Allow multiple simultaneous uploads via single POST. #4563
Conversation
|
Is this ready for review and will this allow to specify separate dbkey/datatype pairs for each file? |
|
It lets you add different names, space_to_tab and to_posix_lines values, and such - but I guess not different dbkeys and filetypes. I'll update the PR to do this and add a test case for that this morning. |
| if override_file_type: | ||
| return override_file_type | ||
| else: | ||
| return context.get(self.file_type_name, self.default_file_type) |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Very minor but could we do something like unless you think its less performant:
default_type = context.get(self.file_type_name, self.default_file_type)
return context.get("override_file_type", default_type)
I also wonder if we could just name it file_type instead of override_file_type since they can be distinguished by being specified on request vs file bunch level. Thanks a lot for this addition. This is awesome.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Yeah - so I had that at first but the fact that a value - even though it was empty - was in the parent child context means the parent context was ignored. I should probably take another swing at this though - because you are right - the way it is now kinda sucks.
| @@ -279,10 +285,18 @@ def value_from_basic(self, value, app, ignore_errors=False): | |||
| rval.append(rval_dict) | |||
| return rval | |||
|
|
|||
| def get_file_count(self, trans, context): | |||
| file_count = context.get("file_count", "auto") | |||
| if file_count == "auto": | |||
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Just a minor one. Can we make it one liner?
file_count = len(self.get_datatype(trans, context).writable_files) if file_count == "auto" else int(file_count)
thank you!
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I'll rebase with this change, thanks!
jmchilton
force-pushed
the
multiple_files_per_upload
branch
from
ddeb712
to
e6fbd9b
Compare
The upload.py tool itself already allowed this and update upload dataset grouping to handle this.
jmchilton
force-pushed
the
multiple_files_per_upload
branch
from
e6fbd9b
to
1fa4ea2
Compare
|
I've changed the interface here so that "file_type" or "dbkey" in the parent context are taken as defaults and in the "per-file" context these can be overridden with "file_type" or "dbkey" instead of requiring a different variable "override_file_type" / "override_dbkey" as I had it before. I added a few more tests for different combinations of override versus default for dbkey and file_type. |
|
Thanks a lot for working on this. I aligned the submission format in #4513 and it seems to work well. |
| if dbkey == "": | ||
| if parent_context: | ||
| dbkey = parent_context.get("dbkey", dbkey) | ||
| return dbkey |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I might be missing something but why are we not just returning parent_context.get("dbkey", context.get("dbkey"))?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
So the inner dbkey - the per file one - is just a hidden field in the tool form with a default of "" - that is what the outer one is checking the top-level dbkey param in the tool that I think will default to ?. So if the API request sends a dbkey for all files and then one for a specific file - I think we should use the base for all files that don't specify an explicit dbkey and then use the specific keys as set. I tried to use this strategy with the file extensions also. This implementation is crap because we are mapping API requests to a tool that wasn't really ever designed to do this well (these frustrations made led me to create #4734).
So I implemented API tests to verify all this behavior with respect to specific file dbkey versus dbkey for all files - if you can rework the implementation to be cleaner in such a way that the API calls don't break - I'm totally on board. I'm quite frustrated with a lot of grouping.py. There are more test cases in #4746 that should also help verify cleanups to the implementation don't break FTP uploads and such.
|
Thanks for the merge @guerler - let me know if there is anything else I can do to help with optimizing uploads. |
The upload.py tool itself already allowed this.