EnC: Improving the experience

[tmat]

This is an umbrella issue for work towards improving the Edit and Continue/Hot Reload experience in C# and VB.

Language and compiler features

• Lambdas:
  • EnC - Allow capturing new variables in lambdas #54672
  • E&C: Using a lambda-captured variable in an async method throws NRE at runtime & debugger #15542
  • Rude edit for lambda signature changes seems wrong #3978
  • [Enc] Adding a constructor to a type with field/property initializers that contain lambdas #2504
  • EnC Razor scenario: allow adding new lambda closures #67841
  • EnC: default lambda parameters #69246
• StackAlloc:
  • EnC: Allow stackalloc in non-active members #67307
• Renames and signature changes
  • EnC: Update names of deleted members to a special name #70117
  • EnC: Allow signature changes and method/field/etc renames #59264
  • EnC: Renaming a property with initializer doesn't work as expected #69216
  • EnC: Changing signature of an async method or an iterator does not work #69199
  • EnC: Add a code action that updates all call-sites of a method with changed signature #69197
  • MissingMethodException when calling method prior to hot reload change #65442
  • EnC: Emit trampoline for deleted property that shadows primary parameter #69317
• Member reodering
  • EnC: support member reordering edits #69894
• More support for editing Async
  • EnC: allow editing all await expressions unless they are active #54096
• Other
  • EnC: nint and nuint should be treated as equivalent to IntPtr and UIntPtr #48637
  • EnC: Allow changing nullable annotations #49011
  • DIM EnC: Adding a non-virtual member to an interface fails at runtime #37128
  • EnC: support moving fields and properties #69247

17.8

• Primary constructors
  • Implement EnC support for Primary Constructors #67108 (17.8 P1)
  • Primary constructor properties have sequence points but breakpoints can't be placed #63299 (17.8 P1)
• Inline Arrays, Collection Literals:
  • EnC: Inline Arrays #69245 (17.8 P2)
  • Compiler crashes when emitting EnC delta for assembly with synthesized inline array types  #69398 (17.8 P2)
• StackAlloc improvements:
  • Rude edits not detected when changing (primary) constructor initializer #68731
  • Program crashes on second hot reload with stackalloc on method body #69027
  • EnC: Deleting record method that shadows a synthesized one and contains stackalloc may crash the app #69493

17.7

• EnC: Implements support for generic type/method updates #67918

17.4

• EnC: allow adding/removing await expressions in async method #54095

17.3

• EnC: allow adding a namespace declaration #51398 (17.3 P2)
• [EnC] Allow renaming methods, properties, events etc. #62364
• [EnC] Allow deleting method #61806

17.0

• Expand #line to support columns #46526 (17.0 P2)
• A change in a top-level statement or an addition of a new top-level statement is not picked up by ENC #44196 (17.0 P3)
• EnC: Updating lambda parameters to discards breaks EnC #48635 (17.0 P3)
• EnC - Allow parameter renames #52563 (17.0 P3)
• EnC: Allow adding/removing/updating attributes #49012 (17.0 P2)
  • Follow up: EnC - Attribute updates on parameters don't get emitted #54777
  • Follow up: EnC - More attribute edit tests #54430
• compilation.EmitDifference produces no updated methods when "#line hidden" is present #49631 (17.0 P2)
• Enable EnC of methods containing switch expressions #43099 (17.0 P2)
• EnC: support for record structs #51200 (17.0 P2)
• EnC: validate mixed declarations and variables in deconstruction #50901 (17.0 P4)

16.x

• EnC: Adding/updating/removing attribute on local function, its return type or parameter should be rude edit #48636 (16.10)
• Enc: Adding a namespace import shouldn't be a rude edit #10043 (16.10)
• Allow adding members to and updating constructors of a partial class #50016 (16.10)
• EnC: support edits in files generated via source generators #50283 (16.10)
• Support EnC on records and with expressions #44877 (16.11)

Project system changes

• EnC: allow adding/renaming source file during debugging/hot reload #49013
  • EnC: Rude edits not reported when file is added by Generate from Usage #32494
• EnC: allow adding/renaming source file during debugging/hot reload #49013
• EnC Scenario: deleting a file doesn't display rude edit #41144
• EnC: allow adding a package/project/metadata reference during debugging #49015
• Allow projects to be loaded/added unloaded/removed during EnC/HR session #1204

16.10

• EnC: allow moving type to another file #50876

Edits while application is running

• EnC: F5 applies change made during debugging session while the app is running #49004
• Update EnC error messages used for Hot Reload #52018
• Implement Ctlr+F5 Hot Reload coordinator and Apply Changes command 1304576
• Create stale view for .NET hot reload stale methods 1384582

Attach

• Support for attaching debugger after Hot Reload changes made
• EnC: support EnC while attached to multiple processes #52613

Reloadable types

• EnC: Emit addition instead of in-place update for edits in reloadable types #49006 (17.0 P3)
• Renaming/changing arity of a reloadable type is not handled correctly #54881
• Allow renaming reloadable types #54886

Hot Reload runtime events

• EnC: Calculate updated type definition tokens and pass it to the debugger #52585 (17.0 P2)

Runtime specific Rude Edits

• EnC: Runtime-specific Rude Edits #49010 (16.10)
• EnC: Report rude edit when compiler adds synthesized types to the compilation and runtime does not support adding types #54676

Partner Hot Reload APIs

• Expose EnC analysis APIs to Razor via External Access  #50773 (16.10)
• Make EnC analysis APIs required by watch tool public #50774
• Multiple Client support from EnC Workspace Service #53701 (17.0 P2)

Misc

• IsActiveStatementInExceptionRegionAsync: https://devdiv.visualstudio.com/DevDiv/_workitems/edit/1310859
• Active statements: https://devdiv.visualstudio.com/DevDiv/_workitems/edit/1301343
• Ctrl+S and open files: https://devdiv.visualstudio.com/DevDiv/_workitems/edit/1354232 (17.0 P2)

[tmat]

@jinujoseph @LyalinDotCom @davidwengier

[tmat]

Telemetry on Rude Edits:

Active Statements

(ActiveStatementUpdate, None, 36299)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, CatchClause, 14642)
(DeleteActiveStatement, None, 11601)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, ForEachStatement, 5891)
(InsertAroundActiveStatement, ForEachStatement, 2203)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, OnErrorGoToLabelStatement, 2096)
(InsertAroundActiveStatement, TryStatement, 1824)
(DeleteAroundActiveStatement, CatchClause, 1623)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, CatchBlock, 1607)
(InsertAroundActiveStatement, CatchClause, 1579)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, OnErrorResumeNextStatement, 1385)
(InsertAroundActiveStatement, AwaitExpression, 1258)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, TryStatement, 1138)
(DeleteAroundActiveStatement, TryStatement, 1103)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, ForEachBlock, 1087)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, FinallyClause, 1074)
(PartiallyExecutedActiveStatementUpdate, None, 844)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, UsingStatement, 770)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, WithBlock, 175)
(InsertAroundActiveStatement, ForEachBlock, 170)
(InsertAroundActiveStatement, TryBlock, 163)
(InsertAroundActiveStatement, CatchBlock, 162)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, TryBlock, 123)

Lambdas

(ChangingLambdaParameters, SimpleLambdaExpression, 34373)
(CapturingVariable, None, 26315)
(NotCapturingVariable, None, 16326)
(ChangingLambdaReturnType, SimpleLambdaExpression, 11203)
(DeletingCapturedVariable, None, 5208)
(ChangingCapturedVariableType, None, 3532)
(NotAccessingCapturedVariableInLambda, None, 2995)
(AccessingCapturedVariableInLambda, None, 2624)
(ChangingLambdaParameters, ParenthesizedLambdaExpression, 2585)
(ChangingQueryLambdaType, WhereClause, 2376)
(ChangingQueryLambdaType, JoinClause, 2023)
(ChangingQueryLambdaType, SelectClause, 1394)
(InsertLambdaWithMultiScopeCapture, None, 925)
(ChangingLambdaReturnType, ParenthesizedLambdaExpression, 1063)
(ChangingQueryLambdaType, GroupClause, 412)
(ChangingQueryLambdaType, WhereClause, 255)
(RenamingCapturedVariable, None, 465)
(ChangingLambdaReturnType, SingleLineFunctionLambdaExpression, 321)
(ChangingQueryLambdaType, FromClause, 738)
(ChangingLambdaParameters, SingleLineFunctionLambdaExpression, 737)

Usings (supported in 16.10 - #10043)

(Insert, UsingDirective, 24132)
(Delete, UsingDirective, 6570)
(Insert, ImportsStatement, 897)
(Update, UsingDirective, 814)
(Delete, ImportsStatement, 238)

Generics (Supported on .NET 8 and VS 17.7)

(GenericMethodUpdate, MethodDeclaration, 10609)
(GenericTypeUpdate, MethodDeclaration, 7234)
(GenericMethodTriviaUpdate, MethodDeclaration, 2527)
(GenericTypeTriviaUpdate, MethodDeclaration, 1810)
(GenericMethodUpdate, FunctionBlock, 216)

Async and iterators (supported in 17.4)

(Delete, AwaitExpression, 9186)
(Insert, AwaitExpression, 8006)
(AwaitStatementUpdate, None, 3621)

Attribute (supported in 17.0 P2)

(Update, Attribute, 6922)
(Insert, AttributeList, 4560)
(Delete, AttributeList, 3256)
(Delete, Attribute, 106)

Partial Types (supported in 16.10 - #50016)

(PartialTypeInitializerUpdate, VariableDeclarator, 4504)
(PartialTypeInitializerUpdate, VariableDeclarator, 519)
(PartialTypeInitializerUpdate, ModifiedIdentifier, 499)

Member deletes and renames (some support in 17.3, improvements in 17.8)

(Delete, MethodDeclaration, 9822)
(Delete, FieldDeclaration, 5802)
(Delete, PropertyDeclaration, 6006)
(Delete, Parameter, 4148)
(Delete, SubBlock, 1201)
(Delete, FunctionBlock, 353)
(Delete, SetAccessorDeclaration, 314)
(Renamed, Parameter, 5695)
(Renamed, MethodDeclaration, 4795)
(Renamed, PropertyDeclaration, 3578)
(Renamed, VariableDeclarator, 2231)
(Renamed, ClassDeclaration, 739)
(Renamed, SubStatement, 355)
(Renamed, EnumMemberDeclaration, 314)

Modifiers (currently we do not have telemetry on which modifiers, in 17.0 accessibility modifiers are separated)

(ModifiersUpdate, MethodDeclaration, 3753)
(ModifiersUpdate, FieldDeclaration, 144)
(ModifiersUpdate, FieldDeclaration, 1735)
(ModifiersUpdate, PropertyDeclaration, 1329)
(ModifiersUpdate, ConstructorDeclaration, 627)
(ModifiersUpdate, ClassDeclaration, 578)
(ModifiersUpdate, Parameter, 251)
(ModifiersUpdate, SetAccessorDeclaration, 245)
(ModifiersUpdate, Parameter, 210)
(ModifiersUpdate, SubStatement, 92)
(ModifiersUpdate, FunctionStatement, 61)
(ModifiersUpdate, EventFieldDeclaration, 26)
(ModifiersUpdate, EnumDeclaration, 25)
(ModifiersUpdate, ClassStatement, 13)
(ModifiersUpdate, PropertyStatement, 11)
(ModifiersUpdate, GetAccessorDeclaration, 10)
(ModifiersUpdate, StructDeclaration, 9)
(ModifiersUpdate, InterfaceDeclaration, 6)
(ModifiersUpdate, OperatorDeclaration, 5)

Member/Signature updates (mostly supported in 17.3, improvements in 17.8)

(Insert, Parameter, 8821)
(TypeUpdate, PropertyDeclaration, 6869)
(TypeUpdate, MethodDeclaration, 4097)
(TypeUpdate, Parameter, 4038)
(TypeUpdate, VariableDeclaration, 1934)
(TypeUpdate, PropertyStatement, 258)
(Update, VariableDeclarator, 2784)
(InitializerUpdate, Parameter, 1187)
(InitializerUpdate, EnumMemberDeclaration, 320)
(Delete, Parameter, 269)

Switch Expressions (17.0 P2: #43099)

(SwitchExpressionUpdate, MethodDeclaration, 1400)

Namespaces (#51398)

(Insert, NamespaceDeclaration, 6420)
(Renamed, NamespaceDeclaration, 503)
(Delete, NamespaceDeclaration, 275)
(Insert, NamespaceBlock, 67)
(Delete, NamespaceBlock, 7)

Virtuals and interfaces

(InsertVirtual, MethodDeclaration, 1571)
(BaseTypeOrInterfaceUpdate, ClassDeclaration, 1065)
(InsertVirtual, PropertyDeclaration, 464)

Low frequency

(Move, PropertyDeclaration, 968)
(Move, FieldDeclaration, 771)
(Insert, EnumMemberDeclaration, 863)
(Delete, ClassDeclaration, 807)
(Renamed, ModifiedIdentifier, 806)
(UpdateStaticLocal, SubBlock, 799)
(Insert, Parameter, 720)
(Delete, FieldDeclaration, 689)
(InsertHandlesClause, SubBlock, 669)
(TypeUpdate, Parameter, 519)
(Move, Parameter, 510)
("259.0", SubBlock, 480)
(ChangingCapturedVariableScope, None, 478)
(TypeUpdate, VariableDeclarator, 472)
(GenericTypeUpdate, ConstructorDeclaration, 464)
(Delete, ConstructorDeclaration, 390)
(DeleteLambdaWithMultiScopeCapture, None, 367)
(PartiallyExecutedActiveStatementDelete, None, 355)
(ComplexQueryExpression, SubBlock, 332)
(ActiveStatementLambdaRemoved, SimpleLambdaExpression, 326)
(MethodBodyAdd, GetAccessorDeclaration, 313)
("259.0", FunctionBlock, 294)
(HandlesClauseUpdate, SubStatement, 285)
(Insert, FieldDeclaration, 283)
(ActiveStatementLambdaRemoved, ParenthesizedLambdaExpression, 266)
(Update, VariableDeclarator, 263)
(ComplexQueryExpression, FunctionBlock, 256)
(InsertAroundActiveStatement, UsingStatement, 251)
(Delete, EnumMemberDeclaration, 228)
(ChangingFromAsynchronousToSynchronous, Block, 225)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, FinallyBlock, 224)
(MethodBodyAdd, SetAccessorDeclaration, 215)
(MethodBodyDelete, GetAccessorDeclaration, 210)
(UpdateStaticLocal, FunctionBlock, 208)
(Delete, SimpleAsClause, 204)
(InsertGenericMethod, MethodDeclaration, 198)
(TypeUpdate, FunctionStatement, 189)
(Renamed, FunctionStatement, 173)
(MemberBodyTooBig, SubBlock, 170)
(Insert, SimpleAsClause, 151)
(MethodBodyDelete, SetAccessorDeclaration, 145)
(PartialTypeInitializerUpdate, PropertyDeclaration, 144)
(Move, ClassDeclaration, 143)
(InsertAroundActiveStatement, FinallyClause, 143)
(DeleteAroundActiveStatement, FinallyClause, 141)
(ChangingQueryLambdaType, AscendingOrdering, 141)
(UpdatingStateMachineMethodAroundActiveStatement, None, 139)
(Insert, AwaitExpression, 138)
(DeleteAroundActiveStatement, CatchBlock, 135)
(Insert, Attribute, 131)
(Delete, PropertyStatement, 131)
(Delete, AwaitExpression, 130)
(ChangingQueryLambdaType, LetClause, 130)
(GenericTypeUpdate, GetAccessorDeclaration, 127)
(ChangingQueryLambdaType, SelectClause, 124)
(GenericTypeUpdate, SetAccessorDeclaration, 124)
(Update, Attribute, 119)
(GenericTypeTriviaUpdate, ConstructorDeclaration, 118)
(Move, EnumMemberDeclaration, 116)
(Insert, YieldReturnStatement, 113)
(Move, FieldDeclaration, 113)
(Delete, VariableDeclarator, 112)
(MemberBodyTooBig, FunctionBlock, 111)
(ChangingLambdaParameters, LocalFunctionStatement, 110)
(Renamed, PropertyStatement, 110)
(InsertIntoInterface, SubBlock, 104)
(Delete, YieldReturnStatement, 102)
(InsertIntoStruct, VariableDeclarator, 102)
(Delete, GetAccessorDeclaration, 101)
(InsertFile, None, 100)
(Insert, OptionStatement, 96)
(Delete, EnumDeclaration, 95)
(Delete, PropertyBlock, 93)
(Delete, OptionStatement, 93)
(StackAllocUpdate, MethodDeclaration, 90)
(GenericTypeUpdate, SubBlock, 89)
(Insert, EnumMemberDeclaration, 86)
(Delete, AttributesStatement, 83)
(InsertAroundActiveStatement, LockStatement, 78)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, OnErrorGoToZeroStatement, 75)
(TypeUpdate, ModifiedIdentifier, 70)
(GenericTypeInitializerUpdate, VariableDeclarator, 65)
(PartialTypeInitializerUpdate, None, 64)
(Delete, EventFieldDeclaration, 64)
(DeleteAroundActiveStatement, TryBlock, 63)
(InsertAroundActiveStatement, WithBlock, 61)
(Insert, AttributeList, 61)
(UpdatingStateMachineMethodMissingAttribute, Block, 60)
(ChangingLambdaReturnType, MultiLineFunctionLambdaExpression, 59)
(InsertIntoInterface, FunctionBlock, 59)
(GenericTypeUpdate, FunctionBlock, 59)
(Update, ImportsStatement, 57)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, DeclarationExpression, 53)
(InsertVirtual, SubBlock, 52)
(Renamed, ClassStatement, 52)
(InsertExtern, MethodDeclaration, 52)
(Delete, ClassBlock, 52)
(InsertAroundActiveStatement, UsingBlock, 51)
(ChangingLambdaReturnType, LocalFunctionStatement, 51)
(MethodKindUpdate, FunctionStatement, 50)
(InsertIntoStruct, ModifiedIdentifier, 50)
(Insert, ModuleBlock, 50)
(Insert, TypeParameterList, 49)
(InsertOperator, ConversionOperatorDeclaration, 49)
(ChangingQueryLambdaType, DescendingOrdering, 48)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, UsingBlock, 46)
(GenericMethodUpdate, SubBlock, 45)
(GenericMethodTriviaUpdate, FunctionBlock, 44)
(BaseTypeOrInterfaceUpdate, ClassBlock, 44)
(Delete, AttributeList, 42)
(InitializerUpdate, Parameter, 40)
(MethodBodyDelete, PropertyDeclaration, 38)
(Renamed, EnumDeclaration, 38)
(Delete, DelegateDeclaration, 37)
(ChangingLambdaParameters, MultiLineFunctionLambdaExpression, 37)
(MethodBodyAdd, PropertyDeclaration, 37)
(Renamed, Parameter, 37)
(InsertVirtual, FunctionBlock, 36)
(Delete, ConversionOperatorDeclaration, 34)
(BaseTypeOrInterfaceUpdate, InterfaceDeclaration, 33)
(AccessorKindUpdate, SetAccessorDeclaration, 33)
(Move, Parameter, 32)
(Delete, StructDeclaration, 32)
(ChangingVisibility, None, 32)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, LocalFunctionStatement, 30)
(Delete, TypeParameterList, 30)
(InitializerUpdate, EnumMemberDeclaration, 30)
(Delete, ModifiedIdentifier, 30)
(AccessorKindUpdate, GetAccessorDeclaration, 28)
(MemberBodyInternalError, Block, 28)
(ChangingLambdaParameters, MultiLineSubLambdaExpression, 27)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, LockStatement, 27)
(DeleteAroundActiveStatement, FinallyBlock, 27)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, IsPatternExpression, 26)
(Renamed, EnumMemberDeclaration, 25)
(GenericTypeTriviaUpdate, GetAccessorDeclaration, 25)
(InsertAroundActiveStatement, YieldReturnStatement, 25)
(ChangingQueryLambdaType, CollectionRangeVariable, 25)
(Insert, YieldBreakStatement, 24)
(Move, PropertyStatement, 23)
(MethodKindUpdate, SubStatement, 23)
(GenericTypeTriviaUpdate, SetAccessorDeclaration, 23)
(InsertVirtual, SetAccessorDeclaration, 22)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, ResumeNextStatement, 22)
(ActiveStatementLambdaRemoved, AnonymousMethodExpression, 21)
(Delete, EnumMemberDeclaration, 21)
(GenericTypeUpdate, PropertyDeclaration, 21)
(InsertIntoStruct, PropertyDeclaration, 20)
(PartialTypeInitializerUpdate, PropertyStatement, 20)
(GenericTypeTriviaUpdate, FunctionBlock, 19)
(Renamed, InterfaceDeclaration, 19)
(TypeKindUpdate, ClassDeclaration, 19)
(Delete, TypeParameterConstraintClause, 18)
(ChangingLambdaParameters, SingleLineSubLambdaExpression, 17)
(Renamed, TypeParameter, 17)
(Delete, ConstructorBlock, 17)
(Delete, YieldBreakStatement, 17)
(Delete, InterfaceDeclaration, 17)
(ChangingQueryLambdaType, AscendingOrdering, 17)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, ResumeStatement, 16)
(InsertAroundActiveStatement, FinallyBlock, 16)
(InsertVirtual, ConstructorDeclaration, 16)
(EnumUnderlyingTypeUpdate, EnumDeclaration, 15)
(Insert, TypeParameterConstraintClause, 15)
(ActiveStatementLambdaRemoved, SingleLineFunctionLambdaExpression, 15)
(GenericTypeInitializerUpdate, PropertyDeclaration, 15)
(SwitchExpressionUpdate, ConstructorDeclaration, 15)
(TypeUpdate, TypeParameterConstraintClause, 15)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, SwitchStatement, 15)
(Renamed, StructDeclaration, 14)
(Delete, DestructorDeclaration, 14)
(Delete, EventDeclaration, 14)
(Move, EventFieldDeclaration, 13)
(InsertMethodWithExplicitInterfaceSpecifier, MethodDeclaration, 13)
(Insert, ForEachStatement, 13)
(GenericTypeUpdate, GetAccessorBlock, 12)
(Insert, DestructorDeclaration, 11)
(MethodBodyDelete, MethodDeclaration, 11)
(Move, EnumMemberDeclaration, 11)
(InsertVirtual, PropertyBlock, 11)
(ChangingFromAsynchronousToSynchronous, ForEachStatement, 11)
(ActiveStatementLambdaRemoved, LocalFunctionStatement, 11)
(InsertAroundActiveStatement, YieldBreakStatement, 11)
(GenericTypeTriviaUpdate, SubBlock, 11)
(Renamed, DelegateDeclaration, 10)
(SwitchBetweenLambdaAndLocalFunction, LocalFunctionStatement, 10)
(Insert, VariableDeclarator, 10)
(Insert, ModifiedIdentifier, 10)
(Delete, ModuleBlock, 9)
(UpdateStaticLocal, GetAccessorBlock, 9)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, TupleExpression, 8)
(Move, ModifiedIdentifier, 8)
(Insert, DeclareFunctionStatement, 8)
(Delete, ParameterList, 8)
(ChangingFromAsynchronousToSynchronous, LocalDeclarationStatement, 7)
(Insert, AttributesStatement, 7)
(InsertAroundActiveStatement, AwaitExpression, 7)
(Renamed, TypeParameterConstraintClause, 7)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, ForEachVariableStatement, 7)
(Move, EnumDeclaration, 7)
(Renamed, ModuleStatement, 7)
(Move, ClassBlock, 6)
(ActiveStatementLambdaRemoved, WhereClause, 6)
(Delete, DeclareFunctionStatement, 6)
(GenericTypeTriviaUpdate, PropertyDeclaration, 6)
(SwitchExpressionUpdate, GetAccessorDeclaration, 6)
(Insert, Attribute, 6)
(Move, StructDeclaration, 6)
(GenericTypeUpdate, OperatorDeclaration, 6)
(Delete, OperatorDeclaration, 6)
(Delete, EventStatement, 6)
(ActiveStatementLambdaRemoved, SingleLineSubLambdaExpression, 6)
(InsertVirtual, GetAccessorDeclaration, 6)
(InsertOperator, OperatorDeclaration, 6)
(Delete, ForEachStatement, 6)
(ChangingQueryLambdaType, FromClause, 6)
(Delete, StructureBlock, 6)
(ActiveStatementLambdaRemoved, MultiLineSubLambdaExpression, 6)
(InsertIntoInterface, FieldDeclaration, 6)
(InsertVirtual, PropertyStatement, 6)
(InsertAroundActiveStatement, SyncLockBlock, 6)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, ResumeLabelStatement, 6)
(GenericMethodTriviaUpdate, SubBlock, 6)
(Insert, FunctionStatement, 5)
(ChangingQueryLambdaType, DescendingOrdering, 5)
(TypeKindUpdate, StructDeclaration, 5)
(Move, InterfaceDeclaration, 5)
(Delete, IndexerDeclaration, 5)
(SwitchExpressionUpdate, SetAccessorDeclaration, 5)
(GenericTypeTriviaUpdate, VariableDeclarator, 5)
(MethodBodyAdd, MethodDeclaration, 4)
(Insert, TypeParameter, 4)
(ChangingQueryLambdaType, ExpressionRangeVariable, 4)
(Delete, SetAccessorBlock, 4)
(Delete, EnumBlock, 4)
(ImplementsClauseUpdate, PropertyStatement, 4)
(InsertOperator, OperatorBlock, 4)
(InsertIntoInterface, ConstructorBlock, 4)
(FieldKindUpdate, EventFieldDeclaration, 4)
(ComplexQueryExpression, ConstructorBlock, 4)
(MethodBodyDelete, ConstructorDeclaration, 4)
(ModifiersUpdate, ModuleStatement, 4)
(Delete, TypeParameter, 4)
(GenericTypeUpdate, SetAccessorBlock, 4)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, SimpleAssignmentExpression, 4)
(GenericTypeUpdate, ConstructorBlock, 4)
(Insert, LocalDeclarationStatement, 4)
(TypeUpdate, DelegateDeclaration, 3)
(ModifiersUpdate, DelegateDeclaration, 3)
(SwitchBetweenLambdaAndLocalFunction, SimpleLambdaExpression, 3)
(ActiveStatementLambdaRemoved, SelectClause, 3)
(ChangingStateMachineShape, AwaitExpression, 3)
(TypeUpdate, OperatorDeclaration, 3)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, SyncLockBlock, 3)
(Delete, Attribute, 3)
(ImplementsClauseUpdate, FunctionStatement, 3)
(Insert, DeclareSubStatement, 3)
(Insert, ExternAliasDirective, 3)
(Move, DelegateDeclaration, 3)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, FixedStatement, 3)
(Delete, GetAccessorBlock, 3)
(BaseTypeOrInterfaceUpdate, StructDeclaration, 3)
(TypeKindUpdate, InterfaceDeclaration, 3)
(DeclareLibraryUpdate, DeclareFunctionStatement, 3)
(TypeKindUpdate, ClassStatement, 3)
(Update, OptionStatement, 3)
(Insert, ParameterList, 3)
(Renamed, NamespaceStatement, 2)
(ActiveStatementLambdaRemoved, WhereClause, 2)
(UpdateAroundActiveStatement, OnErrorGoToMinusOneStatement, 2)
(ActiveStatementLambdaRemoved, ExpressionRangeVariable, 2)
(ActiveStatementLambdaRemoved, AscendingOrdering, 2)
(ComplexQueryExpression, SetAccessorBlock, 2)
(ModifiersUpdate, ConversionOperatorDeclaration, 2)
(Move, VariableDeclarator, 2)
(InsertGenericMethod, FunctionBlock, 2)
(ChangingStateMachineShape, VariableDeclarator, 2)
(ActiveStatementLambdaRemoved, AscendingOrdering, 2)
(TypeUpdate, IndexerDeclaration, 2)
(InsertIntoInterface, EventFieldDeclaration, 2)
(Move, EventStatement, 2)
("259.0", ConstructorBlock, 2)
(SwitchExpressionUpdate, PropertyDeclaration, 2)
(InsertAroundActiveStatement, ForEachVariableStatement, 2)
(ReadOnlyReferences, Parameter, 2)
(UpdateStaticLocal, SetAccessorBlock, 2)
(SourceFileTooBig, None, 2)
(ModifiersUpdate, SubNewStatement, 2)
(FieldKindUpdate, FieldDeclaration, 2)
(Delete, FunctionStatement, 2)
(Delete, YieldStatement, 2)
(ChangingFromAsynchronousToSynchronous, InvocationExpression, 2)
(ActiveStatementLambdaRemoved, JoinClause, 2)
(Delete, DelegateSubStatement, 2)
(ChangingLambdaReturnType, MultiLineSubLambdaExpression, 2)
(Renamed, ConversionOperatorDeclaration, 2)
(GenericTypeUpdate, AddHandlerAccessorBlock, 1)
(TypeUpdate, EventStatement, 1)
(ChangingFromAsynchronousToSynchronous, IdentifierName, 1)
(Insert, TypeParameterList, 1)
(ActiveStatementLambdaRemoved, JoinCondition, 1)
(SwitchExpressionUpdate, OperatorDeclaration, 1)
(Move, StructureBlock, 1)
(AccessorKindUpdate, RemoveAccessorDeclaration, 1)
(AccessorKindUpdate, AddAccessorDeclaration, 1)
(Move, NamespaceDeclaration, 1)
(Renamed, StructureStatement, 1)
(ActiveStatementLambdaRemoved, DescendingOrdering, 1)
(TypeUpdate, ConversionOperatorDeclaration, 1)
(ChangingFromAsynchronousToSynchronous, AwaitExpression, 1)
(GenericTypeUpdate, DestructorDeclaration, 1)
(Delete, OperatorBlock, 1)
(VarianceUpdate, TypeParameter, 1)
(InsertAroundActiveStatement, FixedStatement, 1)
(DeclareLibraryUpdate, DeclareSubStatement, 1)
(MethodBodyAdd, ConstructorDeclaration, 1)
(InsertExtern, ConstructorDeclaration, 1)
(ModifiersUpdate, DeclareFunctionStatement, 1)
(Insert, SubStatement, 1)
(Delete, DeclareSubStatement, 1)
(GenericTypeUpdate, RemoveAccessorDeclaration, 1)
(GenericTypeUpdate, AddAccessorDeclaration, 1)
(MemberBodyInternalError, FunctionBlock, 1)
(InsertIntoClassWithLayout, VariableDeclarator, 1)
(GenericTypeTriviaUpdate, DestructorDeclaration, 1)
(ComplexQueryExpression, GetAccessorBlock, 1)
(ModifiersUpdate, IndexerDeclaration, 1)
(Renamed, TypeParameter, 1)
(InsertHandlesClause, FunctionBlock, 1)
(InsertVirtual, FieldDeclaration, 1)
(GenericTypeTriviaUpdate, SetAccessorBlock, 1)
(TypeUpdate, DeclareFunctionStatement, 1)
(SwitchBetweenLambdaAndLocalFunction, ParenthesizedLambdaExpression, 1)
(GenericTypeTriviaUpdate, AddHandlerAccessorBlock, 1)
(InsertVirtual, EventFieldDeclaration, 1)
(ActiveStatementLambdaRemoved, DescendingOrdering, 1)
(GenericTypeTriviaUpdate, ConstructorBlock, 1)
(TypeKindUpdate, ModuleStatement, 1)
(UpdatingStateMachineMethodMissingAttribute, SubBlock, 1)
(InsertGenericMethod, SubBlock, 1)
(Renamed, EnumStatement, 1)
(Renamed, DeclareFunctionStatement, 1)
(InsertAroundActiveStatement, VariableDeclarator, 1)
(UpdateStaticLocal, ConstructorBlock, 1)
(HandlesClauseUpdate, FunctionStatement, 1)
(ActiveStatementLambdaRemoved, FromClause, 1)
(InsertIntoInterface, MethodDeclaration, 1)
(Move, DelegateSubStatement, 1)
(GenericTypeTriviaUpdate, GetAccessorBlock, 1)