a client service or alias has been removed

[xsuntel]

I have a question about how to use a new registered client on SF4. Because I have trouble using it.

Could you please give me an advice?

httplug.yaml

    discovery:
        client: 'auto'
        async_client: false

    clients:
        default:
            factory: 'httplug.factory.guzzle6'
            plugins: ['httplug.plugin.logger']
            config:
               verify: false
               timeout: 3
        test:
            factory: 'httplug.factory.guzzle6'
            plugins: ['httplug.plugin.logger']
            config:
                verify: false
                timeout: 3

IndexController.php

    $request = $this->container->get('httplug.message_factory')->createRequest('GET', $url);
    $response = $this->container->get('httplug.client.test')->sendRequest($request);

    var_dump($response);
    die();

ServiceNotFoundException

The "httplug.client.test" service or alias has been removed or inlined when the container was 
compiled. You should either make it public, or stop using the container directly and use 
dependency injection instead.

$ php ./bin/console debug:container httplug.client.test

Information for Service "httplug.client.test"
=============================================

 ----------------- ---------------------------------------- 
  Option            Value                                   
 ----------------- ---------------------------------------- 
  Service ID        httplug.client.test                     
  Class             Http\Client\Common\PluginClient         
  Tags              -                                       
  Public            no                                      
  Synthetic         no                                      
  Lazy              no                                      
  Shared            yes                                     
  Abstract          no                                      
  Autowired         no                                      
  Autoconfigured    no                                      
  Factory Service   Http\Client\Common\PluginClientFactory  
  Factory Method    createClient                            
 ----------------- ---------------------------------------- 

[Nyholm]

Hey. I just saw this issue now. Did you resolve it?

[xsuntel]

Hi, Nyholm

No, I closed this issue because I just wanted to double check it.

I have reopened this issue.

[xsuntel]

I think that It seems to be related to symfony/symfony#28296

[nicolas-grekas]

I'm not sure at all it's related to symfony/symfony#28296.
As the report says, "httplug.client.test" is not public, so it can be inlined or removed - which it had been as the error says. Calling $this->container->get('httplug.client.test') (i.e. on a private service) is deprecated on 3.4 for this reason: it can break without further notices, per the inlining/removing logic.

[xsuntel]

Thank you for your information. :)