那条用例,否则行为被测试锁死、CI 判红。这属于对外可观察行为的变更,需要维护方决策。可选的产品侧兜底(与上述判定正交):客户端在「本轮已结束、且唯一可见内容是 reasoning」时给出显式提示(如「模型未返回正文,可重试本轮」),避免用户以为消息丢了。
补充线索
toolUse的 step 不受影响(stopReason为toolUse,走另一分支),所以表现为「工具用得越多越不容易踩到」。assistant/message的content块类型、text总长与stopReason,stopReason=stop && textLen=0即为命中。hasIssuesEnabled: false,因此按CONTRIBUTING.zh.md的指引发在 Discussions。若需要改走 Issue 或其他渠道,请告知。All reactions