Good first issues stopped being a welcome mat — they are a menu now #213361
Replies: 1 comment
|
Thank you for your interest in contributing to our community! We currently only accept discussions created through the GitHub UI using our provided discussion templates. Please re-submit your discussion by navigating to the appropriate category and using the template provided. This discussion has been closed because it was not submitted through the expected format. If you believe this was a mistake, please reach out to the maintainers. |
0 replies
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
🏷️ Discussion Type
Question
💬 Feature/Topic Area
Other
Body
pip-tools retired the
help wantedlabel because it kept attracting low-effort PRs, and its maintainers are now talking about doing the same togood first issue. Their contributing guide says something I keep coming back to: having an LLM resolve one of these issues doesn't help anyone learn, because watching someone else do the work isn't how you learn it.I think the label was always doing more than marking small tasks. A good first issue was a place where a human could show up, ask clumsy questions, and slowly absorb the context that isn't written down anywhere. The comment thread accumulated the real spec: constraints, decisions, dead ends. That took years to build, and it was free.
Now an agent can read the label, produce a clean-looking patch in minutes, and close the issue without ever using that context. Worse, several agents can arrive at the same issue with conflicting fixes, all ignoring what was agreed in the thread. The thread stops being the spec and becomes noise under four competing PRs.
So where does everyone else land?
good first issuea finite teaching resource now? If so, what's the fair way to spend it?Sources for the curious: the pip-tools contributing guide and the discussion that started it, jazzband/pip-tools#2278. I'd especially like to hear from maintainers who actually changed their labels — what happened next?
All reactions