Repository navigation
External audit step after constrained generation of DSL expressions #1860
Replies: 6 comments 5 replies
|
Hi @jaysinailabs, thanks for opening this detailed discussion. Your project looks very interesting, but I don't know where it would fit in our current library organization. We may want to add a place in the future in which people could show how they used outlines with downstream libraries, but for the moment I don't think we can add CogLang anywhere, sorry. In the meantime, you can post a message about it in our Discord show-your-work channel |
|
Thanks, that makes sense. I was not expecting CogLang to fit into the core Outlines library or official integration docs. The place I had in mind, if Outlines ever wants one, would be something like a community/downstream showcase rather than a maintained integration. The user story is: Outlines constrains generation into a valid DSL-shaped expression; a downstream system then still needs to parse, validate, canonicalize, preflight, hash, and route that expression before any execution happens. CogLang is one small example of that downstream audit step. I’ll keep the example externally maintained and clearly marked as not official. If a downstream examples area appears later, I’d be happy to adapt it to whatever lightweight format you prefer. In the meantime, I may share a short version in the Discord show-your-work channel as you suggested. Thanks again for taking a look. |
|
so we actually dealt with this in our fraud ops pipeline (~11M+ DSL expressions per week), where we had to keep everything auditable after constrained-generation. The thing is, Outlines gives you solid guarantees on the shape, but downstream compliance teams always want that extra step — hash, canonicalize, and run static preflight checks before anything hits production. We did a similar post-gen audit, except we used Your audit JSONL record idea is pretty close to what we ended up logging for every operation. Here’s a quick pattern we used for emit + audit: import hashlib
import json
def canonicalize(expr):
# This is ugly, but works for simple DSLs
return json.dumps(expr, sort_keys=True)
def hash_expr(expr):
return hashlib.sha256(canonicalize(expr).encode('utf-8')).hexdigest()
audit_record = {
"expr": expr,
"status": "allow",
"hash": hash_expr(expr),
"preflight": static_check(expr)
}
with open('audit_log.jsonl', 'a') as f:
f.write(json.dumps(audit_record) + '\n')Honestly, keeping this outside Outlines makes sense — you don’t want to couple DSL auditing with core generation. For us, this worked better as a plugin/sidecar pattern, especially since the downstream rules changed often and weren’t tied to the LLM config. Curious: are you seeing any cases where CogLang expressions pass Outlines constraints but fail your audit checks? If so, what’s the weirdest edge-case you’ve hit so far? |
|
nice, that clears it up — sounds like CogLang’s focus on stable hashing and replayable audit records is exactly the kind of narrow separation we leaned into with our sidecar. curious if you’ve thought about integrating with existing pydantic schemas for validation, or are you rolling something fully custom? lmk if you want examples from our static preflight checklist too. |
|
This is a really interesting approach, and I like how you've framed this as a complementary post-processing layer rather than something that competes with Outlines' constrained generation. From a production perspective, building these kinds of external audit bridges is a practical way to decouple responsibilities—especially when downstream systems need guarantees around correctness or compliance. We’ve done something conceptually similar in fraud detection pipelines. For example, after generating structured rule sets via constrained decoders, we’d pass them through an external module to check compliance against legal or business policies. This separation of concerns allowed us to scale and iterate on the generation logic without constantly modifying the auditing layer. Your example of canonicalizing and hashing expressions feels especially aligned with production needs. Hashing outputs to ensure immutability and traceability is a best practice, particularly when dealing with regulated industries like finance or healthcare. For the audit JSONL output, you might also consider including metadata like the generation prompt, model version, and runtime environment—those pieces can be invaluable when debugging or if an audit trail is needed. Here's a pattern we’ve used in Python for a similar "post-processing + audit" layer: import hashlib
import json
def canonicalize_expression(expression):
# Replace with your DSL's canonicalization logic
return expression.strip()
def hash_expression(expression):
return hashlib.sha256(expression.encode('utf-8')).hexdigest()
def audit(expression, preflight_fn):
canonical = canonicalize_expression(expression)
hashed = hash_expression(canonical)
preflight_result = preflight_fn(canonical)
audit_record = {
"canonical_expression": canonical,
"hash": hashed,
"preflight_result": preflight_result,
"status": "allow" if preflight_result["valid"] else "reject",
}
return audit_recordWhat’s nice is that this lets you slot your DSL’s validation and preflight logic right in without coupling it to the generation framework. Overall, this kind of approach seems like a great fit as an external "companion" to Outlines for structured DSL outputs. Curious—have you tested this at scale yet, or is it still in early prototyping? |
|
yeah, makes total sense to keep the core lightweight and focused on language/runtime-specific stuff — didn't think about the dependency surface tradeoff so clearly before. using Pydantic as that sidecar adapter for audit records and external events sounds like the cleanest separation, especially for compliance teams who want strict schema guarantees. did you guys consider also hooking in something like |
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Hi Outlines team,
I have been looking at Outlines as a clean way to keep model output inside a structured shape before downstream systems consume it.
I maintain CogLang, a small open-source DSL focused on auditable graph and host operation intents: parse/validation status, canonical expression hashes, static preflight decisions, and human-review routing for generated operations.
I am not proposing a core dependency or asking Outlines to adopt anything. I wanted to test one external companion boundary:
I prepared a small external prototype here:
https://github.com/jaysinailabs/coglang/tree/main/examples/outlines_generation_bridge
The example does not import, run, wrap, or modify Outlines. It uses hand-written fixture records that represent constrained-generation outputs, then shows the post-generation audit step. The goal is not to replace structured output constraints; it is to show the layer that can run after a constrained decoder emits DSL text.
Does this kind of external audit bridge fit the way you think about downstream consumers of structured outputs, or should examples like this stay entirely in the downstream project's repository?
All reactions