Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

[python3.10] upgrade pytest to 6.2.4 that supports python3.10 #24828

Closed
wants to merge 3 commits into from

Conversation

scv119
Copy link
Contributor

@scv119 scv119 commented May 16, 2022

Why are these changes needed?

upgrade pytest to a version support python 3.10

Related issue number

Checks

  • I've run scripts/format.sh to lint the changes in this PR.
  • I've included any doc changes needed for https://docs.ray.io/en/master/.
  • I've made sure the tests are passing. Note that there might be a few flaky tests, see the recent failures at https://flakey-tests.ray.io/
  • Testing Strategy
    • Unit tests
    • Release tests
    • This PR is not tested :(

@scv119 scv119 marked this pull request as ready for review May 16, 2022 01:30
@scv119 scv119 added the do-not-merge Do not merge this PR! label May 16, 2022
@scv119 scv119 linked an issue May 16, 2022 that may be closed by this pull request
2 tasks
@rkooo567
Copy link
Contributor

Wonder if there's a way to warn contributors who use the older version..

@scv119
Copy link
Contributor Author

scv119 commented May 16, 2022

looks pytest 6.2.5 failed to load conftest.py

@rkooo567 rkooo567 mentioned this pull request May 19, 2022
6 tasks
@stale
Copy link

stale bot commented Jun 18, 2022

This pull request has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed in 14 days if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.

  • If you'd like to keep this open, just leave any comment, and the stale label will be removed.

@stale stale bot added the stale The issue is stale. It will be closed within 7 days unless there are further conversation label Jun 18, 2022
@Riatre Riatre mentioned this pull request Jul 9, 2022
6 tasks
pcmoritz pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Jul 13, 2022
See #23676 for context. This is another attempt at that as I figured out what's going wrong in `bazel test`. Supersedes #24828.

Now that there are Python 3.10 wheels for Ray 1.13 and this is no longer a blocker for supporting Python 3.10, I still want to make `bazel test //python/ray/tests/...` work for developing in a 3.10 env, and make it easier to add Python 3.10 tests to CI in future.

The change contains three commits with rather descriptive commit message, which I repeat here:

Pass deps to py_test in py_test_module_list

    Bazel macro py_test_module_list takes a `deps` argument, but completely
    ignores it instead of passes it to `native.py_test`. Fixing that as we
    are going to use deps of py_test_module_list in BUILD in later changes.

    cpp/BUILD.bazel depends on the broken behaviour: it deps-on a cc_library
    from a py_test, which isn't working, see upstream issue:
    bazelbuild/bazel#701.
    This is fixed by simply removing the (non-working) deps.

Depend on conftest and data files in Python tests BUILD files

    Bazel requires that all the files used in a test run should be
    represented in the transitive dependencies specified for the test
    target. For py_test, it means srcs, deps and data.

    Bazel enforces this constraint by creating a "runfiles" directory,
    symbolic links files in the dependency closure and run the test in the
    "runfiles" directory, so that the test shouldn't see files not in the
    dependency graph.

    Unfortunately, the constraint does not apply for a large number of
    Python tests, due to pytest (>=3.9.0, <6.0) resolving these symbolic
    links during test collection and effectively "breaks out" of the
    runfiles tree.

    pytest >= 6.0 introduces a breaking change and removed the symbolic link
    resolving behaviour, see pytest pull request
    pytest-dev/pytest#6523 for more context.

    Currently, we are underspecifying dependencies in a lot of BUILD files
    and thus blocking us from updating to newer pytest (for Python 3.10
    support). This change hopefully fixes all of them, and at least those in
    CI, by adding data or source dependencies (mostly for conftest.py-s)
    where needed.

Bump pytest version from 5.4.3 to 7.0.1

    We want at least pytest 6.2.5 for Python 3.10 support, but not past
    7.1.0 since it drops Python 3.6 support (which Ray still supports), thus
    the version constraint is set to <7.1.

    Updating pytest, combined with earlier BUILD fixes, changed the ground
    truth of a few error message based unit test, these tests are updated to
    reflect the change.

    There are also two small drive-by changes for making test_traceback and
    test_cli pass under Python 3.10. These are discovered while debugging CI
    failures (on earlier Python) with a Python 3.10 install locally.  Expect
    more such issues when adding Python 3.10 to CI.
@stale
Copy link

stale bot commented Jul 14, 2022

Hi again! The issue will be closed because there has been no more activity in the 14 days since the last message.

Please feel free to reopen or open a new issue if you'd still like it to be addressed.

Again, you can always ask for help on our discussion forum or Ray's public slack channel.

Thanks again for opening the issue!

@stale stale bot closed this Jul 14, 2022
truelegion47 pushed a commit to truelegion47/ray that referenced this pull request Jul 14, 2022
See ray-project#23676 for context. This is another attempt at that as I figured out what's going wrong in `bazel test`. Supersedes ray-project#24828.

Now that there are Python 3.10 wheels for Ray 1.13 and this is no longer a blocker for supporting Python 3.10, I still want to make `bazel test //python/ray/tests/...` work for developing in a 3.10 env, and make it easier to add Python 3.10 tests to CI in future.

The change contains three commits with rather descriptive commit message, which I repeat here:

Pass deps to py_test in py_test_module_list

    Bazel macro py_test_module_list takes a `deps` argument, but completely
    ignores it instead of passes it to `native.py_test`. Fixing that as we
    are going to use deps of py_test_module_list in BUILD in later changes.

    cpp/BUILD.bazel depends on the broken behaviour: it deps-on a cc_library
    from a py_test, which isn't working, see upstream issue:
    bazelbuild/bazel#701.
    This is fixed by simply removing the (non-working) deps.

Depend on conftest and data files in Python tests BUILD files

    Bazel requires that all the files used in a test run should be
    represented in the transitive dependencies specified for the test
    target. For py_test, it means srcs, deps and data.

    Bazel enforces this constraint by creating a "runfiles" directory,
    symbolic links files in the dependency closure and run the test in the
    "runfiles" directory, so that the test shouldn't see files not in the
    dependency graph.

    Unfortunately, the constraint does not apply for a large number of
    Python tests, due to pytest (>=3.9.0, <6.0) resolving these symbolic
    links during test collection and effectively "breaks out" of the
    runfiles tree.

    pytest >= 6.0 introduces a breaking change and removed the symbolic link
    resolving behaviour, see pytest pull request
    pytest-dev/pytest#6523 for more context.

    Currently, we are underspecifying dependencies in a lot of BUILD files
    and thus blocking us from updating to newer pytest (for Python 3.10
    support). This change hopefully fixes all of them, and at least those in
    CI, by adding data or source dependencies (mostly for conftest.py-s)
    where needed.

Bump pytest version from 5.4.3 to 7.0.1

    We want at least pytest 6.2.5 for Python 3.10 support, but not past
    7.1.0 since it drops Python 3.6 support (which Ray still supports), thus
    the version constraint is set to <7.1.

    Updating pytest, combined with earlier BUILD fixes, changed the ground
    truth of a few error message based unit test, these tests are updated to
    reflect the change.

    There are also two small drive-by changes for making test_traceback and
    test_cli pass under Python 3.10. These are discovered while debugging CI
    failures (on earlier Python) with a Python 3.10 install locally.  Expect
    more such issues when adding Python 3.10 to CI.

Signed-off-by: Your Name <your@email.com>
edoakes pushed a commit to edoakes/ray that referenced this pull request Jul 14, 2022
See ray-project#23676 for context. This is another attempt at that as I figured out what's going wrong in `bazel test`. Supersedes ray-project#24828.

Now that there are Python 3.10 wheels for Ray 1.13 and this is no longer a blocker for supporting Python 3.10, I still want to make `bazel test //python/ray/tests/...` work for developing in a 3.10 env, and make it easier to add Python 3.10 tests to CI in future.

The change contains three commits with rather descriptive commit message, which I repeat here:

Pass deps to py_test in py_test_module_list

    Bazel macro py_test_module_list takes a `deps` argument, but completely
    ignores it instead of passes it to `native.py_test`. Fixing that as we
    are going to use deps of py_test_module_list in BUILD in later changes.

    cpp/BUILD.bazel depends on the broken behaviour: it deps-on a cc_library
    from a py_test, which isn't working, see upstream issue:
    bazelbuild/bazel#701.
    This is fixed by simply removing the (non-working) deps.

Depend on conftest and data files in Python tests BUILD files

    Bazel requires that all the files used in a test run should be
    represented in the transitive dependencies specified for the test
    target. For py_test, it means srcs, deps and data.

    Bazel enforces this constraint by creating a "runfiles" directory,
    symbolic links files in the dependency closure and run the test in the
    "runfiles" directory, so that the test shouldn't see files not in the
    dependency graph.

    Unfortunately, the constraint does not apply for a large number of
    Python tests, due to pytest (>=3.9.0, <6.0) resolving these symbolic
    links during test collection and effectively "breaks out" of the
    runfiles tree.

    pytest >= 6.0 introduces a breaking change and removed the symbolic link
    resolving behaviour, see pytest pull request
    pytest-dev/pytest#6523 for more context.

    Currently, we are underspecifying dependencies in a lot of BUILD files
    and thus blocking us from updating to newer pytest (for Python 3.10
    support). This change hopefully fixes all of them, and at least those in
    CI, by adding data or source dependencies (mostly for conftest.py-s)
    where needed.

Bump pytest version from 5.4.3 to 7.0.1

    We want at least pytest 6.2.5 for Python 3.10 support, but not past
    7.1.0 since it drops Python 3.6 support (which Ray still supports), thus
    the version constraint is set to <7.1.

    Updating pytest, combined with earlier BUILD fixes, changed the ground
    truth of a few error message based unit test, these tests are updated to
    reflect the change.

    There are also two small drive-by changes for making test_traceback and
    test_cli pass under Python 3.10. These are discovered while debugging CI
    failures (on earlier Python) with a Python 3.10 install locally.  Expect
    more such issues when adding Python 3.10 to CI.

Signed-off-by: Edward Oakes <ed.nmi.oakes@gmail.com>
nikitavemuri pushed a commit to nikitavemuri/ray that referenced this pull request Jul 15, 2022
See ray-project#23676 for context. This is another attempt at that as I figured out what's going wrong in `bazel test`. Supersedes ray-project#24828.

Now that there are Python 3.10 wheels for Ray 1.13 and this is no longer a blocker for supporting Python 3.10, I still want to make `bazel test //python/ray/tests/...` work for developing in a 3.10 env, and make it easier to add Python 3.10 tests to CI in future.

The change contains three commits with rather descriptive commit message, which I repeat here:

Pass deps to py_test in py_test_module_list

    Bazel macro py_test_module_list takes a `deps` argument, but completely
    ignores it instead of passes it to `native.py_test`. Fixing that as we
    are going to use deps of py_test_module_list in BUILD in later changes.

    cpp/BUILD.bazel depends on the broken behaviour: it deps-on a cc_library
    from a py_test, which isn't working, see upstream issue:
    bazelbuild/bazel#701.
    This is fixed by simply removing the (non-working) deps.

Depend on conftest and data files in Python tests BUILD files

    Bazel requires that all the files used in a test run should be
    represented in the transitive dependencies specified for the test
    target. For py_test, it means srcs, deps and data.

    Bazel enforces this constraint by creating a "runfiles" directory,
    symbolic links files in the dependency closure and run the test in the
    "runfiles" directory, so that the test shouldn't see files not in the
    dependency graph.

    Unfortunately, the constraint does not apply for a large number of
    Python tests, due to pytest (>=3.9.0, <6.0) resolving these symbolic
    links during test collection and effectively "breaks out" of the
    runfiles tree.

    pytest >= 6.0 introduces a breaking change and removed the symbolic link
    resolving behaviour, see pytest pull request
    pytest-dev/pytest#6523 for more context.

    Currently, we are underspecifying dependencies in a lot of BUILD files
    and thus blocking us from updating to newer pytest (for Python 3.10
    support). This change hopefully fixes all of them, and at least those in
    CI, by adding data or source dependencies (mostly for conftest.py-s)
    where needed.

Bump pytest version from 5.4.3 to 7.0.1

    We want at least pytest 6.2.5 for Python 3.10 support, but not past
    7.1.0 since it drops Python 3.6 support (which Ray still supports), thus
    the version constraint is set to <7.1.

    Updating pytest, combined with earlier BUILD fixes, changed the ground
    truth of a few error message based unit test, these tests are updated to
    reflect the change.

    There are also two small drive-by changes for making test_traceback and
    test_cli pass under Python 3.10. These are discovered while debugging CI
    failures (on earlier Python) with a Python 3.10 install locally.  Expect
    more such issues when adding Python 3.10 to CI.

Signed-off-by: Nikita Vemuri <nikitavemuri@gmail.com>
truelegion47 pushed a commit to truelegion47/ray that referenced this pull request Jul 16, 2022
See ray-project#23676 for context. This is another attempt at that as I figured out what's going wrong in `bazel test`. Supersedes ray-project#24828.

Now that there are Python 3.10 wheels for Ray 1.13 and this is no longer a blocker for supporting Python 3.10, I still want to make `bazel test //python/ray/tests/...` work for developing in a 3.10 env, and make it easier to add Python 3.10 tests to CI in future.

The change contains three commits with rather descriptive commit message, which I repeat here:

Pass deps to py_test in py_test_module_list

    Bazel macro py_test_module_list takes a `deps` argument, but completely
    ignores it instead of passes it to `native.py_test`. Fixing that as we
    are going to use deps of py_test_module_list in BUILD in later changes.

    cpp/BUILD.bazel depends on the broken behaviour: it deps-on a cc_library
    from a py_test, which isn't working, see upstream issue:
    bazelbuild/bazel#701.
    This is fixed by simply removing the (non-working) deps.

Depend on conftest and data files in Python tests BUILD files

    Bazel requires that all the files used in a test run should be
    represented in the transitive dependencies specified for the test
    target. For py_test, it means srcs, deps and data.

    Bazel enforces this constraint by creating a "runfiles" directory,
    symbolic links files in the dependency closure and run the test in the
    "runfiles" directory, so that the test shouldn't see files not in the
    dependency graph.

    Unfortunately, the constraint does not apply for a large number of
    Python tests, due to pytest (>=3.9.0, <6.0) resolving these symbolic
    links during test collection and effectively "breaks out" of the
    runfiles tree.

    pytest >= 6.0 introduces a breaking change and removed the symbolic link
    resolving behaviour, see pytest pull request
    pytest-dev/pytest#6523 for more context.

    Currently, we are underspecifying dependencies in a lot of BUILD files
    and thus blocking us from updating to newer pytest (for Python 3.10
    support). This change hopefully fixes all of them, and at least those in
    CI, by adding data or source dependencies (mostly for conftest.py-s)
    where needed.

Bump pytest version from 5.4.3 to 7.0.1

    We want at least pytest 6.2.5 for Python 3.10 support, but not past
    7.1.0 since it drops Python 3.6 support (which Ray still supports), thus
    the version constraint is set to <7.1.

    Updating pytest, combined with earlier BUILD fixes, changed the ground
    truth of a few error message based unit test, these tests are updated to
    reflect the change.

    There are also two small drive-by changes for making test_traceback and
    test_cli pass under Python 3.10. These are discovered while debugging CI
    failures (on earlier Python) with a Python 3.10 install locally.  Expect
    more such issues when adding Python 3.10 to CI.

Signed-off-by: Your Name <your@email.com>
truelegion47 pushed a commit to truelegion47/ray that referenced this pull request Jul 16, 2022
See ray-project#23676 for context. This is another attempt at that as I figured out what's going wrong in `bazel test`. Supersedes ray-project#24828.

Now that there are Python 3.10 wheels for Ray 1.13 and this is no longer a blocker for supporting Python 3.10, I still want to make `bazel test //python/ray/tests/...` work for developing in a 3.10 env, and make it easier to add Python 3.10 tests to CI in future.

The change contains three commits with rather descriptive commit message, which I repeat here:

Pass deps to py_test in py_test_module_list

    Bazel macro py_test_module_list takes a `deps` argument, but completely
    ignores it instead of passes it to `native.py_test`. Fixing that as we
    are going to use deps of py_test_module_list in BUILD in later changes.

    cpp/BUILD.bazel depends on the broken behaviour: it deps-on a cc_library
    from a py_test, which isn't working, see upstream issue:
    bazelbuild/bazel#701.
    This is fixed by simply removing the (non-working) deps.

Depend on conftest and data files in Python tests BUILD files

    Bazel requires that all the files used in a test run should be
    represented in the transitive dependencies specified for the test
    target. For py_test, it means srcs, deps and data.

    Bazel enforces this constraint by creating a "runfiles" directory,
    symbolic links files in the dependency closure and run the test in the
    "runfiles" directory, so that the test shouldn't see files not in the
    dependency graph.

    Unfortunately, the constraint does not apply for a large number of
    Python tests, due to pytest (>=3.9.0, <6.0) resolving these symbolic
    links during test collection and effectively "breaks out" of the
    runfiles tree.

    pytest >= 6.0 introduces a breaking change and removed the symbolic link
    resolving behaviour, see pytest pull request
    pytest-dev/pytest#6523 for more context.

    Currently, we are underspecifying dependencies in a lot of BUILD files
    and thus blocking us from updating to newer pytest (for Python 3.10
    support). This change hopefully fixes all of them, and at least those in
    CI, by adding data or source dependencies (mostly for conftest.py-s)
    where needed.

Bump pytest version from 5.4.3 to 7.0.1

    We want at least pytest 6.2.5 for Python 3.10 support, but not past
    7.1.0 since it drops Python 3.6 support (which Ray still supports), thus
    the version constraint is set to <7.1.

    Updating pytest, combined with earlier BUILD fixes, changed the ground
    truth of a few error message based unit test, these tests are updated to
    reflect the change.

    There are also two small drive-by changes for making test_traceback and
    test_cli pass under Python 3.10. These are discovered while debugging CI
    failures (on earlier Python) with a Python 3.10 install locally.  Expect
    more such issues when adding Python 3.10 to CI.

Signed-off-by: Your Name <your@email.com>
avnishn pushed a commit to smorad/ray that referenced this pull request Jul 20, 2022
See ray-project#23676 for context. This is another attempt at that as I figured out what's going wrong in `bazel test`. Supersedes ray-project#24828.

Now that there are Python 3.10 wheels for Ray 1.13 and this is no longer a blocker for supporting Python 3.10, I still want to make `bazel test //python/ray/tests/...` work for developing in a 3.10 env, and make it easier to add Python 3.10 tests to CI in future.

The change contains three commits with rather descriptive commit message, which I repeat here:

Pass deps to py_test in py_test_module_list

    Bazel macro py_test_module_list takes a `deps` argument, but completely
    ignores it instead of passes it to `native.py_test`. Fixing that as we
    are going to use deps of py_test_module_list in BUILD in later changes.

    cpp/BUILD.bazel depends on the broken behaviour: it deps-on a cc_library
    from a py_test, which isn't working, see upstream issue:
    bazelbuild/bazel#701.
    This is fixed by simply removing the (non-working) deps.

Depend on conftest and data files in Python tests BUILD files

    Bazel requires that all the files used in a test run should be
    represented in the transitive dependencies specified for the test
    target. For py_test, it means srcs, deps and data.

    Bazel enforces this constraint by creating a "runfiles" directory,
    symbolic links files in the dependency closure and run the test in the
    "runfiles" directory, so that the test shouldn't see files not in the
    dependency graph.

    Unfortunately, the constraint does not apply for a large number of
    Python tests, due to pytest (>=3.9.0, <6.0) resolving these symbolic
    links during test collection and effectively "breaks out" of the
    runfiles tree.

    pytest >= 6.0 introduces a breaking change and removed the symbolic link
    resolving behaviour, see pytest pull request
    pytest-dev/pytest#6523 for more context.

    Currently, we are underspecifying dependencies in a lot of BUILD files
    and thus blocking us from updating to newer pytest (for Python 3.10
    support). This change hopefully fixes all of them, and at least those in
    CI, by adding data or source dependencies (mostly for conftest.py-s)
    where needed.

Bump pytest version from 5.4.3 to 7.0.1

    We want at least pytest 6.2.5 for Python 3.10 support, but not past
    7.1.0 since it drops Python 3.6 support (which Ray still supports), thus
    the version constraint is set to <7.1.

    Updating pytest, combined with earlier BUILD fixes, changed the ground
    truth of a few error message based unit test, these tests are updated to
    reflect the change.

    There are also two small drive-by changes for making test_traceback and
    test_cli pass under Python 3.10. These are discovered while debugging CI
    failures (on earlier Python) with a Python 3.10 install locally.  Expect
    more such issues when adding Python 3.10 to CI.

Signed-off-by: Avnish <avnishnarayan@gmail.com>
klwuibm pushed a commit to yuanchi2807/ray that referenced this pull request Jul 27, 2022
See ray-project#23676 for context. This is another attempt at that as I figured out what's going wrong in `bazel test`. Supersedes ray-project#24828.

Now that there are Python 3.10 wheels for Ray 1.13 and this is no longer a blocker for supporting Python 3.10, I still want to make `bazel test //python/ray/tests/...` work for developing in a 3.10 env, and make it easier to add Python 3.10 tests to CI in future.

The change contains three commits with rather descriptive commit message, which I repeat here:

Pass deps to py_test in py_test_module_list

    Bazel macro py_test_module_list takes a `deps` argument, but completely
    ignores it instead of passes it to `native.py_test`. Fixing that as we
    are going to use deps of py_test_module_list in BUILD in later changes.

    cpp/BUILD.bazel depends on the broken behaviour: it deps-on a cc_library
    from a py_test, which isn't working, see upstream issue:
    bazelbuild/bazel#701.
    This is fixed by simply removing the (non-working) deps.

Depend on conftest and data files in Python tests BUILD files

    Bazel requires that all the files used in a test run should be
    represented in the transitive dependencies specified for the test
    target. For py_test, it means srcs, deps and data.

    Bazel enforces this constraint by creating a "runfiles" directory,
    symbolic links files in the dependency closure and run the test in the
    "runfiles" directory, so that the test shouldn't see files not in the
    dependency graph.

    Unfortunately, the constraint does not apply for a large number of
    Python tests, due to pytest (>=3.9.0, <6.0) resolving these symbolic
    links during test collection and effectively "breaks out" of the
    runfiles tree.

    pytest >= 6.0 introduces a breaking change and removed the symbolic link
    resolving behaviour, see pytest pull request
    pytest-dev/pytest#6523 for more context.

    Currently, we are underspecifying dependencies in a lot of BUILD files
    and thus blocking us from updating to newer pytest (for Python 3.10
    support). This change hopefully fixes all of them, and at least those in
    CI, by adding data or source dependencies (mostly for conftest.py-s)
    where needed.

Bump pytest version from 5.4.3 to 7.0.1

    We want at least pytest 6.2.5 for Python 3.10 support, but not past
    7.1.0 since it drops Python 3.6 support (which Ray still supports), thus
    the version constraint is set to <7.1.

    Updating pytest, combined with earlier BUILD fixes, changed the ground
    truth of a few error message based unit test, these tests are updated to
    reflect the change.

    There are also two small drive-by changes for making test_traceback and
    test_cli pass under Python 3.10. These are discovered while debugging CI
    failures (on earlier Python) with a Python 3.10 install locally.  Expect
    more such issues when adding Python 3.10 to CI.

Signed-off-by: klwuibm <kwu888@gmail.com>
franklsf95 pushed a commit to franklsf95/ray that referenced this pull request Aug 2, 2022
See ray-project#23676 for context. This is another attempt at that as I figured out what's going wrong in `bazel test`. Supersedes ray-project#24828.

Now that there are Python 3.10 wheels for Ray 1.13 and this is no longer a blocker for supporting Python 3.10, I still want to make `bazel test //python/ray/tests/...` work for developing in a 3.10 env, and make it easier to add Python 3.10 tests to CI in future.

The change contains three commits with rather descriptive commit message, which I repeat here:

Pass deps to py_test in py_test_module_list

    Bazel macro py_test_module_list takes a `deps` argument, but completely
    ignores it instead of passes it to `native.py_test`. Fixing that as we
    are going to use deps of py_test_module_list in BUILD in later changes.

    cpp/BUILD.bazel depends on the broken behaviour: it deps-on a cc_library
    from a py_test, which isn't working, see upstream issue:
    bazelbuild/bazel#701.
    This is fixed by simply removing the (non-working) deps.

Depend on conftest and data files in Python tests BUILD files

    Bazel requires that all the files used in a test run should be
    represented in the transitive dependencies specified for the test
    target. For py_test, it means srcs, deps and data.

    Bazel enforces this constraint by creating a "runfiles" directory,
    symbolic links files in the dependency closure and run the test in the
    "runfiles" directory, so that the test shouldn't see files not in the
    dependency graph.

    Unfortunately, the constraint does not apply for a large number of
    Python tests, due to pytest (>=3.9.0, <6.0) resolving these symbolic
    links during test collection and effectively "breaks out" of the
    runfiles tree.

    pytest >= 6.0 introduces a breaking change and removed the symbolic link
    resolving behaviour, see pytest pull request
    pytest-dev/pytest#6523 for more context.

    Currently, we are underspecifying dependencies in a lot of BUILD files
    and thus blocking us from updating to newer pytest (for Python 3.10
    support). This change hopefully fixes all of them, and at least those in
    CI, by adding data or source dependencies (mostly for conftest.py-s)
    where needed.

Bump pytest version from 5.4.3 to 7.0.1

    We want at least pytest 6.2.5 for Python 3.10 support, but not past
    7.1.0 since it drops Python 3.6 support (which Ray still supports), thus
    the version constraint is set to <7.1.

    Updating pytest, combined with earlier BUILD fixes, changed the ground
    truth of a few error message based unit test, these tests are updated to
    reflect the change.

    There are also two small drive-by changes for making test_traceback and
    test_cli pass under Python 3.10. These are discovered while debugging CI
    failures (on earlier Python) with a Python 3.10 install locally.  Expect
    more such issues when adding Python 3.10 to CI.

Signed-off-by: Frank Luan <lsf@berkeley.edu>
gramhagen pushed a commit to gramhagen/ray that referenced this pull request Aug 15, 2022
See ray-project#23676 for context. This is another attempt at that as I figured out what's going wrong in `bazel test`. Supersedes ray-project#24828.

Now that there are Python 3.10 wheels for Ray 1.13 and this is no longer a blocker for supporting Python 3.10, I still want to make `bazel test //python/ray/tests/...` work for developing in a 3.10 env, and make it easier to add Python 3.10 tests to CI in future.

The change contains three commits with rather descriptive commit message, which I repeat here:

Pass deps to py_test in py_test_module_list

    Bazel macro py_test_module_list takes a `deps` argument, but completely
    ignores it instead of passes it to `native.py_test`. Fixing that as we
    are going to use deps of py_test_module_list in BUILD in later changes.

    cpp/BUILD.bazel depends on the broken behaviour: it deps-on a cc_library
    from a py_test, which isn't working, see upstream issue:
    bazelbuild/bazel#701.
    This is fixed by simply removing the (non-working) deps.

Depend on conftest and data files in Python tests BUILD files

    Bazel requires that all the files used in a test run should be
    represented in the transitive dependencies specified for the test
    target. For py_test, it means srcs, deps and data.

    Bazel enforces this constraint by creating a "runfiles" directory,
    symbolic links files in the dependency closure and run the test in the
    "runfiles" directory, so that the test shouldn't see files not in the
    dependency graph.

    Unfortunately, the constraint does not apply for a large number of
    Python tests, due to pytest (>=3.9.0, <6.0) resolving these symbolic
    links during test collection and effectively "breaks out" of the
    runfiles tree.

    pytest >= 6.0 introduces a breaking change and removed the symbolic link
    resolving behaviour, see pytest pull request
    pytest-dev/pytest#6523 for more context.

    Currently, we are underspecifying dependencies in a lot of BUILD files
    and thus blocking us from updating to newer pytest (for Python 3.10
    support). This change hopefully fixes all of them, and at least those in
    CI, by adding data or source dependencies (mostly for conftest.py-s)
    where needed.

Bump pytest version from 5.4.3 to 7.0.1

    We want at least pytest 6.2.5 for Python 3.10 support, but not past
    7.1.0 since it drops Python 3.6 support (which Ray still supports), thus
    the version constraint is set to <7.1.

    Updating pytest, combined with earlier BUILD fixes, changed the ground
    truth of a few error message based unit test, these tests are updated to
    reflect the change.

    There are also two small drive-by changes for making test_traceback and
    test_cli pass under Python 3.10. These are discovered while debugging CI
    failures (on earlier Python) with a Python 3.10 install locally.  Expect
    more such issues when adding Python 3.10 to CI.

Signed-off-by: Scott Graham <scgraham@microsoft.com>
gramhagen pushed a commit to gramhagen/ray that referenced this pull request Aug 15, 2022
See ray-project#23676 for context. This is another attempt at that as I figured out what's going wrong in `bazel test`. Supersedes ray-project#24828.

Now that there are Python 3.10 wheels for Ray 1.13 and this is no longer a blocker for supporting Python 3.10, I still want to make `bazel test //python/ray/tests/...` work for developing in a 3.10 env, and make it easier to add Python 3.10 tests to CI in future.

The change contains three commits with rather descriptive commit message, which I repeat here:

Pass deps to py_test in py_test_module_list

    Bazel macro py_test_module_list takes a `deps` argument, but completely
    ignores it instead of passes it to `native.py_test`. Fixing that as we
    are going to use deps of py_test_module_list in BUILD in later changes.

    cpp/BUILD.bazel depends on the broken behaviour: it deps-on a cc_library
    from a py_test, which isn't working, see upstream issue:
    bazelbuild/bazel#701.
    This is fixed by simply removing the (non-working) deps.

Depend on conftest and data files in Python tests BUILD files

    Bazel requires that all the files used in a test run should be
    represented in the transitive dependencies specified for the test
    target. For py_test, it means srcs, deps and data.

    Bazel enforces this constraint by creating a "runfiles" directory,
    symbolic links files in the dependency closure and run the test in the
    "runfiles" directory, so that the test shouldn't see files not in the
    dependency graph.

    Unfortunately, the constraint does not apply for a large number of
    Python tests, due to pytest (>=3.9.0, <6.0) resolving these symbolic
    links during test collection and effectively "breaks out" of the
    runfiles tree.

    pytest >= 6.0 introduces a breaking change and removed the symbolic link
    resolving behaviour, see pytest pull request
    pytest-dev/pytest#6523 for more context.

    Currently, we are underspecifying dependencies in a lot of BUILD files
    and thus blocking us from updating to newer pytest (for Python 3.10
    support). This change hopefully fixes all of them, and at least those in
    CI, by adding data or source dependencies (mostly for conftest.py-s)
    where needed.

Bump pytest version from 5.4.3 to 7.0.1

    We want at least pytest 6.2.5 for Python 3.10 support, but not past
    7.1.0 since it drops Python 3.6 support (which Ray still supports), thus
    the version constraint is set to <7.1.

    Updating pytest, combined with earlier BUILD fixes, changed the ground
    truth of a few error message based unit test, these tests are updated to
    reflect the change.

    There are also two small drive-by changes for making test_traceback and
    test_cli pass under Python 3.10. These are discovered while debugging CI
    failures (on earlier Python) with a Python 3.10 install locally.  Expect
    more such issues when adding Python 3.10 to CI.
Stefan-1313 pushed a commit to Stefan-1313/ray_mod that referenced this pull request Aug 18, 2022
See ray-project#23676 for context. This is another attempt at that as I figured out what's going wrong in `bazel test`. Supersedes ray-project#24828.

Now that there are Python 3.10 wheels for Ray 1.13 and this is no longer a blocker for supporting Python 3.10, I still want to make `bazel test //python/ray/tests/...` work for developing in a 3.10 env, and make it easier to add Python 3.10 tests to CI in future.

The change contains three commits with rather descriptive commit message, which I repeat here:

Pass deps to py_test in py_test_module_list

    Bazel macro py_test_module_list takes a `deps` argument, but completely
    ignores it instead of passes it to `native.py_test`. Fixing that as we
    are going to use deps of py_test_module_list in BUILD in later changes.

    cpp/BUILD.bazel depends on the broken behaviour: it deps-on a cc_library
    from a py_test, which isn't working, see upstream issue:
    bazelbuild/bazel#701.
    This is fixed by simply removing the (non-working) deps.

Depend on conftest and data files in Python tests BUILD files

    Bazel requires that all the files used in a test run should be
    represented in the transitive dependencies specified for the test
    target. For py_test, it means srcs, deps and data.

    Bazel enforces this constraint by creating a "runfiles" directory,
    symbolic links files in the dependency closure and run the test in the
    "runfiles" directory, so that the test shouldn't see files not in the
    dependency graph.

    Unfortunately, the constraint does not apply for a large number of
    Python tests, due to pytest (>=3.9.0, <6.0) resolving these symbolic
    links during test collection and effectively "breaks out" of the
    runfiles tree.

    pytest >= 6.0 introduces a breaking change and removed the symbolic link
    resolving behaviour, see pytest pull request
    pytest-dev/pytest#6523 for more context.

    Currently, we are underspecifying dependencies in a lot of BUILD files
    and thus blocking us from updating to newer pytest (for Python 3.10
    support). This change hopefully fixes all of them, and at least those in
    CI, by adding data or source dependencies (mostly for conftest.py-s)
    where needed.

Bump pytest version from 5.4.3 to 7.0.1

    We want at least pytest 6.2.5 for Python 3.10 support, but not past
    7.1.0 since it drops Python 3.6 support (which Ray still supports), thus
    the version constraint is set to <7.1.

    Updating pytest, combined with earlier BUILD fixes, changed the ground
    truth of a few error message based unit test, these tests are updated to
    reflect the change.

    There are also two small drive-by changes for making test_traceback and
    test_cli pass under Python 3.10. These are discovered while debugging CI
    failures (on earlier Python) with a Python 3.10 install locally.  Expect
    more such issues when adding Python 3.10 to CI.

Signed-off-by: Stefan van der Kleij <s.vanderkleij@viroteq.com>
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
do-not-merge Do not merge this PR! stale The issue is stale. It will be closed within 7 days unless there are further conversation
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

[Feature] Python 3.10 wheel
2 participants