Replace Calamares with an installer specific to Nitrux #218
UriHerrera
started this conversation in
Ideas
Replies: 1 comment
Additional RemarksAbout Secure BootCalamares overstates the guarantees of the "Secure Boot support" in the sb-shim path. Calamares v3.4.2 has an sb-shim path: it registers a shim entry with efibootmgr and generates GRUB's config. It relies on the distribution to put the signed shim and GRUB files on the EFI partition. In this path, Calamares doesn't install fallback files or check whether the efibootmgr entry-creation command succeeded. Nitrux can supply the signed files; I've added fallback-file installation to a helper for our settings package. So Secure Boot can work, but a named Nitrux firmware entry still depends on NVRAM registration succeeding. |
0 replies
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
It's the never-ending story: third-party software has problems, but we're blamed for them; when it works, it's never "Nitrux works great," but if it crashes or whatever, it's always "Nitrux has problems," and I am just up to here with that.
Given all the problems I've had with Calamares in the past and, more recently, its inability to use QML modules at all, I think it's best to start considering moving away from it. Also, Calamares describes itself as a framework rather than an installer, and I don't need a framework; I just want an installer. An installer for Nitrux that works in Nitrux.
It is certainly the most ambitious replacement yet. There are no Qt alternatives; evidently, there are no QML alternatives. All logic would be from scratch.
For the UI, well, we could look back at the older QML implementation we had.
Requirements
Functionality
All reactions