Repository navigation
Don't close covers/blinds when windows are open #268
Replies: 5 comments
|
Besides the safety aspect, as you describe, there might also be other use cases for this. I myself don't close roller shutters in the summer when it's (very) hot inside and colder outside, in which case I mostly also have the windows fully open to get some draft through the (not airconditioned) house. (And in the bedroom I also keep the roller shutters fully open (and window tilted open) during the night in the summer with warm inside temperatures . But I do let them close automatically "just" before sunrise (sun elevation rising above -5 degrees or something alike). With windows facing north it will otherwise result in a lot of sunlight and an early wake-up. And a couple of minutes after the wakeup alarm (or pressing button for "wakeup" / "lights on") they will open again. While in the winter the roller shutters just get fully closed. And it also works for anything in between, like "keep open for 40%" with a 20 °C indoor temperature and not too cold outside. Obviously retaining the "close before sunrise when not awake yet"). Not sure if all these ideas would be worthwile to implement 😄. But some simple form of "as long as the window(s) are open don't close the covers/... might be a nice feature as it obviously also "controls the inside temperature", for those without AC. |
|
I would like to add an important safety consideration: I live in an attic apartment with skylights (Velux) and exterior shutters. With this specific setup, it is mandatory that the window is completely closed before the shutter starts moving. Even if the window is only slightly tilted, a collision with the descending shutter is inevitable. In my previous manual automations, I always included a condition that checks the window contact sensor and blocks the movement if the window is open. It would be great if RoomMind could natively support such a safety check (e.g., via a linked sensor entity) to prevent hardware damage. |
|
Yesterday in the evening I had evidence of exactly this. My kitchen window was Open and the cover closed. So this is definitely and issue. Also, when I hit the cover remote it did Open the Cover again, but a minute later RoomMind closed it again. I thought manual override would prevent this? |
|
Would love to see some priority in this enhancement since a blind getting stuck in the tilted window in my kitchen nearly broke. For now, I deactivate cover control to be sure this wont happen. Looking forward to reactivating it though. Aside from the covers closing while windows are open, it works without a flaw. |
|
I also have exact the situation as Luke2105-Loft59 Some of my shutters are Velux and should be closed to close the shutter. Though the shutter can be closed to some 40-50%, which I can control exactly from HA with the OverKiz integration. Now I use automations and Z-wave door/window sensors to check this. I also use the partially close feature to close vertical shutters to 80%, what means they reach the bottom position, but ventilation holes are open. Especially usefull where a sun in spring warms the room too much, but where a windows behind the shutter can be open since the outdoor temperature is not too warm. And I have one shutter where one particular window/door sensor should have the state closed, and at least one of two others open. Those two others control another shutter. This to prevent that we are locked into the garden from where I cannot escape without forcing a shutter. I'll keep it to the window open part. But I try to get as smart as possible with (partially) closing and opening blinds. Both for protection: shutters closed at night) but als to let sun in when needed (warming on a cool day) or keep the sun out (when it is hot or when hot times are in the forecast). |


Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Not sure if this is adressed already. Cannot currently test it, because summer is still far. I didnt find any documentation on this.
Description
I use an automation right now to close my covers/blinds based on the position of the sun, which I get by outside temperature on the window (external temperature sensor) and illuminance (illuminance sensor). The covers/blinds are on the inside and the windows open to the inside of the room. So when the window is open, I do not want the covers/blinds to close. Is this also implemented in the automatic cover control or are the window/door sensors also just used for the mpc?
Use case
Prevent covers/blinds from closing when a window is open and this influences safe operation of the covers/blinds!
Alternatives considered
No response
All reactions